SlideShare une entreprise Scribd logo
1  sur  11
Télécharger pour lire hors ligne
PRIME INVESTMENT RESEARCH
FOOD & BEVERAGE |EGYPT
JUHAYNA FOOD INDUSTRIES – VALUATION UPDATE
OCTOBER 30, 2016
Source: Bloomberg
JUHAYNA FOOD INDUSTRIES …
FX PRESSURES PUTTING PROFITABILITY MARGINS AT STAKE …
“BUY”
MARKET PRICE EGP 3.87
FAIR VALUE EGP 5.00
POTENTIAL 29% UPSIDE
INVESTMENT GRADE
“VALUE”
Stock Data
Outstanding Shares [Mn] 941.4
Mkt. Cap [Bn] 3.64
Bloomberg – Reuters JUFO EY / JUFO.CA
52-WEEKS LOW/HIGH 3.6 – 8.49
DAILY AVERAGE TURNOVER (‘000S) 4,816.7
Ownership
Pharon Investments 52.22%
BoD 0.85%
Free Float 46.93%
We published our Re-initiation of Coverage for Juhayna Food Industries (JUFO.CA) in February 2016. At that
time, our Fair Value stood at EGP 6.98/share. We believe that a valuation update is necessary at the current
time. The new value reflects the changes that took place with respect to the risk free rate, the exchange
rates, the company’s pricing strategy and the CAPEX plans.
We update our Fair Value for Juhayna Food Industries with a “Buy” rating driven from an upside
potential of 29%; driven from our estimated Fair Value of EGP 5.00. Using the DCF valuation methodology
for Juhayna, we utilized an average WACC over our forecasted horizon of 16.73%, a risk free rate of
13.20%, and a market risk premium of 8%. We used the average F&B Sector Beta which is equivalent to
0.68. We applied a multiple-stage growth model:
- 2016 - 2020: we forecasted full financial statements, as the company will witness hyper growth rates.
- 2021 - 2025: we assumed FCF to grow at a high rate of 8%.
- 2026 - Infinity: the terminal value of the company is based on a perpetual growth rate of 5%.
Value (EGP / Share) Upside Potential
100% DCF 5.00 29%
100% P/E Multiple 5.29 37%
50% DCF / 50% P/E Multiples 5.15 33%
2016 could be considered the worst year for the F&B sector on the EGX. The stocks of Juhayna Food
Industries (JUFO.CA), Edita Food Industries (EFID.CA) and Arabian Food Industries - Domty - (DOMT.CA) lost
50%, 49% and 49% respectively of their values since the beginning of 2016, where on the other hand the
EGX30 gained 18% during the same period.
SOURCE: BLOOMBERG
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
Oct-15
Nov-15
Dec-15
Jan-16
Feb-16
Mar-16
Apr-16
May-16
Jun-16
Jul-16
Aug-16
Sep-16
Oct-16
JUFO EGX30 Rebased
0
1,000
2,000
3,000
4,000
5,000
6,000
7,000
8,000
9,000
0
5
10
15
20
25
Jan-16 Feb-16 Mar-16 Apr-16 May-16 Jun-16 Jul-16 Aug-16 Sep-16 Oct-16
JUFO EFID DOMT EGX30
1
PRIME INVESTMENT RESEARCH
FOOD & BEVERAGE |EGYPT
JUHAYNA FOOD INDUSTRIES – VALUATION UPDATE
OCTOBER 30, 2016
SOURCE: BLOOMBERG & PRIME ESTIMATES
The severe drop in prices in the local F&B stocks, especially Juhayna have made them appear very appealing to
investors, as they currently trade at low P/E multiples, when compared to their global peers.
Company Name P/E - 2016 (x)
Global Peers
Huishian Dairy 48.59
Bright Dairy 46.82
Danone 29.66
Saputo Inc 26.50
Dairy Crest Group 22.17
Vietnam Dairy 21.93
Maeil Dairy Industry Co Ltd 20.76
Dean Foods Co. 16.11
Synlait Milk Ltd. 14.55
China Dairy 3.10
Median Global Peers 22.05
Company Name P/E - 2016 (x)
Regional Peers
Al Marai 24.36
Agthia Group 19.87
Halwani Bros. 17.47
Jordan Dairy 16.83
Sadafco 15.43
Savola 14.95
Median Regional Peers 17.15
Company Name P/E - 2016 (x)
Local Peers
Edita Food Industries 18.7
Arabian Food Industries - Domty 16.1
Median Local Peers 17.4
Company Name P/E - 2016 (x)
Juhayna Food Industries 15.99
2
PRIME INVESTMENT RESEARCH
FOOD & BEVERAGE |EGYPT
JUHAYNA FOOD INDUSTRIES – VALUATION UPDATE
OCTOBER 30, 2016
JUFO VS. EGX 30 INDEX – 2010-2016 YTD
JUFO STOCK PERFORMANCE - 2016
SOURCE: BLOOMBERG
Since Juhayna’ listing on the EGX in 2010, the stock’s performance has usually been better than that of the EGX30,
however, 2016 has been different. Many negative incidents have led the stock’s price to deteriorate, including:
1. Poor 2Q2016 results – August 2016.
2. Exclusion from the EGX 30 Index – August 2016.
3. Exclusion from the FTSE Russel Index – September 2016.
4. Poor 3Q2016 results – October 2016.
13%
-49%
48%
20%
31%
-22%
18%
30%
-36%
104% 102%
-18% -15%
-50%
-60%
-40%
-20%
0%
20%
40%
60%
80%
100%
120%
2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016
EGX30 JUFO
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
Jan-16 Feb-16 Mar-16 Apr-16 May-16 Jun-16 Jul-16 Aug-16 Sep-16 Oct-16
Poor
2Q2016
Results
Exclusion
from
EGX30
Exclusion
from FTSE
Russell
Index
Poor
3Q2016
Results
3
PRIME INVESTMENT RESEARCH
FOOD & BEVERAGE |EGYPT
JUHAYNA FOOD INDUSTRIES – VALUATION UPDATE
OCTOBER 30, 2016
Financial Statements … Historical & Forecast
Income Statement Brief Hist. Forecast
In EGP Mn 2015 2016F 2017F 2018F
Revenues
4,231 4,898.2 5,879.7 6,702.1
Change
15% 16% 20% 14%
COGS
2,558.8 3,159.9 3,830.6 4,408.6
Change
2% 23% 21% 15%
Gross Profit
1,672.4 1,738.2 2,049.1 2,293.5
Depreciation & Amortization
204.3 235.6 266.3 299.6
EBITDA
863.4 768.4 933.4 1,010.8
Net Income (Before Minority Interest)
279.9 228.0 361.9 432.9
Net Income (After Minority Interest)
279.9 227.8 361.6 432.6
Net Attributable Income
279.8 205.4 325.9 389.9
NPM 7% 5% 6%
6%
Balance Sheet Brief Hist. Forecast
In EGP Mn 2015 2016F 2017F 2018F
Cash
794.9 192.9 238.9 253.9
Net Receivables
171.9 201.3 241.6 275.4
Net Inventory
606.9 703.4 771.4 854.5
Other Current Assets
16.1 1.1 1.3 1.5
Total Current Assets
1,589.8 1,098.6 1,253.2 1,385.4
Net PPE
2,761.2 2,968.3 3,373.2 3,267.6
Other LT-Assets
644.2 699.7 199.7 199.7
Total Long Term Assets
3,405.5 3,667.9 3,572.9 3,467.3
Total Assets
4,995.3 4,766.6 4,826.1 4,852.7
Liabilities
STD - incl CPLTD
916.9 1,084.6 1,048.8 963.7
Accounts Payable
199.4 207.7 251.8 289.8
Total Current Liabilities
1,307.02 1,455.4 1,499.8 1,481.9
Total Long Term Liabilities
1,265.3 845.5 601.2 375.4
4
PRIME INVESTMENT RESEARCH
FOOD & BEVERAGE |EGYPT
JUHAYNA FOOD INDUSTRIES – VALUATION UPDATE
OCTOBER 30, 2016
SOURCE: JUHAYNA & PRIME ESTIMATES
SOURCE: JUHAYNA & PRIME ESTIMATES
Total Liabilities
2,572.3 2,300.9 2,101.01 1,857.3
Equity
Paid-in-Capital
941.4 941.4 941.4 941.4
Reserves
798.3 812.3 823.7 841.7
RE
682.5 712.04 960.05 1,212.3
Total Equity
2,422.9 2,465.7 2,725.1 2,995.4
Financial Ratios Hist. Forecast
GPM
40% 35% 35% 34%
EBITDA Margin
20% 16% 16% 15%
NPM
7% 5% 6% 6%
EPS
0.30 0.24 0.38 0.46
DPS
0.15 0.08 0.13 0.18
P/E
13.02 15.99 10.07 8.42
EV/EBITDA
5.6 6.0 4.6 3.9
ROA
6.20% 4.11% 6.84% 8.08%
ROE
12.20% 8.43% 13.21% 14.36%
Debt / Equity Ratio
Total Assets Turnover
52.98% 49.61% 42.04% 33.67%
0.85 1.03 1.22 1.38
5
PRIME INVESTMENT RESEARCH
FOOD & BEVERAGE |EGYPT
JUHAYNA FOOD INDUSTRIES – VALUATION UPDATE
OCTOBER 30, 2016
PRICE HIKES’ TIMELINE
REVENUE CONTRIBUTION (%) – 9M2016
REVENUE CONTRIBUTION (%) – 3Q2016
REVENUES - EGP MN.
Financial Analysis & Key Highlights:
Revenues:
Financial Analysis & Key Highlights:
Revenues:
1,259 1,135
3,696
3,103
0
500
1,000
1,500
2,000
2,500
3,000
3,500
4,000
3Q2016 3Q2015 9M2016 9M2015
Juhayna was able to achieve healthy growth rates in revenues during the 3Q2016
and the 9M2016. During the 3Q2016, the company achieved revenues of EGP
1,259mn versus EGP 1,135mn during the same period a year earlier, showing a
growth rate of 11%. During the 9M2016, the company achieved revenues of EGP
3,696mn, against EGP 3,103mn during the same period a year earlier, showing a
growth rate of 19%. The largest contributor to revenues remained to be the dairy
segment, contributing 51% to revenues, followed by the juice and yogurt
segments contributing 23% and 22% respectively during 3Q2016. As for the
9M2016, the revenue contribution is also led by the dairy segment with a
contribution of 47%, followed by the yogurt and juice segments with 25% and
22% respectively.
This rise in revenues came on the back of both; volumes and prices. During the
1Q2016, the company did not raise the price of any of its products, yet it ceased
all the promotions / offers that it used to offer to customers. Starting April, the
company decided to gradually raise prices on all of its products, where each
month, the company would raise the blended average price by 2-5%. The
management believes that raising the prices gradually is better than raising the
prices in a single price hike with regards to customers’ perceptions and
competition. The company expects to keep raising prices in this manner in the
comping 5-6 quarters. During the 2Q2016, the company raised the average
blended price by 6%, divided equally on 3 months. Meanwhile, during the
3Q2016, the company followed suit where it raised the average blended price by
6-7%, where prices rose by 4% and 2-3% during July and August respectively.
During October the company managed to further increase the average blended
price by 5% and the management intends to keep raising prices in the same
manner each month till the end of year. The management targets to raise prices
by 30% throughout 2016; meaning that prices will increase by a further 8%
during November and December.
