SlideShare une entreprise Scribd logo
1  sur  19
Project Delivery
Methods
By: StacyAbernathy
Three
Delivery
Methods
Design-Bid-Build
Design-Build
Integrated Project Delivery
Design-Bid-
Build
Owner
GCA/E
Advocating
for Progress
While studies show that alternative delivery systems
routinely result in safer, faster, lower cost and higher
quality projects, the vast majority of projects are still
delivered in the traditional Design-Bid-Build lump
sum manner with the designers and the builders
operating in separate silos and often pitted against
each other. Why? Political expediency! (p. 22)
Kenig, M., Allison, M., Black, B., Burdi, L., Colella, C., Davis, H., & Williams, M. (2010). Integrated project delivery
for public and private owners. National Association of State Facilities Administrators (NASFA), Construction Owners
Association of America (COAA), The Association of Higher Education Facilities Officers (APPA), Associated General
Contractors of America (AGC) and American Institute of Architects (AIA).
 lowest possible initial price as highest priority
 bidders look for future change orders in
contract document errors and ambiguities
 utilize lowest price subcontractors to increase
profit
 look for every opportunity to increase profit
during the project
Solving
D-B-B
Disadvantages
Design-Build
Owner C/A/E
Integrated
Project
Delivery
Owner
ConstructorsA/E
The rest of the
team
Owner
TectonA/E
Constructors
Constructors
Constructors
Constructors
Constructors
Constructors
I-P-D
Advantages
 clarify errors and ambiguity to eliminate
surprise change orders
 cover the entire scope at a fair price
 use lowest price qualified contractors to
protect owners
 look for every opportunity to create cost
savings
I-P-D
Early-in
Team
I-P-D
Early-in
Team
TheAdvantage
Community Schools of Frankfort
Compare
Design-Bid-Build Integrated Project
Delivery
2400 SF
800 SF DriveThru
$700,000
$300/SF
3888 SF
900SF DriveThru
$930,000
$240/SF
I-P-D
Mark-up
Reduction
CM
GC - 13%
GC Project Management
13%
13%
13%
13%
13%
13%
13%
13%
13%
13%
13%
13%
A/E
Subcontracts
or
Prime Contracts
Risk
D-B-B vs. I-P-D
Design-Bid-Build
buys all risk at the
outset
Integrated Project Delivery
eliminates risk where
possible and
micromanages
unavoidable risk
Risk
Management
 Design
 Scope creep
 Budget
 Schedule
 Site conditions
 Weather
 Bid document clarity
 Contractor qualifications
 Safety
 Labor
 Economy
Risk
Management
RiskManaged
RiskShifting
Savings
ProjectCost
I-P-D
Risk
Management
Example
ColdWeather Budget $50,000
Excavation $7,899
Blankets-Aggregate $2,271
Blankets-Concrete $3,648
Concrete Mix $959
Bottled Gas $2,928
Heaters $4,781
Electric hookup $795
Enclosures $10,286
Actual $33,567
I-P-D is the
TectonWay
The American Institute of Architects AIA defines IPD as “a
project delivery approach that integrates people, systems,
business structures, and practices into a process that
collaboratively harnesses the talents and insights of all
project participants to optimize project results, increase
value to the owner, reduce waste, and maximize efficiency
through all phases of design, fabrication, and construction”
AIA California Council 2007. (p. 816)
Kent, D.C., & Becerik-Gerber, B. (2010). Understanding construction industry experience and attitudes toward integrated
project delivery. Journal of construction engineering and management.
Always on time . . .
. .. alwaysunderbudget

Contenu connexe

Tendances

Build,Operate,Own,Transfer (BOOT)
Build,Operate,Own,Transfer (BOOT)Build,Operate,Own,Transfer (BOOT)
Build,Operate,Own,Transfer (BOOT)Mohd. Ikhwan
 
6 Alternative Construction Project Delivery Methods
6 Alternative Construction Project Delivery Methods6 Alternative Construction Project Delivery Methods
6 Alternative Construction Project Delivery MethodsMcCarthy Holdings, Inc.
 
