A major class of molecules that may enable such proteins to be modulated through TPD are known as proteolysis-targeting chimera (PROTAC) protein degraders. Here we talk about the summary of PROTAC degraders in clinical trials.
Keppel Ltd. 1Q 2024 Business Update Presentation Slides
Summary of PROTAC Degraders in Clinical Trials.pdf
1. Biopharma PEG https://www.biochempeg.com
Summary of PROTAC Degraders in Clinical
Trials
Targeted protein degradation (TPD) is an emerging therapeutic modality that has
attracted the substantial interest of drug developers in recent years, and major progress
has been made in this area. A major class of molecules that may enable such proteins to
be modulated through TPD are known as proteolysis-targeting chimera (PROTAC)
protein degraders. PROTACs are heterobifunctional small molecules consisting of two
ligands joined by a linker: one ligand recruits and binds a protein of interest (POI) while
the other recruits and binds an E3 ubiquitin ligase.
Figure 1. PROTAC, source: https://xvivo.com/
In the 20 years since the concept of PROTAC molecules that use the
ubiquitin-proteasome system to degrade target proteins was first reported, TPD has
moved from academia to industry, where many companies have initiated preclinical and
early clinical development programs. in 2019, the first PROTAC molecules enter clinical
trials; in 2020, these trials provided the first clinical proof-of-concept for the modality
against two well-established cancer targets: the estrogen receptor (ER) and the androgen
receptor (AR). With this success, the TPD field is now ready and committed to tackling
‘undrugged’ targets.
Timeline of PROTAC discoveries
2. Biopharma PEG https://www.biochempeg.com
Figure 2. Timeline of PROTAC discoveries, source: reference [1]
In 2008, the Crews team developed the first small molecule-based PROTAC that
effectively degrades AR in cancer cells. This cell-permeable PROTAC contains Nutlin (an
E3 ligase MDM2 inhibitor) and a non-steroidal AR ligand (SARM) and links the two
through a PEG-based linker fragment.
In 2010, Itoh et al. synthesized another PROTAC molecule using methyl-ubenimex to
recruit an E3 ligase (inhibitor of apoptosis protein (IAP)) to degrade POI. To improve
potency and target selectivity, small molecules with high affinity and specificity (e.g.,
phthalimides that recruit the E3 ligase cereblon (CRBN) or VHL-1 recognizing the E3
ligase Von Hippel-Lindau (VHL)) into PROTAC molecules, which in turn down-regulate a
variety of cancer targets, such as Ikaros family zinc finger protein 1/3 (IKZF1/3) and
estrogen-related receptor alpha (ERRα). The breakthrough of small molecule-based
PROTAC opens a new path for PROTAC as a cancer treatment strategy.
Since 2013, companies such as Arvinas, C4 Therapeutics, and Kymera Therapeutics
have been established to focus on the development of this technology, and
pharmaceutical giants such as Merck, Genentech, Pfizer, Novartis, and Boehringer
Ingelheim have also laid out their plans for this field. But until 2020, four questions are
long overdue for answers.
1) Whether PROTAC is safe in the body.
2) Whether PROTAC can act accurately at the target site in the body.
3) Whether PROTAC is therapeutically effective.
4) Whether PROTAC retains the pharmacokinetic properties of small molecules.
In 2019, Arvinas' ARV-110 and ARV-471 were the first to enter clinical phase 1, and in
2020 the company published study data that provided clear and positive answers to all
3. Biopharma PEG https://www.biochempeg.com
four of these questions and also successfully pushed the pipeline into phase 2
accordingly.
PROTACs in Clinical Trials
Figure 3. PROTAC targeted protein degraders in clinical development, source: reference
[1]
ARV-110
Androgen receptor (AR) activity is a major driver of prostate cancer, so the first line of
treatment is "anti-androgen therapy" - lowering androgen levels or blocking the androgen
receptor. However, "anti-androgen therapy" is ineffective in 15-25% of patients, who are
left in a passive situation with no treatment after desmothering, and this group of patients
was selected for the clinical trial of ARV-110, which was administered orally once daily.
Ligands targeting androgen receptors (green), linkers (red), and ligands targeting E3
CRBN (blue).
4. Biopharma PEG https://www.biochempeg.com
Figure 4. Structure of ARV-110, source: reference [1]
In February 2022, Arvinas released clinical phase 1 dose creep and clinical phase 2
interim data showing that a dose of 420 mg was determined to be safe and is being
followed in the ongoing phase 2 clinic. ARV-110 is able to act on specific targets in vivo
and has shown preliminary efficacy in treating tumors.
