SlideShare une entreprise Scribd logo
1  sur  20
Demitra Salteris
Lawson COMM360
May 13, 2014
Successful “Thugs”
For centuries, we human beings have lived within communities, in which we have near
always portrayed superiority differences between different peoples, especially in regards to race
and ethnicity. The Civil Rights Act of 1964 claimed that “All persons shall be entitled to the full
and equal enjoyment of the goods, services, facilities, and privileges, advantages, and
accommodations of any place of public accommodation, without discrimination or segregation
on the ground of race, color, religion, or national origin.” Unfortunately, many individuals,
myself included, can agree that the promises of the abovementioned act have not held true for all.
Despite the Civil Rights Movement and many other movements and efforts to change the ways
of society, this prejudice and racism still exists today in the United States. Although there is
some dispute about how ubiquitous and influential racism is in the United States, it is clearly
evident that it still impacts the rights, opportunities, and treatment of minorities. More
specifically, the United States’ history of discrimination combined with modern racism is still
strongly impacting the treatment of African-Americans today. According to a PBS article by
George M. Frederickson, “Racism exists when one ethnic group or historical collectivity
dominates, excludes, or seeks to eliminate another on the basis of differences that it believes are
hereditary and unalterable.” Hindered in terms of entitlement and respect, African-Americans
have largely been victims of the aforementioned definition for several eras. Even the individuals
whom were/are successful and educated are perceived as inferior in some ways, and are
2
prevented from receiving the full respect and entitlements that they deserve for their success. On
top of that, I believe African-Americans are not only disabled from achieving the full perks of
success, but they are also pin-holed by society to only fill certain positions of success and fame. I
believe this attempt to prevent African-Americans from fulfilling wide varieties of successful
careers and lifestyles is because success often means power. Even though it may not be as openly
expressed nowadays, I think many white Americans still do not want African-Americans to have
power because they want to remain the superior ones. Overall, due to prejudice, African-
Americans are stereotyped and referred to with negative connotations, even when they do not
match them. Hence, in this paper I will analyze and interpret several pieces of rhetorical text,
predominantly black rhetoric, to illuminate how hatred, discrimination, and an unwillingness to
accept and respect those who differ, still relevantly impacts perceptions and hinders achievement
of comprehensive success. I will show how it is discrimination in society that is still the leading
cause of a truly successful and powerful African-American being considered an anomaly.
If one were to take a look at the 2014 Forbes list of the World’s most powerful people, it
would quickly become apparent that they are almost all non-blacks. There are only two black
people out of the list of seventy-two people total, for supposedly the world’s most powerful
people. One of those two black people is President Barack Obama (in spot #2) and then Aliko
Dangote, CEO of the Dangote Group and Africa’s richest man (in spot #64), is the second black
person on the list. To be more specific though, since Dangote is not American, President Barack
Obama is the only actual African-American individual listed in the most powerful people list.
Some may debate that this is this just a coincidence. On the other hand though, others believe
that it is all because the history of discrimination is so deeply engrained in our system that we are
3
still putting up barriers for African-Americans. After much deliberation and clear evidence, that I
will continue to speak of later, I must say I definitely believe that it is due to the latter.
Sure, society has had a rise in famous African-American figures, but if one were to ask a
group of Americans to name some successful African-American men, then besides President
Obama, the most widely-known ones would definitely consist of mainly athletes or those in the
entertainment industry, i.e. comedians, actors, music moguls, etc. This clearly demonstrates what
I mentioned earlier about African-Americans seeming to be pin-holed so that they may only
fulfill certain positions of success that do not have too high authority and influence over history.
Athletes and entertainers exhibit much less authority and power compared to other high positions
of success, such as politicians, lawyers, and surgeons, in my opinion. Additionally, African-
Americans are accepted into these certain positions that I mentioned, to provide for whatever
intents and purposes society has, and usually nothing more. In essence, these famous African-
American figures and celebrities, especially men in particular, may have achieved greatness in
pay and popularity but not necessarily as much respect overall compared to other successful,
non-black figures. One extremely recent and pertinent example involves the case of now-former
owner of the Clippers NBA team, Donald Sterling, telling his mistress that he does not want her
bringing any black people to his games, and does not want her fraternizing with them on any
social media, like Instagram. This shows an instance of African-American individuals being
accepted only in the positions that some members of society want them in, because he does not
want black people around him for any other purpose besides playing for his team and making
him money.
In the conversation between Donald Sterling and his girlfriend, one part in particular
stood out so vehemently to me. In this part of the recording, Sterling basically claims he is not
4
racist; that is just the way the world is, so he follows it. Yet, he goes on to mention how in Israel
they treat black people like dogs, and that the white Jews are a hundred and fifty percent better
than black Jews; clearly showing that he is bigoted because his perception of blacks is that they
are substandard. His girlfriend, who ironically happens to be half black, also asks him in the
conversation why he has to treat black people like dogs too, and if he thinks that it is right.
Sterling responded with a bold statement of, “It isn’t a question – we don’t evaluate what’s right
and wrong, we live in a society. We live in a culture. We have to live within that culture….I
don’t want to change the culture because I can’t. It’s too big…I don’t want change.” The public
sharing of this preposterous conversation caused quite an uproar, but this man’s extreme racism
and hatred never would have been brought to light if someone had not spied and secretly
recorded the conversation. Also, I think the worst part is that Sterling kept claiming that he is not
a racist. Ultimately, the whole ordeal that occurred with Sterling highlights how there truly are
Caucasian people that are highly prejudiced and instilled with negative perceptions of African-
Americans, in current times. So, the true question is, how many more non-black successful
figures and people with authority in society think and act in the same manner as Sterling?
Because if enough important people have the same ideology, then it is extremely obvious that
they are the ones who are trying to maintain African-Americans at an inferior status, sometimes
without everyone else in society even being aware of them doing so.
By ensuring that systems concerning social status in regards to ethnicity stay in place,
then it is ensuring that not everyone is provided with the opportunity to rise above and become
successful, especially if they attempt to rise from ‘nothing.’ High levels of poverty and
unemployment appear to be prominent among many African-American communities, arguably
due to the strong prominence of racism still existing. Yet, there are a vast number of African-
5
American individuals which lead ‘normal’ lifestyles and are also viewed as unequal to non-
blacks. In reference to an article from California State University of Sacramento, there are two
types of racism: 1) “Moral racism- The belief that a race of people is morally inferior, and as
such members of that race are deserving of less respect and concern.” 2) “Genetic Racism- The
belief that a race of people is genetically inferior, and as such members of that race are (on the
average) less intelligent, and generally less capable.” These two subsets of racism so clearly
provide a reasoning behind why even African-Americans who have succeeded, achieved equal
pay and popularity, still do not necessarily receive all the same respect.
A very public example of a successful black individual that felt disrespected due to what
he perceived as racism was in 2006, when Kanye West at a Concert for Hurricane [Katrina]
Relief made the jaw-dropping statement: “George Bush doesn’t care about black people.” The
lack of response to Hurricane Katrina made Kanye feel as though the only reason could be
because the affected area is filled with mostly black people and since the news was portraying
black people with negative connotations. Thus, due to disrespectful implications towards mostly
blacks, he felt that the commander in chief, aka the President, did not care about helping black
people nor how they were negatively affected by the disaster. Kanye started off the presentation
by completely ignoring the script and claiming, “I hate the way they portray us in the media. You
see a black family, it says, 'They're looting.' You see a white family, it says, 'They're looking for
food.' And, you know, it's been five days because most of the people are black…and just to
imagine if I was down there, and those are my people down there. So anybody out there that
wants to do anything that we can help—with the way America is set up to help the poor, the
black people, the less well-off, as slow as possible. I mean, the Red Cross is doing everything
they can. We already realize a lot of people that could help are at war right now, fighting another
6
way—and they've given them permission to go down and shoot us!” Known for being very
straightforward, Kanye made it adamant that the public knew what was going on in the disaster
zones, and how the black families there were being mostly depicted as thieves and such, even
though everyone was acting in the same ways to survive. On top of his statements in regards to
the hurricane relief, he also squeezed in his opinions of how America is not as invested in
providing urgent aid and care for those are less well-off, specifically poor and black people.
From what I interpreted, I think Kanye is trying to illustrate how societal discrimination is still
prominently affecting the opportunities and livelihoods of black people. Even though Kanye was
not directly affected by the hurricane, he still felt very upset and disrespected by media’s
statements surrounding the disaster because even though the statements were not towards him
specifically, he still knew that they were aimed towards people who were basically just like him.
Another reason that Kanye felt disrespected is because he put himself in the shoes of ‘his fellow
people’ and felt as though if he was down in New Orleans during the time of the ordeal that he
would have been treated and portrayed in the same light as those there because he is black.
Lamentably, although Kanye’s statements were considered very controversial, they did nothing
for the issue at hand. Presumably, I would assume this is because people did not take him very
seriously due to his lack of credibility, the fact that he did not sound very composed in his
speech, and predominantly because of what is known for.
As a rapper, Kanye West has several tracks in which he speaks profanely at times, and in
many songs he refers to aspects and terminology like gold diggers, slaves, swagga, drugs,
n*ggas, etc., that are supposedly more understood or related to in black communities. Some
tracks are songs that are heartfelt or deep, and focus on struggles and hardships that he and
people like him have experienced in life. Nonetheless, he is looked down upon by many because
7
of the negative connotations drawn from his lyrics from people who do not understand the
culture and terminology. Even though Kanye is rich, famous, and successful, he is still at times,
undesirably personified through the notions that people draw from his lyrics. Also, the
vernacular that he uses at times can be interpreted by some as informal or uneducated due to
slight variations of Standard English, in addition to slang terms.
An even more dramatic example of a successful black person who has been affected by
racism and stereotypical assumptions involves the misinterpretation and offensive labeling of
NFL Seahawks cornerback, Richard Sherman. This past year, Richard Sherman was widely
