SlideShare une entreprise Scribd logo
1  sur  18
Feed/Browse Experience
Overview
July 25, 2016
Purpose
To provide an overview of the feed product
Outcome
A common understanding of the feed product
Agenda
What was the motivation?
What are our objectives?
What is the approach?
What have we done so far?
What are we doing now?
What’s next?
What was the motivation?
Provide a consistent user experience across all CBC short-form content
Faster, more frequent delivery of new product features to the audience based on
their needs
Reduce operational costs
Reduce the number of digital products that require regular maintenance
Leverage new technology so our products are more performant
What are our objectives?
1. Evolvable user experience
2. Increase engagement
3. Increase retention
4. Increase reach
5. Increase revenue
What is the approach?
Responsive redesign of all CBC websites (apps are not included)
Consistent user experience
Agile/Lean startup
User tests
Iterative development
What is the approach?
Working in partnership with content areas and business units
Regular check-ins for collaborative decision making and sharing of work in progress
What is the approach?
Separating content from presentation
Stories Video Social Media
Manage
Content
Distribute
Deliver
Experience
The Feed
Polopoly
Ocelot
MPX
Content Aggregator
Layer 7
What have we done so far?
Collected data
Analyzed audience behaviour
Conducted tests
Released beta sites for Arts and News using Polopoly presentation
Gathered feedback to inform the Feed product
Built an internal demo site for the feed (http://feed.cbc.ca/)
CBC Arts
CBC News
What are the most important things we’ve
learned?
Feedback forms
Beta is clean, modern and readable
Text size may be too big, especially for non-breaking headlines
Some users find the beta site easy to navigate
Some say it’s difficult to find News sections
Requires a lot of scrolling
Validation Board
Density of the page
Number of images displayed at the top of the page
Ordering of links to drive engagement
Quick results from randomized test
Approximately 7,800 users were sent to each site.
Users entered either beta or current state from the Canada landing page
Survey ran for approximately 1.5 hours over the ET lunch hour
U Texas capped the survey at 485 users in each site.
Beta
Current
Beta (survey)
Current (survey)
What are we doing now?
Ocelot development
Gradual release to the public
Content API development
Demo site
Navigation
Testing
Infrastructure setup for new development, QA and production environments
What’s next?
Release plan/timing
End of July hidden production release
Post-Olympics gradual rollout to all content areas that are using Polopoly
Deprecation of old web products when the audience shows us they are engaged with the new product
Demonstrate how the feed can support other objectives:
Cross-promotion
Launching new verticals
Ad products (Native, viewability, video)

Contenu connexe

Similaire à Feed Overview July 25

Realtime Learning: Using Triggers to Know What the ?$# is Going On
Realtime Learning: Using Triggers to Know What the ?$# is Going OnRealtime Learning: Using Triggers to Know What the ?$# is Going On
Realtime Learning: Using Triggers to Know What the ?$# is Going OnDomino Data Lab
 
Sakai Foundation Update 2009
Sakai Foundation Update 2009Sakai Foundation Update 2009
Sakai Foundation Update 2009Michael Korcuska
 
August 2011 final
August 2011 finalAugust 2011 final
August 2011 finalOCLC
 
Experimenting on Humans
Experimenting on HumansExperimenting on Humans
Experimenting on HumansC4Media
 
2010 January Sakai Foundation Executive Brief
2010 January Sakai Foundation Executive Brief2010 January Sakai Foundation Executive Brief
2010 January Sakai Foundation Executive Briefthe Hartsook Letter
 
FCB Partners Webinar: Process 2020: The Cutting Edge of Process Innovation
FCB Partners Webinar: Process 2020: The Cutting Edge of Process Innovation FCB Partners Webinar: Process 2020: The Cutting Edge of Process Innovation
FCB Partners Webinar: Process 2020: The Cutting Edge of Process Innovation FCBPartners
 
Public Sector Agility Accelerator
Public Sector Agility AcceleratorPublic Sector Agility Accelerator
Public Sector Agility AcceleratorCraig Smith
 
Overview Of Eye Tracking At Yahoo
Overview Of Eye Tracking At YahooOverview Of Eye Tracking At Yahoo
Overview Of Eye Tracking At YahooPrasad Kantamneni
 