In patients with tumors carrying the AR T878X/H875Y mutation, ARV-110 reduced
prostate-specific antigen (PSA) levels by ≥50% (PSA50) in 46% of patients. Of the seven
patients who met RECIST criteria and were evaluable, six had tumor reduction and two
achieved partial remission. Arvinas plans to conduct a pivotal clinical phase 3 trial in late
2022 to further evaluate ARV-110 in patients with tumors carrying the AR T878X/H875Y
mutation.
Figure 5. ARV-110 Phase 2 clinical trials, source: reference [2]
5. Biopharma PEG https://www.biochempeg.com
Figure 6. ARV-110 Phase 2 clinical trials, source: reference [2]
ARV-471
ARV-471 is an estrogen receptor (ER) PROTAC degrader co-developed by Arvinas and
Pfizer for the treatment of ER+/HER2- breast cancer.
Figure 7. structure of AVR-471, source: reference [1]
Based on clinical phase 1 results published by Arvinas on December 10, 2021, ARV-471
had a favorable safety profile, with no dose-limiting toxicity observed with a once-daily oral
dose of 700 mg in a dose creep trial, provided that the patients had received multiple
treatments prior to enrollment.
The average degradation rate of ARV-471 was 64% with a maximum of 89% compared to
the 40-50% degradation rate of fulvestrant, an ER degrader currently used in clinical
6. Biopharma PEG https://www.biochempeg.com
practice. Of the 47 evaluable patients enrolled, 19 had clinical benefits (including partial
remission and stable disease) with a benefit rate of 40%, including 3 patients in partial
remission.
Figure 8. ARV-471 Phase 2 clinical trials, source: reference [3]
Figure 9. ARV-471 Phase 2 clinical trials, source: reference [3]
ARV-471 is currently in 2 concurrent trials, clinical phase 2 monotherapy for metastatic
breast cancer and clinical phase 1b in combination with the CDK4/6 inhibitor palbociclib.
NX-2127 & NX-5948
NX-2127 and NX-5948 from NurixTheraputics is a BTK degrader used to treat a variety of
immune inflammatory conditions such as rheumatoid arthritis.
There are several marketed BTK drugs, however, the emergence of the C481S drug
resistance mutation has diminished the effectiveness of first-generation BTK inhibitors.
7. Biopharma PEG https://www.biochempeg.com
Yet, this presents a new opportunity for PROTAC therapy, which does not rely on
long-term covalent binding of small molecules to BTK and is therefore not affected by
mutations in the binding site on BTK. PROTAC only required relatively weaker
non-covalent binding to BTK to recruit E3 proteases to modify and ultimately degrade BTK.
Both of NurixTheraputics' BTK degraders are currently in clinical phase 1: NX-2127 for
malignant hematomas and NX-5948 for hematomas and autoimmune diseases.
Figure 10. BTK degrader, source: https://www.nurixtx.com/
NX-2127 data released by Nurix in October 2021 showed that BTK levels in peripheral
blood were significantly reduced in the first six patients enrolled from Day 1 and remained
suppressed throughout the dosing period. BTK degradation levels exceeded 80% and
90% in the 100mg/200mg dose groups, respectively.
8. Biopharma PEG https://www.biochempeg.com
According to data from a preclinical study of NX-5948 presented by Nurix at the 2021
American Society of Hematology (ASH) annual meeting, NX-5948 significantly reduced
BTK protein levels in TMD8 tumor cells and microglia in the brain.
KT-474
KT-474 is an IRAK4 degrader. No drugs targeting IRAK4 are currently available worldwide,
but studies demonstrating that IRAK4 plays a key role in inflammatory responses, B-cell
lymphomas are well established and there are several traditional small molecule inhibitors
in development, targeting autoimmune diseases.
IRAK4 mediates the IL-1R/TLR downstream signaling pathway and participates in
immune monitoring through two pathways: on the one hand, IRAK4 has kinase activity
and is able to phosphorylate the downstream proteins IRF5/7; on the other hand, IRAK4
acts as a scaffold structure responsible for the formation of the protein multimer
myddosome complex.
