This document analyzes acknowledgment patterns in English and Lithuanian research writing. It finds that British scholars place more importance on acknowledgments by making them longer separate sections and expressing gratitude to more individuals than Lithuanian scholars. The study analyzed acknowledgments from scientific books and PhD theses in the humanities. It found that acknowledgments were longer and more common in separate sections for British books, but less common in Lithuanian theses, which tend to express gratitude orally instead of in writing. Cultural differences and traditions seem to influence acknowledgment practices between the two countries.
Academic Literacies A Critical Lens On Writing And Reading In The AcademyJeff Nelson
This document provides an overview of the field of Academic Literacies, which explores academic reading and writing as social practices. It emerged in the 1990s in response to increasing student diversity in higher education. Academic Literacies views academic literacy practices as situated within institutional structures and power relations rather than as autonomous, transferable skills. It combines empirical study of academic conventions with a critical perspective on making these practices more equitable. The document discusses the historical context and key theoretical influences, and examines connections and divergences between Academic Literacies and English for Academic Purposes.
A Student’s Guide to Reading and Writing in Social AnthropologyUkrit Chalermsan
This document provides guidance for students on reading and writing in social anthropology. It begins by explaining that the writing practices and conventions of anthropologists may not be transparent to newcomers. It then discusses different types of anthropological literature students may encounter, including essays, ethnographies, and theoretical chapters/articles. The document aims to demystify challenges students may face and help them engage effectively with anthropological texts.
An Investigation Of Generic Structures Of Pakistani Doctoral Thesis Acknowled...Ashley Smith
This document summarizes previous research on the genre of acknowledgements sections in doctoral theses and discusses a study investigating the generic structures of acknowledgement sections in Pakistani theses. It reviews literature showing that acknowledgements have traditionally been a neglected genre but are important for expressing gratitude. The study analyzed 235 acknowledgements from Pakistani theses using genre analysis methods to identify seven moves and sub-units that reflect socio-cultural norms in Pakistani acknowledgement writing. Previous models of acknowledgement structure from other contexts did not fully capture patterns in Pakistani texts.
An Overview Of Research On Turkish Language Education A Bibliometry StudyEmily Smith
This document summarizes a bibliometric study that analyzed 128 published studies on Turkish language education indexed in the Web of Science database. The study examined topics, countries/institutions, authors, languages, and keywords of the publications. Key findings were that studies on Turkish language education have increased in the last 10 years but are still insufficient. Previous bibliometric studies on teaching Turkish as a foreign language were also summarized, which cataloged resources by historical works, books, articles, theses, and proceedings.
Relating Research and Practice in Information LiteracySheila Webber
Panel by Sheila Webber (University of Sheffield), Ola Pilerot (University of Borås), Louise Limberg (University of Borås), Bill Johnston (Strathclyde University) presented at the European Conference on Information Literacy, Dubrovnik, October 2014.
A Review On Critical Discourse AnalysisLisa Garcia
This document provides a review of critical discourse analysis (CDA). It discusses the origins and development of CDA over the past few decades. CDA aims to reveal the relationships between language, ideology, and power. The review covers early studies in the 1970s-1980s that helped establish CDA. It then discusses prominent scholars and different analytical approaches that emerged in the 1980s-1990s, including those developed by Fairclough, Wodak, van Dijk, and others. The review aims to help readers understand the evolution of CDA and promote further academic research in this area.
This document is the introduction to Teresa Mastalerz's diploma thesis on incorporating elements of British culture into teaching English to secondary school students in Poland. It provides sample lesson plans on selected British saints.
The introduction summarizes the theoretical background covered in the first three chapters on the concept of culture, the relationship between culture and language, and incorporating culture into English language teaching. It then justifies the choice of focusing on British patron saints in the sample lesson plans. The plans aim to find similarities between cultures and stimulate further learning.
The introduction concludes by stating that the lesson plans follow the concept that culture is an inherent part of teaching a foreign language and that learning culture and language should be integrated.
Indigenous Standpoint Theory ^0 Decolonizing Methodologies 3-2024 3.pdfbonduran1
Indigenous Standpoint Theory and decolonizing methodologies are discussed in several documents. Key points:
1) A study uses an Indigenous worldview and decolonizing methodology to develop a culturally appropriate framework for assessing climate resilience of Indigenous communities.
2) Content analysis of role models selected by Indigenous youth found they tend to choose those matching their gender and other Indigenous people or people of color, such as mothers and Indigenous sportsmen.
3) Reflecting on positionality is important for sensitive research involving inequalities and power dynamics, such as with refugees, to navigate relations and explore overlooked elements.
Academic Literacies A Critical Lens On Writing And Reading In The AcademyJeff Nelson
This document provides an overview of the field of Academic Literacies, which explores academic reading and writing as social practices. It emerged in the 1990s in response to increasing student diversity in higher education. Academic Literacies views academic literacy practices as situated within institutional structures and power relations rather than as autonomous, transferable skills. It combines empirical study of academic conventions with a critical perspective on making these practices more equitable. The document discusses the historical context and key theoretical influences, and examines connections and divergences between Academic Literacies and English for Academic Purposes.
A Student’s Guide to Reading and Writing in Social AnthropologyUkrit Chalermsan
This document provides guidance for students on reading and writing in social anthropology. It begins by explaining that the writing practices and conventions of anthropologists may not be transparent to newcomers. It then discusses different types of anthropological literature students may encounter, including essays, ethnographies, and theoretical chapters/articles. The document aims to demystify challenges students may face and help them engage effectively with anthropological texts.
An Investigation Of Generic Structures Of Pakistani Doctoral Thesis Acknowled...Ashley Smith
This document summarizes previous research on the genre of acknowledgements sections in doctoral theses and discusses a study investigating the generic structures of acknowledgement sections in Pakistani theses. It reviews literature showing that acknowledgements have traditionally been a neglected genre but are important for expressing gratitude. The study analyzed 235 acknowledgements from Pakistani theses using genre analysis methods to identify seven moves and sub-units that reflect socio-cultural norms in Pakistani acknowledgement writing. Previous models of acknowledgement structure from other contexts did not fully capture patterns in Pakistani texts.
An Overview Of Research On Turkish Language Education A Bibliometry StudyEmily Smith
This document summarizes a bibliometric study that analyzed 128 published studies on Turkish language education indexed in the Web of Science database. The study examined topics, countries/institutions, authors, languages, and keywords of the publications. Key findings were that studies on Turkish language education have increased in the last 10 years but are still insufficient. Previous bibliometric studies on teaching Turkish as a foreign language were also summarized, which cataloged resources by historical works, books, articles, theses, and proceedings.
Relating Research and Practice in Information LiteracySheila Webber
Panel by Sheila Webber (University of Sheffield), Ola Pilerot (University of Borås), Louise Limberg (University of Borås), Bill Johnston (Strathclyde University) presented at the European Conference on Information Literacy, Dubrovnik, October 2014.
A Review On Critical Discourse AnalysisLisa Garcia
This document provides a review of critical discourse analysis (CDA). It discusses the origins and development of CDA over the past few decades. CDA aims to reveal the relationships between language, ideology, and power. The review covers early studies in the 1970s-1980s that helped establish CDA. It then discusses prominent scholars and different analytical approaches that emerged in the 1980s-1990s, including those developed by Fairclough, Wodak, van Dijk, and others. The review aims to help readers understand the evolution of CDA and promote further academic research in this area.
This document is the introduction to Teresa Mastalerz's diploma thesis on incorporating elements of British culture into teaching English to secondary school students in Poland. It provides sample lesson plans on selected British saints.
The introduction summarizes the theoretical background covered in the first three chapters on the concept of culture, the relationship between culture and language, and incorporating culture into English language teaching. It then justifies the choice of focusing on British patron saints in the sample lesson plans. The plans aim to find similarities between cultures and stimulate further learning.
The introduction concludes by stating that the lesson plans follow the concept that culture is an inherent part of teaching a foreign language and that learning culture and language should be integrated.
Indigenous Standpoint Theory ^0 Decolonizing Methodologies 3-2024 3.pdfbonduran1
Indigenous Standpoint Theory and decolonizing methodologies are discussed in several documents. Key points:
1) A study uses an Indigenous worldview and decolonizing methodology to develop a culturally appropriate framework for assessing climate resilience of Indigenous communities.
2) Content analysis of role models selected by Indigenous youth found they tend to choose those matching their gender and other Indigenous people or people of color, such as mothers and Indigenous sportsmen.
3) Reflecting on positionality is important for sensitive research involving inequalities and power dynamics, such as with refugees, to navigate relations and explore overlooked elements.
Synchronic Diachronic Aspect of Lexic Semantic and Functional Features of Sci...YogeshIJTSRD
The article provides general information about the synchronous diachronic aspect of the lexical semantic and functional features of the English scientific pedagogical text. The article shows that diachronic linguistics studies language change, and synchronic linguistics studies language states without their history. At the same time, the impact of the development of science on various areas of education, innovations in various areas of the English language will be discussed. Sharipova Mekhriniso Shavkatovna "Synchronic-Diachronic Aspect of Lexic-Semantic and Functional Features of Scientific-Pedagogical Text of English" Published in International Journal of Trend in Scientific Research and Development (ijtsrd), ISSN: 2456-6470, Special Issue | Innovative Development of Modern Research , April 2021, URL: https://www.ijtsrd.com/papers/ijtsrd39851.pdf Paper URL : https://www.ijtsrd.com/humanities-and-the-arts/english/39851/synchronicdiachronic-aspect-of-lexicsemantic-and-functional-features-of-scientificpedagogical-text-of-english/sharipova-mekhriniso-shavkatovna
The document discusses the concept of 'wedding' in the English language from a linguocultural perspective. It begins by outlining the aim, objectives, and significance of studying this concept. It then provides theoretical background on cognitive linguistics and linguoculturology. Next, it examines the interrelations between linguoculturology and cognitive linguistics. Finally, it analyzes the concept of 'wedding' in English and Uzbek, comparing lexical units, phrases, and cultural traditions associated with weddings in both languages. The document takes a linguocultural approach to understanding how the concept of 'wedding' is expressed and interpreted among English speakers.
Final paper textual analysis elizabeth narváez cardonaenarvaez2009
1) This document analyzes scientific articles about academic writing in Colombian higher education to map the academic discourse community in this field. Textual analysis of introductions and conclusions identifies research agendas and involved stakeholders.
2) After 2006, the discourse shifted from advocating for freshman writing courses to advocating for teaching writing across higher education.
3) The field of academic writing in Colombian higher education is emerging. Future research agendas include applying findings to institutional practices and exploring international debates to further develop the field.
This document outlines the agenda for a symposium on researching multilingually. It discusses key issues such as negotiating meanings across languages and cultures, the role of interpreters, challenges of representation and translation, and assumptions made in mainstream research methods texts. Specific examples are provided, including a 1946 study by David Boder who conducted Holocaust survivor interviews in 9 languages, and issues of power dynamics, reflexivity and ethics in multilingual research. The document maps how different disciplines approach and represent multilingual research and provides guidance for newcomers to the field from research methods textbooks.
An Analysis Of Dissertation Abstracts In Terms Of Translation Errors And Acad...Karla Adamson
This study analyzes English abstracts of Turkish MA and PhD dissertations to identify translation errors and issues with academic style and discourse. The study examines 90 dissertation abstracts from both Turkish and English-speaking researchers. The findings show that Turkish researchers rely on their translation skills in writing English abstracts, which can lead to errors. However, the analysis of rhetorical moves in the abstracts did not reveal large differences, suggesting universally accepted structures in dissertation abstracts. The study aims to evaluate how effectively Turkish researchers communicate their knowledge in English in terms of language competence and adherence to academic discourse conventions.
