SlideShare une entreprise Scribd logo
1  sur  98
How to Engage Physicians in
Best Practices to Respond to
Healthcare Transformation
Kent Bottles, MD
www.kentbottlesmd.com
kent@kentbottlesmd.com
Georgia CPA Society
February 11, 2016
Dr. Kent Bottles
Lecturer
Thomas Jefferson University College of Population Health
kentbottles@gmail.com
www.kentbottlesmd.com
What Leaders Do
• Establish a vision that can inspire others
– Environmental assessment of opportunities,
risks, challenges
• Translate the vision into strategies &
tactics
• Assign responsibilities to the right people
• Hold the assigned people accountable
Managing Complex Change
VisionVision SkillsSkills Incentives or
Consequences
Incentives or
Consequences ResourcesResources Action
Plan
Action
Plan
SkillsSkills Incentives or
Consequences
Incentives or
Consequences ResourcesResources Action
Plan
Action
Plan
VisionVision Incentives or
Consequences
Incentives or
Consequences ResourcesResources Action
Plan
Action
Plan
VisionVision SkillsSkills ResourcesResources Action
Plan
Action
Plan
VisionVision SkillsSkills Incentives or
Consequences
Incentives or
Consequences
Action
Plan
Action
Plan
VisionVision SkillsSkills Incentives or
Consequences
Incentives or
Consequences ResourcesResources
CHANGE
Confusion
Anxiety
Gradual Change
Frustration
False Starts
2015 Healthcare Trends
• Consolidation
• Patient-Centered
• Payment Reform
• Big Data PA
• Population Health
• Transparency
• Accountability
• Risk Transfer
• Technology
• High-Cost Drugs
Old New
• Sickness System
• Health: No Disease
• Acute Disease
• Fee for Service
• Hospital Beds Full
• Hospital-Centric
• Doctor-Centric
• Doctor Decides
• MD Defines Quality
• Wellness System
• Health: Wellness
• Chronic Disease
• Value-Based
• Hospital Beds Empty
• Community-Centric
• Patient-Centric
• Shared Dec. Making
• Measurable Metrics
• Cost not considered
• Independent doctors
• Independent hospital
• Med record secret
• Opaque
• Artificial harmony
• Analogue
• Hypothesis-driven
clinical trials
• Decreased cost
• Employed docs
• Integrated system
• Open access record
• Transparent
• Cognitive conflict
• Digital
• Predictive analytics
actionable correlations
Old New
David Feinberg, MD
WSJ, September 27, 2015
“I think my job ultimately is to close every
one of our hospitals. Because we should
take care of you at home. We should take
care of you at school. Nobody wants to go
to the hospital. We really need to work to
keep people healthy. Now, people will still
get hit by cars, and there’ll be complex
surgeries that require hospitalizations. But
I’m trying to put myself out of business.”
Payment Reform
1010
The Curve
Bundled
Payments
Partial
Capitation
Global
Payment
Fee for
Service
Shared
Savings
Visitor
Symptomatic
Acute Needs
Services & Supplies
Unit Based
No Financial Risk
Visitor
Symptomatic
Acute Needs
Services & Supplies
Unit Based
No Financial Risk
Patient
Episode
Most Common Conditions
Packaged Treatments
Efficiency-Based
Partial Financial Risk
Patient
Episode
Most Common Conditions
Packaged Treatments
Efficiency-Based
Partial Financial Risk
Person
Overall Health
Community Health
Characteristics
Manage Well-Being
Outcome-Based
Full Financial Risk
Person
Overall Health
Community Health
Characteristics
Manage Well-Being
Outcome-Based
Full Financial Risk
Delivery System Reform
A Promise from HHS
Source: HHS Secretary Sylvia Burwell (January 30, 2015)
The Price Ain’t Right? Hospital Prices and Health
Spending on the Privately Insured*
Zack Cooper, Yale University
Stuart Craig, University of Pennsylvania
Martin Gaynor, Carnegie Mellon
John Van Reenen, London School of Economics
December 2015
www.healthcarepricingproject.org
*This research received financial support from the Commonwealth Fund, the National Institute for
Health Care Management, and the Economic and Social Science Research Council.
Medicare
Private
Introduction
• The U.S. spends more than other nations on healthcare—$2.8 trillion dollars
(17.2% of GDP)—without evidence of better outcomes
• Wide-ranging analysis of variation in healthcare spending via Medicare suggests
quantity of care given drives spending variation
• However, results may not generalize to private markets where prices are not set
administratively
• However, almost no nation-wide hospital-specific price data and scant data on
spending for privately insured
16
© Cooper, Craig, Gaynor, and Van Reenen
Key Findings – Price Plays
Crucial Role in Spending by
Privately Insured
1. Low correlation (0.140) between Medicare and private spending
per person
2. Price explains large portion of national variation in inpatient
private spending
3. Substantial variation in prices, both within and across markets
4. Higher hospital market concentration is associated with higher
hospital prices
17© Cooper, Craig, Gaynor, and Van Reenen
Overview of the HCCI Data
18© Cooper, Craig, Gaynor, and Van Reenen
Medicare Spending Per Beneficiary
and Private Spending Per Beneficiary
19
© Cooper, Craig, Gaynor, and Van Reenen
Knee Replacement Facility
Prices Within MarketsDenver, CO Atlanta, GA Manhattan, NY
Columbus, OH Philadelphia, PA Houston, TX
Note: Each column is a hospital. Prices are regression-adjusted, measured from 2008 – 2011, and presented in 2011 dollars.
© Cooper, Craig, Gaynor, and Van Reenen
Colonoscopy Facility Prices
Within MarketsDenver, CO Atlanta, GA Manhattan, NY
Columbus, OH Philadelphia, PA Houston, TX
Note: Each column is a hospital. Prices are regression-adjusted, measured from 2008 – 2011, and presented in 2011 dollars.
© Cooper, Craig, Gaynor, and Van Reenen
Conclusions
1.Private health spending per beneficiary per HRR varies by a factor of three across the
nation
1.The correlation between HRR-level spending per Medicare beneficiary and spending per
privately insured beneficiary is low (14.0%)
1.There is extensive private spending variation within and across markets – up to 400%
within markets and far higher than Medicare within/across markets
1.Price is the primary driver of spending variation for the privately insured
1.Monopoly hospitals have a 15.3% price premium
22© Cooper, Craig, Gaynor, and Van Reenen
Conclusions Cont.
• We need to look beyond Grand Junction, Colorado; Rochester, Minnesota; and La Crosse,
Wisconsin
• If we think focuses on regions are important, look at: Rochester, New York; Dubuque,
Iowa; Lynchburg, VA; De Moines, Iowa
• Potential savings from reducing prices is large
» Applying Medicare rates lowers private inpatient spending by 31%
» Applying Medicare rates +10% lowers private inpatient spending by
24%
» Applying Medicare rates +30% lowers private inpatient spending by
11%
– Rather than attending current provider, if everyone paying above median prices got
Median pries in their HRR, it would lower inpatient spending by 20.3%.
23© Cooper, Craig, Gaynor, and Van Reenen
Policy Implications
• Strategies to address healthcare spending variation across the U.S. may differ for publicly
and privately insured populations
• Reducing spending for the privately insured will come via targeting high prices & service
intensity
• Anti-trust enforcement
• Price regulation
• Raise patients’ price elasticity
• Significant scope for savings by steering patients toward low-cost/high-quality providers
via value-based insurance design
• Significant need to make prices more transparent to consumers.
24© Cooper, Craig, Gaynor, and Van Reenen
Hospital, physician prices driving
health costs, business groups say
• Boston Globe, February 9, 2016
• Associated Industries of MA
• MA Association of Health Plans
• National Federation of Independent
Businesses
• Retailers Association of MA
State tells Boston Children’s
Hospital to slow down
• Boston Globe February 13, 2016
• $1 billion Boston’s Children’s Hospital
building expansion
• Hospital must provide independent analysis
that shows the project is consistent with the
Commonwealth’s efforts to meet healthcare
cost-containment goals
ProPublica Surgeon Scorecards
• Medicare claims data 2009 to 2013
• Complication rates for 17,000 surgeons doing 8
procedures
• Mortality rates and readmissions data used as
proxy for complication rates
• Complication rates were risk adjusted for
coexisting conditions and hospital quality
ProPublica Surgeon Scorecards
• 11% of surgeons accounted for 25% of
complications
• Hundreds of surgeons had complication rates at
least twice the national average
• ProPublica recommends patients use the ratings to
select a surgeon and a hospital
ProPublica Surgeon Scorecards
• Rand Corporation perspective attacked
methodology and said pts should not use
• Dr. Lisa Rosenbaum in NEJM: no better than Yelp
• Dr. Peter Pronovost: adjusted complication rate
was not true complication rate due to being based
on flawed claims data
ProPublica Surgeon Scorecards
• Dr. Charles Mick, former president of North
American Spine Society said scorecard long
overdue and wonderful to have information in
the public
• Dr. Robert Wachter: if I were a pt., I would
give scorecard considerable weight in choosing
doctor
• Paul Levy called for public release of
American College of Surgeons National
Surgical Quality Improvement Program results
ProPublica Surgeon Scorecards
• Dr. Shephard Hurwitz announced scorecard
would be used by American Board of
Orthopaedic Surgery to recertify surgeons
• If a surgeon has a high complication rate,
recertification may be delayed or interview for
more details might be suggested
• “It is controversial, but the fact is that we’re
doing it in the spirit of transparency and
holding people accountable for what’s already
in the public domain”
Hospital
Readmission
Program
Accountable
Care
Organization
s
DRG
Modifier
Hospital
Value-Based
Purchasing
HAC
Reduction
Bundled
Payments
Physician
Value
Modifier
Physician
Quality
Reporting
System
Care
Management
CAHPS
Surveys
EHR
Incentive
Program
(Meaningful
Use)
Quality
Programs
Many Programs Affect Revenue
Let’s Talk Dollars: What’s at Stake?
By 2017, up to 9% of
Medicare PFS
reimbursement could be
lost due to Value-
Modifier, PQRS, and
Meaningful Use penalties.
By 2016, 1.75% of DRG
Payments will be
withheld and potentially
retained based on
performance over several
categories.
It’s Not Just CMS…
• Commercial payers are
also beginning to
require inclusion of
quality measures and
programs. Major
payers are quickly
jumping on board:
– BCBS
– Aetna
– Cigna
– United Healthcare
MACRA
Medicare Access and CHIP
Reauthorization Act of 2015
Payment Reform - Annual Updates
2015
0.5% update effective June 1
- versus 21 percent cut scheduled for April 1
2016 – 2019 0.5% annual updates
2020 - 2025 No updates
2026+
0.75% annual updates for providers in alternative
payment models
0.25% annual updates for everyone else
The SGR Fix
Benefits:
Certainty of payments
for the next 10 years
No annual fear of
unrealistic payment cuts
Concerns:
Does 0.5% keep up with
medical inflation (plus
the inherent costs of
participation in quality
programs)?
What’s the Problem With Current System?
MIPS – the Details
• Repeals PQRS and MU penalties and VM program
effective December 31, 2018; replaces with MIPS
– Providers will receive a composite score from 1 to 100 based
on quality measures, efficiency measures, meaningful use of
electronic health records, and clinical practice improvement
activities; score will be made publicly available
– Each year, CMS will establish a threshold score based on
median/mean composite performance scores of all providers
measured during previous performance period
Composite Performance Score
For Example: Historic PQRS Measures
For Example: Cost Measures included in
VM Program
For Example: Potentially Stage 3
Requirements of MU
Program
For Example: Population Health
Initiatives
MIPS Scoring System
0 100
Quality Efficiency
Meaningful
Use
Clinical
Process
Improvement
78
National Median Composite Provider
Score (Example)
= Medicare Provider
= National Median Composite Score
Adjustment Factor
Year Penalty Cap Bonus opportunity
(subject to scaling factor)
2019 -4% Up to +12%
2020 -5% Up to +15%
2021 -7% Up to +21%
2022 -9% Up to +27%
Exceptional Performance Incentive Payment
If meet or beat stretch goal, also receive payment from
annual $500 million incentive bonus pool (not to exceed 10 percent)
By no later than December 2 each year, CMS will make available each eligible
professional’s adjustment factor for upcoming year
Quality Measures Component
• CMS to finalize annual list of quality measures by
November 1 of preceding year
– Clinical care
– Safety
– Care coordination
– Patient and caregiver experience
– Population health and prevention
• Preference for measures endorsed by professional
organizations; others subject to peer review
procedures
Quality Measure
Development Plan
• CMS to publish draft plan by 01/01/16 and final plan
by 05/01/16; annual reports on implementation
• $15 million annually from 2015 to 2019
• Priorities
– Outcomes (including patient-reported and functional status)
– Patient experience
– Care coordination
– Appropriate resource use
Resource Use Measures
Component
• Incorporate current VM total cost-of-care
measures
• Measures development
– CMS to develop new classification codes in 2016-17
• Care episode groups
• Patient condition groups
• Patient relationship categories
– Beginning January 1, 2018, claims must include new
codes as appropriate
EHR Meaningful Use
Component
• Credit based on meeting then-current meaningful
use requirements
• Eliminate inconsistencies in quality measure
reporting requirements
Clinical Practice Improvement
Activities (CPIA) Component
• CMS to develop menu of specific CPIAs for
which EPs will receive credit
– Expanded practice access
– Population health management
– Care coordination
– Beneficiary engagement
– Patient safety and practice assessment
– Participation in alternative payment model
• Consideration for small and rural practices
…More MIPS
• Providers scoring below threshold subject to payment cuts
capped at 4% in 2019, 5% in 2020, 7% in 2021, and 9% in
2022.
• Providers scoring above threshold will receive bonus
payments, up to three times the annual penalty cap.
• Providers scoring above “stretch” performance score will
receive an additional bonus payment allocated from a
$500 million annual pool.
• Providers participating in alternative payment mechanisms
(APMs) may opt out of MIPs in favor of annual 5% bonus
payment.
Raising the Stakes
• Over time, the MIPS penalties
become substantially greater than
those contemplated in existing CMS
programs.
• This, coupled with the fact that