characterized as a “thug” in the media, immediately after the airing of an interview after last
year’s NFC championship game, in which he totally eluded the asked question and began yelling
aggressively and appearing pumped up as if he was ready to fight. He also did not use all
Standard English terminology, which can come off as being uneducated to some. For example, in
this interview he referred to an opponent player as a “sorry receiver” instead of an unskilled
receiver, or when he says “gon’ get” instead of ‘going to get.’ What many do not know though is
that this man (Sherman) who was considered a “thug,” actually graduated from renowned
Stanford University with a 4.0 grade point average. In addition, he also has 40 million dollars
guaranteed to him, on top of the money he already has made playing, for signing his four-year
extension with the Seahawks. Clearly, Sherman is much better educated and has tremendously
more money than a vast majority of society, so one would expect him to be applauded and
respected for his accomplishments, instead of being disrespected and pigeonholed as if he is just
some simple black person from the streets. Thus, Sherman serves as an example of how some
black people are referred to as merely “brothers” or “thugs,” and viewed as lesser, even though
they may be well-educated, well-off moneywise, in addition to being well-mannered. There is
8
also irony in non-blacks calling out black people for their “improper” use of English because
many of the terms that they use when referring to black people have different denotations than
what they think they stand for. I will expand on these misinterpretations below, as well as how
being stuck in one mind set due to an unwillingness to accept differences impacts the reputation
and perceptions towards anyone whom thinks and speaks in ways that are unlike what they were
taught is right.
According to Encyclopedia Britannica, the term “thug” surprisingly does not even come
from American culture, and actually originates from centuries ago in India. Thug or “thag” in
Hindi means something completely different than the connotation it is presumed to mean.
Britannica states that the original definition of a thug was “a member of a well-organized
confederacy of professional assassins who traveled in gangs throughout India for several hundred
years.” It is also described as being very similar to Satanism, except it is even more violent.
Thus, it is clear that the individuals that non-blacks were trying to degrade black people by
calling them something that they thought meant something else completely, and in fact does not
relate to African-Americans at all, if used in the original sense. So, the African-Americans that
are referred to as thugs, like Sherman was, are being referred to as something that they are not.
The connotation that non-blacks seem to believe matches with the term “thug,” seems to be a
person who is violent, uneducated, “ghetto”, a degenerate, or a thief, etc. that does not care to
conform to societal standards. The term’s usage being adopted into rap and hip-hop music then
combined with messages related to black culture that were viewed as not conforming to societal
morals and standards by non-blacks. The aforementioned combined with prejudice, likely
inspired the anglicized, more modernly presumed connotation. I say the modern connotation is
derived from prejudice because the term is meant to come off as degrading, and some believe
9
that, “recently the white conservative movement in the U.S.A. has adopted it as a substantive
replacement for the vulgar and toxic term "nigger" which is no longer safe for use in most media
channels (democraticunderground.com).” The modern introduction of the term through rap and
hip-hop obviously did not denote the same. As Tupac defined it, “a thug is someone who is
going through struggles, has gone through struggles, and continues to live day by day with
nothing for them. That person is a thug, and the life they are living is the thug life.”
Unfortunately, many individuals spun this expression around to be negative due to an inability to
relate, in addition to its connection to other aspects of poor, troubled black neighborhoods such
as exposure to violence, drugs, crime, etc.
The non-permeable minds of some individuals will never be able to grasp the
connotations of certain speech that does not match the style of language and rhetoric that they
were raised within. If people are kept inside these barriers and do not attempt to make efforts in
understanding and accepting others’ ideologies and terminology, then it will never be fully
possible to interpret what the other people truly mean. Modernly, this is exactly what happens
with a lot of African-American speech communities. These slight variations of the English
vernacular by large populations of African-Americans caused another break in society since
many other Americans could not grasp the terminology and vernacular. This breakoff resulted in
the creation of a newer linguistic category, referred to by linguists as either ‘Black English’,
‘African-American Vernacular English (AAVE)’, or the more negative connotation that was
coined around the 1960’s called “Nonstandard Negro English.” I have learned throughout the
years that, very often when individuals are unsure of or do not agree with something, then they
end up bashing it. Thus, the aforementioned phenomena of bashing what you do not like or agree
with, happened in regards to African-American speech, causing many negative criticisms.
10
Hence, that is why many non-blacks try to use these circumstances surrounding vernacular
disagreement as another way to downplay the success of black individuals. The coining of such
terms as “Nonstandard Negro English,” coincided with terms of other distasteful, negative
connotations towards African-Americans, which was naturally, very disliked by a vast majority
of African-American individuals. This linguistic discrepancy was just another way that society
could discriminate against African-Americans. So, in 1973 a group of black scholars took it into
their hands and created a new term known as Ebonics. According to an article by John R.
Rickford from The Linguistic Society of America, Ebonics is “a blend of the words ebony
‘black’ and phonics ‘sounds’,” and simply means ‘black speech.’ Examples include random
slang words like “ashy” to refer to the whitish-gray appearance of black skin when dry, and then
there are also grammatical variations like some pronunciation changes caused by the dropping of
b, d, g from the beginning of auxiliary verbs, resulting in statements like “ah ‘on know” instead
of the formal “I don’t know.” Speaking in this vernacular is often regarded as a sign of a lack of
sophistication and education, due to many not being familiar with its connection to the African
culture and the Black Diaspora of places like Jamaica, Nigeria, and more places whose roots
stem from Africa. There are other cases however, where very literate and well-known figures,
have used Ebonics instead for dramatic or realistic effect, including famous authors like Zora
Neal Hurston and Toni Morrison, as well as many Black preachers and entertainers, especially
rappers.
According to Michael Eric Dyson, “rap expresses the ongoing preoccupation with
literacy and orality that has characterized African-American communities since the inception of
legally coerced illiteracy during slavery (pg. 408)…It expresses the desire of young black people
to reclaim their history, reactivate forms of black radicalism, and contest the powers of despair
11
and economic depression that presently besiege the black community (pg. 410).” Although these
intentions may be obvious to those who are part of the black community, they once again can be
interpreted differently due to an inability to understand and relate. I believe that many
individuals which are impervious to such lifestyles and culture just perceive black communities
that live in such ways as people who are incapable of being someone who is successful and
respected. Thus, discrimination, an inability to understand, and an unwillingness to accept that
just because black people speak a certain way and experience certain ordeals which do not meet
society’s supposed moral standards; causes others to not be able to see past the unappealing
details to the deeper meanings and intentions of becoming something better in the world.
Referring back to Tupac, he was a major figure which utilized Ebonics in his lyrics while
describing the socioeconomic struggles of black communities that existed, and that he personally
rose up from. When a lot of people hear the lyrics or statements of rappers speaking about
violence, crime, and poverty, they are crudely misinterpreted. They think that these are the only
ways of life that these people strive to live and pursue, but that is not so. There is a so much
deeper meaning. It is about rising from the bottom, and working as hard as you possibly can to
make it up from there. Certain people may live differently than others, surrounded by poor living
situations and more precarious obstacles, but that does not mean that they are not good people
and does not mean that they are any less worthy or capable of being a successful individual "That
boy ain't a gangsta, fo'sho'. Look at how he walks, he's a thug. life. That's the saddest face I've
seen in all my life as a teen," is one lyrical example including Ebonics, in which he is referring to
the hardships of coming from a poor, black community and the struggles of living with next to
nothing. Many individuals who were unable to understand Tupac’s meaning, wrote it off as him
promoting being a person from the streets that hustles or acts like a “thug.” However, like I said
12
is because they did not understand what Tupac was trying to portray, and exactly what he
denoted “thug life” as. Tupac’s definition of thug life was broken down into a statement “Thug
life- the hate you gave little infants f*cks everyone.”
Essentially, with certain individuals practicing such horrible prejudice and hatred in their
everyday lives they are just passing it onto future generations. They are setting it up so that they
are an example of how humans should supposedly treat one another, but clearly it is not the right
way to harm others based on their ethnic background. When hateful people raise their children
within the same hatred then it often becomes the only environment they know of. The youth are
the ones who are our future; the ones who will make great changes to society. So, if the ones
controlling our future are engrained with such outrageous bigotry towards one another, won’t
they not be able to come together to keep society thriving? Thus, it seems to me that if the future
is filled with hate-driven individuals then like Tupac said everyone be will f*cked, because then
everyone is ultimately being gipped of enhancement opportunities for society. If the problem of
hatred hinders the advancements of society too greatly, then it could ultimately crumble.
Additionally, the containment of poor, black people, due to fear of gaining supremacy is
another reason for the shortage of inspirational and successful black figures because since very
few are provided with equal opportunities for rising to success. In reference to an article written
by Edward Williams, he also made the claim of how with such few examples of high levels of
success among black men, it makes it difficult for young, black men to find a path to mold their
own lives by. Also according to Williams’ article,
“Over the last 200 years of American history, there has been one African-American
male President, one African-American male Attorney General, one African-American
male Secretary of State, and two African-American male Supreme Court Justices. There is
13
currently one African-American male governor, there have only been four in American History.
Five (0.83%) of the Fortune 500 CEOs are African-American men. Approximately 1% of all law
firm partners are African-American men. There has been one African-American male Surgeon
General in American history. And fewer than six percent of all high-ranking military officers are
African-American.”
These ridiculously low figures in reference to black men who hold positions of high
success, demonstrate part of the crisis that discrimination causes. With a lack of sufficient
successful and intelligent black people being openly presented to society, it consequently means
that there is a lack of role models for those still struggling to aspire after. I can think of a few
instances from my own experiences of living in the United States during Obama’s presidency, in
which individuals made crude remarks about him. When listening to the radio one day, I even
heard a conversation in which a little African-American boy said to a white woman how he
wanted to be the next black president. She retorted with something along the lines of ‘oh no, we
already had one of those, we don’t need another one. With the rarity of these accomplished black
