SlideShare une entreprise Scribd logo
1  sur  8
Télécharger pour lire hors ligne
Survey Analysis:
Employee Motivation
by Generation Factors
By Seleste Lunsford




        Developing the 21st
              century workforce
                              TM
There’s no question that motivated employees are         Our survey respondents were evenly distributed
more productive and more creative, and add more          across the four generations, and all were asked
overall value to an organization than their “just        the same questions about their motivators, goals,
doing what it takes to get by” counterparts. They        achievement strategies, and learning preferences.
can, in fact, be key to your success—a differentiator    Some results were predictable, based on where the
that sets you apart from the competition.                respondents are in their careers; others, as you’ll see,
                                                         were enlightening.
Y because it comes from within, motivation cannot
 et
be created, taught, or instilled. It can, however,       Motivators by Generation
be tapped into, supported, and maintained. The           When asked about the most important goal in their
question is how. Does money always do the trick?         job (i.e., what motivates them), employees across the
Are recognition and respect critical factors?            generations on average sorted to self-fulfillment and
Is the promise of career advancement key?                “feeling good about what I do.” This response was
                                                         most pronounced for Traditionalists (45%), many of
Well, yes and no. What works for one employee            whom are nearing retirement age and likely are at
doesn’t necessarily work for another. And because        least content—if not satisfied—with their careers just
different individuals are, by nature, driven by          as they are. (See Figure 1.)
different motivators, there will never be a one-
size-fits-all approach.                                  The second most frequent response was a tie,
                                                         with “flexibility in my schedule” being selected
What’s an organization to do?                            by 37% of Baby Boomers and “advancement in my
                                                         career/profession /company” being selected by 37%
Group Think                                              of Generation Y/Millennials. It’s interesting to
Armed with the knowledge that motivation is one of       note that flexibility ranked high by Traditionalists
the most important—yet least understood—keys to          and Generation Xers as well, although only 10%
employee performance improvement, AchieveGlobal          of Generation Y/Millennials see it as their most
set out to investigate to what extent generational       important motivation.
differences are at play in motivational factors.
                                                         Surprisingly, “more money/better benefits” did not
The thought behind the survey of approximately 300       turn up as a large motivator across the generations
employees across the United States was this: Since       as a whole. It was ranked highest by Generation
motivating employees based on their individual drivers   Xers, 16% of whom selected it as their most
can be complex, and motivating employees with a          important motivation. Its importance falls
blanket approach leaves many out in the cold, maybe      further from there, with only 9% of Generation
a glimpse into generational trends can provide some      Y/Millennials, 5% of Baby Boomers, and 4% of
logical direction for an organization-wide approach      Traditionalists giving it top billing.
to employee motivation.
                                                         A possible explanation for “more money” ranking
And what better time to explore such an approach         so low is that money has been shown to have only
than now—a unique point in U.S. history where            a short-term impact on behavior, making it more
at least four generations of employees are in the        effective as an incentive than as a long-term moti-
workplace:                                               vator. In addition, many employees rewarded with
                                                         money end up using it to pay bills—at which point
•   Traditionalists – those born before 1947             it becomes compensation and loses its value as a
•   Baby Boomers – those born between 1947 – 1964        motivator.

•   Generation X – those born between 1965 – 1980
•   Generation Y/Millennials – those born after 1980


2 | EMPLOYEE MOTIVATION BY GENERATION FACTORS
Figure 1
  Most Important Goal
                                        Before Traditionalist         Baby Boomers             Generation X             Generation Y/Millennials
  50%

  45%

  40%

   35%

  30%

   25%

  20%

   15%

   10%

   5%

   0%
            Self-fulfillment/       Flexibility in my  Advancement in my Knowing that I’m More money/better      Gaining respect           Gaining the
          feeling good about      schedule/time off    career/profession/ contributing to the benefits           of others in my           recognition
                what I do        to do things I enjoy      company          success of my                        organization               I deserve
                                   outside of work                           organization


Going for the Goal                                                            Generation Y/Millennials, only 21% of Traditionalists
As part of our survey, we also set out to under-                              felt the same way—with Generation Xers and
stand the strategies different generations think are                          Baby Boomers falling in-between the two, with
vital to reaching their career goals. Not surprisingly,                       40% and 35%, respectively. On the flip side, 60% of
their answers linked directly to their career stage.                          Traditionalists chose “just doing the best job I can” as
(See Figure 2.)                                                               the activity most likely to lead to achieving their goals,
                                                                              while only 15% of Generation Y/Millennials think
While “advancing my skills/knowledge” was at the                              that’s the right path to their own career success.
top of the list for 59% of workforce newbies