Application Performance Testing: A Simplified Universal Approach
Application Performance Testing: A Simplified Universal ApproachApplication Performance Testing: A Simplified Universal Approach
Application Performance Testing: A Simplified Universal ApproachTechWell
 
You're Live, Now What?
You're Live, Now What?You're Live, Now What?
You're Live, Now What?Evergreen ILS
 
Exoven web-sovellusseminaarin kalvot
Exoven web-sovellusseminaarin kalvotExoven web-sovellusseminaarin kalvot
Exoven web-sovellusseminaarin kalvotExove
 
Guiding a Product Roadmap in a Chaotic World
Guiding a Product Roadmap in a Chaotic WorldGuiding a Product Roadmap in a Chaotic World
Guiding a Product Roadmap in a Chaotic WorldEric de Jager
 
Jan Bosch | Agile Product Development: From Hunch to Hard Data
Jan Bosch | Agile Product Development: From Hunch to Hard DataJan Bosch | Agile Product Development: From Hunch to Hard Data
Jan Bosch | Agile Product Development: From Hunch to Hard DataOptimizely
 

Similaire à Feed Overview July 25 (20)

2009 02 26 Upv V02
2009 02 26 Upv V022009 02 26 Upv V02
2009 02 26 Upv V02
 
Realtime Learning: Using Triggers to Know What the ?$# is Going On
Realtime Learning: Using Triggers to Know What the ?$# is Going OnRealtime Learning: Using Triggers to Know What the ?$# is Going On
Realtime Learning: Using Triggers to Know What the ?$# is Going On
 
From e-Lib to NOF-digi and beyond
From e-Lib to NOF-digi and beyondFrom e-Lib to NOF-digi and beyond
From e-Lib to NOF-digi and beyond
 
Sakai Foundation Update 2009
Sakai Foundation Update 2009Sakai Foundation Update 2009
Sakai Foundation Update 2009
 
August 2011 final
August 2011 finalAugust 2011 final
August 2011 final
 
Experimenting on Humans
Experimenting on HumansExperimenting on Humans
Experimenting on Humans
 
2010 January Sakai Foundation Executive Brief
2010 January Sakai Foundation Executive Brief2010 January Sakai Foundation Executive Brief
2010 January Sakai Foundation Executive Brief
 
FCB Partners Webinar: Process 2020: The Cutting Edge of Process Innovation
FCB Partners Webinar: Process 2020: The Cutting Edge of Process Innovation FCB Partners Webinar: Process 2020: The Cutting Edge of Process Innovation
FCB Partners Webinar: Process 2020: The Cutting Edge of Process Innovation
 
Public Sector Agility Accelerator
Public Sector Agility AcceleratorPublic Sector Agility Accelerator
Public Sector Agility Accelerator
 
AAC Global use case
AAC Global use caseAAC Global use case
AAC Global use case
 
I cons forum0610
I cons forum0610I cons forum0610
I cons forum0610
 
Overview Of Eye Tracking At Yahoo
Overview Of Eye Tracking At YahooOverview Of Eye Tracking At Yahoo
Overview Of Eye Tracking At Yahoo
 
OSCELOT
OSCELOTOSCELOT
OSCELOT
 
Application Performance Testing: A Simplified Universal Approach
Application Performance Testing: A Simplified Universal ApproachApplication Performance Testing: A Simplified Universal Approach
Application Performance Testing: A Simplified Universal Approach
 
HOBBIT at ESWC EU Networking Session
HOBBIT at ESWC EU Networking SessionHOBBIT at ESWC EU Networking Session
HOBBIT at ESWC EU Networking Session
 
You're Live, Now What?
You're Live, Now What?You're Live, Now What?
You're Live, Now What?
 