male figures it sends a message to other young, black men that it is very rare for individuals like
them to succeed and be provided with the opportunity to make it to such high positions of
success. Additionally, it makes it apparent that for African-Americans there is no set path to
attempt to follow, making their attempts at achieving such high success seem even more
complicated. In consequence, I believe there will likely be an even greater decline of African-
Americans rising up from the bottom.
We know that different races, including African-Americans, all have the same inherent
abilities, thus the high statistics of poverty, unemployment, and crime, can be most rationally
explained by the persistence of bigoted authorities in society to maintain the “status quo,” with
14
white supremacy. Attempts by some to promote equality are not always fully carried out
however. Senator Robert F. Kennedy once stated, “We have always believed it possible for men
and women who start at the bottom to rise as far as their talent and energy allow. Neither race
nor place of birth should affect their chances." Although this statement in particular is widely
referring to immigration, I believe it serves dually in reference to racism and prejudice, and is
essentially summarizing the claim that I made above pertaining to African-Americans having the
same intrinsic abilities as every other race does. I wholeheartedly agree with the statement in
that, neither race nor place of birth should impact one’s chances to rise from the bottom.
However, based on United States history alone, the notion that Americans have always believed
in such can be proven false. I say this because several different types of individuals throughout
time have been prevented from rising up in success, including all different ethnic minorities and
women. Additionally, I think it is important to highlight the fact that Kennedy says should,
because it shows that he believes that people ought to not be having that happen, but not
necessarily that it is enforced or is something that is for sure happening. Chiefly, just because the
famous political figure made the claim, does not mean that the masses will all believe in and
follow what he said. Kennedy’s quote was very inspirational, but that was about it for the most
part.
Like Senator Robert F. Kennedy claimed, our attitudes towards the situation reflects our
faith in the American ideal; of it being the ‘land of opportunity,’ and equality for all. However, I
am going to go a step further in the analysis of this quote, and say that if our attitudes towards
the topic are positive then yes it will help motivate others to take advantage of America’s
opportunities. Yet, if too great a number of attitudes towards minorities are negative then it
reflects that we do not care about the American ideal of all peoples being entitled to the same
15
liberties. A reflection of the latter regrettably seems to be more present in society, involving
deleterious attitudes in regards to African-Americans not being deserving or worthy of being
provided with equal entitlements, opportunities, respect, and most controversially, status.
It almost seems that no matter how much time passes, there will still be prejudice and
discrimination in the world. The persistent impact of prejudice and racism has become so
engrained that it seems we may never be able to shake it. Sadly, due to the usually more
aggressive drive behind individuals filled with hatred and prejudice it denounces many of the
breakthroughs attempted to be made towards achieving complete equality. In fact, almost every
famous figure that attempted to strongly change the prejudiced ways of society and the
breakdown of it in terms of social status, from Abraham Lincoln to Martin Luther King Jr. and
Malcolm X to John F. Kennedy, all were very tragically stopped in their attempts by being killed
by bigoted individuals that felt that they could not bear, and refused to allow, a change in the
social system and supposed order of supremacy.
There are many people in positions of high power in society, which still believe in white
supremacy and the inclusion of a social system broken down by race that should not have the
capability to be altered by any member of the general public. These people’s actions are hard to
counteract if one does not have the same amount of power and authority, especially financially,
but the only way to prevent further slinking back to our country’s discriminatory roots, is to keep
fighting against their ways. I think I can confidently say that practically every individual in the
world that has received some sort of education has heard about the famous figures mentioned
above, for their publicized attempts to change society from its current racially broken down
system. However, there are so many more sources that one can acquire knowledge about this
racial issue and the obstacles preventing its solution. Thus, I think education and collaboration
16
are key tools in providing those who want change, greater ability to fight back against racism.
James Baldwin once stated,
“The paradox of education is precisely this – that as one begins to become conscious one
begins to examine the society in which he is being educated. The purpose of education, finally, is
to create in a person the ability to look at the world for himself, to make his own decisions, to say
to himself this is black or this is white, to decide for himself whether there is a God in heaven or
not. To ask questions of the universe, and then learn to live with those questions, is the way he
achieves his own identity. But no society is really anxious to have that kind of person around.
What societies really, ideally, want is a citizenry which will simply obey the rules of society. If a
society succeeds in this, that society is about to perish. The obligation of anyone who thinks of
himself as responsible is to examine society and try to change it and to fight it –at no matter what
risk.”
Summarizing what Baldwin stated, essentially some higher powers of society do not want
people to be extremely educated in everything, or to question how society is run, thus they try
disabling people from receiving the opportunity to do so, especially with African-Americans.
Based on my analyses, it seems to me that the higher powers which are creating these obstacles
believe that if they continue to do so, then individuals will not be powerful or educated enough to
try to question their ways publicly and that they will not be able to get together enough people to
turn against them. The high powers of society only want these individuals around to abide by
their rules and to maintain the roles that they are ‘designated.’ Essentially the higher powers of
society that wish to maintain the discriminatory mainframe are blocking all forms of betterment
and achievement, in the hopes that it will also leave those individuals with not enough resources
and knowledge to fight back against them. Not only that, but also if more African-Americans are
17
provided with education and guidance on how they can be successful, then they can help
progress their race’s influence even more so.
From my understanding of the research that I conducted there are not only the typical
pressures of success, but there is even more pressure on African-American males due to the fact
of them still being considered an anomaly. If more African-Americans receive higher educations,
then they can hopefully achieve more greatness in society’s highly successful positions, and
subsequently pass along their knowledge and recommendations to other African-Americans of
both now and the future. If enough African-Americans achieve high success, then they can also
collaborate together to try to increase their ranking in the social system, ultimately in hopes of
achieving a proliferation of highly respected, and successful African-American figures.
In reference to Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. he most notably stated that, “all progress is
precarious and the solution of one problem brings us face to face with another problem.” I
understand that the notion of combatting something as big and powerful as racism can seem
incredibly overwhelming, if not impossible. But if enough people joined together to fight it at the
same time then who knows what could happen. I truly think there just has not been a large
enough collaboration of successfully educated and knowledgeable individuals to fight against the
issue of discrimination. From Dr. Martin Luther King Jr.’s statement, I think he perfectly
captures the notion of how yes, there are some risks in going against the system and trying to
progress the proliferation of educated, and successfully ranking African-Americans. However,
there is always going to be someone who has a problem with accepting differences, and society
is always going to have some sort of problem to solve, so I think they should not be deterred.
Sometimes we have to do the things that we are told we cannot do to ultimately achieve the
results that we want. In this case, although there may be worries of systematic backlash, I think
18
African-Americans must still push to rise above and make solutions to society’s discriminatory
problems, because otherwise there will never be change.
Referring back to James Baldwin’s statement of how “The obligation of anyone who
thinks of himself as responsible is to examine society and try to change it and to fight it –at no
matter what risk,” touches exactly on the notion that I am trying to convey. If people, particularly
African-Americans, want to see change, then they are going to have to go above and beyond to
fight the issue, no matter the cost. Despite successful black people still being considered an
anomaly, they are incredibly more educated and successful than they were decades ago. So, they
should take advantage of this and join together to combat discrimination because there is close to
no chance that circumstances could revert back to how poorly African-Americans were treated
before, so why not take the chance of advancing equality even more.
Conclusively, I strongly believe that an alliance of enough strong-minded, educated black
individuals can form paths of success that they can utilize to, in the words of Public Enemy,
“fight the power.” The concepts of prejudice and racism have been around for a long time, so
they unfortunately are going to take a long time to uproot from society as well. Nevertheless, the
constraints of racism in regards to the advancements and true success of African-Americans have
lightened some recently. As long as African-Americans keep doing whatever they possibly can
to make a change in society, they can continue to rise in success, maintaining strong hopes for
becoming powerful enough figures to make an ultimate change in how they are hindered by
society.
19
Works Cited
Dyson, Michael Eric. "The Culture of Hip-Hop." The Michael Eric Dyson reader. New York:
Basic Civitas Books, 2004. 408-410. Print.
Forbes. "The World's Most Powerful People." Forbes. Forbes Magazine, n.d. Web. 1 May 2014.
<http://www.forbes.com/powerful-people/list/>.
Frederickson, George M.. "The Historical Origins and Development of Race." PBS. PBS, n.d.
Web. 1 May 2014. <http://www.pbs.org/race/000_About/002_04-background-02-
01.htm>.
"Is Affirmative Action Fair?." History of Discrimination. California State University,
Sacramento, n.d. Web. 29 Apr. 2014.
<http://www.csus.edu/indiv/g/gaskilld/socialissues14/affirmative%20action.htm>.
A Concert for Hurricane Relief. NBC Universal Television Group. NBC, New York. 2 Sept.
2005. Television.
Kennedy, Robert F.. "Talk:Robert F. Kennedy." - Wikiquote. N.p., n.d. Web. 2 May 2014.
<http://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Talk:Robert_F._Kennedy>.
Rickford, John R.. "Linguistic Society of America." What is Ebonics (African American
English)?. The Linguistic Society of America, n.d. Web. 1 May 2014.
<http://www.linguisticsociety.org/content/what-ebonics-african-american-english>.
Sherman, Richard. "Richard Sherman Post Game Interview: Seattle Seahawks cornerback
Richard Sherman Post Game 49ers." NFL Network. FOX Sports. FOX, Washington,
DC: 20 Jan. 2014. Television.
"thug". Encyclopædia Britannica. Encyclopædia Britannica Online. Encyclopædia
Britannica Inc., 2014. Web. 1 May 2014.
<http://www.britannica.com/EBchecked/topic/594263/thug>.
20
"Thug Life Army." Code of 'THUG LIFE. Star Sound Music Group, 22 Sept. 2004. Web. 1 May
2014. <http://www.thuglifearmy.com/code-of-thug-life.html>. Quotes from Tupac
Shakur
Wagner, Kyle. "Exclusive: The Extended Donald Sterling Tape." Deadspin. N.p., n.d. Web. 1
May 2014. <http://deadspin.com/exclusive-the-extended-donald-sterling-tape-
1568291249>.
Williams, Edward. "The Weight of Being a (Young and Successful) Black Male." PolicyMic.
N.p., 21 July 2012. Web. 30 Apr. 2014. <http://www.policymic.com/articles/11599/the-
weight-of-being-a-young-and-successful-black-male>.