  Figure 2
  Methods for Achieving Goals, by Generation
                                               Traditionalists       Baby Boomers             Generation X              Generation Y/Millennials
  70%

  60%

  50%

  40%

  30%

  20%

  10%

   0%
          Advancing my skills/           Just doing the best        Taking on additional       Networking with others              Strengthening my
         knowledge to learn as                job I can            responsibilities at work      in and outside of                relationship with my
          much as I can about                                                                     my organization                 boss and leadership
           my job/profession
                                                                                              EMPLOYEE MOTIVATION BY GENERATION FACTORS | 3
These results—large populations of older employees                              the oldest generation, Traditionalists generally see
who just want to keep doing what they’re doing                                  little value in having a mentor, with a mere 11%
while younger employees are eager to grow and                                   ranking it at the top.
learn—could have a handful of implications on an
organization’s change management initiatives.                                   The Optimal Approach
                                                                                Our survey results made one thing perfectly clear:
Lessons in Learning                                                             The best way to ensure employees across the
Because “advancing skills” was reported as such an                              board benefit from training is to get creative, lean
important avenue to achieving goals, the next set of                            toward a more informal learning experience, and
questions became even more relevant. We asked our                               make it personal.
survey participants about sources of learning and
their efficacy.                                                                 To get creative, organizations need to offer oppor-
                                                                                tunities to experience the content in a number of
As seen in Figure 3 below, employees across all four                            ways: role plays and visceral experiences that
generations favor self-taught and outside training over                         engage both the heart and the mind; multimedia
formal programs traditionally offered inside the work-                          approaches such as video, wikis, blogs, and Web-
place, such as, lecture-based training or eLearning                             based training; and opportunities to learn from
page-turners.                                                                   trainers as well as peers.

Although earlier generations are more in favor of                               As for the preference toward a more informal
formal training than younger ones, it’s likely a func-                          learning experience, training ideally should be
tion of being “what they know and are accustomed                                delivered in short increments and embedded into
to” vs. a strong preference in that direction. And                              the learner’s workflow. Shortened attention spans
with today’s proliferation of wikis, blogs, and social                          and increased workloads have made multitasking a
networking sites on the internet, it’s no surprise that                         way of life. The ability to blend learning with the
Generation Y/Millennials lean heavily in favor of                               way individuals work is an attractive option for
self-taught learning.                                                           the future.

“Having a mentor” earned its fair share of responses—                           And above all, learning at its best is personalized.
coming in third place out of five for both                                      Resist the temptation to compartmentalize
Generation Xers and Generation Y/Millennials                                    employees into one prescribed generation.
(21%) and landing in a three-way tie for second                                 Instead, zone in on individual preferences as much
place with Baby Boomers (25%). Predictably, as                                  as possible.
    Figure 3
    Lessons in Learning
                                                   Traditionalists      Baby Boomers            Generation X         Generation Y/Millennials
    35%

    30%

    25%

    20%

    15%

    10%

     5%

     0%
              Self-taught methods           Education and training   Formal training programs      Having a mentor               Other
          (reading, online sources, etc.)    outside of workplace         in workplace

4 | EMPLOYEE MOTIVATION BY GENERATION FACTORS
Remember: There is no one-size-fits-all approach to maintaining motivation, delivering training
or anything else having to do with your very individual employees.

Creating a Motivating Environment
Here are some thought starters to use as you consider developing new programs or creating new systems
around employee motivation. But always remember: None of this trumps addressing individual needs
and values!

Figure 4
Creating a Motivating Environment

                           Traditionalists              Baby Boomers                   Generation X                 Generation Y/Millennial


CONSIDER THE BENEFIT • Help craft case studies to       • Look for easy-to-identify    • Help rewrite job           • Jointly develop
OF HAVING THESE       reinforce their perception          process improvements           descriptions to define        personalized learning
EMPLOYEES …           of the good being done              that will save time for        desirable career options     paths with their leaders
                      by the organization and             individuals and the
                                                                                       • Participate in coach-      • Hone leadership skills by
                      their role in it                    organization
                                                                                         the-coach development        chairing community
                           • Co-facilitate training     • Play devil’s advocate to                                    service projects
                                                                                       • Define the organization’s
                             sessions as SMEs             test new ideas
                                                                                         employee value             • Use technology
                           • Be personally exposed to   • Participate in scheduled       proposition                  platforms to share
                             the external business        formal 1:1 meetings with                                    knowledge gained in
                                                                                       • Help interview new-hire
                             realities that are           their leaders for feedback                                  self-study exercises
                                                                                         candidates
                             necessitating change         (in person, if possible)
                                                                                                                    • Lead “after action
                                                                                       • Participate in cross-
                                                                                                                      reviews” at the comple-
                                                                                         functional task forces
                                                                                                                      tion of key projects to
                                                                                                                      formalize on-the-job
                                                                                                                      learning