On a segment level, the company was able to raise the prices the most for the
juice segment, followed by the dairy and yogurt segments. During the 9M2016,
the company raised the prices of the juice, dairy and yogurt products by 14%,
11.5% and 3.5% respectively. During the 10M2016, the company raised the
prices of the juice, dairy and yogurt products by 25%, 19% and 5% respectively.
Dairy , 51%
Yogurt ,
22%
Juice, 23%
Concentrat
es , 2%
Agriculture
, 0.3% Arju, 1.7%
Dairy , 47%
Yogurt ,
25%
Juice, 22%
Concentrate
s , 2%
Agriculture
, 2% Arju, 2%
0% 0% 0%
2% 2% 2%
4%
2 - 3%
0%
5%
0%
1%
2%
3%
4%
5%
6%
Jan-16 Feb-16 Mar-16 Apr-16 May-16 Jun-16 Jul-16 Aug-16 Sep-16 Oct-16
1Q2016
No price hikes - Only freezing of
Promotions / Offers
2Q2016
The blended average price rose
by 6%, with an equal increase of 2%
per month
3Q2016
The blended average price rose
by 6-7%, with an increase of 4%
and 2-3% during July and August
respectively.
4Q2016
The blended average price rose
by 5% during October and the
management intends to keep
raising prices each month till
the end of year.
6
PRIME INVESTMENT RESEARCH
FOOD & BEVERAGE |EGYPT
JUHAYNA FOOD INDUSTRIES – VALUATION UPDATE
OCTOBER 30, 2016
DAIRY – REVENUES – EGP MN.
YOGURT – REVENUES – EGP MN.
JUICE – REVENUES – EGP MN.
CONCENTRATES – REVENUES – EGP MN.
AGRICULTURE – REVENUES – EGP MN.
SOURCE: JUHAYNA
Dairy:
The dairy segment showed a healthy growth in revenues. Dairy revenues stood at EGP 636mn
and EGP 1,744mn during 3Q2016 and 9M2016 respectively. The growth in revenues was
mainly driven by an increase in prices, as prices in the dairy segment rose by 11.5% during the
9M2016.
Yogurt:
The yogurt segment‘s revenues dropped in 3Q2016 by 5% y-o-y, while it grew in 9M2016 by
14%. The yogurt revenues stood at EGP 283mn and EGP 923mn during 3Q2016 and 9M2016
respectively. The drop in revenues in 3Q2016 was due to the effect of the Holy month of
Ramadan. Ramadan is considered the peak season for yogurt sales. The majority of Ramadan
occurred during the second quarter of 2016, where Ramadan was divided between the second
quarter and the third quarter in 2015. The management was hesitant to increase prices for
yogurt, as consumers tend to be quiet price sensitive with respect to yogurt; when the
company increased the yogurt prices by 25% in 2013, the company lost market share and the
volumes were hit severely. Consequently, during the 9M2016, the yogurt prices were
increased by the lowest rate, 3.5% and thus the 14% increase in yogurt sales was mainly driven
by an increase in volumes.
Juice:
The juice segment showed the largest growth among the main company’s segments, growing
by 22% and 38% during the 3Q2016 and 9M2016 respectively. The juice segment’s revenues
stood at EGP 293mn and EGP 812mn during the 3Q2016 and the 9M2016 respectively. The
company was able to increase the prices of the juice products the most, where the juice prices
rose by 14% during the 9M2016 and it was able to further increase the prices in October by
more than 10%, reaching an aggregate increase of 25% during the 10M2016. Even though the
22% growth rate that was achieved in 3Q2016 is considered good, it is much lower than the
rate of the previous 2 quarters; the growth rates in the juice segment during the 1Q2016 and
2Q2016 were 62% and 42%. This is mainly due to the high base effect, where the juice
segment was expanded to a large extent during the 3Q2015.
Concentrates:
The concentrates segment showed the highest growth among all the sectors during the
3Q2016 and the 9M2016, growing by 58% and 60% respectively. The concentrates revenues
stood at EGP 20mn and 87mn during the 3Q2016 and the 9M2016 respectively. This is mainly
due the new concentrates’ production line that was added in El Marwa factory, which almost
increased the production capacity by 50%.
Agriculture:
The agriculture segment’s revenues dropped during 3Q2016 by 33%, yet it grew during the
9M2016 at a healthy rate of 10%. The agriculture segment’s revenues stood at EGP 4mn and
EGP 59mn during the 3Q2016 and the 9M2016 respectively. The drop in the segment’s
revenues was mainly due to some changes that occurred with respect with the types of fruits
produced and their implied seasonality.
Arju:
Revenues from Juhayna’s VC - Arju – stood at EGP 22mn and EGP 77mn during the 3Q2016
and the 9M2016 respectively. Arju’s revenues appeared for the first time during the 1Q2016.
At the beginning of 2016, the management had a target of achieving revenues from Arju of
almost EGP250mn, yet it was revised down two times; where at the end it was set at EGP
100mn. The below-expectations performance of Arju was mainly due to the FX crunch and
some disruptions with imports.
Arju’s Second Phase: It is worthy to note that the company bought a plot of land in order to
construct a new production plant for the Arju new products. Construction is expected to begin
early 2017 and production is expected to start during 2018, which is consistent with the VC’s
initial plan.
636 579
1,744
1,595
0
500
1,000
1,500
2,000
3Q2016 3Q2015 9M2016 9M2015
283 296
923
813
0
200
400
600
800
1,000
3Q2016 3Q2015 9M2016 9M2015
293
241
812
587
0
200
400
600
800
1,000
3Q2016 3Q2015 9M2016 9M2015
20
13
87
55
0
20
40
60
80
100
3Q2016 3Q2015 9M2016 9M2015
4 6
59
54
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
3Q2016 3Q2015 9M2016 9M2015
7
PRIME INVESTMENT RESEARCH
FOOD & BEVERAGE |EGYPT
JUHAYNA FOOD INDUSTRIES – VALUATION UPDATE
OCTOBER 30, 2016
WHOLE MILK POWDER -WMP – PRICES – USD/MT
SOURCE: GLOBAL DAIRY TRADE
COGS:
Juhayna’s COGS were negatively affected during the 3Q2016 and the 9M2016, increasing by 22% and 28% respectively. The increase
in COGS surpassed the increase in revenues, affecting the company’s margins. The hike in COGS is mainly affected by the FX
exposure. The company has a very high negative exposure to FX. Moreover the non-EGP revenues represent a minimal 3% of the
total revenues, where it only covers c2-5% of the company’s FX requirements. Since the 2Q2016, the company started resorting to
the parallel market, where the spread between the official market and the parallel market rates had a range of 40-55%. Since then,
the company secures c90% of its FX requirements from the parallel market, at a rate of 12-13 EGP/USD.
The company is subject to exchange rate risk, as 60% of the direct raw materials are imported, which represent almost 50% of the
total COGS. The management is trying to “localize” more of the direct raw materials and it has a target of reaching 50% instead of
60% within one year in order to reduce its exposure to FX. The localizing of the raw materials will be mainly directed towards the
concentrates segment; currently 50% of the mango concentrates are imported from India and the management seeks to localize it
100% within one year. Meanwhile, the management seeks to depend more on their local dairy farm to secure raw milk, in case the
prices of powder milk keep on increasing at faster than anticipated rates. Also, the company is currently trying to secure the
packaging materials for yogurt (plastics) locally.
Gross Profit:
Even though the company raised the prices among all of its products, it was unable to pass all the increase in COGs to consumers,
which consequently affected the company’s margins. The company achieved a gross profit of EGP 380mn and EGP 1.1bn during the
3Q2016 and 9M2016 respectively. The company’s GPM stood at 30% during the 3Q2016 and 9M2016 respectively, versus 37% and
35% during 3Q2015 and 9M2015 respectively.
Dairy Farm:
Juhayna’s dairy farm remains to be on top of the management’s priorities. Currently the herd consists of 2,500 Holstein milking cows
and 1,000 Holstein non-milking cows (50% are pregnant and the remaining 50% are female babies). It is expected that the cows herd
will reach 4,000 milking cows by late 2016 / early 2017, post receiving one or two shipments. After the first phase will be completed
(reaching a herd of 4,000 milking cows), the phase will be evaluated and the beginning / postponement of phase 2 will be decided
upon the first phase’s evaluation.
Inventory of Powder Milk:
Juhayna has powder milk stock that is sufficient for production till June 2017. It is worthy to note that the powder milk prices started
to pick up since July 2016, where prices hiked by 20-30% since July till October. The hike in prices is simply a matter of supply and
demand and it is somehow a rebound after the huge drop in powder milk prices that took place in 2015. According to management,
the outlook for powder milk prices is currently quiet unclear, however they expect prices to have an average of USD 3,000/MT in
2017. Any increase in the prices of the powder milk would have a negative impact on the company’s margins, and the impact would
be further enlarged incase further EGP devaluation / floatation occurs as the powder milk is entirely imported.
2,453
2,148 2,260
2,304
2,210
2,188 1,952
1,890
1,974
1,971
2,013
2,156 2,176
2,252 2,205
2,118
2,062
2,079
2,265
2,695 2,793
2,782
2,681
2,760
0
500
1,000
1,500
