SlideShare une entreprise Scribd logo
1  sur  26
Télécharger pour lire hors ligne
Being in the World 3:
Anxiety & Skepticism
— The Esoteric Teaching —
dharmasar@gmail.com
ANXIETY, SKEPTICISM AND NIHILISM
Our ontological analysis of anxiety in the previous section
also sheds much light on skepticism and nihilism. Philosophers
again and again attempt disproofs of skepticism about the
reality of the external world; nevertheless all such attempts
to invalidate the skeptical attitude ultimately fail.This is
because any proper conception of our worldliness makes the
skeptic’s doubts self-defeating, impossible and devoid of
significance.We cannot disprove an unprovable philosophy.
Nevertheless, skepticism as a mode of being persists.
In our default state we do not have any Being besides being in the
world.The world is the context for everything we experience or
can experience; just as water is the context for everything a fish can
experience.We never experience the world as a thing in itself, only
the things that exist in the world, including ourselves.Thus, skeptical
questions about ‘reality’ or ‘the world’ as separate and independent
from ourselves are meaningless and unanswerable. It is as useless to
attempt to prove or disprove such ontologically incoherent
statements as it is to try to make sense out of nonsense.
ANXIETY, SKEPTICISM AND NIHILISM
Yet, skeptical doubts about individual objects in the world are
not only articulable but also irrefutable, and such skepticism is
pervasive in modern thought. From the ontological point of
view, the skeptical impulse is certainly self-defeating, since its
doubts annihilate the conditions for their own meaning.Yet
skepticism is also self-renewing as a human possibility, affecting
those possessed by it with a near-unshakable confidence in
their own conclusions. How is this possible?
ANXIETY, SKEPTICISM AND NIHILISM
Since the skeptical attitude is a human ontological possibility—a way of
understanding and grasping one’s worldly existence—it must be subject
to ontological analysis.That means among other things that it should be
inflected by a particular mood.We can easily observe that the skeptic is
someone beset by gnawing doubts—someone in the grip of anxiety.
Skepticism is anxiety manifest as philosophy. But more than that, anxiety
is one of the most powerful possibilities of our phenomenological self-
disclosure. In anxiety we reveal ourselves as worldly beings whose Being
is an issue for us.Thus we should expect skeptical anxiety to be very
useful in phenomenological self-inquiry; and so it is.
ANXIETY, SKEPTICISM AND NIHILISM
Anxiety finds its clearest expression when it has no
particular object. Pure objectless anxiety is related to, and
hence reveals, the worldliness of the world and the
uncanniness or alienating strangeness of being in the
world; thus it helps to disclose our own inherently worldly
Being. It also reveals that our way of being in the world is
that of being not at home in the world. How does
skeptical anxiety confirm this paradoxical perception?
ANXIETY, SKEPTICISM AND NIHILISM
One aspect of anxiety is the sense of a disconnect between
ourselves and the world. It gives a sense of a void at the heart of
reality, and a sense of ourselves as not at home in the world.
Another aspect of anxiety reveals a disconnect between ourselves
and others, as if their thoughts and feelings were unknowable.
Thus we often experience ourselves as alone and alienated in the
world. In either mode, skepticism as an expression of anxiety
finds itself opposed to common sense, to what ‘everybody
knows’: the truths of average everyday human existence, being in
the world absorbed in phenomena and the opinions of others.
ANXIETY, SKEPTICISM AND NIHILISM
In this opposition to worldliness, the
skeptic discloses and falsifies the default
realities of typical human beingness. For
although we are essentially worldly, we are
also always more than any particular
worldly situation in which we find
ourselves; although we are overwhelmed by
being in the world, we are also individuated.
ONTOLOGICAL STRUCTURE OF ANXIETY
Falsification
Contingency
Uncanniness
Worldly Anxiety
Hence the argumentative skeptic, in his denial
of our worldliness, commonality and
inauthenticity, also denies the truth of our
being in the world.At the same time, the
objectless anxiety of which skepticism is the
expression, in its fear of accepting absorption
in the world, hints at the hidden truth of our
Being: our innate possibility to attain true
individuality, integrity and authenticity.
ONTOLOGICAL STRUCTURE OF ANXIETY
Falsification
Contingency
Uncanniness
Worldly Anxiety
Further, if skepticism repudiates the commonsense expressions
of ordinary being in the world, then they must be contingent,
simply an accident of the conditions of our being in the world.
Skepticism shows that worldly articulations of meaning can
continue to affect us only if we continue to care about them.The
self-defeating character of skepticism (“This sentence is false.”)
means the skeptic can effect such withdrawals of interest in the
world even in the guise of the most passionate investment in it.
ONTOLOGICAL STRUCTURE OF ANXIETY
In other words, the self-subversiveness of skepticism shows
that caring about worldly discourse, in which the issue of our
own Being is most fundamentally at stake, is not automatic. It
is not that expressions of worldliness are part of the
predetermined essence of our existence. Rather, they are a
cultural inheritance that we can choose whether or not to
take responsibility for, in and through our being in the world.
ONTOLOGICAL STRUCTURE OF ANXIETY
There is also a third aspect that skeptical anxiety helps to
bring out: the uncanniness of being in the world. For the
worldliness of the world to which anxiety is a response is a
system or field of meaning; therefore the sense or meaning
of our existence is ultimately an aspect of our Being.
ONTOLOGICAL STRUCTURE OF ANXIETY
If that is so, the significance of our lives cannot be derived
from any external source or authority—whether that source
