1. Youth Innovation in Skåne
An Ethnographic Study
By I.Dimitrievski, M.Fraser Berndtsson,
R.Liepytė, M.Pumputytė, A.Steponavičiūtė
2. Innovation stems from people. In order for the region to become the most
innovative in Europe by 2020, the citizens will need to become the most
innovative.
The role of the government is to give the tools for innovation to new
generations. These tools need to be adjusted and fine-tuned to suit and
be usable for the new generations, if they are to be used.
The aim of the project was to explore the creative and innovative
practices of youth in Skåne, to gain insights that may be used for
enhancing the innovative spirit in Skåne’s youth.
3. Why Applied Cultural Analysis?
Applied cultural analysis provides us with a theoretical and
methodological framework to explore the often hidden logics of the
mundane.
The ethnographic focus on routines and everyday events invites a dialogue
with the people on the ground.
Our qualitative methodology allows us to pinpoint significant aspects that
quantitative methods often overlook – like lifestyles, everyday practices,
values, meanings, and the small details that build up the bigger picture.
We bring various schools of thought together and combine them with
diverse ethnographic methods (fieldwork, participant and non-participant
observation, individual and group interviews, communicative group
activities and focus groups, visual documentation).
4. Environments:
Academic and vocational schools, NGO
and municipal run youth centers
Field sites:
Helsingborg, Lund, Östra Ljungby,
and Malmö (Rosengård)
Follow the youth –
diversity and inclusion
5. Innovators
We are all innovators, but nobody is born an innovator.
We need structured freedom and innovation network in order to establish an innovation
mode.
People become more developed as innovators through practice, practice, and more
practice.
While we practice, we need
Scaffolding: mentors and peers bridge the gap between our skill level and what we
want to achieve. They help us, and by watching them do it, we learn to do it ourselves.
Experience: as we achieve good results gradually undertaking more difficult and
realistic projects, we gain confidence and see greater possibilities ahead.
6. The evolution of the innovator
Beginner
Embodiedabilities
Scaffolding =
Mentors + peers
bridge the gap
between our
present skill-level
and our goals
Motivation
Experience of fun and
making a difference in
the world
Professional/
master
7. “If you don’t have the chance to communicate with
anyone, you can’t develop as a person or do
anything”.
Anna, 16
“Maybe when we are in the group we are inspiring
each other”.
Eva, youth worker
Innovation is a social phenomenon. It requires:
Communication youth-to-youth, youth-to-parents, youth-to-teachers.
Safe and comfortable environment conducive to good interpersonal
communication.
Interpersonal communication
8. Emotional experiences
Self-expression
Interests and aspirations
Making a difference
Bringing a dream closer to reality
Motivation
9. Doing something new, acting creatively brings the reward
of positive emotional experiences – fun, excitement,
feelings of achievement.
Emotional experiences
11. Interests and aspirations
By doing things – by innovating – youth is involved in a life-
long project: to realize their hopes, interests, and aspirations.
13. Bringing a dream closer to reality
I like playing music, it’s my dream. And I
like showing people how I make it. Who
knows if I, like, get money. There was one
guy whose name is Fred. He’s on YouTube.
And he was like me. Like nothing. And now
he’s a millionaire.
Ismail
16. IsmaIl and Per recording a song
41
Scaffolding step-by-step
From a lyric to a recorded song
17. Scaffolding over the long haul
From internship to street festival to youth consultants managing projects
and finding funding by themselves
18. To have effective scaffolding, effective mentors are needed.
These are people like teachers, youth workers, and coaches.
Mentoring is a juggling act. Mentors must balance:
Helping youth and allowing them to do it by themselves
Structure and freedom
Encouragement and strictness
Other factors
All these needs will differ from youth to youth, project to
project.
Mentors need resources and support.
Scaffolding and mentors
19. Usefulness for more people
Changebeyondtheoriginal The evolution of innovation
More basic
E.g. Battery charger
a) Specifications provided
b) For personal use
Intermediate
E.g. Cookbook
a) Realization of own idea
b) Own design
c) Originally for use by family and friends, but
interest spread and more copies sold
More developed
E.g. Music CD
a) Independently realized project
from composition through production
b) For public consumption through radio
and sales of the CD
20. Innovation is a process which happens over
time and space:
long term development from childhood to
adulthood in diverse settings of everyday life
22. Recommendations
Approach youth innovation in the region from
the ground up
Broaden the definition of innovation
Be inclusive
Remember the importance of the unquantifiable.
Feelings matter.
23. If you can only do one thing…
Policy
makers
Youth and youth
workers
1 bullet – elaborate more on a project
2 bullet- our research problems are based on this 3 questions. Elaborate
We chose diverse academic and vocational schools, NGO and municipal run youth centers in Helsingborg, Lund, Östra Ljungby, and Malmö (Rosengård) as research field sites in order to represent the whole region, to reflect the social diversity and capture the variety of youth innovation
Scaffolding – bridging the gaps
An important way mentors help us learn to do things is through scaffolding. Scaffolding bridges the gap between what we want to achieve and what we can achieve with our present abilities. For example, if we are unsure of our goals, mentors might lead a brainstorming session so we can see the options and decide. Or, if we want to renovate a toilet and are at a loss as to how to connect certain pipes, a mentor might show us how to do it or help us do it ourselves. If we want to put on a street festival, the mentor might provide the necessary contacts within the appropriate municipal departments. Or, if we want to make music, the mentor might take us step-by-step through the process – from writing the lyrics, to setting down the beats, to recording the vocals, adding the melody, etc.
In short, mentors scaffold by teaching us the step-by-step processes of getting things done and helping us do it ourselves by adding their knowledge, skills, and emotional support when things get tough.
The point with scaffolding is that by helping us achieve something, by assisting us through the process, mentors guide us so we build up the experience and gain more skills to do it ourselves the next time.
Yet to be able to provide effective scaffolding, mentors need resources. They need the time to see what we’re doing and to help us as needed. By being with us over the course of our projects they can truly understand our interests, strengths and weaknesses, what we want to do, where gaps exist in our knowledge, skills, confidence, and how best to bridge those gaps.
One final thing. Mentors. To have effective scaffolding, you need effective mentors. Often adults like teachers, youth workers, coaches.
Mentoring is a juggling act. Mentors have to understand the individual youth and their needs, what help they need and when, and strike the right balance between helping and letting youth do it by themselves. Mentors also have to work with youth’s characters and emotions, and know how to provide encouragement, how to be strict, which will differ from youth to youth.
Mentors need resources and support.
And now over to Milda.
Innovation is a process which happens over time and space (long term development in diverse settings of everyday life)
Improve the communication between the two:
shift from top -> down, to bottom-> up
Get close, connect with youth and address what’s important to them