Traditional small-molecule inhibitors can only block its kinase activity but not its scaffold
structure, a characteristic that determines the inadequate inhibition of IRAK4 by
small-molecule inhibitors. In contrast, PROTAC is able to completely degrade IRAK4,
blocking both kinase activity and scaffold structure, which theoretically provides better
inhibition.
Figure 11. IRAK4 Targeting, source: reference [4]
Results of the phase 1 trial showed that a single dose of KT-474 dose-dependently
reduced IRAK4 levels in healthy volunteers, and was able to reduce IRAK levels in
peripheral blood mononuclear cells by more than 95% at the highest 3 doses tested.
9. Biopharma PEG https://www.biochempeg.com
Figure 12. KT-474 Achieved >95% IRAK4 Degradation After Single Dose, source:
reference [4]
After receiving KT-474 for 24-48 hours, the highest two doses of KT-474 significantly
reduced TLR receptor agonist-elicited levels of multiple pro-inflammatory cytokines by up
to 97%.
Figure 13. KT-474 clinical trails, source: reference [4]
KT-474 demonstrated a good safety and tolerability profile, with the most common
adverse events being mild or severe headache or nausea and no serious adverse events.
Most recently, at the American Association of Immunologists (AAI) Annual Meeting 2022,
Kymera demonstrated that KTX-545, an IRAK4 degrader, blocks various innate immune
signaling pathways in different immune cell types and outperforms traditional small
molecule kinase inhibitors.
DT2216
10. Biopharma PEG https://www.biochempeg.com
Most of the first PROTACs to enter the clinic, including ARV-110 and ARV-471, utilized E3
CRBN to degrade the target protein. However, Dialectic Therapeutics' BCL-XL degrader
DT2216 employs VHL, which targets hematologic and multiple solid tumors, selectively
induces degradation of BCL-XL (B-cell lymphoma-extra large) protein, and stimulates the
initiation of the apoptotic program in cancer cells or makes cancer cells more sensitive to
chemotherapy. It is currently in clinical phase 1.
Figure 14. DT-2216, source: https://www.cancer-research-network.com/
BCL-XL is a member of the BCL-2 family of proteins, which prevents apoptosis and not
only promotes cancer progression, but also leads to drug resistance in cancer cells.
Therefore, drug development targeting BCL-XL would greatly improve the efficacy of
cancer therapy. In previous preclinical studies, DT2216 was able to selectively induce
BCL-XL protein degradation, stimulating apoptosis or making cancer cells more sensitive
to chemotherapy.
The targeting and dose limitations of common BCL-XL inhibitors kill platelets, leading to a
reduction in platelet counts. This toxicity drawback limits the use of BCL-XL inhibitors as
safe and effective anticancer agents. However, the data suggest that DT2216 is weakly
toxic to platelets, thanks to E3 selection - VHL is in low abundance in platelets.
However, questions are also emerging, and it has been discovered that tumor cells may
develop mutations that escape CRBN and VHL-mediated E3 degradation. Of course, as
research goes further, new E3s will be discovered.
11. Biopharma PEG https://www.biochempeg.com
Figure 15. Specialized E3 ligases for potential PROTAC applications, source: reference
[1]
These heterobifunctional PROTACs in phase I and phase II clinical trials has been truly
gratifying. We are excited about the discoveries in basic biology and chemistry that will
further advance targeted protein degradation in the decades to come, and we believe this
modality has the potential to offer patients new treatment options across diverse
indications.
PEG linkers are the most common motifs incorporated into PROTAC linker
structures. According to statistics, 54% of the reported PROTAC molecules used PEG as
a linker. Biopharma PEG is dedicated to the R&D of PROTAC Linker, providing high purity
PEG linkers with various reactive groups to continuously assist your project development.
Reference:
[1] Békés, M., Langley, D.R. & Crews, C.M. PROTAC targeted protein degraders: the past
is prologue. Nat Rev Drug Discov 21, 181–200 (2022).
https://doi.org/10.1038/s41573-021-00371-6
[2] https://sec.report/Document/0001193125-22-044926/
[3] https://www.streetinsider.com/dr/news.php?id=19335892
[4] https://sec.report/Document/0001193125-21-308787/
Related Articles:
PROTACs VS. Traditional Small Molecule Inhibitors
PROTACs and Targeted Protein Degradation
Focus On PROTAC: Summary Of Targets From 2001 To 2019
Four Major Trends In The Development of PROTAC
Molecular Glues: A New Dawn of Small Molecule Drugs After PROTAC