The document describes an educational exercise that uses simulations to help students understand how galaxy shapes form through interactions and collisions. Students will observe images of galaxies, then use a "Galaxy Crash" simulation to test different parameters and try to recreate the shapes. They will analyze the simulations to determine how long interactions take and what may happen to the galaxies in the future. The goal is for students to understand conceptually how galaxy morphologies arise and to think critically about astronomical observations and simulations.
1. CRASHING GALAXIES
(INQUIRY BASED TEACHING)
Tsourlidaki Eleftheria
Ellinogermaniki Agogi
2. GENERAL INFORMATION
• Brief Description: The following exercise aims to introduce to
students the concept of varying galactic morphologies. Students
will try to investigate the origin of the shapes of the galaxies that
stem from galaxy interactions.
• Connection to the curriculum:
Elementary education: Interdisciplinary courses, Astronomy:
Galaxies
Secondary education: Introduction to astronomy and space
physics, Gravity
• Age range: 9 – 11, 11 – 14, 14 – 16
• Time required: 2 didactic hours
• Technical Requirements:
Computers with internet connection and flash
Go-Lab platform
• Keywords: galaxy, elliptical, spiral, irregulars, lenticular, Hubble
3. GENERAL INFORMATION
Educational Objectives:
- Learn about the different shapes of galaxies.
- Get acquainted with making and studying astronomical
observations.
- Learn about simulations and how they may be used in a
scientific context.
Cognitive domain (processes): to think critically and creatively
Cognitive domain (knowledge): conceptual knowledge,
procedural knowledge
Affective domain: to respond and participate
Psychomotor domain: to adapt and perform creatively
4. QUESTIONS ELICITING ANSWERS :
EXHIBIT CURIOSITY
- What do these pictures depict?
- How are galaxies created?
- What would happen to our Galaxy if it
collided with another?
5. QUESTIONS ELICITING ANSWERS :
EXHIBIT CURIOSITY
During this exercise we will:
- Collect images of galaxies using a robotic
telescope
- Investigate the origin of the shape of the
galaxy we’ll observe using simulations.
6. QUESTIONS ELICITING ANSWERS :
DEFINE QUESTION FROM CURRENT KNOWLEDGE
- How are galaxies formulated?
- How many galaxies are there in the universe?
- What is a galaxy composed of?
-What is so special about the centre of galaxies?
-Why are galactic centres so bright?
7. ACTIVE INVESTIGATION : PROPOSE
PRELIMINARY EXPLANATION OR HYPOTHESIS
- How can we learn how these shapes came to be?
- How do you think these galaxies looked like before
they started interacting?
- What will happen to these galaxies in the future?
- How long does it take for a galaxy to be
formulated?
8. ACTIVE INVESTIGATION :
PLAN & CONDUCT SIMPLE INVESTIGATION
Choose some of the galaxies indicated and make
observations using the Faulkes telescopes.
9. ACTIVE INVESTIGATION : PLAN &
CONDUCT SIMPLE INVESTIGATION
NGC 4038 - The Antennae
12:01:52.68, -18:51:54.00
Coordinates:
Filter: Color
Exposure: 180 s
M51 and its companion, NGC 5195
Coordinates: 13:29:53.16, 47:11:48.120
Filter: Color
Exposure: 180 s
10. ACTIVE INVESTIGATION :
PLAN & CONDUCT SIMPLE INVESTIGATION
- We are now going to investigate the shapes of the
galaxies we observed.
How was their shape created?
How long did it take to be created?
What will happen in the future?
We are going to investigate the origin of these two
galaxies and answer the questions mentioned above
using a simulation. Just like astronomers do, we will try to
reproduce the observed image using a simulation, in order
to understand the process behind the shape of the
observed image.
•
11. ACTIVE INVESTIGATION :
PLAN & CONDUCT SIMPLE INVESTIGATION
- Go to the “Galaxy Crash” simulation
- Look at the galaxy in the image you have obtained from the
telescope and try to recreate its shape by using the simulator. In
order to do this, change the parameters in the panel and carry
out numerous simulations until you achieve the desired result.
- When the shape of the galaxy in the image resembles the
shape in the simulation stop the simulation and make a print-
screen. Insert your print screen in your notebook. If needed,
prior to making your print-screen, rotate and enlarge the image
in the simulation in order to make a more accurate match to
the real image.
13. DISCUSSION:
EXPLANATION BASED ON EVIDENCE
- Explain which parameters you used for your best model in the
simulations you have carried out.
- How long did it take for this interaction to reach the observed
stage?
- Based on your simulation, describe how the current shape of the
galaxy has been formed.
- Based on your simulation, what do you think will happen to these
galaxies in the future?
- What happens to the relative velocities of the galaxies as they
reach their point of closest approach (perigalacticon, or peri for
short)?
14. DISCUSSION:
CONSIDER OTHER EXPLANATIONS
- Do your team’s parameter match the parameters
chosen by other teams?
- Could there be any other different way to form the
same galaxy?
- Do you conclusions much your initial predictions?
15. REFLECTION:
COMMUNICATE EXPLANATION
- What parameters are involved in the shaping of
galaxies?
- Why are spiral galaxies more active in terms of
star formation?
- How long does it take for a galaxy to form?
What kind of galaxy is the Milky Way?
Notes de l'éditeur
You may begin your lesson with a presentation of a video or numerous pictures depicting different galaxies. Trigger a small conversation with your class by asking your students what they know about galaxies in general.
You may inform your students about what they will do during this exercise.
Ask your students to pick an image and comment on what they see Initiate a conversation by asking questions on the structure of the depicted galaxies. This will help you understand what they already know on the subject.
Ask your students whether they can imagine how such galaxies are formed. Discuss with them how could these shapes have been created and introduce the central idea of investigating the past of galaxies and the universe in general by creating respective simulations. Note down their answers.
Inform your students that you are going to start your investigation be making observations of galaxies, just like astronomers do.
After we retrieve our observation we will study the morphology of the galaxy and attempt to reproduce its shape using a ‘ Galaxy Crash ’ simulation.
Useful tips: It is thought that NGC 5195 has a mass of about 30-50% the mass of M51. In recent simulations of these two galaxies, astronomers - among other parameters - varied the angle of inclination (theta) for M51 between 10-30 degrees, and for NGC 5195, between 25-50 degrees. Astronomers believe NGC 4038 to be the result of a collision between two spiral galaxies of similar mass. In recent simulations of this galaxy interaction, astronomers incline both galaxies at 60 degrees to the orbital plane (i.e. theta = 60 degrees). Try not to change too many parameters at once in a run. See how each parameter individually affects the simulated galaxies first. Remember, we are only seeing the above observed interactions from one viewing angle, so click and drag the view of the simulation to see the interactions from different angles to see which best match our observations. The smaller the value for Peri, the stronger the tidal interaction between the two galaxies, but also, the faster the interaction, so long tidal tails may not form. The larger the value for Peri, the slower the interactions, but the weaker the tidal interaction between the galaxies, so again, long tidal tails may not form!
Compare the parameters each team used in order to produce the images of the galaxies. Check if all teams have used more or less the same parameters, if not discuss about the different scenarios regarding the formation of the galaxies under investigation. Students will refer to their initial predictions and compare them to the results of their research.