Contenu connexe

Tendances

Racial discrimination, protest p pt
Racial discrimination, protest p ptRacial discrimination, protest p pt
Racial discrimination, protest p ptDr. Vandana Pathak
 
Soc345 lect5 lect6_race_ethnicity
Soc345 lect5 lect6_race_ethnicitySoc345 lect5 lect6_race_ethnicity
Soc345 lect5 lect6_race_ethnicityjdubrow2000
 
Double V_MIDN CHANG_1APR2016_FINAL_NS412
Double V_MIDN CHANG_1APR2016_FINAL_NS412Double V_MIDN CHANG_1APR2016_FINAL_NS412
Double V_MIDN CHANG_1APR2016_FINAL_NS412David Chang
 
An Examination of Black Soccer Participation and Fandom in America
An Examination of Black Soccer Participation and Fandom in AmericaAn Examination of Black Soccer Participation and Fandom in America
An Examination of Black Soccer Participation and Fandom in AmericaPatrick Rose
 
Racial discrimination slide
Racial discrimination slideRacial discrimination slide
Racial discrimination slideNicci9240
 
Racism and xenophobia.
Racism and xenophobia.Racism and xenophobia.
Racism and xenophobia.IANJOHN18
 
George Floyd: Black lives matter, peaceful protests and black history
George Floyd: Black lives matter, peaceful protests and black historyGeorge Floyd: Black lives matter, peaceful protests and black history
George Floyd: Black lives matter, peaceful protests and black historyRupinder K Gill
 
Futurew of the american dream
Futurew of the american dreamFuturew of the american dream
Futurew of the american dreamKate McLean
 
A Capsule of Black Electoral Politics in America
A Capsule of Black Electoral Politics in AmericaA Capsule of Black Electoral Politics in America
A Capsule of Black Electoral Politics in AmericaRBG Communiversity
 
Racism Project
Racism ProjectRacism Project
Racism Projectcbh27810
 
Racial bias and stereo types in sports media across all mediums
Racial bias and stereo types in sports media across all mediums  Racial bias and stereo types in sports media across all mediums
Racial bias and stereo types in sports media across all mediums Joel H. Cooper
 
Black women build in the era of danger
Black women build in the era of dangerBlack women build in the era of danger
Black women build in the era of dangerTawana Jacobs, APR
 
2016 election already here for fringe hopefuls politico
2016 election already here for fringe hopefuls   politico2016 election already here for fringe hopefuls   politico
2016 election already here for fringe hopefuls politicoTemperance Lancecouncil
 

Tendances (20)

Racial discrimination, protest p pt
Racial discrimination, protest p ptRacial discrimination, protest p pt
Racial discrimination, protest p pt
 
1990-hatred-in-georgia111
1990-hatred-in-georgia1111990-hatred-in-georgia111
1990-hatred-in-georgia111
 
Soc345 lect5 lect6_race_ethnicity
Soc345 lect5 lect6_race_ethnicitySoc345 lect5 lect6_race_ethnicity
Soc345 lect5 lect6_race_ethnicity
 
Double V_MIDN CHANG_1APR2016_FINAL_NS412
Double V_MIDN CHANG_1APR2016_FINAL_NS412Double V_MIDN CHANG_1APR2016_FINAL_NS412
Double V_MIDN CHANG_1APR2016_FINAL_NS412
 
An Examination of Black Soccer Participation and Fandom in America
An Examination of Black Soccer Participation and Fandom in AmericaAn Examination of Black Soccer Participation and Fandom in America
An Examination of Black Soccer Participation and Fandom in America
 
Racial discrimination slide
Racial discrimination slideRacial discrimination slide
Racial discrimination slide
 
Lyrical analysis
Lyrical analysisLyrical analysis
Lyrical analysis
 
Everyday racism
Everyday racismEveryday racism
Everyday racism
 
Racism and xenophobia.
Racism and xenophobia.Racism and xenophobia.
Racism and xenophobia.
 
