Contenu connexe Similaire à Robo Advice: Revenge of the Incumbents (MyVest and Aite INVEST session) (20) Robo Advice: Revenge of the Incumbents (MyVest and Aite INVEST session)2. Aite (pronounced “eye-tay”) Group is an
independent research and advisory firm focused on
business, technology, and regulatory issues and their
impact on the financial services industry.
A fintech pioneer headquartered in the heart of San
Francisco, MyVest combines best practices in wealth
management with best-in-class technology. Our
cloud-based platform enables holistic, client-centric
wealth management across the enterprise in a
single, unified system.
Alois Pirker
Research Director,
Wealth Management
Anton Honikman
CEO
© 2017 MyVest Corporation. All Rights Reserved.
3. Type Definition
% of
Population
Wirehouse
Merrill Lynch, UBS, Wells Fargo Advisors,
Morgan Stanley
8%
Independent RIA
Mostly small firms but also have RIA
groups working within larger broker-
dealer firms
16%
FA with other
self-clearing firm
Large / regional players: e.g.,
Ameriprise, Edward Jones, Raymond
James, LPL, RBC
13%
FA with online
broker
Schwab, Fidelity, TD Ameritrade on the
retail side (fewer than 2,000 advisors)
10%
FA with
insurance BD
e.g. AXA, Northwestern (fewer than 10K
advisors, some with more than 5K)
15%
FA with
independent BD
e.g. Commonwealth Financial, ING
(fewer than 5,000 advisors)
14%
FA with bank BD
e.g. PNC, M&T Bank (fewer than 1,000
advisors)
8%
FA with private
bank / bank trust
e.g. Northern Trust, US Trust, Bessemer
Trust
16%
2 Annual Survey of 400 Advisors1 Qualitative Interviews
In-depth interviews with a variety of
industry participants:
• Executives at financial institutions
• Financial advisors
• Executives at fintech firms
• Start-up firms and disruptors
“We take a topic and look at it
from both sides, and that gives
us a sense of what's happening
in the market.”
- Alois Pirker, Aite Group
Aite Group Methodology
© 2017 MyVest Corporation. All Rights Reserved.
4. How Did We Get Here?
The Evolution of Robo-Advice
6. 1996 Today
OverallAdoption
B2B for
Enterprise 1.0
Quick Wins
Simplicity, UX
B2B for
Enterprise 2.0
Hybrid Human+Tech
Multi-Segment
+
+
Pioneers
Early Niches
B2C 1.0
Retail Disrupters
B2B for
Independent
Advisors
Disrupt RIA Vendors
B2C Pivots to B2B
B2C 2.0
Retail Response
Evolution: From robo-advice to digital wealth
© 2017 MyVest Corporation. All Rights Reserved.
7. 1996 Today
OverallAdoption
B2B for
Enterprise 1.0
Quick Wins
Simplicity, UX
B2B for
Enterprise 2.0
Hybrid Human+Tech
Multi-Segment
+
+
Pioneers
Early Niches
B2C 1.0
Retail Disrupters
B2B for
Independent
Advisors
Disrupt RIA Vendors
B2C Pivots to B2B
B2C 2.0
Retail Response
Evolution: From robo-advice to digital wealth
© 2017 MyVest Corporation. All Rights Reserved.
“B2B for Enterprise 1.0 is a quick win;
B2B for Enterprise 2.0 is about strategic
business transformation.”
- Alois Pirker, Aite Group
8. $70
$141
$204
$16
$25
$43
$171
2016 2017E 2018E
Estimated Growth of Digital Advisor Solutions
($ in Billions)
Retail assets
acquired by
traditional
incumbents
Retail assets
acquired by start-
up digital advisors
directly
Vanguard,
Schwab, Fidelity,
E*Trade, TD
Ameritrade
$400B
$90B
Market sizing & growth: Incumbents pulling away
© 2017 MyVest Corporation. All Rights Reserved.
9. $70
$141
$204
$16
$25
$43
$171
2016 2017E 2018E
Estimated Growth of Digital Advisor Solutions
($ in Billions)
Retail assets
acquired by
traditional
incumbents
Retail assets
acquired by start-
up digital advisors
directly
Vanguard,
Schwab, Fidelity,
E*Trade, TD
Ameritrade
$400B
$90B
Market sizing & growth: Incumbents pulling away
© 2017 MyVest Corporation. All Rights Reserved.
“Banks and insurance firms will
challenge this $171 billion growth
segment.”
