From the SMX West Conference in San Jose, California, March 1-3, 2016. SESSION: The Great Campaign Structure & Match Type Debate. PRESENTATION: Management Friendly Alpha-Beta - Given by Caitlin Halpert, @caitlin_halpert - 3Q Digital, Account Director. #SMX #23B
2. #SMX #23B @Caitlin_Halpert
How I’m going to win!!
• Why
are
we
having
this
debate?
Why?
• Alpha-‐Beta
defined
What?
• I
do
not
accept
your
misconceptions!
How?
5. #SMX #23B @Caitlin_Halpert
Alpha-Beta campaign structure
We
aim
for
query
control
through
exact
match,
single-‐keyword
ad
groups,
paired
with
broad/broad
modified
match
keywords,
and
exact
match
negatives
for
mapping
BETA
(query mining)
Broad and +BMM
ALPHA
(query sculpting)
[Exact]
6. #SMX #23B @Caitlin_Halpert
Single-keyword ad groups & negatives
Query Reports Alpha Campaign 1:1 Mappings
best query ever
stupid query
Performance negative
AG/KW: [best query ever] - [best query ever]
Negative in all beta
campaigns
Query
Keyword
Ad
Landing
Page
9. #SMX #23B @Caitlin_Halpert9
A Harte Hanks Company
Alpha-Beta gone wrong!
190 active campaigns in Google
346,536 Active Keywords
§ 85% are flagged as low search volume
§ 9% of active keywords are fully eligible
In the last 30 days:
§ 2% of keywords had more than 10 impressions
§ 37 keywords rendered conversions
10. #SMX #23B @Caitlin_Halpert
Ease management in 3 steps
Careful
keyword
selection
Aim
for
high
data-‐density
Review
&
update
keyword
lists
13. #SMX #23B @Caitlin_Halpert
Beta selection is just as important!
Betas
mine
new
queries
AND
roll-‐up
data
from
lower
volume
queries
that
will
never
be
promoted
to
alpha
For
any
variation
you’re
considering:
§ Is
there
search
volume
or
past
performance
to
show
that
there’s
sufficient
data?
Use
the
Keyword
Planner
§ Is
there
a
unique
landing
page?
If
resources
are
tight,
is
it
worth
the
investment?
§ Is
there
unique
messaging?
Will
that
additional
modifier
fit
in
the
ad
copy?
§ Are
you
further
segmenting
campaigns
(e.g.
geography)?
Use
fewer
betas
to
start
when
segmentation
is
required
If
the
product
falls
in
an
easy
to
identify
category,
keep
it
simple
and
have
catch-‐all
head
terms
to
start
14. #SMX #23B @Caitlin_Halpert
Copying
Alphas
is
lazy
§ [pink
dresses]
is
different
from
[dresses
pink]
§ +pink
+dresses
is
not
different
from
+dresses
+pink
For
type/product/theme
coverage,
start
with
the
site
as
a
guide,
but
minimize
variations
§ +cotton
+nurse
+uniform
–
YES
§ +pink
+nurse
+uniform
–
YES
§ +pink
+cotton
+nurse
+uniform
–
NO
Use your brain.
16. #SMX #23B @Caitlin_Halpert
Use Dynamic Search Ads!
Use
DSA
for
what
it’s
designed
for
–
ensuring
coverage
across
your
product
set
Use
DSA
to
find
new
Alphas
&
Betas
Outlier:
Certain
retailers
cannot
use
DSA
because
of
policy
reasons
so
an
automated
system
to
maintain
coverage
across
10,000+
SKUs
is
acceptable,
but
bidding
is
difficult
19. #SMX #23B @Caitlin_Halpert
Remove low search volume (LSV) keywords
LSV
keywords
are
not
serving
• Or,
not
serving
as
often
as
they
would
if
matched
to
higher-‐volume
keywords
LSV
keywords
are
a
waste
of
time
• Unique
ad
creation
is
a
large
time
investment
with
no
pay-‐off
LSV
keywords
change
over
time
• [gopro2
hd]
might
have
had
volume
3
years
ago,
but
it
doesn’t
now
–
CUT
IT
• [wine
Christmas
gifts]
only
has
volume
from
Nov
15th-‐Dec
25th
–
PAUSE
&
MARK
AS
SEASONAL
20. #SMX #23B @Caitlin_Halpert
Remove non-converting keywords
Some
keywords
are
logically
a
good
fit,
but
after
months
still
don’t
convert
§ Have
they
been
given
a
chance
(had
bids
above
first-‐page
recommendations)?