Exoven web-sovellusseminaarin kalvot
Exoven web-sovellusseminaarin kalvotExoven web-sovellusseminaarin kalvot
Exoven web-sovellusseminaarin kalvot
 
A True Story of Why QA Loves DevOps
A True Story of Why QA Loves DevOpsA True Story of Why QA Loves DevOps
A True Story of Why QA Loves DevOps
 
Guiding a Product Roadmap in a Chaotic World
Guiding a Product Roadmap in a Chaotic WorldGuiding a Product Roadmap in a Chaotic World
Guiding a Product Roadmap in a Chaotic World
 
Jan Bosch | Agile Product Development: From Hunch to Hard Data
Jan Bosch | Agile Product Development: From Hunch to Hard DataJan Bosch | Agile Product Development: From Hunch to Hard Data
Jan Bosch | Agile Product Development: From Hunch to Hard Data
 

Dernier

VIP Call Girls In Saharaganj ( Lucknow ) 🔝 8923113531 🔝 Cash Payment (COD) 👒
VIP Call Girls In Saharaganj ( Lucknow  ) 🔝 8923113531 🔝  Cash Payment (COD) 👒VIP Call Girls In Saharaganj ( Lucknow  ) 🔝 8923113531 🔝  Cash Payment (COD) 👒
VIP Call Girls In Saharaganj ( Lucknow ) 🔝 8923113531 🔝 Cash Payment (COD) 👒anilsa9823
 
Russian Call Girls In Gurgaon ❤️8448577510 ⊹Best Escorts Service In 24/7 Delh...
Russian Call Girls In Gurgaon ❤️8448577510 ⊹Best Escorts Service In 24/7 Delh...Russian Call Girls In Gurgaon ❤️8448577510 ⊹Best Escorts Service In 24/7 Delh...
Russian Call Girls In Gurgaon ❤️8448577510 ⊹Best Escorts Service In 24/7 Delh...lizamodels9
 
The Coffee Bean & Tea Leaf(CBTL), Business strategy case study
The Coffee Bean & Tea Leaf(CBTL), Business strategy case studyThe Coffee Bean & Tea Leaf(CBTL), Business strategy case study
The Coffee Bean & Tea Leaf(CBTL), Business strategy case studyEthan lee
 
It will be International Nurses' Day on 12 May
It will be International Nurses' Day on 12 MayIt will be International Nurses' Day on 12 May
It will be International Nurses' Day on 12 MayNZSG
 
How to Get Started in Social Media for Art League City
How to Get Started in Social Media for Art League CityHow to Get Started in Social Media for Art League City
How to Get Started in Social Media for Art League CityEric T. Tung
 
0183760ssssssssssssssssssssssssssss00101011 (27).pdf
0183760ssssssssssssssssssssssssssss00101011 (27).pdf0183760ssssssssssssssssssssssssssss00101011 (27).pdf
0183760ssssssssssssssssssssssssssss00101011 (27).pdfRenandantas16
 
Mondelez State of Snacking and Future Trends 2023
Mondelez State of Snacking and Future Trends 2023Mondelez State of Snacking and Future Trends 2023
Mondelez State of Snacking and Future Trends 2023Neil Kimberley
 
Yaroslav Rozhankivskyy: Три складові і три передумови максимальної продуктивн...
Yaroslav Rozhankivskyy: Три складові і три передумови максимальної продуктивн...Yaroslav Rozhankivskyy: Три складові і три передумови максимальної продуктивн...
Yaroslav Rozhankivskyy: Три складові і три передумови максимальної продуктивн...Lviv Startup Club
 
B.COM Unit – 4 ( CORPORATE SOCIAL RESPONSIBILITY ( CSR ).pptx
B.COM Unit – 4 ( CORPORATE SOCIAL RESPONSIBILITY ( CSR ).pptxB.COM Unit – 4 ( CORPORATE SOCIAL RESPONSIBILITY ( CSR ).pptx
B.COM Unit – 4 ( CORPORATE SOCIAL RESPONSIBILITY ( CSR ).pptxpriyanshujha201
 
Call Girls In DLf Gurgaon ➥99902@11544 ( Best price)100% Genuine Escort In 24...
Call Girls In DLf Gurgaon ➥99902@11544 ( Best price)100% Genuine Escort In 24...Call Girls In DLf Gurgaon ➥99902@11544 ( Best price)100% Genuine Escort In 24...
Call Girls In DLf Gurgaon ➥99902@11544 ( Best price)100% Genuine Escort In 24...lizamodels9
 