is conceived as God, as a range of Platonic ideals, or as a
structure of values encoded in the structure of reality by
genetics or other physical laws. Our authentic being must be
rooted in the uniqueness of our individuality, and thus must
be sought within ourselves by phenomenal self-examination.
ONTOLOGICAL STRUCTURE OF ANXIETY
How then can the structures of meaning that give
orientation and meaning to our being in the world
have any genuinely objective authority, any real claim
on us? Skepticism asserts that meaning must be an
essentially anthropocentric construction designed to
cover up the intrinsic meaninglessness of the world.
ONTOLOGICAL STRUCTURE OF ANXIETY
Anxiety’s disclosure of the world as a domain in
which we are ultimately not at home, and can choose
to accept or not, is perfect confirmation of the
ontological truth that the meaning of our lives lacks
any external ground. It does not prove that the
meaning of our life is arbitrary or synthetic; rather it
can only be derived from a deep ontological analysis
of our being in the world as an as-lived experience.
ONTOLOGICAL STRUCTURE OF ANXIETY
Anxiety’s disclosure of the world as a domain in
which we are ultimately not at home, and can
choose to accept or not, is perfect confirmation of
the ontological truth that the meaning of our lives
lacks any external ground. It does not prove that the
meaning of our life is arbitrary or synthetic; rather it
can only be derived from a deep ontological analysis
of our being in the world as an as-lived experience.
ONTOLOGICAL STRUCTURE OF ANXIETY
The uncanniness of our being in the world revealed by
skepticism captures the ontological root of nihilism.
Nihilism is an extreme form of philosophical skepticism
concerning the reality or substance of value and meaning.
We must carefully distinguish between the truth of nihilism
and the distortions embedded in its intellectual expression.
ONTOLOGICAL STRUCTURE OF ANXIETY
The idea of meaningfulness wholly external to our being in the
world is indeed empty of significance. But acknowledging the
internal relation between idle talk and our ordinary Being does
not mean that we deny, trivialize or relativize the conceptions of
truth and reality.Thus, an authentic response to nihilism
acknowledges that life’s meaning lacks any external, absolute
ground without denying its very real effects upon us.
ONTOLOGICAL STRUCTURE OF ANXIETY
Any absolute external structure of significance would
have to be constituted in ways entirely independent of
the ontological structure of our being in the world. How
could an external source of meaning provide us with
internal articulation of being in the world? How could it
constitute the worldliness of the world, and thus orient
and motivate our practical activities within it?
ONTOLOGICAL STRUCTURE OF ANXIETY
The transcendental concept that the world is meaningless
or false, and only a wholly external structure of meaning
can make any authoritative claims, is backwards. Rather, the
only structures of meaning that can possibly make claims
on us are ones to which our worldly Being is inherently
open, and by which it is structured and articulated.
ONTOLOGICAL STRUCTURE OF ANXIETY
In other words, the idea of absolute transcendental objectivity
that fuels nihilism cannot provide the authority and
authenticity that our worldly fields of meaning could have, but
unfortunately lack. Nor can it be right to think of the
structures of significance in which we exist as merely internal.
The ontological structures of being in the world are all the
meaning there is, or could be, for creatures whose Being is like
ours. Such meanings are the limits or conditions necessary to
determine any being whose Being is worldly, and hence finite.
ONTOLOGICAL STRUCTURE OF ANXIETY
The truth in nihilism is that our Being is essentially finite or
conditioned.We are not unconditioned, infinite or godlike;
nor are we entirely reducible to our determining conditions.
We are not possessed by an external ground of meaning,
nor are we wholly self-grounding either.Accordingly, to say
that our worldliness is uncanny means that it must be
understood in relation to what it is not and to that which is
not—in relation to nothing and nothingness.
ONTOLOGICAL STRUCTURE OF ANXIETY
The skeptics truly suffer the reality of ordinary human
existence, for they give philosophical expression to
the pervasive mood of anxiety in being in the world.
However from an ontological point of view,
skepticism does not properly articulate that reality, or
how best to understand its passionate anxiety.This is
a vital task of authentic phenomenology.
ONTOLOGICAL STRUCTURE OF ANXIETY
Phenomenological investigations of Being must be informed by
some particular mood.We are open to skeptical anxiety; not
only subjecting it to serious phenomenological analysis, but also
allowing it to guide our sense of what matters in the field of
practical activity.Then we become sensitive to the most far-
reaching and primordial existential disclosure of our Being.
What else could better facilitate our attempts to grasp our
Being in as transparent a manner as possible—to make the
existential possibility of investigating our Being truly our own?
ONTOLOGICAL STRUCTURE OF ANXIETY
But it is critical that we adopt a moderate attitude
toward the skeptical mood. Especially, we should
not take skepticism’s interpretation of its own
significance for granted.We should not accept the
skeptic’s over-anxious claim of knowing that the
world is not knowable, without acknowledging that
the world cannot therefore be doubtable either.
ONTOLOGICAL STRUCTURE OF ANXIETY
Authentically skeptical phenomenology distinguishes the
disclosures made possible by its mood of anxiety from that
mood’s self-concealment and deception.We must overcome
skepticism from within, by being skeptical about its self-
distorted misunderstandings.We must dwell in the mode of
being in the world without making ourselves at home in it.
Only thus can we discover what is truthful about skepticism,
and the actual value that skepticism can disclose to us.
ONTOLOGICAL STRUCTURE OF ANXIETY