Construction Project management
Construction Project management Construction Project management
Construction Project management Anupama holla
 
Construction Project Management
Construction Project ManagementConstruction Project Management
Construction Project ManagementAravind Samala
 
Construction Project Management
Construction Project Management Construction Project Management
Construction Project Management Rajat Nainwal
 
Project management in construction.
Project management in construction.Project management in construction.
Project management in construction.NAVNEET KUMAR JHA
 
construction contracts case study
construction contracts case studyconstruction contracts case study
construction contracts case studyMahSobeh
 
Construction Project Management Powerpoint Presentation Slides
Construction Project Management Powerpoint Presentation SlidesConstruction Project Management Powerpoint Presentation Slides
Construction Project Management Powerpoint Presentation SlidesSlideTeam
 
Construction contracts docuements_08092008
Construction contracts docuements_08092008Construction contracts docuements_08092008
Construction contracts docuements_08092008AYM1979
 
Project Management Process and Its Phases
Project Management Process and Its PhasesProject Management Process and Its Phases
Project Management Process and Its PhasesGaurav Sukhija
 
Construction project management
Construction project managementConstruction project management
Construction project managementsaif hasan
 
Construction Project Management
Construction Project ManagementConstruction Project Management
Construction Project Managementjohnkirth1898
 
Comparison of Design Bid Build vs. Design Build Finance Operate & Maintain
Comparison of Design Bid Build vs. Design Build Finance Operate & MaintainComparison of Design Bid Build vs. Design Build Finance Operate & Maintain
Comparison of Design Bid Build vs. Design Build Finance Operate & MaintainBob Prieto
 
Estimating seminar 1 slides
Estimating seminar 1 slidesEstimating seminar 1 slides
Estimating seminar 1 slidesDoreen Yeo
 
Build - Operate - Transfer
Build - Operate - TransferBuild - Operate - Transfer
Build - Operate - TransferKshitij Gupta
 
Construction Projects Feasibility studies
Construction Projects Feasibility studiesConstruction Projects Feasibility studies
Construction Projects Feasibility studiesSubhendu Datta
 
Civil Engineering Construction Proposal PowerPoint Presentation Slides
Civil Engineering Construction Proposal PowerPoint Presentation SlidesCivil Engineering Construction Proposal PowerPoint Presentation Slides
Civil Engineering Construction Proposal PowerPoint Presentation SlidesSlideTeam
 

Tendances (20)

Build,Operate,Own,Transfer (BOOT)
Build,Operate,Own,Transfer (BOOT)Build,Operate,Own,Transfer (BOOT)
Build,Operate,Own,Transfer (BOOT)
 
6 Alternative Construction Project Delivery Methods
6 Alternative Construction Project Delivery Methods6 Alternative Construction Project Delivery Methods
6 Alternative Construction Project Delivery Methods
 
Construction Project management
Construction Project management Construction Project management
Construction Project management
 
Construction Project Management
Construction Project ManagementConstruction Project Management
Construction Project Management
 
Construction Project Management
Construction Project Management Construction Project Management
Construction Project Management
 
Construction Cost Control
Construction Cost ControlConstruction Cost Control
Construction Cost Control
 
Project management in construction.
Project management in construction.Project management in construction.
Project management in construction.
 
construction contracts case study
construction contracts case studyconstruction contracts case study
construction contracts case study
 
Construction Project Management Powerpoint Presentation Slides
Construction Project Management Powerpoint Presentation SlidesConstruction Project Management Powerpoint Presentation Slides
Construction Project Management Powerpoint Presentation Slides
 
Construction contracts docuements_08092008
Construction contracts docuements_08092008Construction contracts docuements_08092008
Construction contracts docuements_08092008
 
Project Management Process and Its Phases
Project Management Process and Its PhasesProject Management Process and Its Phases
Project Management Process and Its Phases
 
Construction project management
Construction project managementConstruction project management
Construction project management
 
Project cost control
Project cost controlProject cost control
Project cost control
 
Construction Project Management
Construction Project ManagementConstruction Project Management
Construction Project Management
 
Fidic contracts management introduction
Fidic contracts management introductionFidic contracts management introduction
Fidic contracts management introduction
 
Comparison of Design Bid Build vs. Design Build Finance Operate & Maintain
Comparison of Design Bid Build vs. Design Build Finance Operate & MaintainComparison of Design Bid Build vs. Design Build Finance Operate & Maintain
Comparison of Design Bid Build vs. Design Build Finance Operate & Maintain
 
Estimating seminar 1 slides
Estimating seminar 1 slidesEstimating seminar 1 slides
Estimating seminar 1 slides
 
Build - Operate - Transfer
Build - Operate - TransferBuild - Operate - Transfer
Build - Operate - Transfer
 
Construction Projects Feasibility studies
Construction Projects Feasibility studiesConstruction Projects Feasibility studies
Construction Projects Feasibility studies
 