- Anton Honikman, MyVest
10. 3%
16%
31%
23%
13%
15%
5%
15%
13%
32%
20%
15%
Practice has
made the
decision to
launch a digital
advisor service
Very interested Interested Somewhat
interested
Not interested We have not
discussed
this/thought
about this
Q2 2017 Q3 2015
50%
interested or
ready to
adopt
(up from 33%)
Source: Aite Group survey of 369 financial advisors, Q2 2017 and 403 financial advisors, Q3 2015.
Q: How interested is your practice in leveraging
new digital advisor technology over the next few years?
Advisor interest in new technology
© 2017 MyVest Corporation. All Rights Reserved.
11. 3%
16%
31%
23%
13%
15%
5%
15%
13%
32%
20%
15%
Practice has
made the
decision to
launch a digital
advisor service
Very interested Interested Somewhat
interested
Not interested We have not
discussed
this/thought
about this
Q2 2017 Q3 2015
50%
interested or
ready to
adopt
(up from 33%)
Source: Aite Group survey of 369 financial advisors, Q2 2017 and 403 financial advisors, Q3 2015.
Q: How interested is your practice in leveraging
new digital advisor technology over the next few years?
Advisor interest in new technology
© 2017 MyVest Corporation. All Rights Reserved.
“The sands are shifting.
The fastest growing advisors see the
opportunity in new technology.”
- Alois Pirker, Aite Group
12. Response
% of
Population
Improve the clients' digital experience 46%
Acquire a new segment of clients 40%
Automate processes
(onboarding, portfolio management)
39%
Offer clients more service options
to best fit their needs and preferences
39%
Serve some of our existing clients
more cost-effectively
34%
Meet the needs of any client/prospect...
who prefers passive/low-cost portfolio
management
32%
The “What”
Q: What are (or would be) the practice’s goals
for such a platform?
Response
% of
Population
Generation X
(35- to 50-year-olds)
49%
Millennials
(under 35 years old)
48%
High-potential clients
(e.g., early career professionals)
47%
Children of existing clients 45%
Friends of existing clients who do not meet
the minimum balance
27%
Parents or other relatives of existing clients 26%
Any client who does not meet our practice’s
minimum balance
13%
The “Who”
Q: What types of clients would your practice
seek to acquire or service through a digital
advisor platform?
Source: Aite Group survey of 369 financial advisors, Q2 2017.
Who will they target & what are their goals?
© 2017 MyVest Corporation. All Rights Reserved.
13. Response
% of
Population
Improve the clients' digital experience 46%
Acquire a new segment of clients 40%
Automate processes
(onboarding, portfolio management)
39%
Offer clients more service options
to best fit their needs and preferences
39%
Serve some of our existing clients
more cost-effectively
34%
Meet the needs of any client/prospect...
who prefers passive/low-cost portfolio
management
32%
The “What”
Q: What are (or would be) the practice’s goals
for such a platform?
Response
% of
Population
Generation X
(35- to 50-year-olds)
49%
Millennials
(under 35 years old)
48%
High-potential clients
(e.g., early career professionals)
47%
Children of existing clients 45%
Friends of existing clients who do not meet
the minimum balance
27%
Parents or other relatives of existing clients 26%
Any client who does not meet our practice’s
minimum balance
13%
The “Who”
Q: What types of clients would your practice
seek to acquire or service through a digital
advisor platform?
Source: Aite Group survey of 369 financial advisors, Q2 2017.
Who will they target & what are their goals?
© 2017 MyVest Corporation. All Rights Reserved.
“As you can see, these digital advice
platforms service nearly all client
segments and firm goals.”
- Alois Pirker, Aite Group
20. Serve multiple segments
Value-added services
Robust client data layer
Incumbents’ new opportunities in digital wealth
© 2017 MyVest Corporation. All Rights Reserved.
“There’s so much opportunity in the
amount of data firms have.
Start with the data and use it to
hyper-personalize the experience.”
- Anton Honikman, MyVest
21. 1. Invest in great UI/UX (table stakes)
2. Leverage your strengths
3. Seek out smart fintech partnerships
4. Move from simple segmentation to
hyper-personalization
Incumbent
recipe for
success
22. 1. Invest in great UI/UX (table stakes)
2. Leverage your strengths
3. Seek out smart fintech partnerships
4. Move from simple segmentation to
hyper-personalization
Incumbent
recipe for
success
“Incumbents, now is your time.”
- Anton Honikman, MyVest