2,000
2,500
3,000
Nov-15 Dec-15 Jan-16 Feb-16 Mar-16 Apr-16 May-16 Jun-16 Jul-16 Aug-16 Sep-16 Oct-16
8
PRIME INVESTMENT RESEARCH
FOOD & BEVERAGE |EGYPT
JUHAYNA FOOD INDUSTRIES – VALUATION UPDATE
OCTOBER 30, 2016
Sales & Distribution Expenses:
The sales and distribution expenses had a major impact on the company’s performance. The company’s sales and distribution
expenses rose by 13% and 29% during 3Q2016 and 9M2016 respectively. The company recorded EGP 197mn and EGP 601mn in
3Q2016 and 9M2016 respectively as sales and distribution expenses. The rise in the sales and distribution expenses is due to the fact
that the company increased its distribution fleet (vans and trucks) by 20% since the beginning of 2016. Moreover, the sales and
distribution expenses is directly related to sales, so its increase is also a result of the increase in sales, yet the sales and distribution
expenses as a percentage of revenues increased in 3Q2016 and 9M2016, as it stood at 15.6% and 16.25% in 3Q2016 and 9M2016
respectively, against 15.3% and 15% during the comparable periods a year earlier.
Financing Income & Financing Expenses:
The net financing expenses increased during the 3Q2016 and 9M2016. The company incurred net financing expenses of EGP 66mn
and EGP 163mn during the 3Q2016 and 9M2016, growing by 45% and 29% respectively. The largest bulk is for the interest expenses;
which stood at EGP 71mn and EGP 191mn during 3Q2016 and 9M2016 respectively. The rise in the interest expense is due to the
variable interest rates which is linked to the corridor rate. The corridor rate in Egypt rose by c250bps throughout 2016. The current
cost of debt for the company stands at 14.5%. Moreover, the company obtained medium-term financing through Qatar National
Bank (QNB) and HSBC totaling EGP78mn during 2Q2016.
CAPEX:
Juhayna revised down its CAPEX plans for 2016 to EGP 500mn from EGP 640mn that was previously set. During 2016, the company
added 8 filling lines (3 for milk, 3 for juice and 2 for yogurt) and a single production line for concentrates. In the 9M2016, the
company invested EGP 408mn, where the company invested EGP 67mn in production, EGP 14mn in distribution and EGP 44mn in
farming. As the company increased the production capacity for all the segments during the last 2 years, the management believes
that such expansions are very sufficient during the coming few years and that CAPEX is expected to be relaxed during the coming
years.
Due to the FX crunch and somehow the lack of visibility, the management decided to postpone any major CAPEX projects that were
planned for 2017, suggesting that such projects (including capacity additions) may be revisited by 2H2018. In 2017, the company will
solely focus on completing the existing projects.
VAT:
Juhayna started to apply the Value Added Tax (VAT) starting September 2016. The effect of the VAT on the company is minimal –
less than 1% -, as dairy and yogurt are exempted. Even though the juice is subject to tax, each juice sub-category is subject to VAT in
a different manner. The pure juice, c.20% of the total juice sales, is subject to 13%, while on the other hand, the drink juice, c.80% of
the total juice sales, is subject to only 3% at the consumer level, where the other 10% would be paid by the company at the
concentrates level.
Market Shares:
Even though the competition is still very tough, the company remained to be a market leader in dairy and yogurt.
- Milk: The company’s market share advanced 3 points, standing at c66%. Al Marai and Danone remain to the be the company’s
main competitors.
- Yogurt: The company’s market share has been quiet consistent in the spoonable yogurt with a share of 33%. However, the
market share for the drinkable yogurt advanced by 9 points, standing at c44%. The increase in the drinkable yogurt came on
the back of the introduction of 2 new products; Mix Drinkable Yogurt and Zabado Plus. Danone and Lactalis remain to be the
main competitors for the spoonable and drinkable yogurt respectively.
- Juice: Competition is toughest in the juice category. Juhayna lost 2 points in the market share in juice, reaching 20%. The
deterioration in the market share is mainly due to Al Marai, who started offering a lowered priced product. Beyti and Faragello
remain to be the main competitors for Juhayna in the juice segment.
It is worthy to note that the management stressed that they have always had two main priorities; profitability and maintaining
market shares. However, in case the two priorities could not be attained in a certain period (such as the current period), the
management would take actions in favor of profitability against maintaining their market shares.
9
PRIME INVESTMENT RESEARCH
FOOD & BEVERAGE |EGYPT
JUHAYNA FOOD INDUSTRIES – VALUATION UPDATE
OCTOBER 30, 2016
Stock Recommendation Guidelines
Recommendation Target-to-Market Price (x)
Buy x > 15%
Accumulate 5%< x <15%
Hold -5% < x < 5%
Reduce -15% < x < -5%
Sell x < -15%
Strong Buy x > 40%
Investment Grade Explanation
Growth 3 Yr. Earnings CAGR > 20%
Value Equity Positioned Within Maturity Stage of Cycle
Speculative Quality Earnings Reflect Above Normal Risk Factor
10
PRIME INVESTMENT RESEARCH
FOOD & BEVERAGE |EGYPT
JUHAYNA FOOD INDUSTRIES – VALUATION UPDATE
OCTOBER 30, 2016
PRIME SECURITIES
Hassan Samir Managing Director  +202 3300 5611  Hsamir@egy.primegroup.org
RESEARCH TEAM
Aboubakr Emam, CFA Head of Research  +202 3300 5724  Aemam@egy.primegroup.org
Eman Negm, MSc Economist  +202 3300 5716  Enegm@egy.primegroup.org
Mohamed Marei Equity Analyst  +202 3300 5725  Mmarei@egy.primegroup.org
Ali Afifi Equity Analyst  +202 3300 5723  Aafifi@egy.primegroup.org
Omneya El Hammamy Equity Analyst  +202 3300 5718  OelHammamy@egy.primegroup.org
Ingy Fahmy Equity Analyst  +202 3300 5722  Iashraf@egy.primegroup.org
Taher Seif Equity Analyst  +202 3300 5719  Tseif@egy.primegroup.org
Mohamed Magdi Junior Equity Analyst  +202 3300 5720  Mmagdi@egy.primegroup.org
SALES TEAM
Mohamed Ezzat Head of Sales & Branches  +202 3300 5784  mezzat@egy.primegroup.org
Shawkat Raslan Heliopolis Branch Manager  +202 3300 5110  sraslan@egy.primegroup.org
Amr Saber Team Head – Institutions Desk  +202 3300 5659  asaber@egy.primegroup.org
Amr Alaa, CFTe Manager  +202 3300 5609  aalaa@egy.primegroup.org
Mohamed Elmetwaly Manager  +202 3300 5610  melmetwaly@egy.primegroup.org
Emad Elsafoury Manager  +202 3300 5624  eelsafoury@egy.primegroup.org
HEAD OFFICE
PRIME SECURITIES S.A.E.
Regulated by CMA license no. 179
Members of the Cairo Stock Exchange
2 Wadi El Nil St., Liberty Tower,
7th-8thFloor, Mohandessin, Giza, Egypt
Tel: +202 33005700/770/650/649
Fax: +202 3760 7543
Disclaimer
Information included in this report has no regard to specific investment objectives, financial situation, advices or particular needs of the report users. The
report is published for information purposes only and is not to be construed as a solicitation or an offer to buy or sell any securities or related financial
instruments. Unless specifically stated otherwise, all price information is only considered as indicator.
No express or implied representation or guarantee is provided with respect to completeness, accuracy or reliability of information included in this report.
Past performance is not necessarily an indication of future results. Fluctuation of foreign currency rates of exchange may adversely affect the value, price or
income of any products mentioned in this report.
Information included in this report should not be regarded by report users as a substitute for the exercise of their own due diligence and analysis based on
own assessment and judgment criteria. Any opinions given are subject to change without notice and may significantly differ or be contrary to opinions
expressed by other Prime business areas as a result of using different assumptions and criteria. Prime Group is under no obligation responsible to update
or keep current the information contained herein.
Prime Group, its directors, officers, employees or clients may have or have had interests or long or short positions in the securities and/or currencies
referred to herein, and may at any time make purchases and/or sales in them as principal or agent.
Prime Group, its related entities, directors, employees and agents accepts no liability whatsoever for any loss or damage of any kind arising from the use of
all or part of these information included in this report. Certain laws and regulations impose liabilities which cannot be disclaimed. This disclaimer shall, in
no way, constitute a waiver or limitation of any rights a person may have under such laws and/or regulations.
Furthermore, Prime Group or any of the group companies may have or have had a relationship with or may provide or have provided other services, within
its objectives to the relevant companies.
Copyright 2016 Prime Group all rights reserved. You are hereby notified that distribution and copying of this document is strictly prohibited without the
prior approval of Prime Group.
11