Academic Communication Writing Research Papers As A Culturally Conditioned A...Sarah Adams
This document summarizes research on differences in academic writing styles across cultures. It discusses how Robert Kaplan initiated the field of contrastive rhetoric by arguing that logical structures and paragraph organization reflect cultural influences. Later studies found that languages like Italian, Spanish, German, and Russian employ more digressive structures than the linear style preferred in English. Cultural traditions shape conventions like stating main ideas, using pronouns, and expressing opinions. Understanding these differences helps explain challenges non-native English speakers face publishing research globally in English.
A Schematic And Linguistic Analysis Of The Literature Review Section Of MPhil...Lori Moore
This document provides a literature review and analysis of literature review sections in MPhil research proposals in English. It begins with an introduction outlining the purpose and methodology. Three moves were identified in the literature review sections: 1) Introducing history, theories and concepts, 2) Reviewing related studies, and 3) Indicating a gap in existing literature. Each move contains defined steps. The analysis found these moves were present in the proposals and generally arranged sequentially. Additionally, attitude markers were analyzed to determine if proposals evaluated literature, finding 25% used these markers while most just summarized studies. This confirms assertions that novice writers often do not critically assess literature.
The document discusses the concept of World Englishes and its development over time. It covers several key topics:
- Kachru's model of concentric circles that categorizes varieties of English into Inner Circle, Outer Circle, and Expanding Circle.
- The stratification of English and how its functions have been studied in various interactional contexts across circles.
- Issues around bilingual creativity in English literatures from places in contact with English. This has resulted in multicanons and a shift in the traditional English canon.
- Sociolinguistic factors like nativization and Englishization that have shaped the development of English varieties worldwide.
- Pedagogical reasons for teaching
Diversity and Citizenship in the Curriculum: Research ReviewPeachy Essay
In May 2006 the Department for Education and Skills (DfES) established the Diversity and Citizenship Curriculum Review Group, headed by Keith Ajegbo, former Headteacher of Deptford Green Secondary School, Lewisham. To aid the team, the DfES
commissioned a research project, based on a literature review and case study research. The study was conducted between June to November 2006.
Assessing Student Theses Differences And Similarities Between Examiners Fro...Jim Jimenez
Examiners from different academic disciplines may assess student theses differently due to variations in disciplinary traditions and views of knowledge. Previous research has found both similarities and differences in assessment criteria depending on examiner background. This study aims to investigate whether examiners from different subject areas (e.g. pedagogy, science, social science) emphasize similar or different criteria when assessing student teacher theses in Sweden. An online survey asked 66 examiners from six universities to compare and rank 45 assessment criteria. The results showed minor differences between disciplines, with only 2 of the 45 criteria showing significant differences. This indicates teacher education uses primarily generic assessment standards regardless of examiner background.
An Exploratory Study On Authorial (In)Visibilty Across Postgraduate Academic ...Sabrina Ball
This document summarizes a research study that analyzed how postgraduate students from Turkey, Britain, and Turkish students writing in English establish their authorial presence in discussion sections of dissertations. The study analyzed 90 dissertations total from the three groups, looking at both explicit mentions using first-person pronouns and implicit mentions using passive voice and impersonal constructions. The quantitative analysis found that Turkish students and Turkish students writing in English preferred implicit mentions to create a more impersonal impression, while British students used more explicit mentions for a more self-prominent academic prose. The qualitative analysis provided some evidence that all three groups used explicit and implicit mentions to accomplish common discourse functions in discussion sections.
“Coming clean” about researching multilingually – learning from different dis...RMBorders
Andrews, J. (University of the West of England), Fay, R. (University of Manchester), Holmes, P. and Attia, M. (both Durham University), “Coming clean” about researching multilingually – learning from different disciplines. Paper presented at the 2nd AHRC Researching Multilingually at the Borders of Language, the Body, Law and the State Symposium, 15th – 17th October 2014, Durham University.
The document discusses ideologies that are promoted in imported English textbooks used in Colombia. It finds that textbooks commonly depict American and British cultures positively and reinforce the hegemony of English through portraying English speakers, cultures, and customs as superior. Textbooks also contain elements of sexism, stereotyping of other cultures, and an emphasis on consumerism. While teachers are generally aware of these ideologies, they do not always explicitly discuss them with students. Making students aware of the ideological aspects of language learning is important to avoid undue cultural influence.
English academic writing for students and researchers by yakhontova t.vsupra_uny
This document provides an introduction to a textbook on English academic writing for students and researchers in Ukraine. The goal of the textbook is to familiarize learners with the key features of rhetoric, style and genre organization in English academic discourse. It aims to develop skills in constructing and writing academic texts in English across various genres. The textbook also seeks to help learners develop strategies for mastering academic writing as a complex skill with social, cognitive and linguistic aspects. The intended audience includes graduate students and researchers who want to independently learn the basics of English academic communication. The theoretical basis draws on the concept of genre as both a social-communicative phenomenon and a text type with relatively stable compositional and linguistic characteristics. Accordingly, the textbook examines the
Anthropological Theory Of Culture Research ReportRenee Lewis
The document presents an expanded report on research into the anthropological theory of culture. Specifically, it analyzes the seminal 1952 work "Culture: A Critical Review of Concepts and Definitions" by Alfred Kroeber and Clyde Kluckhohn. The research had three main goals: [1] Develop archival materials on Kluckhohn to understand the ideological design of the classification system. [2] Correct inaccuracies in the Polish literature regarding Kroeber and Kluckhohn's classification. [3] Elaborate the classification system to make it more functional for further development. The research aims to advance the metatheoretical understanding of culture and facilitate the development of axiomatics in cultural studies.
A GENRE ANALYSIS ON THE DISCUSSION SECTION OF QUANTITATIVE AND QUALITATIVE RE...Jeff Nelson
This document discusses a study that analyzed the discussion sections of quantitative and qualitative research articles in English language teaching and linguistics. The study aimed to investigate the moves and steps in the discussion sections, as well as the rhetorical structure patterns. It analyzed 20 qualitative and 20 quantitative research articles using Yang and Allison's framework. The study found that all moves from the framework were present in both types of articles, though the frequency differed. It also found two main patterns - repetitive and organized - though there was some variation within each. The study provides evidence on the generic structure of discussion sections and insights for move analysis in this field.
Study on book purchasing reading behaviorJuliane Ritt
This document summarizes findings from a survey of over 2,000 academic staff members from six UK universities about their article and book reading patterns. Some key findings include:
1) Academics read an average of 22 scholarly articles per month, or around 267 articles per year. Medical/health academics read the most at 30 articles per month on average.
2) Three-quarters of article readings are for research and writing purposes. 38% of readings were rated as very important or essential to the reader's main purpose.
3) Time spent reading articles varies by discipline, from 41 minutes for medical academics to 72 minutes for engineering academics.
4) While books remain important for teaching and research, especially in
Academic Culture - Students And Culture ShockShannon Green
This document discusses academic culture shock that students experience when entering university. It notes that each academic discipline has its own culture, norms, and discourse practices that students must learn. This can be challenging for students from a different linguistic or cultural background. The document identifies several factors that contribute to culture shock for non-native English speaking students, including differences in rhetorical styles across languages and genres, varying writing assignments across disciplines, and discipline-specific vocabulary, citation practices, and levels of hedging. Overall, the document examines how moving into an academic community requires students to adapt to a new cultural and linguistic context.
The document discusses the nature of science (NOS). It defines NOS as the epistemology and sociology of science, how science understands the natural world, and how values and beliefs influence scientific knowledge. It also discusses NOS as having ten key aspects. The document emphasizes that teachers have an inadequate understanding of NOS. It analyzes the representation of NOS in three South African science textbooks and finds little representation. It recommends improving teacher understanding of NOS through professional development and analyzing textbooks to find opportunities to teach NOS.
This document provides a summary of the book "Studying British Cultures: An Introduction" which presents an overview of British Cultural Studies through a collection of essays by experts in the field. The book takes an interdisciplinary approach and is divided into two sections - the first deals with general aspects of cultural studies and its relationship to education, while the second examines specific aspects of Scottish, Welsh, Irish and West Indian cultures. It provides cultural context needed to understand literature and encourages comparative analysis between cultures.
How To Write A Progress Report For A ProjectJoe Andelija
This document provides instructions for writing a progress report for a project. It outlines 5 key steps: 1) Create an account, 2) Complete a request form providing instructions and deadline, 3) Review bids from writers and choose one, 4) Review the paper and authorize payment, 5) Request revisions to ensure satisfaction. The process aims to match clients with qualified writers and provide high-quality, original content through revisions.
Quality Writing Paper. Best Website For Homework Help Services.Joe Andelija
This document discusses the debate between Mac and PC operating systems. It notes that while PCs are more popular due to higher software availability, Macs are actually more durable and useful. PCs have a wider variety of available software since most users own PCs. However, Macs last longer over time with continued software and operating system support. Overall the document argues that Macs provide better value than PCs despite their higher initial cost.
Contenu connexe
Similaire à Acknowledgment Patterns In English And Lithuanian Research Writing
Synchronic Diachronic Aspect of Lexic Semantic and Functional Features of Sci...YogeshIJTSRD
The article provides general information about the synchronous diachronic aspect of the lexical semantic and functional features of the English scientific pedagogical text. The article shows that diachronic linguistics studies language change, and synchronic linguistics studies language states without their history. At the same time, the impact of the development of science on various areas of education, innovations in various areas of the English language will be discussed. Sharipova Mekhriniso Shavkatovna "Synchronic-Diachronic Aspect of Lexic-Semantic and Functional Features of Scientific-Pedagogical Text of English" Published in International Journal of Trend in Scientific Research and Development (ijtsrd), ISSN: 2456-6470, Special Issue | Innovative Development of Modern Research , April 2021, URL: https://www.ijtsrd.com/papers/ijtsrd39851.pdf Paper URL : https://www.ijtsrd.com/humanities-and-the-arts/english/39851/synchronicdiachronic-aspect-of-lexicsemantic-and-functional-features-of-scientificpedagogical-text-of-english/sharipova-mekhriniso-shavkatovna
The document discusses the concept of 'wedding' in the English language from a linguocultural perspective. It begins by outlining the aim, objectives, and significance of studying this concept. It then provides theoretical background on cognitive linguistics and linguoculturology. Next, it examines the interrelations between linguoculturology and cognitive linguistics. Finally, it analyzes the concept of 'wedding' in English and Uzbek, comparing lexical units, phrases, and cultural traditions associated with weddings in both languages. The document takes a linguocultural approach to understanding how the concept of 'wedding' is expressed and interpreted among English speakers.
Final paper textual analysis elizabeth narváez cardonaenarvaez2009
1) This document analyzes scientific articles about academic writing in Colombian higher education to map the academic discourse community in this field. Textual analysis of introductions and conclusions identifies research agendas and involved stakeholders.
2) After 2006, the discourse shifted from advocating for freshman writing courses to advocating for teaching writing across higher education.
3) The field of academic writing in Colombian higher education is emerging. Future research agendas include applying findings to institutional practices and exploring international debates to further develop the field.
This document outlines the agenda for a symposium on researching multilingually. It discusses key issues such as negotiating meanings across languages and cultures, the role of interpreters, challenges of representation and translation, and assumptions made in mainstream research methods texts. Specific examples are provided, including a 1946 study by David Boder who conducted Holocaust survivor interviews in 9 languages, and issues of power dynamics, reflexivity and ethics in multilingual research. The document maps how different disciplines approach and represent multilingual research and provides guidance for newcomers to the field from research methods textbooks.
