SlideShare une entreprise Scribd logo
1  sur  41
Télécharger pour lire hors ligne
Presentation for workshop on Spatial Dimensions of
Productivity organised by the OECD Global Forum on
Productivity and the OECD Spatial Productivity Lab
OECD Trento Centre, Bolzano, Italy
28-29th March 2019
Stephen Aldridge
Director for Analysis and Data
Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government
UK
PUBLIC SECTOR EFFICIENCY IN THE UK
1
THE UK’S TRACK RECORD IN
PUBLIC SECTOR EFFICIENCY
WORK
2
The UK has a strong track record in public
sector efficiency measurement and analysis
3
1998: Direct measures of government outputs included in UK National Accounts.
2003: National Statistician commissions the economist Tony Atkinson to review the measurement of
government output in the National Accounts.
2004: First public service productivity statistics on health care released.
2005: Atkinson Review: Final Report published; UK Centre for the Measurement of Government Activity
(UKCeMGA) established in the Office for National Statistics (ONS); first education productivity article
released.
2006: Public service productivity articles for adult social care and social security administration released.
2009: First total public service productivity article released. UKCeMGA merged with National Accounts having
implemented 90% of recommendations.
2014: Cross-departmental analysts’ group on public sector efficiency established (Public Sector Efficiency
Group).
2015: Public Sector Efficiency Group produces papers and report for the 2015 Spending Review.
2016: ONS establish public sector efficiency measurement unit.
2017: Publication of Sir Michael Barber’s Public Value Review and Public Value Framework.
PURPOSE OF THIS
PRESENTATION
4
The purpose of this presentation is…
5
• to offer a clear definition of public sector efficiency
• to set out why public sector efficiency is important
• to spell out the challenges to measuring public sector efficiency
• to explain what public sector activities we’re interested in
• to set out what the data shows for a selection of public services
• to summarise the key drivers of public sector efficiency and some examples
of what can be done
• to offer some thoughts on next steps
WHAT DO WE MEAN BY
PUBLIC SECTOR
EFFICIENCY?
6
What do we mean by public sector efficiency?
7
Public sector efficiency refers to the process of turning pubic money into
desired outcomes
Public
Money
Inputs
Inputs
Outputs
Outputs
Desired
Outcomes
Economy
How cheaply are the inputs
being purchased?
Productivity
How much output is produced for
each unit of input?
Effectiveness and resilience
How do the outputs affect desired
outcomes?
Technical Efficiency
How well are inputs turned into outputs?
Allocative
Efficiency
Are the right
outputs being
produced?
Allocative Efficiency
Public Sector Efficiency
Relevant to the entire process of turning public money into desired outcomes
The Public Sector/Service Production Process
A simplified model of how public money is turned into inputs, outputs and outcomes
What do we mean by public sector efficiency?
Technical efficiency
‘Doing things right’
Doing the things we currently do
either at less cost, or getting
more outputs from what we
currently do at the same cost, or
some combination of the two.
Allocative efficiency
‘Doing the right things’
Finding wholly different ways of
achieving desired outcomes – at
less or substantially less cost.
Service transformation is crucial
to allocative efficiency and
unlocking transformational
improvements in efficiency.
8
Public sector efficiency can be defined in two distinct ways: technical and
allocative
Inputs Inputs Inputs
Outputs Outputs Outputs
Desired Outcomes
Alternative ways of achieving desired outcomes
WHY IS PUBLIC SECTOR
EFFICIENCY IMPORTANT?
9
Why is public sector efficiency important?
It matters to the difference the public
sector and public services make to
outcomes the public and policy makers
are concerned about:
- Health
- Educational attainment
- Public safety
- Etc.
10
It matters to productivity in the wider
economy
Giordano et al’s IMF working paper
suggests firms in an Italian province with
above median public sector efficiency
achieve higher levels of output per Euro
spent on salaries (+11%)
Source: Does Public Sector Inefficiency Constrain Firm Productivity: Evidence
from Italian Provinces by R Giordano, S Lanau, P Tommasino, and P
Topalova, IMF Working Paper, WP/15/168, July 2015
It matters to the burden of taxation and
fiscal sustainability
The more efficiently services are
provided, all other things being equal, the
greater the fiscal sustainability
1pp p.a.
increase in public sector productivity
growth
=
64% of GDP
reduction in public sector net debt
2.7% increase p.a.
Public Sector Net Debt as a % of GDP in the UK under different rates of public
sector productivity growth
Source: Office for Budget Responsibility, 2013
WHAT ARE THE CHALLENGES
IN MEASURING PUBLIC
SECTOR EFFICIENCY?
11
What are the challenges in measuring
public sector efficiency?
12
While all efficiency data available are imperfect and subject to caveats, none of the
problems around defining and measuring efficiency are insurmountable.
Analysing public sector efficiency poses a number of measurement challenges
Public
Money
Inputs Outputs Desired
Outcomes
The ONS has produced guidance on what data
is needed to construct a cost weighted index
of inputs and outputs that can be used to
construct an efficiency index.
How can we attribute changes in
outcomes to changes in outputs?
Especially when changes in
outcomes may take time to
happen
How do we define and
measure the quality of
outputs?
How do we turn cost and
price data into volumes of
inputs and outputs?
Problems
Potential
Solutions
How do we ensure
consistency in
measuring costs?
When outcomes are affected by many factors (e.g. health), quality adjustment
can be used to account for the effectiveness of the outputs produced. A range
of methods exist to measure quality, e.g. QALYs, or client satisfaction.
Where the outcome is a public good (e.g. defence) assessing the impact of
outputs on outcomes is more difficult, and may require an interdisciplinary
approach – for example, using an independent risk based assessment.
Consistency Costs into volumes
ONS Guidance
Quality Attribution
Quality adjustment & public goods
WHAT PUBLIC SECTOR
ACTIVITIES ARE WE
INTERESTED IN?
13
What public sector activities are we interested in?
• Back office services including Human Resources and Finance.
• Transactional services including benefit administration and tax
collection.
• Front line public services including schools, policing, health, social
care, etc.
14
Public sector activities can be broken down into three broad categories:
back office, transactional and front line
The efficiency of back office and transactional services is more readily
measurable (if not without challenges) but by far the greatest public
sector spend is on frontline services.
WHAT DO THE DATA SHOW?
15
What do the data show?
(a) Across the public sector as a whole
16
Total economy productivity
Inputs: Hours worked
Outputs: Gross Domestic Product
Market sector productivity
Inputs: The volume of labour (adjusted for the
skill mix of the workforce), and the volume of
capital used.
Outputs: Total economic output of the market
sector (measured by Gross Value Added, GVA).
Total public services productivity
Inputs : Inputs can be broken down into three
components. They are labour, intermediate
consumption (expenditure on goods and services)
and consumption of fixed capital.
Outputs: are measured in one of 4 ways:
(a) outputs are assumed to equal inputs (e.g.
defence spending) – 38% of total
(b) quality adjusted outputs equal inputs – 3%
(c) quantity alone – 12% (e.g. social security
administration and children’s social care)
(d) quality adjusted – 47%
Over the longer term, private sector productivity has grown faster than
public sector productivity, but since 2010 the reverse has been true
80
90
100
110
120
130
Index,1997=100
Productivity, Index 1997=100
Market sector
productivity
Total public services
productivity
Total economy
productivity
Total economy
productivity
Market sector
productivity98
100
102
104
106
108
Index,2010=100
Productivity, Index 2010=100
Total public services
productivity
Source: ONS
https://www.ons.gov.uk/economy/economicoutputandproductivity/publicservicesproductivity/datasets/
growthratesandindicesfortotalpublicserviceoutputinputsandproductivitytable1
Quality
adjustment
begins
What do the data show?
(b) Health services
17
Much of the historic productivity
increase has been driven by reduced
average length of hospital stay and
shifting activity to day cases. This allows
fewer beds and nurses per episode, though
the average acuity of patients in hospital
increases.
A combination of pay restraint, improved
labour productivity, centralised
procurement, reduced use of agency
staff, the abolition of some tiers of
management and greater use of generic
drugs have delivered significant efficiency
savings over the past 7-8 years.
Productivity
growth rates
(p/a) Health
Total
Economy Public Sector
1997 to 2007 0.8% 2.1% 0.0%
2007 to 2016 1.2% 0.2% 0.6%
1997 to 2016 1.0% 1.2% 0.3%
Inputs : Inputs to publicly-funded health
care have three components: labour,
purchases of goods and services and
consumption of fixed capital.
Outputs : Healthcare output is measured
as the quantity of healthcare delivered,
adjusted for changes in the quality of
delivery. Outputs include hospital inpatient,
outpatient and day case episodes, family
health services, including General
Practitioner (GP) services, prescribing –
includes all drugs prescribed by General
Practitioners and non-NHS provision
funded by government.
Quality is measured using survival
rates/health gain, waiting times and
surveys of patient experience
Source: ONS
(https://www.ons.gov.uk/economy/economicoutputandproductivity/publicservicesproductivity/artic
les/publicservicesproductivityestimatestotalpublicservices/2016)
60
80
100
120
140
160
180
200
220
240
260
280
300
Index,1995/96=100
UK health care inputs, quality adjusted output
and productivity
Quality adjusted
productivity
Inputs
Quality adjusted
outputs
What do the data show?
(c) Schools*
18
The wider evidence base suggests
changes in school performance are
heavily influenced by factors outside the
education system, such as parental
engagement and the home learning
environment.
Quality adjusted outputs
Quality adjusted
productivity
Inputs: Labour; purchases of goods and services;
capital services
Outputs: Total number of full time equivalent students
Quality adjustment: Number of individuals achieving
5 A*-C GCSE grades
Source: ONS
(https://www.ons.gov.uk/economy/economicoutputandproductivity/publicservicesproductivity/datasets/publicserviceproductivityestimateseducation)
* Including further education and training of teachers
What do the data show?
(d) Adult Social Care
19
• Inputs include labour, intermediate consumption of goods and services, and capital used by local authorities in providing adult social care
services and care purchased by local authorities from independent sector providers.
• Outputs: For services where activity data are available, the quantity of adult social care output (weeks in care, meals provided etc.) is
measured by calculating the growth rates of different adult social care activities and weighting these by their unit costs.
• The quality adjustment is based on the concept of adjusted social care-related quality of life and produced using data from the Adult Social
Care Survey. This quality adjustment measures changes in how well care clients’ needs are met across domains of quality of life affected by
social care, while controlling for factors outside the control of adult social care services which may also affect quality of life.
Source: ONS
(https://www.ons.gov.uk/economy/economicoutputandproductivity/publicservicesproductivity/articles/publicserviceproductivityadultsocialcareenglandfinancialyearen
ding2018/2019-02-06/relateddata)
60
80
100
120
140
160
180
200
1996/97 1999/00 2002/03 2005/06 2008/09 2011/12 2014/15 2017/18
Index,1996/97=100
UK adult social care inputs, output and productivity
Outputs
Quality adjustment begins
Productivity
Inputs
Part of the reduction in
productivity between
1996/97 and 2010/11
may be because the
output measure
makes no allowance
for quality over this
period. Where the
data are available
from 2010/11
onwards, quality-
adjusted productivity
does not fall.
No account is taken of
changes in clients’
needs (case mix) and
excludes non-Local
authority funded care
is excluded
What do the data show
(e) Local Government
20
64
65
66
67
70
72
17
16
12
13
13
13
18
19
22
19
16
13
0% 50% 100%
2018
2017
2016
2015
2014
2013
How satisfied or dissatisfied are
you with the way your local
council(s) runs things?
satisfied neither dissatisfied
Source: Local Government Association: Polling on resident satisfaction
with councils, 2018 Source: MHCLG Revenue Outturn / Revenue Accounts data. Central Government
Grant exclude schools, public health and housing benefit
ANALYSIS OF THE
TECHNICAL EFFICIENCY OF
LOCAL GOVERNMENT
21
What we’ve done
22
The UK Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government
has recently analysed, in some detail, the technical efficiency of local
government. This focused on local authority expenditure on different
services per unit of output, adjusted for quality, i.e. a lower unit cost
represents (all else being equal) greater efficiency.
The analysis compares a local authority with similar local authorities
for service quality to assess the potential for efficiency savings. A
‘similar local authority’ is defined by controls for service quality, wage
levels and property costs
The analysis controls for different local authority wage and property
costs by including an Area Cost Adjustment. The quality measures
include, for example: children entering a child protection plan for a
second time, social care quality adjusted life years and roads