private payers are likely to “piggy-
back” on the MIPS program, make
the push for quality and efficiency
simply too strong for providers to
ignore.
• Just as before, there will be winners
and losers in this program.
• The legislation is very broadly
defined, CMS will have to fill in the
details…
Alternative Payment Models
2019 - 2024: 5% participation bonus
Two Tracks for Providers
Merit-Based Incentive Payment System
Advanced Alternative Payment Models
2020: -5% to +15%1
at risk
2019: Combine PQRS, MU, & VBM
programs: -4% to +12%1
at risk
2022 and on: -9% to
+27%1
at risk
2021: -7% to +21%1
at risk
2018: Last year of separate MU, PQRS,
and VBM penalties
2019 - 2020: 25% Medicare
revenue requirement
2021 and on: Ramped up Medicare or all-
payer revenue requirements
2015:H2 – 2019: 0.5% annual update 2026 and on: 0.25%
annual update
2026 and on: 0.75%
annual update
2020 – 2025: Frozen payment rates
2015:H2 – 2019: 0.5% annual update 2020 – 2025: Frozen payment rates
51
APM Framework White Paper
January 2016
• Health Care Payment Learning & Action
Network (LAN)
• Established in March 2015
• Private payers, large employers, providers,
patients, consumer groups, state
governments, federal government
• https://hcp-lan.org/workproducts/apm-
whitepaper.pdf
APM Framework White Paper
January 2016
• Changing financial reward to providers
• Patient input to APM design
• Patients should go to high-value providers
• Patients should be active in shared decision
making
APM Framework White Paper
January 2016
• Shift toward shared risk and population-
based payment models
• Value-based incentives intense enough for
providers to invest in and implement
delivery system reforms
• Value-based incentives should increase
• Centers of excellence, ACO, PCMH can be
supported by different payment models
APM Framework Category 1
January 2016
• FFS with No Link to Quality & Value
• DRG
• Not adjusted for
– Infrastructure investments
– Reporting of quality data
– Provider performance on cost
– Provider performance on quality
APM Framework Category 2
January 2016
• FFS Linked to Quality and Value
• 2A: Infrastructure payments
• 2B: Positive or negative incentives to
report quality data
• 2C: Rewards for high clinical quality
• 2D: Reward high clinical quality & penalize
low clinical quality providers
APM Framework Category 3
January 2016
• APMs Built on FFS Architecture
• Mechanism for management of procedures,
episode of care or all health services
• 3A: Upside opportunity to share in savings
• 3B: Upside gainsharing and downside risk
based on cost measures
APM Framework Category 4
January 2016
• Population0Based Payment
• Holds providers accountable for meeting
quality & person-centered care goals for a
population of patients
• Cover preventive, health improvement,
health maintenance, and specialized care
APM Framework Category 4
January 2016
• Population-Based Payment
• 4A: Population-based but limited to sets of
condition-specific services (asthma, DM,
cancer); they remain person-focused in that
they hold providers accountable for total
cost and quality of care for that condition
• 4B: Capitated or population-based for all of
individual’s healthcare needs
Health Care Learning & Action
Network (LAN)
January 2016
Population-Based Payment Work Group
Clinical Episode Payment Work Group
https://hcp-lan.org/workproducts/apm-
whitepaper.pdf
Docs Don’t Get SGR Fix Raise
• Medicare Physician Fee Schedule Final Rule Says
2016 pay will be 0.29% < 2015
• Protecting Access to Medicare Act & Achieving a
Better Life Experience Act & RVU Budget
Neutrality Rule mean conversion factor in 2016
will be $35.8279 (1.5 RVU = $53.74)
• RVU X Conversion Factor
– 1.5 RVU X $35.9335 = $53.90 (2015)
– 1.5 RVU X $37.7302 = $56.60 (2016)
None of this will work
without….
 Physician buy-in,
and
leadership is
critical to
success in a
value-based
payment world.
Physician View of Hospital
Administrators Weber, Physician Executive, July, 2006
• Insulated from pressures of patient care
• Don’t understand how hard doctors work
• Paid for non-productive work
• Worry about how much things cost
• Focus on problems
• Don’t get out from behind their desks
Hospital Administrator View of
Physicians Weber, Physician Executive, July, 2006
• Lack big-picture understanding
• Don’t make time to administrate; veto
decisions made by others
• Unwilling to confront peer physicians
• Do not make decisions; no leadership
• Act as if other providers are less valuable
than physicians; not good team players
Differences between
Administrators and Clinicians
Administrators
proactive planners
work well with groups
delayed gratification
id. with organization
establish rules
multidisciplinary
long time frame
institutional prerogative
influence
hospital: community asset
Clinicians
reactive
work well 1:1
quick gratification
id. with profession
resent rules
specialists
short time frame
individual prerogative
control
hospital: work shop
Collective vs. Expert Cultures
• Nurses, administrators
• Others ahead of self
• Trusting
• Value loyalty
• Avoid conflict/risk
• Thin-skinned
• Consensus building
• Process-oriented
• Engineering, MD, law
• Self-interest
• Accomplishment
• Power
• Teamwork not valued
• Quick decisions
• Thick-skinned
• Outcomes-oriented
Collective vs. Expert Cultures
• Malignant:
Cynic/Victim
• Have common
mission, values, vision
• Collaboration
• Malignant: Narcissism
• Specific vision where
self-interest is obvious
• Do not need mission,
values statements
• Collegiality
Expert Engineer Culture
Edgar H. Schein, DEC is Dead, Long Live DEC, 2003
• Individual commitment is not to employer
• People, organization, bureaucracy are constraints
to be overcome
• Engineering culture disdains management and
marketing
• No loyalty to customer: if trade-offs had to be
made between building “fun,” “elegant”
technologically challenging computers and the
needs of “dumb” customers guess who won?
Unhappy Doctors & Happy Doctors
• “Your doctor’s unhappiness is a
catastrophic problem that the new law
didn’t anticipate and is not prepared to
address.” Dr. Marc Siegel, Associate
Professor of Medicine, NYU Langone
Medical Center
• “To us, supporting the ACA makes moral
and medical sense.” Dr. Jeffrey Drazen,
Editor-in-Chief, and Dr. Gregory Curfman,
Executive Editor, NEJM
Dr. Daniel F. Craviotto, Jr.
• Docs in the trenches do not have a voice
• “Damn the mandates…from bureaucrats
who are not in the healing profession”
• EHRs waste time
• Board recertification is time consuming
• Physicians as a group should not accept any
health insurance
Dr. Aaron Carroll
• Complaining about no voice in WSJ
• “Most people have to choose between doing
God’s work and being in the 1%--Only doctors get
to do both”
• Board recertification is mandated by doctors
• “It’s tone deaf in today’s economy for people at
the top end of the spectrum to complain so
publicly about how little they are paid”
• Less than 1% of physicians opt out of Medicare
Dan Munro
• His criticisms are not patient-centered
• Orthopedics annual compensation of
$413,000
• 84 million non-elderly were uninsured or
underinsured in 2012
• 100 million Americans in poverty or in the
fretful zone just above it
• Half of all doctors believe they are fairly
compensated
Defying the Medical Machine
NY Times, January 10, 2016
• Increasing efficiency vs. deference to MDs
• Sacred Heart Medical Center, Springfield
• Bids to outsource 36 hospitalists positions
• MDs at Sacred Heart see 15 patients a day
• EmCare MDs see 15 to 18 patients a day
Defying the Medical Machine
NY Times, January 10, 2016
• “Giving me a bonus for seeing two more
patients – I’m not sure I should be doing
that. It’s safe.” Dr. Rajeev Alexander
• 1/3 of hospitalists left Sacred Heart
Defying the Medical Machine
NY Times, January 10, 2016
• Form a union
• Independent hospitalist group
• Form an alliance with outsourcing firm that
the doctors selected
Defying the Medical Machine
NY Times, January 10, 2016
• Spouse decides to play the field
• You’ve been great; you’ve always been
there
• I just heard there could be better spouses
out there
• The good news is, you’re still in the running
too
Defying the Medical Machine
NY Times, January 10, 2016
• Formed union with American Federation of
Teachers
• The administrator behind outsourcing left
• Outsourcing plan abandoned
Defying the Medical Machine
NY Times, January 10, 2016
• REAL rounds (Rounding embraced by all
leaders)
• “Are you kidding me. Real rounds as
opposed to what we do?” Dr. D. Schwartz
• “What’s the widget the hospital produces?
It’s the hospital-patient relationship. You
don’t improve it with extra little tasks.” Dr.
Rajeev Alexander
Defying the Medical Machine
NY Times, January 10, 2016
• Hospitalists insist it is not about the money
• Administrators insist it is about the money
Defying the Medical Machine
NY Times, January 10, 2016
• Skin in the game
• “It really took all of my self control to not
say, ‘What the hell do you mean skin in the
game?’ We have our licenses, our
livelihoods, our professions. Every single
time we walk up to a patient, everything is
on the line.”
Defying the Medical Machine
NY Times, January 10, 2016
• Skin in the game
• “My thought was, I’ll put some of my skin
in the game if you put your name on the
chart…If there’s a lawsuit, you’re on there.
You come down and make a decision about
my patient, then we’ll talk about skin in the
game.” Dr. David Schwartz
Danielle Ofri, MD
• 33% of HA1C at goal
• 44% of cholesterol at goal
• 26% of blood pressure at goal
Danielle Ofri, MD
• “I don’t even bother checking the results
anymore. I just quietly push the reports
under the pile of unread journals, phone
messages, insurance forms, and prior
authorizations.”
Kaiser IDs Gaps in MD Readiness for a
Reformed Delivery System (Crosson, Health Affairs, 2011)
• Systems thinking
• Leadership and management skills
• Continuity of care
• Care coordination
• Procedural skills
• Office-based practice competencies
– Inter-professional team skills
– Clinical IT meaningful use skills
– Population management skills
– Reflective practice and CQI skills
AHA Physician Leadership Forum:
Competency Development
• Leadership training
• Systems theory and analysis
• Use of information technology
• Cross-disciplinary training/team building
Mindset of the Traditional Physician
• My success depends on my individual
behavior
• Individual activities lead to personal financial
success
• Individual activities lead to successful clinical
outcomes
• Strong financial and clinical performance of
my parent organization and physician
colleagues have little impact on my personal
success
• “Cowboys”
Mindset of the Integrated
Employed Physician
• My success is enhanced by collaboration
• Individual activities lead to the financial success of parent
organization
• Individual activities lead to successful clinical outcomes
because of collaboration
• Strong financial and clinical performance of my parent
organization
• And physician colleagues have major impact on my personal
success
• “Pit Crews”
Traditional Physician Leadership
• Represent local physician interests at
organization-wide venues
• Secure resources for local physicians
• Rally physicians against perceived enemy
− Hospital administration
− Insurance companies
− Competing physicians
Physician Leadership in
Integrated Aligned System
• Holding physicians accountable for performance
• Working as part of a leadership team of the
organization
• Supporting decisions they may not personally
agree with
• Modeling behavior that supports the overall
organization goals
• Leaders job is not to protect, defend, and ensure
local interests that may conflict with overall
organization interests
• Leading in an integrated aligned system is a real
job
Leading Physicians Through
Change (Mary Jane Kornacki & Jack Silversin)
• Effective physician leadership
• Shared vision
• Compact: Alignment of behavior with
shared vision
• Physician leadership needed in a
transformed clinical delivery system
• Holding physicians accountable for clinical
performance
• Holding physicians accountable for
financial performance
• Working as part of leadership team
• Actively supporting decisions they do not
agree with
Leading Physicians Through
Change (Mary Jane Kornacki & Jack Silversin)
• Collect and organize relevant data
– Your organization’s mission
– Reliable data on current market reality
– Trend data suggesting what will be important
for future success
– Your organization’s capabilities and strengths
– Your organization’s weaknesses
– The mission and vision of the larger enterprise
Leading Physicians Through
Change (Mary Jane Kornacki & Jack Silversin)
• Compact is the expectations members of an
organization have regarding the intangible
assets and benefits they’re entitled to and
what their organization expects in return
• Compact is part of organizational life that is
taken for granted
• Rewriting a compact is an example of
adaptive change
Leading Physicians Through
Change (Mary Jane Kornacki & Jack Silversin)
• Culture works that supports strategies and actions
that result in a successful business
• Culture is differentiator between high- and low-
performing hospitals treating AMI (Annals of
Internal Medicine 154(6):384, 3/15/2011)
• Culture that contributed to past success does not
change as fast as new strategies & tactics
• Culture shaped by shared assumptions & beliefs
about the right way to do things (may not be
conscious)
Leading Physicians Through
Change (Mary Jane Kornacki & Jack Silversin)
• Traditional compact
• Physicians Give
– Patient care
– Quality care as they define it
• Physicians Get
– Autonomy
– Protection
– Entitlement
Leading Physicians Through
Change (Mary Jane Kornacki & Jack Silversin)
• New compact
• Physicians Give
– Patient-centered care
– Acknowledged interdependence
– Delegated authority to leaders
– Accountability
• Physicians Get
– Market-responsive organization able to survive
– Influence on governance
– Input on decisions affecting the practice
– Compensation linked to organization & individual
performance on outcomes, cost, and quality
Leading Physicians Through
Change (Mary Jane Kornacki & Jack Silversin)
Symptoms of Resistance
• Superficial agreement with change with no
commitment or follow-through
• Slow progress
• Apathy
• Excuses for lack of engagement or progress
Addressing Resistance
• Leaders cross bridge first by coming to
terms with own concerns
• Help physicians let go of expectations that
cannot be met
• Get out the news
• Listen to and honor resistance