An Analysis Of Dissertation Abstracts In Terms Of Translation Errors And Acad...Karla Adamson
This study analyzes English abstracts of Turkish MA and PhD dissertations to identify translation errors and issues with academic style and discourse. The study examines 90 dissertation abstracts from both Turkish and English-speaking researchers. The findings show that Turkish researchers rely on their translation skills in writing English abstracts, which can lead to errors. However, the analysis of rhetorical moves in the abstracts did not reveal large differences, suggesting universally accepted structures in dissertation abstracts. The study aims to evaluate how effectively Turkish researchers communicate their knowledge in English in terms of language competence and adherence to academic discourse conventions.
Academic Communication Writing Research Papers As A Culturally Conditioned A...Sarah Adams
This document summarizes research on differences in academic writing styles across cultures. It discusses how Robert Kaplan initiated the field of contrastive rhetoric by arguing that logical structures and paragraph organization reflect cultural influences. Later studies found that languages like Italian, Spanish, German, and Russian employ more digressive structures than the linear style preferred in English. Cultural traditions shape conventions like stating main ideas, using pronouns, and expressing opinions. Understanding these differences helps explain challenges non-native English speakers face publishing research globally in English.
A Schematic And Linguistic Analysis Of The Literature Review Section Of MPhil...Lori Moore
This document provides a literature review and analysis of literature review sections in MPhil research proposals in English. It begins with an introduction outlining the purpose and methodology. Three moves were identified in the literature review sections: 1) Introducing history, theories and concepts, 2) Reviewing related studies, and 3) Indicating a gap in existing literature. Each move contains defined steps. The analysis found these moves were present in the proposals and generally arranged sequentially. Additionally, attitude markers were analyzed to determine if proposals evaluated literature, finding 25% used these markers while most just summarized studies. This confirms assertions that novice writers often do not critically assess literature.
The document discusses the concept of World Englishes and its development over time. It covers several key topics:
- Kachru's model of concentric circles that categorizes varieties of English into Inner Circle, Outer Circle, and Expanding Circle.
- The stratification of English and how its functions have been studied in various interactional contexts across circles.
- Issues around bilingual creativity in English literatures from places in contact with English. This has resulted in multicanons and a shift in the traditional English canon.
- Sociolinguistic factors like nativization and Englishization that have shaped the development of English varieties worldwide.
- Pedagogical reasons for teaching
Diversity and Citizenship in the Curriculum: Research ReviewPeachy Essay
In May 2006 the Department for Education and Skills (DfES) established the Diversity and Citizenship Curriculum Review Group, headed by Keith Ajegbo, former Headteacher of Deptford Green Secondary School, Lewisham. To aid the team, the DfES
commissioned a research project, based on a literature review and case study research. The study was conducted between June to November 2006.
Assessing Student Theses Differences And Similarities Between Examiners Fro...Jim Jimenez
Examiners from different academic disciplines may assess student theses differently due to variations in disciplinary traditions and views of knowledge. Previous research has found both similarities and differences in assessment criteria depending on examiner background. This study aims to investigate whether examiners from different subject areas (e.g. pedagogy, science, social science) emphasize similar or different criteria when assessing student teacher theses in Sweden. An online survey asked 66 examiners from six universities to compare and rank 45 assessment criteria. The results showed minor differences between disciplines, with only 2 of the 45 criteria showing significant differences. This indicates teacher education uses primarily generic assessment standards regardless of examiner background.
An Exploratory Study On Authorial (In)Visibilty Across Postgraduate Academic ...Sabrina Ball
This document summarizes a research study that analyzed how postgraduate students from Turkey, Britain, and Turkish students writing in English establish their authorial presence in discussion sections of dissertations. The study analyzed 90 dissertations total from the three groups, looking at both explicit mentions using first-person pronouns and implicit mentions using passive voice and impersonal constructions. The quantitative analysis found that Turkish students and Turkish students writing in English preferred implicit mentions to create a more impersonal impression, while British students used more explicit mentions for a more self-prominent academic prose. The qualitative analysis provided some evidence that all three groups used explicit and implicit mentions to accomplish common discourse functions in discussion sections.
“Coming clean” about researching multilingually – learning from different dis...RMBorders
Andrews, J. (University of the West of England), Fay, R. (University of Manchester), Holmes, P. and Attia, M. (both Durham University), “Coming clean” about researching multilingually – learning from different disciplines. Paper presented at the 2nd AHRC Researching Multilingually at the Borders of Language, the Body, Law and the State Symposium, 15th – 17th October 2014, Durham University.
The document discusses ideologies that are promoted in imported English textbooks used in Colombia. It finds that textbooks commonly depict American and British cultures positively and reinforce the hegemony of English through portraying English speakers, cultures, and customs as superior. Textbooks also contain elements of sexism, stereotyping of other cultures, and an emphasis on consumerism. While teachers are generally aware of these ideologies, they do not always explicitly discuss them with students. Making students aware of the ideological aspects of language learning is important to avoid undue cultural influence.
English academic writing for students and researchers by yakhontova t.vsupra_uny
This document provides an introduction to a textbook on English academic writing for students and researchers in Ukraine. The goal of the textbook is to familiarize learners with the key features of rhetoric, style and genre organization in English academic discourse. It aims to develop skills in constructing and writing academic texts in English across various genres. The textbook also seeks to help learners develop strategies for mastering academic writing as a complex skill with social, cognitive and linguistic aspects. The intended audience includes graduate students and researchers who want to independently learn the basics of English academic communication. The theoretical basis draws on the concept of genre as both a social-communicative phenomenon and a text type with relatively stable compositional and linguistic characteristics. Accordingly, the textbook examines the
Anthropological Theory Of Culture Research ReportRenee Lewis
The document presents an expanded report on research into the anthropological theory of culture. Specifically, it analyzes the seminal 1952 work "Culture: A Critical Review of Concepts and Definitions" by Alfred Kroeber and Clyde Kluckhohn. The research had three main goals: [1] Develop archival materials on Kluckhohn to understand the ideological design of the classification system. [2] Correct inaccuracies in the Polish literature regarding Kroeber and Kluckhohn's classification. [3] Elaborate the classification system to make it more functional for further development. The research aims to advance the metatheoretical understanding of culture and facilitate the development of axiomatics in cultural studies.
A GENRE ANALYSIS ON THE DISCUSSION SECTION OF QUANTITATIVE AND QUALITATIVE RE...Jeff Nelson
This document discusses a study that analyzed the discussion sections of quantitative and qualitative research articles in English language teaching and linguistics. The study aimed to investigate the moves and steps in the discussion sections, as well as the rhetorical structure patterns. It analyzed 20 qualitative and 20 quantitative research articles using Yang and Allison's framework. The study found that all moves from the framework were present in both types of articles, though the frequency differed. It also found two main patterns - repetitive and organized - though there was some variation within each. The study provides evidence on the generic structure of discussion sections and insights for move analysis in this field.
Study on book purchasing reading behaviorJuliane Ritt
This document summarizes findings from a survey of over 2,000 academic staff members from six UK universities about their article and book reading patterns. Some key findings include:
1) Academics read an average of 22 scholarly articles per month, or around 267 articles per year. Medical/health academics read the most at 30 articles per month on average.
2) Three-quarters of article readings are for research and writing purposes. 38% of readings were rated as very important or essential to the reader's main purpose.
3) Time spent reading articles varies by discipline, from 41 minutes for medical academics to 72 minutes for engineering academics.
4) While books remain important for teaching and research, especially in
Academic Culture - Students And Culture ShockShannon Green
This document discusses academic culture shock that students experience when entering university. It notes that each academic discipline has its own culture, norms, and discourse practices that students must learn. This can be challenging for students from a different linguistic or cultural background. The document identifies several factors that contribute to culture shock for non-native English speaking students, including differences in rhetorical styles across languages and genres, varying writing assignments across disciplines, and discipline-specific vocabulary, citation practices, and levels of hedging. Overall, the document examines how moving into an academic community requires students to adapt to a new cultural and linguistic context.
The document discusses the nature of science (NOS). It defines NOS as the epistemology and sociology of science, how science understands the natural world, and how values and beliefs influence scientific knowledge. It also discusses NOS as having ten key aspects. The document emphasizes that teachers have an inadequate understanding of NOS. It analyzes the representation of NOS in three South African science textbooks and finds little representation. It recommends improving teacher understanding of NOS through professional development and analyzing textbooks to find opportunities to teach NOS.
This document provides a summary of the book "Studying British Cultures: An Introduction" which presents an overview of British Cultural Studies through a collection of essays by experts in the field. The book takes an interdisciplinary approach and is divided into two sections - the first deals with general aspects of cultural studies and its relationship to education, while the second examines specific aspects of Scottish, Welsh, Irish and West Indian cultures. It provides cultural context needed to understand literature and encourages comparative analysis between cultures.
Similaire à Acknowledgment Patterns In English And Lithuanian Research Writing (20)
How To Write A Progress Report For A ProjectJoe Andelija
This document provides instructions for writing a progress report for a project. It outlines 5 key steps: 1) Create an account, 2) Complete a request form providing instructions and deadline, 3) Review bids from writers and choose one, 4) Review the paper and authorize payment, 5) Request revisions to ensure satisfaction. The process aims to match clients with qualified writers and provide high-quality, original content through revisions.
Quality Writing Paper. Best Website For Homework Help Services.Joe Andelija
This document discusses the debate between Mac and PC operating systems. It notes that while PCs are more popular due to higher software availability, Macs are actually more durable and useful. PCs have a wider variety of available software since most users own PCs. However, Macs last longer over time with continued software and operating system support. Overall the document argues that Macs provide better value than PCs despite their higher initial cost.
The Ultimate Guide To Writing A Brilliant History EJoe Andelija
The document provides instructions for requesting and completing an assignment writing request on the HelpWriting.net website. It outlines a 5-step process: 1) Create an account with an email and password. 2) Complete a form with assignment details, sources, and deadline. 3) Review bids from writers and choose one. 4) Review the completed paper and authorize payment. 5) Request revisions until satisfied. It emphasizes the site's guarantee of original, high-quality work or a full refund.
A Day In The Life Of Miss Kranz Today Is Your Day FrJoe Andelija
The document outlines a 5-step process for requesting assignment writing help from HelpWriting.net, including creating an account, submitting a request form with instructions and deadline, reviewing writer bids and choosing one, placing a deposit to start the work, and authorizing final payment if pleased with the paper after receiving revisions if needed. The service promises original, high-quality content and refunds for plagiarized work, aiming to fully meet customer needs.
Excellent Tips On Research Paper Writing EducationaJoe Andelija
The story follows Caila, a popular 16-year old high school student who becomes pregnant and must deal with the challenges of her new situation. While driving home from school one day, Caila's car is suddenly hijacked by a mysterious man who orders her boyfriend Owen to keep driving. The story sets up a concerning situation for the expecting Caila as her hijacking could put her and her unborn child in danger.
Analysis Of The Poem The Of The. Online assignment writing service.Joe Andelija
1. The document discusses abdominal wounds during the Civil War. Treatment often involved pushing organs back in and suturing the wound. Food was withheld due to risk of contamination from intestinal leakage. Opium was used to slow digestion.
2. It provides an example of Major General Henry Barnum who was shot in the lower abdomen but survived capture before dying of his wounds.
3. Abdominal wounds had a 90% fatality rate while chest wounds were sometimes survivable with wound cleaning and suturing. Complex wounds from bullets were hard to clean and amputation was often used instead.