FULL ENJOY Call Girls In Mahipalpur Delhi Contact Us 8377877756
FULL ENJOY Call Girls In Mahipalpur Delhi Contact Us 8377877756FULL ENJOY Call Girls In Mahipalpur Delhi Contact Us 8377877756
FULL ENJOY Call Girls In Mahipalpur Delhi Contact Us 8377877756dollysharma2066
 
Dr. Admir Softic_ presentation_Green Club_ENG.pdf
Dr. Admir Softic_ presentation_Green Club_ENG.pdfDr. Admir Softic_ presentation_Green Club_ENG.pdf
Dr. Admir Softic_ presentation_Green Club_ENG.pdfAdmir Softic
 
Mysore Call Girls 8617370543 WhatsApp Number 24x7 Best Services
Mysore Call Girls 8617370543 WhatsApp Number 24x7 Best ServicesMysore Call Girls 8617370543 WhatsApp Number 24x7 Best Services
Mysore Call Girls 8617370543 WhatsApp Number 24x7 Best ServicesDipal Arora
 
Monte Carlo simulation : Simulation using MCSM
Monte Carlo simulation : Simulation using MCSMMonte Carlo simulation : Simulation using MCSM
Monte Carlo simulation : Simulation using MCSMRavindra Nath Shukla
 
Call Girls Pune Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Pune Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service AvailableCall Girls Pune Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Pune Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service AvailableDipal Arora
 
Insurers' journeys to build a mastery in the IoT usage
Insurers' journeys to build a mastery in the IoT usageInsurers' journeys to build a mastery in the IoT usage
Insurers' journeys to build a mastery in the IoT usageMatteo Carbone
 
Call Girls Navi Mumbai Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Avail...
Call Girls Navi Mumbai Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Avail...Call Girls Navi Mumbai Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Avail...
Call Girls Navi Mumbai Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Avail...Dipal Arora
 
Regression analysis: Simple Linear Regression Multiple Linear Regression
Regression analysis:  Simple Linear Regression Multiple Linear RegressionRegression analysis:  Simple Linear Regression Multiple Linear Regression
Regression analysis: Simple Linear Regression Multiple Linear RegressionRavindra Nath Shukla
 

Dernier (20)

VIP Call Girls In Saharaganj ( Lucknow ) 🔝 8923113531 🔝 Cash Payment (COD) 👒
VIP Call Girls In Saharaganj ( Lucknow  ) 🔝 8923113531 🔝  Cash Payment (COD) 👒VIP Call Girls In Saharaganj ( Lucknow  ) 🔝 8923113531 🔝  Cash Payment (COD) 👒
VIP Call Girls In Saharaganj ( Lucknow ) 🔝 8923113531 🔝 Cash Payment (COD) 👒
 
Russian Call Girls In Gurgaon ❤️8448577510 ⊹Best Escorts Service In 24/7 Delh...
Russian Call Girls In Gurgaon ❤️8448577510 ⊹Best Escorts Service In 24/7 Delh...Russian Call Girls In Gurgaon ❤️8448577510 ⊹Best Escorts Service In 24/7 Delh...
Russian Call Girls In Gurgaon ❤️8448577510 ⊹Best Escorts Service In 24/7 Delh...
 
The Coffee Bean & Tea Leaf(CBTL), Business strategy case study
The Coffee Bean & Tea Leaf(CBTL), Business strategy case studyThe Coffee Bean & Tea Leaf(CBTL), Business strategy case study
The Coffee Bean & Tea Leaf(CBTL), Business strategy case study
 
It will be International Nurses' Day on 12 May
It will be International Nurses' Day on 12 MayIt will be International Nurses' Day on 12 May
It will be International Nurses' Day on 12 May
 
Forklift Operations: Safety through Cartoons
Forklift Operations: Safety through CartoonsForklift Operations: Safety through Cartoons
Forklift Operations: Safety through Cartoons
 
How to Get Started in Social Media for Art League City
How to Get Started in Social Media for Art League CityHow to Get Started in Social Media for Art League City
How to Get Started in Social Media for Art League City
 
