Trade and Circular Economy Workshop - Session 3 - Daniel Montalvo
1. A few words about the role of trade in the
transition to a Circular Economy in Europe
OECD Workshop on International Trade and the Circular Economy
Daniel Montalvo
OECD, 26 February 2020
3. Trade as a tool to increase circularity…
…when there’s a good environmental case for
using trade to foster circularity
• Already low-level restrictions for recovery
• Make use of economy of scale
• Find the best treatment option in line with waste
hierarchy
• Ensure BAT for receiving facilities
• Broadly equivalent conditions for receiving facilities
outside the EU
4. … but some principles apply
• Certain “solutions” are discouraged (i.e. disposal)
• Avoid trade where waste involves “risks” or induces
environmental impacts (e.g hazardousness)
• Avoid generating social and environmental
externalities on third parties (i.e. ban on hazardous
waste to non-OECD)
• Self-sufficiency and proximity
• Legitimate strategic interest to develop own
infrastructure or unlock dependencies (e.g.
criticality)
11. Options for sustainable plastic waste trade
• Plastics Strategy and CE Action Plan 2.0 will foster
collection (increasing quantities) but also quality
(easing the management)
• Higher quality and new feedstocks or material
replacement could solve issues underlying bans
or trade restrictions
• Better collection can enable markets that are
now undesirable
• Better technology and investment in third
countries can change the picture
• Safe-by design plastics and hazardous chemicals
• Extended Producer Responsibility plays a role
15. References and further contact with EEA
Contact us: Daniel.Montalvo@eea.europa.eu
The European Environment - State and Outlook Report 2020
https://www.eea.europa.eu/publications/soer-2020/chapter-09_soer2020-waste-and-resources/view
Waste prevention, focus on plastics
https://www.eea.europa.eu/publications/preventing-plastic-waste-in-europe
The plastic waste trade in the circular economy
Briefing:
https://www.eea.europa.eu/themes/waste/resource-efficiency/the-plastic-waste-trade-in
Full report:
https://www.eionet.europa.eu/etcs/etc-wmge/products/etc-reports/plastics-waste-trade-and-the-environment
Reducing loss of resources from waste management
Briefing:
https://www.eea.europa.eu/themes/waste/waste-management/reducing-loss-of-resources-from
Full report:
https://www.eionet.europa.eu/etcs/etc-wmge/products/etc-reports/are-we-losing-resources-when-managing-europes-waste-1
Textiles in Europe’s circular economy
Briefing:
https://www.eea.europa.eu/themes/waste/resource-efficiency/textiles-in-europe-s-circular-economy
Full report:
https://www.eionet.europa.eu/etcs/etc-wmge/products/etc-reports/textiles-and-the-environment-in-a-circular-economy
Notes de l'éditeur
China ban (and others)
Basel amendment on plastics
Less exports, but lack of information on what happens to non-exported plastics
Lead to demand for treatment in the EU
Insufficient recycling infrastructure in the EU (lack of data): incineration? Landfilling?
Opportunity to develop EU recycling infrastructure according to BAT – Circular Economy
Not ideal dealing of plastics is a fact
A good case for non-trading plastics and improving the environmental performance of the plastic system overall
EU legislation is focusing more and more on preparation for re-use (e.g. “right to repair” most likely to be included in the forthcoming CE Action Plan, forthcoming fee modulation implementing act for Extended Producer Responsibility Schemes)
Collective or individual Extended Producer Responsibility Schemes already widespread and increasing, wide range of private initiatives for take-back schemes
CE is about closed loops and about maintaining value of waste as high as possible: best suited actors to serve these two objectives are the producers themselves
Therefore, trade can be the enabler for waste materials and, especially, components to reach producers in the context of the more and more global value chains
This way, this kind of trade can also replace illegal trade, such as in the case of WEEE (or “used products”) illegal exports.
Textiles as a key sector whose drivers are dominated by a global supply chain
Embedded impacts happen to be really high – 4th largest
Highly linear production-consumption system where a lot can be done
A host of options for all phases of the circular economy can help – make reference to briefing