Civil Engineering Construction Proposal PowerPoint Presentation Slides
Civil Engineering Construction Proposal PowerPoint Presentation SlidesCivil Engineering Construction Proposal PowerPoint Presentation Slides
Civil Engineering Construction Proposal PowerPoint Presentation Slides
 

En vedette

Project delivery, what good looks like
Project delivery, what good looks likeProject delivery, what good looks like
Project delivery, what good looks likeMatthew Rees
 
Implementing a project delivery framework
Implementing a project delivery frameworkImplementing a project delivery framework
Implementing a project delivery frameworkJohn Napier
 
Construction Projects Delivery Methods - Nilaksh Kothari, Manitowoc Public Ut...
Construction Projects Delivery Methods - Nilaksh Kothari, Manitowoc Public Ut...Construction Projects Delivery Methods - Nilaksh Kothari, Manitowoc Public Ut...
Construction Projects Delivery Methods - Nilaksh Kothari, Manitowoc Public Ut...marcus evans Network
 
Flawless Project Delivery
Flawless Project DeliveryFlawless Project Delivery
Flawless Project DeliveryKen Ede
 
A text book of fluid mechanics and hydraulic machines dr. r. k. bansal
A text book of fluid mechanics and hydraulic machines   dr. r. k. bansalA text book of fluid mechanics and hydraulic machines   dr. r. k. bansal
A text book of fluid mechanics and hydraulic machines dr. r. k. bansalStefano Bianchini
 
TSL Construction Methods
TSL Construction MethodsTSL Construction Methods
TSL Construction Methodsunspawl
 
1. 441 intro to environmental engineering peng
1. 441 intro to environmental engineering peng1. 441 intro to environmental engineering peng
1. 441 intro to environmental engineering pengRichard Templin
 
Analytical comparision of BOT,BOOT and PPP models
 Analytical comparision of BOT,BOOT and PPP models Analytical comparision of BOT,BOOT and PPP models
Analytical comparision of BOT,BOOT and PPP modelsBhavin Sharma
 
Fluid mechanics and hydraulic machines by R.K.BANSAL
Fluid mechanics and hydraulic machines by R.K.BANSALFluid mechanics and hydraulic machines by R.K.BANSAL
Fluid mechanics and hydraulic machines by R.K.BANSALRavish Roy
 
Airpollution Dispersion And Modelling Using Computers Ub Chitranshi
Airpollution Dispersion And Modelling Using Computers  Ub ChitranshiAirpollution Dispersion And Modelling Using Computers  Ub Chitranshi
Airpollution Dispersion And Modelling Using Computers Ub ChitranshiKetan Wadodkar
 
Bot(build operate transfr)
Bot(build operate transfr)Bot(build operate transfr)
Bot(build operate transfr)Kritika Garg
 
Data-Centric Approach for Project Delivery
Data-Centric Approach for Project DeliveryData-Centric Approach for Project Delivery
Data-Centric Approach for Project DeliveryAVEVA Group plc
 
Moving To New AVEVA Technology
Moving To New AVEVA TechnologyMoving To New AVEVA Technology
Moving To New AVEVA TechnologyAVEVA Group plc
 
1 introduction to environmental engineering
1 introduction to environmental engineering1 introduction to environmental engineering
1 introduction to environmental engineeringMoudud Hasan
 

En vedette (20)

Project delivery, what good looks like
Project delivery, what good looks likeProject delivery, what good looks like
Project delivery, what good looks like
 
Implementing a project delivery framework
Implementing a project delivery frameworkImplementing a project delivery framework
Implementing a project delivery framework
 
Construction Projects Delivery Methods - Nilaksh Kothari, Manitowoc Public Ut...
Construction Projects Delivery Methods - Nilaksh Kothari, Manitowoc Public Ut...Construction Projects Delivery Methods - Nilaksh Kothari, Manitowoc Public Ut...
Construction Projects Delivery Methods - Nilaksh Kothari, Manitowoc Public Ut...
 