Contenu connexe

Tendances

Edita Graduation Project
Edita Graduation ProjectEdita Graduation Project
Edita Graduation Project
Abdelrahman Ali
 
FINAL PROJECT PRSENTATION2
FINAL PROJECT PRSENTATION2FINAL PROJECT PRSENTATION2
FINAL PROJECT PRSENTATION2
Faiza Hina
 
Financial ratios analysis project at Nestle and Engro Foods
Financial ratios analysis project at Nestle and Engro FoodsFinancial ratios analysis project at Nestle and Engro Foods
Financial ratios analysis project at Nestle and Engro Foods
raboz
 
Omanization of the private sector
Omanization of the private sectorOmanization of the private sector
Omanization of the private sector
Ayesha Makki
 

Tendances (20)

Financial Analysis of Juhayna Food Industries
Financial Analysis of Juhayna Food IndustriesFinancial Analysis of Juhayna Food Industries
Financial Analysis of Juhayna Food Industries
 
Swot analysis of engro foods, created by Aabaed ul rehman,M.com.UAF
Swot analysis of engro foods, created by Aabaed ul rehman,M.com.UAFSwot analysis of engro foods, created by Aabaed ul rehman,M.com.UAF
Swot analysis of engro foods, created by Aabaed ul rehman,M.com.UAF
 
National foods
National foodsNational foods
National foods
 
Ratio Analysis in 'ROYAL CERAMIC LANKA PLC'
Ratio Analysis in 'ROYAL CERAMIC LANKA PLC'Ratio Analysis in 'ROYAL CERAMIC LANKA PLC'
Ratio Analysis in 'ROYAL CERAMIC LANKA PLC'
 
Edita Graduation Project
Edita Graduation ProjectEdita Graduation Project
Edita Graduation Project
 
Comparative Analysis between P&G and Unilever
Comparative Analysis between P&G and UnileverComparative Analysis between P&G and Unilever
Comparative Analysis between P&G and Unilever
 
" Diletto Carnation " ice-cream business proposal for Walls Presentation
" Diletto Carnation " ice-cream business proposal for Walls Presentation" Diletto Carnation " ice-cream business proposal for Walls Presentation
" Diletto Carnation " ice-cream business proposal for Walls Presentation
 
Almarai,nissan,sbi
Almarai,nissan,sbiAlmarai,nissan,sbi
Almarai,nissan,sbi
 
Almarai final report
Almarai final reportAlmarai final report
Almarai final report
 
FINAL PROJECT PRSENTATION2
FINAL PROJECT PRSENTATION2FINAL PROJECT PRSENTATION2
FINAL PROJECT PRSENTATION2
 
Walls company
Walls companyWalls company
Walls company
 
National foods pakistan report
National foods pakistan reportNational foods pakistan report
National foods pakistan report
 
Yo good Frozen yogurt franchise plan
Yo good Frozen yogurt franchise planYo good Frozen yogurt franchise plan
Yo good Frozen yogurt franchise plan
 
Term report about igloo ice cream
Term report about igloo ice creamTerm report about igloo ice cream
Term report about igloo ice cream
 
National Foods - Introduction To ERP Systems
National Foods - Introduction To ERP SystemsNational Foods - Introduction To ERP Systems
National Foods - Introduction To ERP Systems
 
Financial ratios analysis project at Nestle and Engro Foods
Financial ratios analysis project at Nestle and Engro FoodsFinancial ratios analysis project at Nestle and Engro Foods
Financial ratios analysis project at Nestle and Engro Foods
 
Ethiopia
EthiopiaEthiopia
Ethiopia
 
Engro foods
Engro foodsEngro foods
Engro foods
 
CINNABON CASE STUDY
CINNABON CASE STUDY  CINNABON CASE STUDY
CINNABON CASE STUDY
 
Omanization of the private sector
Omanization of the private sectorOmanization of the private sector
Omanization of the private sector
 

Similaire à 1.Juhayna Food Industries - Valuation Update - October 2016

Juhayna Food Industries - Results Commentary - 1Q2016 - 19 April 2016
Juhayna Food Industries - Results Commentary - 1Q2016 - 19 April 2016Juhayna Food Industries - Results Commentary - 1Q2016 - 19 April 2016
Juhayna Food Industries - Results Commentary - 1Q2016 - 19 April 2016
Omneya El Hammamy
 