AND AVOID THESE            • Send them to training      • Ask them to mentor a         • Assume they can            • Provide constructive
COMMON MISTAKES…             “cold,” without a            new hire without giving        innately lead both           feedback without
                             pre-assessment to            them training on how to        younger and                  context
                             identify skill/knowledge     mentor                         older generations
                             gaps




                                                                                        EMPLOYEE MOTIVATION BY GENERATION FACTORS | 5
About the Research                                       About the Author
In August 2009, AchieveGlobal conducted a study of       Seleste Lunsford is an Executive Consultant for
300 individuals in the workforce to identify the goals   AchieveGlobal, based in Tampa, FL. Her areas of
and motivations of workers across generations.           expertise include customer management and sales
Our objective was to understand what motivates           effectiveness. Ms. Lunsford works with clients in
employees, what goals they seek to achieve at work       a variety of business models and in industries such as
and in their careers, and the activities they pursue     banking, insurance, manufacturing, federal govern-
to further their goals.                                  ment and telecommunications. Recent clients
                                                         include MasterCard International, The United States
Of the 300 completed surveys, respondents were           Navy, The South Financial Group, AAA, Travelers
evenly distributed across four generations: those        Insurance, NTELOS, AllianceBernstein, Office
born before 1947 (Traditionalists), between 1947         Depot, and Convergys.
and 1964 (Baby Boomers), between 1965 and 1980
(Generation X), and those born after 1980                In prior positions, Ms. Lunsford managed a $35
(Generation Y/Millennials).                              million portfolio of sales effectiveness products
                                                         and services— leading all market analysis, product
To control for other variables, we collected data on     development and sales force education activities.
education, the number of years in the workplace,         She has also worked as a Senior Consultant in the
and the number of years at the current place of          payments industry, helping global banks manage
employment. We discuss the effect of these variables     customer experiences over multiple delivery channels.
in this report where there is a statistically signifi-
cant relationship.                                       Ms. Lunsford earned an MBA degree from Florida
                                                         State University, where she also earned a B.S. degree
Overall, respondents in this study are highly educated   in Physics.
professionals, representing all four generations
proportionately (75 completed surveys in each).
They have been in the workforce for a significant
period of time, but most have not been in their
current job for more than five years.




6 | EMPLOYEE MOTIVATION BY GENERATION FACTORS
About AchieveGlobal
In the 21st century, the level of human skills will determine
organization success. AchieveGlobal provides exceptional
development in interpersonal business skills giving com-
panies the workforce they need for business results.
Located in over 40 countries, we offer multi-language,
learning-based solutions—globally, regionally, and locally.

We understand the competition you face. Your success
depends on people who have the skills to handle the
challenges beyond the reach of technology. We’re experts
in developing these skills, and it’s these skills that turn
your strategies into business success in the 21st century.

These are things technology can’t do. Think. Learn.
Solve problems. Listen. Motivate. Explain. People with
these skills have a bright future in the 21st century.
AchieveGlobal prepares you for that world.




                                                                EMPLOYEE MOTIVATION BY GENERATION FACTORS | 7
World Headquarters
                              8875 Hidden River Parkway, Suite 400
                              Tampa, Florida 33637 USA
                              Toll Free: 800.456.9390
                              www.achieveglobal.com

© 2009 AchieveGlobal, Inc. No. M01274 v. 1.0 (12/2009)

Contenu connexe

Tendances

The Peloton Model of Social Performance Management
The Peloton Model of Social Performance ManagementThe Peloton Model of Social Performance Management
The Peloton Model of Social Performance ManagementBhupesh Chaurasia
 
Module 3 material_sample Vocational Training
Module 3 material_sample Vocational TrainingModule 3 material_sample Vocational Training
Module 3 material_sample Vocational TrainingDewey Alfonso
 
Effective leadership
Effective leadershipEffective leadership
Effective leadershipMarynelGagani
 
Management of people in difficult times. Innovation as motivating factor
Management of people in difficult times. Innovation as motivating factorManagement of people in difficult times. Innovation as motivating factor
Management of people in difficult times. Innovation as motivating factorXavier Baño
 
New Paradigm For Management Education Paper For National Conference At Vim V2.0
New Paradigm For Management Education Paper For National Conference At Vim V2.0New Paradigm For Management Education Paper For National Conference At Vim V2.0
New Paradigm For Management Education Paper For National Conference At Vim V2.0Anand Joshi
 