0183760ssssssssssssssssssssssssssss00101011 (27).pdf
0183760ssssssssssssssssssssssssssss00101011 (27).pdf0183760ssssssssssssssssssssssssssss00101011 (27).pdf
0183760ssssssssssssssssssssssssssss00101011 (27).pdf
 
Mondelez State of Snacking and Future Trends 2023
Mondelez State of Snacking and Future Trends 2023Mondelez State of Snacking and Future Trends 2023
Mondelez State of Snacking and Future Trends 2023
 
Yaroslav Rozhankivskyy: Три складові і три передумови максимальної продуктивн...
Yaroslav Rozhankivskyy: Три складові і три передумови максимальної продуктивн...Yaroslav Rozhankivskyy: Три складові і три передумови максимальної продуктивн...
Yaroslav Rozhankivskyy: Три складові і три передумови максимальної продуктивн...
 
B.COM Unit – 4 ( CORPORATE SOCIAL RESPONSIBILITY ( CSR ).pptx
B.COM Unit – 4 ( CORPORATE SOCIAL RESPONSIBILITY ( CSR ).pptxB.COM Unit – 4 ( CORPORATE SOCIAL RESPONSIBILITY ( CSR ).pptx
B.COM Unit – 4 ( CORPORATE SOCIAL RESPONSIBILITY ( CSR ).pptx
 
Call Girls In DLf Gurgaon ➥99902@11544 ( Best price)100% Genuine Escort In 24...
Call Girls In DLf Gurgaon ➥99902@11544 ( Best price)100% Genuine Escort In 24...Call Girls In DLf Gurgaon ➥99902@11544 ( Best price)100% Genuine Escort In 24...
Call Girls In DLf Gurgaon ➥99902@11544 ( Best price)100% Genuine Escort In 24...
 
FULL ENJOY Call Girls In Mahipalpur Delhi Contact Us 8377877756
FULL ENJOY Call Girls In Mahipalpur Delhi Contact Us 8377877756FULL ENJOY Call Girls In Mahipalpur Delhi Contact Us 8377877756
FULL ENJOY Call Girls In Mahipalpur Delhi Contact Us 8377877756
 
Dr. Admir Softic_ presentation_Green Club_ENG.pdf
Dr. Admir Softic_ presentation_Green Club_ENG.pdfDr. Admir Softic_ presentation_Green Club_ENG.pdf
Dr. Admir Softic_ presentation_Green Club_ENG.pdf
 
Mysore Call Girls 8617370543 WhatsApp Number 24x7 Best Services
Mysore Call Girls 8617370543 WhatsApp Number 24x7 Best ServicesMysore Call Girls 8617370543 WhatsApp Number 24x7 Best Services
Mysore Call Girls 8617370543 WhatsApp Number 24x7 Best Services
 
VVVIP Call Girls In Greater Kailash ➡️ Delhi ➡️ 9999965857 🚀 No Advance 24HRS...
VVVIP Call Girls In Greater Kailash ➡️ Delhi ➡️ 9999965857 🚀 No Advance 24HRS...VVVIP Call Girls In Greater Kailash ➡️ Delhi ➡️ 9999965857 🚀 No Advance 24HRS...
VVVIP Call Girls In Greater Kailash ➡️ Delhi ➡️ 9999965857 🚀 No Advance 24HRS...
 
Monte Carlo simulation : Simulation using MCSM
Monte Carlo simulation : Simulation using MCSMMonte Carlo simulation : Simulation using MCSM
Monte Carlo simulation : Simulation using MCSM
 
Call Girls Pune Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Pune Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service AvailableCall Girls Pune Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Pune Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
 
Insurers' journeys to build a mastery in the IoT usage
Insurers' journeys to build a mastery in the IoT usageInsurers' journeys to build a mastery in the IoT usage
Insurers' journeys to build a mastery in the IoT usage
 
Call Girls Navi Mumbai Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Avail...
Call Girls Navi Mumbai Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Avail...Call Girls Navi Mumbai Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Avail...
Call Girls Navi Mumbai Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Avail...
 