Relatório FAO
Relatório FAO Relatório FAO
Relatório FAO
AgriPoint
 
Edita Food Industries - Re-initiation of Coverage - August 2016
Edita Food Industries - Re-initiation of Coverage - August 2016Edita Food Industries - Re-initiation of Coverage - August 2016
Edita Food Industries - Re-initiation of Coverage - August 2016
Omneya El Hammamy
 
market-potential defination
 market-potential defination market-potential defination
market-potential defination
Mayur Patel
 

Similaire à 1.Juhayna Food Industries - Valuation Update - October 2016 (20)

Juhayna Food Industries - Results Commentary - 1Q2016 - 19 April 2016
Juhayna Food Industries - Results Commentary - 1Q2016 - 19 April 2016Juhayna Food Industries - Results Commentary - 1Q2016 - 19 April 2016
Juhayna Food Industries - Results Commentary - 1Q2016 - 19 April 2016
 
MALEE Oppday 59Q2 17/8/2016
MALEE Oppday 59Q2 17/8/2016MALEE Oppday 59Q2 17/8/2016
MALEE Oppday 59Q2 17/8/2016
 
MALEE Oppday 59Q3 16/11/2016
MALEE Oppday 59Q3 16/11/2016MALEE Oppday 59Q3 16/11/2016
MALEE Oppday 59Q3 16/11/2016
 
Agro Tech Foods: Demonstrates continued strong growth in tough environment; Buy
Agro Tech Foods: Demonstrates continued strong growth in tough environment; BuyAgro Tech Foods: Demonstrates continued strong growth in tough environment; Buy
Agro Tech Foods: Demonstrates continued strong growth in tough environment; Buy
 
Malee Oppday59Q4 28/2/2017
Malee Oppday59Q4 28/2/2017Malee Oppday59Q4 28/2/2017
Malee Oppday59Q4 28/2/2017
 
Dabur Q3FY15: Mixed quarter; maintain neutral
 Dabur Q3FY15: Mixed quarter; maintain neutral Dabur Q3FY15: Mixed quarter; maintain neutral
Dabur Q3FY15: Mixed quarter; maintain neutral
 
Japfa_Ltd_Investor_Presentation_9M2021.pdf
Japfa_Ltd_Investor_Presentation_9M2021.pdfJapfa_Ltd_Investor_Presentation_9M2021.pdf
Japfa_Ltd_Investor_Presentation_9M2021.pdf
 
Relatório FAO
Relatório FAO Relatório FAO
Relatório FAO
 
Fresenius SE & Co. KGaA Q3 2016 Analyst Presentation
Fresenius SE & Co. KGaA Q3 2016 Analyst Presentation Fresenius SE & Co. KGaA Q3 2016 Analyst Presentation
Fresenius SE & Co. KGaA Q3 2016 Analyst Presentation
 
Fresenius SE & Co. KGaA Q2 2016 Analyst Presentation
Fresenius SE & Co. KGaA Q2 2016 Analyst PresentationFresenius SE & Co. KGaA Q2 2016 Analyst Presentation
Fresenius SE & Co. KGaA Q2 2016 Analyst Presentation
 
Project 2016 17 (shubham)pdf
Project 2016 17 (shubham)pdfProject 2016 17 (shubham)pdf
Project 2016 17 (shubham)pdf
 
Zagazig university - student research 2017
Zagazig university - student research 2017Zagazig university - student research 2017
Zagazig university - student research 2017
 
Edita Food Industries - Re-initiation of Coverage - August 2016
Edita Food Industries - Re-initiation of Coverage - August 2016Edita Food Industries - Re-initiation of Coverage - August 2016
Edita Food Industries - Re-initiation of Coverage - August 2016
 
market-potential defination
 market-potential defination market-potential defination
market-potential defination
 
Dabur Q4FY14 results in line with expectations by Motilal Oswal
Dabur Q4FY14 results in line with expectations by Motilal OswalDabur Q4FY14 results in line with expectations by Motilal Oswal
Dabur Q4FY14 results in line with expectations by Motilal Oswal
 
20230404 Camil Institutional Presentation
20230404 Camil Institutional Presentation20230404 Camil Institutional Presentation
20230404 Camil Institutional Presentation
 
Food Additives Industry Research Report
 Food Additives Industry Research Report  Food Additives Industry Research Report
Food Additives Industry Research Report
 
Food Additives Market Analysis, Market Size, Application Analysis and Regiona...
Food Additives Market Analysis, Market Size, Application Analysis and Regiona...Food Additives Market Analysis, Market Size, Application Analysis and Regiona...
Food Additives Market Analysis, Market Size, Application Analysis and Regiona...
 
SGS 2014 Half Year Results Report
SGS 2014 Half Year Results ReportSGS 2014 Half Year Results Report
SGS 2014 Half Year Results Report
 
FAO Food Outlook May 2015
FAO Food Outlook May 2015FAO Food Outlook May 2015
FAO Food Outlook May 2015
 