UNLOCKING CREATIVITY (1)
UNLOCKING CREATIVITY (1)UNLOCKING CREATIVITY (1)
UNLOCKING CREATIVITY (1)Ripunjoy Bhuyan
 
Nothing beats experience – anand joshi, md noble tek (india) learning infin...
Nothing beats experience – anand joshi, md noble tek (india)   learning infin...Nothing beats experience – anand joshi, md noble tek (india)   learning infin...
Nothing beats experience – anand joshi, md noble tek (india) learning infin...Anand Joshi
 
CRITICAL REFLECTION IN LEADERSHIP - Authentic Leaders Drive Engagement Demyst...
CRITICAL REFLECTION IN LEADERSHIP - Authentic Leaders Drive Engagement Demyst...CRITICAL REFLECTION IN LEADERSHIP - Authentic Leaders Drive Engagement Demyst...
CRITICAL REFLECTION IN LEADERSHIP - Authentic Leaders Drive Engagement Demyst...Department of Electrical Services
 
Gptw for all leadership in action summit
Gptw for all leadership in action summitGptw for all leadership in action summit
Gptw for all leadership in action summitKam Kazemi
 
Adaptive leader
Adaptive leaderAdaptive leader
Adaptive leaderLong Huynh
 

Tendances (13)

The Peloton Model of Social Performance Management
The Peloton Model of Social Performance ManagementThe Peloton Model of Social Performance Management
The Peloton Model of Social Performance Management
 
Module 3 material_sample Vocational Training
Module 3 material_sample Vocational TrainingModule 3 material_sample Vocational Training
Module 3 material_sample Vocational Training
 
Nir Halevy on Motivating Your Workforce
Nir Halevy on Motivating Your WorkforceNir Halevy on Motivating Your Workforce
Nir Halevy on Motivating Your Workforce
 
Effective leadership
Effective leadershipEffective leadership
Effective leadership
 
Management of people in difficult times. Innovation as motivating factor
Management of people in difficult times. Innovation as motivating factorManagement of people in difficult times. Innovation as motivating factor
Management of people in difficult times. Innovation as motivating factor
 
New Paradigm For Management Education Paper For National Conference At Vim V2.0
New Paradigm For Management Education Paper For National Conference At Vim V2.0New Paradigm For Management Education Paper For National Conference At Vim V2.0
New Paradigm For Management Education Paper For National Conference At Vim V2.0
 
UNLOCKING CREATIVITY (1)
UNLOCKING CREATIVITY (1)UNLOCKING CREATIVITY (1)
UNLOCKING CREATIVITY (1)
 
Nothing beats experience – anand joshi, md noble tek (india) learning infin...
Nothing beats experience – anand joshi, md noble tek (india)   learning infin...Nothing beats experience – anand joshi, md noble tek (india)   learning infin...
Nothing beats experience – anand joshi, md noble tek (india) learning infin...
 
Change Communications
Change CommunicationsChange Communications
Change Communications
 
CRITICAL REFLECTION IN LEADERSHIP - Authentic Leaders Drive Engagement Demyst...
CRITICAL REFLECTION IN LEADERSHIP - Authentic Leaders Drive Engagement Demyst...CRITICAL REFLECTION IN LEADERSHIP - Authentic Leaders Drive Engagement Demyst...
CRITICAL REFLECTION IN LEADERSHIP - Authentic Leaders Drive Engagement Demyst...
 
Gptw for all leadership in action summit
Gptw for all leadership in action summitGptw for all leadership in action summit
Gptw for all leadership in action summit
 
Advisor Resources
Advisor ResourcesAdvisor Resources
Advisor Resources
 
Adaptive leader
Adaptive leaderAdaptive leader
Adaptive leader
 

Similaire à Employee Motivation Survey Analysis Reveals Generational Differences

Gallup Q12's Employee Engagement Findings
Gallup Q12's Employee Engagement FindingsGallup Q12's Employee Engagement Findings
Gallup Q12's Employee Engagement FindingsPaul Sohn
 
JuliaMagdelino_WhitePaper
JuliaMagdelino_WhitePaperJuliaMagdelino_WhitePaper
JuliaMagdelino_WhitePaperJulia Magdelino
 
Leading Millenniums to Leadership Greatness
Leading Millenniums to Leadership GreatnessLeading Millenniums to Leadership Greatness
Leading Millenniums to Leadership GreatnessRoshan Thiran
 
FS - Ebook - Engaging Millenials in the Workplace (18872)
FS - Ebook - Engaging Millenials in the Workplace (18872)FS - Ebook - Engaging Millenials in the Workplace (18872)
FS - Ebook - Engaging Millenials in the Workplace (18872)April Scarlett
 