–
PAUSE
§ Is
there
search
volume,
but
CVR
is
too
low?
–
PAUSE
§ Is
search
volume
so
low
that
data-‐based
decisions
are
impossible?
–
PAUSE
There’s
a
difference
between
pausing
&
no
longer
serving
and
pausing
&
redirecting
queries
to
a
higher
volume
keyword
§ Understand
which
you’re
doing
but
know
there’s
little
risk
in
pausing
a
non-‐converter
that’s
had
it’s
chance
21. #SMX #23B @Caitlin_Halpert
Do these things!
• Top
performers
deserve
special
attention
• Set
up
for
long-‐term
query
sculpting
Alpha-‐Beta
SKAGs
• Keep
keywords
simple
–
it’s
easy
to
add
more
• Think
about
data-‐density
Selection
• Keep
Alpha-‐Beta
clean
with
negative
&
alpha
updates
• Remove
low-‐volume
&
non-‐converters
Maintenance
24. #SMX #23B @Caitlin_Halpert
What’s wrong with “keyword coverage”…
Query
/
Keyword
Max
CPC
Avg
Pos
Cost
Conv
CPA
Brand.com
$9013.76
2185
$4.13
[Brand.com]
$.80
1.0
$1978.16
470
$4.21
[Brand
misspelling
1]
$.80
1.0
$2009.61
526
$3.82
[Brand
misspelling
2]
$.80
1.0
$2093.21
492
$4.25
[Brand
misspelling
3]
$.80
1.0
$2063.74
445
$4.64
96%
of
the
spend
on
the
“misspelling”
Alphas
is
actually
from
the
correct
spelling
query
25. #SMX #23B @Caitlin_Halpert
What do SKAG ad group builds look like?
Campaign
Ad
Group
Keyword
Headline
Desc
Line
1
Desc
Line
2
Display
URL
Brand
-‐
Alpha
brand.com
[brand.com]
Brand.com
-‐
Official
Try
Our
New
Widgets
Today!
Best
Deal
Available
Now.
Brand.com
Brand
-‐
Beta
brand
name
+brand
+name
Brand
Name
-‐
Official
Try
Our
New
Widgets
Today!
Best
Deal
Available
Now.
Brand.com
Brand
-‐
Beta
brand.com
+brand.com
Brand.com
-‐
Official
Try
Our
New
Widgets
Today!
Best
Deal
Available
Now.
Brand.com
Non-‐Brand
-‐
Alpha
cool
product
[cool
product]
Buy
a
Cool
Product
Try
Our
Cool
Product
Today.
Best
Deal
Available
Now.
Brand.com/Cool-‐
Product
Non-‐Brand
-‐
Alpha
new
cool
product
[new
cool
product]
Buy
a
New
Cool
Product
Try
Our
New
Cool
Product
Today.
Best
Deal
Available
Now.
Brand.com/New-‐
Cool-‐Product
Non-‐Brand
-‐
Alpha
other
product
[other
product]
Buy
a
Other
Product
Try
Our
Other
Product
Today.
Best
Deal
Available
Now.
Brand.com/Other-‐
Product
Non-‐Brand
-‐
Beta
cool
product
+cool
+product
Buy
a
Cool
Product
Try
Our
Cool
Product
Today.
Best
Deal
Available
Now.
Brand.com/Cool-‐
Product
26. #SMX #23B @Caitlin_Halpert
• Performance
warrants
unique
keyword
–
corresponding
alpha
neg
will
fix
mapping
issues
Alpha
promotion
• When
problem
query
exists
as
an
alpha
Confirm
alpha
negatives
• Fixes
cross-‐matching
when
a
target
keyword
exists
&
term
does
not
qualify
for
alpha
promotion
Ad
group
level
negatives
• If
misspellings
or
alternative
keyword
variations
are
capturing
the
same
queries
as
other
keywords
Pause/remove
keywords
4 ways to fix bad mapping within Alpha-Beta