George Floyd: Black lives matter, peaceful protests and black history
George Floyd: Black lives matter, peaceful protests and black historyGeorge Floyd: Black lives matter, peaceful protests and black history
George Floyd: Black lives matter, peaceful protests and black history
 
Futurew of the american dream
Futurew of the american dreamFuturew of the american dream
Futurew of the american dream
 
Racism today
Racism todayRacism today
Racism today
 
A Capsule of Black Electoral Politics in America
A Capsule of Black Electoral Politics in AmericaA Capsule of Black Electoral Politics in America
A Capsule of Black Electoral Politics in America
 
Racism Project
Racism ProjectRacism Project
Racism Project
 
Racial bias and stereo types in sports media across all mediums
Racial bias and stereo types in sports media across all mediums  Racial bias and stereo types in sports media across all mediums
Racial bias and stereo types in sports media across all mediums
 
Made in america terrorist
Made in america terroristMade in america terrorist
Made in america terrorist
 
Black women build in the era of danger
Black women build in the era of dangerBlack women build in the era of danger
Black women build in the era of danger
 
L 4 White Privilege
L 4 White PrivilegeL 4 White Privilege
L 4 White Privilege
 
Anthropology Final
Anthropology Final Anthropology Final
Anthropology Final
 
2016 election already here for fringe hopefuls politico
2016 election already here for fringe hopefuls   politico2016 election already here for fringe hopefuls   politico
2016 election already here for fringe hopefuls politico
 

En vedette

สร้างอักษร
สร้างอักษรสร้างอักษร
สร้างอักษรPanuded Wongtankas
 
Homework Powerpoint
Homework PowerpointHomework Powerpoint
Homework Powerpointjenmulder
 
7 powodów dla których content marketing nie ma sensu bez social media
7 powodów dla których content marketing nie ma sensu bez social media7 powodów dla których content marketing nie ma sensu bez social media
7 powodów dla których content marketing nie ma sensu bez social mediaWhites
 
jz300725d_Ramirez_Presentation
jz300725d_Ramirez_Presentationjz300725d_Ramirez_Presentation
jz300725d_Ramirez_Presentationjpcoffice
 
Fondale et al PLOSone 2014 (dragged) 2
Fondale et al PLOSone 2014 (dragged) 2Fondale et al PLOSone 2014 (dragged) 2
Fondale et al PLOSone 2014 (dragged) 2Hyunsun Park
 
Invitación Historias con-sabidas
Invitación Historias con-sabidasInvitación Historias con-sabidas
Invitación Historias con-sabidasfigheritas
 
business plan
business planbusiness plan
business planxilvar
 
áLbum de fotografías
áLbum de fotografías  áLbum de fotografías
áLbum de fotografías wormaxd
 
3ª fase classificação final do 2º ciclo
3ª fase   classificação final do 2º ciclo3ª fase   classificação final do 2º ciclo
3ª fase classificação final do 2º cicloBiblioteca Escolar Aeob
 
3ª fase classificação final do secundário
3ª fase   classificação final do secundário3ª fase   classificação final do secundário
3ª fase classificação final do secundárioBiblioteca Escolar Aeob
 
#العلاج_الطبيعي - لمحة تعريفية عن التخصص
#العلاج_الطبيعي - لمحة تعريفية عن التخصص#العلاج_الطبيعي - لمحة تعريفية عن التخصص
#العلاج_الطبيعي - لمحة تعريفية عن التخصصPTideas
 

En vedette (15)

Presentation.R04
Presentation.R04Presentation.R04
Presentation.R04
 
Final Digipak Outcome
Final Digipak OutcomeFinal Digipak Outcome
Final Digipak Outcome
 
สร้างอักษร
สร้างอักษรสร้างอักษร
สร้างอักษร
 
Amy winehouse
Amy winehouseAmy winehouse
Amy winehouse
 
Homework Powerpoint
Homework PowerpointHomework Powerpoint
Homework Powerpoint
 
7 powodów dla których content marketing nie ma sensu bez social media
7 powodów dla których content marketing nie ma sensu bez social media7 powodów dla których content marketing nie ma sensu bez social media
7 powodów dla których content marketing nie ma sensu bez social media
 
jz300725d_Ramirez_Presentation
jz300725d_Ramirez_Presentationjz300725d_Ramirez_Presentation
jz300725d_Ramirez_Presentation
 
Fondale et al PLOSone 2014 (dragged) 2
Fondale et al PLOSone 2014 (dragged) 2Fondale et al PLOSone 2014 (dragged) 2
Fondale et al PLOSone 2014 (dragged) 2
 
Invitación Historias con-sabidas
Invitación Historias con-sabidasInvitación Historias con-sabidas
Invitación Historias con-sabidas
 
business plan
business planbusiness plan
business plan
 
áLbum de fotografías
áLbum de fotografías  áLbum de fotografías
áLbum de fotografías
 
Calloway's Merchandising Case Study Final
Calloway's Merchandising Case Study FinalCalloway's Merchandising Case Study Final
Calloway's Merchandising Case Study Final
 
3ª fase classificação final do 2º ciclo
3ª fase   classificação final do 2º ciclo3ª fase   classificação final do 2º ciclo
3ª fase classificação final do 2º ciclo
 
3ª fase classificação final do secundário
3ª fase   classificação final do secundário3ª fase   classificação final do secundário
3ª fase classificação final do secundário
 
#العلاج_الطبيعي - لمحة تعريفية عن التخصص
#العلاج_الطبيعي - لمحة تعريفية عن التخصص#العلاج_الطبيعي - لمحة تعريفية عن التخصص
#العلاج_الطبيعي - لمحة تعريفية عن التخصص
 