considered in need of maintenance.
23
Service Area Net current
expenditure (16/17)
Share of
efficiency
savings
Adult Social Care £15bn 31%
Children’s Social Care £9bn 19%
Environmental protective and
cultural services excl. waste
& buses* £4bn 10%
Highway maintenance £2bn 10%
Waste* £3bn 9%
Planning & Development £1bn 8%
Corporate & Democratic* £1bn 4%
Homelessness <£1bn 3%
Fire & Rescue £2bn 3%
Subsidised buses £1bn 2%
What we’ve found
*Does not account for quality. For the purposes of illustration efficiency estimates have been halved
The scope for
efficiency
improvements
has been
estimated
assuming all
authorities
operate at the
median level of
efficiency of
similar
authorities
The scope for efficiency savings is not,
however, evenly distributed across local
authorities
24
Local authorities
The authorities with the greatest
potential for efficiency savings
vary from service to service
Our analysis also suggests that those
authorities that are relatively less efficient
tend to be those that are least resilient in
terms of financial sustainability
25
0
50
100150200
40 60 80 100 120 140
Responsibilities (%)
2019/20 assuming no efficiency savings 2019/20 with efficiency savings
Local Authority financial sustainability is
measured using two metrics:
(i) Financial reserves as a % of non-
discretionary spending (Reserves)
(ii) Level of spending on non-
discretionary activities as a % of
total core spending power
(Responsibilities)
Least financially
sustainable
*Core spending power measures the core revenue funding available for local authority services, including Council Tax and locally
retained business rates. Spending on non-discretionary activities can exceed 100% of core spending given funding from other sources
and reserves.
DRIVERS OF PUBLIC SECTOR
EFFICIENCY
26
Benchmarking
Effective use of
ICT
Strengthened
incentives
Front-line
service
integration
Channel shift
Intelligent
outsourcing
New entry
competition/
market creation
Effective use of
data
Empowering
users: Co-
production &
co-design
Shared
services
Organisational
structure
Workforce
capability &
leadership
Markets & Competition
Service re-design & alternative
delivery mechanisms
Technology, Data & TargetingOrganisation & Workforce
Drivers of public sector efficiency – the key
factors
Cost
benchmarking
Holding down
pay
Prevention/
early
intervention
Reconfiguring
services
Sharing best
practice
Technological
advances
Hard budget constraints
+
spending flexibility
27
There is no efficiency ‘silver
bullet.’ There are many levers
that need to be pulled to
improve public sector
efficiency.
Pay systems
Some case studies
28
• Public Service Data Dashboards
• Benchmarking: The Model Hospital
• The London Rough Sleeping Social Impact Bond
• The Troubled Families Programme
• Preventative Health Care
• Predictive Analytics
Public Service Data Dashboards
A means of providing
information on inputs, outputs
and outcomes in one place
Numbers that Government
departments recognise
Timely data drawn together
by the Office for National
Statistics. Incorporating
impartial guidance on
interpretation and
comparison of statistics
Outcomes which map broadly
to Government’s single
departmental plans
What are they?
29
Which drivers of public sector
efficiency do they address?
Cost
benchmarking
Effective use of
ICT
Effective use of
data
What do they show?
Key data for four
Departments:
Department of Work
and Pensions,
Department of Health
and Social Care,
Department for
Education and Ministry
of Justice.
Source: ONS
Benchmarking: The Model Hospital
The Model Hospital is a free online digital service for National Health Service staff and leaders to help identify performance
variation and local opportunities to improve both productivity and quality on the National Health Service front line.
It breaks down key metrics across all the activity of an NHS service provider.
What is it?
Which drivers of public
sector efficiency does it
address?
Effective use of
data
Cost
benchmarking
What are the
benefits?
Helping to deliver an
estimated £1.45bn of
savings from 2017-18
Source: NHS Improvement.
Sharing best
practice
Identify your
opportunities to
improve
Understand the
drivers of your
opportunities
Identify areas for
action
Develop a plan
Best practice and
direct support
Tracking and
monitoring of
delivery
The model hospital online service allows a service provider to access the efficiency gains they
could realise if they performed as well as the median or better hospitals in their ‘peer group’
(hospitals with most similar attributes and context).
The London Rough Sleeping Social Impact Bond
The London rough sleeping SIB
was a four year programme
designed to bring new finance
and new ways of working to
improve the outcomes for a
cohort of rough sleepers whose
needs were not being met by
existing services.
It aimed to test if outcomes could
be improved through a payment
by results structure.
What is it?
31
Which drivers of public sector efficiency does it address?
Strengthened
incentives
Front-line service
integration
Effective use of
data
How was it evaluated?
Comparison of outcomes using
administrative data for SIB cohort
and control group. Assessment of
impact on rough sleeping and
wider outcomes.
Findings
The results show that, when compared to a well-matched comparison group, the
intervention significantly reduced rough sleeping over a two year period.
On average the intervention group (the SIB group) had significantly fewer
episodes of rough sleeping compared to the comparison groups.
After two years: the mean number of rough sleeping contacts for the SIB group
was 9.2 compared to 13.9 for the comparison group. 40% of the SIB cohort did not
sleep rough at all in the two years after the start of the intervention compared to
33% of the comparison group
Source: https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/london-homelessness-social-impact-bond-evaluation
The Troubled Families Programme
Adults or children involved in crime or anti-
social behaviour
Children not attending school regularly
Adults out of work
Children who need help or are in need of or
subject to a child protection plan
Families affected by domestic violence and
abuse
Parents and children with a range of health
problems
32
What is it?
A programme that
aims to help families
placing high costs on
public services.
Programme runs
between 2015-
2020
Reaching 400k
families
Which drivers of public sector
efficiency does it address?
Strengthened
incentives
Front-line
service
integration
Effective use of
data
Workforce
capability &
leadership
Prevention/
early
intervention
Reconfiguring
services
Sharing best
practice
How has it been evaluated?
33
How is it being evaluated?
Which data is being linked?
What is the scale of the
administrative linked
data?
Impact Analysis using linked
administrative datasets to gather
outcome data on both an
intervention group and
comparison group.
Cost Benefit Analysis, applied
to the Impact Analysis findings,
using unit cost data on different
services and other evidence to
estimate public value and fiscal
benefits.
sentence
type
Police
National
Computer
National
Pupil
Database
Work &
Pensions
Longitudinal
Study
CRIME
EDUCATION &
CHILD
SAFEGUARDING
EMPLOYMENT
&
BENEFITS
convictions
sentence
length
in care
pupil referral
unit
educational
attainment
(KS1/2/3
scores)
exclusionsschool
absence
special
educational
needs
employment
type of
benefits
pay & tax
pensionstax credits
nature of
health
problems
295,435 families in total
46,907
families in the
comparison group
248,528
families in the
intervention group
864,205
individuals in the
intervention group
170,080
individuals in the
comparison group
In December 2017, around 295K
families were matched to
administrative datasets…
+ data from every upper tier local authority
0.5%
0.6%
1.0%
1.3%
1.7%
0.5%
1.1%
1.6%
2.1%
2.5%
0.0%
0.5%
1.0%
1.5%
2.0%
2.5%
3.0%
0-6 months
pre
0-6 months 7-12
months
13-18
months
19-24
months
The Troubled Families Programme – Impact Analysis
34
Smaller proportion of Looked After Children in
intervention group than comparison group.
Intervention Comparison
95% confidence interval
Smaller proportion of adults given custodial
sentences in the intervention group in the two
years after joining the programme
Anytime within two years
after programme:
Custodial
sentence
Cautioned Convicted
Proportion of adult
offenders on the
programme
1.2% 1.9% 5.9%
Proportion of adult
offenders in the
comparison group
1.6% 2.2% 6.1%
Difference -0.4%*** -0.3% -0.3%
Note: statistically significant difference; *** p value <0.001.
%Childrenincare
These impacts are sufficient to produce outturn
monetised benefits greater than the costs
Preventative Health Care
Preventative health care is about stopping problems (e.g. by vaccination or stopping smoking); spotting problems early (e.g.
screening for illness); and maintaining independence (e.g. rehabilitation). The National Health Service currently spends
around £97bn on treatment and £8bn on preventative care.
What is it?
Which drivers of public sector efficiency does it address?
Effective use of
data
Cost
benchmarking
Prevention/ early
intervention
Technological
advances
Inputs
Doctors, medicines,
equipment, etc.
Outputs
GP visits, operations,
prescriptions, etc.
Outcomes
Patient experience,
QALYs etc.
What are the benefits?
It promotes improved allocative efficiency – shifting resources to more effective interventions
To become more
technically efficient, we
need to reduce input costs
and / or inputs per unit of
output.
To become more allocatively
efficient, we need to produce
more effective outputs and fewer
of the less effective ones.
It costs the National Health Service ~
£15k to produce one QALY. By
contrast public health interventions
have a QALY of around £8k – though
there is large variation
NHS total factor
productivity growth has
outperformed the wider
public sector and UK
economy in the last 20
years
Sources: Marginal cost per Quality Adjusted Life Year (QALY) (York University research); Owen et al (2017) - https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/28977629
Predictive Analytics
36
Which drivers of public sector
efficiency do they address?
Effective use of
data
Prevention/
early
intervention
Technological
advances
Effective use of
ICT
Aim
Develop predictive risk
modelling tools to assist
child welfare screening and
other decisions
To improve the effective
targeting of services
towards vulnerable children
and other groups
Method
Photo: Cate Dingley for The New York Times
Article by Dan Hurley Jan., 2018: https://www.nytimes.com/2018/01/02/magazine/can-an-algorithm-tell-when-kids-are-in-danger.html
Predictive algorithms. Sky news: https://news.sky.com/story/predictive-algorithms-hidden-revolution-taking-place-in-uks-councils-and-police-forces-11650160
What is it?
What are the benefits?
At least 53 local authorities and 14 police forces are
using predictive algorithms in the UK for applications
as varied as traffic management and identifying
children at risk of neglect or abuse. By allowing
earlier intervention and better targeting of
interventions they help to improve outcomes for
citizens, reduce costs and improve efficiency.
THE SCOPE FOR IMPROVING
EFFICIENCY FURTHER
37
38
Markets and
competition
Service redesigns
and alternative
delivery mechanisms
Technology, data
and targeting
Hard budget
constraints and
spending flexibility
Organisation and
workforce
£££
££
££
£££
£
£
££
££
££
£££
££
£££
£££
££
££
Short term Medium term Long term
Short term: Implemented in the next 1 to 2 years
Medium term: Implemented in the next 5 years
Long term: Implemented beyond the next 5 years
£ limited scope for efficiencies,
££ some scope for efficiencies,
£££ substantial scope for efficiencies
Assessment of the scope for improving
efficiency further
Drivers of efficiency Our analysis of past
trends and future scope
suggests:
• Hard budget
constraints and
organisational and
workforce changes
– including pay
constraint – are
powerful drivers in
the short run
• Service re-design
and more
competition matter
in the medium term
• Technology and
data are longer term
drivers
However, there is
potential for these
drivers to be mutually
reinforcing.
NEXT STEPS
39
Next Steps
40
(a) Public Value and the Public Value
Framework:
What is it?
A new framework to build a stronger public
value and efficiency culture at all levels
across the public sector. It is currently
being piloted and the framework refined.
Government departments will be required
to report on public value performance and
the improvements they will make against
the framework in their 2019/20 Single
Departmental Plans.
Public value is expected to play a key role
in the 2019 Spending Review
Source: https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/delivering-better-outcomes-for-citizens-practical-steps-for-unlocking-public-
value and https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/public-value-framework-and-supplementary-guidance
Next Steps
41
(b) Public Sector Efficiency Group
What is it?
A cross-departmental analysts’ group that meets every 3-4 months, comprising of colleagues across
Whitehall with an interest in public sector efficiency.
What does it do?
i) Bring together evidence on efficiency trends and drivers.
UK and international evidence  Literature reviews
Departments’ efficiency stories  Department papers
Advice from experts and practitioners  Experts workshops
ii) Draws out insights for achieving further efficiency improvements.
iii) Disseminates findings from key pieces of analytical work and research and produces reports.
(c) Promoting data analytics and evidence of what works across the wider public
sector
The Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government and the Cabinet Office have established a
local authority what works and data analytics network. There are now also 12 Office of Data Analytics
across local government.
(d) Office for National Statistics
Ongoing work by the ONS Public Sector Efficiency Measurement Unit to improve data and statistics.

