Recommandé
Recommandé
Contenu connexe
Similaire à Personalized Tasks and Anonymous Peer Feedback in the Fundamentals of Electrical Engineering
Similaire à Personalized Tasks and Anonymous Peer Feedback in the Fundamentals of Electrical Engineering (20)
Plus de Mathias Magdowski
Plus de Mathias Magdowski (20)
Dernier
Dernier (20)
Personalized Tasks and Anonymous Peer Feedback in the Fundamentals of Electrical Engineering
- 1. Personalized Tasks and Anonymous Peer Feedback in the Fundamentals of Electrical Engineering inspirED Virtual Conference 2022 Mathias Magdowski Chair for Electromagnetic Compatibility, Institute for Medical Engineering Otto von Guericke University, Magdeburg, Germany May 25, 2022 License: cb CC BY 4.0 (Attribution, ShareAlike)
- 2. Motivation Tasks and Sample Solutions Implementation Evaluation and Discussion Survey What field are you from? 1. mathematics, computer science, engineering, technology 2. education and teaching 3. medicine and care 4. languages and media 5. finance and insurance 6. something else Personalized Tasks and Anonymous Peer Feedback 2
- 3. Motivation Tasks and Sample Solutions Implementation Evaluation and Discussion Disclaimer http://www.watson.ch/Digital/Schweiz/846879648-Warum-unsere-Schulen-NICHT-auf-Microsoft-%28oder-Apple% 29-setzen-sollten Personalized Tasks and Anonymous Peer Feedback 3
- 4. Motivation Tasks and Sample Solutions Implementation Evaluation and Discussion Organizational Matters Slides: yes Personalized Tasks and Anonymous Peer Feedback 4
- 5. Motivation Tasks and Sample Solutions Implementation Evaluation and Discussion Organizational Matters Slides: yes Recording: yes Personalized Tasks and Anonymous Peer Feedback 4
- 6. Motivation Tasks and Sample Solutions Implementation Evaluation and Discussion Organizational Matters Slides: yes Recording: yes Questions: with pleasure Personalized Tasks and Anonymous Peer Feedback 4
- 7. Motivation Tasks and Sample Solutions Implementation Evaluation and Discussion Overview Why all this? What does a typical task look like? Topic „Nodal Analysis“ Implementation in Feedback Fruits What has come out of it? Personalized Tasks and Anonymous Peer Feedback 5
- 9. Motivation Tasks and Sample Solutions Implementation Evaluation and Discussion Survey What do you see as the biggest benefit or most useful advantage of a peer reviewed assessment? https://www.menti.com/123456 Personalized Tasks and Anonymous Peer Feedback 7
- 10. Motivation Tasks and Sample Solutions Implementation Evaluation and Discussion Traditional Performance Assessments Source: https://pixabay.com/de/photos/taschenrechner-notizblock-1687962/ Personalized Tasks and Anonymous Peer Feedback 8
- 11. Motivation Tasks and Sample Solutions Implementation Evaluation and Discussion Demands in the Working World Source: https://pixabay.com/de/arbeitsplatz-team-gesch%C3%A4ftstreffen-1245776/ Personalized Tasks and Anonymous Peer Feedback 9
- 12. Motivation Tasks and Sample Solutions Implementation Evaluation and Discussion Classical E-Learning Tasks Personalized Tasks and Anonymous Peer Feedback 10
- 13. Motivation Tasks and Sample Solutions Implementation Evaluation and Discussion Free Handwritten Solution Personalized Tasks and Anonymous Peer Feedback 11
- 14. Motivation Tasks and Sample Solutions Implementation Evaluation and Discussion Free Handwritten Solution Personalized Tasks and Anonymous Peer Feedback 12
- 15. Motivation Tasks and Sample Solutions Implementation Evaluation and Discussion Examples of Student Misconceptions Specification of Fourier coefficients in V and V ◦ : also see: https://twitter.com/LehrstuhlEMV/status/1257605076308426753 Personalized Tasks and Anonymous Peer Feedback 13
- 16. Motivation Tasks and Sample Solutions Implementation Evaluation and Discussion Examples of Student Misconceptions Complex impedance converted to time function: € #ß = 2.42Mt 8,411J -- ZAB = 81751 " Sin Iwtt 73,95 ) I 8,751 . ewtt 73,95 - also see: https://twitter.com/LehrstuhlEMV/status/1264294433027174401 Personalized Tasks and Anonymous Peer Feedback 14