Example Of Narrative Report For Ojt In RestauJoe Andelija
The document provides instructions for using the HelpWriting.net website to request writing assistance. It outlines a 5-step process: 1) Create an account; 2) Complete an order form with instructions and deadline; 3) Review bids from writers and select one; 4) Review the completed paper and authorize payment; 5) Request revisions until satisfied. It emphasizes the site's commitment to original, high-quality work and full refunds for plagiarized content.
The document discusses fractal image compression and methods for uploading digital images using fractals. It first defines fractals and describes two methods for producing them: the photocopier method and chaos game. It then reviews methods for compressing digital images using fractal image compression and debates the feasibility and utility of employing this technique. A demonstration web application is provided to illustrate the chaos game method for generating fractal iterates.
How To Write A Good, Or Really Bad, Philosophy EsJoe Andelija
The document provides instructions for requesting writing assistance from HelpWriting.net, including creating an account, completing an order form with instructions and deadline, and reviewing writer bids before choosing a writer and placing a deposit to start the assignment. It notes that customers can request revisions until satisfied with the paper and will receive a refund if the paper is plagiarized.
Submit Essays For Money - College Homework Help AJoe Andelija
The document provides instructions for submitting essays for money through an online service. It outlines a 5-step process: 1) Create an account, 2) Complete an order form providing instructions and deadline, 3) Review bids from writers and select one, 4) Review the completed paper and authorize payment, 5) Request revisions until satisfied. The service aims to provide original, high-quality content and offers refunds for plagiarized work.
The Basics Of MLA Style Essay Format, Essay TemplJoe Andelija
The document provides instructions for creating an account and submitting an assignment request on the HelpWriting.net website in 5 steps: register with a password and email, complete an order form with instructions and deadline, review writer bids and choose one to start the assignment, review and approve the completed paper for payment, and request revisions until satisfied with the final product. The website aims to fully meet customer needs through a bidding system and free revisions on original, high-quality content.
The document discusses sexual assault on college campuses, noting that it is a serious issue with 1 in 5 women being sexually assaulted. It references an article about ending college sexual assault and how the victim reacted similarly to many others by not reporting it and falling behind in their studies as their mental state deteriorated. The summary calls attention to the 2011 "Dear Colleague" letter that aimed to address this serious problem affecting students worldwide.
Buy Cheap Essay Writing An Essay For College ApplicatioJoe Andelija
The document discusses Aetna, a major health care company in the US. It provides health care, group insurance, and pension plans. Aetna serves over 28 million individuals through health, dental, pharmacy, vision, and other plans. It relies on employer groups, individuals, students, and other workers. Founded in 1982, Aetna is headquartered in Hartford, Connecticut and offers a variety of medical, insurance, and retirement products and services.
Writing Paper For First Grade - 11 Best Images OfJoe Andelija
The document provides instructions for requesting writing assistance from HelpWriting.net, including creating an account, completing an order form with instructions and deadline, and reviewing bids from writers to select one and place a deposit to start the assignment. It notes the site uses a bidding system and offers free revisions, and stands by providing original, high-quality content or offering a full refund.
Steps In Doing Research Paper , Basic Steps In TheJoe Andelija
The document outlines the basic 5-step process for obtaining writing assistance from HelpWriting.net, including creating an account, submitting a request with instructions and sources, reviewing bids from writers and selecting one, authorizing payment after receiving and approving the paper, and having the option to request revisions. It emphasizes that original, high-quality content is guaranteed and plagiarized work will result in a full refund.
Gingerbread Writing Project The Kindergarten SmorgJoe Andelija
The document provides instructions for creating an account and submitting a paper writing request on the HelpWriting.net website. It outlines a 5-step process: 1) Create an account with a password and email. 2) Complete a 10-minute order form providing instructions, sources, and deadline. 3) Review bids from writers and select one. 4) Review the completed paper and authorize payment if satisfied. 5) Request revisions until fully satisfied, with a refund option for plagiarized work. The purpose is to outline the simple process for students to request paper writing assistance on the site.
Analytical Essay - What Is An Analytical Essay Before YJoe Andelija
Pseudo seizure dogs can detect when a person is about to have a non-epileptic seizure and alert them. The dogs are trained to detect subtle cues in a person's behavior or physiology before a seizure occurs. They can alert the person by nudging or pawing them. This gives the person time to prepare for the seizure or seek help. The dogs' ability to predict seizures is remarkable and shows their strong bond with their owner. Their alerts allow people to gain more independence and feel safer knowing their dog is there to help.
Comparative Essay English (Advanced) - Year 11 HSCJoe Andelija
The document provides instructions for using a writing assistance service called HelpWriting.net. It outlines a 5-step process: 1) Create an account with an email and password. 2) Complete an order form with instructions, sources, and deadline. 3) Review bids from writers and choose one. 4) Review the completed paper and authorize payment. 5) Request revisions until satisfied. The service offers original, plagiarism-free content and guarantees customer satisfaction.
Pay Someone To Write A Letter For Me, Writing A Letter Requesting MJoe Andelija
Here are a few key philosophical problems with perception:
The Problem of Skepticism - How can we be certain that our perceptions accurately represent reality? Our perceptions could be misleading or deceptive. We have no way to directly compare our perceptions to reality itself. This leads to philosophical skepticism about what we can truly know.
The Problem of Qualia - There is a philosophical problem about the nature of subjective, first-person experiences (qualia) like the experience of redness or pain. It is unclear how physical processes in the brain give rise to conscious experiences with subjective qualities. The existence of qualia poses problems for physicalist explanations of the mind.
The Problem of Illusions - Perceptual illusions demonstrate that our
Essay Plan Essay Plan, Essay Writing, Essay WritinJoe Andelija
The document provides a 5-step process for requesting and receiving help with an assignment from HelpWriting.net:
1. Create an account with a password and email.
2. Complete a 10-minute order form with instructions, sources, and deadline.
3. Review bids from writers and choose one based on qualifications.
4. Review the completed paper and authorize payment if satisfied.
5. Request revisions until fully satisfied, with a refund option for plagiarism.
The simplified electron and muon model, Oscillating Spacetime: The Foundation...RitikBhardwaj56
Discover the Simplified Electron and Muon Model: A New Wave-Based Approach to Understanding Particles delves into a groundbreaking theory that presents electrons and muons as rotating soliton waves within oscillating spacetime. Geared towards students, researchers, and science buffs, this book breaks down complex ideas into simple explanations. It covers topics such as electron waves, temporal dynamics, and the implications of this model on particle physics. With clear illustrations and easy-to-follow explanations, readers will gain a new outlook on the universe's fundamental nature.
Exploiting Artificial Intelligence for Empowering Researchers and Faculty, In...Dr. Vinod Kumar Kanvaria
Exploiting Artificial Intelligence for Empowering Researchers and Faculty,
International FDP on Fundamentals of Research in Social Sciences
at Integral University, Lucknow, 06.06.2024
By Dr. Vinod Kumar Kanvaria
This presentation includes basic of PCOS their pathology and treatment and also Ayurveda correlation of PCOS and Ayurvedic line of treatment mentioned in classics.
How to Fix the Import Error in the Odoo 17Celine George
An import error occurs when a program fails to import a module or library, disrupting its execution. In languages like Python, this issue arises when the specified module cannot be found or accessed, hindering the program's functionality. Resolving import errors is crucial for maintaining smooth software operation and uninterrupted development processes.
How to Manage Your Lost Opportunities in Odoo 17 CRMCeline George
Odoo 17 CRM allows us to track why we lose sales opportunities with "Lost Reasons." This helps analyze our sales process and identify areas for improvement. Here's how to configure lost reasons in Odoo 17 CRM
Main Java[All of the Base Concepts}.docxadhitya5119
This is part 1 of my Java Learning Journey. This Contains Custom methods, classes, constructors, packages, multithreading , try- catch block, finally block and more.
This slide is special for master students (MIBS & MIFB) in UUM. Also useful for readers who are interested in the topic of contemporary Islamic banking.
हिंदी वर्णमाला पीपीटी, hindi alphabet PPT presentation, hindi varnamala PPT, Hindi Varnamala pdf, हिंदी स्वर, हिंदी व्यंजन, sikhiye hindi varnmala, dr. mulla adam ali, hindi language and literature, hindi alphabet with drawing, hindi alphabet pdf, hindi varnamala for childrens, hindi language, hindi varnamala practice for kids, https://www.drmullaadamali.com
LAND USE LAND COVER AND NDVI OF MIRZAPUR DISTRICT, UPRAHUL
This Dissertation explores the particular circumstances of Mirzapur, a region located in the
core of India. Mirzapur, with its varied terrains and abundant biodiversity, offers an optimal
environment for investigating the changes in vegetation cover dynamics. Our study utilizes
advanced technologies such as GIS (Geographic Information Systems) and Remote sensing to
analyze the transformations that have taken place over the course of a decade.
The complex relationship between human activities and the environment has been the focus
of extensive research and worry. As the global community grapples with swift urbanization,
population expansion, and economic progress, the effects on natural ecosystems are becoming
more evident. A crucial element of this impact is the alteration of vegetation cover, which plays a
significant role in maintaining the ecological equilibrium of our planet.Land serves as the foundation for all human activities and provides the necessary materials for
these activities. As the most crucial natural resource, its utilization by humans results in different
'Land uses,' which are determined by both human activities and the physical characteristics of the
land.
The utilization of land is impacted by human needs and environmental factors. In countries
like India, rapid population growth and the emphasis on extensive resource exploitation can lead
to significant land degradation, adversely affecting the region's land cover.
Therefore, human intervention has significantly influenced land use patterns over many
centuries, evolving its structure over time and space. In the present era, these changes have
accelerated due to factors such as agriculture and urbanization. Information regarding land use and
cover is essential for various planning and management tasks related to the Earth's surface,
providing crucial environmental data for scientific, resource management, policy purposes, and
diverse human activities.
Accurate understanding of land use and cover is imperative for the development planning
of any area. Consequently, a wide range of professionals, including earth system scientists, land
and water managers, and urban planners, are interested in obtaining data on land use and cover
changes, conversion trends, and other related patterns. The spatial dimensions of land use and
cover support policymakers and scientists in making well-informed decisions, as alterations in
these patterns indicate shifts in economic and social conditions. Monitoring such changes with the
help of Advanced technologies like Remote Sensing and Geographic Information Systems is
crucial for coordinated efforts across different administrative levels. Advanced technologies like
Remote Sensing and Geographic Information Systems
9
Changes in vegetation cover refer to variations in the distribution, composition, and overall
structure of plant communities across different temporal and spatial scales. These changes can
occur natural.
LAND USE LAND COVER AND NDVI OF MIRZAPUR DISTRICT, UP
Acknowledgment Patterns In English And Lithuanian Research Writing
1. DISCOURSE and INTERACTION 11/2/2018
ACKNOWLEDGMENT PATTERNS IN ENGLISH
AND LITHUANIAN RESEARCH WRITING
Jolanta Šinkūnienė and Gabrielė Dudzinskaitė
Abstract
The paper focuses on the features of acknowledgments in scientific texts written by British
and Lithuanian authors in the Humanities. The data comes from a self-compiled corpus
of acknowledgments in scientific books written by British and Lithuanian researchers in
their native languages, and from doctoral dissertations written by Lithuanian doctoral
students in Lithuanian. The results of the quantitative and qualitative analysis suggest that
the British scholars place more importance on acknowledgments as they single out their
thanks as separate sections, make them longer and express gratitude for a larger number
of individuals and institutions than the Lithuanian scholars. Generally the same moves
and steps are employed in the three data sets, but the distribution of some moves and steps
is different.
