SlideShare une entreprise Scribd logo
1  sur  7
Télécharger pour lire hors ligne
Nokia vs. Motorola
Suhail Attar
Pushpinderjit Singh
Dr. Raja Nag
May 08, 2014
Abstract.
In this project, we are calculating the Capital Gains Yield, the Dividends Yield, and
the Total Yield for Nokia and Motorola to illustrate how these two companies are
preforming financially. Those calculations are made from the Stock Prices and the
Dividends, which were allocated form the Bloomberg Terminal.
Introduction.
Before we talk about our findings and our research, let us get to know about what
these companies are how they are performing in the market.
Nokia.
 Headquarters in Finland.
 The company was founded in 1871 by Fredrik Idestam and Leo Mechelin.
 Nokia first entered the telecommunications equipment market in 1960 when an
electronics department was established at Finnish Cable Works to concentrate on
the production of radio-transmission equipment.
 One of the world's cutting-edge technology companies and until 2012 the world's
largest maker of cellphones—failed to adjust quickly enough to changes in how
people used their phones.
 Nokia is traded is NOK in New York Stock Exchange. (NYSE)
 Currently owned by Microsoft.
Motorola.
 Founded on September 25, 1928.
 Headquarters- Schaumburg, Illinois, United States.
 Motorola's wireless telephone handset division was a pioneer in cellular
telephones. Also known as the Personal Communication Sector (PCS) prior to
2004, it pioneered the "flip phone" with the MicroTAC.
 Motorola's handset division recorded a loss of $1.2 billion in the fourth quarter of
2007, while the company as a whole earned $100 million during that quarter.
 Its global market share has been on the decline; from 18.4% of the market in 2007
the company had a share of just 6.0% by Q1 2009.
 Motorola is traded is MSI in New York Stock Exchange. (NYSE)
 Currently owned by Google.
INDUSTRY OVERVIEW
While the telecommunications industry is more than a century old, the industry today
finds itself in the middle of a communications revolution as broadband and wireless
technologies radically transforming the industry. According to the recent study done by
the government agency, In the United States:
 The number of American wireless customers now exceeds 290 million, a penetration rate
of approximately 95 percent. According to a recent government study, 27 percent of U.S.
homes rely on cell phones only for voice services.
 With the wireless voice market at near saturation, the new major growth area for service
providers is data as more and more customers upgrade to smartphones with data service
plans. In addition, a new market is emerging for machine-to-machine wireless data
communications.
 In recent quarters, smartphones have made up for at least 40 percent of all new handset
sales. Approximately 31 percent of all wireless customers now have smartphones, and that
number is projected to grow to 67 percent by 2015.
 According to the Federal Communications Commission (FCC), high-speed wire line
Internet connections have flattened. Growth in the first half of 2010 was 1 percent,
totaling 82 million connections. Meanwhile, mobile broadband connections in the same
period grew by more than 27 percent to more than 71 million connections.
 Two-thirds of all Americans now have wire line-based broadband service at home,
according to the Pew Internet Project's August 2010 survey. That figure is an increase
from 2009 when 63 percent of Americans had a home wire line broadband connection.
The Financial Information.
(P) Stock Price, “The cost of purchasing a security on an exchange.” (InvestorWords)
(D) Dividends, “A dividend is a distribution of a portion of a company's earnings,
decided by the board of directors, to a class of its shareholders. Dividends can be issued
as cash payments, as shares of stock, or other property.” (Investopedia)
(CGY) Capital Gains Yield, “The price appreciation component of a security's (such
as a common stock) total return. For stock holdings, the capital gains yield will be the
change in price divided by the original (purchase) price.” (Investopedia)
(DY) Dividends Yield, “A financial ratio that indicates how much a company pays
out in dividends each year relative to its share price.” (Investopedia)
(TY) Total Yield, CGY + DY.
Motorola
2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013