CEE Executive Briefing on Harnessing Multigenerational Workforce in India - 1...
CEE Executive Briefing on Harnessing Multigenerational Workforce in India - 1...CEE Executive Briefing on Harnessing Multigenerational Workforce in India - 1...
CEE Executive Briefing on Harnessing Multigenerational Workforce in India - 1...Centre for Executive Education
 
lesson5-topic34-210426055848 (2).pdf
lesson5-topic34-210426055848 (2).pdflesson5-topic34-210426055848 (2).pdf
lesson5-topic34-210426055848 (2).pdfKimberlyjoycsolomon
 
Lesson 5 topic 3 &4
Lesson 5   topic 3 &4Lesson 5   topic 3 &4
Lesson 5 topic 3 &4chumce02
 
Understanding Millennials In The Workforce
Understanding Millennials In The WorkforceUnderstanding Millennials In The Workforce
Understanding Millennials In The WorkforceThe Change School
 
A2 maop.bus211.01
A2 maop.bus211.01A2 maop.bus211.01
A2 maop.bus211.01L14MaoP
 
Reply to TEVA 2No matter where you go or what you do, they are t.docx
Reply to TEVA 2No matter where you go or what you do, they are t.docxReply to TEVA 2No matter where you go or what you do, they are t.docx
Reply to TEVA 2No matter where you go or what you do, they are t.docxsodhi3
 
Gallupq12summaryboeingportlandr1 120223005928-phpapp02
Gallupq12summaryboeingportlandr1 120223005928-phpapp02Gallupq12summaryboeingportlandr1 120223005928-phpapp02
Gallupq12summaryboeingportlandr1 120223005928-phpapp02Agatha C Melvin
 
Robert Half Generation Y White Paper Def
Robert Half Generation Y White Paper   DefRobert Half Generation Y White Paper   Def
Robert Half Generation Y White Paper Defsonvde01
 
Genywhitepaperdef 12973487439766-phpapp02
Genywhitepaperdef 12973487439766-phpapp02Genywhitepaperdef 12973487439766-phpapp02
Genywhitepaperdef 12973487439766-phpapp02AndyLoots
 
Equinox Partners - 15Five Leader's Guide
Equinox Partners - 15Five Leader's GuideEquinox Partners - 15Five Leader's Guide
Equinox Partners - 15Five Leader's GuidePlamen Petrov
 
Leadership in an Aging workforce and emerging leaders
Leadership in an Aging workforce and emerging leadersLeadership in an Aging workforce and emerging leaders
Leadership in an Aging workforce and emerging leadersDr. Ann M. Kappel, SWP
 
15Five's Guide To Creating High Performing Teams
15Five's Guide To Creating High Performing Teams15Five's Guide To Creating High Performing Teams
15Five's Guide To Creating High Performing TeamsDavid Hassell
 
Preparing Leaders to Meet Gen Y Expectations by Adam Bawany in Daily FT - 27 ...
Preparing Leaders to Meet Gen Y Expectations by Adam Bawany in Daily FT - 27 ...Preparing Leaders to Meet Gen Y Expectations by Adam Bawany in Daily FT - 27 ...
Preparing Leaders to Meet Gen Y Expectations by Adam Bawany in Daily FT - 27 ...Centre for Executive Education
 

Similaire à Employee Motivation Survey Analysis Reveals Generational Differences (20)

Gallup Q12's Employee Engagement Findings
Gallup Q12's Employee Engagement FindingsGallup Q12's Employee Engagement Findings
Gallup Q12's Employee Engagement Findings
 
JuliaMagdelino_WhitePaper
JuliaMagdelino_WhitePaperJuliaMagdelino_WhitePaper
JuliaMagdelino_WhitePaper
 
Essays About Leadership
Essays About LeadershipEssays About Leadership
Essays About Leadership
 
Leading Millenniums to Leadership Greatness
Leading Millenniums to Leadership GreatnessLeading Millenniums to Leadership Greatness
Leading Millenniums to Leadership Greatness
 
FS - Ebook - Engaging Millenials in the Workplace (18872)
FS - Ebook - Engaging Millenials in the Workplace (18872)FS - Ebook - Engaging Millenials in the Workplace (18872)
FS - Ebook - Engaging Millenials in the Workplace (18872)
 
CEE Executive Briefing on Harnessing Multigenerational Workforce in India - 1...
CEE Executive Briefing on Harnessing Multigenerational Workforce in India - 1...CEE Executive Briefing on Harnessing Multigenerational Workforce in India - 1...
CEE Executive Briefing on Harnessing Multigenerational Workforce in India - 1...
 