- 17. Motivation Tasks and Sample Solutions Implementation Evaluation and Discussion Idea Personalizable tasks for handwritten solution: ▶ handwritten −→ authentic, low-threshold for formulas, schematics, diagrams, misconceptions become visible ▶ personalized −→ no plagiarism possible ▶ peer review −→ no correction effort −→ good ready-made personalized sample solution ▶ via Moodle, Feedback Fruits and e-mail −→ scalable, no „red tape“ Personalized Tasks and Anonymous Peer Feedback 15
- 18. Motivation Tasks and Sample Solutions Implementation Evaluation and Discussion Creation and Sending of the Tasks Registration MAT- LAB LaTeX Matriculation No. PDF Task Sample Solution Folder Personalized Tasks and Anonymous Peer Feedback 16
- 19. Motivation Tasks and Sample Solutions Implementation Evaluation and Discussion Submission and Distribution of the Solutions QR Code Web Server Folder Sample Solution Own Solution Peer Solutions Personalized Tasks and Anonymous Peer Feedback 17
- 20. Motivation Tasks and Sample Solutions Implementation Evaluation and Discussion Mutual Correction and Completion Received Feedback Given Feedback Score List Web Server Grade Reflection QR Code to Sample Solution Personalized Tasks and Anonymous Peer Feedback 18
- 21. Motivation Tasks and Sample Solutions Implementation Evaluation and Discussion Survey What do you see as the biggest benefit or most useful advantage of a peer reviewed assessment? https://www.menti.com/123456 Personalized Tasks and Anonymous Peer Feedback 19
- 22. What does a typical task look like?
- 23. Motivation Tasks and Sample Solutions Implementation Evaluation and Discussion Task (same for all) Nodal analysis shall be used to calculate the three nodal voltages UKn1, UKn2 and UKn3 between the respective node and the reference node. a) Draw the three nodal voltages UKn1, UKn2 and UKn3 in the circuit diagram (3 points). b) Set up the system of equations to calculate the nodal voltages using nodal analysis in matrix form (9 points). c) Insert the values of the components into the system of equations (1 point). d) Solve the system of equations and thus calculate the three nodal voltages UKn1, UKn2 and UKn3 (3 points). Personalized Tasks and Anonymous Peer Feedback 21
- 24. Motivation Tasks and Sample Solutions Implementation Evaluation and Discussion Circuit Diagram (for Matriculation Number 123 460) Iq1 R1 Iq2 R2 Iq3 Iq4 R3 0 1 2 3 Personalized Tasks and Anonymous Peer Feedback 22
- 25. Motivation Tasks and Sample Solutions Implementation Evaluation and Discussion Circuit Diagram (for Matriculation Number 123 461) Iq1 Iq2 R1 Iq3 R2 Iq4 R3 0 1 2 3 Personalized Tasks and Anonymous Peer Feedback 23
- 26. Motivation Tasks and Sample Solutions Implementation Evaluation and Discussion Circuit Diagram (for Matriculation Number 123 462) R1 Iq1 Iq2 R2 R3 0 1 2 3 Personalized Tasks and Anonymous Peer Feedback 24
- 27. Motivation Tasks and Sample Solutions Implementation Evaluation and Discussion Circuit Diagram (for Matriculation Number 123 463) Iq1 R1 R2 Iq2 Iq3 R3 0 1 2 3 Personalized Tasks and Anonymous Peer Feedback 25
- 28. Motivation Tasks and Sample Solutions Implementation Evaluation and Discussion Sample Solution (for Matriculation Number 123 460) Set up the system of equations to calculate the network: G1 0 0 0 G3 −G3 0 −G3 G2 + G3 · UKn1 UKn2 UKn3 = Iq1 + Iq3 + Iq4 Iq2 − Iq3 −Iq4 Insert the values of the components into the system of equations: 9 S 0 0 0 7 S −7 S 0 −7 S 13 S · UKn1 UKn2 UKn3 = 11 A −3 A −5 A Personalized Tasks and Anonymous Peer Feedback 26