Comm360 Research Paper final

  • 1. Demitra Salteris Lawson COMM360 May 13, 2014 Successful “Thugs” For centuries, we human beings have lived within communities, in which we have near always portrayed superiority differences between different peoples, especially in regards to race and ethnicity. The Civil Rights Act of 1964 claimed that “All persons shall be entitled to the full and equal enjoyment of the goods, services, facilities, and privileges, advantages, and accommodations of any place of public accommodation, without discrimination or segregation on the ground of race, color, religion, or national origin.” Unfortunately, many individuals, myself included, can agree that the promises of the abovementioned act have not held true for all. Despite the Civil Rights Movement and many other movements and efforts to change the ways of society, this prejudice and racism still exists today in the United States. Although there is some dispute about how ubiquitous and influential racism is in the United States, it is clearly evident that it still impacts the rights, opportunities, and treatment of minorities. More specifically, the United States’ history of discrimination combined with modern racism is still strongly impacting the treatment of African-Americans today. According to a PBS article by George M. Frederickson, “Racism exists when one ethnic group or historical collectivity dominates, excludes, or seeks to eliminate another on the basis of differences that it believes are hereditary and unalterable.” Hindered in terms of entitlement and respect, African-Americans have largely been victims of the aforementioned definition for several eras. Even the individuals whom were/are successful and educated are perceived as inferior in some ways, and are
  • 2. 2 prevented from receiving the full respect and entitlements that they deserve for their success. On top of that, I believe African-Americans are not only disabled from achieving the full perks of success, but they are also pin-holed by society to only fill certain positions of success and fame. I believe this attempt to prevent African-Americans from fulfilling wide varieties of successful careers and lifestyles is because success often means power. Even though it may not be as openly expressed nowadays, I think many white Americans still do not want African-Americans to have power because they want to remain the superior ones. Overall, due to prejudice, African- Americans are stereotyped and referred to with negative connotations, even when they do not match them. Hence, in this paper I will analyze and interpret several pieces of rhetorical text, predominantly black rhetoric, to illuminate how hatred, discrimination, and an unwillingness to accept and respect those who differ, still relevantly impacts perceptions and hinders achievement of comprehensive success. I will show how it is discrimination in society that is still the leading cause of a truly successful and powerful African-American being considered an anomaly. If one were to take a look at the 2014 Forbes list of the World’s most powerful people, it would quickly become apparent that they are almost all non-blacks. There are only two black people out of the list of seventy-two people total, for supposedly the world’s most powerful people. One of those two black people is President Barack Obama (in spot #2) and then Aliko Dangote, CEO of the Dangote Group and Africa’s richest man (in spot #64), is the second black person on the list. To be more specific though, since Dangote is not American, President Barack Obama is the only actual African-American individual listed in the most powerful people list. Some may debate that this is this just a coincidence. On the other hand though, others believe that it is all because the history of discrimination is so deeply engrained in our system that we are
  • 3. 3 still putting up barriers for African-Americans. After much deliberation and clear evidence, that I will continue to speak of later, I must say I definitely believe that it is due to the latter. Sure, society has had a rise in famous African-American figures, but if one were to ask a group of Americans to name some successful African-American men, then besides President Obama, the most widely-known ones would definitely consist of mainly athletes or those in the entertainment industry, i.e. comedians, actors, music moguls, etc. This clearly demonstrates what I mentioned earlier about African-Americans seeming to be pin-holed so that they may only fulfill certain positions of success that do not have too high authority and influence over history. Athletes and entertainers exhibit much less authority and power compared to other high positions of success, such as politicians, lawyers, and surgeons, in my opinion. Additionally, African- Americans are accepted into these certain positions that I mentioned, to provide for whatever intents and purposes society has, and usually nothing more. In essence, these famous African- American figures and celebrities, especially men in particular, may have achieved greatness in pay and popularity but not necessarily as much respect overall compared to other successful, non-black figures. One extremely recent and pertinent example involves the case of now-former owner of the Clippers NBA team, Donald Sterling, telling his mistress that he does not want her bringing any black people to his games, and does not want her fraternizing with them on any social media, like Instagram. This shows an instance of African-American individuals being accepted only in the positions that some members of society want them in, because he does not want black people around him for any other purpose besides playing for his team and making him money. In the conversation between Donald Sterling and his girlfriend, one part in particular stood out so vehemently to me. In this part of the recording, Sterling basically claims he is not
  • 4. 4 racist; that is just the way the world is, so he follows it. Yet, he goes on to mention how in Israel they treat black people like dogs, and that the white Jews are a hundred and fifty percent better than black Jews; clearly showing that he is bigoted because his perception of blacks is that they are substandard. His girlfriend, who ironically happens to be half black, also asks him in the conversation why he has to treat black people like dogs too, and if he thinks that it is right. Sterling responded with a bold statement of, “It isn’t a question – we don’t evaluate what’s right and wrong, we live in a society. We live in a culture. We have to live within that culture….I don’t want to change the culture because I can’t. It’s too big…I don’t want change.” The public sharing of this preposterous conversation caused quite an uproar, but this man’s extreme racism and hatred never would have been brought to light if someone had not spied and secretly recorded the conversation. Also, I think the worst part is that Sterling kept claiming that he is not a racist. Ultimately, the whole ordeal that occurred with Sterling highlights how there truly are Caucasian people that are highly prejudiced and instilled with negative perceptions of African- Americans, in current times. So, the true question is, how many more non-black successful figures and people with authority in society think and act in the same manner as Sterling? Because if enough important people have the same ideology, then it is extremely obvious that they are the ones who are trying to maintain African-Americans at an inferior status, sometimes without everyone else in society even being aware of them doing so. By ensuring that systems concerning social status in regards to ethnicity stay in place, then it is ensuring that not everyone is provided with the opportunity to rise above and become successful, especially if they attempt to rise from ‘nothing.’ High levels of poverty and unemployment appear to be prominent among many African-American communities, arguably due to the strong prominence of racism still existing. Yet, there are a vast number of African-
  • 5. 5 American individuals which lead ‘normal’ lifestyles and are also viewed as unequal to non- blacks. In reference to an article from California State University of Sacramento, there are two types of racism: 1) “Moral racism- The belief that a race of people is morally inferior, and as such members of that race are deserving of less respect and concern.” 2) “Genetic Racism- The belief that a race of people is genetically inferior, and as such members of that race are (on the average) less intelligent, and generally less capable.” These two subsets of racism so clearly provide a reasoning behind why even African-Americans who have succeeded, achieved equal pay and popularity, still do not necessarily receive all the same respect. A very public example of a successful black individual that felt disrespected due to what he perceived as racism was in 2006, when Kanye West at a Concert for Hurricane [Katrina] Relief made the jaw-dropping statement: “George Bush doesn’t care about black people.” The lack of response to Hurricane Katrina made Kanye feel as though the only reason could be because the affected area is filled with mostly black people and since the news was portraying black people with negative connotations. Thus, due to disrespectful implications towards mostly blacks, he felt that the commander in chief, aka the President, did not care about helping black people nor how they were negatively affected by the disaster. Kanye started off the presentation by completely ignoring the script and claiming, “I hate the way they portray us in the media. You see a black family, it says, 'They're looting.' You see a white family, it says, 'They're looking for food.' And, you know, it's been five days because most of the people are black…and just to imagine if I was down there, and those are my people down there. So anybody out there that wants to do anything that we can help—with the way America is set up to help the poor, the black people, the less well-off, as slow as possible. I mean, the Red Cross is doing everything they can. We already realize a lot of people that could help are at war right now, fighting another
  • 6. 6 way—and they've given them permission to go down and shoot us!” Known for being very straightforward, Kanye made it adamant that the public knew what was going on in the disaster zones, and how the black families there were being mostly depicted as thieves and such, even though everyone was acting in the same ways to survive. On top of his statements in regards to the hurricane relief, he also squeezed in his opinions of how America is not as invested in providing urgent aid and care for those are less well-off, specifically poor and black people. From what I interpreted, I think Kanye is trying to illustrate how societal discrimination is still prominently affecting the opportunities and livelihoods of black people. Even though Kanye was not directly affected by the hurricane, he still felt very upset and disrespected by media’s statements surrounding the disaster because even though the statements were not towards him specifically, he still knew that they were aimed towards people who were basically just like him. Another reason that Kanye felt disrespected is because he put himself in the shoes of ‘his fellow people’ and felt as though if he was down in New Orleans during the time of the ordeal that he would have been treated and portrayed in the same light as those there because he is black. Lamentably, although Kanye’s statements were considered very controversial, they did nothing for the issue at hand. Presumably, I would assume this is because people did not take him very seriously due to his lack of credibility, the fact that he did not sound very composed in his speech, and predominantly because of what is known for. As a rapper, Kanye West has several tracks in which he speaks profanely at times, and in many songs he refers to aspects and terminology like gold diggers, slaves, swagga, drugs, n*ggas, etc., that are supposedly more understood or related to in black communities. Some tracks are songs that are heartfelt or deep, and focus on struggles and hardships that he and people like him have experienced in life. Nonetheless, he is looked down upon by many because