Contenu connexe

Tendances

Philosophy lecture 11
Philosophy lecture 11Philosophy lecture 11
Philosophy lecture 11
Mr-Mike
 
The philosophical enterprise
The philosophical enterpriseThe philosophical enterprise
The philosophical enterprise
Leofrix Asturias
 

Tendances (20)

GABRIEL MARCEL MYSTERY OF BEING
GABRIEL MARCEL MYSTERY OF BEINGGABRIEL MARCEL MYSTERY OF BEING
GABRIEL MARCEL MYSTERY OF BEING
 
Philosophy of-the-human-person
Philosophy of-the-human-person Philosophy of-the-human-person
Philosophy of-the-human-person
 
01 existentialism & mans search for meaning
01  existentialism & mans search for meaning01  existentialism & mans search for meaning
01 existentialism & mans search for meaning
 
Consciousness, Identity and Self
Consciousness, Identity and SelfConsciousness, Identity and Self
Consciousness, Identity and Self
 
Philosophy lecture 11
Philosophy lecture 11Philosophy lecture 11
Philosophy lecture 11
 
Six basic themes of existentialism
Six basic themes of existentialismSix basic themes of existentialism
Six basic themes of existentialism
 
02 existentialism
02  existentialism02  existentialism
02 existentialism
 
04 man as embodiment
04   man as embodiment04   man as embodiment
04 man as embodiment
 
The philosophical enterprise
The philosophical enterpriseThe philosophical enterprise
The philosophical enterprise
 
Introduction to the Philosophy of the Human Person
Introduction to the Philosophy of the Human PersonIntroduction to the Philosophy of the Human Person
Introduction to the Philosophy of the Human Person
 
Existentialism Intro Presentation
Existentialism Intro PresentationExistentialism Intro Presentation
Existentialism Intro Presentation
 
Understanding the Self - Topics 1-4
Understanding the Self - Topics 1-4Understanding the Self - Topics 1-4
Understanding the Self - Topics 1-4
 
09 phenomenology of death
09   phenomenology of death09   phenomenology of death
09 phenomenology of death
 
Body or Soul? Philosophy
Body or Soul? PhilosophyBody or Soul? Philosophy
Body or Soul? Philosophy
 
History of Western modern Philosophy
History of Western modern PhilosophyHistory of Western modern Philosophy
History of Western modern Philosophy
 
Philosophy of modern time
Philosophy of modern timePhilosophy of modern time
Philosophy of modern time
 
Stoicism
StoicismStoicism
Stoicism
 
Eternity and on immortality. episode 2.
Eternity and on immortality. episode 2.Eternity and on immortality. episode 2.
Eternity and on immortality. episode 2.
 