lesson5-topic34-210426055848 (2).pdf
lesson5-topic34-210426055848 (2).pdflesson5-topic34-210426055848 (2).pdf
lesson5-topic34-210426055848 (2).pdf
 
Lesson 5 topic 3 &4
Lesson 5   topic 3 &4Lesson 5   topic 3 &4
Lesson 5 topic 3 &4
 
Understanding Millennials In The Workforce
Understanding Millennials In The WorkforceUnderstanding Millennials In The Workforce
Understanding Millennials In The Workforce
 
A2 maop.bus211.01
A2 maop.bus211.01A2 maop.bus211.01
A2 maop.bus211.01
 
Reply to TEVA 2No matter where you go or what you do, they are t.docx
Reply to TEVA 2No matter where you go or what you do, they are t.docxReply to TEVA 2No matter where you go or what you do, they are t.docx
Reply to TEVA 2No matter where you go or what you do, they are t.docx
 
Gallupq12summaryboeingportlandr1 120223005928-phpapp02
Gallupq12summaryboeingportlandr1 120223005928-phpapp02Gallupq12summaryboeingportlandr1 120223005928-phpapp02
Gallupq12summaryboeingportlandr1 120223005928-phpapp02
 
Robert Half Generation Y White Paper Def
Robert Half Generation Y White Paper   DefRobert Half Generation Y White Paper   Def
Robert Half Generation Y White Paper Def
 
Genywhitepaperdef 12973487439766-phpapp02
Genywhitepaperdef 12973487439766-phpapp02Genywhitepaperdef 12973487439766-phpapp02
Genywhitepaperdef 12973487439766-phpapp02
 
Employee Engagment
Employee EngagmentEmployee Engagment
Employee Engagment
 
Equinox Partners - 15Five Leader's Guide
Equinox Partners - 15Five Leader's GuideEquinox Partners - 15Five Leader's Guide
Equinox Partners - 15Five Leader's Guide
 
Leadership in an Aging workforce and emerging leaders
Leadership in an Aging workforce and emerging leadersLeadership in an Aging workforce and emerging leaders
Leadership in an Aging workforce and emerging leaders
 
Generations
GenerationsGenerations
Generations
 
15Five's Guide To Creating High Performing Teams
15Five's Guide To Creating High Performing Teams15Five's Guide To Creating High Performing Teams
15Five's Guide To Creating High Performing Teams
 
Preparing Leaders to Meet Gen Y Expectations by Adam Bawany in Daily FT - 27 ...
Preparing Leaders to Meet Gen Y Expectations by Adam Bawany in Daily FT - 27 ...Preparing Leaders to Meet Gen Y Expectations by Adam Bawany in Daily FT - 27 ...
Preparing Leaders to Meet Gen Y Expectations by Adam Bawany in Daily FT - 27 ...
 