Contenu connexe

Tendances

Alexandert Himbert - Trade facilitation and spatial patterns of economic acti...
Alexandert Himbert - Trade facilitation and spatial patterns of economic acti...Alexandert Himbert - Trade facilitation and spatial patterns of economic acti...
Alexandert Himbert - Trade facilitation and spatial patterns of economic acti...OECD CFE
 
Productivity, Agglomeration and Metro Governance
Productivity, Agglomeration and Metro GovernanceProductivity, Agglomeration and Metro Governance
Productivity, Agglomeration and Metro GovernanceStructuralpolicyanalysis
 
The Global Productivity Slowdown, Technology Divergence and Public Policy: A ...
The Global Productivity Slowdown, Technology Divergence and Public Policy: A ...The Global Productivity Slowdown, Technology Divergence and Public Policy: A ...
The Global Productivity Slowdown, Technology Divergence and Public Policy: A ...Structuralpolicyanalysis
 
Productivity Spillovers, Diffusion and Public Policies: A Portuguese Perspective
Productivity Spillovers, Diffusion and Public Policies: A Portuguese PerspectiveProductivity Spillovers, Diffusion and Public Policies: A Portuguese Perspective
Productivity Spillovers, Diffusion and Public Policies: A Portuguese PerspectiveStructuralpolicyanalysis
 
Jonathan Timmis - Cloud computing and firm growth
Jonathan Timmis - Cloud computing and firm growthJonathan Timmis - Cloud computing and firm growth
Jonathan Timmis - Cloud computing and firm growthOECD CFE
 
The Global Productivity Slowdown, Technology Diffusion and Public Policy
The Global Productivity Slowdown, Technology Diffusion and Public PolicyThe Global Productivity Slowdown, Technology Diffusion and Public Policy
The Global Productivity Slowdown, Technology Diffusion and Public PolicyStructuralpolicyanalysis
 
service innovation and the EU economy
service innovation and the EU economyservice innovation and the EU economy
service innovation and the EU economyIan Miles
 
Local or Global Sourcing and Firms' Performance: Empirical Evidence from the ...
Local or Global Sourcing and Firms' Performance: Empirical Evidence from the ...Local or Global Sourcing and Firms' Performance: Empirical Evidence from the ...
Local or Global Sourcing and Firms' Performance: Empirical Evidence from the ...Structuralpolicyanalysis
 
State of the economy session. small businesses and the pandemic
State of the economy session. small businesses and the pandemicState of the economy session. small businesses and the pandemic
State of the economy session. small businesses and the pandemicenterpriseresearchcentre
 
The Relationship Between GVCs and Productivity
The Relationship Between GVCs and ProductivityThe Relationship Between GVCs and Productivity
The Relationship Between GVCs and ProductivityStructuralpolicyanalysis
 
IAOS 2018 - Towards a framework for measuring the digital economy, N. Ahmad
IAOS 2018 - Towards a framework for measuring the digital economy, N. AhmadIAOS 2018 - Towards a framework for measuring the digital economy, N. Ahmad
IAOS 2018 - Towards a framework for measuring the digital economy, N. AhmadStatsCommunications
 
The Productivity-Wage Nexus in Selected OECD Countries
The Productivity-Wage Nexus in Selected OECD CountriesThe Productivity-Wage Nexus in Selected OECD Countries
The Productivity-Wage Nexus in Selected OECD CountriesStructuralpolicyanalysis
 
Public Service Productivity: Some Food for Thought
Public Service Productivity: Some Food for ThoughtPublic Service Productivity: Some Food for Thought
Public Service Productivity: Some Food for ThoughtStructuralpolicyanalysis
 
The Role of Production Factor Quality and Technology Diffusion in 20th Centur...
The Role of Production Factor Quality and Technology Diffusion in 20th Centur...The Role of Production Factor Quality and Technology Diffusion in 20th Centur...
The Role of Production Factor Quality and Technology Diffusion in 20th Centur...Structuralpolicyanalysis
 
UK productivity: challenging every business to improve
UK productivity: challenging every business to improveUK productivity: challenging every business to improve
UK productivity: challenging every business to improveStructuralpolicyanalysis
 

Tendances (20)

Alexandert Himbert - Trade facilitation and spatial patterns of economic acti...
Alexandert Himbert - Trade facilitation and spatial patterns of economic acti...Alexandert Himbert - Trade facilitation and spatial patterns of economic acti...
Alexandert Himbert - Trade facilitation and spatial patterns of economic acti...
 
Productivity, Agglomeration and Metro Governance
Productivity, Agglomeration and Metro GovernanceProductivity, Agglomeration and Metro Governance
Productivity, Agglomeration and Metro Governance
 
The Global Productivity Slowdown, Technology Divergence and Public Policy: A ...
The Global Productivity Slowdown, Technology Divergence and Public Policy: A ...The Global Productivity Slowdown, Technology Divergence and Public Policy: A ...
The Global Productivity Slowdown, Technology Divergence and Public Policy: A ...
 
Productivity Spillovers, Diffusion and Public Policies: A Portuguese Perspective
Productivity Spillovers, Diffusion and Public Policies: A Portuguese PerspectiveProductivity Spillovers, Diffusion and Public Policies: A Portuguese Perspective
Productivity Spillovers, Diffusion and Public Policies: A Portuguese Perspective
 
Jonathan Timmis - Cloud computing and firm growth
Jonathan Timmis - Cloud computing and firm growthJonathan Timmis - Cloud computing and firm growth
Jonathan Timmis - Cloud computing and firm growth
 
The Productivity-Inclusiveness Nexus
The Productivity-Inclusiveness NexusThe Productivity-Inclusiveness Nexus
The Productivity-Inclusiveness Nexus
 
The Global Productivity Slowdown, Technology Diffusion and Public Policy
The Global Productivity Slowdown, Technology Diffusion and Public PolicyThe Global Productivity Slowdown, Technology Diffusion and Public Policy
The Global Productivity Slowdown, Technology Diffusion and Public Policy
 
service innovation and the EU economy
service innovation and the EU economyservice innovation and the EU economy
service innovation and the EU economy
 
Local or Global Sourcing and Firms' Performance: Empirical Evidence from the ...
Local or Global Sourcing and Firms' Performance: Empirical Evidence from the ...Local or Global Sourcing and Firms' Performance: Empirical Evidence from the ...
Local or Global Sourcing and Firms' Performance: Empirical Evidence from the ...
 
State of the economy session. small businesses and the pandemic
State of the economy session. small businesses and the pandemicState of the economy session. small businesses and the pandemic
State of the economy session. small businesses and the pandemic
 
The Relationship Between GVCs and Productivity
The Relationship Between GVCs and ProductivityThe Relationship Between GVCs and Productivity
The Relationship Between GVCs and Productivity
 
Productivity and Cities
Productivity and CitiesProductivity and Cities
Productivity and Cities
 
IAOS 2018 - Towards a framework for measuring the digital economy, N. Ahmad
IAOS 2018 - Towards a framework for measuring the digital economy, N. AhmadIAOS 2018 - Towards a framework for measuring the digital economy, N. Ahmad
IAOS 2018 - Towards a framework for measuring the digital economy, N. Ahmad
 
Measuring GDP in a digitalised economy
 Measuring GDP in a digitalised economy Measuring GDP in a digitalised economy
Measuring GDP in a digitalised economy
 
The Productivity-Wage Nexus in Selected OECD Countries
The Productivity-Wage Nexus in Selected OECD CountriesThe Productivity-Wage Nexus in Selected OECD Countries
The Productivity-Wage Nexus in Selected OECD Countries
 
Public Service Productivity: Some Food for Thought
Public Service Productivity: Some Food for ThoughtPublic Service Productivity: Some Food for Thought
Public Service Productivity: Some Food for Thought
 
The Role of Production Factor Quality and Technology Diffusion in 20th Centur...
The Role of Production Factor Quality and Technology Diffusion in 20th Centur...The Role of Production Factor Quality and Technology Diffusion in 20th Centur...
The Role of Production Factor Quality and Technology Diffusion in 20th Centur...
 