Understanding Human's Existence and the Valuing Process
Understanding Human's Existence and the Valuing ProcessUnderstanding Human's Existence and the Valuing Process
Understanding Human's Existence and the Valuing Process
 
Denmarkanxiety10
Denmarkanxiety10Denmarkanxiety10
Denmarkanxiety10
 

Similaire à Being in the World 3: Anxiety, Skepticism and Nihilism

Existentialism
ExistentialismExistentialism
Existentialism
lilycutler
 
Non duality abstract
Non duality abstractNon duality abstract
Non duality abstract
Madhu Sameer
 
A philosophical theology for inter faith dialogue
A philosophical theology for inter faith dialogueA philosophical theology for inter faith dialogue
A philosophical theology for inter faith dialogue
johnboy_philothea_net
 
A philosophical theology for inter faith dialogue
A philosophical theology for inter faith dialogueA philosophical theology for inter faith dialogue
A philosophical theology for inter faith dialogue
johnboy_philothea_net
 
Philosophy of the human person(final)
Philosophy of the human person(final)Philosophy of the human person(final)
Philosophy of the human person(final)
Carl Deala
 
Balance Being12302006 200pm
Balance Being12302006 200pmBalance Being12302006 200pm
Balance Being12302006 200pm
jirwin66
 

Similaire à Being in the World 3: Anxiety, Skepticism and Nihilism (20)

Being in the World 1: 
Falling into the World
Being in the World 1: 
Falling into the WorldBeing in the World 1: 
Falling into the World
Being in the World 1: 
Falling into the World
 
PrelimLessons.pptx
PrelimLessons.pptxPrelimLessons.pptx
PrelimLessons.pptx
 
The Evolution of the Idea of Humanhood 3
The Evolution of the Idea of Humanhood 3The Evolution of the Idea of Humanhood 3
The Evolution of the Idea of Humanhood 3
 
Existentialism
ExistentialismExistentialism
Existentialism
 
Being in the World 5: Study Guide
Being in the World 5: Study GuideBeing in the World 5: Study Guide
Being in the World 5: Study Guide
 
Being in the World 5: Dealing with Impending Death
Being in the World 5: Dealing with Impending DeathBeing in the World 5: Dealing with Impending Death
Being in the World 5: Dealing with Impending Death
 
Call of the Friend 2: Conscience
Call of the Friend 2: ConscienceCall of the Friend 2: Conscience
Call of the Friend 2: Conscience
 
Non duality abstract
Non duality abstractNon duality abstract
Non duality abstract
 
A philosophical theology for inter faith dialogue
A philosophical theology for inter faith dialogueA philosophical theology for inter faith dialogue
A philosophical theology for inter faith dialogue
 
A philosophical theology for inter faith dialogue
A philosophical theology for inter faith dialogueA philosophical theology for inter faith dialogue
A philosophical theology for inter faith dialogue
 
Philosophy of the human person(final)
Philosophy of the human person(final)Philosophy of the human person(final)
Philosophy of the human person(final)
 
Affective Ontology and Dialogical Epistemology of the "Self‟ and the "Other
Affective Ontology and Dialogical Epistemology of the "Self‟ and the "OtherAffective Ontology and Dialogical Epistemology of the "Self‟ and the "Other
Affective Ontology and Dialogical Epistemology of the "Self‟ and the "Other
 
Nondual christianity 2011 dec 18
Nondual christianity 2011 dec 18Nondual christianity 2011 dec 18
Nondual christianity 2011 dec 18
 
Are you caught IN THE MATRIX? - Nonduality
Are you caught IN THE MATRIX? - NondualityAre you caught IN THE MATRIX? - Nonduality
Are you caught IN THE MATRIX? - Nonduality
 
Understanding The Self
Understanding The SelfUnderstanding The Self
Understanding The Self
 
Balance Being12302006 200pm
Balance Being12302006 200pmBalance Being12302006 200pm
Balance Being12302006 200pm
 
Existentialism Essays
Existentialism EssaysExistentialism Essays
Existentialism Essays
 
Unified Consciousness
Unified ConsciousnessUnified Consciousness
Unified Consciousness
 
Nondual christianity
Nondual christianityNondual christianity
Nondual christianity
 
Nondual christianity
Nondual christianityNondual christianity
Nondual christianity
 

Plus de Devānanda Sarasvatī

Plus de Devānanda Sarasvatī (20)

Being Integrity 7: Examples
Being Integrity 7: ExamplesBeing Integrity 7: Examples
Being Integrity 7: Examples
 
Being Integrity 5: Transformation Parts 1 & 2
Being Integrity 5: Transformation Parts 1 & 2Being Integrity 5: Transformation Parts 1 & 2
Being Integrity 5: Transformation Parts 1 & 2
 
Being Integrity 3: Discernment
Being Integrity 3: DiscernmentBeing Integrity 3: Discernment
Being Integrity 3: Discernment
 
Being Integrity 0: Introduction
Being Integrity 0: IntroductionBeing Integrity 0: Introduction
Being Integrity 0: Introduction
 
Being Integrity 2: Preliminaries
Being Integrity 2: PreliminariesBeing Integrity 2: Preliminaries
Being Integrity 2: Preliminaries
 
Call of the Friend 4: The Friend
Call of the Friend 4: The FriendCall of the Friend 4: The Friend
Call of the Friend 4: The Friend
 