1.Juhayna Food Industries - Valuation Update - October 2016

  • 1. PRIME INVESTMENT RESEARCH FOOD & BEVERAGE |EGYPT JUHAYNA FOOD INDUSTRIES – VALUATION UPDATE OCTOBER 30, 2016 Source: Bloomberg JUHAYNA FOOD INDUSTRIES … FX PRESSURES PUTTING PROFITABILITY MARGINS AT STAKE … “BUY” MARKET PRICE EGP 3.87 FAIR VALUE EGP 5.00 POTENTIAL 29% UPSIDE INVESTMENT GRADE “VALUE” Stock Data Outstanding Shares [Mn] 941.4 Mkt. Cap [Bn] 3.64 Bloomberg – Reuters JUFO EY / JUFO.CA 52-WEEKS LOW/HIGH 3.6 – 8.49 DAILY AVERAGE TURNOVER (‘000S) 4,816.7 Ownership Pharon Investments 52.22% BoD 0.85% Free Float 46.93% We published our Re-initiation of Coverage for Juhayna Food Industries (JUFO.CA) in February 2016. At that time, our Fair Value stood at EGP 6.98/share. We believe that a valuation update is necessary at the current time. The new value reflects the changes that took place with respect to the risk free rate, the exchange rates, the company’s pricing strategy and the CAPEX plans. We update our Fair Value for Juhayna Food Industries with a “Buy” rating driven from an upside potential of 29%; driven from our estimated Fair Value of EGP 5.00. Using the DCF valuation methodology for Juhayna, we utilized an average WACC over our forecasted horizon of 16.73%, a risk free rate of 13.20%, and a market risk premium of 8%. We used the average F&B Sector Beta which is equivalent to 0.68. We applied a multiple-stage growth model: - 2016 - 2020: we forecasted full financial statements, as the company will witness hyper growth rates. - 2021 - 2025: we assumed FCF to grow at a high rate of 8%. - 2026 - Infinity: the terminal value of the company is based on a perpetual growth rate of 5%. Value (EGP / Share) Upside Potential 100% DCF 5.00 29% 100% P/E Multiple 5.29 37% 50% DCF / 50% P/E Multiples 5.15 33% 2016 could be considered the worst year for the F&B sector on the EGX. The stocks of Juhayna Food Industries (JUFO.CA), Edita Food Industries (EFID.CA) and Arabian Food Industries - Domty - (DOMT.CA) lost 50%, 49% and 49% respectively of their values since the beginning of 2016, where on the other hand the EGX30 gained 18% during the same period. SOURCE: BLOOMBERG 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 Oct-15 Nov-15 Dec-15 Jan-16 Feb-16 Mar-16 Apr-16 May-16 Jun-16 Jul-16 Aug-16 Sep-16 Oct-16 JUFO EGX30 Rebased 0 1,000 2,000 3,000 4,000 5,000 6,000 7,000 8,000 9,000 0 5 10 15 20 25 Jan-16 Feb-16 Mar-16 Apr-16 May-16 Jun-16 Jul-16 Aug-16 Sep-16 Oct-16 JUFO EFID DOMT EGX30 1
  • 2. PRIME INVESTMENT RESEARCH FOOD & BEVERAGE |EGYPT JUHAYNA FOOD INDUSTRIES – VALUATION UPDATE OCTOBER 30, 2016 SOURCE: BLOOMBERG & PRIME ESTIMATES The severe drop in prices in the local F&B stocks, especially Juhayna have made them appear very appealing to investors, as they currently trade at low P/E multiples, when compared to their global peers. Company Name P/E - 2016 (x) Global Peers Huishian Dairy 48.59 Bright Dairy 46.82 Danone 29.66 Saputo Inc 26.50 Dairy Crest Group 22.17 Vietnam Dairy 21.93 Maeil Dairy Industry Co Ltd 20.76 Dean Foods Co. 16.11 Synlait Milk Ltd. 14.55 China Dairy 3.10 Median Global Peers 22.05 Company Name P/E - 2016 (x) Regional Peers Al Marai 24.36 Agthia Group 19.87 Halwani Bros. 17.47 Jordan Dairy 16.83 Sadafco 15.43 Savola 14.95 Median Regional Peers 17.15 Company Name P/E - 2016 (x) Local Peers Edita Food Industries 18.7 Arabian Food Industries - Domty 16.1 Median Local Peers 17.4 Company Name P/E - 2016 (x) Juhayna Food Industries 15.99 2
  • 3. PRIME INVESTMENT RESEARCH FOOD & BEVERAGE |EGYPT JUHAYNA FOOD INDUSTRIES – VALUATION UPDATE OCTOBER 30, 2016 JUFO VS. EGX 30 INDEX – 2010-2016 YTD JUFO STOCK PERFORMANCE - 2016 SOURCE: BLOOMBERG Since Juhayna’ listing on the EGX in 2010, the stock’s performance has usually been better than that of the EGX30, however, 2016 has been different. Many negative incidents have led the stock’s price to deteriorate, including: 1. Poor 2Q2016 results – August 2016. 2. Exclusion from the EGX 30 Index – August 2016. 3. Exclusion from the FTSE Russel Index – September 2016. 4. Poor 3Q2016 results – October 2016. 13% -49% 48% 20% 31% -22% 18% 30% -36% 104% 102% -18% -15% -50% -60% -40% -20% 0% 20% 40% 60% 80% 100% 120% 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 EGX30 JUFO 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 Jan-16 Feb-16 Mar-16 Apr-16 May-16 Jun-16 Jul-16 Aug-16 Sep-16 Oct-16 Poor 2Q2016 Results Exclusion from EGX30 Exclusion from FTSE Russell Index Poor 3Q2016 Results 3
  • 4. PRIME INVESTMENT RESEARCH FOOD & BEVERAGE |EGYPT JUHAYNA FOOD INDUSTRIES – VALUATION UPDATE OCTOBER 30, 2016 Financial Statements … Historical & Forecast Income Statement Brief Hist. Forecast In EGP Mn 2015 2016F 2017F 2018F Revenues 4,231 4,898.2 5,879.7 6,702.1 Change 15% 16% 20% 14% COGS 2,558.8 3,159.9 3,830.6 4,408.6 Change 2% 23% 21% 15% Gross Profit 1,672.4 1,738.2 2,049.1 2,293.5 Depreciation & Amortization 204.3 235.6 266.3 299.6 EBITDA 863.4 768.4 933.4 1,010.8 Net Income (Before Minority Interest) 279.9 228.0 361.9 432.9 Net Income (After Minority Interest) 279.9 227.8 361.6 432.6 Net Attributable Income 279.8 205.4 325.9 389.9 NPM 7% 5% 6% 6% Balance Sheet Brief Hist. Forecast In EGP Mn 2015 2016F 2017F 2018F Cash 794.9 192.9 238.9 253.9 Net Receivables 171.9 201.3 241.6 275.4 Net Inventory 606.9 703.4 771.4 854.5 Other Current Assets 16.1 1.1 1.3 1.5 Total Current Assets 1,589.8 1,098.6 1,253.2 1,385.4 Net PPE 2,761.2 2,968.3 3,373.2 3,267.6 Other LT-Assets 644.2 699.7 199.7 199.7 Total Long Term Assets 3,405.5 3,667.9 3,572.9 3,467.3 Total Assets 4,995.3 4,766.6 4,826.1 4,852.7 Liabilities STD - incl CPLTD 916.9 1,084.6 1,048.8 963.7 Accounts Payable 199.4 207.7 251.8 289.8 Total Current Liabilities 1,307.02 1,455.4 1,499.8 1,481.9 Total Long Term Liabilities 1,265.3 845.5 601.2 375.4 4
  • 5. PRIME INVESTMENT RESEARCH FOOD & BEVERAGE |EGYPT JUHAYNA FOOD INDUSTRIES – VALUATION UPDATE OCTOBER 30, 2016 SOURCE: JUHAYNA & PRIME ESTIMATES SOURCE: JUHAYNA & PRIME ESTIMATES Total Liabilities 2,572.3 2,300.9 2,101.01 1,857.3 Equity Paid-in-Capital 941.4 941.4 941.4 941.4 Reserves 798.3 812.3 823.7 841.7 RE 682.5 712.04 960.05 1,212.3 Total Equity 2,422.9 2,465.7 2,725.1 2,995.4 Financial Ratios Hist. Forecast GPM 40% 35% 35% 34% EBITDA Margin 20% 16% 16% 15% NPM 7% 5% 6% 6% EPS 0.30 0.24 0.38 0.46 DPS 0.15 0.08 0.13 0.18 P/E 13.02 15.99 10.07 8.42 EV/EBITDA 5.6 6.0 4.6 3.9 ROA 6.20% 4.11% 6.84% 8.08% ROE 12.20% 8.43% 13.21% 14.36% Debt / Equity Ratio Total Assets Turnover 52.98% 49.61% 42.04% 33.67% 0.85 1.03 1.22 1.38 5
  • 6. PRIME INVESTMENT RESEARCH FOOD & BEVERAGE |EGYPT JUHAYNA FOOD INDUSTRIES – VALUATION UPDATE OCTOBER 30, 2016 PRICE HIKES’ TIMELINE REVENUE CONTRIBUTION (%) – 9M2016 REVENUE CONTRIBUTION (%) – 3Q2016 REVENUES - EGP MN. Financial Analysis & Key Highlights: Revenues: Financial Analysis & Key Highlights: Revenues: 1,259 1,135 3,696 3,103 0 500 1,000 1,500 2,000 2,500 3,000 3,500 4,000 3Q2016 3Q2015 9M2016 9M2015 Juhayna was able to achieve healthy growth rates in revenues during the 3Q2016 and the 9M2016. During the 3Q2016, the company achieved revenues of EGP 1,259mn versus EGP 1,135mn during the same period a year earlier, showing a growth rate of 11%. During the 9M2016, the company achieved revenues of EGP 3,696mn, against EGP 3,103mn during the same period a year earlier, showing a growth rate of 19%. The largest contributor to revenues remained to be the dairy segment, contributing 51% to revenues, followed by the juice and yogurt segments contributing 23% and 22% respectively during 3Q2016. As for the 9M2016, the revenue contribution is also led by the dairy segment with a contribution of 47%, followed by the yogurt and juice segments with 25% and 22% respectively. This rise in revenues came on the back of both; volumes and prices. During the 1Q2016, the company did not raise the price of any of its products, yet it ceased all the promotions / offers that it used to offer to customers. Starting April, the company decided to gradually raise prices on all of its products, where each month, the company would raise the blended average price by 2-5%. The management believes that raising the prices gradually is better than raising the prices in a single price hike with regards to customers’ perceptions and competition. The company expects to keep raising prices in this manner in the comping 5-6 quarters. During the 2Q2016, the company raised the average blended price by 6%, divided equally on 3 months. Meanwhile, during the 3Q2016, the company followed suit where it raised the average blended price by 6-7%, where prices rose by 4% and 2-3% during July and August respectively. During October the company managed to further increase the average blended price by 5% and the management intends to keep raising prices in the same manner each month till the end of year. The management targets to raise prices by 30% throughout 2016; meaning that prices will increase by a further 8% during November and December. On a segment level, the company was able to raise the prices the most for the juice segment, followed by the dairy and yogurt segments. During the 9M2016, the company raised the prices of the juice, dairy and yogurt products by 14%, 11.5% and 3.5% respectively. During the 10M2016, the company raised the prices of the juice, dairy and yogurt products by 25%, 19% and 5% respectively. Dairy , 51% Yogurt , 22% Juice, 23% Concentrat es , 2% Agriculture , 0.3% Arju, 1.7% Dairy , 47% Yogurt , 25% Juice, 22% Concentrate s , 2% Agriculture , 2% Arju, 2% 0% 0% 0% 2% 2% 2% 4% 2 - 3% 0% 5% 0% 1% 2% 3% 4% 5% 6% Jan-16 Feb-16 Mar-16 Apr-16 May-16 Jun-16 Jul-16 Aug-16 Sep-16 Oct-16 1Q2016 No price hikes - Only freezing of Promotions / Offers 2Q2016 The blended average price rose by 6%, with an equal increase of 2% per month 3Q2016 The blended average price rose by 6-7%, with an increase of 4% and 2-3% during July and August respectively. 4Q2016 The blended average price rose by 5% during October and the management intends to keep raising prices each month till the end of year. 6