Flawless Project Delivery
Flawless Project DeliveryFlawless Project Delivery
Flawless Project Delivery
 
Midterm 2 guide
Midterm 2 guideMidterm 2 guide
Midterm 2 guide
 
A text book of fluid mechanics and hydraulic machines dr. r. k. bansal
A text book of fluid mechanics and hydraulic machines   dr. r. k. bansalA text book of fluid mechanics and hydraulic machines   dr. r. k. bansal
A text book of fluid mechanics and hydraulic machines dr. r. k. bansal
 
Air Pollution
Air Pollution Air Pollution
Air Pollution
 
TSL Construction Methods
TSL Construction MethodsTSL Construction Methods
TSL Construction Methods
 
Engineer in society
Engineer in societyEngineer in society
Engineer in society
 
1. 441 intro to environmental engineering peng
1. 441 intro to environmental engineering peng1. 441 intro to environmental engineering peng
1. 441 intro to environmental engineering peng
 
Analytical comparision of BOT,BOOT and PPP models
 Analytical comparision of BOT,BOOT and PPP models Analytical comparision of BOT,BOOT and PPP models
Analytical comparision of BOT,BOOT and PPP models
 
Fluid mechanics and hydraulic machines by R.K.BANSAL
Fluid mechanics and hydraulic machines by R.K.BANSALFluid mechanics and hydraulic machines by R.K.BANSAL
Fluid mechanics and hydraulic machines by R.K.BANSAL
 
Airpollution Dispersion And Modelling Using Computers Ub Chitranshi
Airpollution Dispersion And Modelling Using Computers  Ub ChitranshiAirpollution Dispersion And Modelling Using Computers  Ub Chitranshi
Airpollution Dispersion And Modelling Using Computers Ub Chitranshi
 
Bot(build operate transfr)
Bot(build operate transfr)Bot(build operate transfr)
Bot(build operate transfr)
 
Public Procurement and Contract - Theory and practice in Nepal_2013
Public Procurement and Contract - Theory and practice in Nepal_2013Public Procurement and Contract - Theory and practice in Nepal_2013
Public Procurement and Contract - Theory and practice in Nepal_2013
 
Data-Centric Approach for Project Delivery
Data-Centric Approach for Project DeliveryData-Centric Approach for Project Delivery
Data-Centric Approach for Project Delivery
 
Moving To New AVEVA Technology
Moving To New AVEVA TechnologyMoving To New AVEVA Technology
Moving To New AVEVA Technology
 
1 introduction to environmental engineering
1 introduction to environmental engineering1 introduction to environmental engineering
1 introduction to environmental engineering
 
Project Implementation
Project ImplementationProject Implementation
Project Implementation
 
Air Pollution
Air PollutionAir Pollution
Air Pollution
 

Similaire à Project Delivery Methods

Public Private Partnerships
Public Private PartnershipsPublic Private Partnerships
Public Private PartnershipsRussell Ash
 
CCDC-Boise-Parking-Structure-Design-Guidelines_2016-Final-Draft-08-04-2016.pdf
CCDC-Boise-Parking-Structure-Design-Guidelines_2016-Final-Draft-08-04-2016.pdfCCDC-Boise-Parking-Structure-Design-Guidelines_2016-Final-Draft-08-04-2016.pdf
CCDC-Boise-Parking-Structure-Design-Guidelines_2016-Final-Draft-08-04-2016.pdfChassyTesoro1
 
2016 McKinsey Tim McManus Managing big projects
2016 McKinsey Tim McManus Managing big projects2016 McKinsey Tim McManus Managing big projects
2016 McKinsey Tim McManus Managing big projectsTim McManus
 
Strategies in building procurement (summarized)
Strategies in building procurement (summarized)Strategies in building procurement (summarized)
Strategies in building procurement (summarized)Michael Audu
 
2010 uci douglas hospital team platinum award by bdc
2010 uci douglas hospital team platinum award by bdc2010 uci douglas hospital team platinum award by bdc
2010 uci douglas hospital team platinum award by bdcAvi Grigorescu
 
Performance evaluation of design build projects with and without agency const...
Performance evaluation of design build projects with and without agency const...Performance evaluation of design build projects with and without agency const...
Performance evaluation of design build projects with and without agency const...IAEME Publication
 
Performance evaluation of design build (d-b) projects
Performance evaluation of design build (d-b) projectsPerformance evaluation of design build (d-b) projects
Performance evaluation of design build (d-b) projectsiaemedu
 
Pounding the Pavement to Reduce GHG Emissions from Civil Remarks Fall 2016
Pounding the Pavement to Reduce GHG Emissions from Civil Remarks Fall 2016Pounding the Pavement to Reduce GHG Emissions from Civil Remarks Fall 2016
Pounding the Pavement to Reduce GHG Emissions from Civil Remarks Fall 2016David Choy
 
5 d conference smart built culture - october 2013 - short
5 d conference   smart built culture - october 2013 - short5 d conference   smart built culture - october 2013 - short
5 d conference smart built culture - october 2013 - shortJames Salmon
 