Call of the Friend 1: The Call
Call of the Friend 1: The CallCall of the Friend 1: The Call
Call of the Friend 1: The Call
 
Call of the Friend 3: Authenticity
Call of the Friend 3: AuthenticityCall of the Friend 3: Authenticity
Call of the Friend 3: Authenticity
 
Being in the World: Conclusions
Being in the World: ConclusionsBeing in the World: Conclusions
Being in the World: Conclusions
 
Being in the World 6: Study Guide
Being in the World 6: Study GuideBeing in the World 6: Study Guide
Being in the World 6: Study Guide
 
Being in the World 6: 
A Basis for Authentic Choice
Being in the World 6: 
A Basis for Authentic ChoiceBeing in the World 6: 
A Basis for Authentic Choice
Being in the World 6: 
A Basis for Authentic Choice
 
Being in the World 4: Study Guide
Being in the World 4: Study GuideBeing in the World 4: Study Guide
Being in the World 4: Study Guide
 
Being in the World 4: Being & Death
Being in the World 4: Being & DeathBeing in the World 4: Being & Death
Being in the World 4: Being & Death
 
Being in the World 3: Study Guide
Being in the World 3: Study GuideBeing in the World 3: Study Guide
Being in the World 3: Study Guide
 
Being in the World 2: Study Guide
Being in the World 2: Study GuideBeing in the World 2: Study Guide
Being in the World 2: Study Guide
 
Being in the World 1: Study Guide
Being in the World 1:  Study GuideBeing in the World 1:  Study Guide
Being in the World 1: Study Guide
 
Being in the World 0: Intro
Being in the World 0: IntroBeing in the World 0: Intro
Being in the World 0: Intro
 
Becoming Genius 5: Metacognition
Becoming Genius 5: MetacognitionBecoming Genius 5: Metacognition
Becoming Genius 5: Metacognition
 
Becoming Genius 4: Analysis
Becoming Genius 4: AnalysisBecoming Genius 4: Analysis
Becoming Genius 4: Analysis
 
Becoming Genius 3: Ontology
Becoming Genius 3: OntologyBecoming Genius 3: Ontology
Becoming Genius 3: Ontology
 

Dernier

Girls in Mahipalpur (delhi) call me [🔝9953056974🔝] escort service 24X7
Girls in Mahipalpur  (delhi) call me [🔝9953056974🔝] escort service 24X7Girls in Mahipalpur  (delhi) call me [🔝9953056974🔝] escort service 24X7
Girls in Mahipalpur (delhi) call me [🔝9953056974🔝] escort service 24X7
9953056974 Low Rate Call Girls In Saket, Delhi NCR
 
February 2024 Recommendations for newsletter
February 2024 Recommendations for newsletterFebruary 2024 Recommendations for newsletter
February 2024 Recommendations for newsletter
ssuserdfec6a
 
the Husband rolesBrown Aesthetic Cute Group Project Presentation
the Husband rolesBrown Aesthetic Cute Group Project Presentationthe Husband rolesBrown Aesthetic Cute Group Project Presentation
the Husband rolesBrown Aesthetic Cute Group Project Presentation
brynpueblos04
 
KLINIK BATA Jual obat penggugur kandungan 087776558899 ABORSI JANIN KEHAMILAN...
KLINIK BATA Jual obat penggugur kandungan 087776558899 ABORSI JANIN KEHAMILAN...KLINIK BATA Jual obat penggugur kandungan 087776558899 ABORSI JANIN KEHAMILAN...
KLINIK BATA Jual obat penggugur kandungan 087776558899 ABORSI JANIN KEHAMILAN...
Cara Menggugurkan Kandungan 087776558899
 

Dernier (15)

Social Learning Theory presentation.pptx
Social Learning Theory presentation.pptxSocial Learning Theory presentation.pptx
Social Learning Theory presentation.pptx
 
Girls in Mahipalpur (delhi) call me [🔝9953056974🔝] escort service 24X7
Girls in Mahipalpur  (delhi) call me [🔝9953056974🔝] escort service 24X7Girls in Mahipalpur  (delhi) call me [🔝9953056974🔝] escort service 24X7
Girls in Mahipalpur (delhi) call me [🔝9953056974🔝] escort service 24X7
 
2023 - Between Philosophy and Practice: Introducing Yoga
2023 - Between Philosophy and Practice: Introducing Yoga2023 - Between Philosophy and Practice: Introducing Yoga
2023 - Between Philosophy and Practice: Introducing Yoga
 
Exploring Stoic Philosophy From Ancient Wisdom to Modern Relevance.pdf
Exploring Stoic Philosophy From Ancient Wisdom to Modern Relevance.pdfExploring Stoic Philosophy From Ancient Wisdom to Modern Relevance.pdf
Exploring Stoic Philosophy From Ancient Wisdom to Modern Relevance.pdf
 