Contenu connexe

Tendances

Partnering for Population Health: Strategies to Promote Collaboration Among t...
Partnering for Population Health: Strategies to Promote Collaboration Among t...Partnering for Population Health: Strategies to Promote Collaboration Among t...
Partnering for Population Health: Strategies to Promote Collaboration Among t...Conifer Health Solutions
 
Creating Data-driven Strategies to Improve Hospital Outcomes: A Case Manager'...
Creating Data-driven Strategies to Improve Hospital Outcomes: A Case Manager'...Creating Data-driven Strategies to Improve Hospital Outcomes: A Case Manager'...
Creating Data-driven Strategies to Improve Hospital Outcomes: A Case Manager'...Conifer Health Solutions
 
An ACO Case Study: Quality Improvement in Healthcare
An ACO Case Study: Quality Improvement in HealthcareAn ACO Case Study: Quality Improvement in Healthcare
An ACO Case Study: Quality Improvement in HealthcareHealth Catalyst
 
PYA Monitors Topics on Healthcare Radar at AlaHA
PYA Monitors Topics on Healthcare Radar at AlaHAPYA Monitors Topics on Healthcare Radar at AlaHA
PYA Monitors Topics on Healthcare Radar at AlaHAPYA, P.C.
 
Journey to Value: Four Questions Providers Ask
Journey to Value: Four Questions Providers AskJourney to Value: Four Questions Providers Ask
Journey to Value: Four Questions Providers AskConifer Health Solutions
 
Corus™ Suite: Next-Generation Cost Management Technology
Corus™ Suite: Next-Generation Cost Management TechnologyCorus™ Suite: Next-Generation Cost Management Technology
Corus™ Suite: Next-Generation Cost Management TechnologyHealth Catalyst
 
Use ACE Scores in Machine Learning to Predict Disease Earlier and Improve Out...
Use ACE Scores in Machine Learning to Predict Disease Earlier and Improve Out...Use ACE Scores in Machine Learning to Predict Disease Earlier and Improve Out...
Use ACE Scores in Machine Learning to Predict Disease Earlier and Improve Out...Health Catalyst
 
The Key to Transitioning from Fee-for-Service to Value-Based Reimbursements
The Key to Transitioning from Fee-for-Service to Value-Based ReimbursementsThe Key to Transitioning from Fee-for-Service to Value-Based Reimbursements
The Key to Transitioning from Fee-for-Service to Value-Based ReimbursementsHealth Catalyst
 
Emad Rizk, MD - Navigating the Complexity of New Value-Based Reimbursement Mo...
Emad Rizk, MD - Navigating the Complexity of New Value-Based Reimbursement Mo...Emad Rizk, MD - Navigating the Complexity of New Value-Based Reimbursement Mo...
Emad Rizk, MD - Navigating the Complexity of New Value-Based Reimbursement Mo...Cleveland HeartLab, Inc.
 
The Top Seven Analytics-Driven Approaches for Reducing Diagnostic Error and I...
The Top Seven Analytics-Driven Approaches for Reducing Diagnostic Error and I...The Top Seven Analytics-Driven Approaches for Reducing Diagnostic Error and I...
The Top Seven Analytics-Driven Approaches for Reducing Diagnostic Error and I...Health Catalyst
 
Physician Practice Trends 2014
Physician Practice Trends 2014Physician Practice Trends 2014
Physician Practice Trends 2014Jackson Healthcare
 
Hospital Readmissions Reduction Program: Keys to Success
Hospital Readmissions Reduction Program: Keys to SuccessHospital Readmissions Reduction Program: Keys to Success
Hospital Readmissions Reduction Program: Keys to SuccessHealth Catalyst
 
Readmission Reduction E-book
Readmission Reduction E-bookReadmission Reduction E-book
Readmission Reduction E-bookBESLER
 
Surviving Value-Based Purchasing in Healthcare
Surviving Value-Based Purchasing in HealthcareSurviving Value-Based Purchasing in Healthcare
Surviving Value-Based Purchasing in HealthcareHealth Catalyst
 
The Healthcare Outcomes Improvement Engine: The Best Way to Ensure Sustainabl...
The Healthcare Outcomes Improvement Engine: The Best Way to Ensure Sustainabl...The Healthcare Outcomes Improvement Engine: The Best Way to Ensure Sustainabl...
The Healthcare Outcomes Improvement Engine: The Best Way to Ensure Sustainabl...Health Catalyst
 
5 Ways to Mitigate ACO Risk Using Analytics
5 Ways to Mitigate ACO Risk Using Analytics5 Ways to Mitigate ACO Risk Using Analytics
5 Ways to Mitigate ACO Risk Using AnalyticsHealth Catalyst
 
The Heartaches Associated with Billing for Cardiac Devices
The Heartaches Associated with Billing for Cardiac DevicesThe Heartaches Associated with Billing for Cardiac Devices
The Heartaches Associated with Billing for Cardiac DevicesPYA, P.C.
 
Will New Healthcare Policy Impact Value-Based Healthcare?
Will New Healthcare Policy Impact Value-Based Healthcare?Will New Healthcare Policy Impact Value-Based Healthcare?
Will New Healthcare Policy Impact Value-Based Healthcare?Health Catalyst
 
Care Management - Critical Component Of Effective Population Health
Care Management - Critical Component Of Effective Population HealthCare Management - Critical Component Of Effective Population Health
Care Management - Critical Component Of Effective Population HealthHealth Catalyst
 
Hot Topics in Physician Compensation
Hot Topics in Physician CompensationHot Topics in Physician Compensation
Hot Topics in Physician CompensationPYA, P.C.
 

Tendances (20)

Partnering for Population Health: Strategies to Promote Collaboration Among t...
Partnering for Population Health: Strategies to Promote Collaboration Among t...Partnering for Population Health: Strategies to Promote Collaboration Among t...
Partnering for Population Health: Strategies to Promote Collaboration Among t...
 
Creating Data-driven Strategies to Improve Hospital Outcomes: A Case Manager'...
Creating Data-driven Strategies to Improve Hospital Outcomes: A Case Manager'...Creating Data-driven Strategies to Improve Hospital Outcomes: A Case Manager'...
Creating Data-driven Strategies to Improve Hospital Outcomes: A Case Manager'...
 
An ACO Case Study: Quality Improvement in Healthcare
An ACO Case Study: Quality Improvement in HealthcareAn ACO Case Study: Quality Improvement in Healthcare
An ACO Case Study: Quality Improvement in Healthcare
 
PYA Monitors Topics on Healthcare Radar at AlaHA
PYA Monitors Topics on Healthcare Radar at AlaHAPYA Monitors Topics on Healthcare Radar at AlaHA
PYA Monitors Topics on Healthcare Radar at AlaHA
 
Journey to Value: Four Questions Providers Ask
Journey to Value: Four Questions Providers AskJourney to Value: Four Questions Providers Ask
Journey to Value: Four Questions Providers Ask
 
Corus™ Suite: Next-Generation Cost Management Technology
Corus™ Suite: Next-Generation Cost Management TechnologyCorus™ Suite: Next-Generation Cost Management Technology
Corus™ Suite: Next-Generation Cost Management Technology
 
Use ACE Scores in Machine Learning to Predict Disease Earlier and Improve Out...
Use ACE Scores in Machine Learning to Predict Disease Earlier and Improve Out...Use ACE Scores in Machine Learning to Predict Disease Earlier and Improve Out...
Use ACE Scores in Machine Learning to Predict Disease Earlier and Improve Out...
 
The Key to Transitioning from Fee-for-Service to Value-Based Reimbursements
The Key to Transitioning from Fee-for-Service to Value-Based ReimbursementsThe Key to Transitioning from Fee-for-Service to Value-Based Reimbursements
The Key to Transitioning from Fee-for-Service to Value-Based Reimbursements
 
Emad Rizk, MD - Navigating the Complexity of New Value-Based Reimbursement Mo...
Emad Rizk, MD - Navigating the Complexity of New Value-Based Reimbursement Mo...Emad Rizk, MD - Navigating the Complexity of New Value-Based Reimbursement Mo...
Emad Rizk, MD - Navigating the Complexity of New Value-Based Reimbursement Mo...
 
The Top Seven Analytics-Driven Approaches for Reducing Diagnostic Error and I...
The Top Seven Analytics-Driven Approaches for Reducing Diagnostic Error and I...The Top Seven Analytics-Driven Approaches for Reducing Diagnostic Error and I...
The Top Seven Analytics-Driven Approaches for Reducing Diagnostic Error and I...
 
Physician Practice Trends 2014
Physician Practice Trends 2014Physician Practice Trends 2014
Physician Practice Trends 2014
 
Hospital Readmissions Reduction Program: Keys to Success
Hospital Readmissions Reduction Program: Keys to SuccessHospital Readmissions Reduction Program: Keys to Success
Hospital Readmissions Reduction Program: Keys to Success
 
Readmission Reduction E-book
Readmission Reduction E-bookReadmission Reduction E-book
Readmission Reduction E-book
 
Surviving Value-Based Purchasing in Healthcare
Surviving Value-Based Purchasing in HealthcareSurviving Value-Based Purchasing in Healthcare
Surviving Value-Based Purchasing in Healthcare
 
The Healthcare Outcomes Improvement Engine: The Best Way to Ensure Sustainabl...
The Healthcare Outcomes Improvement Engine: The Best Way to Ensure Sustainabl...The Healthcare Outcomes Improvement Engine: The Best Way to Ensure Sustainabl...
The Healthcare Outcomes Improvement Engine: The Best Way to Ensure Sustainabl...
 
5 Ways to Mitigate ACO Risk Using Analytics
5 Ways to Mitigate ACO Risk Using Analytics5 Ways to Mitigate ACO Risk Using Analytics
5 Ways to Mitigate ACO Risk Using Analytics
 
The Heartaches Associated with Billing for Cardiac Devices
The Heartaches Associated with Billing for Cardiac DevicesThe Heartaches Associated with Billing for Cardiac Devices
The Heartaches Associated with Billing for Cardiac Devices
 
Will New Healthcare Policy Impact Value-Based Healthcare?
Will New Healthcare Policy Impact Value-Based Healthcare?Will New Healthcare Policy Impact Value-Based Healthcare?
Will New Healthcare Policy Impact Value-Based Healthcare?
 
Care Management - Critical Component Of Effective Population Health
Care Management - Critical Component Of Effective Population HealthCare Management - Critical Component Of Effective Population Health
Care Management - Critical Component Of Effective Population Health
 
Hot Topics in Physician Compensation
Hot Topics in Physician CompensationHot Topics in Physician Compensation
Hot Topics in Physician Compensation
 

En vedette

Demystifying Commercial Reasonableness in Physician/Hospital Transactions
Demystifying Commercial Reasonableness in Physician/Hospital TransactionsDemystifying Commercial Reasonableness in Physician/Hospital Transactions
Demystifying Commercial Reasonableness in Physician/Hospital TransactionsPYA, P.C.
 
How Digital & Big Data Revolution Will Transform Primary Care Medicine
How Digital & Big Data Revolution Will Transform Primary Care MedicineHow Digital & Big Data Revolution Will Transform Primary Care Medicine
How Digital & Big Data Revolution Will Transform Primary Care MedicinePYA, P.C.
 
Capacitating procurement professionals through mentorship and coaching
Capacitating procurement professionals through mentorship and coachingCapacitating procurement professionals through mentorship and coaching
Capacitating procurement professionals through mentorship and coachingDerek Hendrikz
 
Remuneration Strategy by Derek Hendrikz
Remuneration Strategy by Derek HendrikzRemuneration Strategy by Derek Hendrikz
Remuneration Strategy by Derek HendrikzDerek Hendrikz
 
Hot Topics in Physician Compensation
Hot Topics in Physician CompensationHot Topics in Physician Compensation
Hot Topics in Physician CompensationPYA, P.C.
 
Big Data: Implications of Data Mining for Employed Physician Compliance Manag...
Big Data: Implications of Data Mining for Employed Physician Compliance Manag...Big Data: Implications of Data Mining for Employed Physician Compliance Manag...
Big Data: Implications of Data Mining for Employed Physician Compliance Manag...PYA, P.C.
 
Pacing Volume-to-Value Transition
Pacing Volume-to-Value TransitionPacing Volume-to-Value Transition
Pacing Volume-to-Value TransitionPYA, P.C.
 
Certification+: The Most Comprehensive Compliance Solution
Certification+: The Most Comprehensive Compliance SolutionCertification+: The Most Comprehensive Compliance Solution
Certification+: The Most Comprehensive Compliance SolutionPYA, P.C.
 
How to Have a Successful Engagement and a Happily Ever After: “New Age” Nuanc...
How to Have a Successful Engagement and a Happily Ever After: “New Age” Nuanc...How to Have a Successful Engagement and a Happily Ever After: “New Age” Nuanc...
How to Have a Successful Engagement and a Happily Ever After: “New Age” Nuanc...PYA, P.C.
 
Modern Physician-Hospital Affiliations in an Era of Increased Fraud and Abuse...
Modern Physician-Hospital Affiliations in an Era of Increased Fraud and Abuse...Modern Physician-Hospital Affiliations in an Era of Increased Fraud and Abuse...
Modern Physician-Hospital Affiliations in an Era of Increased Fraud and Abuse...PYA, P.C.
 
Big Data: Implications of Data Mining for Employed Physician Compliance Manag...
Big Data: Implications of Data Mining for Employed Physician Compliance Manag...Big Data: Implications of Data Mining for Employed Physician Compliance Manag...
Big Data: Implications of Data Mining for Employed Physician Compliance Manag...PYA, P.C.
 
Medicare ACO Roadmap Infographic
Medicare ACO Roadmap InfographicMedicare ACO Roadmap Infographic
Medicare ACO Roadmap InfographicPYA, P.C.
 
Analyzing Transactions--Doing the Deal
Analyzing Transactions--Doing the DealAnalyzing Transactions--Doing the Deal
Analyzing Transactions--Doing the DealPYA, P.C.
 
MACRA and the Merit-Based Incentive Payment System (MIPS)
MACRA and the Merit-Based Incentive Payment System (MIPS)MACRA and the Merit-Based Incentive Payment System (MIPS)
MACRA and the Merit-Based Incentive Payment System (MIPS)PYA, P.C.
 