Contractor Supplier Roundtable Presentation
Contractor Supplier Roundtable PresentationContractor Supplier Roundtable Presentation
Contractor Supplier Roundtable Presentationcity of dania beach
 
CORE AIA Presentation
CORE AIA PresentationCORE AIA Presentation
CORE AIA Presentationcfiorilli
 
Handout_Delivery Methods.pdf
Handout_Delivery Methods.pdfHandout_Delivery Methods.pdf
Handout_Delivery Methods.pdfsarmedwahab
 
July 2015 Construct15_Richard Morwood_V4 (2)
July 2015 Construct15_Richard Morwood_V4 (2)July 2015 Construct15_Richard Morwood_V4 (2)
July 2015 Construct15_Richard Morwood_V4 (2)Richard Morwood
 

Similaire à Project Delivery Methods (20)

Mit1 040s09 lec18
Mit1 040s09 lec18Mit1 040s09 lec18
Mit1 040s09 lec18
 
Public Private Partnerships
Public Private PartnershipsPublic Private Partnerships
Public Private Partnerships
 
CCDC-Boise-Parking-Structure-Design-Guidelines_2016-Final-Draft-08-04-2016.pdf
CCDC-Boise-Parking-Structure-Design-Guidelines_2016-Final-Draft-08-04-2016.pdfCCDC-Boise-Parking-Structure-Design-Guidelines_2016-Final-Draft-08-04-2016.pdf
CCDC-Boise-Parking-Structure-Design-Guidelines_2016-Final-Draft-08-04-2016.pdf
 
2016 McKinsey Tim McManus Managing big projects
2016 McKinsey Tim McManus Managing big projects2016 McKinsey Tim McManus Managing big projects
2016 McKinsey Tim McManus Managing big projects
 
Strategies in building procurement (summarized)
Strategies in building procurement (summarized)Strategies in building procurement (summarized)
Strategies in building procurement (summarized)
 
2010 uci douglas hospital team platinum award by bdc
2010 uci douglas hospital team platinum award by bdc2010 uci douglas hospital team platinum award by bdc
2010 uci douglas hospital team platinum award by bdc
 
Performance evaluation of design build projects with and without agency const...
Performance evaluation of design build projects with and without agency const...Performance evaluation of design build projects with and without agency const...
Performance evaluation of design build projects with and without agency const...
 
Performance evaluation of design build (d-b) projects
Performance evaluation of design build (d-b) projectsPerformance evaluation of design build (d-b) projects
Performance evaluation of design build (d-b) projects
 
Procurement system
Procurement systemProcurement system
Procurement system
 
Pounding the Pavement to Reduce GHG Emissions from Civil Remarks Fall 2016
Pounding the Pavement to Reduce GHG Emissions from Civil Remarks Fall 2016Pounding the Pavement to Reduce GHG Emissions from Civil Remarks Fall 2016
Pounding the Pavement to Reduce GHG Emissions from Civil Remarks Fall 2016
 
5 d conference smart built culture - october 2013 - short
5 d conference   smart built culture - october 2013 - short5 d conference   smart built culture - october 2013 - short
5 d conference smart built culture - october 2013 - short
 
What has changed since the crash of 2008
What has changed since the crash of 2008What has changed since the crash of 2008
What has changed since the crash of 2008
 
Contractor Supplier Roundtable Presentation
Contractor Supplier Roundtable PresentationContractor Supplier Roundtable Presentation
Contractor Supplier Roundtable Presentation
 
Bridging Gt Apr09
Bridging Gt Apr09Bridging Gt Apr09
Bridging Gt Apr09
 
ASCE T&DI Abstract 40 - Final Paper
ASCE T&DI Abstract 40 - Final PaperASCE T&DI Abstract 40 - Final Paper
ASCE T&DI Abstract 40 - Final Paper
 
CORE AIA Presentation
CORE AIA PresentationCORE AIA Presentation
CORE AIA Presentation
 
Chap 1.pdf
Chap 1.pdfChap 1.pdf
Chap 1.pdf
 
Chap 1.pdf
Chap 1.pdfChap 1.pdf
Chap 1.pdf
 
Handout_Delivery Methods.pdf
Handout_Delivery Methods.pdfHandout_Delivery Methods.pdf
Handout_Delivery Methods.pdf
 
July 2015 Construct15_Richard Morwood_V4 (2)
July 2015 Construct15_Richard Morwood_V4 (2)July 2015 Construct15_Richard Morwood_V4 (2)
July 2015 Construct15_Richard Morwood_V4 (2)
 

Project Delivery Methods