Dadar West Escorts 🥰 8617370543 Call Girls Offer VIP Hot Girls
Dadar West Escorts 🥰 8617370543 Call Girls Offer VIP Hot GirlsDadar West Escorts 🥰 8617370543 Call Girls Offer VIP Hot Girls
Dadar West Escorts 🥰 8617370543 Call Girls Offer VIP Hot Girls
 
SIKP311 Sikolohiyang Pilipino - Ginhawa.pptx
SIKP311 Sikolohiyang Pilipino - Ginhawa.pptxSIKP311 Sikolohiyang Pilipino - Ginhawa.pptx
SIKP311 Sikolohiyang Pilipino - Ginhawa.pptx
 
Pokemon Go... Unraveling the Conspiracy Theory
Pokemon Go... Unraveling the Conspiracy TheoryPokemon Go... Unraveling the Conspiracy Theory
Pokemon Go... Unraveling the Conspiracy Theory
 
February 2024 Recommendations for newsletter
February 2024 Recommendations for newsletterFebruary 2024 Recommendations for newsletter
February 2024 Recommendations for newsletter
 
Goregaon West Escorts 🥰 8617370543 Call Girls Offer VIP Hot Girls
Goregaon West Escorts 🥰 8617370543 Call Girls Offer VIP Hot GirlsGoregaon West Escorts 🥰 8617370543 Call Girls Offer VIP Hot Girls
Goregaon West Escorts 🥰 8617370543 Call Girls Offer VIP Hot Girls
 
Emotional Freedom Technique Tapping Points Diagram.pdf
Emotional Freedom Technique Tapping Points Diagram.pdfEmotional Freedom Technique Tapping Points Diagram.pdf
Emotional Freedom Technique Tapping Points Diagram.pdf
 
Call Girls In Mumbai Just Genuine Call ☎ 7738596112✅ Call Girl Andheri East G...
Call Girls In Mumbai Just Genuine Call ☎ 7738596112✅ Call Girl Andheri East G...Call Girls In Mumbai Just Genuine Call ☎ 7738596112✅ Call Girl Andheri East G...
Call Girls In Mumbai Just Genuine Call ☎ 7738596112✅ Call Girl Andheri East G...
 
Colaba Escorts 🥰 8617370543 Call Girls Offer VIP Hot Girls
Colaba Escorts 🥰 8617370543 Call Girls Offer VIP Hot GirlsColaba Escorts 🥰 8617370543 Call Girls Offer VIP Hot Girls
Colaba Escorts 🥰 8617370543 Call Girls Offer VIP Hot Girls
 
the Husband rolesBrown Aesthetic Cute Group Project Presentation
the Husband rolesBrown Aesthetic Cute Group Project Presentationthe Husband rolesBrown Aesthetic Cute Group Project Presentation
the Husband rolesBrown Aesthetic Cute Group Project Presentation
 
March 2023 Recommendations for newsletter
March 2023 Recommendations for newsletterMarch 2023 Recommendations for newsletter
March 2023 Recommendations for newsletter
 
KLINIK BATA Jual obat penggugur kandungan 087776558899 ABORSI JANIN KEHAMILAN...
KLINIK BATA Jual obat penggugur kandungan 087776558899 ABORSI JANIN KEHAMILAN...KLINIK BATA Jual obat penggugur kandungan 087776558899 ABORSI JANIN KEHAMILAN...
KLINIK BATA Jual obat penggugur kandungan 087776558899 ABORSI JANIN KEHAMILAN...
 