Productivity and structural reforms
Productivity and structural reformsProductivity and structural reforms
Productivity and structural reforms
 
UK productivity: challenging every business to improve
UK productivity: challenging every business to improveUK productivity: challenging every business to improve
UK productivity: challenging every business to improve
 
Public Sector Productivity Challenges
Public Sector Productivity ChallengesPublic Sector Productivity Challenges
Public Sector Productivity Challenges
 

Similaire à Stephen Aldridge -Public sector efficiency in the UK

public service innovation
public service innovationpublic service innovation
public service innovationIan Miles
 
What are the challenges in measuring pulic sector efficiency? - Julian Kelly,...
What are the challenges in measuring pulic sector efficiency? - Julian Kelly,...What are the challenges in measuring pulic sector efficiency? - Julian Kelly,...
What are the challenges in measuring pulic sector efficiency? - Julian Kelly,...OECD Governance
 
Public Sector Productivity - Ronnie Downes and Sean Dougherty, OECD
 Public Sector Productivity - Ronnie Downes and Sean Dougherty, OECD Public Sector Productivity - Ronnie Downes and Sean Dougherty, OECD
Public Sector Productivity - Ronnie Downes and Sean Dougherty, OECDOECD Governance
 
Presentation by Christian Kastrop on 'Productivity and Public Sector Performa...
Presentation by Christian Kastrop on 'Productivity and Public Sector Performa...Presentation by Christian Kastrop on 'Productivity and Public Sector Performa...
Presentation by Christian Kastrop on 'Productivity and Public Sector Performa...OECD Governance
 
Productivity and public sector performance - Christian Kastrop, OECD Secretariat
Productivity and public sector performance - Christian Kastrop, OECD SecretariatProductivity and public sector performance - Christian Kastrop, OECD Secretariat
Productivity and public sector performance - Christian Kastrop, OECD SecretariatOECD Governance
 
Tiểu luận tiếng anh thương mại đại học Ngoại Thương Kinh Tế Vi Mô
Tiểu luận tiếng anh thương mại đại học Ngoại Thương Kinh Tế Vi MôTiểu luận tiếng anh thương mại đại học Ngoại Thương Kinh Tế Vi Mô
Tiểu luận tiếng anh thương mại đại học Ngoại Thương Kinh Tế Vi MôDịch vụ Làm Luận Văn 0936885877
 
Ecb working paper 242 public sector efficiency an international comparison
Ecb working paper 242 public sector efficiency an international comparisonEcb working paper 242 public sector efficiency an international comparison
Ecb working paper 242 public sector efficiency an international comparisonPiet De Pauw
 
intelligent-workplace-white-paper
intelligent-workplace-white-paperintelligent-workplace-white-paper
intelligent-workplace-white-paperJamie Hall
 
Greece-2016-oecd-economic-survey-ensuring-inclusive-recovery-10-march
Greece-2016-oecd-economic-survey-ensuring-inclusive-recovery-10-marchGreece-2016-oecd-economic-survey-ensuring-inclusive-recovery-10-march
Greece-2016-oecd-economic-survey-ensuring-inclusive-recovery-10-marchOECD, Economics Department
 
The power of productivity and uk prosperity
The power of productivity and uk prosperityThe power of productivity and uk prosperity
The power of productivity and uk prosperityross harling
 
Fiscal space and the composition of public finances - Jean-Marc Fournier, OECD
Fiscal space and the composition of public finances - Jean-Marc Fournier, OECDFiscal space and the composition of public finances - Jean-Marc Fournier, OECD
Fiscal space and the composition of public finances - Jean-Marc Fournier, OECDOECD Governance
 
Procurex national bill hall - deloitte
Procurex national   bill hall - deloitteProcurex national   bill hall - deloitte
Procurex national bill hall - deloitteScottMacBiP
 
Evaluation of Integrated Care: From methods to governance and applications - ...
Evaluation of Integrated Care: From methods to governance and applications - ...Evaluation of Integrated Care: From methods to governance and applications - ...
Evaluation of Integrated Care: From methods to governance and applications - ...Francisco Lupiáñez-Villanueva
 
User satisfaction and administrative simplification within the perspective of...
User satisfaction and administrative simplification within the perspective of...User satisfaction and administrative simplification within the perspective of...
User satisfaction and administrative simplification within the perspective of...ePractice.eu
 
Opening up our data using fme
Opening up our data using fmeOpening up our data using fme
Opening up our data using fmeKamrul Kashem
 
Spending reviews - Stefan Kiss, Slovak Republic
Spending reviews - Stefan Kiss, Slovak RepublicSpending reviews - Stefan Kiss, Slovak Republic
Spending reviews - Stefan Kiss, Slovak RepublicOECD Governance
 

Similaire à Stephen Aldridge -Public sector efficiency in the UK (20)

public service innovation
public service innovationpublic service innovation
public service innovation
 
What are the challenges in measuring pulic sector efficiency? - Julian Kelly,...
What are the challenges in measuring pulic sector efficiency? - Julian Kelly,...What are the challenges in measuring pulic sector efficiency? - Julian Kelly,...
What are the challenges in measuring pulic sector efficiency? - Julian Kelly,...
 
Public Sector Productivity - Ronnie Downes and Sean Dougherty, OECD
 Public Sector Productivity - Ronnie Downes and Sean Dougherty, OECD Public Sector Productivity - Ronnie Downes and Sean Dougherty, OECD
Public Sector Productivity - Ronnie Downes and Sean Dougherty, OECD
 
Presentation by Christian Kastrop on 'Productivity and Public Sector Performa...
Presentation by Christian Kastrop on 'Productivity and Public Sector Performa...Presentation by Christian Kastrop on 'Productivity and Public Sector Performa...
Presentation by Christian Kastrop on 'Productivity and Public Sector Performa...
 
Productivity and public sector performance - Christian Kastrop, OECD Secretariat
Productivity and public sector performance - Christian Kastrop, OECD SecretariatProductivity and public sector performance - Christian Kastrop, OECD Secretariat
Productivity and public sector performance - Christian Kastrop, OECD Secretariat
 
AFD Proparco - April 2018 Results Community Workshop
AFD Proparco - April 2018 Results Community WorkshopAFD Proparco - April 2018 Results Community Workshop
AFD Proparco - April 2018 Results Community Workshop
 
Tiểu luận tiếng anh thương mại đại học Ngoại Thương Kinh Tế Vi Mô
Tiểu luận tiếng anh thương mại đại học Ngoại Thương Kinh Tế Vi MôTiểu luận tiếng anh thương mại đại học Ngoại Thương Kinh Tế Vi Mô
Tiểu luận tiếng anh thương mại đại học Ngoại Thương Kinh Tế Vi Mô
 
Ecb working paper 242 public sector efficiency an international comparison
Ecb working paper 242 public sector efficiency an international comparisonEcb working paper 242 public sector efficiency an international comparison
Ecb working paper 242 public sector efficiency an international comparison
 
intelligent-workplace-white-paper
intelligent-workplace-white-paperintelligent-workplace-white-paper
intelligent-workplace-white-paper
 
Portugal economic-survey-main-findings
Portugal economic-survey-main-findingsPortugal economic-survey-main-findings
Portugal economic-survey-main-findings
 
Greece-2016-oecd-economic-survey-ensuring-inclusive-recovery-10-march
Greece-2016-oecd-economic-survey-ensuring-inclusive-recovery-10-marchGreece-2016-oecd-economic-survey-ensuring-inclusive-recovery-10-march
Greece-2016-oecd-economic-survey-ensuring-inclusive-recovery-10-march
 
The power of productivity and uk prosperity
The power of productivity and uk prosperityThe power of productivity and uk prosperity
The power of productivity and uk prosperity
 
Efficiency Analysis of Health Sector Expenditure Allocation in 2020 (Case Stu...
Efficiency Analysis of Health Sector Expenditure Allocation in 2020 (Case Stu...Efficiency Analysis of Health Sector Expenditure Allocation in 2020 (Case Stu...
Efficiency Analysis of Health Sector Expenditure Allocation in 2020 (Case Stu...
 
Fiscal space and the composition of public finances - Jean-Marc Fournier, OECD
Fiscal space and the composition of public finances - Jean-Marc Fournier, OECDFiscal space and the composition of public finances - Jean-Marc Fournier, OECD
Fiscal space and the composition of public finances - Jean-Marc Fournier, OECD
 
Procurex national bill hall - deloitte
Procurex national   bill hall - deloitteProcurex national   bill hall - deloitte
Procurex national bill hall - deloitte
 
Evaluation of Integrated Care: From methods to governance and applications - ...
Evaluation of Integrated Care: From methods to governance and applications - ...Evaluation of Integrated Care: From methods to governance and applications - ...
Evaluation of Integrated Care: From methods to governance and applications - ...
 
User satisfaction and administrative simplification within the perspective of...
User satisfaction and administrative simplification within the perspective of...User satisfaction and administrative simplification within the perspective of...
User satisfaction and administrative simplification within the perspective of...
 
Opening up our data using fme
Opening up our data using fmeOpening up our data using fme
Opening up our data using fme
 
Spending reviews - Stefan Kiss, Slovak Republic
Spending reviews - Stefan Kiss, Slovak RepublicSpending reviews - Stefan Kiss, Slovak Republic
Spending reviews - Stefan Kiss, Slovak Republic
 
Jaana Remes
Jaana RemesJaana Remes
Jaana Remes
 

Plus de OECD CFE

Servizio Civile Universale - Serena SUSIGAN
Servizio Civile Universale - Serena SUSIGANServizio Civile Universale - Serena SUSIGAN
Servizio Civile Universale - Serena SUSIGANOECD CFE
 
Servizio Civile Universale - Federica DE LUCA
Servizio Civile Universale - Federica DE LUCAServizio Civile Universale - Federica DE LUCA
Servizio Civile Universale - Federica DE LUCAOECD CFE
 
Servizio Civile Universale - Cristina PASCHETTA
Servizio Civile Universale - Cristina PASCHETTAServizio Civile Universale - Cristina PASCHETTA
Servizio Civile Universale - Cristina PASCHETTAOECD CFE
 
FDI and Superstar Spillovers: Evidence from Firm-to-Firm Transactions - Amit...
FDI and Superstar Spillovers: Evidence from Firm-to-Firm Transactions  - Amit...FDI and Superstar Spillovers: Evidence from Firm-to-Firm Transactions  - Amit...
FDI and Superstar Spillovers: Evidence from Firm-to-Firm Transactions - Amit...OECD CFE
 
E-invoicing data for functional territories definition: the use case of pharm...
E-invoicing data for functional territories definition: the use case of pharm...E-invoicing data for functional territories definition: the use case of pharm...
E-invoicing data for functional territories definition: the use case of pharm...OECD CFE
 
Mapping location and co-location of industries at the neighborhood level - A...
Mapping location and co-location of industries at the neighborhood level  - A...Mapping location and co-location of industries at the neighborhood level  - A...
Mapping location and co-location of industries at the neighborhood level - A...OECD CFE
 
Advancing and democratizing business data in Canada- Patrick Gill & Stephen Tapp
Advancing and democratizing business data in Canada- Patrick Gill & Stephen TappAdvancing and democratizing business data in Canada- Patrick Gill & Stephen Tapp
Advancing and democratizing business data in Canada- Patrick Gill & Stephen TappOECD CFE
 