- 29. Motivation Tasks and Sample Solutions Implementation Evaluation and Discussion Sample Solution (for Matriculation Number 123 461) Set up the system of equations to calculate the network: G2 −G2 0 −G2 G2 + G3 −G3 0 −G3 G1 + G3 · UKn1 UKn2 UKn3 = −Iq1 + Iq3 + Iq4 −Iq2 − Iq3 −Iq4 Insert the values of the components into the system of equations: 8 S −8 S 0 −8 S 16 S −8 S 0 −8 S 14 S · UKn1 UKn2 UKn3 = 4 A −15 A −8 A Personalized Tasks and Anonymous Peer Feedback 27
- 30. Motivation Tasks and Sample Solutions Implementation Evaluation and Discussion Sample Solution (for Matriculation Number 123 462) Set up the system of equations to calculate the network: G1 + G2 0 −G2 0 G3 −G3 −G2 −G3 G2 + G3 · UKn1 UKn2 UKn3 = −Iq2 Iq1 + Iq2 0 Insert the values of the components into the system of equations: 7 S 0 −4 S 0 1 S −1 S −4 S −1 S 5 S · UKn1 UKn2 UKn3 = −1 A 2 A 0 Personalized Tasks and Anonymous Peer Feedback 28
- 31. Motivation Tasks and Sample Solutions Implementation Evaluation and Discussion Sample Solution (for Matriculation Number 123 463) Set up the system of equations to calculate the network: G1 0 0 0 G2 + G3 −G3 0 −G3 G3 · UKn1 UKn2 UKn3 = −Iq1 − Iq3 0 Iq2 + Iq3 Insert the values of the components into the system of equations: 7 S 0 0 0 6 S −3 S 0 −3 S 3 S · UKn1 UKn2 UKn3 = −6 A 0 10 A Personalized Tasks and Anonymous Peer Feedback 29
- 32. Motivation Tasks and Sample Solutions Implementation Evaluation and Discussion Survey Can you think of personalised/randomized tasks that can also be used for your department? 1. yes, immediately, many 2. yes, some 3. yes, but only after some thought 4. no, not likely 5. nohow, no way Personalized Tasks and Anonymous Peer Feedback 30
- 33. Implementation in Feedback Fruits
- 34. Motivation Tasks and Sample Solutions Implementation Evaluation and Discussion Creating the Feedback Fruits Activity in Moodle Personalized Tasks and Anonymous Peer Feedback 32
- 35. Motivation Tasks and Sample Solutions Implementation Evaluation and Discussion Creating the Feedback Fruits Activity in Moodle Personalized Tasks and Anonymous Peer Feedback 33
- 36. Motivation Tasks and Sample Solutions Implementation Evaluation and Discussion Creating the Feedback Fruits Activity in Moodle Personalized Tasks and Anonymous Peer Feedback 34
- 37. Motivation Tasks and Sample Solutions Implementation Evaluation and Discussion Survey Do you use a learning management system and if so, which one? 1. Moodle 2. ILIAS 3. OLAT/OPAL 4. Blackboard 5. Canvas 6. something else 7. none Personalized Tasks and Anonymous Peer Feedback 35
- 38. Motivation Tasks and Sample Solutions Implementation Evaluation and Discussion Overview Over the Peer Review Activity Personalized Tasks and Anonymous Peer Feedback 36
- 39. Motivation Tasks and Sample Solutions Implementation Evaluation and Discussion Overview Over the Peer Review Activity Personalized Tasks and Anonymous Peer Feedback 37
- 40. Motivation Tasks and Sample Solutions Implementation Evaluation and Discussion Overview Over the Peer Review Activity Personalized Tasks and Anonymous Peer Feedback 38
- 41. Motivation Tasks and Sample Solutions Implementation Evaluation and Discussion Overview Over the Peer Review Activity Personalized Tasks and Anonymous Peer Feedback 39
- 42. Motivation Tasks and Sample Solutions Implementation Evaluation and Discussion Editing the Peer Review Activity Personalized Tasks and Anonymous Peer Feedback 40
- 43. Motivation Tasks and Sample Solutions Implementation Evaluation and Discussion Editing the Peer Review Activity Personalized Tasks and Anonymous Peer Feedback 41
- 44. Motivation Tasks and Sample Solutions Implementation Evaluation and Discussion Editing the Peer Review Activity Personalized Tasks and Anonymous Peer Feedback 42
- 45. Motivation Tasks and Sample Solutions Implementation Evaluation and Discussion Editing the Peer Review Activity Personalized Tasks and Anonymous Peer Feedback 43
- 46. Motivation Tasks and Sample Solutions Implementation Evaluation and Discussion QR Code Pointing to the Sample Solution Personalized Tasks and Anonymous Peer Feedback 44
- 47. What has come out of it?