The March to MIPS
The March to MIPSThe March to MIPS
The March to MIPSPYA, P.C.
 
What's CMS Up To These Days
What's CMS Up To These DaysWhat's CMS Up To These Days
What's CMS Up To These DaysPYA, P.C.
 
Exploring Methodologies and Discount Rates in Valuing Intangible Assets
Exploring Methodologies and Discount Rates in Valuing Intangible AssetsExploring Methodologies and Discount Rates in Valuing Intangible Assets
Exploring Methodologies and Discount Rates in Valuing Intangible AssetsPYA, P.C.
 
Compliance Is One of the Best Ways to Market Your Business
Compliance Is One of the Best Ways to Market Your BusinessCompliance Is One of the Best Ways to Market Your Business
Compliance Is One of the Best Ways to Market Your BusinessPYA, P.C.
 
Presentation Makes the Case for Enterprise Risk Management
Presentation Makes the Case for Enterprise Risk ManagementPresentation Makes the Case for Enterprise Risk Management
Presentation Makes the Case for Enterprise Risk ManagementPYA, P.C.
 
Transitioning Within a New Market
Transitioning Within a New MarketTransitioning Within a New Market
Transitioning Within a New MarketPYA, P.C.
 

En vedette (20)

Demystifying Commercial Reasonableness in Physician/Hospital Transactions
Demystifying Commercial Reasonableness in Physician/Hospital TransactionsDemystifying Commercial Reasonableness in Physician/Hospital Transactions
Demystifying Commercial Reasonableness in Physician/Hospital Transactions
 
How Digital & Big Data Revolution Will Transform Primary Care Medicine
How Digital & Big Data Revolution Will Transform Primary Care MedicineHow Digital & Big Data Revolution Will Transform Primary Care Medicine
How Digital & Big Data Revolution Will Transform Primary Care Medicine
 
Capacitating procurement professionals through mentorship and coaching
Capacitating procurement professionals through mentorship and coachingCapacitating procurement professionals through mentorship and coaching
Capacitating procurement professionals through mentorship and coaching
 
Remuneration Strategy by Derek Hendrikz
Remuneration Strategy by Derek HendrikzRemuneration Strategy by Derek Hendrikz
Remuneration Strategy by Derek Hendrikz
 
Hot Topics in Physician Compensation
Hot Topics in Physician CompensationHot Topics in Physician Compensation
Hot Topics in Physician Compensation
 
Big Data: Implications of Data Mining for Employed Physician Compliance Manag...
Big Data: Implications of Data Mining for Employed Physician Compliance Manag...Big Data: Implications of Data Mining for Employed Physician Compliance Manag...
Big Data: Implications of Data Mining for Employed Physician Compliance Manag...
 
Pacing Volume-to-Value Transition
Pacing Volume-to-Value TransitionPacing Volume-to-Value Transition
Pacing Volume-to-Value Transition
 
Certification+: The Most Comprehensive Compliance Solution
Certification+: The Most Comprehensive Compliance SolutionCertification+: The Most Comprehensive Compliance Solution
Certification+: The Most Comprehensive Compliance Solution
 
How to Have a Successful Engagement and a Happily Ever After: “New Age” Nuanc...
How to Have a Successful Engagement and a Happily Ever After: “New Age” Nuanc...How to Have a Successful Engagement and a Happily Ever After: “New Age” Nuanc...
How to Have a Successful Engagement and a Happily Ever After: “New Age” Nuanc...
 
Modern Physician-Hospital Affiliations in an Era of Increased Fraud and Abuse...
Modern Physician-Hospital Affiliations in an Era of Increased Fraud and Abuse...Modern Physician-Hospital Affiliations in an Era of Increased Fraud and Abuse...
Modern Physician-Hospital Affiliations in an Era of Increased Fraud and Abuse...
 
Big Data: Implications of Data Mining for Employed Physician Compliance Manag...
Big Data: Implications of Data Mining for Employed Physician Compliance Manag...Big Data: Implications of Data Mining for Employed Physician Compliance Manag...
Big Data: Implications of Data Mining for Employed Physician Compliance Manag...
 
Medicare ACO Roadmap Infographic
Medicare ACO Roadmap InfographicMedicare ACO Roadmap Infographic
Medicare ACO Roadmap Infographic
 
Analyzing Transactions--Doing the Deal
Analyzing Transactions--Doing the DealAnalyzing Transactions--Doing the Deal
Analyzing Transactions--Doing the Deal
 
MACRA and the Merit-Based Incentive Payment System (MIPS)
MACRA and the Merit-Based Incentive Payment System (MIPS)MACRA and the Merit-Based Incentive Payment System (MIPS)
MACRA and the Merit-Based Incentive Payment System (MIPS)
 
The March to MIPS
The March to MIPSThe March to MIPS
The March to MIPS
 
What's CMS Up To These Days
What's CMS Up To These DaysWhat's CMS Up To These Days
What's CMS Up To These Days
 
Exploring Methodologies and Discount Rates in Valuing Intangible Assets
Exploring Methodologies and Discount Rates in Valuing Intangible AssetsExploring Methodologies and Discount Rates in Valuing Intangible Assets
Exploring Methodologies and Discount Rates in Valuing Intangible Assets
 
Compliance Is One of the Best Ways to Market Your Business
Compliance Is One of the Best Ways to Market Your BusinessCompliance Is One of the Best Ways to Market Your Business
Compliance Is One of the Best Ways to Market Your Business
 
Presentation Makes the Case for Enterprise Risk Management
Presentation Makes the Case for Enterprise Risk ManagementPresentation Makes the Case for Enterprise Risk Management
Presentation Makes the Case for Enterprise Risk Management
 
Transitioning Within a New Market
Transitioning Within a New MarketTransitioning Within a New Market
Transitioning Within a New Market
 

Similaire à How to Engage Physicians in Best Practices to Respond to Healthcare Transformation

Onc july atlanta 2011
Onc  july atlanta 2011 Onc  july atlanta 2011
Onc july atlanta 2011 Paul Grundy
 
Pharmacy's Emerging Role in Accountable Care Organizations (ACO)
Pharmacy's Emerging Role in Accountable Care Organizations (ACO)Pharmacy's Emerging Role in Accountable Care Organizations (ACO)
Pharmacy's Emerging Role in Accountable Care Organizations (ACO)Parata Systems
 
Patient Centered Medical home talk at WVU
Patient Centered Medical home talk at WVUPatient Centered Medical home talk at WVU
Patient Centered Medical home talk at WVUPaul Grundy
 
Sponsored Webinar: Bringing Price Transparency to Healthcare
Sponsored Webinar: Bringing Price Transparency to HealthcareSponsored Webinar: Bringing Price Transparency to Healthcare
Sponsored Webinar: Bringing Price Transparency to HealthcareModern Healthcare
 
Todd Berner: Assessment of Payer ACOs: Industry's Role
Todd Berner: Assessment of Payer ACOs: Industry's RoleTodd Berner: Assessment of Payer ACOs: Industry's Role
Todd Berner: Assessment of Payer ACOs: Industry's RoleTodd Berner MD
 
The changing landscape of health care in the US -- drivers and outcomes
The changing landscape of health care in the US -- drivers and outcomesThe changing landscape of health care in the US -- drivers and outcomes
The changing landscape of health care in the US -- drivers and outcomesGregory Travis
 
Case Study "Using Real Time Clinical Data To Support Patient Risk Stratificat...
Case Study "Using Real Time Clinical Data To Support Patient Risk Stratificat...Case Study "Using Real Time Clinical Data To Support Patient Risk Stratificat...
Case Study "Using Real Time Clinical Data To Support Patient Risk Stratificat...Health IT Conference – iHT2
 
Methods for Fostering the Widespread Implementation of Shared Decision Making
Methods for Fostering the Widespread Implementation of Shared Decision MakingMethods for Fostering the Widespread Implementation of Shared Decision Making
Methods for Fostering the Widespread Implementation of Shared Decision MakingInformed Medical Decisions Foundation
 
National Conference on Health and Domestic Violence. Plenary talk
 National Conference on Health and Domestic Violence. Plenary talk  National Conference on Health and Domestic Violence. Plenary talk
National Conference on Health and Domestic Violence. Plenary talk Paul Grundy
 
Federal healthcare slides
Federal healthcare slidesFederal healthcare slides
Federal healthcare slidesLayton Lang
 
Utah hospital aug 2014
Utah hospital aug 2014Utah hospital aug 2014
Utah hospital aug 2014Paul Grundy
 
Patient Centered Medical Home
Patient Centered Medical HomePatient Centered Medical Home
Patient Centered Medical HomeRyan Squire
 
Paul Grundy, Better Care, Reducing Costs, Improving Service Patient Centered ...
Paul Grundy, Better Care, Reducing Costs, Improving Service Patient Centered ...Paul Grundy, Better Care, Reducing Costs, Improving Service Patient Centered ...
Paul Grundy, Better Care, Reducing Costs, Improving Service Patient Centered ...Cleveland HeartLab, Inc.
 
Oslo paul grundy nov 2014
Oslo paul grundy nov 2014Oslo paul grundy nov 2014
Oslo paul grundy nov 2014Paul Grundy
 
The Future of the American Healthcare Delivery System in an Era of Change
The Future of the American Healthcare Delivery System in an Era of ChangeThe Future of the American Healthcare Delivery System in an Era of Change
The Future of the American Healthcare Delivery System in an Era of ChangePYA, P.C.
 
Predictive Risk Stratification: Using Analytics to Empower Change with Action...
Predictive Risk Stratification: Using Analytics to Empower Change with Action...Predictive Risk Stratification: Using Analytics to Empower Change with Action...
Predictive Risk Stratification: Using Analytics to Empower Change with Action...Health Catalyst
 
2C Grundy Extracting Value: Patient Centered Medical Home EHiN 2014
2C Grundy Extracting Value: Patient Centered Medical Home EHiN 2014 2C Grundy Extracting Value: Patient Centered Medical Home EHiN 2014
2C Grundy Extracting Value: Patient Centered Medical Home EHiN 2014 IKT-Norge
 

Similaire à How to Engage Physicians in Best Practices to Respond to Healthcare Transformation (20)

Onc july atlanta 2011
Onc  july atlanta 2011 Onc  july atlanta 2011
Onc july atlanta 2011
 
Pharmacy's Emerging Role in Accountable Care Organizations (ACO)
Pharmacy's Emerging Role in Accountable Care Organizations (ACO)Pharmacy's Emerging Role in Accountable Care Organizations (ACO)
Pharmacy's Emerging Role in Accountable Care Organizations (ACO)
 
Homeless Navigator Feb. Issue
Homeless Navigator Feb. IssueHomeless Navigator Feb. Issue
Homeless Navigator Feb. Issue
 
Patient Centered Medical home talk at WVU
Patient Centered Medical home talk at WVUPatient Centered Medical home talk at WVU
Patient Centered Medical home talk at WVU
 
Sponsored Webinar: Bringing Price Transparency to Healthcare
Sponsored Webinar: Bringing Price Transparency to HealthcareSponsored Webinar: Bringing Price Transparency to Healthcare
Sponsored Webinar: Bringing Price Transparency to Healthcare
 
Todd Berner: Assessment of Payer ACOs: Industry's Role
Todd Berner: Assessment of Payer ACOs: Industry's RoleTodd Berner: Assessment of Payer ACOs: Industry's Role
Todd Berner: Assessment of Payer ACOs: Industry's Role
 
The changing landscape of health care in the US -- drivers and outcomes
The changing landscape of health care in the US -- drivers and outcomesThe changing landscape of health care in the US -- drivers and outcomes
The changing landscape of health care in the US -- drivers and outcomes
 
Case Study "Using Real Time Clinical Data To Support Patient Risk Stratificat...
Case Study "Using Real Time Clinical Data To Support Patient Risk Stratificat...Case Study "Using Real Time Clinical Data To Support Patient Risk Stratificat...
Case Study "Using Real Time Clinical Data To Support Patient Risk Stratificat...
 
Methods for Fostering the Widespread Implementation of Shared Decision Making
Methods for Fostering the Widespread Implementation of Shared Decision MakingMethods for Fostering the Widespread Implementation of Shared Decision Making
Methods for Fostering the Widespread Implementation of Shared Decision Making
 
National Conference on Health and Domestic Violence. Plenary talk
 National Conference on Health and Domestic Violence. Plenary talk  National Conference on Health and Domestic Violence. Plenary talk
National Conference on Health and Domestic Violence. Plenary talk
 
Federal healthcare slides
Federal healthcare slidesFederal healthcare slides
Federal healthcare slides
 
Utah hospital aug 2014
Utah hospital aug 2014Utah hospital aug 2014
Utah hospital aug 2014
 
Patient Centered Medical Home
Patient Centered Medical HomePatient Centered Medical Home
Patient Centered Medical Home
 
Paul Grundy, Better Care, Reducing Costs, Improving Service Patient Centered ...
Paul Grundy, Better Care, Reducing Costs, Improving Service Patient Centered ...Paul Grundy, Better Care, Reducing Costs, Improving Service Patient Centered ...
Paul Grundy, Better Care, Reducing Costs, Improving Service Patient Centered ...
 
Oslo paul grundy nov 2014
Oslo paul grundy nov 2014Oslo paul grundy nov 2014
Oslo paul grundy nov 2014
 
The Future of the American Healthcare Delivery System in an Era of Change
The Future of the American Healthcare Delivery System in an Era of ChangeThe Future of the American Healthcare Delivery System in an Era of Change
The Future of the American Healthcare Delivery System in an Era of Change
 
Predictive Risk Stratification: Using Analytics to Empower Change with Action...
Predictive Risk Stratification: Using Analytics to Empower Change with Action...Predictive Risk Stratification: Using Analytics to Empower Change with Action...
Predictive Risk Stratification: Using Analytics to Empower Change with Action...
 