  • 7. 7 of the negative connotations drawn from his lyrics from people who do not understand the culture and terminology. Even though Kanye is rich, famous, and successful, he is still at times, undesirably personified through the notions that people draw from his lyrics. Also, the vernacular that he uses at times can be interpreted by some as informal or uneducated due to slight variations of Standard English, in addition to slang terms. An even more dramatic example of a successful black person who has been affected by racism and stereotypical assumptions involves the misinterpretation and offensive labeling of NFL Seahawks cornerback, Richard Sherman. This past year, Richard Sherman was widely characterized as a “thug” in the media, immediately after the airing of an interview after last year’s NFC championship game, in which he totally eluded the asked question and began yelling aggressively and appearing pumped up as if he was ready to fight. He also did not use all Standard English terminology, which can come off as being uneducated to some. For example, in this interview he referred to an opponent player as a “sorry receiver” instead of an unskilled receiver, or when he says “gon’ get” instead of ‘going to get.’ What many do not know though is that this man (Sherman) who was considered a “thug,” actually graduated from renowned Stanford University with a 4.0 grade point average. In addition, he also has 40 million dollars guaranteed to him, on top of the money he already has made playing, for signing his four-year extension with the Seahawks. Clearly, Sherman is much better educated and has tremendously more money than a vast majority of society, so one would expect him to be applauded and respected for his accomplishments, instead of being disrespected and pigeonholed as if he is just some simple black person from the streets. Thus, Sherman serves as an example of how some black people are referred to as merely “brothers” or “thugs,” and viewed as lesser, even though they may be well-educated, well-off moneywise, in addition to being well-mannered. There is
  • 8. 8 also irony in non-blacks calling out black people for their “improper” use of English because many of the terms that they use when referring to black people have different denotations than what they think they stand for. I will expand on these misinterpretations below, as well as how being stuck in one mind set due to an unwillingness to accept differences impacts the reputation and perceptions towards anyone whom thinks and speaks in ways that are unlike what they were taught is right. According to Encyclopedia Britannica, the term “thug” surprisingly does not even come from American culture, and actually originates from centuries ago in India. Thug or “thag” in Hindi means something completely different than the connotation it is presumed to mean. Britannica states that the original definition of a thug was “a member of a well-organized confederacy of professional assassins who traveled in gangs throughout India for several hundred years.” It is also described as being very similar to Satanism, except it is even more violent. Thus, it is clear that the individuals that non-blacks were trying to degrade black people by calling them something that they thought meant something else completely, and in fact does not relate to African-Americans at all, if used in the original sense. So, the African-Americans that are referred to as thugs, like Sherman was, are being referred to as something that they are not. The connotation that non-blacks seem to believe matches with the term “thug,” seems to be a person who is violent, uneducated, “ghetto”, a degenerate, or a thief, etc. that does not care to conform to societal standards. The term’s usage being adopted into rap and hip-hop music then combined with messages related to black culture that were viewed as not conforming to societal morals and standards by non-blacks. The aforementioned combined with prejudice, likely inspired the anglicized, more modernly presumed connotation. I say the modern connotation is derived from prejudice because the term is meant to come off as degrading, and some believe
  • 9. 9 that, “recently the white conservative movement in the U.S.A. has adopted it as a substantive replacement for the vulgar and toxic term "nigger" which is no longer safe for use in most media channels (democraticunderground.com).” The modern introduction of the term through rap and hip-hop obviously did not denote the same. As Tupac defined it, “a thug is someone who is going through struggles, has gone through struggles, and continues to live day by day with nothing for them. That person is a thug, and the life they are living is the thug life.” Unfortunately, many individuals spun this expression around to be negative due to an inability to relate, in addition to its connection to other aspects of poor, troubled black neighborhoods such as exposure to violence, drugs, crime, etc. The non-permeable minds of some individuals will never be able to grasp the connotations of certain speech that does not match the style of language and rhetoric that they were raised within. If people are kept inside these barriers and do not attempt to make efforts in understanding and accepting others’ ideologies and terminology, then it will never be fully possible to interpret what the other people truly mean. Modernly, this is exactly what happens with a lot of African-American speech communities. These slight variations of the English vernacular by large populations of African-Americans caused another break in society since many other Americans could not grasp the terminology and vernacular. This breakoff resulted in the creation of a newer linguistic category, referred to by linguists as either ‘Black English’, ‘African-American Vernacular English (AAVE)’, or the more negative connotation that was coined around the 1960’s called “Nonstandard Negro English.” I have learned throughout the years that, very often when individuals are unsure of or do not agree with something, then they end up bashing it. Thus, the aforementioned phenomena of bashing what you do not like or agree with, happened in regards to African-American speech, causing many negative criticisms.
  • 10. 10 Hence, that is why many non-blacks try to use these circumstances surrounding vernacular disagreement as another way to downplay the success of black individuals. The coining of such terms as “Nonstandard Negro English,” coincided with terms of other distasteful, negative connotations towards African-Americans, which was naturally, very disliked by a vast majority of African-American individuals. This linguistic discrepancy was just another way that society could discriminate against African-Americans. So, in 1973 a group of black scholars took it into their hands and created a new term known as Ebonics. According to an article by John R. Rickford from The Linguistic Society of America, Ebonics is “a blend of the words ebony ‘black’ and phonics ‘sounds’,” and simply means ‘black speech.’ Examples include random slang words like “ashy” to refer to the whitish-gray appearance of black skin when dry, and then there are also grammatical variations like some pronunciation changes caused by the dropping of b, d, g from the beginning of auxiliary verbs, resulting in statements like “ah ‘on know” instead of the formal “I don’t know.” Speaking in this vernacular is often regarded as a sign of a lack of sophistication and education, due to many not being familiar with its connection to the African culture and the Black Diaspora of places like Jamaica, Nigeria, and more places whose roots stem from Africa. There are other cases however, where very literate and well-known figures, have used Ebonics instead for dramatic or realistic effect, including famous authors like Zora Neal Hurston and Toni Morrison, as well as many Black preachers and entertainers, especially rappers. According to Michael Eric Dyson, “rap expresses the ongoing preoccupation with literacy and orality that has characterized African-American communities since the inception of legally coerced illiteracy during slavery (pg. 408)…It expresses the desire of young black people to reclaim their history, reactivate forms of black radicalism, and contest the powers of despair
  • 11. 11 and economic depression that presently besiege the black community (pg. 410).” Although these intentions may be obvious to those who are part of the black community, they once again can be interpreted differently due to an inability to understand and relate. I believe that many individuals which are impervious to such lifestyles and culture just perceive black communities that live in such ways as people who are incapable of being someone who is successful and respected. Thus, discrimination, an inability to understand, and an unwillingness to accept that just because black people speak a certain way and experience certain ordeals which do not meet society’s supposed moral standards; causes others to not be able to see past the unappealing details to the deeper meanings and intentions of becoming something better in the world. Referring back to Tupac, he was a major figure which utilized Ebonics in his lyrics while describing the socioeconomic struggles of black communities that existed, and that he personally rose up from. When a lot of people hear the lyrics or statements of rappers speaking about violence, crime, and poverty, they are crudely misinterpreted. They think that these are the only ways of life that these people strive to live and pursue, but that is not so. There is a so much deeper meaning. It is about rising from the bottom, and working as hard as you possibly can to make it up from there. Certain people may live differently than others, surrounded by poor living situations and more precarious obstacles, but that does not mean that they are not good people and does not mean that they are any less worthy or capable of being a successful individual "That boy ain't a gangsta, fo'sho'. Look at how he walks, he's a thug. life. That's the saddest face I've seen in all my life as a teen," is one lyrical example including Ebonics, in which he is referring to the hardships of coming from a poor, black community and the struggles of living with next to nothing. Many individuals who were unable to understand Tupac’s meaning, wrote it off as him promoting being a person from the streets that hustles or acts like a “thug.” However, like I said
  • 12. 12 is because they did not understand what Tupac was trying to portray, and exactly what he denoted “thug life” as. Tupac’s definition of thug life was broken down into a statement “Thug life- the hate you gave little infants f*cks everyone.” Essentially, with certain individuals practicing such horrible prejudice and hatred in their everyday lives they are just passing it onto future generations. They are setting it up so that they are an example of how humans should supposedly treat one another, but clearly it is not the right way to harm others based on their ethnic background. When hateful people raise their children within the same hatred then it often becomes the only environment they know of. The youth are the ones who are our future; the ones who will make great changes to society. So, if the ones controlling our future are engrained with such outrageous bigotry towards one another, won’t they not be able to come together to keep society thriving? Thus, it seems to me that if the future is filled with hate-driven individuals then like Tupac said everyone be will f*cked, because then everyone is ultimately being gipped of enhancement opportunities for society. If the problem of hatred hinders the advancements of society too greatly, then it could ultimately crumble. Additionally, the containment of poor, black people, due to fear of gaining supremacy is another reason for the shortage of inspirational and successful black figures because since very few are provided with equal opportunities for rising to success. In reference to an article written by Edward Williams, he also made the claim of how with such few examples of high levels of success among black men, it makes it difficult for young, black men to find a path to mold their own lives by. Also according to Williams’ article, “Over the last 200 years of American history, there has been one African-American male President, one African-American male Attorney General, one African-American male Secretary of State, and two African-American male Supreme Court Justices. There is
  • 13. 13 currently one African-American male governor, there have only been four in American History. Five (0.83%) of the Fortune 500 CEOs are African-American men. Approximately 1% of all law firm partners are African-American men. There has been one African-American male Surgeon General in American history. And fewer than six percent of all high-ranking military officers are African-American.” These ridiculously low figures in reference to black men who hold positions of high success, demonstrate part of the crisis that discrimination causes. With a lack of sufficient successful and intelligent black people being openly presented to society, it consequently means that there is a lack of role models for those still struggling to aspire after. I can think of a few instances from my own experiences of living in the United States during Obama’s presidency, in which individuals made crude remarks about him. When listening to the radio one day, I even heard a conversation in which a little African-American boy said to a white woman how he wanted to be the next black president. She retorted with something along the lines of ‘oh no, we already had one of those, we don’t need another one. With the rarity of these accomplished black male figures it sends a message to other young, black men that it is very rare for individuals like them to succeed and be provided with the opportunity to make it to such high positions of success. Additionally, it makes it apparent that for African-Americans there is no set path to attempt to follow, making their attempts at achieving such high success seem even more complicated. In consequence, I believe there will likely be an even greater decline of African- Americans rising up from the bottom. We know that different races, including African-Americans, all have the same inherent abilities, thus the high statistics of poverty, unemployment, and crime, can be most rationally explained by the persistence of bigoted authorities in society to maintain the “status quo,” with