Employee Motivation Survey Analysis Reveals Generational Differences

  • 1. Survey Analysis: Employee Motivation by Generation Factors By Seleste Lunsford Developing the 21st century workforce TM
  • 2. There’s no question that motivated employees are Our survey respondents were evenly distributed more productive and more creative, and add more across the four generations, and all were asked overall value to an organization than their “just the same questions about their motivators, goals, doing what it takes to get by” counterparts. They achievement strategies, and learning preferences. can, in fact, be key to your success—a differentiator Some results were predictable, based on where the that sets you apart from the competition. respondents are in their careers; others, as you’ll see, were enlightening. Y because it comes from within, motivation cannot et be created, taught, or instilled. It can, however, Motivators by Generation be tapped into, supported, and maintained. The When asked about the most important goal in their question is how. Does money always do the trick? job (i.e., what motivates them), employees across the Are recognition and respect critical factors? generations on average sorted to self-fulfillment and Is the promise of career advancement key? “feeling good about what I do.” This response was most pronounced for Traditionalists (45%), many of Well, yes and no. What works for one employee whom are nearing retirement age and likely are at doesn’t necessarily work for another. And because least content—if not satisfied—with their careers just different individuals are, by nature, driven by as they are. (See Figure 1.) different motivators, there will never be a one- size-fits-all approach. The second most frequent response was a tie, with “flexibility in my schedule” being selected What’s an organization to do? by 37% of Baby Boomers and “advancement in my career/profession /company” being selected by 37% Group Think of Generation Y/Millennials. It’s interesting to Armed with the knowledge that motivation is one of note that flexibility ranked high by Traditionalists the most important—yet least understood—keys to and Generation Xers as well, although only 10% employee performance improvement, AchieveGlobal of Generation Y/Millennials see it as their most set out to investigate to what extent generational important motivation. differences are at play in motivational factors. Surprisingly, “more money/better benefits” did not The thought behind the survey of approximately 300 turn up as a large motivator across the generations employees across the United States was this: Since as a whole. It was ranked highest by Generation motivating employees based on their individual drivers Xers, 16% of whom selected it as their most can be complex, and motivating employees with a important motivation. Its importance falls blanket approach leaves many out in the cold, maybe further from there, with only 9% of Generation a glimpse into generational trends can provide some Y/Millennials, 5% of Baby Boomers, and 4% of logical direction for an organization-wide approach Traditionalists giving it top billing. to employee motivation. A possible explanation for “more money” ranking And what better time to explore such an approach so low is that money has been shown to have only than now—a unique point in U.S. history where a short-term impact on behavior, making it more at least four generations of employees are in the effective as an incentive than as a long-term moti- workplace: vator. In addition, many employees rewarded with money end up using it to pay bills—at which point • Traditionalists – those born before 1947 it becomes compensation and loses its value as a • Baby Boomers – those born between 1947 – 1964 motivator. • Generation X – those born between 1965 – 1980 • Generation Y/Millennials – those born after 1980 2 | EMPLOYEE MOTIVATION BY GENERATION FACTORS
  • 3. Figure 1 Most Important Goal Before Traditionalist Baby Boomers Generation X Generation Y/Millennials 50% 45% 40% 35% 30% 25% 20% 15% 10% 5% 0% Self-fulfillment/ Flexibility in my Advancement in my Knowing that I’m More money/better Gaining respect Gaining the feeling good about schedule/time off career/profession/ contributing to the benefits of others in my recognition what I do to do things I enjoy company success of my organization I deserve outside of work organization Going for the Goal Generation Y/Millennials, only 21% of Traditionalists As part of our survey, we also set out to under- felt the same way—with Generation Xers and stand the strategies different generations think are Baby Boomers falling in-between the two, with vital to reaching their career goals. Not surprisingly, 40% and 35%, respectively. On the flip side, 60% of their answers linked directly to their career stage. Traditionalists chose “just doing the best job I can” as (See Figure 2.) the activity most likely to lead to achieving their goals, while only 15% of Generation Y/Millennials think While “advancing my skills/knowledge” was at the that’s the right path to their own career success. top of the list for 59% of workforce newbies Figure 2 Methods for Achieving Goals, by Generation Traditionalists Baby Boomers Generation X Generation Y/Millennials 70% 60% 50% 40% 30% 20% 10% 0% Advancing my skills/ Just doing the best Taking on additional Networking with others Strengthening my knowledge to learn as job I can responsibilities at work in and outside of relationship with my much as I can about my organization boss and leadership my job/profession EMPLOYEE MOTIVATION BY GENERATION FACTORS | 3
  • 4. These results—large populations of older employees the oldest generation, Traditionalists generally see who just want to keep doing what they’re doing little value in having a mentor, with a mere 11% while younger employees are eager to grow and ranking it at the top. learn—could have a handful of implications on an organization’s change management initiatives. The Optimal Approach Our survey results made one thing perfectly clear: Lessons in Learning The best way to ensure employees across the Because “advancing skills” was reported as such an board benefit from training is to get creative, lean important avenue to achieving goals, the next set of toward a more informal learning experience, and questions became even more relevant. We asked our make it personal. survey participants about sources of learning and their efficacy. To get creative, organizations need to offer oppor- tunities to experience the content in a number of As seen in Figure 3 below, employees across all four ways: role plays and visceral experiences that generations favor self-taught and outside training over engage both the heart and the mind; multimedia formal programs traditionally offered inside the work- approaches such as video, wikis, blogs, and Web- place, such as, lecture-based