How the CCP Model Could Ensure Better Patient Care & Reduced Costs
How the CCP Model Could Ensure Better Patient Care & Reduced CostsHow the CCP Model Could Ensure Better Patient Care & Reduced Costs
How the CCP Model Could Ensure Better Patient Care & Reduced Costs
 
Rosen slides
Rosen slidesRosen slides
Rosen slides
 
2C Grundy Extracting Value: Patient Centered Medical Home EHiN 2014
2C Grundy Extracting Value: Patient Centered Medical Home EHiN 2014 2C Grundy Extracting Value: Patient Centered Medical Home EHiN 2014
2C Grundy Extracting Value: Patient Centered Medical Home EHiN 2014
 

Plus de PYA, P.C.

“CARES Act Provider Relief Fund: Opportunities, Compliance, and Reporting”
“CARES Act Provider Relief Fund: Opportunities, Compliance, and Reporting”“CARES Act Provider Relief Fund: Opportunities, Compliance, and Reporting”
“CARES Act Provider Relief Fund: Opportunities, Compliance, and Reporting”PYA, P.C.
 
PYA Presented on 2021 E/M Changes and a CARES Act Update During GHA Complianc...
PYA Presented on 2021 E/M Changes and a CARES Act Update During GHA Complianc...PYA Presented on 2021 E/M Changes and a CARES Act Update During GHA Complianc...
PYA Presented on 2021 E/M Changes and a CARES Act Update During GHA Complianc...PYA, P.C.
 
Webinar: “Trick or Treat? October 22nd Revisions to Provider Relief Fund Repo...
Webinar: “Trick or Treat? October 22nd Revisions to Provider Relief Fund Repo...Webinar: “Trick or Treat? October 22nd Revisions to Provider Relief Fund Repo...
Webinar: “Trick or Treat? October 22nd Revisions to Provider Relief Fund Repo...PYA, P.C.
 
“Regulatory Compliance Enforcement Update: Getting Results from the Guidance”
“Regulatory Compliance Enforcement Update: Getting Results from the Guidance” “Regulatory Compliance Enforcement Update: Getting Results from the Guidance”
“Regulatory Compliance Enforcement Update: Getting Results from the Guidance” PYA, P.C.
 
“Federal Legislative and Regulatory Update,” Webinar at DFWHC
 “Federal Legislative and Regulatory Update,” Webinar at DFWHC “Federal Legislative and Regulatory Update,” Webinar at DFWHC
“Federal Legislative and Regulatory Update,” Webinar at DFWHCPYA, P.C.
 
On-Demand Webinar: Compliance With New Provider Relief Funds Reporting Requir...
On-Demand Webinar: Compliance With New Provider Relief Funds Reporting Requir...On-Demand Webinar: Compliance With New Provider Relief Funds Reporting Requir...
On-Demand Webinar: Compliance With New Provider Relief Funds Reporting Requir...PYA, P.C.
 
Webinar: “While You Were Sleeping…Proposed Rule Positioned to Significantly I...
Webinar: “While You Were Sleeping…Proposed Rule Positioned to Significantly I...Webinar: “While You Were Sleeping…Proposed Rule Positioned to Significantly I...
Webinar: “While You Were Sleeping…Proposed Rule Positioned to Significantly I...PYA, P.C.
 
Webinar: “Cybersecurity During COVID-19: A Look Behind the Scenes
Webinar: “Cybersecurity During COVID-19: A Look Behind the ScenesWebinar: “Cybersecurity During COVID-19: A Look Behind the Scenes
Webinar: “Cybersecurity During COVID-19: A Look Behind the ScenesPYA, P.C.
 
Webinar: CMS Pricing Transparency — Final Rule Requirements, Compliance Chall...
Webinar: CMS Pricing Transparency — Final Rule Requirements, Compliance Chall...Webinar: CMS Pricing Transparency — Final Rule Requirements, Compliance Chall...
Webinar: CMS Pricing Transparency — Final Rule Requirements, Compliance Chall...PYA, P.C.
 
Federal Regulatory Update
Federal Regulatory UpdateFederal Regulatory Update
Federal Regulatory UpdatePYA, P.C.
 
Webinar: Post-Pandemic Provider Realignment — Navigating An Uncertain Market
Webinar: Post-Pandemic Provider Realignment — Navigating An Uncertain MarketWebinar: Post-Pandemic Provider Realignment — Navigating An Uncertain Market
Webinar: Post-Pandemic Provider Realignment — Navigating An Uncertain MarketPYA, P.C.
 
07 24-20 pya webinar covid physician compensation
07 24-20 pya webinar covid physician compensation07 24-20 pya webinar covid physician compensation
07 24-20 pya webinar covid physician compensationPYA, P.C.
 
Engaging Your Board In the COVID-19 Era
Engaging Your Board In the COVID-19 EraEngaging Your Board In the COVID-19 Era
Engaging Your Board In the COVID-19 EraPYA, P.C.
 
Webinar: Free Money with Strings Attached – Cares Act Considerations for Fron...
Webinar: Free Money with Strings Attached – Cares Act Considerations for Fron...Webinar: Free Money with Strings Attached – Cares Act Considerations for Fron...
Webinar: Free Money with Strings Attached – Cares Act Considerations for Fron...PYA, P.C.
 
Webinar: “Got a Payroll? Don’t Leave Money on the Table”
Webinar: “Got a Payroll? Don’t Leave Money on the Table”Webinar: “Got a Payroll? Don’t Leave Money on the Table”
Webinar: “Got a Payroll? Don’t Leave Money on the Table”PYA, P.C.
 
Webinar: So You Have a PPP Loan. Now What?
Webinar: So You Have a PPP Loan. Now What?Webinar: So You Have a PPP Loan. Now What?
Webinar: So You Have a PPP Loan. Now What?PYA, P.C.
 
Webinar: “Making It Work—Physician Compensation During the COVID-19 Pandemic”
Webinar: “Making It Work—Physician Compensation During the COVID-19 Pandemic”Webinar: “Making It Work—Physician Compensation During the COVID-19 Pandemic”
Webinar: “Making It Work—Physician Compensation During the COVID-19 Pandemic”PYA, P.C.
 
Webinar: “Provider Relief Fund Payments – What We Know, What We Don’t Know, W...
Webinar: “Provider Relief Fund Payments – What We Know, What We Don’t Know, W...Webinar: “Provider Relief Fund Payments – What We Know, What We Don’t Know, W...
Webinar: “Provider Relief Fund Payments – What We Know, What We Don’t Know, W...PYA, P.C.
 
Webinar: “Hospitals, Capital, and Cashflow Under COVID-19”
Webinar: “Hospitals, Capital, and Cashflow Under COVID-19”Webinar: “Hospitals, Capital, and Cashflow Under COVID-19”
Webinar: “Hospitals, Capital, and Cashflow Under COVID-19”PYA, P.C.
 
PYA Webinar: “Additional Expansion of Medicare Telehealth Coverage During COV...
PYA Webinar: “Additional Expansion of Medicare Telehealth Coverage During COV...PYA Webinar: “Additional Expansion of Medicare Telehealth Coverage During COV...
PYA Webinar: “Additional Expansion of Medicare Telehealth Coverage During COV...PYA, P.C.
 

Plus de PYA, P.C. (20)

“CARES Act Provider Relief Fund: Opportunities, Compliance, and Reporting”
“CARES Act Provider Relief Fund: Opportunities, Compliance, and Reporting”“CARES Act Provider Relief Fund: Opportunities, Compliance, and Reporting”
“CARES Act Provider Relief Fund: Opportunities, Compliance, and Reporting”
 
PYA Presented on 2021 E/M Changes and a CARES Act Update During GHA Complianc...
PYA Presented on 2021 E/M Changes and a CARES Act Update During GHA Complianc...PYA Presented on 2021 E/M Changes and a CARES Act Update During GHA Complianc...
PYA Presented on 2021 E/M Changes and a CARES Act Update During GHA Complianc...
 
Webinar: “Trick or Treat? October 22nd Revisions to Provider Relief Fund Repo...
Webinar: “Trick or Treat? October 22nd Revisions to Provider Relief Fund Repo...Webinar: “Trick or Treat? October 22nd Revisions to Provider Relief Fund Repo...
Webinar: “Trick or Treat? October 22nd Revisions to Provider Relief Fund Repo...
 
“Regulatory Compliance Enforcement Update: Getting Results from the Guidance”
“Regulatory Compliance Enforcement Update: Getting Results from the Guidance” “Regulatory Compliance Enforcement Update: Getting Results from the Guidance”
“Regulatory Compliance Enforcement Update: Getting Results from the Guidance”
 
“Federal Legislative and Regulatory Update,” Webinar at DFWHC
 “Federal Legislative and Regulatory Update,” Webinar at DFWHC “Federal Legislative and Regulatory Update,” Webinar at DFWHC
“Federal Legislative and Regulatory Update,” Webinar at DFWHC
 
On-Demand Webinar: Compliance With New Provider Relief Funds Reporting Requir...
On-Demand Webinar: Compliance With New Provider Relief Funds Reporting Requir...On-Demand Webinar: Compliance With New Provider Relief Funds Reporting Requir...
On-Demand Webinar: Compliance With New Provider Relief Funds Reporting Requir...
 
Webinar: “While You Were Sleeping…Proposed Rule Positioned to Significantly I...
Webinar: “While You Were Sleeping…Proposed Rule Positioned to Significantly I...Webinar: “While You Were Sleeping…Proposed Rule Positioned to Significantly I...
Webinar: “While You Were Sleeping…Proposed Rule Positioned to Significantly I...
 
Webinar: “Cybersecurity During COVID-19: A Look Behind the Scenes
Webinar: “Cybersecurity During COVID-19: A Look Behind the ScenesWebinar: “Cybersecurity During COVID-19: A Look Behind the Scenes
Webinar: “Cybersecurity During COVID-19: A Look Behind the Scenes
 
Webinar: CMS Pricing Transparency — Final Rule Requirements, Compliance Chall...
Webinar: CMS Pricing Transparency — Final Rule Requirements, Compliance Chall...Webinar: CMS Pricing Transparency — Final Rule Requirements, Compliance Chall...
Webinar: CMS Pricing Transparency — Final Rule Requirements, Compliance Chall...
 
Federal Regulatory Update
Federal Regulatory UpdateFederal Regulatory Update
Federal Regulatory Update
 
Webinar: Post-Pandemic Provider Realignment — Navigating An Uncertain Market
Webinar: Post-Pandemic Provider Realignment — Navigating An Uncertain MarketWebinar: Post-Pandemic Provider Realignment — Navigating An Uncertain Market
Webinar: Post-Pandemic Provider Realignment — Navigating An Uncertain Market
 
07 24-20 pya webinar covid physician compensation
07 24-20 pya webinar covid physician compensation07 24-20 pya webinar covid physician compensation
07 24-20 pya webinar covid physician compensation
 
Engaging Your Board In the COVID-19 Era
Engaging Your Board In the COVID-19 EraEngaging Your Board In the COVID-19 Era
Engaging Your Board In the COVID-19 Era
 
Webinar: Free Money with Strings Attached – Cares Act Considerations for Fron...
Webinar: Free Money with Strings Attached – Cares Act Considerations for Fron...Webinar: Free Money with Strings Attached – Cares Act Considerations for Fron...
Webinar: Free Money with Strings Attached – Cares Act Considerations for Fron...
 
Webinar: “Got a Payroll? Don’t Leave Money on the Table”
Webinar: “Got a Payroll? Don’t Leave Money on the Table”Webinar: “Got a Payroll? Don’t Leave Money on the Table”
Webinar: “Got a Payroll? Don’t Leave Money on the Table”
 
Webinar: So You Have a PPP Loan. Now What?
Webinar: So You Have a PPP Loan. Now What?Webinar: So You Have a PPP Loan. Now What?
Webinar: So You Have a PPP Loan. Now What?
 
Webinar: “Making It Work—Physician Compensation During the COVID-19 Pandemic”
Webinar: “Making It Work—Physician Compensation During the COVID-19 Pandemic”Webinar: “Making It Work—Physician Compensation During the COVID-19 Pandemic”
Webinar: “Making It Work—Physician Compensation During the COVID-19 Pandemic”
 
Webinar: “Provider Relief Fund Payments – What We Know, What We Don’t Know, W...
Webinar: “Provider Relief Fund Payments – What We Know, What We Don’t Know, W...Webinar: “Provider Relief Fund Payments – What We Know, What We Don’t Know, W...
Webinar: “Provider Relief Fund Payments – What We Know, What We Don’t Know, W...
 
Webinar: “Hospitals, Capital, and Cashflow Under COVID-19”
Webinar: “Hospitals, Capital, and Cashflow Under COVID-19”Webinar: “Hospitals, Capital, and Cashflow Under COVID-19”
Webinar: “Hospitals, Capital, and Cashflow Under COVID-19”
 
PYA Webinar: “Additional Expansion of Medicare Telehealth Coverage During COV...
PYA Webinar: “Additional Expansion of Medicare Telehealth Coverage During COV...PYA Webinar: “Additional Expansion of Medicare Telehealth Coverage During COV...
PYA Webinar: “Additional Expansion of Medicare Telehealth Coverage During COV...
 