P0 P1 P2 P3 P4 P5
$18.14 $31.78 $37.15 $46.29 $55.68 $67.50
D0 D1 D2 D3 D4 D5
$1.40 $0.35 $0 $0.22 $0.96 $1.14
DY1% DY2% DY3% DY4% DY5%
1.93 0.00 0.59 2.07 2.05
CGY1% CGY2% CGY3% CGY4% CGY5%
75.19 16.90 24.60 20.29 21.23
TY1% TY2% TY3% TY4% TY5%
77.12 16.90 25.20 22.36 23.28
Nokia
2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013
P0 P1 P2 P3 P4 P5
$15.67 $12.79 $10.27 $4.89 $3.87 $8.03
D0 D1 D2 D3 D4 D5
$0.59 $0.56 $0.53 $0.28 $0 $0
DY1% DY2% DY3% DY4% DY5%
3.57 4.14 2.73 0.00 0.00
CGY1% CGY2% CGY3% CGY4% CGY5%
-18.38 -19.70 -52.39 -20.86 107.49
It seems that Motorola have a better performance form the information regarding
its increasing stock prices which more than tripled during the years 2008 through 2013
which is possibly due to the purchase of Google to the company’s mobile division. This
resulted in a steady flow in the overall Capital Gain Yield Ratio expect for the year 2009
due to the high increase from $18.14 in 2008 to 31.78 in the year 2009. In the last three
years the company had an average CGY in the low twenties, which is a good indicator of
the good security of the company’s investment. Whereas, Nokia the very well-known
Finnish telecommunication company had a decreasing stock price over the years 2008
through the year 2012, but in the year 2013 the company had a considerable increase the
doubled its stock price, which could be very much due to the purchase of Microsoft to the
Mobile division of the company that benefited the company’s performance lately. In
regard to the Capital Gain Yield the company was not doing nearly good as Motorola
where it was resulting in negative percentages due to the decreasing stock prices but again
as mentioned the impact of Microsoft purchase have shown a significantly better result in
the CGY of the year 2013, that is resulting in a safe and secure investment.
In regards to the dividends, Motorola gives very low dividends compared to their
stock, but it is increasing from the last three years. The Dividends Yield reflects the
dividends policy of the company which are low but steady in the last two years, where it
would be a very unlikely to an investor interested in a high cash flow of his or her
investment, but likely for some who want a steady alternative. In the other side, Nokia’s
dividends are proportionally high with their stock prices, but it seems that they have
1.93 0.00 0.59 2.07 2.05
CGY1% CGY2% CGY3% CGY4% CGY5%
75.19 16.90 24.60 20.29 21.23
TY1% TY2% TY3% TY4% TY5%
77.12 16.90 25.20 22.36 23.28
Nokia
2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013
P0 P1 P2 P3 P4 P5
$15.67 $12.79 $10.27 $4.89 $3.87 $8.03
D0 D1 D2 D3 D4 D5
$0.59 $0.56 $0.53 $0.28 $0 $0
DY1% DY2% DY3% DY4% DY5%
3.57 4.14 2.73 0.00 0.00
CGY1% CGY2% CGY3% CGY4% CGY5%
-18.38 -19.70 -52.39 -20.86 107.49
TY1% TY2% TY3% TY4% TY5%
-14.81 -15.56 -49.66 -20.86 107.49
stopped giving it in the last two years, which resulted in a decreasing dividends amount
to zero in the last two years, which could be due to the new Management by Microsoft.
Their new dividends policy is reflected in their Dividends Yield ratio which shows that it
went up, down, and zero in the last two years. Unlike Motorola, this performance will be
very unlikely for those interested in a cash flow because it seems that there is none.
Citations
 "Our story." Nokia. N.p., n.d. Web. 8 May 2014.
<http://company.nokia.com/en/about-us/our-company/our-story>.
 "Company Profile." Investor Relations. N.p., n.d. Web. 8 May 2014.
<http://www.verizon.com/investor/industryoverview.htm>.
 "Manufacturing." - Motorola Solutions USA. N.p., n.d. Web. 8 May 2014.
<http://www.motorolasolutions.com/US-
EN/Business+Solutions/Industry+Solutions/Manufacturing>.
 "Nokia hangs on to second place in mobile-phone market - CNET." CNET. N.p.,
n.d. Web. 8 May 2014. <http://www.cnet.com/news/nokia-hangs-on-to-second-
place-in-mobile-phone-market/>.
 The Bloomberg Terminal.
 "Stock Price." What Is Stock Price? Definition and Meaning. Web. 14 Oct. 2015.
 "Dividend Definition | Investopedia." Investopedia. 25 Nov. 2003. Web. 14 Oct.
2015.
 "Capital Gains Yield Definition | Investopedia." Investopedia. 9 Nov. 2006. Web.
14 Oct. 2015.
 "Capital Gains Yield Definition | Investopedia." Investopedia. 9 Nov. 2006. Web.
14 Oct. 2015.
 "Capital Gains Yield Definition | Investopedia." Investopedia. 9 Nov. 2006. Web.
14 Oct. 2015.