Being in the World 3: Anxiety, Skepticism and Nihilism

  • 1. Being in the World 3: Anxiety & Skepticism — The Esoteric Teaching — dharmasar@gmail.com
  • 2. ANXIETY, SKEPTICISM AND NIHILISM Our ontological analysis of anxiety in the previous section also sheds much light on skepticism and nihilism. Philosophers again and again attempt disproofs of skepticism about the reality of the external world; nevertheless all such attempts to invalidate the skeptical attitude ultimately fail.This is because any proper conception of our worldliness makes the skeptic’s doubts self-defeating, impossible and devoid of significance.We cannot disprove an unprovable philosophy. Nevertheless, skepticism as a mode of being persists.
  • 3. In our default state we do not have any Being besides being in the world.The world is the context for everything we experience or can experience; just as water is the context for everything a fish can experience.We never experience the world as a thing in itself, only the things that exist in the world, including ourselves.Thus, skeptical questions about ‘reality’ or ‘the world’ as separate and independent from ourselves are meaningless and unanswerable. It is as useless to attempt to prove or disprove such ontologically incoherent statements as it is to try to make sense out of nonsense. ANXIETY, SKEPTICISM AND NIHILISM
  • 4. Yet, skeptical doubts about individual objects in the world are not only articulable but also irrefutable, and such skepticism is pervasive in modern thought. From the ontological point of view, the skeptical impulse is certainly self-defeating, since its doubts annihilate the conditions for their own meaning.Yet skepticism is also self-renewing as a human possibility, affecting those possessed by it with a near-unshakable confidence in their own conclusions. How is this possible? ANXIETY, SKEPTICISM AND NIHILISM
  • 5. Since the skeptical attitude is a human ontological possibility—a way of understanding and grasping one’s worldly existence—it must be subject to ontological analysis.That means among other things that it should be inflected by a particular mood.We can easily observe that the skeptic is someone beset by gnawing doubts—someone in the grip of anxiety. Skepticism is anxiety manifest as philosophy. But more than that, anxiety is one of the most powerful possibilities of our phenomenological self- disclosure. In anxiety we reveal ourselves as worldly beings whose Being is an issue for us.Thus we should expect skeptical anxiety to be very useful in phenomenological self-inquiry; and so it is. ANXIETY, SKEPTICISM AND NIHILISM
  • 6. Anxiety finds its clearest expression when it has no particular object. Pure objectless anxiety is related to, and hence reveals, the worldliness of the world and the uncanniness or alienating strangeness of being in the world; thus it helps to disclose our own inherently worldly Being. It also reveals that our way of being in the world is that of being not at home in the world. How does skeptical anxiety confirm this paradoxical perception? ANXIETY, SKEPTICISM AND NIHILISM
  • 7. One aspect of anxiety is the sense of a disconnect between ourselves and the world. It gives a sense of a void at the heart of reality, and a sense of ourselves as not at home in the world. Another aspect of anxiety reveals a disconnect between ourselves and others, as if their thoughts and feelings were unknowable. Thus we often experience ourselves as alone and alienated in the world. In either mode, skepticism as an expression of anxiety finds itself opposed to common sense, to what ‘everybody knows’: the truths of average everyday human existence, being in the world absorbed in phenomena and the opinions of others. ANXIETY, SKEPTICISM AND NIHILISM
  • 8. In this opposition to worldliness, the skeptic discloses and falsifies the default realities of typical human beingness. For although we are essentially worldly, we are also always more than any particular worldly situation in which we find ourselves; although we are overwhelmed by being in the world, we are also individuated. ONTOLOGICAL STRUCTURE OF ANXIETY Falsification Contingency Uncanniness Worldly Anxiety
  • 9. Hence the argumentative skeptic, in his denial of our worldliness, commonality and inauthenticity, also denies the truth of our being in the world.At the same time, the objectless anxiety of which skepticism is the expression, in its fear of accepting absorption in the world, hints at the hidden truth of our Being: our innate possibility to attain true individuality, integrity and authenticity. ONTOLOGICAL STRUCTURE OF ANXIETY Falsification Contingency Uncanniness Worldly Anxiety
  • 10. Further, if skepticism repudiates the commonsense expressions of ordinary being in the world, then they must be contingent, simply an accident of the conditions of our being in the world. Skepticism shows that worldly articulations of meaning can continue to affect us only if we continue to care about them.The self-defeating character of skepticism (“This sentence is false.”) means the skeptic can effect such withdrawals of interest in the world even in the guise of the most passionate investment in it. ONTOLOGICAL STRUCTURE OF ANXIETY
  • 11. In other words, the self-subversiveness of skepticism shows that caring about worldly discourse, in which the issue of our own Being is most fundamentally at stake, is not automatic. It is not that expressions of worldliness are part of the predetermined essence of our existence. Rather, they are a cultural inheritance that we can choose whether or not to take responsibility for, in and through our being in the world. ONTOLOGICAL STRUCTURE OF ANXIETY
  • 12. There is also a third aspect that skeptical anxiety helps to bring out: the uncanniness of being in the world. For the worldliness of the world to which anxiety is a response is a system or field of meaning; therefore the sense or meaning of our existence is ultimately an aspect of our Being. ONTOLOGICAL STRUCTURE OF ANXIETY