Keywords
acknowledgments, scientific books, PhD theses, Lithuanian, English
1 Introduction
A growing interest in research writing worldwide has resulted in a number
of studies that reveal not only universal features of academic discourse, but also
trends typical to specific cultures (Duszak 1997, Fløttum et al. 2006, Suomela-
Salmi & Dervin 2009). Differences between the so-called ‘form-oriented’ vs
‘content-oriented’ cultures (Clyne 1987) or ‘reader-responsible’ vs ‘writer-
responsible’ (Hinds 1987) styles of writing point at a different conceptualization
of the reader-writer roles and relationships in different cultures, as well as a
numberofdifferencesinstructuringandpresentingscientificargument.Following
Holliday (1999), Atkinson (2003, 2004) argues that next to the national or ‘big’
culture, the so-called ‘small’ cultures, such as classroom culture or professional-
academic culture, have to be taken into account as well. Numerous cross-
disciplinary studies on academic discourse (Hyland 2005, Hyland & Bondi 2006,
Hyland 2008, inter alia) indeed show that there are certain rhetorical practices
characteristic of one science field, but not typical of the other, thus justifying the
concept of ‘disciplinary culture’ suggested by Mauranen (1993).
Cultural or disciplinary aspects are not the only ones playing an important
role in shaping up academic texts. Textual genres have a significant influence
Discourse and Interaction 11/2/2018, pp. 65-86
ISSN 1802-9930
https://doi.org/10.5817/DI2018-2-65
2. Jolanta Šinkūnienė and Gabrielė dudzinskaitė
66
on the linguistic choices both on macro and micro levels of text construction
as well. Studies on moves and steps in various rhetorical sections of academic
texts, stance and metadiscourse markers in textbooks and research articles or
PhD theses (Hopkins & Dudley-Evans 1988, Swales 2004, Hyland 2005, Hyland
2009), features of conference and research article abstracts (Lorés 2004, Bondi
& Lorés-Sanz 2014, Povolná 2016), show that there are important features of
academic text predetermined by the genre irrespective or alongside culture or
discipline.
While there are many studies on the well established genres, such as research
articles or abstracts, much less attention has been devoted to the genre of
acknowledgments (Hyland 2004). Hyland (2003: 1) argues that even though
acknowledgments with their clear aims and structure are becoming a set genre
in academia, they still constitute the so-called ‘Cinderella’ genre which lacks
greater attention. He foregrounds the importance of this genre, pointing out
a number of insights one can obtain about academic disciplines and cultures,
professional and personal identities, persuasion strategies and hidden influences
by studying acknowledgments (Hyland 2003, Hyland & Tse 2004). For example,
cross-disciplinary comparisons reflect interesting influences of the nature of
the science field on acknowledgments. More individualistic soft fields rely on
cooperation and networking to a smaller extent than hard fields and therefore
have fewer acknowledgments (Cronin et al. 1993, Hyland 2003) as well as rely
on different types of support provided (Diaz-Faes & Bordons 2014).
Research on acknowledgments suggests that there are differences not only in
different science fields, but also in different cultures. Cheng’s (2012) contrastive
study of Master thesis acknowledgments written by Taiwanese and North
American students reveals that Taiwanese students use more explicit and more
complex academic writing strategies than North American students. The study
also shows that Taiwanese students’ acknowledgments are lengthier. Cheng
suggests that Taiwanese students consider acknowledgments to be very formal,
and, therefore, more complex language is thought to be more appropriate. In
his study of Italian and English acknowledgments in research articles, Giannoni
(2002) shows that Italian authors favour impersonal constructions in certain
moves, while English authors employ a wider range and more overt thanking
expressions. Based on 60 English and Lithuanian research articles in four
disciplines, Šinkūnienė’s (2014) study suggests that Lithuanian scholars use very
few acknowledgments in comparison to the English native speakers.
Considerable research has been devoted to acknowledgments in research
articles and MA/PhD theses, however less attention has been paid to
acknowledgments in scientific books, especially from a contrastive perspective.
3. acknowledgment Patterns in english and lithuanian research writing
67
The aim of this study, therefore, is to analyse features of acknowledgments
from cross-linguistic and cross-generic perspectives. The focus of the study is
on the structural patterns of gratitude expression in the acknowledgments in
two different genres (PhD dissertations vs scientific books) and two different
academic cultures (British and Lithuanian).
2 Data and methods
The study is based on a self-compiled corpus of 132 texts of acknowledgments
in two languages and two genres within the field of Humanities. The analysed
acknowledgments come from 100 scientific books written by British and
Lithuanian researchers in their native languages, and from 32 doctoral
dissertations written by Lithuanian doctoral students in Lithuanian. The corpus
was compiled following the guidelines for designing specialised comparable
corpora (Bowker & Pearson 2002, Connor & Moreno 2005).
Only single authored scientific books were selected. The authors of the texts
had to be native speakers of British English and Lithuanian, the work had to be
published between 2007 and 2017, and only one text of each author was selected
for individual sub-corpora. Following Sala (2008), the native speaker status for
the British researchers was determined by searching for the authors’biographical
information on the web. If the author received his/her full education in Britain,
his/her acknowledgments were included into the corpus. The cultural background
of Lithuanian authors was easier to identify by the last name; however, if in
doubt, the author’s biographical information was also checked on the web.
Although the gender of the author was not the focus of the study, an attempt
was still made to balance the corpus for female and male authors to avoid the
potential influence of gender on the results. This was possible for the scientific
books sub-corpus, especially for the British English part which includes
acknowledgments written by 25 female and 25 male authors. The sub-corpus of
scientific books in Lithuanian follows closely with 28 female and 22 male authors.
However, to observe the gender aspect in PhD dissertations was impossible due
to the limitations of the available material, which yielded acknowledgments
written by 28 female and four male authors.
The British English sub-corpus consists of acknowledgments from
50 scientific books in the Humanities collected from one publisher, Cambridge
Scholars Publishing (CSP). CSP (http://www.cambridgescholars.com) is an
independent academic publisher, which publishes scientific work across a range
of disciplines. CSP lists all the published volumes online; in the process of data
collection, scientific books in the Humanities were checked one by one, first
of all to see if they had acknowledgments, and then if the author was a native
4. Jolanta Šinkūnienė and Gabrielė dudzinskaitė
68
British English speaker. If those and the other criteria mentioned above were
met, the acknowledgment was included into the corpus. The sub-corpus features
acknowledgments from Linguistics, Literature, Film and Theatre Studies,
Classics, Cultural Studies, Philosophy, Fine Arts, Music, Archaeology.
The Lithuanian sub-corpus consists of 50 scientific books and 32 doctoral
dissertations written in the Lithuanian language. The data collection for the sub-
corpus of Lithuanian scientific books was not easy because there are far less
academic books published in Lithuanian than in English, and some publishing
houses specialise just in one discipline of the Humanities rather than in many.
As a result, the data for the sub-corpus was collected from twelve different
publishing houses1
. The acknowledgments collected in the sub-corpus are from
such disciplines as History, Literature, Linguistics, Arts, Philosophy. Lithuanian
doctoral dissertations were selected from the webpage of the Research Council
of Lithuania, which chronologically lists all dissertations defended in Lithuania.
The procedure for the selection of acknowledgments from dissertations was
exactly the same as for the British English sub-corpus. A total of 267 doctoral
dissertations in the Humanities satisfying the selection criteria were found, but
only 32 of them (i.e. 12%) contained acknowledgments. This explains a different
number of texts for this sub-corpus. The disciplinary background of the authors
who wrote acknowledgments in their doctoral dissertations was Philology,
Philosophy, Ethnology, History, Theology, Arts, Communication.
During the data collection process we discovered that authors of Lithuanian
scientific books, unlike the British researchers, did not tend to single out their
acknowledgments as a separate section, but predominantly included their
gratitude in the Foreword of the book. The Foreword section typically presents
various aspects related to the book, such as the book background, theoretical
framework, structural parts of the book and their rationale, reference to other
related works, among other things. The section could span from half a page to
many pages in length, therefore for this analysis it was decided to take only
that part of the Foreword, which started with the direct acknowledgment.
The English books and the Lithuanian PhD dissertations contained sections
called Acknowledgments, but these sections sometimes also included some
background information on the book or thesis, so in order to make all three data
sets comparable, only the parts where the actual acknowledgments started were
selected for further analysis.
The size of the corpus used for the study is slightly more than 28,000 words
(Table 1).
5. acknowledgment Patterns in english and lithuanian research writing
69
Sub-corpus Texts Words Mean length (words)
Scientific books in English 50 15,031 300.6
Scientific books in Lithuanian 50 8,387 167.7
Lithuanian doctoral dissertations 32 4,734 147.9
Total 132 28,152 213.3
Table 1: The size and composition of the Acknowledgments corpus
The study employs corpus-based contrastive methodology as well as
quantitative and qualitative analysis. Following Hyland (2004) and Hyland and
Tse (2004), semi-structured interviews were conducted with six researchers from
the Humanities (History, English Philology, Lithuanian Philology). The interview
grid consisted of seven open questions focusing on the interviewees’ views
on the importance of gratitude expression in the academia, acknowledgment
trends dominating in their disciplinary field as well as on their own practices
in acknowledging. As there is a considerable lack of research into Lithuanian
scholars’ practices of acknowledging, only Lithuanian researchers were
interviewed. The interviews were conducted in the Lithuanian language, the cited
fragments of the interviews were translated into English by the authors of the
paper. For the analysis of the structural patterns of acknowledgments Hyland’s
(2004) model of rhetorical Moves and Steps was employed (Section 3.1 presents
the model in more detail).
The examples provided in the paper are coded using EN or LT for the cultural
background of the author, abbreviations SB for scientific books and PhD for
doctoral dissertations, as well as the text number. The coding for the structural
parts uses M for the moves and S for the steps identified.
3 Results and discussion
The results of the study suggest that there is more significance placed on
written acknowledgments in the English academic tradition than in Lithuanian.
This has already become evident in the process of data selection as there was a
difficulty to find acknowledgments as a separate section in Lithuanian scientific
books. The tendency not to devote a separate section for acknowledgments has
also been noted by the interviewees:
In Lithuania there is no tradition to have a separate section for acknowledgments.
Typically, they are provided at the end of the Foreword. (Interviewee 1, History)
6. Jolanta Šinkūnienė and Gabrielė dudzinskaitė
70
So far as doctoral dissertations in Lithuanian are concerned, it was not
possible to collect the sample of texts equivalent to the books sub-corpus
sample as in the time span of ten years only twelve per cent of dissertations
had acknowledgments sections. This is perhaps a surprising finding, as writing
acknowledgments seems to be especially characteristic of PhD work as it “offers
students a unique rhetorical space to both convey their genuine gratitude for
assistance and to promote a capable academic and social identity” (Hyland &
Tse 2004: 259). This is also in a stark contrast with the results of Hyland and Tse
(2004), where 98 per cent of PhD dissertations written by students at Hong Kong
universities had an acknowledgment.
An interesting aspect which was revealed in the process of data collection
was a different trend for Humanities dissertations written by Lithuanian doctoral
students, but in English, not Lithuanian. In the time span selected there were
13 dissertations written in English, and nine of them (69%) contained an
acknowledgments section. It may be that the doctoral students who are exposed
to the English writing traditions more are also influenced by those traditions.