Firm-level production networks: evidence from Estonia - Louise Guillouet
Firm-level production networks: evidence from Estonia - Louise GuillouetFirm-level production networks: evidence from Estonia - Louise Guillouet
Firm-level production networks: evidence from Estonia - Louise GuillouetOECD CFE
 
Using B2B transactions data: teh Belgian experience - Emmanuel Dhyne
Using B2B transactions data: teh Belgian experience - Emmanuel DhyneUsing B2B transactions data: teh Belgian experience - Emmanuel Dhyne
Using B2B transactions data: teh Belgian experience - Emmanuel DhyneOECD CFE
 
Horizon 2020 - research networks across borders - Rupert Kawka
Horizon 2020 - research networks across borders - Rupert KawkaHorizon 2020 - research networks across borders - Rupert Kawka
Horizon 2020 - research networks across borders - Rupert KawkaOECD CFE
 
How can the social and solidarity economy help refugees along their journey?
How can the social and solidarity economy help refugees along their journey?How can the social and solidarity economy help refugees along their journey?
How can the social and solidarity economy help refugees along their journey?OECD CFE
 
Platform cooperatives Webinar ppt
Platform cooperatives Webinar pptPlatform cooperatives Webinar ppt
Platform cooperatives Webinar pptOECD CFE
 
Data-driven regional productivity scorecards in the United Kingdom - Raquel O...
Data-driven regional productivity scorecards in the United Kingdom - Raquel O...Data-driven regional productivity scorecards in the United Kingdom - Raquel O...
Data-driven regional productivity scorecards in the United Kingdom - Raquel O...OECD CFE
 
Competitiveness for Wellbeing - Basque Country - James Wilson.pdf
Competitiveness for Wellbeing - Basque Country - James Wilson.pdfCompetitiveness for Wellbeing - Basque Country - James Wilson.pdf
Competitiveness for Wellbeing - Basque Country - James Wilson.pdfOECD CFE
 
The productivity board of the autonomous province of Trento - Carlo Menon.pdf
The productivity board of the autonomous province of Trento - Carlo Menon.pdfThe productivity board of the autonomous province of Trento - Carlo Menon.pdf
The productivity board of the autonomous province of Trento - Carlo Menon.pdfOECD CFE
 
Rafforzare il partenariato e la cooperazione internazionale in Friuli Venezia...
Rafforzare il partenariato e la cooperazione internazionale in Friuli Venezia...Rafforzare il partenariato e la cooperazione internazionale in Friuli Venezia...
Rafforzare il partenariato e la cooperazione internazionale in Friuli Venezia...OECD CFE
 
Immersive technologies and new audiences for classical ballet-Rogers
Immersive technologies and new audiences for classical ballet-RogersImmersive technologies and new audiences for classical ballet-Rogers
Immersive technologies and new audiences for classical ballet-RogersOECD CFE
 
Data-driven art residencies to reshape the media value chain-Blot
Data-driven art residencies to reshape the media value chain-BlotData-driven art residencies to reshape the media value chain-Blot
Data-driven art residencies to reshape the media value chain-BlotOECD CFE
 
Web 3 ecosystem - Assi-Lama.pdf
Web 3 ecosystem - Assi-Lama.pdfWeb 3 ecosystem - Assi-Lama.pdf
Web 3 ecosystem - Assi-Lama.pdfOECD CFE
 
Taking history to the future - Verwayen
Taking history to the future - VerwayenTaking history to the future - Verwayen
Taking history to the future - VerwayenOECD CFE
 

Plus de OECD CFE (20)

Servizio Civile Universale - Serena SUSIGAN
Servizio Civile Universale - Serena SUSIGANServizio Civile Universale - Serena SUSIGAN
Servizio Civile Universale - Serena SUSIGAN
 
Servizio Civile Universale - Federica DE LUCA
Servizio Civile Universale - Federica DE LUCAServizio Civile Universale - Federica DE LUCA
Servizio Civile Universale - Federica DE LUCA
 
Servizio Civile Universale - Cristina PASCHETTA
Servizio Civile Universale - Cristina PASCHETTAServizio Civile Universale - Cristina PASCHETTA
Servizio Civile Universale - Cristina PASCHETTA
 
FDI and Superstar Spillovers: Evidence from Firm-to-Firm Transactions - Amit...
FDI and Superstar Spillovers: Evidence from Firm-to-Firm Transactions  - Amit...FDI and Superstar Spillovers: Evidence from Firm-to-Firm Transactions  - Amit...
FDI and Superstar Spillovers: Evidence from Firm-to-Firm Transactions - Amit...
 
E-invoicing data for functional territories definition: the use case of pharm...
E-invoicing data for functional territories definition: the use case of pharm...E-invoicing data for functional territories definition: the use case of pharm...
E-invoicing data for functional territories definition: the use case of pharm...
 
Mapping location and co-location of industries at the neighborhood level - A...
Mapping location and co-location of industries at the neighborhood level  - A...Mapping location and co-location of industries at the neighborhood level  - A...
Mapping location and co-location of industries at the neighborhood level - A...
 
Advancing and democratizing business data in Canada- Patrick Gill & Stephen Tapp
Advancing and democratizing business data in Canada- Patrick Gill & Stephen TappAdvancing and democratizing business data in Canada- Patrick Gill & Stephen Tapp
Advancing and democratizing business data in Canada- Patrick Gill & Stephen Tapp
 
Firm-level production networks: evidence from Estonia - Louise Guillouet
Firm-level production networks: evidence from Estonia - Louise GuillouetFirm-level production networks: evidence from Estonia - Louise Guillouet
Firm-level production networks: evidence from Estonia - Louise Guillouet
 
Using B2B transactions data: teh Belgian experience - Emmanuel Dhyne
Using B2B transactions data: teh Belgian experience - Emmanuel DhyneUsing B2B transactions data: teh Belgian experience - Emmanuel Dhyne
Using B2B transactions data: teh Belgian experience - Emmanuel Dhyne
 
Horizon 2020 - research networks across borders - Rupert Kawka
Horizon 2020 - research networks across borders - Rupert KawkaHorizon 2020 - research networks across borders - Rupert Kawka
Horizon 2020 - research networks across borders - Rupert Kawka
 
How can the social and solidarity economy help refugees along their journey?
How can the social and solidarity economy help refugees along their journey?How can the social and solidarity economy help refugees along their journey?
How can the social and solidarity economy help refugees along their journey?
 
Platform cooperatives Webinar ppt
Platform cooperatives Webinar pptPlatform cooperatives Webinar ppt
Platform cooperatives Webinar ppt
 
Data-driven regional productivity scorecards in the United Kingdom - Raquel O...
Data-driven regional productivity scorecards in the United Kingdom - Raquel O...Data-driven regional productivity scorecards in the United Kingdom - Raquel O...
Data-driven regional productivity scorecards in the United Kingdom - Raquel O...
 
Competitiveness for Wellbeing - Basque Country - James Wilson.pdf
Competitiveness for Wellbeing - Basque Country - James Wilson.pdfCompetitiveness for Wellbeing - Basque Country - James Wilson.pdf
Competitiveness for Wellbeing - Basque Country - James Wilson.pdf
 
The productivity board of the autonomous province of Trento - Carlo Menon.pdf
The productivity board of the autonomous province of Trento - Carlo Menon.pdfThe productivity board of the autonomous province of Trento - Carlo Menon.pdf
The productivity board of the autonomous province of Trento - Carlo Menon.pdf
 
Rafforzare il partenariato e la cooperazione internazionale in Friuli Venezia...
Rafforzare il partenariato e la cooperazione internazionale in Friuli Venezia...Rafforzare il partenariato e la cooperazione internazionale in Friuli Venezia...
Rafforzare il partenariato e la cooperazione internazionale in Friuli Venezia...
 
Immersive technologies and new audiences for classical ballet-Rogers
Immersive technologies and new audiences for classical ballet-RogersImmersive technologies and new audiences for classical ballet-Rogers
Immersive technologies and new audiences for classical ballet-Rogers
 
Data-driven art residencies to reshape the media value chain-Blot
Data-driven art residencies to reshape the media value chain-BlotData-driven art residencies to reshape the media value chain-Blot
Data-driven art residencies to reshape the media value chain-Blot
 
Web 3 ecosystem - Assi-Lama.pdf
Web 3 ecosystem - Assi-Lama.pdfWeb 3 ecosystem - Assi-Lama.pdf
Web 3 ecosystem - Assi-Lama.pdf
 
Taking history to the future - Verwayen
Taking history to the future - VerwayenTaking history to the future - Verwayen
Taking history to the future - Verwayen
 

Dernier

Expressive clarity oral presentation.pptx
Expressive clarity oral presentation.pptxExpressive clarity oral presentation.pptx
Expressive clarity oral presentation.pptxtsionhagos36
 
Artificial Intelligence in Philippine Local Governance: Challenges and Opport...
Artificial Intelligence in Philippine Local Governance: Challenges and Opport...Artificial Intelligence in Philippine Local Governance: Challenges and Opport...
Artificial Intelligence in Philippine Local Governance: Challenges and Opport...CedZabala
 
Goa Escorts WhatsApp Number South Goa Call Girl … 8588052666…
Goa Escorts WhatsApp Number South Goa Call Girl … 8588052666…Goa Escorts WhatsApp Number South Goa Call Girl … 8588052666…
Goa Escorts WhatsApp Number South Goa Call Girl … 8588052666…nishakur201
 
VIP High Class Call Girls Amravati Anushka 8250192130 Independent Escort Serv...
VIP High Class Call Girls Amravati Anushka 8250192130 Independent Escort Serv...VIP High Class Call Girls Amravati Anushka 8250192130 Independent Escort Serv...
VIP High Class Call Girls Amravati Anushka 8250192130 Independent Escort Serv...Suhani Kapoor
 
WIPO magazine issue -1 - 2024 World Intellectual Property organization.
WIPO magazine issue -1 - 2024 World Intellectual Property organization.WIPO magazine issue -1 - 2024 World Intellectual Property organization.
WIPO magazine issue -1 - 2024 World Intellectual Property organization.Christina Parmionova
 
VIP Russian Call Girls in Indore Ishita 💚😋 9256729539 🚀 Indore Escorts
VIP Russian Call Girls in Indore Ishita 💚😋  9256729539 🚀 Indore EscortsVIP Russian Call Girls in Indore Ishita 💚😋  9256729539 🚀 Indore Escorts
VIP Russian Call Girls in Indore Ishita 💚😋 9256729539 🚀 Indore Escortsaditipandeya
 
Top Rated Pune Call Girls Hadapsar ⟟ 6297143586 ⟟ Call Me For Genuine Sex Se...
Top Rated  Pune Call Girls Hadapsar ⟟ 6297143586 ⟟ Call Me For Genuine Sex Se...Top Rated  Pune Call Girls Hadapsar ⟟ 6297143586 ⟟ Call Me For Genuine Sex Se...
Top Rated Pune Call Girls Hadapsar ⟟ 6297143586 ⟟ Call Me For Genuine Sex Se...Call Girls in Nagpur High Profile
 