Contenu connexe

Tendances

Deloitte Telecom Predictions 2010
Deloitte Telecom Predictions 2010Deloitte Telecom Predictions 2010
Deloitte Telecom Predictions 2010Plínio Okamoto
 
Deloitte Media Predictions 2010
Deloitte Media Predictions 2010Deloitte Media Predictions 2010
Deloitte Media Predictions 2010Plínio Okamoto
 
2010 Razorfish Outlook Report
2010 Razorfish Outlook Report2010 Razorfish Outlook Report
2010 Razorfish Outlook ReportRazorfish
 
Predictions for Digital 2012
Predictions for Digital 2012 Predictions for Digital 2012
Predictions for Digital 2012 Propel Executive
 
Propel Executive - Predictions for Digital 2012
Propel Executive - Predictions for Digital 2012Propel Executive - Predictions for Digital 2012
Propel Executive - Predictions for Digital 2012propellondon
 
Predictionsdigital2012slides 120213061416 Phpapp01
Predictionsdigital2012slides 120213061416 Phpapp01Predictionsdigital2012slides 120213061416 Phpapp01
Predictionsdigital2012slides 120213061416 Phpapp01kingbaldie
 
Pwc real-estate-2020-building-the-future
Pwc real-estate-2020-building-the-futurePwc real-estate-2020-building-the-future
Pwc real-estate-2020-building-the-futureThierry Labro
 
Technology, media and Telecommunications predictions for 2015
Technology, media and Telecommunications predictions for 2015Technology, media and Telecommunications predictions for 2015
Technology, media and Telecommunications predictions for 2015Thierry Labro
 
Deloitte Technology, Media and Telecommunications Predictions 2014
Deloitte Technology, Media and Telecommunications Predictions 2014Deloitte Technology, Media and Telecommunications Predictions 2014
Deloitte Technology, Media and Telecommunications Predictions 2014David Graham
 
Deloitte - TMT Öngörüleri 2014
Deloitte - TMT Öngörüleri 2014Deloitte - TMT Öngörüleri 2014
Deloitte - TMT Öngörüleri 2014Webrazzi
 
The State of TV Advertising by the Numbers
The State of TV Advertising by the NumbersThe State of TV Advertising by the Numbers
The State of TV Advertising by the NumbersActiveChannel
 
NGN Japan 2012-2017
NGN Japan 2012-2017NGN Japan 2012-2017
NGN Japan 2012-2017Kabir Ahmad
 
Deliotte: Media Predictions 2010
Deliotte: Media Predictions 2010Deliotte: Media Predictions 2010
Deliotte: Media Predictions 2010Jon Bradford
 
motorola 2000 Summary Annual Report (4.4 MB)
motorola 2000 Summary Annual Report (4.4 MB)motorola 2000 Summary Annual Report (4.4 MB)
motorola 2000 Summary Annual Report (4.4 MB)finance7
 
Ways to Change - Insight on How to Succeed in the Digital Future of Magazine ...
Ways to Change - Insight on How to Succeed in the Digital Future of Magazine ...Ways to Change - Insight on How to Succeed in the Digital Future of Magazine ...
Ways to Change - Insight on How to Succeed in the Digital Future of Magazine ...jackgriffinesa
 