  • 7. PRIME INVESTMENT RESEARCH FOOD & BEVERAGE |EGYPT JUHAYNA FOOD INDUSTRIES – VALUATION UPDATE OCTOBER 30, 2016 DAIRY – REVENUES – EGP MN. YOGURT – REVENUES – EGP MN. JUICE – REVENUES – EGP MN. CONCENTRATES – REVENUES – EGP MN. AGRICULTURE – REVENUES – EGP MN. SOURCE: JUHAYNA Dairy: The dairy segment showed a healthy growth in revenues. Dairy revenues stood at EGP 636mn and EGP 1,744mn during 3Q2016 and 9M2016 respectively. The growth in revenues was mainly driven by an increase in prices, as prices in the dairy segment rose by 11.5% during the 9M2016. Yogurt: The yogurt segment‘s revenues dropped in 3Q2016 by 5% y-o-y, while it grew in 9M2016 by 14%. The yogurt revenues stood at EGP 283mn and EGP 923mn during 3Q2016 and 9M2016 respectively. The drop in revenues in 3Q2016 was due to the effect of the Holy month of Ramadan. Ramadan is considered the peak season for yogurt sales. The majority of Ramadan occurred during the second quarter of 2016, where Ramadan was divided between the second quarter and the third quarter in 2015. The management was hesitant to increase prices for yogurt, as consumers tend to be quiet price sensitive with respect to yogurt; when the company increased the yogurt prices by 25% in 2013, the company lost market share and the volumes were hit severely. Consequently, during the 9M2016, the yogurt prices were increased by the lowest rate, 3.5% and thus the 14% increase in yogurt sales was mainly driven by an increase in volumes. Juice: The juice segment showed the largest growth among the main company’s segments, growing by 22% and 38% during the 3Q2016 and 9M2016 respectively. The juice segment’s revenues stood at EGP 293mn and EGP 812mn during the 3Q2016 and the 9M2016 respectively. The company was able to increase the prices of the juice products the most, where the juice prices rose by 14% during the 9M2016 and it was able to further increase the prices in October by more than 10%, reaching an aggregate increase of 25% during the 10M2016. Even though the 22% growth rate that was achieved in 3Q2016 is considered good, it is much lower than the rate of the previous 2 quarters; the growth rates in the juice segment during the 1Q2016 and 2Q2016 were 62% and 42%. This is mainly due to the high base effect, where the juice segment was expanded to a large extent during the 3Q2015. Concentrates: The concentrates segment showed the highest growth among all the sectors during the 3Q2016 and the 9M2016, growing by 58% and 60% respectively. The concentrates revenues stood at EGP 20mn and 87mn during the 3Q2016 and the 9M2016 respectively. This is mainly due the new concentrates’ production line that was added in El Marwa factory, which almost increased the production capacity by 50%. Agriculture: The agriculture segment’s revenues dropped during 3Q2016 by 33%, yet it grew during the 9M2016 at a healthy rate of 10%. The agriculture segment’s revenues stood at EGP 4mn and EGP 59mn during the 3Q2016 and the 9M2016 respectively. The drop in the segment’s revenues was mainly due to some changes that occurred with respect with the types of fruits produced and their implied seasonality. Arju: Revenues from Juhayna’s VC - Arju – stood at EGP 22mn and EGP 77mn during the 3Q2016 and the 9M2016 respectively. Arju’s revenues appeared for the first time during the 1Q2016. At the beginning of 2016, the management had a target of achieving revenues from Arju of almost EGP250mn, yet it was revised down two times; where at the end it was set at EGP 100mn. The below-expectations performance of Arju was mainly due to the FX crunch and some disruptions with imports. Arju’s Second Phase: It is worthy to note that the company bought a plot of land in order to construct a new production plant for the Arju new products. Construction is expected to begin early 2017 and production is expected to start during 2018, which is consistent with the VC’s initial plan. 636 579 1,744 1,595 0 500 1,000 1,500 2,000 3Q2016 3Q2015 9M2016 9M2015 283 296 923 813 0 200 400 600 800 1,000 3Q2016 3Q2015 9M2016 9M2015 293 241 812 587 0 200 400 600 800 1,000 3Q2016 3Q2015 9M2016 9M2015 20 13 87 55 0 20 40 60 80 100 3Q2016 3Q2015 9M2016 9M2015 4 6 59 54 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 3Q2016 3Q2015 9M2016 9M2015 7
  • 8. PRIME INVESTMENT RESEARCH FOOD & BEVERAGE |EGYPT JUHAYNA FOOD INDUSTRIES – VALUATION UPDATE OCTOBER 30, 2016 WHOLE MILK POWDER -WMP – PRICES – USD/MT SOURCE: GLOBAL DAIRY TRADE COGS: Juhayna’s COGS were negatively affected during the 3Q2016 and the 9M2016, increasing by 22% and 28% respectively. The increase in COGS surpassed the increase in revenues, affecting the company’s margins. The hike in COGS is mainly affected by the FX exposure. The company has a very high negative exposure to FX. Moreover the non-EGP revenues represent a minimal 3% of the total revenues, where it only covers c2-5% of the company’s FX requirements. Since the 2Q2016, the company started resorting to the parallel market, where the spread between the official market and the parallel market rates had a range of 40-55%. Since then, the company secures c90% of its FX requirements from the parallel market, at a rate of 12-13 EGP/USD. The company is subject to exchange rate risk, as 60% of the direct raw materials are imported, which represent almost 50% of the total COGS. The management is trying to “localize” more of the direct raw materials and it has a target of reaching 50% instead of 60% within one year in order to reduce its exposure to FX. The localizing of the raw materials will be mainly directed towards the concentrates segment; currently 50% of the mango concentrates are imported from India and the management seeks to localize it 100% within one year. Meanwhile, the management seeks to depend more on their local dairy farm to secure raw milk, in case the prices of powder milk keep on increasing at faster than anticipated rates. Also, the company is currently trying to secure the packaging materials for yogurt (plastics) locally. Gross Profit: Even though the company raised the prices among all of its products, it was unable to pass all the increase in COGs to consumers, which consequently affected the company’s margins. The company achieved a gross profit of EGP 380mn and EGP 1.1bn during the 3Q2016 and 9M2016 respectively. The company’s GPM stood at 30% during the 3Q2016 and 9M2016 respectively, versus 37% and 35% during 3Q2015 and 9M2015 respectively. Dairy Farm: Juhayna’s dairy farm remains to be on top of the management’s priorities. Currently the herd consists of 2,500 Holstein milking cows and 1,000 Holstein non-milking cows (50% are pregnant and the remaining 50% are female babies). It is expected that the cows herd will reach 4,000 milking cows by late 2016 / early 2017, post receiving one or two shipments. After the first phase will be completed (reaching a herd of 4,000 milking cows), the phase will be evaluated and the beginning / postponement of phase 2 will be decided upon the first phase’s evaluation. Inventory of Powder Milk: Juhayna has powder milk stock that is sufficient for production till June 2017. It is worthy to note that the powder milk prices started to pick up since July 2016, where prices hiked by 20-30% since July till October. The hike in prices is simply a matter of supply and demand and it is somehow a rebound after the huge drop in powder milk prices that took place in 2015. According to management, the outlook for powder milk prices is currently quiet unclear, however they expect prices to have an average of USD 3,000/MT in 2017. Any increase in the prices of the powder milk would have a negative impact on the company’s margins, and the impact would be further enlarged incase further EGP devaluation / floatation occurs as the powder milk is entirely imported. 2,453 2,148 2,260 2,304 2,210 2,188 1,952 1,890 1,974 1,971 2,013 2,156 2,176 2,252 2,205 2,118 2,062 2,079 2,265 2,695 2,793 2,782 2,681 2,760 0 500 1,000 1,500 2,000 2,500 3,000 Nov-15 Dec-15 Jan-16 Feb-16 Mar-16 Apr-16 May-16 Jun-16 Jul-16 Aug-16 Sep-16 Oct-16 8