(PRIYA) Call Girls Rajgurunagar ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Service
(PRIYA) Call Girls Rajgurunagar ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Service(PRIYA) Call Girls Rajgurunagar ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Service
(PRIYA) Call Girls Rajgurunagar ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Serviceranjana rawat
 
Lucknow 💋 Russian Call Girls Lucknow ₹7.5k Pick Up & Drop With Cash Payment 8...
Lucknow 💋 Russian Call Girls Lucknow ₹7.5k Pick Up & Drop With Cash Payment 8...Lucknow 💋 Russian Call Girls Lucknow ₹7.5k Pick Up & Drop With Cash Payment 8...
Lucknow 💋 Russian Call Girls Lucknow ₹7.5k Pick Up & Drop With Cash Payment 8...anilsa9823
 
Precarious profits? Why firms use insecure contracts, and what would change t...
Precarious profits? Why firms use insecure contracts, and what would change t...Precarious profits? Why firms use insecure contracts, and what would change t...
Precarious profits? Why firms use insecure contracts, and what would change t...ResolutionFoundation
 
##9711199012 Call Girls Delhi Rs-5000 UpTo 10 K Hauz Khas Whats Up Number
##9711199012 Call Girls Delhi Rs-5000 UpTo 10 K Hauz Khas  Whats Up Number##9711199012 Call Girls Delhi Rs-5000 UpTo 10 K Hauz Khas  Whats Up Number
##9711199012 Call Girls Delhi Rs-5000 UpTo 10 K Hauz Khas Whats Up NumberMs Riya
 
↑VVIP celebrity ( Pune ) Serampore Call Girls 8250192130 unlimited shot and a...
↑VVIP celebrity ( Pune ) Serampore Call Girls 8250192130 unlimited shot and a...↑VVIP celebrity ( Pune ) Serampore Call Girls 8250192130 unlimited shot and a...
↑VVIP celebrity ( Pune ) Serampore Call Girls 8250192130 unlimited shot and a...ranjana rawat
 
Item # 4 - 231 Encino Ave (Significance Only).pdf
Item # 4 - 231 Encino Ave (Significance Only).pdfItem # 4 - 231 Encino Ave (Significance Only).pdf
Item # 4 - 231 Encino Ave (Significance Only).pdfahcitycouncil
 
(DIVYA) Call Girls Wakad ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Service
(DIVYA) Call Girls Wakad ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Service(DIVYA) Call Girls Wakad ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Service
(DIVYA) Call Girls Wakad ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Serviceranjana rawat
 
(TARA) Call Girls Chakan ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Service
(TARA) Call Girls Chakan ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Service(TARA) Call Girls Chakan ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Service
(TARA) Call Girls Chakan ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Serviceranjana rawat
 
(NEHA) Bhosari Call Girls Just Call 7001035870 [ Cash on Delivery ] Pune Escorts
(NEHA) Bhosari Call Girls Just Call 7001035870 [ Cash on Delivery ] Pune Escorts(NEHA) Bhosari Call Girls Just Call 7001035870 [ Cash on Delivery ] Pune Escorts
(NEHA) Bhosari Call Girls Just Call 7001035870 [ Cash on Delivery ] Pune Escortsranjana rawat
 
Regional Snapshot Atlanta Aging Trends 2024
Regional Snapshot Atlanta Aging Trends 2024Regional Snapshot Atlanta Aging Trends 2024
Regional Snapshot Atlanta Aging Trends 2024ARCResearch
 
(SHINA) Call Girls Khed ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Service
(SHINA) Call Girls Khed ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Service(SHINA) Call Girls Khed ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Service
(SHINA) Call Girls Khed ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Serviceranjana rawat
 

Dernier (20)

How to Save a Place: 12 Tips To Research & Know the Threat
How to Save a Place: 12 Tips To Research & Know the ThreatHow to Save a Place: 12 Tips To Research & Know the Threat
How to Save a Place: 12 Tips To Research & Know the Threat
 
Expressive clarity oral presentation.pptx
Expressive clarity oral presentation.pptxExpressive clarity oral presentation.pptx
Expressive clarity oral presentation.pptx
 
Artificial Intelligence in Philippine Local Governance: Challenges and Opport...
Artificial Intelligence in Philippine Local Governance: Challenges and Opport...Artificial Intelligence in Philippine Local Governance: Challenges and Opport...
Artificial Intelligence in Philippine Local Governance: Challenges and Opport...
 
Goa Escorts WhatsApp Number South Goa Call Girl … 8588052666…
Goa Escorts WhatsApp Number South Goa Call Girl … 8588052666…Goa Escorts WhatsApp Number South Goa Call Girl … 8588052666…
Goa Escorts WhatsApp Number South Goa Call Girl … 8588052666…
 
VIP High Class Call Girls Amravati Anushka 8250192130 Independent Escort Serv...
VIP High Class Call Girls Amravati Anushka 8250192130 Independent Escort Serv...VIP High Class Call Girls Amravati Anushka 8250192130 Independent Escort Serv...
VIP High Class Call Girls Amravati Anushka 8250192130 Independent Escort Serv...
 
WIPO magazine issue -1 - 2024 World Intellectual Property organization.
WIPO magazine issue -1 - 2024 World Intellectual Property organization.WIPO magazine issue -1 - 2024 World Intellectual Property organization.
WIPO magazine issue -1 - 2024 World Intellectual Property organization.
 
VIP Russian Call Girls in Indore Ishita 💚😋 9256729539 🚀 Indore Escorts
VIP Russian Call Girls in Indore Ishita 💚😋  9256729539 🚀 Indore EscortsVIP Russian Call Girls in Indore Ishita 💚😋  9256729539 🚀 Indore Escorts
VIP Russian Call Girls in Indore Ishita 💚😋 9256729539 🚀 Indore Escorts
 
The Federal Budget and Health Care Policy
The Federal Budget and Health Care PolicyThe Federal Budget and Health Care Policy
The Federal Budget and Health Care Policy
 
Top Rated Pune Call Girls Hadapsar ⟟ 6297143586 ⟟ Call Me For Genuine Sex Se...
Top Rated  Pune Call Girls Hadapsar ⟟ 6297143586 ⟟ Call Me For Genuine Sex Se...Top Rated  Pune Call Girls Hadapsar ⟟ 6297143586 ⟟ Call Me For Genuine Sex Se...
Top Rated Pune Call Girls Hadapsar ⟟ 6297143586 ⟟ Call Me For Genuine Sex Se...
 
(PRIYA) Call Girls Rajgurunagar ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Service
(PRIYA) Call Girls Rajgurunagar ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Service(PRIYA) Call Girls Rajgurunagar ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Service
(PRIYA) Call Girls Rajgurunagar ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Service
 
Lucknow 💋 Russian Call Girls Lucknow ₹7.5k Pick Up & Drop With Cash Payment 8...
Lucknow 💋 Russian Call Girls Lucknow ₹7.5k Pick Up & Drop With Cash Payment 8...Lucknow 💋 Russian Call Girls Lucknow ₹7.5k Pick Up & Drop With Cash Payment 8...
Lucknow 💋 Russian Call Girls Lucknow ₹7.5k Pick Up & Drop With Cash Payment 8...
 
Precarious profits? Why firms use insecure contracts, and what would change t...
Precarious profits? Why firms use insecure contracts, and what would change t...Precarious profits? Why firms use insecure contracts, and what would change t...
Precarious profits? Why firms use insecure contracts, and what would change t...
 
##9711199012 Call Girls Delhi Rs-5000 UpTo 10 K Hauz Khas Whats Up Number
##9711199012 Call Girls Delhi Rs-5000 UpTo 10 K Hauz Khas  Whats Up Number##9711199012 Call Girls Delhi Rs-5000 UpTo 10 K Hauz Khas  Whats Up Number
##9711199012 Call Girls Delhi Rs-5000 UpTo 10 K Hauz Khas Whats Up Number
 
↑VVIP celebrity ( Pune ) Serampore Call Girls 8250192130 unlimited shot and a...
↑VVIP celebrity ( Pune ) Serampore Call Girls 8250192130 unlimited shot and a...↑VVIP celebrity ( Pune ) Serampore Call Girls 8250192130 unlimited shot and a...
↑VVIP celebrity ( Pune ) Serampore Call Girls 8250192130 unlimited shot and a...
 
Item # 4 - 231 Encino Ave (Significance Only).pdf
Item # 4 - 231 Encino Ave (Significance Only).pdfItem # 4 - 231 Encino Ave (Significance Only).pdf
Item # 4 - 231 Encino Ave (Significance Only).pdf
 
(DIVYA) Call Girls Wakad ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Service
(DIVYA) Call Girls Wakad ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Service(DIVYA) Call Girls Wakad ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Service
(DIVYA) Call Girls Wakad ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Service
 
(TARA) Call Girls Chakan ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Service
(TARA) Call Girls Chakan ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Service(TARA) Call Girls Chakan ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Service
(TARA) Call Girls Chakan ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Service
 
(NEHA) Bhosari Call Girls Just Call 7001035870 [ Cash on Delivery ] Pune Escorts
(NEHA) Bhosari Call Girls Just Call 7001035870 [ Cash on Delivery ] Pune Escorts(NEHA) Bhosari Call Girls Just Call 7001035870 [ Cash on Delivery ] Pune Escorts
(NEHA) Bhosari Call Girls Just Call 7001035870 [ Cash on Delivery ] Pune Escorts
 
Regional Snapshot Atlanta Aging Trends 2024
Regional Snapshot Atlanta Aging Trends 2024Regional Snapshot Atlanta Aging Trends 2024
Regional Snapshot Atlanta Aging Trends 2024
 
(SHINA) Call Girls Khed ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Service
(SHINA) Call Girls Khed ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Service(SHINA) Call Girls Khed ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Service
(SHINA) Call Girls Khed ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Service
 