  • 14. 14 white supremacy. Attempts by some to promote equality are not always fully carried out however. Senator Robert F. Kennedy once stated, “We have always believed it possible for men and women who start at the bottom to rise as far as their talent and energy allow. Neither race nor place of birth should affect their chances." Although this statement in particular is widely referring to immigration, I believe it serves dually in reference to racism and prejudice, and is essentially summarizing the claim that I made above pertaining to African-Americans having the same intrinsic abilities as every other race does. I wholeheartedly agree with the statement in that, neither race nor place of birth should impact one’s chances to rise from the bottom. However, based on United States history alone, the notion that Americans have always believed in such can be proven false. I say this because several different types of individuals throughout time have been prevented from rising up in success, including all different ethnic minorities and women. Additionally, I think it is important to highlight the fact that Kennedy says should, because it shows that he believes that people ought to not be having that happen, but not necessarily that it is enforced or is something that is for sure happening. Chiefly, just because the famous political figure made the claim, does not mean that the masses will all believe in and follow what he said. Kennedy’s quote was very inspirational, but that was about it for the most part. Like Senator Robert F. Kennedy claimed, our attitudes towards the situation reflects our faith in the American ideal; of it being the ‘land of opportunity,’ and equality for all. However, I am going to go a step further in the analysis of this quote, and say that if our attitudes towards the topic are positive then yes it will help motivate others to take advantage of America’s opportunities. Yet, if too great a number of attitudes towards minorities are negative then it reflects that we do not care about the American ideal of all peoples being entitled to the same
  • 15. 15 liberties. A reflection of the latter regrettably seems to be more present in society, involving deleterious attitudes in regards to African-Americans not being deserving or worthy of being provided with equal entitlements, opportunities, respect, and most controversially, status. It almost seems that no matter how much time passes, there will still be prejudice and discrimination in the world. The persistent impact of prejudice and racism has become so engrained that it seems we may never be able to shake it. Sadly, due to the usually more aggressive drive behind individuals filled with hatred and prejudice it denounces many of the breakthroughs attempted to be made towards achieving complete equality. In fact, almost every famous figure that attempted to strongly change the prejudiced ways of society and the breakdown of it in terms of social status, from Abraham Lincoln to Martin Luther King Jr. and Malcolm X to John F. Kennedy, all were very tragically stopped in their attempts by being killed by bigoted individuals that felt that they could not bear, and refused to allow, a change in the social system and supposed order of supremacy. There are many people in positions of high power in society, which still believe in white supremacy and the inclusion of a social system broken down by race that should not have the capability to be altered by any member of the general public. These people’s actions are hard to counteract if one does not have the same amount of power and authority, especially financially, but the only way to prevent further slinking back to our country’s discriminatory roots, is to keep fighting against their ways. I think I can confidently say that practically every individual in the world that has received some sort of education has heard about the famous figures mentioned above, for their publicized attempts to change society from its current racially broken down system. However, there are so many more sources that one can acquire knowledge about this racial issue and the obstacles preventing its solution. Thus, I think education and collaboration
  • 16. 16 are key tools in providing those who want change, greater ability to fight back against racism. James Baldwin once stated, “The paradox of education is precisely this – that as one begins to become conscious one begins to examine the society in which he is being educated. The purpose of education, finally, is to create in a person the ability to look at the world for himself, to make his own decisions, to say to himself this is black or this is white, to decide for himself whether there is a God in heaven or not. To ask questions of the universe, and then learn to live with those questions, is the way he achieves his own identity. But no society is really anxious to have that kind of person around. What societies really, ideally, want is a citizenry which will simply obey the rules of society. If a society succeeds in this, that society is about to perish. The obligation of anyone who thinks of himself as responsible is to examine society and try to change it and to fight it –at no matter what risk.” Summarizing what Baldwin stated, essentially some higher powers of society do not want people to be extremely educated in everything, or to question how society is run, thus they try disabling people from receiving the opportunity to do so, especially with African-Americans. Based on my analyses, it seems to me that the higher powers which are creating these obstacles believe that if they continue to do so, then individuals will not be powerful or educated enough to try to question their ways publicly and that they will not be able to get together enough people to turn against them. The high powers of society only want these individuals around to abide by their rules and to maintain the roles that they are ‘designated.’ Essentially the higher powers of society that wish to maintain the discriminatory mainframe are blocking all forms of betterment and achievement, in the hopes that it will also leave those individuals with not enough resources and knowledge to fight back against them. Not only that, but also if more African-Americans are
  • 17. 17 provided with education and guidance on how they can be successful, then they can help progress their race’s influence even more so. From my understanding of the research that I conducted there are not only the typical pressures of success, but there is even more pressure on African-American males due to the fact of them still being considered an anomaly. If more African-Americans receive higher educations, then they can hopefully achieve more greatness in society’s highly successful positions, and subsequently pass along their knowledge and recommendations to other African-Americans of both now and the future. If enough African-Americans achieve high success, then they can also collaborate together to try to increase their ranking in the social system, ultimately in hopes of achieving a proliferation of highly respected, and successful African-American figures. In reference to Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. he most notably stated that, “all progress is precarious and the solution of one problem brings us face to face with another problem.” I understand that the notion of combatting something as big and powerful as racism can seem incredibly overwhelming, if not impossible. But if enough people joined together to fight it at the same time then who knows what could happen. I truly think there just has not been a large enough collaboration of successfully educated and knowledgeable individuals to fight against the issue of discrimination. From Dr. Martin Luther King Jr.’s statement, I think he perfectly captures the notion of how yes, there are some risks in going against the system and trying to progress the proliferation of educated, and successfully ranking African-Americans. However, there is always going to be someone who has a problem with accepting differences, and society is always going to have some sort of problem to solve, so I think they should not be deterred. Sometimes we have to do the things that we are told we cannot do to ultimately achieve the results that we want. In this case, although there may be worries of systematic backlash, I think
  • 18. 18 African-Americans must still push to rise above and make solutions to society’s discriminatory problems, because otherwise there will never be change. Referring back to James Baldwin’s statement of how “The obligation of anyone who thinks of himself as responsible is to examine society and try to change it and to fight it –at no matter what risk,” touches exactly on the notion that I am trying to convey. If people, particularly African-Americans, want to see change, then they are going to have to go above and beyond to fight the issue, no matter the cost. Despite successful black people still being considered an anomaly, they are incredibly more educated and successful than they were decades ago. So, they should take advantage of this and join together to combat discrimination because there is close to no chance that circumstances could revert back to how poorly African-Americans were treated before, so why not take the chance of advancing equality even more. Conclusively, I strongly believe that an alliance of enough strong-minded, educated black individuals can form paths of success that they can utilize to, in the words of Public Enemy, “fight the power.” The concepts of prejudice and racism have been around for a long time, so they unfortunately are going to take a long time to uproot from society as well. Nevertheless, the constraints of racism in regards to the advancements and true success of African-Americans have lightened some recently. As long as African-Americans keep doing whatever they possibly can to make a change in society, they can continue to rise in success, maintaining strong hopes for becoming powerful enough figures to make an ultimate change in how they are hindered by society.
  • 19. 19 Works Cited Dyson, Michael Eric. "The Culture of Hip-Hop." The Michael Eric Dyson reader. New York: Basic Civitas Books, 2004. 408-410. Print. Forbes. "The World's Most Powerful People." Forbes. Forbes Magazine, n.d. Web. 1 May 2014. <http://www.forbes.com/powerful-people/list/>. Frederickson, George M.. "The Historical Origins and Development of Race." PBS. PBS, n.d. Web. 1 May 2014. <http://www.pbs.org/race/000_About/002_04-background-02- 01.htm>. "Is Affirmative Action Fair?." History of Discrimination. California State University, Sacramento, n.d. Web. 29 Apr. 2014. <http://www.csus.edu/indiv/g/gaskilld/socialissues14/affirmative%20action.htm>. A Concert for Hurricane Relief. NBC Universal Television Group. NBC, New York. 2 Sept. 2005. Television. Kennedy, Robert F.. "Talk:Robert F. Kennedy." - Wikiquote. N.p., n.d. Web. 2 May 2014. <http://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Talk:Robert_F._Kennedy>. Rickford, John R.. "Linguistic Society of America." What is Ebonics (African American English)?. The Linguistic Society of America, n.d. Web. 1 May 2014. <http://www.linguisticsociety.org/content/what-ebonics-african-american-english>. Sherman, Richard. "Richard Sherman Post Game Interview: Seattle Seahawks cornerback Richard Sherman Post Game 49ers." NFL Network. FOX Sports. FOX, Washington, DC: 20 Jan. 2014. Television. "thug". Encyclopædia Britannica. Encyclopædia Britannica Online. Encyclopædia Britannica Inc., 2014. Web. 1 May 2014. <http://www.britannica.com/EBchecked/topic/594263/thug>.
  • 20. 20 "Thug Life Army." Code of 'THUG LIFE. Star Sound Music Group, 22 Sept. 2004. Web. 1 May 2014. <http://www.thuglifearmy.com/code-of-thug-life.html>. Quotes from Tupac Shakur Wagner, Kyle. "Exclusive: The Extended Donald Sterling Tape." Deadspin. N.p., n.d. Web. 1 May 2014. <http://deadspin.com/exclusive-the-extended-donald-sterling-tape- 1568291249>. Williams, Edward. "The Weight of Being a (Young and Successful) Black Male." PolicyMic. N.p., 21 July 2012. Web. 30 Apr. 2014. <http://www.policymic.com/articles/11599/the- weight-of-being-a-young-and-successful-black-male>.