Regression analysis: Simple Linear Regression Multiple Linear Regression
Regression analysis:  Simple Linear Regression Multiple Linear RegressionRegression analysis:  Simple Linear Regression Multiple Linear Regression
Regression analysis: Simple Linear Regression Multiple Linear Regression
 

Feed Overview July 25

  • 2. Purpose To provide an overview of the feed product Outcome A common understanding of the feed product
  • 3. Agenda What was the motivation? What are our objectives? What is the approach? What have we done so far? What are we doing now? What’s next?
  • 4. What was the motivation? Provide a consistent user experience across all CBC short-form content Faster, more frequent delivery of new product features to the audience based on their needs Reduce operational costs Reduce the number of digital products that require regular maintenance Leverage new technology so our products are more performant
  • 5. What are our objectives? 1. Evolvable user experience 2. Increase engagement 3. Increase retention 4. Increase reach 5. Increase revenue
  • 6. What is the approach? Responsive redesign of all CBC websites (apps are not included) Consistent user experience Agile/Lean startup User tests Iterative development
  • 7.
  • 8. What is the approach? Working in partnership with content areas and business units Regular check-ins for collaborative decision making and sharing of work in progress
  • 9.
  • 10. What is the approach? Separating content from presentation
  • 11. Stories Video Social Media Manage Content Distribute Deliver Experience The Feed Polopoly Ocelot MPX Content Aggregator Layer 7
  • 12. What have we done so far? Collected data Analyzed audience behaviour Conducted tests Released beta sites for Arts and News using Polopoly presentation Gathered feedback to inform the Feed product Built an internal demo site for the feed (http://feed.cbc.ca/)
  • 15. What are the most important things we’ve learned? Feedback forms Beta is clean, modern and readable Text size may be too big, especially for non-breaking headlines Some users find the beta site easy to navigate Some say it’s difficult to find News sections Requires a lot of scrolling Validation Board Density of the page Number of images displayed at the top of the page Ordering of links to drive engagement
  • 16. Quick results from randomized test Approximately 7,800 users were sent to each site. Users entered either beta or current state from the Canada landing page Survey ran for approximately 1.5 hours over the ET lunch hour U Texas capped the survey at 485 users in each site. Beta Current Beta (survey) Current (survey)
  • 17. What are we doing now? Ocelot development Gradual release to the public Content API development Demo site Navigation Testing Infrastructure setup for new development, QA and production environments
  • 18. What’s next? Release plan/timing End of July hidden production release Post-Olympics gradual rollout to all content areas that are using Polopoly Deprecation of old web products when the audience shows us they are engaged with the new product Demonstrate how the feed can support other objectives: Cross-promotion Launching new verticals Ad products (Native, viewability, video)

Notes de l'éditeur

  1. Intro the team and the room. The feed is a concept we are using to describe the layout of content on the page
  2. Feed was originally one of the four pillars of the digital strategy. When we started it was just a product. Over time it has evolved to encompass strategies for data, revenue, content, community, distribution, etc. The feed product we are working on is now just one small part of that.
  3. Consistent from a brand and product perspective. Right now we have many disparate digital products. Historically there are about 4 years between redesigns because we have so many things we are trying to maintain at once. When we want to update a feature, like share tools, we have to update each desktop site and mobile site separately.
  4. Engagement - 3 pages per visit Retention - come back 3 times per week Reach - 18 million Canadians
  5. Agile software development is a set of principles for software development in which requirements and solutions evolve through collaboration between self-organizing, cross-functional teams. The Lean Startup provides a scientific approach to creating and managing startups and get a desired product to customers' hands faster.
  6. Agile software development is a set of principles for software development in which requirements and solutions evolve through collaboration between self-organizing, cross-functional teams. The Lean Startup provides a scientific approach to creating and managing startups and get a desired product to customers' hands faster.
  7. Example of collaboration
  8. Agile software development is a set of principles for software development in which requirements and solutions evolve through collaboration between self-organizing, cross-functional teams. The Lean Startup provides a scientific approach to creating and managing startups and get a desired product to customers' hands faster.
  9. Traffic patterns, referral behaviour, path flows, use of navigation through guerilla testing, A/B testing.
  10. Aggregate of audience feedback.
  11. Our focus so far has been on Homepage, Arts, News, Sports and Radio. Everything else will likely come later. We need to do more testing and research to see what the best audience experience would be.