  • 13. If that is so, the significance of our lives cannot be derived from any external source or authority—whether that source is conceived as God, as a range of Platonic ideals, or as a structure of values encoded in the structure of reality by genetics or other physical laws. Our authentic being must be rooted in the uniqueness of our individuality, and thus must be sought within ourselves by phenomenal self-examination. ONTOLOGICAL STRUCTURE OF ANXIETY
  • 14. How then can the structures of meaning that give orientation and meaning to our being in the world have any genuinely objective authority, any real claim on us? Skepticism asserts that meaning must be an essentially anthropocentric construction designed to cover up the intrinsic meaninglessness of the world. ONTOLOGICAL STRUCTURE OF ANXIETY
  • 15. Anxiety’s disclosure of the world as a domain in which we are ultimately not at home, and can choose to accept or not, is perfect confirmation of the ontological truth that the meaning of our lives lacks any external ground. It does not prove that the meaning of our life is arbitrary or synthetic; rather it can only be derived from a deep ontological analysis of our being in the world as an as-lived experience. ONTOLOGICAL STRUCTURE OF ANXIETY
  • 16. Anxiety’s disclosure of the world as a domain in which we are ultimately not at home, and can choose to accept or not, is perfect confirmation of the ontological truth that the meaning of our lives lacks any external ground. It does not prove that the meaning of our life is arbitrary or synthetic; rather it can only be derived from a deep ontological analysis of our being in the world as an as-lived experience. ONTOLOGICAL STRUCTURE OF ANXIETY
  • 17. The uncanniness of our being in the world revealed by skepticism captures the ontological root of nihilism. Nihilism is an extreme form of philosophical skepticism concerning the reality or substance of value and meaning. We must carefully distinguish between the truth of nihilism and the distortions embedded in its intellectual expression. ONTOLOGICAL STRUCTURE OF ANXIETY
  • 18. The idea of meaningfulness wholly external to our being in the world is indeed empty of significance. But acknowledging the internal relation between idle talk and our ordinary Being does not mean that we deny, trivialize or relativize the conceptions of truth and reality.Thus, an authentic response to nihilism acknowledges that life’s meaning lacks any external, absolute ground without denying its very real effects upon us. ONTOLOGICAL STRUCTURE OF ANXIETY
  • 19. Any absolute external structure of significance would have to be constituted in ways entirely independent of the ontological structure of our being in the world. How could an external source of meaning provide us with internal articulation of being in the world? How could it constitute the worldliness of the world, and thus orient and motivate our practical activities within it? ONTOLOGICAL STRUCTURE OF ANXIETY
  • 20. The transcendental concept that the world is meaningless or false, and only a wholly external structure of meaning can make any authoritative claims, is backwards. Rather, the only structures of meaning that can possibly make claims on us are ones to which our worldly Being is inherently open, and by which it is structured and articulated. ONTOLOGICAL STRUCTURE OF ANXIETY
  • 21. In other words, the idea of absolute transcendental objectivity that fuels nihilism cannot provide the authority and authenticity that our worldly fields of meaning could have, but unfortunately lack. Nor can it be right to think of the structures of significance in which we exist as merely internal. The ontological structures of being in the world are all the meaning there is, or could be, for creatures whose Being is like ours. Such meanings are the limits or conditions necessary to determine any being whose Being is worldly, and hence finite. ONTOLOGICAL STRUCTURE OF ANXIETY
  • 22. The truth in nihilism is that our Being is essentially finite or conditioned.We are not unconditioned, infinite or godlike; nor are we entirely reducible to our determining conditions. We are not possessed by an external ground of meaning, nor are we wholly self-grounding either.Accordingly, to say that our worldliness is uncanny means that it must be understood in relation to what it is not and to that which is not—in relation to nothing and nothingness. ONTOLOGICAL STRUCTURE OF ANXIETY
  • 23. The skeptics truly suffer the reality of ordinary human existence, for they give philosophical expression to the pervasive mood of anxiety in being in the world. However from an ontological point of view, skepticism does not properly articulate that reality, or how best to understand its passionate anxiety.This is a vital task of authentic phenomenology. ONTOLOGICAL STRUCTURE OF ANXIETY
  • 24. Phenomenological investigations of Being must be informed by some particular mood.We are open to skeptical anxiety; not only subjecting it to serious phenomenological analysis, but also allowing it to guide our sense of what matters in the field of practical activity.Then we become sensitive to the most far- reaching and primordial existential disclosure of our Being. What else could better facilitate our attempts to grasp our Being in as transparent a manner as possible—to make the existential possibility of investigating our Being truly our own? ONTOLOGICAL STRUCTURE OF ANXIETY
  • 25. But it is critical that we adopt a moderate attitude toward the skeptical mood. Especially, we should not take skepticism’s interpretation of its own significance for granted.We should not accept the skeptic’s over-anxious claim of knowing that the world is not knowable, without acknowledging that the world cannot therefore be doubtable either. ONTOLOGICAL STRUCTURE OF ANXIETY
  • 26. Authentically skeptical phenomenology distinguishes the disclosures made possible by its mood of anxiety from that mood’s self-concealment and deception.We must overcome skepticism from within, by being skeptical about its self- distorted misunderstandings.We must dwell in the mode of being in the world without making ourselves at home in it. Only thus can we discover what is truthful about skepticism, and the actual value that skepticism can disclose to us. ONTOLOGICAL STRUCTURE OF ANXIETY