  • 9. PRIME INVESTMENT RESEARCH FOOD & BEVERAGE |EGYPT JUHAYNA FOOD INDUSTRIES – VALUATION UPDATE OCTOBER 30, 2016 Sales & Distribution Expenses: The sales and distribution expenses had a major impact on the company’s performance. The company’s sales and distribution expenses rose by 13% and 29% during 3Q2016 and 9M2016 respectively. The company recorded EGP 197mn and EGP 601mn in 3Q2016 and 9M2016 respectively as sales and distribution expenses. The rise in the sales and distribution expenses is due to the fact that the company increased its distribution fleet (vans and trucks) by 20% since the beginning of 2016. Moreover, the sales and distribution expenses is directly related to sales, so its increase is also a result of the increase in sales, yet the sales and distribution expenses as a percentage of revenues increased in 3Q2016 and 9M2016, as it stood at 15.6% and 16.25% in 3Q2016 and 9M2016 respectively, against 15.3% and 15% during the comparable periods a year earlier. Financing Income & Financing Expenses: The net financing expenses increased during the 3Q2016 and 9M2016. The company incurred net financing expenses of EGP 66mn and EGP 163mn during the 3Q2016 and 9M2016, growing by 45% and 29% respectively. The largest bulk is for the interest expenses; which stood at EGP 71mn and EGP 191mn during 3Q2016 and 9M2016 respectively. The rise in the interest expense is due to the variable interest rates which is linked to the corridor rate. The corridor rate in Egypt rose by c250bps throughout 2016. The current cost of debt for the company stands at 14.5%. Moreover, the company obtained medium-term financing through Qatar National Bank (QNB) and HSBC totaling EGP78mn during 2Q2016. CAPEX: Juhayna revised down its CAPEX plans for 2016 to EGP 500mn from EGP 640mn that was previously set. During 2016, the company added 8 filling lines (3 for milk, 3 for juice and 2 for yogurt) and a single production line for concentrates. In the 9M2016, the company invested EGP 408mn, where the company invested EGP 67mn in production, EGP 14mn in distribution and EGP 44mn in farming. As the company increased the production capacity for all the segments during the last 2 years, the management believes that such expansions are very sufficient during the coming few years and that CAPEX is expected to be relaxed during the coming years. Due to the FX crunch and somehow the lack of visibility, the management decided to postpone any major CAPEX projects that were planned for 2017, suggesting that such projects (including capacity additions) may be revisited by 2H2018. In 2017, the company will solely focus on completing the existing projects. VAT: Juhayna started to apply the Value Added Tax (VAT) starting September 2016. The effect of the VAT on the company is minimal – less than 1% -, as dairy and yogurt are exempted. Even though the juice is subject to tax, each juice sub-category is subject to VAT in a different manner. The pure juice, c.20% of the total juice sales, is subject to 13%, while on the other hand, the drink juice, c.80% of the total juice sales, is subject to only 3% at the consumer level, where the other 10% would be paid by the company at the concentrates level. Market Shares: Even though the competition is still very tough, the company remained to be a market leader in dairy and yogurt. - Milk: The company’s market share advanced 3 points, standing at c66%. Al Marai and Danone remain to the be the company’s main competitors. - Yogurt: The company’s market share has been quiet consistent in the spoonable yogurt with a share of 33%. However, the market share for the drinkable yogurt advanced by 9 points, standing at c44%. The increase in the drinkable yogurt came on the back of the introduction of 2 new products; Mix Drinkable Yogurt and Zabado Plus. Danone and Lactalis remain to be the main competitors for the spoonable and drinkable yogurt respectively. - Juice: Competition is toughest in the juice category. Juhayna lost 2 points in the market share in juice, reaching 20%. The deterioration in the market share is mainly due to Al Marai, who started offering a lowered priced product. Beyti and Faragello remain to be the main competitors for Juhayna in the juice segment. It is worthy to note that the management stressed that they have always had two main priorities; profitability and maintaining market shares. However, in case the two priorities could not be attained in a certain period (such as the current period), the management would take actions in favor of profitability against maintaining their market shares. 9
  • 10. PRIME INVESTMENT RESEARCH FOOD & BEVERAGE |EGYPT JUHAYNA FOOD INDUSTRIES – VALUATION UPDATE OCTOBER 30, 2016 Stock Recommendation Guidelines Recommendation Target-to-Market Price (x) Buy x > 15% Accumulate 5%< x <15% Hold -5% < x < 5% Reduce -15% < x < -5% Sell x < -15% Strong Buy x > 40% Investment Grade Explanation Growth 3 Yr. Earnings CAGR > 20% Value Equity Positioned Within Maturity Stage of Cycle Speculative Quality Earnings Reflect Above Normal Risk Factor 10
  • 11. PRIME INVESTMENT RESEARCH FOOD & BEVERAGE |EGYPT JUHAYNA FOOD INDUSTRIES – VALUATION UPDATE OCTOBER 30, 2016 PRIME SECURITIES Hassan Samir Managing Director  +202 3300 5611  Hsamir@egy.primegroup.org RESEARCH TEAM Aboubakr Emam, CFA Head of Research  +202 3300 5724  Aemam@egy.primegroup.org Eman Negm, MSc Economist  +202 3300 5716  Enegm@egy.primegroup.org Mohamed Marei Equity Analyst  +202 3300 5725  Mmarei@egy.primegroup.org Ali Afifi Equity Analyst  +202 3300 5723  Aafifi@egy.primegroup.org Omneya El Hammamy Equity Analyst  +202 3300 5718  OelHammamy@egy.primegroup.org Ingy Fahmy Equity Analyst  +202 3300 5722  Iashraf@egy.primegroup.org Taher Seif Equity Analyst  +202 3300 5719  Tseif@egy.primegroup.org Mohamed Magdi Junior Equity Analyst  +202 3300 5720  Mmagdi@egy.primegroup.org SALES TEAM Mohamed Ezzat Head of Sales & Branches  +202 3300 5784  mezzat@egy.primegroup.org Shawkat Raslan Heliopolis Branch Manager  +202 3300 5110  sraslan@egy.primegroup.org Amr Saber Team Head – Institutions Desk  +202 3300 5659  asaber@egy.primegroup.org Amr Alaa, CFTe Manager  +202 3300 5609  aalaa@egy.primegroup.org Mohamed Elmetwaly Manager  +202 3300 5610  melmetwaly@egy.primegroup.org Emad Elsafoury Manager  +202 3300 5624  eelsafoury@egy.primegroup.org HEAD OFFICE PRIME SECURITIES S.A.E. Regulated by CMA license no. 179 Members of the Cairo Stock Exchange 2 Wadi El Nil St., Liberty Tower, 7th-8thFloor, Mohandessin, Giza, Egypt Tel: +202 33005700/770/650/649 Fax: +202 3760 7543 Disclaimer Information included in this report has no regard to specific investment objectives, financial situation, advices or particular needs of the report users. The report is published for information purposes only and is not to be construed as a solicitation or an offer to buy or sell any securities or related financial instruments. Unless specifically stated otherwise, all price information is only considered as indicator. No express or implied representation or guarantee is provided with respect to completeness, accuracy or reliability of information included in this report. Past performance is not necessarily an indication of future results. Fluctuation of foreign currency rates of exchange may adversely affect the value, price or income of any products mentioned in this report. Information included in this report should not be regarded by report users as a substitute for the exercise of their own due diligence and analysis based on own assessment and judgment criteria. Any opinions given are subject to change without notice and may significantly differ or be contrary to opinions expressed by other Prime business areas as a result of using different assumptions and criteria. Prime Group is under no obligation responsible to update or keep current the information contained herein. Prime Group, its directors, officers, employees or clients may have or have had interests or long or short positions in the securities and/or currencies referred to herein, and may at any time make purchases and/or sales in them as principal or agent. Prime Group, its related entities, directors, employees and agents accepts no liability whatsoever for any loss or damage of any kind arising from the use of all or part of these information included in this report. Certain laws and regulations impose liabilities which cannot be disclaimed. This disclaimer shall, in no way, constitute a waiver or limitation of any rights a person may have under such laws and/or regulations. Furthermore, Prime Group or any of the group companies may have or have had a relationship with or may provide or have provided other services, within its objectives to the relevant companies. Copyright 2016 Prime Group all rights reserved. You are hereby notified that distribution and copying of this document is strictly prohibited without the prior approval of Prime Group. 11