Dernier

Gorgeous Call Girls Mohali {7435815124} ❤️VVIP ANGEL Call Girls in Mohali Punjab
Gorgeous Call Girls Mohali {7435815124} ❤️VVIP ANGEL Call Girls in Mohali PunjabGorgeous Call Girls Mohali {7435815124} ❤️VVIP ANGEL Call Girls in Mohali Punjab
Gorgeous Call Girls Mohali {7435815124} ❤️VVIP ANGEL Call Girls in Mohali PunjabSheetaleventcompany
 
Hubli Call Girls 👙 6297143586 👙 Genuine WhatsApp Number for Real Meet
Hubli Call Girls 👙 6297143586 👙 Genuine WhatsApp Number for Real MeetHubli Call Girls 👙 6297143586 👙 Genuine WhatsApp Number for Real Meet
Hubli Call Girls 👙 6297143586 👙 Genuine WhatsApp Number for Real MeetCall Girls Service
 
surat Call Girls 👙 6297143586 👙 Genuine WhatsApp Number for Real Meet
surat Call Girls 👙 6297143586 👙 Genuine WhatsApp Number for Real Meetsurat Call Girls 👙 6297143586 👙 Genuine WhatsApp Number for Real Meet
surat Call Girls 👙 6297143586 👙 Genuine WhatsApp Number for Real MeetCall Girls Chandigarh
 
Sangli Call Girls 👙 6297143586 👙 Genuine WhatsApp Number for Real Meet
Sangli Call Girls 👙 6297143586 👙 Genuine WhatsApp Number for Real MeetSangli Call Girls 👙 6297143586 👙 Genuine WhatsApp Number for Real Meet
Sangli Call Girls 👙 6297143586 👙 Genuine WhatsApp Number for Real MeetCall Girls Service
 
Thoothukudi Call Girls 👙 6297143586 👙 Genuine WhatsApp Number for Real Meet
Thoothukudi Call Girls 👙 6297143586 👙 Genuine WhatsApp Number for Real MeetThoothukudi Call Girls 👙 6297143586 👙 Genuine WhatsApp Number for Real Meet
Thoothukudi Call Girls 👙 6297143586 👙 Genuine WhatsApp Number for Real MeetCall Girls Service
 
Ernakulam Call Girls 👙 6297143586 👙 Genuine WhatsApp Number for Real Meet
Ernakulam Call Girls 👙 6297143586 👙 Genuine WhatsApp Number for Real MeetErnakulam Call Girls 👙 6297143586 👙 Genuine WhatsApp Number for Real Meet
Ernakulam Call Girls 👙 6297143586 👙 Genuine WhatsApp Number for Real MeetCall Girls Chandigarh
 
💚 Punjabi Call Girls In Chandigarh 💯Lucky 🔝8868886958🔝Call Girl In Chandigarh
💚 Punjabi Call Girls In Chandigarh 💯Lucky 🔝8868886958🔝Call Girl In Chandigarh💚 Punjabi Call Girls In Chandigarh 💯Lucky 🔝8868886958🔝Call Girl In Chandigarh
💚 Punjabi Call Girls In Chandigarh 💯Lucky 🔝8868886958🔝Call Girl In ChandigarhSheetaleventcompany
 
bhubaneswar Call Girls 👙 6297143586 👙 Genuine WhatsApp Number for Real Meet
bhubaneswar Call Girls 👙 6297143586 👙 Genuine WhatsApp Number for Real Meetbhubaneswar Call Girls 👙 6297143586 👙 Genuine WhatsApp Number for Real Meet
bhubaneswar Call Girls 👙 6297143586 👙 Genuine WhatsApp Number for Real MeetCall Girls Service
 
Rajkot Call Girls 👙 6297143586 👙 Genuine WhatsApp Number for Real Meet
Rajkot Call Girls 👙 6297143586 👙 Genuine WhatsApp Number for Real MeetRajkot Call Girls 👙 6297143586 👙 Genuine WhatsApp Number for Real Meet
Rajkot Call Girls 👙 6297143586 👙 Genuine WhatsApp Number for Real MeetCall Girls Service
 
Call Girls Service Mohali {7435815124} ❤️VVIP PALAK Call Girl in Mohali Punjab
Call Girls Service Mohali {7435815124} ❤️VVIP PALAK Call Girl in Mohali PunjabCall Girls Service Mohali {7435815124} ❤️VVIP PALAK Call Girl in Mohali Punjab
Call Girls Service Mohali {7435815124} ❤️VVIP PALAK Call Girl in Mohali PunjabSheetaleventcompany
 
Top 20 Famous Indian Female Pornstars Name List 2024
Top 20 Famous Indian Female Pornstars Name List 2024Top 20 Famous Indian Female Pornstars Name List 2024
Top 20 Famous Indian Female Pornstars Name List 2024Sheetaleventcompany
 
palanpur Call Girls 👙 6297143586 👙 Genuine WhatsApp Number for Real Meet
palanpur Call Girls 👙 6297143586 👙 Genuine WhatsApp Number for Real Meetpalanpur Call Girls 👙 6297143586 👙 Genuine WhatsApp Number for Real Meet
palanpur Call Girls 👙 6297143586 👙 Genuine WhatsApp Number for Real MeetCall Girls Service
 
nagpur Call Girls 👙 6297143586 👙 Genuine WhatsApp Number for Real Meet
nagpur Call Girls 👙 6297143586 👙 Genuine WhatsApp Number for Real Meetnagpur Call Girls 👙 6297143586 👙 Genuine WhatsApp Number for Real Meet
nagpur Call Girls 👙 6297143586 👙 Genuine WhatsApp Number for Real MeetCall Girls Service
 
(Deeksha) 💓 9920725232 💓High Profile Call Girls Navi Mumbai You Can Get The S...
(Deeksha) 💓 9920725232 💓High Profile Call Girls Navi Mumbai You Can Get The S...(Deeksha) 💓 9920725232 💓High Profile Call Girls Navi Mumbai You Can Get The S...
(Deeksha) 💓 9920725232 💓High Profile Call Girls Navi Mumbai You Can Get The S...Ahmedabad Call Girls
 
Best Lahore Escorts 😮‍💨03250114445 || VIP escorts in Lahore
Best Lahore Escorts 😮‍💨03250114445 || VIP escorts in LahoreBest Lahore Escorts 😮‍💨03250114445 || VIP escorts in Lahore
Best Lahore Escorts 😮‍💨03250114445 || VIP escorts in LahoreDeny Daniel
 
Bihar Sharif Call Girls 👙 6297143586 👙 Genuine WhatsApp Number for Real Meet
Bihar Sharif Call Girls 👙 6297143586 👙 Genuine WhatsApp Number for Real MeetBihar Sharif Call Girls 👙 6297143586 👙 Genuine WhatsApp Number for Real Meet
Bihar Sharif Call Girls 👙 6297143586 👙 Genuine WhatsApp Number for Real MeetCall Girls Service
 
Independent Call Girls Hyderabad 💋 9352988975 💋 Genuine WhatsApp Number for R...
Independent Call Girls Hyderabad 💋 9352988975 💋 Genuine WhatsApp Number for R...Independent Call Girls Hyderabad 💋 9352988975 💋 Genuine WhatsApp Number for R...
Independent Call Girls Hyderabad 💋 9352988975 💋 Genuine WhatsApp Number for R...Ahmedabad Call Girls
 
Jaipur Call Girls 9257276172 Call Girl in Jaipur Rajasthan
Jaipur Call Girls 9257276172 Call Girl in Jaipur RajasthanJaipur Call Girls 9257276172 Call Girl in Jaipur Rajasthan
Jaipur Call Girls 9257276172 Call Girl in Jaipur Rajasthanindiancallgirl4rent
 
Sexy Call Girl Dharmapuri Arshi 💚9058824046💚 Dharmapuri Escort Service
Sexy Call Girl Dharmapuri Arshi 💚9058824046💚 Dharmapuri Escort ServiceSexy Call Girl Dharmapuri Arshi 💚9058824046💚 Dharmapuri Escort Service
Sexy Call Girl Dharmapuri Arshi 💚9058824046💚 Dharmapuri Escort Servicejaanseema653
 

Dernier (20)

Gorgeous Call Girls Mohali {7435815124} ❤️VVIP ANGEL Call Girls in Mohali Punjab
Gorgeous Call Girls Mohali {7435815124} ❤️VVIP ANGEL Call Girls in Mohali PunjabGorgeous Call Girls Mohali {7435815124} ❤️VVIP ANGEL Call Girls in Mohali Punjab
Gorgeous Call Girls Mohali {7435815124} ❤️VVIP ANGEL Call Girls in Mohali Punjab
 
Punjab Call Girls Contact Number +919053,900,678 Punjab Call Girls
Punjab Call Girls Contact Number +919053,900,678 Punjab Call GirlsPunjab Call Girls Contact Number +919053,900,678 Punjab Call Girls
Punjab Call Girls Contact Number +919053,900,678 Punjab Call Girls
 
Hubli Call Girls 👙 6297143586 👙 Genuine WhatsApp Number for Real Meet
Hubli Call Girls 👙 6297143586 👙 Genuine WhatsApp Number for Real MeetHubli Call Girls 👙 6297143586 👙 Genuine WhatsApp Number for Real Meet
Hubli Call Girls 👙 6297143586 👙 Genuine WhatsApp Number for Real Meet
 
surat Call Girls 👙 6297143586 👙 Genuine WhatsApp Number for Real Meet
surat Call Girls 👙 6297143586 👙 Genuine WhatsApp Number for Real Meetsurat Call Girls 👙 6297143586 👙 Genuine WhatsApp Number for Real Meet
surat Call Girls 👙 6297143586 👙 Genuine WhatsApp Number for Real Meet
 
Sangli Call Girls 👙 6297143586 👙 Genuine WhatsApp Number for Real Meet
Sangli Call Girls 👙 6297143586 👙 Genuine WhatsApp Number for Real MeetSangli Call Girls 👙 6297143586 👙 Genuine WhatsApp Number for Real Meet
Sangli Call Girls 👙 6297143586 👙 Genuine WhatsApp Number for Real Meet
 
Thoothukudi Call Girls 👙 6297143586 👙 Genuine WhatsApp Number for Real Meet
Thoothukudi Call Girls 👙 6297143586 👙 Genuine WhatsApp Number for Real MeetThoothukudi Call Girls 👙 6297143586 👙 Genuine WhatsApp Number for Real Meet
Thoothukudi Call Girls 👙 6297143586 👙 Genuine WhatsApp Number for Real Meet
 
Ernakulam Call Girls 👙 6297143586 👙 Genuine WhatsApp Number for Real Meet
Ernakulam Call Girls 👙 6297143586 👙 Genuine WhatsApp Number for Real MeetErnakulam Call Girls 👙 6297143586 👙 Genuine WhatsApp Number for Real Meet
Ernakulam Call Girls 👙 6297143586 👙 Genuine WhatsApp Number for Real Meet
 
💚 Punjabi Call Girls In Chandigarh 💯Lucky 🔝8868886958🔝Call Girl In Chandigarh
💚 Punjabi Call Girls In Chandigarh 💯Lucky 🔝8868886958🔝Call Girl In Chandigarh💚 Punjabi Call Girls In Chandigarh 💯Lucky 🔝8868886958🔝Call Girl In Chandigarh
💚 Punjabi Call Girls In Chandigarh 💯Lucky 🔝8868886958🔝Call Girl In Chandigarh
 
bhubaneswar Call Girls 👙 6297143586 👙 Genuine WhatsApp Number for Real Meet
bhubaneswar Call Girls 👙 6297143586 👙 Genuine WhatsApp Number for Real Meetbhubaneswar Call Girls 👙 6297143586 👙 Genuine WhatsApp Number for Real Meet
bhubaneswar Call Girls 👙 6297143586 👙 Genuine WhatsApp Number for Real Meet
 
Rajkot Call Girls 👙 6297143586 👙 Genuine WhatsApp Number for Real Meet
Rajkot Call Girls 👙 6297143586 👙 Genuine WhatsApp Number for Real MeetRajkot Call Girls 👙 6297143586 👙 Genuine WhatsApp Number for Real Meet
Rajkot Call Girls 👙 6297143586 👙 Genuine WhatsApp Number for Real Meet
 
Call Girls Service Mohali {7435815124} ❤️VVIP PALAK Call Girl in Mohali Punjab
Call Girls Service Mohali {7435815124} ❤️VVIP PALAK Call Girl in Mohali PunjabCall Girls Service Mohali {7435815124} ❤️VVIP PALAK Call Girl in Mohali Punjab
Call Girls Service Mohali {7435815124} ❤️VVIP PALAK Call Girl in Mohali Punjab
 
Top 20 Famous Indian Female Pornstars Name List 2024
Top 20 Famous Indian Female Pornstars Name List 2024Top 20 Famous Indian Female Pornstars Name List 2024
Top 20 Famous Indian Female Pornstars Name List 2024
 
palanpur Call Girls 👙 6297143586 👙 Genuine WhatsApp Number for Real Meet
palanpur Call Girls 👙 6297143586 👙 Genuine WhatsApp Number for Real Meetpalanpur Call Girls 👙 6297143586 👙 Genuine WhatsApp Number for Real Meet
palanpur Call Girls 👙 6297143586 👙 Genuine WhatsApp Number for Real Meet
 
nagpur Call Girls 👙 6297143586 👙 Genuine WhatsApp Number for Real Meet
nagpur Call Girls 👙 6297143586 👙 Genuine WhatsApp Number for Real Meetnagpur Call Girls 👙 6297143586 👙 Genuine WhatsApp Number for Real Meet
nagpur Call Girls 👙 6297143586 👙 Genuine WhatsApp Number for Real Meet
 
(Deeksha) 💓 9920725232 💓High Profile Call Girls Navi Mumbai You Can Get The S...
(Deeksha) 💓 9920725232 💓High Profile Call Girls Navi Mumbai You Can Get The S...(Deeksha) 💓 9920725232 💓High Profile Call Girls Navi Mumbai You Can Get The S...
(Deeksha) 💓 9920725232 💓High Profile Call Girls Navi Mumbai You Can Get The S...
 
Best Lahore Escorts 😮‍💨03250114445 || VIP escorts in Lahore
Best Lahore Escorts 😮‍💨03250114445 || VIP escorts in LahoreBest Lahore Escorts 😮‍💨03250114445 || VIP escorts in Lahore
Best Lahore Escorts 😮‍💨03250114445 || VIP escorts in Lahore
 
Bihar Sharif Call Girls 👙 6297143586 👙 Genuine WhatsApp Number for Real Meet
Bihar Sharif Call Girls 👙 6297143586 👙 Genuine WhatsApp Number for Real MeetBihar Sharif Call Girls 👙 6297143586 👙 Genuine WhatsApp Number for Real Meet
Bihar Sharif Call Girls 👙 6297143586 👙 Genuine WhatsApp Number for Real Meet
 
Independent Call Girls Hyderabad 💋 9352988975 💋 Genuine WhatsApp Number for R...
Independent Call Girls Hyderabad 💋 9352988975 💋 Genuine WhatsApp Number for R...Independent Call Girls Hyderabad 💋 9352988975 💋 Genuine WhatsApp Number for R...
Independent Call Girls Hyderabad 💋 9352988975 💋 Genuine WhatsApp Number for R...
 
