4. ADDITIVE MANUFACTURING | CNC MACHINING | INJECTION MOLDING
DESIGNING FOR DMLS
Not a replacement for traditional machining, casting, sheet
metal fabrication or metal injection molding (MIM)
5. ADDITIVE MANUFACTURING | CNC MACHINING | INJECTION MOLDING
Reduction of components
Reduction of weight
Quicker assembly times
Reduction of cost
Complexity
DESIGN GOALS FOR DMLS
7. ADDITIVE MANUFACTURING | CNC MACHINING | INJECTION MOLDING
Urban utility bike, EVO
Allows riders to easily attach and detach
different components
CASE STUDY: HUGE DESIGN
8. ADDITIVE MANUFACTURING | CNC MACHINING | INJECTION MOLDING
DMLS was used to
create the lugs,
crankset shell and
fork crown
CASE STUDY: HUGE DESIGN
14. ADDITIVE MANUFACTURING | CNC MACHINING | INJECTION MOLDING
SUPPORTS
Connect the part
to the platform
Hold features in
place
Prevent warping
Photo courtesy Concept Laser
15. ADDITIVE MANUFACTURING | CNC MACHINING | INJECTION MOLDING
SUPPORT removal process
Can be intensive
and may require
machining, EDM
Design tip: Design
parts that will
require minimal
supports. This will
also improve part
quality
Photo courtesy Concept Laser
17. ADDITIVE MANUFACTURING | CNC MACHINING | INJECTION MOLDING
INTERNAL FEATURES
Support and powder removal
access
Design tip: Lattice structures
can be used internally to
reduce weight and provide
support
Channels, overhangs, self-supporting angles, bridge
dimensions
19. ADDITIVE MANUFACTURING | CNC MACHINING | INJECTION MOLDING
OVERHANGS
If the next layer is larger
than the previous layer, it
will create an overhang
DMLS has a small
allowance for unsupported
overhangs
(0.5 mm/0.020 in.)
20. ADDITIVE MANUFACTURING | CNC MACHINING | INJECTION MOLDING
CHANNELS AND HOLES
Channels and holes are
self-supporting features
Great for conformal
cooling applications
21. ADDITIVE MANUFACTURING | CNC MACHINING | INJECTION MOLDING
CHANNELS AND HOLES
As the diameter increases, the overhangs
increase
8mm
(.31”)
6mm
(.24”)
5mm
(.2”)
15mm
(.6”)
12mm
(.47”)
23. ADDITIVE MANUFACTURING | CNC MACHINING | INJECTION MOLDING
INTERNAL STRESSES | WARPAGE
Changes in cross-
sectional areas can
lead to warpage
Large flat surfaces can
bend build plates and
shear bolts
Design tip: Design in additional material to
gradually transition into larger cross-sections
26. ADDITIVE MANUFACTURING | CNC MACHINING | INJECTION MOLDING
DESIGN EXAMPLE: REV 3
Best surface finish, small warpage
potential
Self-supporting features eliminate
need for most supports
27. ADDITIVE MANUFACTURING | CNC MACHINING | INJECTION MOLDING
PROTOTYPING OR
PRODUCTION
DMLS can be a
production method
for complex
geometries
DMLS is also a
low-cost, quick-turn
method for
prototyping
components using
actual end-use
materials
OPTIMIZE DESIGN HIGHER VOLUME
28. ADDITIVE MANUFACTURING | CNC MACHINING | INJECTION MOLDING
CASE STUDY
TRANSITION TO CONVENTIONAL MFG
Total Cost (Tooling + Parts)
DMLS
MIM
Part Quantity
Cost
0 100 200 300 400
Breakeven point
29. CONCLUSION
DMLS opens up new design options,
but it will not replace conventional
manufacturing methods
Understanding constraints will
maximize benefits of DMLS for part
design
QUESTIONS?
Notes de l'éditeur
Proto Labs founded in 1999
Acquired Fineline in 2014, located in Raleigh, North Carolina.
Specialize in additive technologies: SL, SLS and DMLS
Direct metal laser sintering (DMLS) is an additive technology that opens up new design freedoms not possible with conventional manufacturing methods
DMLS is not a replacement for traditional machining, casting, sheet metal fabrication or metal injection molding (MIM), but another tool for designers to utilize.
DMLS has some limitations, but by anticipating these, designers can take full advantage of the technology
Although small features can be resolved, they are not always feasible
Warpage can come into play on thin walls as they grow in height
At a certain height, free standing thin features will fail
Surface roughness varies based on material, build parameters and part orientation
Possible to customize parameters for best surface roughness, but will sacrifice material properties
Surface roughness can be eliminated with post processing, but all areas may not be accessible
Parts have received our standard finish: bead blasting and shot peening
DMLS parts require supports to connect part to platform and hold features in place
Supports prevent part from warping during rapid melting and cooling process
Support removal process can be intensive. May require machining, EDM
Design tip: Design parts that will require minimal supports! This will also improve part quality
A huge benefit of DMLS is the ability to create complex internal features
Channels, overhangs, self supporting angles and bridge dimensions must all be taken into consideration when designing areas that may be hard to access
If an internal feature requires supports, but allows no access, the supports remain inside, and the geometry may not function as intended
Accessibility for powder removal should also be taken into consideration
Design tip: Lattice structures can be used internally to reduce weight and provide support
316L, 30 micron layers
DMLS is a layer-by-layer process
If the next layer is larger than the previous layer, it will create an overhang
Unlike other additive processes, DMLS has a small allowance for unsupported overhangs (0.5 mm/0.020 in.)
If left unsupported, large overhangs may lead to build crash
As the hole diameter increases, the overhangs increase near the closing of the hole
Unsupported holes larger than 8 mm (0.31 in.) diameter will suffer downfacing distortion/curl, and potentially create other build issues
Design tip: Use diamond or teardrop shapes for larger diameter channels
A bridge is any flat downfacing surface that is supported by two or more features
Minimum allowable unsupported bridge distance is small
(~2 mm/0.080 in.)
Changes in cross-sectional area can lead to warpage between features
Large flat surfaces can bend build plates and shear bolts
Design tip: Design in additional material to gradually transition into larger cross-sections
Reduction of components/assembly time/weight …
BUT…supports interfere with function and add build time ($$$). Surface roughness will suffer, potential warpage issues
Best surface finish, small warpage potential
Self-supporting features eliminate need for most supports
Once the design has been optimized using DMLS, it can be transitioned to a higher volume conventional manufacturing process
Throughput gains (more parts in less time)
Cost reduction
Initial design concept proven using DMLS
Throughput limited to 80 parts per week
Transitioned to MIM to achieve scale of thousands of parts per week
Lower overall cost, including MIM tooling