Stephen Aldridge -Public sector efficiency in the UK

  • 1. Presentation for workshop on Spatial Dimensions of Productivity organised by the OECD Global Forum on Productivity and the OECD Spatial Productivity Lab OECD Trento Centre, Bolzano, Italy 28-29th March 2019 Stephen Aldridge Director for Analysis and Data Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government UK PUBLIC SECTOR EFFICIENCY IN THE UK 1
  • 2. THE UK’S TRACK RECORD IN PUBLIC SECTOR EFFICIENCY WORK 2
  • 3. The UK has a strong track record in public sector efficiency measurement and analysis 3 1998: Direct measures of government outputs included in UK National Accounts. 2003: National Statistician commissions the economist Tony Atkinson to review the measurement of government output in the National Accounts. 2004: First public service productivity statistics on health care released. 2005: Atkinson Review: Final Report published; UK Centre for the Measurement of Government Activity (UKCeMGA) established in the Office for National Statistics (ONS); first education productivity article released. 2006: Public service productivity articles for adult social care and social security administration released. 2009: First total public service productivity article released. UKCeMGA merged with National Accounts having implemented 90% of recommendations. 2014: Cross-departmental analysts’ group on public sector efficiency established (Public Sector Efficiency Group). 2015: Public Sector Efficiency Group produces papers and report for the 2015 Spending Review. 2016: ONS establish public sector efficiency measurement unit. 2017: Publication of Sir Michael Barber’s Public Value Review and Public Value Framework.
  • 5. The purpose of this presentation is… 5 • to offer a clear definition of public sector efficiency • to set out why public sector efficiency is important • to spell out the challenges to measuring public sector efficiency • to explain what public sector activities we’re interested in • to set out what the data shows for a selection of public services • to summarise the key drivers of public sector efficiency and some examples of what can be done • to offer some thoughts on next steps
  • 6. WHAT DO WE MEAN BY PUBLIC SECTOR EFFICIENCY? 6
  • 7. What do we mean by public sector efficiency? 7 Public sector efficiency refers to the process of turning pubic money into desired outcomes Public Money Inputs Inputs Outputs Outputs Desired Outcomes Economy How cheaply are the inputs being purchased? Productivity How much output is produced for each unit of input? Effectiveness and resilience How do the outputs affect desired outcomes? Technical Efficiency How well are inputs turned into outputs? Allocative Efficiency Are the right outputs being produced? Allocative Efficiency Public Sector Efficiency Relevant to the entire process of turning public money into desired outcomes The Public Sector/Service Production Process A simplified model of how public money is turned into inputs, outputs and outcomes
  • 8. What do we mean by public sector efficiency? Technical efficiency ‘Doing things right’ Doing the things we currently do either at less cost, or getting more outputs from what we currently do at the same cost, or some combination of the two. Allocative efficiency ‘Doing the right things’ Finding wholly different ways of achieving desired outcomes – at less or substantially less cost. Service transformation is crucial to allocative efficiency and unlocking transformational improvements in efficiency. 8 Public sector efficiency can be defined in two distinct ways: technical and allocative Inputs Inputs Inputs Outputs Outputs Outputs Desired Outcomes Alternative ways of achieving desired outcomes
  • 9. WHY IS PUBLIC SECTOR EFFICIENCY IMPORTANT? 9
  • 10. Why is public sector efficiency important? It matters to the difference the public sector and public services make to outcomes the public and policy makers are concerned about: - Health - Educational attainment - Public safety - Etc. 10 It matters to productivity in the wider economy Giordano et al’s IMF working paper suggests firms in an Italian province with above median public sector efficiency achieve higher levels of output per Euro spent on salaries (+11%) Source: Does Public Sector Inefficiency Constrain Firm Productivity: Evidence from Italian Provinces by R Giordano, S Lanau, P Tommasino, and P Topalova, IMF Working Paper, WP/15/168, July 2015 It matters to the burden of taxation and fiscal sustainability The more efficiently services are provided, all other things being equal, the greater the fiscal sustainability 1pp p.a. increase in public sector productivity growth = 64% of GDP reduction in public sector net debt 2.7% increase p.a. Public Sector Net Debt as a % of GDP in the UK under different rates of public sector productivity growth Source: Office for Budget Responsibility, 2013
  • 11. WHAT ARE THE CHALLENGES IN MEASURING PUBLIC SECTOR EFFICIENCY? 11
  • 12. What are the challenges in measuring public sector efficiency? 12 While all efficiency data available are imperfect and subject to caveats, none of the problems around defining and measuring efficiency are insurmountable. Analysing public sector efficiency poses a number of measurement challenges Public Money Inputs Outputs Desired Outcomes The ONS has produced guidance on what data is needed to construct a cost weighted index of inputs and outputs that can be used to construct an efficiency index. How can we attribute changes in outcomes to changes in outputs? Especially when changes in outcomes may take time to happen How do we define and measure the quality of outputs? How do we turn cost and price data into volumes of inputs and outputs? Problems Potential Solutions How do we ensure consistency in measuring costs? When outcomes are affected by many factors (e.g. health), quality adjustment can be used to account for the effectiveness of the outputs produced. A range of methods exist to measure quality, e.g. QALYs, or client satisfaction. Where the outcome is a public good (e.g. defence) assessing the impact of outputs on outcomes is more difficult, and may require an interdisciplinary approach – for example, using an independent risk based assessment. Consistency Costs into volumes ONS Guidance Quality Attribution Quality adjustment & public goods
  • 13. WHAT PUBLIC SECTOR ACTIVITIES ARE WE INTERESTED IN? 13
  • 14. What public sector activities are we interested in? • Back office services including Human Resources and Finance. • Transactional services including benefit administration and tax collection. • Front line public services including schools, policing, health, social care, etc. 14 Public sector activities can be broken down into three broad categories: back office, transactional and front line The efficiency of back office and transactional services is more readily measurable (if not without challenges) but by far the greatest public sector spend is on frontline services.
  • 15. WHAT DO THE DATA SHOW? 15
  • 16. What do the data show? (a) Across the public sector as a whole 16 Total economy productivity Inputs: Hours worked Outputs: Gross Domestic Product Market sector productivity Inputs: The volume of labour (adjusted for the skill mix of the workforce), and the volume of capital used. Outputs: Total economic output of the market sector (measured by Gross Value Added, GVA). Total public services productivity Inputs : Inputs can be broken down into three components. They are labour, intermediate consumption (expenditure on goods and services) and consumption of fixed capital. Outputs: are measured in one of 4 ways: (a) outputs are assumed to equal inputs (e.g. defence spending) – 38% of total (b) quality adjusted outputs equal inputs – 3% (c) quantity alone – 12% (e.g. social security administration and children’s social care) (d) quality adjusted – 47% Over the longer term, private sector productivity has grown faster than public sector productivity, but since 2010 the reverse has been true 80 90 100 110 120 130 Index,1997=100 Productivity, Index 1997=100 Market sector productivity Total public services productivity Total economy productivity Total economy productivity Market sector productivity98 100 102 104 106 108 Index,2010=100 Productivity, Index 2010=100 Total public services productivity Source: ONS https://www.ons.gov.uk/economy/economicoutputandproductivity/publicservicesproductivity/datasets/ growthratesandindicesfortotalpublicserviceoutputinputsandproductivitytable1
  • 17. Quality adjustment begins What do the data show? (b) Health services 17 Much of the historic productivity increase has been driven by reduced average length of hospital stay and shifting activity to day cases. This allows fewer beds and nurses per episode, though the average acuity of patients in hospital increases. A combination of pay restraint, improved labour productivity, centralised procurement, reduced use of agency staff, the abolition of some tiers of management and greater use of generic drugs have delivered significant efficiency savings over the past 7-8 years. Productivity growth rates (p/a) Health Total Economy Public Sector 1997 to 2007 0.8% 2.1% 0.0% 2007 to 2016 1.2% 0.2% 0.6% 1997 to 2016 1.0% 1.2% 0.3% Inputs : Inputs to publicly-funded health care have three components: labour, purchases of goods and services and consumption of fixed capital. Outputs : Healthcare output is measured as the quantity of healthcare delivered, adjusted for changes in the quality of delivery. Outputs include hospital inpatient, outpatient and day case episodes, family health services, including General Practitioner (GP) services, prescribing – includes all drugs prescribed by General Practitioners and non-NHS provision funded by government. Quality is measured using survival rates/health gain, waiting times and surveys of patient experience Source: ONS (https://www.ons.gov.uk/economy/economicoutputandproductivity/publicservicesproductivity/artic les/publicservicesproductivityestimatestotalpublicservices/2016) 60 80 100 120 140 160 180 200 220 240 260 280 300 Index,1995/96=100 UK health care inputs, quality adjusted output and productivity Quality adjusted productivity Inputs Quality adjusted outputs
  • 18. What do the data show? (c) Schools* 18 The wider evidence base suggests changes in school performance are heavily influenced by factors outside the education system, such as parental engagement and the home learning environment. Quality adjusted outputs Quality adjusted productivity Inputs: Labour; purchases of goods and services; capital services Outputs: Total number of full time equivalent students Quality adjustment: Number of individuals achieving 5 A*-C GCSE grades Source: ONS (https://www.ons.gov.uk/economy/economicoutputandproductivity/publicservicesproductivity/datasets/publicserviceproductivityestimateseducation) * Including further education and training of teachers
  • 19. What do the data show? (d) Adult Social Care 19 • Inputs include labour, intermediate consumption of goods and services, and capital used by local authorities in providing adult social care services and care purchased by local authorities from independent sector providers. • Outputs: For services where activity data are available, the quantity of adult social care output (weeks in care, meals provided etc.) is measured by calculating the growth rates of different adult social care activities and weighting these by their unit costs. • The quality adjustment is based on the concept of adjusted social care-related quality of life and produced using data from the Adult Social Care Survey. This quality adjustment measures changes in how well care clients’ needs are met across domains of quality of life affected by social care, while controlling for factors outside the control of adult social care services which may also affect quality of life. Source: ONS (https://www.ons.gov.uk/economy/economicoutputandproductivity/publicservicesproductivity/articles/publicserviceproductivityadultsocialcareenglandfinancialyearen ding2018/2019-02-06/relateddata) 60 80 100 120 140 160 180 200 1996/97 1999/00 2002/03 2005/06 2008/09 2011/12 2014/15 2017/18 Index,1996/97=100 UK adult social care inputs, output and productivity Outputs Quality adjustment begins Productivity Inputs Part of the reduction in productivity between 1996/97 and 2010/11 may be because the output measure makes no allowance for quality over this period. Where the data are available from 2010/11 onwards, quality- adjusted productivity does not fall. No account is taken of changes in clients’ needs (case mix) and excludes non-Local authority funded care is excluded
  • 20. What do the data show (e) Local Government 20 64 65 66 67 70 72 17 16 12 13 13 13 18 19 22 19 16 13 0% 50% 100% 2018 2017 2016 2015 2014 2013 How satisfied or dissatisfied are you with the way your local council(s) runs things? satisfied neither dissatisfied Source: Local Government Association: Polling on resident satisfaction with councils, 2018 Source: MHCLG Revenue Outturn / Revenue Accounts data. Central Government Grant exclude schools, public health and housing benefit
  • 21. ANALYSIS OF THE TECHNICAL EFFICIENCY OF LOCAL GOVERNMENT 21
  • 22. What we’ve done 22 The UK Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government has recently analysed, in some detail, the technical efficiency of local government. This focused on local authority expenditure on different services per unit of output, adjusted for quality, i.e. a lower unit cost represents (all else being equal) greater efficiency. The analysis compares a local authority with similar local authorities for service quality to assess the potential for efficiency savings. A ‘similar local authority’ is defined by controls for service quality, wage levels and property costs The analysis controls for different local authority wage and property costs by including an Area Cost Adjustment. The quality measures include, for example: children entering a child protection plan for a second time, social care quality adjusted life years and roads considered in need of maintenance.