Jaipur Call Girls 9257276172 Call Girl in Jaipur Rajasthan
Jaipur Call Girls 9257276172 Call Girl in Jaipur RajasthanJaipur Call Girls 9257276172 Call Girl in Jaipur Rajasthan
Jaipur Call Girls 9257276172 Call Girl in Jaipur Rajasthan
 
Sexy Call Girl Dharmapuri Arshi 💚9058824046💚 Dharmapuri Escort Service
Sexy Call Girl Dharmapuri Arshi 💚9058824046💚 Dharmapuri Escort ServiceSexy Call Girl Dharmapuri Arshi 💚9058824046💚 Dharmapuri Escort Service
Sexy Call Girl Dharmapuri Arshi 💚9058824046💚 Dharmapuri Escort Service
 

How to Engage Physicians in Best Practices to Respond to Healthcare Transformation

  • 1. How to Engage Physicians in Best Practices to Respond to Healthcare Transformation Kent Bottles, MD www.kentbottlesmd.com kent@kentbottlesmd.com Georgia CPA Society February 11, 2016
  • 2. Dr. Kent Bottles Lecturer Thomas Jefferson University College of Population Health kentbottles@gmail.com www.kentbottlesmd.com
  • 3. What Leaders Do • Establish a vision that can inspire others – Environmental assessment of opportunities, risks, challenges • Translate the vision into strategies & tactics • Assign responsibilities to the right people • Hold the assigned people accountable
  • 4. Managing Complex Change VisionVision SkillsSkills Incentives or Consequences Incentives or Consequences ResourcesResources Action Plan Action Plan SkillsSkills Incentives or Consequences Incentives or Consequences ResourcesResources Action Plan Action Plan VisionVision Incentives or Consequences Incentives or Consequences ResourcesResources Action Plan Action Plan VisionVision SkillsSkills ResourcesResources Action Plan Action Plan VisionVision SkillsSkills Incentives or Consequences Incentives or Consequences Action Plan Action Plan VisionVision SkillsSkills Incentives or Consequences Incentives or Consequences ResourcesResources CHANGE Confusion Anxiety Gradual Change Frustration False Starts
  • 5. 2015 Healthcare Trends • Consolidation • Patient-Centered • Payment Reform • Big Data PA • Population Health • Transparency • Accountability • Risk Transfer • Technology • High-Cost Drugs
  • 6. Old New • Sickness System • Health: No Disease • Acute Disease • Fee for Service • Hospital Beds Full • Hospital-Centric • Doctor-Centric • Doctor Decides • MD Defines Quality • Wellness System • Health: Wellness • Chronic Disease • Value-Based • Hospital Beds Empty • Community-Centric • Patient-Centric • Shared Dec. Making • Measurable Metrics
  • 7. • Cost not considered • Independent doctors • Independent hospital • Med record secret • Opaque • Artificial harmony • Analogue • Hypothesis-driven clinical trials • Decreased cost • Employed docs • Integrated system • Open access record • Transparent • Cognitive conflict • Digital • Predictive analytics actionable correlations Old New
  • 8. David Feinberg, MD WSJ, September 27, 2015 “I think my job ultimately is to close every one of our hospitals. Because we should take care of you at home. We should take care of you at school. Nobody wants to go to the hospital. We really need to work to keep people healthy. Now, people will still get hit by cars, and there’ll be complex surgeries that require hospitalizations. But I’m trying to put myself out of business.”
  • 11. Bundled Payments Partial Capitation Global Payment Fee for Service Shared Savings Visitor Symptomatic Acute Needs Services & Supplies Unit Based No Financial Risk Visitor Symptomatic Acute Needs Services & Supplies Unit Based No Financial Risk Patient Episode Most Common Conditions Packaged Treatments Efficiency-Based Partial Financial Risk Patient Episode Most Common Conditions Packaged Treatments Efficiency-Based Partial Financial Risk Person Overall Health Community Health Characteristics Manage Well-Being Outcome-Based Full Financial Risk Person Overall Health Community Health Characteristics Manage Well-Being Outcome-Based Full Financial Risk Delivery System Reform
  • 12. A Promise from HHS Source: HHS Secretary Sylvia Burwell (January 30, 2015)
  • 13. The Price Ain’t Right? Hospital Prices and Health Spending on the Privately Insured* Zack Cooper, Yale University Stuart Craig, University of Pennsylvania Martin Gaynor, Carnegie Mellon John Van Reenen, London School of Economics December 2015 www.healthcarepricingproject.org *This research received financial support from the Commonwealth Fund, the National Institute for Health Care Management, and the Economic and Social Science Research Council.
  • 16. Introduction • The U.S. spends more than other nations on healthcare—$2.8 trillion dollars (17.2% of GDP)—without evidence of better outcomes • Wide-ranging analysis of variation in healthcare spending via Medicare suggests quantity of care given drives spending variation • However, results may not generalize to private markets where prices are not set administratively • However, almost no nation-wide hospital-specific price data and scant data on spending for privately insured 16 © Cooper, Craig, Gaynor, and Van Reenen
  • 17. Key Findings – Price Plays Crucial Role in Spending by Privately Insured 1. Low correlation (0.140) between Medicare and private spending per person 2. Price explains large portion of national variation in inpatient private spending 3. Substantial variation in prices, both within and across markets 4. Higher hospital market concentration is associated with higher hospital prices 17© Cooper, Craig, Gaynor, and Van Reenen
  • 18. Overview of the HCCI Data 18© Cooper, Craig, Gaynor, and Van Reenen
  • 19. Medicare Spending Per Beneficiary and Private Spending Per Beneficiary 19 © Cooper, Craig, Gaynor, and Van Reenen
  • 20. Knee Replacement Facility Prices Within MarketsDenver, CO Atlanta, GA Manhattan, NY Columbus, OH Philadelphia, PA Houston, TX Note: Each column is a hospital. Prices are regression-adjusted, measured from 2008 – 2011, and presented in 2011 dollars. © Cooper, Craig, Gaynor, and Van Reenen
  • 21. Colonoscopy Facility Prices Within MarketsDenver, CO Atlanta, GA Manhattan, NY Columbus, OH Philadelphia, PA Houston, TX Note: Each column is a hospital. Prices are regression-adjusted, measured from 2008 – 2011, and presented in 2011 dollars. © Cooper, Craig, Gaynor, and Van Reenen
  • 22. Conclusions 1.Private health spending per beneficiary per HRR varies by a factor of three across the nation 1.The correlation between HRR-level spending per Medicare beneficiary and spending per privately insured beneficiary is low (14.0%) 1.There is extensive private spending variation within and across markets – up to 400% within markets and far higher than Medicare within/across markets 1.Price is the primary driver of spending variation for the privately insured 1.Monopoly hospitals have a 15.3% price premium 22© Cooper, Craig, Gaynor, and Van Reenen
  • 23. Conclusions Cont. • We need to look beyond Grand Junction, Colorado; Rochester, Minnesota; and La Crosse, Wisconsin • If we think focuses on regions are important, look at: Rochester, New York; Dubuque, Iowa; Lynchburg, VA; De Moines, Iowa • Potential savings from reducing prices is large » Applying Medicare rates lowers private inpatient spending by 31% » Applying Medicare rates +10% lowers private inpatient spending by 24% » Applying Medicare rates +30% lowers private inpatient spending by 11% – Rather than attending current provider, if everyone paying above median prices got Median pries in their HRR, it would lower inpatient spending by 20.3%. 23© Cooper, Craig, Gaynor, and Van Reenen
  • 24. Policy Implications • Strategies to address healthcare spending variation across the U.S. may differ for publicly and privately insured populations • Reducing spending for the privately insured will come via targeting high prices & service intensity • Anti-trust enforcement • Price regulation • Raise patients’ price elasticity • Significant scope for savings by steering patients toward low-cost/high-quality providers via value-based insurance design • Significant need to make prices more transparent to consumers. 24© Cooper, Craig, Gaynor, and Van Reenen
  • 25. Hospital, physician prices driving health costs, business groups say • Boston Globe, February 9, 2016 • Associated Industries of MA • MA Association of Health Plans • National Federation of Independent Businesses • Retailers Association of MA
  • 26. State tells Boston Children’s Hospital to slow down • Boston Globe February 13, 2016 • $1 billion Boston’s Children’s Hospital building expansion • Hospital must provide independent analysis that shows the project is consistent with the Commonwealth’s efforts to meet healthcare cost-containment goals
  • 27. ProPublica Surgeon Scorecards • Medicare claims data 2009 to 2013 • Complication rates for 17,000 surgeons doing 8 procedures • Mortality rates and readmissions data used as proxy for complication rates • Complication rates were risk adjusted for coexisting conditions and hospital quality
  • 28. ProPublica Surgeon Scorecards • 11% of surgeons accounted for 25% of complications • Hundreds of surgeons had complication rates at least twice the national average • ProPublica recommends patients use the ratings to select a surgeon and a hospital
  • 29. ProPublica Surgeon Scorecards • Rand Corporation perspective attacked methodology and said pts should not use • Dr. Lisa Rosenbaum in NEJM: no better than Yelp • Dr. Peter Pronovost: adjusted complication rate was not true complication rate due to being based on flawed claims data
  • 30. ProPublica Surgeon Scorecards • Dr. Charles Mick, former president of North American Spine Society said scorecard long overdue and wonderful to have information in the public • Dr. Robert Wachter: if I were a pt., I would give scorecard considerable weight in choosing doctor • Paul Levy called for public release of American College of Surgeons National Surgical Quality Improvement Program results
  • 31. ProPublica Surgeon Scorecards • Dr. Shephard Hurwitz announced scorecard would be used by American Board of Orthopaedic Surgery to recertify surgeons • If a surgeon has a high complication rate, recertification may be delayed or interview for more details might be suggested • “It is controversial, but the fact is that we’re doing it in the spirit of transparency and holding people accountable for what’s already in the public domain”
  • 33. Let’s Talk Dollars: What’s at Stake? By 2017, up to 9% of Medicare PFS reimbursement could be lost due to Value- Modifier, PQRS, and Meaningful Use penalties. By 2016, 1.75% of DRG Payments will be withheld and potentially retained based on performance over several categories.
  • 34. It’s Not Just CMS… • Commercial payers are also beginning to require inclusion of quality measures and programs. Major payers are quickly jumping on board: – BCBS – Aetna – Cigna – United Healthcare
  • 35. MACRA Medicare Access and CHIP Reauthorization Act of 2015
  • 36. Payment Reform - Annual Updates 2015 0.5% update effective June 1 - versus 21 percent cut scheduled for April 1 2016 – 2019 0.5% annual updates 2020 - 2025 No updates 2026+ 0.75% annual updates for providers in alternative payment models 0.25% annual updates for everyone else
  • 37. The SGR Fix Benefits: Certainty of payments for the next 10 years No annual fear of unrealistic payment cuts Concerns: Does 0.5% keep up with medical inflation (plus the inherent costs of participation in quality programs)?
  • 38. What’s the Problem With Current System?
  • 39. MIPS – the Details • Repeals PQRS and MU penalties and VM program effective December 31, 2018; replaces with MIPS – Providers will receive a composite score from 1 to 100 based on quality measures, efficiency measures, meaningful use of electronic health records, and clinical practice improvement activities; score will be made publicly available – Each year, CMS will establish a threshold score based on median/mean composite performance scores of all providers measured during previous performance period
  • 40. Composite Performance Score For Example: Historic PQRS Measures For Example: Cost Measures included in VM Program For Example: Potentially Stage 3 Requirements of MU Program For Example: Population Health Initiatives
  • 41. MIPS Scoring System 0 100 Quality Efficiency Meaningful Use Clinical Process Improvement 78 National Median Composite Provider Score (Example) = Medicare Provider = National Median Composite Score
  • 42. Adjustment Factor Year Penalty Cap Bonus opportunity (subject to scaling factor) 2019 -4% Up to +12% 2020 -5% Up to +15% 2021 -7% Up to +21% 2022 -9% Up to +27% Exceptional Performance Incentive Payment If meet or beat stretch goal, also receive payment from annual $500 million incentive bonus pool (not to exceed 10 percent) By no later than December 2 each year, CMS will make available each eligible professional’s adjustment factor for upcoming year
  • 43. Quality Measures Component • CMS to finalize annual list of quality measures by November 1 of preceding year – Clinical care – Safety – Care coordination – Patient and caregiver experience – Population health and prevention • Preference for measures endorsed by professional organizations; others subject to peer review procedures
  • 44. Quality Measure Development Plan • CMS to publish draft plan by 01/01/16 and final plan by 05/01/16; annual reports on implementation • $15 million annually from 2015 to 2019 • Priorities – Outcomes (including patient-reported and functional status) – Patient experience – Care coordination – Appropriate resource use
  • 45. Resource Use Measures Component • Incorporate current VM total cost-of-care measures • Measures development – CMS to develop new classification codes in 2016-17 • Care episode groups • Patient condition groups • Patient relationship categories – Beginning January 1, 2018, claims must include new codes as appropriate
  • 46. EHR Meaningful Use Component • Credit based on meeting then-current meaningful use requirements • Eliminate inconsistencies in quality measure reporting requirements
  • 47. Clinical Practice Improvement Activities (CPIA) Component • CMS to develop menu of specific CPIAs for which EPs will receive credit – Expanded practice access – Population health management – Care coordination – Beneficiary engagement – Patient safety and practice assessment – Participation in alternative payment model • Consideration for small and rural practices
  • 48. …More MIPS • Providers scoring below threshold subject to payment cuts capped at 4% in 2019, 5% in 2020, 7% in 2021, and 9% in 2022. • Providers scoring above threshold will receive bonus payments, up to three times the annual penalty cap. • Providers scoring above “stretch” performance score will receive an additional bonus payment allocated from a $500 million annual pool. • Providers participating in alternative payment mechanisms (APMs) may opt out of MIPs in favor of annual 5% bonus payment.
  • 49. Raising the Stakes • Over time, the MIPS penalties become substantially greater than those contemplated in existing CMS programs. • This, coupled with the fact that private payers are likely to “piggy- back” on the MIPS program, make the push for quality and efficiency simply too strong for providers to ignore. • Just as before, there will be winners and losers in this program. • The legislation is very broadly defined, CMS will have to fill in the details…