training or eLearning based training; and opportunities to learn from page-turners. trainers as well as peers. Although earlier generations are more in favor of As for the preference toward a more informal formal training than younger ones, it’s likely a func- learning experience, training ideally should be tion of being “what they know and are accustomed delivered in short increments and embedded into to” vs. a strong preference in that direction. And the learner’s workflow. Shortened attention spans with today’s proliferation of wikis, blogs, and social and increased workloads have made multitasking a networking sites on the internet, it’s no surprise that way of life. The ability to blend learning with the Generation Y/Millennials lean heavily in favor of way individuals work is an attractive option for self-taught learning. the future. “Having a mentor” earned its fair share of responses— And above all, learning at its best is personalized. coming in third place out of five for both Resist the temptation to compartmentalize Generation Xers and Generation Y/Millennials employees into one prescribed generation. (21%) and landing in a three-way tie for second Instead, zone in on individual preferences as much place with Baby Boomers (25%). Predictably, as as possible. Figure 3 Lessons in Learning Traditionalists Baby Boomers Generation X Generation Y/Millennials 35% 30% 25% 20% 15% 10% 5% 0% Self-taught methods Education and training Formal training programs Having a mentor Other (reading, online sources, etc.) outside of workplace in workplace 4 | EMPLOYEE MOTIVATION BY GENERATION FACTORS
  • 5. Remember: There is no one-size-fits-all approach to maintaining motivation, delivering training or anything else having to do with your very individual employees. Creating a Motivating Environment Here are some thought starters to use as you consider developing new programs or creating new systems around employee motivation. But always remember: None of this trumps addressing individual needs and values! Figure 4 Creating a Motivating Environment Traditionalists Baby Boomers Generation X Generation Y/Millennial CONSIDER THE BENEFIT • Help craft case studies to • Look for easy-to-identify • Help rewrite job • Jointly develop OF HAVING THESE reinforce their perception process improvements descriptions to define personalized learning EMPLOYEES … of the good being done that will save time for desirable career options paths with their leaders by the organization and individuals and the • Participate in coach- • Hone leadership skills by their role in it organization the-coach development chairing community • Co-facilitate training • Play devil’s advocate to service projects • Define the organization’s sessions as SMEs test new ideas employee value • Use technology • Be personally exposed to • Participate in scheduled proposition platforms to share the external business formal 1:1 meetings with knowledge gained in • Help interview new-hire realities that are their leaders for feedback self-study exercises candidates necessitating change (in person, if possible) • Lead “after action • Participate in cross- reviews” at the comple- functional task forces tion of key projects to formalize on-the-job learning AND AVOID THESE • Send them to training • Ask them to mentor a • Assume they can • Provide constructive COMMON MISTAKES… “cold,” without a new hire without giving innately lead both feedback without pre-assessment to them training on how to younger and context identify skill/knowledge mentor older generations gaps EMPLOYEE MOTIVATION BY GENERATION FACTORS | 5
  • 6. About the Research About the Author In August 2009, AchieveGlobal conducted a study of Seleste Lunsford is an Executive Consultant for 300 individuals in the workforce to identify the goals AchieveGlobal, based in Tampa, FL. Her areas of and motivations of workers across generations. expertise include customer management and sales Our objective was to understand what motivates effectiveness. Ms. Lunsford works with clients in employees, what goals they seek to achieve at work a variety of business models and in industries such as and in their careers, and the activities they pursue banking, insurance, manufacturing, federal govern- to further their goals. ment and telecommunications. Recent clients include MasterCard International, The United States Of the 300 completed surveys, respondents were Navy, The South Financial Group, AAA, Travelers evenly distributed across four generations: those Insurance, NTELOS, AllianceBernstein, Office born before 1947 (Traditionalists), between 1947 Depot, and Convergys. and 1964 (Baby Boomers), between 1965 and 1980 (Generation X), and those born after 1980 In prior positions, Ms. Lunsford managed a $35 (Generation Y/Millennials). million portfolio of sales effectiveness products and services— leading all market analysis, product To control for other variables, we collected data on development and sales force education activities. education, the number of years in the workplace, She has also worked as a Senior Consultant in the and the number of years at the current place of payments industry, helping global banks manage employment. We discuss the effect of these variables customer experiences over multiple delivery channels. in this report where there is a statistically signifi- cant relationship. Ms. Lunsford earned an MBA degree from Florida State University, where she also earned a B.S. degree Overall, respondents in this study are highly educated in Physics. professionals, representing all four generations proportionately (75 completed surveys in each). They have been in the workforce for a significant period of time, but most have not been in their current job for more than five years. 6 | EMPLOYEE MOTIVATION BY GENERATION FACTORS
  • 7. About AchieveGlobal In the 21st century, the level of human skills will determine organization success. AchieveGlobal provides exceptional development in interpersonal business skills giving com- panies the workforce they need for business results. Located in over 40 countries, we offer multi-language, learning-based solutions—globally, regionally, and locally. We understand the competition you face. Your success depends on people who have the skills to handle the challenges beyond the reach of technology. We’re experts in developing these skills, and it’s these skills that turn your strategies into business success in the 21st century. These are things technology can’t do. Think. Learn. Solve problems. Listen. Motivate. Explain. People with these skills have a bright future in the 21st century. AchieveGlobal prepares you for that world. EMPLOYEE MOTIVATION BY GENERATION FACTORS | 7
  • 8. World Headquarters 8875 Hidden River Parkway, Suite 400 Tampa, Florida 33637 USA Toll Free: 800.456.9390 www.achieveglobal.com © 2009 AchieveGlobal, Inc. No. M01274 v. 1.0 (12/2009)