This document discusses methods for measuring food insecurity in developed countries like the UK. It begins by reviewing early discussions around defining and quantifying food insecurity/hunger in North America. It then examines qualitative research exploring experiences of food insecurity. Common themes included uncertainty over food supply, shortage of food, unsuitable/monotonous diets, and reduced food quality and quantity.
The document outlines the development of standardized household food security surveys like the USDA Household Food Security Survey Module. It compares this tool to other measures like the FAO Food Insecurity Experience Scale. It acknowledges limitations of these tools in fully capturing all dimensions of food security like availability, utilization, and stability over time. Finally, it considers reasons
ICT role in 21st century education and it's challenges.pdf
Loopstra festival socialscience_8nov16_toshare
1. Measuring food insecurity in the UK: !
what, why, methods, limitations"
Rachel Loopstra!
rachel.loopstra@sociology.ox.ac.uk!
Department of Sociology, University of Oxford!
Division of Diabetes and Nutritional Sciences, King’s College London!
!
http://nutritionalsciences.lamp.utoronto.ca/
8. Narra0ves of hunger: Uncertain access to
food
“When I see my cupboard becoming
empty, I wonder how am I going to fill
it again and I get panicky”
“You always have a soluDon for yourself: to do without, but if you
don’t have enough for the kids, what do you do? This is where stress
starts to build and then you pedal to find a soluDon to be able to eat
unDl the end of the month”
9. Narra0ves of hunger: Shortage of Food
“From the second week of each month, there is so liWle food
leX in the fridge and in the cupboard that it is hard to make up
a dish”
“For sure we are not starving to death, but
we cannot eat so we can fill up”
“I have to watch and tell my children “you ate
enough, save some for tomorrow…”
10. Narra0ves of hunger: Unsuitability of food
and monotony of diet
“We are limited to items on sale (or to what we are given)”.
“We want to follow Canada's Food Guide but it is impossible.”
“I am not able to offer enough fresh fruit, vegetables,
cheese, quality foods for my kids”
“The same stuff always… noodles with soya sauce,
shepherd's pie, pancakes…”
11. Narra0ves of hunger: Reduced food quan0ty
and quality
“In the hardest Dmes, I cut the number of meals and
when I eat, I don’t eat what I want to eat: I don’t have
enough to make a meal so I eat junk food…”
“My stomach oXen hurts when I go to bed at
night, I endure the situaDon because I want
my daughter to grow normally.”
12. Core components of household food insecurity
iden0fied in qualita0ve in-depth interviews with
low income families.
Quan%ty Quality Psychological Social
Household Level Food DepleDon Unsuitable food Food Anxiety Unacceptable
means of food
acquisiDon
Individual Level Insufficient intake Inadequate diet Feeling deprived,
lack of choice
Disrupted eaDng
Radimer et al. 1992; Hamelin et al. 2002.
!Range in severity !MulD-dimensional ! Not equally experienced
13. Defini0ons of food insecurity
(synonymous with food poverty?)
“The inability to acquire or consume an adequate quality or
sufficient quantity of food in socially acceptable ways or the
uncertainty that one will be able to do so.”
(Radimer et al., J of Nutrition, 1992)
“Food insecurity exists whenever the availability of nutritionally
adequate and safe foods or the ability to acquire acceptable
foods in socially acceptable ways is limited or uncertain”
(Anderson, J of Nutrition. 1990)
16. Adult: Stage 2
In the last 12 months…
4a Did (you/you or other adults in your household) ever
cut the size of your meals or skip meals because
there wasn't enough money for food?
Yes
No
4b If yes: How often did this happen—almost every
month, some months but not every month, or in only
1 or 2 months?
Almost every month
Some months but not
every month
Only 1 or 2 months
5 Did you ever eat less than you felt you should
because there wasn't enough money for food?
Yes
No
6 Were you every hungry but didn't eat because there
wasn't enough money for food?
Yes
No
7 Did you lose weight because there wasn't enough
money for food?
Yes
No
If at least one ques-on affirmed, on to Stage 3.
17. Adult: Stage 3
In the last 12 months…
8a Did (you/you or other adults in your household) ever
not eat for a whole day because there wasn't
enough money for food?
Yes
No
8b If yes: How often did this happen—almost every
month, some months but not every month, or in only
1 or 2 months?
Almost every
month
Some months
but not every
month
Only 1 or 2
months
18. Child: Stage 1
Now I'm going to read you several statements that people have made about the food
situation of their children.
In the last 12 months, were these statements…
1 “We relied on only a few kinds of low-cost food to feed our children
because we were running out of money to buy food.”
Often true
Sometimes
true
Never true
2 “We couldn’t feed our children a balanced meal, because we couldn’t
afford that.”
Often true
Sometimes
true
Never true
3 “The children were not eating enough because we just couldn't afford
enough food."
Often true
Sometimes
true
Never true
If at least one ques-on affirmed, on to Stage 2.
19. Child: Stage 2
In the past 12 months…
4 Did you ever cut the size of any of the
children’s meals because there wasn't enough
money for food?
Yes
No
5a Did any of the children ever skip meals
because there wasn't enough money for food?
Yes
No
5b How often did this happen? Almost every month
Some months but not every
month
Only 1 or 2 months
If at least one ques-on affirmed, on to Stage 3.
20. Child: Stage 3
In the past 12 months…
6a Were the children ever hungry but
you just couldn't afford more food?
Yes
No
6b Did any of the children ever not
eat for a whole day because there
wasn't enough money for food?
Yes
No
26. Ashby et al. Measurement of the dimensions of food insecurity in
developed countries: a systema0c literature review. Public Health
Nutri0on. Nov 2016.
Household
food
security
scales
Hager two-
item screen
ESCLA Community
Childhood Hunger
IdenDficaDon
Project (CCHIP)
tool
Cornell Child
Food Security
Measure
Girard four-
point tool
Household Food
Insecurity Access
Scale (HFIAS)
Townsend Food
Behaviour
Checklist
27. Domains of food security
Economic and physical
ACCESS to food
Focus of household food insecurity measurement scales.
Physical AVAILABILITY
of food
Food availability addresses the “supply side” of food security.
Food UTILIZATION
Feeding pracDces, food preparaDon, diversity and adequacy of
the diet and intra-household distribuDon of food.
STABILITY of the other
three dimensions over
Dme
Even if your food intake is adequate today, you are sDll
considered to be food insecure if you have inadequate access to
food on a periodic basis.
Source: FAO.
Ashby et al. Measurement of the dimensions of food insecurity in developed countries: a systemaDc literature review.
Public Health NutriDon. Nov 2016.
28. What do household food insecurity scales
NOT measure?
• Availability of food
• Chronicity/temporality (except USDA – within year)
• Dietary intake, dietary quality, nutriDonal status, malnutriDon
• Social exclusion from social ways of eaDng, cultural food pracDces
• Acceptability: sources of food & feelings about sources of food; ability
to follow preferred diet
29. Why measure & monitor household food
insecurity using an available measure?
• Secure access to basic, sufficient food a
human right.
• Food insecurity is one dimension of poverty
that has disDnct consequences for health and
well-being.
• Tools validated, well-accepted measures of
problem of insecure food access.
• To understand magnitude & vulnerability in
populaDon (move beyond reliance on food
bank usage data).
• To understand consequences.
• To understand policy-drivers and tailor
intervenDons.
• UDlity for advocacy
31. Building momentum
• Fill in the template, include a web link and/or contact details
How are you involved in studying food insecurity in the UK?
• Take it to the ‘building momentum’ table
• AcDviDes will be grouped
• An electronic version will be circulated following the event