  • 51. 2019 - 2024: 5% participation bonus Two Tracks for Providers Merit-Based Incentive Payment System Advanced Alternative Payment Models 2020: -5% to +15%1 at risk 2019: Combine PQRS, MU, & VBM programs: -4% to +12%1 at risk 2022 and on: -9% to +27%1 at risk 2021: -7% to +21%1 at risk 2018: Last year of separate MU, PQRS, and VBM penalties 2019 - 2020: 25% Medicare revenue requirement 2021 and on: Ramped up Medicare or all- payer revenue requirements 2015:H2 – 2019: 0.5% annual update 2026 and on: 0.25% annual update 2026 and on: 0.75% annual update 2020 – 2025: Frozen payment rates 2015:H2 – 2019: 0.5% annual update 2020 – 2025: Frozen payment rates 51
  • 52. APM Framework White Paper January 2016 • Health Care Payment Learning & Action Network (LAN) • Established in March 2015 • Private payers, large employers, providers, patients, consumer groups, state governments, federal government • https://hcp-lan.org/workproducts/apm- whitepaper.pdf
  • 53. APM Framework White Paper January 2016 • Changing financial reward to providers • Patient input to APM design • Patients should go to high-value providers • Patients should be active in shared decision making
  • 54. APM Framework White Paper January 2016 • Shift toward shared risk and population- based payment models • Value-based incentives intense enough for providers to invest in and implement delivery system reforms • Value-based incentives should increase • Centers of excellence, ACO, PCMH can be supported by different payment models
  • 55. APM Framework Category 1 January 2016 • FFS with No Link to Quality & Value • DRG • Not adjusted for – Infrastructure investments – Reporting of quality data – Provider performance on cost – Provider performance on quality
  • 56. APM Framework Category 2 January 2016 • FFS Linked to Quality and Value • 2A: Infrastructure payments • 2B: Positive or negative incentives to report quality data • 2C: Rewards for high clinical quality • 2D: Reward high clinical quality & penalize low clinical quality providers
  • 57. APM Framework Category 3 January 2016 • APMs Built on FFS Architecture • Mechanism for management of procedures, episode of care or all health services • 3A: Upside opportunity to share in savings • 3B: Upside gainsharing and downside risk based on cost measures
  • 58. APM Framework Category 4 January 2016 • Population0Based Payment • Holds providers accountable for meeting quality & person-centered care goals for a population of patients • Cover preventive, health improvement, health maintenance, and specialized care
  • 59. APM Framework Category 4 January 2016 • Population-Based Payment • 4A: Population-based but limited to sets of condition-specific services (asthma, DM, cancer); they remain person-focused in that they hold providers accountable for total cost and quality of care for that condition • 4B: Capitated or population-based for all of individual’s healthcare needs
  • 60. Health Care Learning & Action Network (LAN) January 2016 Population-Based Payment Work Group Clinical Episode Payment Work Group https://hcp-lan.org/workproducts/apm- whitepaper.pdf
  • 61. Docs Don’t Get SGR Fix Raise • Medicare Physician Fee Schedule Final Rule Says 2016 pay will be 0.29% < 2015 • Protecting Access to Medicare Act & Achieving a Better Life Experience Act & RVU Budget Neutrality Rule mean conversion factor in 2016 will be $35.8279 (1.5 RVU = $53.74) • RVU X Conversion Factor – 1.5 RVU X $35.9335 = $53.90 (2015) – 1.5 RVU X $37.7302 = $56.60 (2016)
  • 62. None of this will work without….  Physician buy-in, and leadership is critical to success in a value-based payment world.
  • 63. Physician View of Hospital Administrators Weber, Physician Executive, July, 2006 • Insulated from pressures of patient care • Don’t understand how hard doctors work • Paid for non-productive work • Worry about how much things cost • Focus on problems • Don’t get out from behind their desks
  • 64. Hospital Administrator View of Physicians Weber, Physician Executive, July, 2006 • Lack big-picture understanding • Don’t make time to administrate; veto decisions made by others • Unwilling to confront peer physicians • Do not make decisions; no leadership • Act as if other providers are less valuable than physicians; not good team players
  • 65. Differences between Administrators and Clinicians Administrators proactive planners work well with groups delayed gratification id. with organization establish rules multidisciplinary long time frame institutional prerogative influence hospital: community asset Clinicians reactive work well 1:1 quick gratification id. with profession resent rules specialists short time frame individual prerogative control hospital: work shop
  • 66. Collective vs. Expert Cultures • Nurses, administrators • Others ahead of self • Trusting • Value loyalty • Avoid conflict/risk • Thin-skinned • Consensus building • Process-oriented • Engineering, MD, law • Self-interest • Accomplishment • Power • Teamwork not valued • Quick decisions • Thick-skinned • Outcomes-oriented
  • 67. Collective vs. Expert Cultures • Malignant: Cynic/Victim • Have common mission, values, vision • Collaboration • Malignant: Narcissism • Specific vision where self-interest is obvious • Do not need mission, values statements • Collegiality
  • 68. Expert Engineer Culture Edgar H. Schein, DEC is Dead, Long Live DEC, 2003 • Individual commitment is not to employer • People, organization, bureaucracy are constraints to be overcome • Engineering culture disdains management and marketing • No loyalty to customer: if trade-offs had to be made between building “fun,” “elegant” technologically challenging computers and the needs of “dumb” customers guess who won?
  • 69. Unhappy Doctors & Happy Doctors • “Your doctor’s unhappiness is a catastrophic problem that the new law didn’t anticipate and is not prepared to address.” Dr. Marc Siegel, Associate Professor of Medicine, NYU Langone Medical Center • “To us, supporting the ACA makes moral and medical sense.” Dr. Jeffrey Drazen, Editor-in-Chief, and Dr. Gregory Curfman, Executive Editor, NEJM
  • 70. Dr. Daniel F. Craviotto, Jr. • Docs in the trenches do not have a voice • “Damn the mandates…from bureaucrats who are not in the healing profession” • EHRs waste time • Board recertification is time consuming • Physicians as a group should not accept any health insurance
  • 71. Dr. Aaron Carroll • Complaining about no voice in WSJ • “Most people have to choose between doing God’s work and being in the 1%--Only doctors get to do both” • Board recertification is mandated by doctors • “It’s tone deaf in today’s economy for people at the top end of the spectrum to complain so publicly about how little they are paid” • Less than 1% of physicians opt out of Medicare
  • 72. Dan Munro • His criticisms are not patient-centered • Orthopedics annual compensation of $413,000 • 84 million non-elderly were uninsured or underinsured in 2012 • 100 million Americans in poverty or in the fretful zone just above it • Half of all doctors believe they are fairly compensated
  • 73. Defying the Medical Machine NY Times, January 10, 2016 • Increasing efficiency vs. deference to MDs • Sacred Heart Medical Center, Springfield • Bids to outsource 36 hospitalists positions • MDs at Sacred Heart see 15 patients a day • EmCare MDs see 15 to 18 patients a day
  • 74. Defying the Medical Machine NY Times, January 10, 2016 • “Giving me a bonus for seeing two more patients – I’m not sure I should be doing that. It’s safe.” Dr. Rajeev Alexander • 1/3 of hospitalists left Sacred Heart
  • 75. Defying the Medical Machine NY Times, January 10, 2016 • Form a union • Independent hospitalist group • Form an alliance with outsourcing firm that the doctors selected
  • 76. Defying the Medical Machine NY Times, January 10, 2016 • Spouse decides to play the field • You’ve been great; you’ve always been there • I just heard there could be better spouses out there • The good news is, you’re still in the running too
  • 77. Defying the Medical Machine NY Times, January 10, 2016 • Formed union with American Federation of Teachers • The administrator behind outsourcing left • Outsourcing plan abandoned
  • 78. Defying the Medical Machine NY Times, January 10, 2016 • REAL rounds (Rounding embraced by all leaders) • “Are you kidding me. Real rounds as opposed to what we do?” Dr. D. Schwartz • “What’s the widget the hospital produces? It’s the hospital-patient relationship. You don’t improve it with extra little tasks.” Dr. Rajeev Alexander
  • 79. Defying the Medical Machine NY Times, January 10, 2016 • Hospitalists insist it is not about the money • Administrators insist it is about the money
  • 80. Defying the Medical Machine NY Times, January 10, 2016 • Skin in the game • “It really took all of my self control to not say, ‘What the hell do you mean skin in the game?’ We have our licenses, our livelihoods, our professions. Every single time we walk up to a patient, everything is on the line.”
  • 81. Defying the Medical Machine NY Times, January 10, 2016 • Skin in the game • “My thought was, I’ll put some of my skin in the game if you put your name on the chart…If there’s a lawsuit, you’re on there. You come down and make a decision about my patient, then we’ll talk about skin in the game.” Dr. David Schwartz
  • 82. Danielle Ofri, MD • 33% of HA1C at goal • 44% of cholesterol at goal • 26% of blood pressure at goal
  • 83. Danielle Ofri, MD • “I don’t even bother checking the results anymore. I just quietly push the reports under the pile of unread journals, phone messages, insurance forms, and prior authorizations.”
  • 84. Kaiser IDs Gaps in MD Readiness for a Reformed Delivery System (Crosson, Health Affairs, 2011) • Systems thinking • Leadership and management skills • Continuity of care • Care coordination • Procedural skills • Office-based practice competencies – Inter-professional team skills – Clinical IT meaningful use skills – Population management skills – Reflective practice and CQI skills
  • 85. AHA Physician Leadership Forum: Competency Development • Leadership training • Systems theory and analysis • Use of information technology • Cross-disciplinary training/team building
  • 86. Mindset of the Traditional Physician • My success depends on my individual behavior • Individual activities lead to personal financial success • Individual activities lead to successful clinical outcomes • Strong financial and clinical performance of my parent organization and physician colleagues have little impact on my personal success • “Cowboys”
  • 87. Mindset of the Integrated Employed Physician • My success is enhanced by collaboration • Individual activities lead to the financial success of parent organization • Individual activities lead to successful clinical outcomes because of collaboration • Strong financial and clinical performance of my parent organization • And physician colleagues have major impact on my personal success • “Pit Crews”
  • 88. Traditional Physician Leadership • Represent local physician interests at organization-wide venues • Secure resources for local physicians • Rally physicians against perceived enemy − Hospital administration − Insurance companies − Competing physicians
  • 89. Physician Leadership in Integrated Aligned System • Holding physicians accountable for performance • Working as part of a leadership team of the organization • Supporting decisions they may not personally agree with • Modeling behavior that supports the overall organization goals • Leaders job is not to protect, defend, and ensure local interests that may conflict with overall organization interests • Leading in an integrated aligned system is a real job
  • 90. Leading Physicians Through Change (Mary Jane Kornacki & Jack Silversin) • Effective physician leadership • Shared vision • Compact: Alignment of behavior with shared vision
  • 91. • Physician leadership needed in a transformed clinical delivery system • Holding physicians accountable for clinical performance • Holding physicians accountable for financial performance • Working as part of leadership team • Actively supporting decisions they do not agree with Leading Physicians Through Change (Mary Jane Kornacki & Jack Silversin)
  • 92. • Collect and organize relevant data – Your organization’s mission – Reliable data on current market reality – Trend data suggesting what will be important for future success – Your organization’s capabilities and strengths – Your organization’s weaknesses – The mission and vision of the larger enterprise Leading Physicians Through Change (Mary Jane Kornacki & Jack Silversin)
  • 93. • Compact is the expectations members of an organization have regarding the intangible assets and benefits they’re entitled to and what their organization expects in return • Compact is part of organizational life that is taken for granted • Rewriting a compact is an example of adaptive change Leading Physicians Through Change (Mary Jane Kornacki & Jack Silversin)
  • 94. • Culture works that supports strategies and actions that result in a successful business • Culture is differentiator between high- and low- performing hospitals treating AMI (Annals of Internal Medicine 154(6):384, 3/15/2011) • Culture that contributed to past success does not change as fast as new strategies & tactics • Culture shaped by shared assumptions & beliefs about the right way to do things (may not be conscious) Leading Physicians Through Change (Mary Jane Kornacki & Jack Silversin)
  • 95. • Traditional compact • Physicians Give – Patient care – Quality care as they define it • Physicians Get – Autonomy – Protection – Entitlement Leading Physicians Through Change (Mary Jane Kornacki & Jack Silversin)
  • 96. • New compact • Physicians Give – Patient-centered care – Acknowledged interdependence – Delegated authority to leaders – Accountability • Physicians Get – Market-responsive organization able to survive – Influence on governance – Input on decisions affecting the practice – Compensation linked to organization & individual performance on outcomes, cost, and quality Leading Physicians Through Change (Mary Jane Kornacki & Jack Silversin)
  • 97. Symptoms of Resistance • Superficial agreement with change with no commitment or follow-through • Slow progress • Apathy • Excuses for lack of engagement or progress
  • 98. Addressing Resistance • Leaders cross bridge first by coming to terms with own concerns • Help physicians let go of expectations that cannot be met • Get out the news • Listen to and honor resistance

Notes de l'éditeur

  1. Will use this slide instead of 35 if the figures are correct.
  2. Tip of the iceberg…….
  3. Place to plug healthcareloop.com – lots of information, listserv to push out information on relevant info (internal, daily) We’ve seen specialty-specific quality programs from private payers