@GRIAusConf_Linking Sustainability Data To Value - Maria Balatbat
1. Linking Sustainability
Data To Value
Chair: Eszter Vitorino Füleky, Network Relations Manager,
Global Reporting Initiative
Dr Maria Balabat, Senior Lecturer, University of New South Wales
Annabelle Bennett, Account Director, Trucost
Dr Lara Jefferson, Manager, Environment and Approvals, Crosslands
Resources Limited co-presenting with
Kylie Ashenbrenner, Principal Consultant Strategic Projects at ERM
2. Australian School of Business
Linking Sustainability Data to Value
Dr Maria Balatbat
3. Sustainability defined
“…development which meets the needs of the present without
compromising the future generations to meet their own needs”
(Brundtland Report, 1987)
“Corporate sustainability is a business approach to create long-
term shareholder value by embracing opportunities and
managing risks deriving from economic, environmental and
social developments.” (Dow Jones Sustainability Indices)
Many companies get caught up with Triple Bottom Line
Reporting. Although transparency is an important aspect of
sustainability, embedding the concepts internally to add
shareholder value is the most imporatant issue (The Mays
Report, 2003).
4.
5. Business Case for embedding and accounting
sustainability and climate changes
Winning and retaining customers
• Competitive advantage, innovation and new products
• Attracting, motivating and retaining staff
• Managing risk and opportunity
• Driving operational efficiencies and cost reduction
• Maintaining licence to operate
• Accessing capital
• Reputation and brand
Source: adapted from the Prince's Accounting for Sustainability
Project (2007)
6. Sustainability ‘accounting’ and
disclosure frameworks
Principles
• – United Nations Global Compact (UNGC)
• – United Nations Principles for
Responsible Investment (UNPRI)
Accounting and disclosure frameworks
• – Corporate Responsibility Index (CRI)
• – Global Reporting Initiative (GRI)
• – Accounting for sustainability (A4S)
• – International Integrated Reporting
Committee (IIRC)
• – Carbon Disclosure Project (CDP)
• – Good Business Register (GBR)
7. Sustainability ‘accounting’ and
disclosure frameworks
Standards and regulations
– Greenhouse Gas Protocol
– National Greenhouse Energy
Reporting Scheme (NGERs)
– ISO 26000 – Social Responsibility
– ISO 14001 – Environmental
management systems
– ISO 14064 – Climate change
– OHS 18001 – Occupational, health
and safety
– AA1000 Series – Accountability and
assurance
8. Current Research
Siew, Balatbat and Carmichael, 2012 “Influence of ESG
Scores on Firm Performance: Australian Evidence”,
Working Paper
- This research is partly funded by CPA Australia
- Top 300 ASX listed firms in 11 industry sectors
- Evaluated and Obtained ESG Scores of firms using the
database provided by CAER, Australian provider of
EIRIS
- Use best of sector methodology to examine correlation
between ESG scores and firm performance (financial,
share market and analysts forrecasts)
9. Current initiatives in SRI
• United Nations Principles for Responsible Investment
(UNPRI)
• Carbon Disclosure Project (CDP)
• ESG Research Australia
• Investor Group on Climate Change
• Responsible Investment Association Australasia
• Reporting schemes using data from sustainability reports
and other engagement by specialised analysts (e.g.
Bloomberg, Thomson Reuters, RiskMetrics)
Indices
– Dow Jones Sustainability Indexes (DJSI)
– KLD/FTSE4Good
– MCSI ESG Indices
Notes de l'éditeur
While there is a consensus that sustainability is now a mainstream issue, it is not always well defined in such a way that the information provided assist investors in decision making. For example the definition of sustainability in the Brundtland Report 1987. From a business and investor perspective the definition of corporate sustainability is most relevant as defined by the DJSI. Socially responsible investing ( SRI ), also known as sustainable, socially conscious, green or ethical investing, is any investment strategy which seeks to consider both financial return and social good . In general, socially responsible investors encourage corporate practices that promote environmental stewardship , consumer protection , human rights , and diversity . Some avoid businesses involved in alcohol , tobacco , gambling , pornography , weapons , and/or the military . The areas of concern recognized by the SRI industry can be summarized as environment, social justice , and corporate governance -- as in environmental social governance (ESG) issues. In addition to stock ownership either directly or through mutual funds, other key aspects of SRI include shareholder advocacy and community investing. The term "socially responsible investing" sometimes narrowly refers to practices that seek to avoid harm by screening companies included in an investment portfolio. [1] However, the term is also used more broadly to include more proactive practices such as impact investing , shareholder advocacy and community investing . [2] Amy Domini , a prominent member of the socially responsible investing community and the founder of Domini Social Investments, has stated that shareholder advocacy and community investing are pillars of socially responsible investing and that doing only negative screening is "not what I would consider adequate." [3]
There is a growing interest in socially responsible investing ( SRI ), also known as sustainable, socially conscious, green or ethical investing, is any investment strategy which seeks to consider both financial return and social good . In general, socially responsible investors encourage corporate practices that promote environmental stewardship , consumer protection , human rights , and diversity . Some avoid businesses involved in alcohol , tobacco , gambling , pornography , weapons, and/or the military. The areas of concern recognized by the SRI industry can be summarized as environment, social justice, and corporate governance -- as in environmental social governance (ESG) issues. In addition to stock ownership either directly or through mutual funds, other key aspects of SRI include shareholder advocacy and community investing. The term "socially responsible investing" sometimes narrowly refers to practices that seek to avoid harm by screening companies included in an investment portfolio. [1] However, the term is also used more broadly to include more proactive practices such as impact investing, shareholder advocacy and community investing. [2] Amy Domini, a prominent member of the socially responsible investing community and the founder of Domini Social Investments, has stated that shareholder advocacy and community investing are pillars of socially responsible investing and that doing only negative screening is "not what I would consider adequate." [3] The areas of concern recognised by socially responsible and ethical investors include: environment, social justice, and corporate governance – or better know as environmental social governance (ESG) issues. Socially responsible investing also refers to practices that seek to avoid harm by screening companies included in an investment portfolio (whether it is fund manager or a business decision maker for an organisation) For example: negative screening of investments, evaluating ESG performance and making investment decisions on the basis of high ESG scores, or simply making capital investment decision
Responsible investment screening Best of sector Thematic investment Impact investing ESG integration Engagement with companies on ESG issues Shareholder activism In the conventional investment process, screening is used to reduce the investible universe based on preferred financial criteria such as leverage metrics and valuation ratios. In the case of responsible investment, however, screening also includes environmental, social, governance (ESG) and ethical factors as well as financial criteria. Responsible investment screening is used in many ways: it can be applied to select investments based upon relative performance on specific issues (such as carbon emission benchmarks or governance standards) or to exclude entire sectors or activities (such as gambling or those who abuse human rights); it can be used for equities as well as property, fixed income and infrastructure; it can be employed either before or after the financial analysis has taken place; and it is usually supported by a pre-determined methodology that is clearly defined and transparent. The competitive performance of screened investments depends on both the screening methodology and the final portfolio construction which seeks to minimise correlation and volatility and maximise diversification and risk-adjusted return potential. Negative screening is the term used to describe the exclusion or avoidance of an investment based upon environmental, social, governance or ethical factors, while positive screening is the favourable consideration of an investment opportunity based upon these issues.