  • 23. 23 Service Area Net current expenditure (16/17) Share of efficiency savings Adult Social Care £15bn 31% Children’s Social Care £9bn 19% Environmental protective and cultural services excl. waste & buses* £4bn 10% Highway maintenance £2bn 10% Waste* £3bn 9% Planning & Development £1bn 8% Corporate & Democratic* £1bn 4% Homelessness <£1bn 3% Fire & Rescue £2bn 3% Subsidised buses £1bn 2% What we’ve found *Does not account for quality. For the purposes of illustration efficiency estimates have been halved The scope for efficiency improvements has been estimated assuming all authorities operate at the median level of efficiency of similar authorities
  • 24. The scope for efficiency savings is not, however, evenly distributed across local authorities 24 Local authorities The authorities with the greatest potential for efficiency savings vary from service to service
  • 25. Our analysis also suggests that those authorities that are relatively less efficient tend to be those that are least resilient in terms of financial sustainability 25 0 50 100150200 40 60 80 100 120 140 Responsibilities (%) 2019/20 assuming no efficiency savings 2019/20 with efficiency savings Local Authority financial sustainability is measured using two metrics: (i) Financial reserves as a % of non- discretionary spending (Reserves) (ii) Level of spending on non- discretionary activities as a % of total core spending power (Responsibilities) Least financially sustainable *Core spending power measures the core revenue funding available for local authority services, including Council Tax and locally retained business rates. Spending on non-discretionary activities can exceed 100% of core spending given funding from other sources and reserves.
  • 26. DRIVERS OF PUBLIC SECTOR EFFICIENCY 26
  • 27. Benchmarking Effective use of ICT Strengthened incentives Front-line service integration Channel shift Intelligent outsourcing New entry competition/ market creation Effective use of data Empowering users: Co- production & co-design Shared services Organisational structure Workforce capability & leadership Markets & Competition Service re-design & alternative delivery mechanisms Technology, Data & TargetingOrganisation & Workforce Drivers of public sector efficiency – the key factors Cost benchmarking Holding down pay Prevention/ early intervention Reconfiguring services Sharing best practice Technological advances Hard budget constraints + spending flexibility 27 There is no efficiency ‘silver bullet.’ There are many levers that need to be pulled to improve public sector efficiency. Pay systems
  • 28. Some case studies 28 • Public Service Data Dashboards • Benchmarking: The Model Hospital • The London Rough Sleeping Social Impact Bond • The Troubled Families Programme • Preventative Health Care • Predictive Analytics
  • 29. Public Service Data Dashboards A means of providing information on inputs, outputs and outcomes in one place Numbers that Government departments recognise Timely data drawn together by the Office for National Statistics. Incorporating impartial guidance on interpretation and comparison of statistics Outcomes which map broadly to Government’s single departmental plans What are they? 29 Which drivers of public sector efficiency do they address? Cost benchmarking Effective use of ICT Effective use of data What do they show? Key data for four Departments: Department of Work and Pensions, Department of Health and Social Care, Department for Education and Ministry of Justice. Source: ONS
  • 30. Benchmarking: The Model Hospital The Model Hospital is a free online digital service for National Health Service staff and leaders to help identify performance variation and local opportunities to improve both productivity and quality on the National Health Service front line. It breaks down key metrics across all the activity of an NHS service provider. What is it? Which drivers of public sector efficiency does it address? Effective use of data Cost benchmarking What are the benefits? Helping to deliver an estimated £1.45bn of savings from 2017-18 Source: NHS Improvement. Sharing best practice Identify your opportunities to improve Understand the drivers of your opportunities Identify areas for action Develop a plan Best practice and direct support Tracking and monitoring of delivery The model hospital online service allows a service provider to access the efficiency gains they could realise if they performed as well as the median or better hospitals in their ‘peer group’ (hospitals with most similar attributes and context).
  • 31. The London Rough Sleeping Social Impact Bond The London rough sleeping SIB was a four year programme designed to bring new finance and new ways of working to improve the outcomes for a cohort of rough sleepers whose needs were not being met by existing services. It aimed to test if outcomes could be improved through a payment by results structure. What is it? 31 Which drivers of public sector efficiency does it address? Strengthened incentives Front-line service integration Effective use of data How was it evaluated? Comparison of outcomes using administrative data for SIB cohort and control group. Assessment of impact on rough sleeping and wider outcomes. Findings The results show that, when compared to a well-matched comparison group, the intervention significantly reduced rough sleeping over a two year period. On average the intervention group (the SIB group) had significantly fewer episodes of rough sleeping compared to the comparison groups. After two years: the mean number of rough sleeping contacts for the SIB group was 9.2 compared to 13.9 for the comparison group. 40% of the SIB cohort did not sleep rough at all in the two years after the start of the intervention compared to 33% of the comparison group Source: https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/london-homelessness-social-impact-bond-evaluation
  • 32. The Troubled Families Programme Adults or children involved in crime or anti- social behaviour Children not attending school regularly Adults out of work Children who need help or are in need of or subject to a child protection plan Families affected by domestic violence and abuse Parents and children with a range of health problems 32 What is it? A programme that aims to help families placing high costs on public services. Programme runs between 2015- 2020 Reaching 400k families Which drivers of public sector efficiency does it address? Strengthened incentives Front-line service integration Effective use of data Workforce capability & leadership Prevention/ early intervention Reconfiguring services Sharing best practice
  • 33. How has it been evaluated? 33 How is it being evaluated? Which data is being linked? What is the scale of the administrative linked data? Impact Analysis using linked administrative datasets to gather outcome data on both an intervention group and comparison group. Cost Benefit Analysis, applied to the Impact Analysis findings, using unit cost data on different services and other evidence to estimate public value and fiscal benefits. sentence type Police National Computer National Pupil Database Work & Pensions Longitudinal Study CRIME EDUCATION & CHILD SAFEGUARDING EMPLOYMENT & BENEFITS convictions sentence length in care pupil referral unit educational attainment (KS1/2/3 scores) exclusionsschool absence special educational needs employment type of benefits pay & tax pensionstax credits nature of health problems 295,435 families in total 46,907 families in the comparison group 248,528 families in the intervention group 864,205 individuals in the intervention group 170,080 individuals in the comparison group In December 2017, around 295K families were matched to administrative datasets… + data from every upper tier local authority
  • 34. 0.5% 0.6% 1.0% 1.3% 1.7% 0.5% 1.1% 1.6% 2.1% 2.5% 0.0% 0.5% 1.0% 1.5% 2.0% 2.5% 3.0% 0-6 months pre 0-6 months 7-12 months 13-18 months 19-24 months The Troubled Families Programme – Impact Analysis 34 Smaller proportion of Looked After Children in intervention group than comparison group. Intervention Comparison 95% confidence interval Smaller proportion of adults given custodial sentences in the intervention group in the two years after joining the programme Anytime within two years after programme: Custodial sentence Cautioned Convicted Proportion of adult offenders on the programme 1.2% 1.9% 5.9% Proportion of adult offenders in the comparison group 1.6% 2.2% 6.1% Difference -0.4%*** -0.3% -0.3% Note: statistically significant difference; *** p value <0.001. %Childrenincare These impacts are sufficient to produce outturn monetised benefits greater than the costs
  • 35. Preventative Health Care Preventative health care is about stopping problems (e.g. by vaccination or stopping smoking); spotting problems early (e.g. screening for illness); and maintaining independence (e.g. rehabilitation). The National Health Service currently spends around £97bn on treatment and £8bn on preventative care. What is it? Which drivers of public sector efficiency does it address? Effective use of data Cost benchmarking Prevention/ early intervention Technological advances Inputs Doctors, medicines, equipment, etc. Outputs GP visits, operations, prescriptions, etc. Outcomes Patient experience, QALYs etc. What are the benefits? It promotes improved allocative efficiency – shifting resources to more effective interventions To become more technically efficient, we need to reduce input costs and / or inputs per unit of output. To become more allocatively efficient, we need to produce more effective outputs and fewer of the less effective ones. It costs the National Health Service ~ £15k to produce one QALY. By contrast public health interventions have a QALY of around £8k – though there is large variation NHS total factor productivity growth has outperformed the wider public sector and UK economy in the last 20 years Sources: Marginal cost per Quality Adjusted Life Year (QALY) (York University research); Owen et al (2017) - https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/28977629
  • 36. Predictive Analytics 36 Which drivers of public sector efficiency do they address? Effective use of data Prevention/ early intervention Technological advances Effective use of ICT Aim Develop predictive risk modelling tools to assist child welfare screening and other decisions To improve the effective targeting of services towards vulnerable children and other groups Method Photo: Cate Dingley for The New York Times Article by Dan Hurley Jan., 2018: https://www.nytimes.com/2018/01/02/magazine/can-an-algorithm-tell-when-kids-are-in-danger.html Predictive algorithms. Sky news: https://news.sky.com/story/predictive-algorithms-hidden-revolution-taking-place-in-uks-councils-and-police-forces-11650160 What is it? What are the benefits? At least 53 local authorities and 14 police forces are using predictive algorithms in the UK for applications as varied as traffic management and identifying children at risk of neglect or abuse. By allowing earlier intervention and better targeting of interventions they help to improve outcomes for citizens, reduce costs and improve efficiency.
  • 37. THE SCOPE FOR IMPROVING EFFICIENCY FURTHER 37
  • 38. 38 Markets and competition Service redesigns and alternative delivery mechanisms Technology, data and targeting Hard budget constraints and spending flexibility Organisation and workforce £££ ££ ££ £££ £ £ ££ ££ ££ £££ ££ £££ £££ ££ ££ Short term Medium term Long term Short term: Implemented in the next 1 to 2 years Medium term: Implemented in the next 5 years Long term: Implemented beyond the next 5 years £ limited scope for efficiencies, ££ some scope for efficiencies, £££ substantial scope for efficiencies Assessment of the scope for improving efficiency further Drivers of efficiency Our analysis of past trends and future scope suggests: • Hard budget constraints and organisational and workforce changes – including pay constraint – are powerful drivers in the short run • Service re-design and more competition matter in the medium term • Technology and data are longer term drivers However, there is potential for these drivers to be mutually reinforcing.
  • 40. Next Steps 40 (a) Public Value and the Public Value Framework: What is it? A new framework to build a stronger public value and efficiency culture at all levels across the public sector. It is currently being piloted and the framework refined. Government departments will be required to report on public value performance and the improvements they will make against the framework in their 2019/20 Single Departmental Plans. Public value is expected to play a key role in the 2019 Spending Review Source: https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/delivering-better-outcomes-for-citizens-practical-steps-for-unlocking-public- value and https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/public-value-framework-and-supplementary-guidance
  • 41. Next Steps 41 (b) Public Sector Efficiency Group What is it? A cross-departmental analysts’ group that meets every 3-4 months, comprising of colleagues across Whitehall with an interest in public sector efficiency. What does it do? i) Bring together evidence on efficiency trends and drivers. UK and international evidence  Literature reviews Departments’ efficiency stories  Department papers Advice from experts and practitioners  Experts workshops ii) Draws out insights for achieving further efficiency improvements. iii) Disseminates findings from key pieces of analytical work and research and produces reports. (c) Promoting data analytics and evidence of what works across the wider public sector The Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government and the Cabinet Office have established a local authority what works and data analytics network. There are now also 12 Office of Data Analytics across local government. (d) Office for National Statistics Ongoing work by the ONS Public Sector Efficiency Measurement Unit to improve data and statistics.