Slides from Opportunities knocked? Tackling racial disadvantages and discrimination in the workplace, an event held at the Resolution Foundation on 18th July 2018.
Opportunities knocked? Tackling racial disadvantages and discrimination in the workplace
1. Opportunities knocked?
Tackling racial disadvantages and discrimination in
the workplace
1
Kathleen Henehan, Research and Policy Analyst, Resolution
Foundation
David Lammy, MP forTottenham and Chair of the Race and
CommunityAPPG
Zubaida Haque, Deputy Director,The RunnymedeTrust
Torsten Bell, Resolution Foundation (Chair)
July 2018
@resfoundation ##paypenalty
Wifi: 2QAG_guest password: W3lc0m3!!
3. There is some good news on education
3
Starting with
education: the
proportion of
working-age adults
with degrees has
grown rapidly over
the past two
decades
Men and women
from ethnic
minorities have
made the most
progress, now
topping the charts
4. …there is also good news on employment
4
Employment is up
substantially
among men from
ethnic minority
backgrounds
While Indian men
overtook white
men, employment
also grew 24 and
30 per cent among
Black and
Pakistani/
Bangladeshi men
5. Job done? Not quite.
5
Despite there being
overall pay growth
over recent
decades,
significant pay gaps
persist
Average hourly pay
among white
women and black
men is 2o per cent
below that of white
men
This is particularly
worrying given
growth in
educational
attainment
6. Job done? Not quite.
6
Despite there being
overall pay growth
over recent
decades,
significant pay gaps
persist
Average hourly pay
among white
women and black
men is 2o per cent
below that of white
men
This is particularly
worrying given
growth in
educational
attainment
7. Job done? Not quite.
7
Despite there being
overall pay growth
over recent
decades,
significant pay gaps
persist
Average hourly pay
among white
women and black
men is 2o per cent
below that of white
men
This is particularly
worrying given
growth in
educational
attainment
8. Job done? Not quite.
8
Despite there being
overall pay growth
over recent
decades,
significant pay gaps
persist
Average hourly pay
among white
women and black
men is 2o per cent
below that of white
men
This is particularly
worrying given
growth in
educational
attainment
9. Some pay gaps might down to observable
characteristics
9
For instance, age
Overall, ethnic
minority groups
tend to have much
younger age-
profile than white
men and women
These age
differences factor
into employment
rates and they can
depress levels of
pay among
younger groups
10. Some pay gaps might down to observable
characteristics
10
Also, occupation.
A plurality of Indian
and white men and
women are in
higher-skilled,
higher-paid roles
(blue)
However, a large
proportion of black
and Pakistani/
Bangladeshi
workers find
themselves in mid
(purple) and lower
(red) paid work
11. Some pay gaps might down to observable
characteristics
11
Also, occupation.
A plurality of Indian
and white men and
women are in
higher-skilled,
higher-paid roles
(blue)
However, a large
proportion of black
and Pakistani/
Bangladeshi
workers find
themselves in mid
(purple) and lower
(red) paid work
12. Some pay gaps might down to observable
characteristics
12
Also, occupation.
A plurality of Indian
and white men and
women are in
higher-skilled,
higher-paid roles
(blue)
However, a large
proportion of black
and Pakistani/
Bangladeshi
workers find
themselves in mid
(purple) and lower
(red) paid work
13. But big pay penalties remain after we’ve put those
characteristics aside
13
Even after
accounting for
where a region,
qualifications and
occupation, large
penalties between
white and ethnic
minority men
persist
All things being
equal, a black
graduate man
could expect to
earn 17 per cent
less an hour than a
white graduate
man
14. But big pay penalties remain after we’ve put those
characteristics aside
14
Even after
accounting for
where a region,
qualifications and
occupation, large
penalties between
white and ethnic
minority men
persist
All things being
equal, a black
graduate man
could expect to
earn 17 per cent
less an hour than a
white graduate
man
15. They tend to be smaller among women, but stubborn
over time
15
Pay penalties are
smaller among
women, but do still
exist
All things being
equal a Pakistani/
Bangladeshi non-
graduate could
expect to be paid
five per cent less an
hour than white
women
Worryingly, for all
graduates and for
most groups, these
penalties haven’t
shifted over time
16. Overall, a worrying picture
• There’s been significant progress on education and
employment among ethnic minority groups in recent
decades
• Yet this hasn’t resulted in pay gaps closing
• Smaller, but still big, pay penalties for ethnic
minorities remain even after accounting observable
differences between workers…
• …which means policymakers’ focus shouldn’t be
limited to the further equalisation of opportunities
like education but also on disadvantage and
discrimination
16