- 48. Motivation Tasks and Sample Solutions Implementation Evaluation and Discussion Evaluation of a Typical Cycle Bare numbers: ▶ Tasks sent to about 200 students ▶ Solutions submitted by about 100 students ▶ Review carried out by about 90 students Personalized Tasks and Anonymous Peer Feedback 46
- 49. Motivation Tasks and Sample Solutions Implementation Evaluation and Discussion Evaluation of a Typical Cycle Bare numbers: ▶ Tasks sent to about 200 students ▶ Solutions submitted by about 100 students ▶ Review carried out by about 90 students Advantage: ▶ excellent activation ▶ good exam preparation without „teaching to the test“ Personalized Tasks and Anonymous Peer Feedback 46
- 50. Motivation Tasks and Sample Solutions Implementation Evaluation and Discussion Poor Image Quality of Submissions/Corrections Personalized Tasks and Anonymous Peer Feedback 47
- 51. Motivation Tasks and Sample Solutions Implementation Evaluation and Discussion Survey What do you see as the biggest obstacle to using peer review in teaching? https://www.menti.com/123456 Personalized Tasks and Anonymous Peer Feedback 48
- 52. Motivation Tasks and Sample Solutions Implementation Evaluation and Discussion Round Table Discussion on Evaluation and Further Development 1. Do the personalised additional tasks make you feel well prepared for the performance assessments and the exam? 2. How do you classify the degree of difficulty of the tasks (also in comparison to the examples in the lecture, the other exercises and the tasks in the performance review or examination)? 3. How do you assess the clarity and comprehensibility of the tasks/sample solutions? 4. How do you estimate the workload (also in comparison to other courses)? Personalized Tasks and Anonymous Peer Feedback 49
- 53. Motivation Tasks and Sample Solutions Implementation Evaluation and Discussion Round Table Discussion on Evaluation and Further Development 5. How do you assess the fairness of the mutual evaluation? 6. Do you find the assistance (detail and precision of the sample solution, listing of typical errors) in the mutual evaluation sufficient? 7. Do you feel well enough informed about the procedure (processing time, submission modalities, deadlines, etc.)? 8. How do you evaluate the technical handling (sending the tasks by e-mail, submission via the learning management system Moodle)? Personalized Tasks and Anonymous Peer Feedback 50
- 54. Motivation Tasks and Sample Solutions Implementation Evaluation and Discussion Further Information Achievements to date: ▶ 13 different task types developed so far ▶ 45 runs in 10 semesters so far ▶ 8000 personalized tasks sent out ▶ 3750 student solutions submitted ▶ 7150 student peer reviews accomplished Links (in German): Lightning Talk: https://youtu.be/LDw_Ifmg2WM Twitter: #PersonalisierteAufgaben Article: Research in Learning Technology, DOI: 10.25304/rlt.v28.2339 FAQ: SlideShare Personalized Tasks and Anonymous Peer Feedback 51
- 55. Motivation Tasks and Sample Solutions Implementation Evaluation and Discussion Survey What do you see as the biggest obstacle to using peer review in teaching? https://www.menti.com/123456 Personalized Tasks and Anonymous Peer Feedback 52
- 56. Motivation Tasks and Sample Solutions Implementation Evaluation and Discussion https://twitter.com/MarkusRidderbu8/status/ 1523708966039351297 Thank you very much for your attention! Are there any questions? Personalized Tasks and Anonymous Peer Feedback 53