The mean length of acknowledgments in the three sub-corpora confirms
similar trends. Acknowledgments are nearly twice lengthier in the analysed
English scientific books (300.6 words on average) than in the Lithuanian
scientific books and in doctoral dissertations (see Table 1 above). The longest
thanking text in the sub-corpus of doctoral dissertations is 279 words, in the
sub-corpus of scientific books in Lithuanian it amounts to 552 words, whereas
the longest acknowledgments text written by a British researcher is 2,024 words.
These results suggest that the English authors of the analysed texts treat
acknowledgments as an essential part of the research process; their importance
is foregrounded by devoting a special section for them. A very small number
of acknowledgments found in PhD dissertations seems to suggest that novice
Lithuanianresearchersdonothaveatraditiontoincludewrittenacknowledgments
in their theses. It does not mean, however, that Lithuanian doctoral students do
not receive support or are not grateful for it. According to our interviewees, there
is a tradition to express gratitude after the dissertation’s defence orally, especially
since the PhD thesis is considered to be unpublished work:
You think that the PhD thesis will still be defended and you will have an opportunity
to thank orally, because finishing writing your dissertation is not the final point.
If I had written a monograph, I would have included acknowledgments, because
I would not have had an opportunity to express my thanks orally. (Interviewee 3,
Lithuanian Philology)
7. acknowledgment Patterns in english and lithuanian research writing
71
Dissertation is not a book, it does not have an ISBN code, that is why
acknowledgments are expressed orally. When people publish a book based on
the dissertation, then acknowledgments are necessarily there. (Interviewee 1,
History)
A different view, however, is expressed by scholars from English Philology:
It is especially the PhD thesis where it is important to express acknowledgments
properly. Writing a dissertation is a long process, you meet a lot of people in your
academic career and it is natural to want to thank them. You want to express your
gratitude to your supervisor, your family. (Interviewee 5, English Philology)
Interviews with scholars from Lithuanian and English Philology also point
towards diverging tendencies of what is expected from students in terms of
expressing thanks in writing. Researchers who presumably are exposed to the
Lithuanian writing tradition more are not surprised that students do not write
acknowledgments:
I would never allow my students to thank me as a supervisor, because it seems
to me that it is self-evident. It would be very strange to me. (Interviewee 2,
Lithuanian Philology)
However, the interviewees who are used to the English writing tradition treat
acknowledgments as an essential part of academic life. They believe that to
include acknowledgments in any research writing should be a common practice:
Even in BA papers acknowledgments probably should be present <...>. It is a kind
of recognition of the work of the supervisor, it indicates who was leading the work,
who pointed you to a particular direction. (Interviewee 5, English Philology)
I would feel bad if I would not be acknowledged for my help. I don’t like works
that do not have acknowledgments. Acknowledgments should be a required part
of academic genres. (Interviewee 4, English Philology)
In this section very general tendencies were presented. The following sections
will look at the specific moves and patterns of gratitude expression in more detail.
3.1 The generic structure of acknowledgments
Hyland’s (2004) model of the generic structure of acknowledgments
distinguishes three main moves, namely, the Reflecting move where the author
usually gives some comments on his or her research experience, the Thanking
8. Jolanta Šinkūnienė and Gabrielė dudzinskaitė
72
move and the Announcing move, both of which can be broken into smaller steps
(Table 2):
1 Reflecting move
Introspective comments on the writer’s research
experience
2 Thanking move Mapping credit to individuals and institutions
2.1 Presenting participants Introducing those to be thanked
2.2 Thanking for academic
assistance
Thanks for intellectual support, ideas, analyses,
feedback, etc.
2.3 Thanking for resources
Thanks for data access & clerical, technical and financial
support
2.4 Thanking for moral support
Thanks for encouragement, friendship, sympathy,
patience, etc.
3 Announcing move Public statement of responsibility and inspiration
3.1 Accepting responsibility An insertion of authorial responsibility for flaws or errors
3.2 Dedicating the thesis A formal dedication of the thesis to an individual(s)
Table 2: Move structure of dissertation acknowledgments (adapted from Hyland 2004: 308)
As explained in the Data and methods section, due to data compatibility
reasons we had to start the analysis directly from the Thanking move, which
Hyland (2004) considers to be the only obligatory move in the acknowledgments
rhetorical structure. We have also singled out the Announcing move wherever it
was present.
Moves and steps EN books LT books LT dissertations
2 Thanking move 100% 100% 100%
2.1 Presenting participants 64% 50% 41%
2.2 Academic assistance 94% 100% 100%
2.3 Resources 90% 86% 72%
2.4 Moral support 76% 68% 100%
3 Announcing move 58% 34% 6%
9. acknowledgment Patterns in english and lithuanian research writing
73
Moves and steps EN books LT books LT dissertations
3.1 Accepting
responsibility
8% 10% 6%
3.2 Dedication 58% 28% 0
Table 3: The distribution of moves and steps across the sub-corpora (%)
The results in Table 3 show the percentage of the texts in each of the three
sub-corpora that contain at least one particular move or step. We can see that the
Thanking move is the core move of the analysed acknowledgments with every
text including it in the form of one step or several steps. This is hardly surprising
as thanking is the actual purpose of this section. The distribution of the steps in
Move 2, however, reflects different aspects scholars feel grateful for in the two
genres. While thanks for academic assistance dominate in this move in scientific
books in both languages, the doctoral students feel equally grateful for moral
support. Thanking for various resources is included in nearly all scholarly books,
whereas PhD students seem to rely on external resources to a smaller extent.
Hyland’s (2004) disciplinary study of PhD dissertations shows similar trends
with thanking for resources being the least frequent move, and thanking for
academic assistance appearing in 100 per cent of the cases.
Table 3 above shows how many texts in the sample contained one or another
move or step at least once. However, some moves or steps were recurring,
sometimes many times within one text of acknowledgments. The frequency of
the overall occurrence of the three major steps (2.2-2.4) of the Thanking move is
presented in Table 4.
EN books LT books LT dissertations
# raw % # raw % # raw %
Academic assistance 159 31% 172 43% 115 42%
Resources 206 41% 153 39% 45 16%
Moral support 142 28% 71 18% 114 42%
Total 507 100% 396 100% 274 100%
Table 4: The frequency of occurrence of the Thanking move steps 2.2-2.4 in raw numbers and
percentages
10. Jolanta Šinkūnienė and Gabrielė dudzinskaitė
74
We can see that a total of 1,177 cases of occurrences of thanks for academic
assistance, resources and moral support were found in the total of 132 texts.
Nearly half of them are in the English scholarly books with the largest share
devoted to thanks for various types of resources provided. The most frequent
category in the Lithuanian books, thanks for academic assistance, occurred more
than once in each of the acknowledgments, whereas as many as 115 cases of
thanks for academic assistance and 114 of them for moral support were used in
32 PhD texts, making these two the most popular categories of gratitude in the
Thanking move of the PhD sub-corpus.
Going back to Table 3, we can see that the third move (theAnnouncing move)
is less frequent in all three sub-corpora. Claiming responsibility for any flaws
or errors in the English and Lithuanian acknowledgments (Step 3.1) seems to
be equally scarce in all three sub-corpora, whereas the dedication of the work
to someone is much more pronounced in the British acknowledgments, with
Lithuanian PhD work displaying none of this.
The following sections will look at each of the moves in more detail.
3.1.1 The Thanking move
As mentioned before, this is the core move of the acknowledgments genre. It
occurs in all the texts, centering around three main thanking steps for academic
assistance, resources and moral support. There could be several steps included
into one sentence, sometimes of all three types, as in Example 1:
(1) Once again I must thank Arthur Keaveney, who has continued to lend support and
encouragement along the way [M2S4] and, in more practical terms, has helped
proof-read the manuscript [M2S3] and offered much advice on publishing my
work [M2S2]. (EN SB 10)
The Thanking move also contains one rarer step, which prepares the reader
for the coming thanks, i.e. the Presenting participants step, which is discussed in
more detail in the section below.
3.1.1.1Presenting participants step
This step occurred in nearly half of acknowledgments and was slightly more
popular in scientific books. In this step authors frequently confirm that research
writing is a difficult and time consuming process and that it usually requires the
help of other people. In most of the cases, this step occurred in the initial position
of the Thanking move:
(2) I would like to thank the following individuals for their help and support, without
which, this book would not have been accomplished. (EN SB 16)
11. acknowledgment Patterns in english and lithuanian research writing
75
(3) Kaip prie kiekvienos knygos gimimo, ir prie šios prisidėjo gausus ratas žmonių
(palaikytojų, skatintojų, patarėjų, kritikų, bičiulių, draugų, istorikų) <...>.
(LT SB 42)
[Just like in the birth of every book, this book also enjoyed a contribution of
numerous people (supporters, encouragers, advisers, critics, friends, comrades,
historians).]
Hyland (2004) claims that the Presenting participants step is a part of longer,
more complex acknowledgments and this was also confirmed by the data in
our corpus. Since the English acknowledgments were generally longer than the
Lithuanian ones, it explains why this step occurs more frequently in the English
authors’ books (64% vs 50% in LT books vs 41% in LT PhD theses, Table 3).
This step is quite formulaic in character, therefore it is very similarly expressed
in both languages and genres.
3.1.1.2Thanking for academic assistance
Thanking for academic assistance involves gratitude for intellectual ideas,
feedback and criticism, granting approval for publication, assisting with
the analysis, and so on. The high frequency of this step shows that it is very
important to thank those who contributed to the work in one way or the other. It
also suggests that scientific work is never one person’s work, it usually involves
various types of assistance from a number of people:
(4) Visų pirma norėčiau nuoširdžiai padėkoti savo darbo vadovei prof. habil. dr.
Aurelijai Usonienei už pasiūlytą įdomią temą ir vertingas mokslines įžvalgas bei
diskusijas disertacijos tema. (LT PhD 9)
[First of all I would like to sincerely thank the supervisor of my work, Prof. Dr.
habil. Aurelija Usonienė for an interesting suggested topic and for valuable
scientific insights and discussions.]
(5) First, I would like to thank Professor Guido Rings and Dr. Sebastian Rasinger at
Anglia Ruskin University and Dr. Joseph Poulshock at Tokyo Christian University
for their careful readings of my manuscripts and for providing me with valuable
feedback, which enabled me to make the necessary revisions. (EN SB 16)
The difference here perhaps is mainly generic, with the tendency for PhD
students to thank more experienced individuals, higher in academic rank,
typically their supervisors and scientific committee members who reviewed the
manuscript. However, there are also cases when doctoral students offer thanks to
their peers for commenting on the manuscript or for fruitful academic discussions.
In PhD work the first one of the three thanking steps to appear is typically thanks
for academic assistance with 78 per cent of all PhD authors placing it before
12. Jolanta Šinkūnienė and Gabrielė dudzinskaitė
76
thanking for resources or moral support. Even though one could expect the first
person acknowledged in PhD work to be the supervisor, as in Example (4), this
is not always the case, with nine out of 32 PhD theses providing thanks for other
people, typically still from the academic field, but not the supervisors, who
would appear later in the list. These other people would usually be first teachers
or inspirational scholars, who made the students interested in the field.
While most of the scientific book authors tend to thank people equal in status,
there are also cases when the book developed from the PhD thesis, in which case
the acknowledgments resemble those of the PhD students and are devoted to the
supervisors or examiners:
(6) Sincere thanks are also due to my two examiners, Professor Miri Rubin and
Professor Andrew Louth, for their valuable insight and excellent advice.
(EN SB 16)
Though thanking for academic assistance could include a variety of aspects to be
grateful for, the most usual ones in all three sub-corpora are for helpful insights,
feedback and critical comments on the manuscript.
