Initial reporting of ongoing empirical research into technology use by Emirati tertiary students. Completed PhD dissertation:
Martin, J. (2013). Technology, education and Arab youth in the 21st century: A study of the UAE. (Doctoral dissertation), University of Queensland, Brisbane, Australia. Retrieved from http://drjanetmartin.wordpress.com/research/
2. Outline for the session
* The “Digital Natives” debate
What claims have been made about young
people today, and implications for education
* Definitions
* International research summary
* Significance of UAE research
* Research design
3. The “Digital Natives” debate
•Can multitask
•Have a short
attention span
•Prefer non-linear,
visual, interactive,
collaborative learning
•Are innately skilful,
expert, confident,
intuitive when dealing
with technology
•Have brain changes
4. The “Digital Natives” debate
•Expect digital technologies
to be an integrated part of
education
•Education which is not
technology-based is
boring/obsolete
•Education needs to
radically change to remain
relevant to students and
society
•“Natives” vs “Immigrants”
5. The “Digital Natives” debate
* Net Generation
* Millennials
* Google Generation
* Digital natives
* Digital Generation
* Generation “Y”
6.
7. Commentary vs Research
* This debate has gained wide traction
* Government policy and educational
institutional policy affected
* What has the research basis been?
8. International Research Summary
* Internet use has increased dramatically in
the past 10-12 years in many countries
* Internet has an increasing role especially in
the lives of many young people
* Majority of students use core technologies
only
* Majority of students not skilled or confident
with a variety of digital tools
* No evidence for short attention span
* Limited evidence for multiskilling
9. International Research Summary
This is NOT a homogenous generation
Great variation is apparent in access, use, and ability
world-wide, and within countries and regions
•economic, political, or cultural forces within different countries
•gender
•socio-economic status
•education
•content and language
•rurality...institutional variations...school vs personal use...age...
10. A “piece of the evidence”
Empirical research into the
Millennial generation of the
United Arab Emirates (UAE) in the
Middle East ...
... a rapidly changing and sometimes
volatile part of the world
11.
12.
13. Oil was discovered in the UAE in the
1960’s
The UAE was formed as a federation
of ‘emirates’ in 1971.
Within 40 years ...
14.
15.
16.
17.
18. ... a new country of fast
development,
great contrasts and ambiguities
20. Research Design
Primary goal to form part of internationally
comparative documentation of the Millennial
generation (an indicator for the Middle East):
•What is the extent of UAE Emirati Millennials’
engagement with digital technologies?
•Are there possible implications for UAE
educational systems
?
•Are there cultural, demographic, linguistic,
educational considerations which impact upon
engagement?
21. Research Design
Mixed method design
•Survey instrument
Participants will be Emirati youth 18-25 yrs old
who are attending tertiary education in the
UAE
Stratified random sample of 1,000-1,500
Survey instrument adapted from
Kennedy/Newton with permission
Data collection – cross-sectional, online survey
by December 2011, after pilot testing
22. Research Design
Mixed method design
•Semi-structured Interviews
Participants will be volunteers from survey
respondents – small, representative sample
Semi-structured interview of 4-5 open-ended
questions based on survey responses
Involvement of Emirati research assistant to
minimize potential cross-cultural interview
problems
23. Research Design
Data Analysis
Enables deconstruction of responses to identify
patterns, and make inferences about the whole
Quantitative – Use of SPSS for descriptive,
inferential, and correlational analysis.
Qualitative – Use of Nvivo for annotation and
coding of interview responses.
Notes de l'éditeur
A ”radically new generation”
Born after 1980, who grew up immersed in digital technology – developed with the Internet
Possess sophisticated skills to effectively use technologies
... and further, this new generation...
Boring – “industrial age education”
Digital technologies – recording of information in binary code (Internet, digital media, web-based technologies, emerging technologies, information and communication technologies ITC, computer games, digital music and videos, mobile phones, television or ‘media’ in general)
Millennials to name this “generation” by the change in the calendar rather than conversance with technology
Traction
Governments, educational institutions, authors/commentators, academics (!!) – just Google and thousands of results turn up. Lots of money here.
Much has been “anecdotal” or “un-evidenced” information
Do university IT intro courses target the areas students need assistance with?
RESEARCH – mostly since 2008 - USA, UK, South Africa, Canada, Ireland, Belgium, South-east Asian countries including Hong Kong, Singapore, Taiwan, Japan, Korea, China, Australia, and 30 OECD countries (OECD and PISA) – moving from “speculative hype to grounded empirical investigation”
There is a SMALL amount of empirical investigation to date!
Much research so far in developed countries and regions
More content creation in the USA
Lower usage in academic rather than home/personal settings
Multiskilling existed before the Internet
Middle-class, educated, white Americans are not the ”standard”
Changes to education systems should be based upon empirical research within the country/region applicable
Why the UAE – lived there...
What has been concluded in developed countries should be verified in very different parts of the world
Issues of culture and society could be important factors here to consider
Within 40 years ...
Population grew from under 300,000 to over 4 million – Emiratis are now a minority 20%
Arabic speaking. Mainly Islamic.
Stable and visionary government – unprecedented change and prosperity
Economy grew and diversified from trading and oil to construction, aviation, commerce, tourism and service industries
Education became strongly supported for males and females.
Traditional schools teaching memorization – especially of the Quran – replaced with modern schools
First university opened 1977 – by 2009 there were 64 universities!
Average years of schooling increased from less than 3 years (nearly 50% illiteracy) in the early 1970’s, to 12 years of schooling (7% illiteracy) by 2009.
Remaining problems – especially in the school system.
Technology has had an important influence in the UAE – bringing the world into a more sheltered place
Internet penetration rate high – growth of 414% from 2000-2010. Estimated 83% of Emirati households have broadband – central stats not available.
Mobile phone penetration over 200%
Laptop and wired universities
Arabic content on the Internet increasing rapidly. 2008 - Arabic script in web addresses. Arabic spoken by 300-350 million people in 22 Arab countries – less than 1% of all online content in Arabic in mid-2010. Now fastest growing language on the Internet. Facebook growing by 18% per month!
Regulation/blocking of sites deemed to be inconsistent with religious, cultural, political and moral values of the country
Open at national universities
AND did I mention the SAND?
73% under 30 years of age in 2010 – a wealthy, young and increasingly educated population
Very little research to date – small sample numbers; small scale research; difficult to reproduce or generalize from the results
Mixed method – use multiple methods of data collection and analysis – triangulation
Sample frame is the group to be selected from
Kennedy survey used by Newton & Ellis in Australia and Thinyane in South Africa to date – high level of standardization of questions. Instrument has been tested for validity (measures what it is meant to measure) and reliability (consistently measures)
Adaptations – language level, cultural considerations, clarified meanings
Data collection cross-sectional – data collected at one point in time
Online – Survey Gizmo
Ethical clearance sought in all places!
Participants – selected on the basis of convenience, access, geographical representation
Flexible format to allow for deviation from structure, while ensuring clarification of basic themes
Inferential – enable estimation and inferences about the population
Parametric stats – test the statistical significance of data and relationships
Much is currently unknown on this topic, but future policy decisions should be based on empirical research, rather than emotive and anecdotal commentry