3.1.1.3Thanking for providing resources
This step involves giving thanks for material support provided by individuals
and/or institutions. The support acknowledged here ranges from access to data,
permissions to use copyright materials, proofreading of the text, technical help,
to providing good work conditions and financial assistance. Following Hyland
(2004), types of acknowledged resources were classified into several categories,
such as access to data, financial support, clerical assistance and technical help
(Table 5):
Resource type EN books LT books LT dissertations
# raw % # raw % # raw %
Access to data 111 54% 61 40% 16 36%
Clerical support 22 11% 28 18% 8 18%
Financial support 34 16% 28 18% 11 24%
Technical support 39 19% 36 24% 10 22%
Total 206 100% 153 100% 45 100%
Table 5: The distribution of Thanking for resources categories across the sub-corpora in raw
numbers and percentages
13. acknowledgment Patterns in english and lithuanian research writing
77
The results show that access to data is the type of resources authors in all
three data sets acknowledge most frequently. This category does not only include
thanks for the access to datasets compiled by other people as in (7), but also
access to information, pre-prints, images, permissions to use copyright materials,
photographs, drawings. Here the help of libraries and various other institutions
as well as individuals is greatly appreciated, especially by the British authors:
(7) Taip pat esu dėkinga dr. Ritai Juknevičienei už suteiktą galimybę naudotis jos
sukauptu anglų filologijos pirmo kurso tekstynu <...>. (LT PhD 12)
[I am also grateful to dr. Rita Juknevičienė for the possibility to use her self-
compiled corpus of first year English Philology students [writings].]
(8) The Gye Diaries Trust, courtesy of the Royal Opera House, London, kindly
consented to the use of Frederick Gye’s diaries and travel journals, and Stephen
Agus has permitted the use of unpublished material. (EN SB 24)
(9) I am particularly grateful to Louis Hellman who gave me permission to use a
number of his brilliant cartoons. (EN SB 33)
The second most frequent category acknowledged by the authors of books
is technical assistance. Percentage wise it is the third most frequent category in
PhD work, however, having in mind the generally low frequency of occurrences
of thanking steps in PhD theses, the difference between the technical support
category and the financial support category, which is second in frequency, is just
one occurrence. The technical support is mainly provided by publishing houses
with little difference of thanks expression in the two languages and genres:
(10) Nuoširdūs padėkos žodžiai priklauso ir Lietuvių literatūros ir tautosakos instituto
Leidybos centro vadovui Gyčiui Vaškeliui, kurio pastangomis priešleidybinis
stresas virto maloniu laukimu, kol rankraštus įgis knygos pavidalą. (LT SB 12)
[Sincere words of thanks are also due to Gytis Vaškelis, the head of the Publishing
center at the Institute of Lithuanian literature and folklore, whose efforts turned
the pre-publication stress into pleasant waiting for the manuscript to become a
book.]
(11) The team at Cambridge Scholars Publishing has proved remarkably supportive
and efficient in bringing this book to print. (EN SB 41)
Occasionally this is the category that also involves the help of family
members, especially in the scientific books data set in both languages:
(12) Secondly, [special thanks go to] my youngest son Jason Haines who has given me
invaluable technical support, and assistance in inserting my images. (EN SB 19)
14. Jolanta Šinkūnienė and Gabrielė dudzinskaitė
78
(13) Lygiai taip pat esu dėkingas savo šeimai, o sūnui Mindaugui dar ir už greitąją
kompiuterio darbų pagalbą. (LT SB 15)
[I am equally grateful to my family, and to my son Mindaugas also for the efficient
help with computer work.]
The financial support for which the authors felt grateful included not only
funding and scholarships, but also practical arrangements for which the authors
did not have to pay, for example, accommodation or working space. Particularly
in scientific books thanking for financial support, funding or grants was
frequently quite implicit, with usually only institution mentioned and the direct
act of thanking omitted:
(14) Monografija nebūtų išleista be Vilniaus universiteto Filologijos fakulteto
paramos. (LT SB 3)
[The monograph would not have been published without the support of Vilnius
University Faculty of Philology.]
(15) Financial support was kindly given by the Department of History at the University
of York and the University of Huddersfield’s School of Music, Humanities and
Media. (EN SB 9)
In contrast, there are acknowledgments for the financial support which
include an explicit speech act of thanking, however, these appear less frequently
in the sub-corpora:
(16) Svarbus štrichas kiekvienos knygos pasirodymo istorijoje yra finansavimas, todėl
dėkoju Lietuvos mokslo tarybai, kurios paskirta parama užtikrino sklandžią
knygos leidybą. (LT SB 22)
[An important aspect in the history of every book is financing, therefore I thank
the Research Council of Lithuania, which provided support for the smooth
publication of the book.]
(17) Lastly, I would like to thank the John D. Bies Research Endowment for funding my
research. (EN SB 5)
As explained by the interviewees, such expressions of acknowledgments
as in (14)-(15) could be due to the fact that big national funding agencies are
impersonal and, therefore, the acknowledgment of funding is typically very
formal or simply phrased according to the officially stated requirements:
To me the Research Council is something non-personal, that is why I thank it very
formally. (Interviewee 5, English Philology)
15. acknowledgment Patterns in english and lithuanian research writing
79
If it were a private funding enterprise <...> then it would be necessary to express
thanks explicitly. (Interviewee 1, History)
A more personal thanking statement in (17) exemplifies the idea of
the interviewees that the financial support from private funds is typically
acknowledged in a more personal way.
Finally, clerical support acknowledgments were the least frequent type of
support in all the three sub-corpora. Clerical support was usually provided by
colleagues and administrative workers, and sometimes even family members,
but only in the case of scientific books.
(18) Darbą spartino kolegė Irena Buračaitė. Ji parengė knygos rodykles. (LT SB 7)
[The work was made faster by the colleague Irena Buračaitė. She prepared the
book index.]
(19) Finally, I must thank my wife for her painstaking correction of my numberless
keyboard idiosyncrasies. (EN SB 13)
PhD students did not have many cases of clerical support thanks and these
primarily included acknowledging proofreading services or translating the
summary of the dissertation into English.
3.1.1.4Thanking for moral support
The final step in the Thanking move is more personal, with gratitude here
typically expressed for friendship, encouragement, patience, care or sympathy.
Thanking for moral support occurs in 68 per cent and 76 per cent of Lithuanian
and English scientific book acknowledgments respectively, and it is used in every
PhD thesis acknowledgment making it 100 per cent occurrence. For doctoral
students the PhD thesis is their first big and serious scientific work, it is a journey
of disappointments and discoveries, therefore moral support here plays a crucial
role. Likewise, writing a book is a big commitment in terms of time and energy,
often requiring scholars ‘to steal’ time from their loved ones and devote it to
work. The frequency of the step suggests that for researchers it is important to
express gratitude not only to academic community and colleagues, but also to
the people outside of the academia, who supported them morally, never ceased
to believe in them and thus contributed to their research in different, yet not less
important ways.
(20) Ačiū Rolandui, mano vyrui, tėvams – Danutei ir Juozui, sesei Karolinai ir
ištikimiems bičiuliams, kurie pakeldavo mano dvasią bejėgiškumo ir nevilties
akimirkomis. Be šios pagalbos darbas nebūtų pasiekęs dienos šviesos. (LT PhD 2)
16. Jolanta Šinkūnienė and Gabrielė dudzinskaitė
80
[Thanks to Rolandas, my husband, to my parents, Danutė and Juozas, to my sister
Karolina and faithful friends, who raised my spirits in the moments of helplessness
and despair. Without this help, the work would have not seen the light of the day.]
(21) Finally, the most tremendous gratitude is extended to my longsuffering family: to
John who has endured long weeks as a single parent whilst I indulged both the
need for research and the desire to excavate and to my son Gareth and daughters
Fiona, Bronwyn, and Enya, who have been waiting for Mum to finish writing –
this is for you. (EN SB 38)
(22) Ačiū dukrelėms, kurios kantriai laukė, kol mama parašys ‘savo knygą’. (LT
PhD 28)
[Thanks to my little daughters who have been patiently waiting for Mum to finish
writing ‘her book’.]
Nearly identical Examples (21)-(22), where mothers are thanking their children
for waiting patiently until they complete their writing, show that in the research
world apart from exciting discoveries and scientific victories there are also
universal emotions and feelings authors experience irrespective of language
or culture.
Though thanks for moral support are usually offered for family members
and close friends, they quite frequently include supervisors (in PhD theses) and
colleagues (in scientific books).
3.1.1.5Participants of acknowledgments
Onemoreaspectoftheanalysisfocusedontheparticipantsofacknowledgments,
i.e. individuals and institutions acknowledged by the authors in Steps 2.2-2.4
of the Thanking move. In the whole data set a total of 1,979 individuals were
acknowledged and there were as many as 386 occurrences of thanks to various
groups and 235 instances of acknowledgments to institutions (Table 6).
Participants EN books LT books LT dissertations
# raw % # raw % # raw %
Individuals 917 73% 692 81% 370 77%
Groups 174 14% 106 12% 106 22%
Institutions 168 13% 60 7% 7 1%
Total 1259 100% 858 100% 483 100%
Table 6: The distribution of participants of acknowledgments across the three sub-corpora in
raw numbers and percentages
17. acknowledgment Patterns in english and lithuanian research writing
81
As can be seen in Table 6, the major share of gratitude in the scholarly
work in the Humanities goes to individual people. Individual people feature
in all three Thanking move steps: thanking for academic assistance, resources
and moral support. This category of participants in acknowledgments is also
the most heterogeneous with regard to terms of reference; here participants can
be acknowledged with (1) their full academic title, (2) first name and surname,
(3) first name only, or (4) family name, such as father or husband (Table 7):
Terms of reference EN books LT books LT dissertations
# raw % # raw % # raw %
Academic title + first name and
surname
137 15% 281 41% 166 45%
First name and surname 619 67% 363 52% 134 36%
First name 146 16% 27 4% 46 12%
Family name 15 2% 21 3% 24 7%
Total 917 100% 692 100% 370 100%
Table 7: Terms of reference to individuals in the three sub-corpora in raw numbers and
percentages
The most popular choice in both scientific book sub-corpora is to acknowledge
people by their first name and surname. However, there is a difference between
the level of formality employed in the acknowledgments in the two languages.
The British authors employ the academic title of the individuals they thank to a
much smaller extent than the Lithuanian scholars, and the percentage of people
acknowledged by their first name only is also biggest in the British sub-corpus.
In the PhD sub-corpus most of the individuals acknowledged are thanked using
their full academic title. This is not surprising keeping in mind that PhD students
mostly thank their supervisors, reviewers and senior colleagues. PhD students
also mention their family in the acknowledgments to the highest extent in the
three sub-corpora. The importance to mention family in PhD work is also noted
by our interviewees:
Everyone includes less formal acknowledgments in the dissertations, to the
family members, even to their cat <...>. It is customary to thank closer people
who most probably did not contribute a lot to the academic text, but who helped
you emotionally, made you feel good or assisted in the household chores.
(Interviewee 4, English Philology)
18. Jolanta Šinkūnienė and Gabrielė dudzinskaitė
82
‘Groups’ in Table 6 mean non-personalised references such as, for example,
friends, colleagues, librarians, etc. It is the second most frequent category in
all three sub-corpora. Institutions are acknowledged least frequently in all three
sub-corpora and include academic and non-academic enterprises. Thanks to
institutions go primarily for the financial support in all three data sets, though
occasionally museums, galleries, libraries are also acknowledged for providing
help with the data or permissions to use material.
The basic difference between the sub-corpora again is more in the level of
details and the number of participants acknowledged. The British authors tend
to mention as many individuals and institutions which contributed to the book as
possible, whereas the Lithuanian authors seem to express their gratitude to those
who contributed the most.
3.1.2 The Announcing move
This move was less frequent in the texts of Lithuanian writers and was more
characteristic of the scientific books in both languages than of the doctoral
dissertations acknowledgments. In Hyland’s model (2004), the move includes
two steps: accepting responsibility for the remaining flaws in the work and
dedicating the work to someone.
3.1.2.1Accepting responsibility
Very few texts in all three sub-corpora included this step (four in the books
sub-corpus by British authors, five in the books sub-corpus by Lithuanian authors,
and two in PhD work). This step immediately follows the Thanking move, and
usually is in combination with such boosters as no doubt or savaime suprantama
‘it goes without saying’.
(23) Savaime suprantama, kad už visus knygos trūkumus atsakau tik aš. (LT SB 35)
[It goes without saying that for all the shortcomings of the book I am the only one
responsible.]
(24) In spite of their contributions I have no doubt about the gaps and errors remaining
in this book, for which the fault is mine alone. (EN SB 3)
The authors may be willing to strengthen the claim, so that the reader is in no
doubt about who is responsible for the work and its content.
3.1.2.2Dedicating the work
This step is dominant in the English sub-corpus with more than half of all
books (58%) including it. In the Lithuanian books dedications appeared to a
19. acknowledgment Patterns in english and lithuanian research writing
83
much smaller extent with only 28 per cent of all books including it. In Hyland’s
(2004) data from PhD and MA dissertations this step occurred as the final step
in the acknowledgments, however, in our sub-corpora of scientific books more
dedications were placed at the beginning of the acknowledgments rather than at
the end. When they appeared at the beginning, typically these were short phrases
such as to/for X:
(25) To my parents, Cecilia and Barry. (EN SB 8)
(26) For Michael. (EN SB 15)
(27) Skiriu Erdvilui. (LT SB 37)
[I dedicate [this book] to Erdvilas.]
Placed at the beginning of the acknowledgments text with typically just the
first name of the person(s) for whom the book is dedicated, such brief formulae
create a very personal feel. The same practice of dedicating the book could be
observed in literary works of fiction and should generally be characteristic of a
book genre.
None of the dedications were found in the PhD dissertations, probably because
it is not a completely autonomous work; here considerable help may be provided
by the supervisor which could have restricted the authors from dedicating the
work to the important people in their lives.
4 Concluding remarks
With their coherent structure and clear aims, acknowledgments are an
important part of research writing. They perform a wide range of functions,
not only allowing authors to express their gratitude, but also to take their own
responsibilities for the work. Acknowledgments also provide an opportunity
for the readers to catch a glimpse of a more personal side of the author in the
view of his/her relationship with both academic community members and family
and friends.
The results suggest that the British scholars place more importance on
acknowledgments as they single out their thanks as separate sections, make them
lengthier and express gratitude for far more individuals and institutions than the
Lithuanian scholars. This is especially obvious in the case of Lithuanian doctoral
students, who rarely write acknowledgments in their dissertations. The reason
for this is a general tendency to orally acknowledge individuals or institutions
immediately after the defence. Hyland (2004) suggests that a lack of knowledge
and practice in this particular genre may also influence students’ choices to
20. Jolanta Šinkūnienė and Gabrielė dudzinskaitė
84
include or exclude a written acknowledgment in a thesis. As suggested by some
of our interviewees, students should be taught how to write acknowledgments
just like they are taught how to compose other parts of their scientific papers, or
at least they should be made aware that acknowledging practices exist in writing.
The generic structure analysis shows some differences in the distribution of
moves and steps. Doctoral students tend to be more grateful for moral support than
the established scholars, and they presumably receive less help in various types
of resources as they express less thanks in this category. The authors of the books
in both cultures seem to be quite uniform in thanking moves and steps, the major
difference being the frequency of the Dedication step. The British researchers
tend to be in favour of dedicating the work to somebody, typically a close person.
Both experienced and novice Lithuanian scholars seem to be slightly more formal
in expressing thanks, as a significant part of the acknowledgments’ participants
appear with their full academic titles. In contrast, the British researchers tend to
be less focused on academic ranks when they thank.
Even though there were some differences between genres and cultures, the
most frequent moves of acknowledgments and their formulations seem to be
universal despite the cultural background of writers or the genre, and include
thanking for academic assistance, resources and moral support. The moves and
steps identified were not different from the previous studies (cf. Hyland 2004).
Further work could include studies on acknowledgments written by
Lithuanian scholars in English or in other languages, and in other academic
disciplines, as well as research on acknowledgment practices in other academic
cultures. It would also be interesting to compare acknowledgment patterns in
PhD dissertations written by Lithuanian students with those of the British PhD
students, as such a study would be more comparable in terms of genre.
Acknowledgments
We would like to thank two anonymous reviewers for their detailed and very
useful comments.
Notes
1 Aidai, Akademinė leidykla, Dailės akademinė leidykla, Generolo Jono Žemaičio Lietuvos karo
akademijos leidykla, Lietuvių kalbos institutas, Lietuvių literatūros ir tautosakos institutas,
Mokslo ir enciklopedijos leidybos centras, Mokslo studija, Naujasis lankas, Versus Aureus,
Vilniaus pedagoginis universitetas, Vilniaus universiteto leidykla.
21. acknowledgment Patterns in english and lithuanian research writing
85
References
Atkinson, D. (2003) ‘Writing and culture in the post-process era.’ Journal of Second
Language Writing 12(1), 49-63.
Atkinson, D. (2004) ‘Contrasting rhetorics/contrasting cultures: Why contrastive rhetoric
needs a better conceptualization of culture.’Journal of English for Academic Purposes
3(4), 277-289.
Bondi, M. and Lorés-Sanz, R. (eds) (2014) Abstracts in Academic Discourse: Variation
and Change. Bern: Peter Lang.
Bowker, L. and Pearson, J. (2002) Working with Specialized Language: A Practical Guide
to Using Corpora. London and New York: Routledge.
Cheng, W. (2012) ‘A contrastive study of master thesis acknowledgment by Taiwanese
and North American students.’ Open Journal of Modern Linguistics 2(1), 8-17.
Clyne, M. (1987) ‘Cultural differences in the organization of academic texts: English and
German.’ Journal of Pragmatics 11(2), 211-247.
Connor, U. M. and Moreno, I. A. (2005) ‘Tertium comparationis: A vital component in
contrastive research methodology.’ In: Bruthiaux, P., Atkinson, D., Eggington, W.,
Grabe, W. and Ramanathan, V. (eds) Directions in Applied Linguistics: Essays in
Honor of Robert B. Kaplan. England: Multingual Matters. 153-164.
Cronin, B., McKenzie, G. and Rubio, L. (1993) ‘The norms of acknowledgment in four
humanities and social sciences disciplines.’ Journal of Documentation 49(1), 29-43.
Díaz-Faes, A. A. and Bordons, M. (2014) ‘Acknowledgements in scientific publications:
Presence in Spanish science and text patterns across disciplines.’ Journal of the
Association for Information Science and Technology 65(9), 1834-1849.
Duszak, A. (ed.) (1997) Culture and Styles of Academic Discourse. Berlin and New York:
Mouton de Gruyter.
Fløttum, K., Dahl, T. and Kinn, T. (2006) Academic Voices: Across Languages and
Disciplines. Amsterdam and Philadelphia: John Benjamins.
Giannoni, D. S. (2002) ‘Worlds of gratitude: A contrastive study of acknowledgment texts
in English and Italian research articles.’ Applied Linguistics 23(1), 1-31.
Hinds, J. (1987) ‘Reader versus writer responsibility: A new typology.’In: Connor, U. and
Kaplan, R. B. (eds) Writing across Languages: Analyses of L2 Text. Reading, MA:
Addison-Wesley. 141-152.
Holliday, A. (1999) ‘Small cultures.’ Applied Linguistics 20(2), 237-264.
Hopkins, A. and Dudley-Evans, T. (1988) ‘A genre-based investigation of the discussion
sections in articles and dissertations.’ English for Specific Purposes 7(2), 113-121.
Hyland, K. (2003) ‘Dissertation acknowledgments: The anatomy of Cinderella genre.
Written Communication 20(3), 242-268.
Hyland, K. (2004) ‘Graduates’ gratitude: The generic structure of dissertation
acknowledgments.’ English for Specific Purposes 23(3), 303-324.
Hyland, K. (2005) Metadiscourse: Exploring Interaction in Writing. London and New
York: Continuum.
Hyland, K. (2008) ‘Persuasion, interaction and the construction of knowledge:
Representing self and others in research writing.’ International Journal of English
Studies 8(2), 1-23.
Hyland, K. (2009) Academic Discourse. London: Continuum.
Hyland, K. and Bondi, M. (eds) (2006) Academic Discourse Across Disciplines. Bern:
Peter Lang.
22. Jolanta Šinkūnienė and Gabrielė dudzinskaitė
86
Hyland, K. and Tse, P. (2004) ‘“I would like to thank my supervisor”.’Acknowledgments
in graduate dissertations.’International Journal of Applied Linguistics 48(2), 259-275.
Lorés, R. (2004) ‘On RA abstracts: From rhetorical structure to thematic organization.’
English for Specific Purposes 23(3), 280-302.
Mauranen, A. (1993) ‘Cultural differences in academic discourse – problems of a
linguistic and cultural minority.’ In: Löfman, L., Kurki-Suonio, L., Pellinen, S., and
Lehtonen, J. (eds) The Competent Intercultural Communicator: AFinLA Yearbook.
Helsinki: AFinLA. 157-174.
Povolná, R. (2016) ‘Cross-cultural analysis of conference abstracts.’ Discourse and
Interaction 9(1), 29-48.
Sala, M. (2008) ‘Argumentative styles as cultural identity traits in legal studies.’
Linguistica e Filologia 27, 93-113.
Šinkūnienė, J. (2014) Lietuviškojo humanitarinių ir socialinių mokslų diskurso ypatybės:
Mokslostudija [Insights into Lithuanian scientific discourse of the Humanities and
Social Sciences]. Vilnius: VU leidykla.
Suomela-Salmi, E. and Dervin, F. (eds) (2009) Cross-linguistic and Cross-cultural
Perspectives on Academic Discourse. Amsterdam and Philadelphia: John Benjamins.
Swales, J. M. (2004) Research Genres: Explorations and Applications. Cambridge:
Cambridge University Press.
Jolanta Šinkūnienė is Associate Professor of English Linguistics at the Faculty
of Philology, Vilnius University, Lithuania. Her research interests focus on
research writing patterns and epistemological traditions of various disciplines
and cultures, academic rhetoric, elements of persuasion in academic discourse,
research publication practices, evaluation of research, academic identity aspects.
Address: Dr. Jolanta Šinkūnienė, Institute of English, Romance and Classical
Studies, Department of English Philology, Faculty of Philology, Vilnius University,
Universiteto 5, LT-01513Vilnius, Lithuania. [e-mail: jolanta.sinkuniene@flf.vu.lt]
Gabrielė Dudzinskaitė holds a BA degree in English Philology obtained at
Vilnius University, Lithuania. Her research interests include cross-linguistic
and cross-disciplinary aspects of academic text construction, especially the
macrostructure and metadiscoursal features of academic texts.
Address: Gabrielė Dudzinskaitė, Vivulskio 18-11, LT-03115, Vilnius, Lithuania.
[e-mail: dudzinskaite@gmail.com]