Sector and insolvency review winter 2012
Sector and insolvency review winter 2012Sector and insolvency review winter 2012
Sector and insolvency review winter 2012Sarah Duggan
 

Tendances (19)

Deloitte Telecom Predictions 2010
Deloitte Telecom Predictions 2010Deloitte Telecom Predictions 2010
Deloitte Telecom Predictions 2010
 
Deloitte Media Predictions 2010
Deloitte Media Predictions 2010Deloitte Media Predictions 2010
Deloitte Media Predictions 2010
 
2010 Razorfish Outlook Report
2010 Razorfish Outlook Report2010 Razorfish Outlook Report
2010 Razorfish Outlook Report
 
Predictions for Digital 2012
Predictions for Digital 2012 Predictions for Digital 2012
Predictions for Digital 2012
 
Propel Executive - Predictions for Digital 2012
Propel Executive - Predictions for Digital 2012Propel Executive - Predictions for Digital 2012
Propel Executive - Predictions for Digital 2012
 
Predictionsdigital2012slides 120213061416 Phpapp01
Predictionsdigital2012slides 120213061416 Phpapp01Predictionsdigital2012slides 120213061416 Phpapp01
Predictionsdigital2012slides 120213061416 Phpapp01
 
61 Minutes AAEP 2010
61 Minutes AAEP 201061 Minutes AAEP 2010
61 Minutes AAEP 2010
 
Pwc real-estate-2020-building-the-future
Pwc real-estate-2020-building-the-futurePwc real-estate-2020-building-the-future
Pwc real-estate-2020-building-the-future
 
Technology, media and Telecommunications predictions for 2015
Technology, media and Telecommunications predictions for 2015Technology, media and Telecommunications predictions for 2015
Technology, media and Telecommunications predictions for 2015
 
Microsoft Power Point Johannison Final
Microsoft Power Point   Johannison FinalMicrosoft Power Point   Johannison Final
Microsoft Power Point Johannison Final
 
Deloitte Technology, Media and Telecommunications Predictions 2014
Deloitte Technology, Media and Telecommunications Predictions 2014Deloitte Technology, Media and Telecommunications Predictions 2014
Deloitte Technology, Media and Telecommunications Predictions 2014
 
Deloitte - TMT Öngörüleri 2014
Deloitte - TMT Öngörüleri 2014Deloitte - TMT Öngörüleri 2014
Deloitte - TMT Öngörüleri 2014
 
The State of TV Advertising by the Numbers
The State of TV Advertising by the NumbersThe State of TV Advertising by the Numbers
The State of TV Advertising by the Numbers
 
NGN Japan 2012-2017
NGN Japan 2012-2017NGN Japan 2012-2017
NGN Japan 2012-2017
 
Deliotte: Media Predictions 2010
Deliotte: Media Predictions 2010Deliotte: Media Predictions 2010
Deliotte: Media Predictions 2010
 
Issue+3+layouts+finalxx
Issue+3+layouts+finalxxIssue+3+layouts+finalxx
Issue+3+layouts+finalxx
 
motorola 2000 Summary Annual Report (4.4 MB)
motorola 2000 Summary Annual Report (4.4 MB)motorola 2000 Summary Annual Report (4.4 MB)
motorola 2000 Summary Annual Report (4.4 MB)
 
Ways to Change - Insight on How to Succeed in the Digital Future of Magazine ...
Ways to Change - Insight on How to Succeed in the Digital Future of Magazine ...Ways to Change - Insight on How to Succeed in the Digital Future of Magazine ...
Ways to Change - Insight on How to Succeed in the Digital Future of Magazine ...
 
Sector and insolvency review winter 2012
Sector and insolvency review winter 2012Sector and insolvency review winter 2012
Sector and insolvency review winter 2012
 

En vedette

Cola Wars: Coca-Cola vs.Pepsico
Cola Wars: Coca-Cola vs.PepsicoCola Wars: Coca-Cola vs.Pepsico
Cola Wars: Coca-Cola vs.PepsicoMarkadabra
 
Honda vs Toyota Business Strategy
Honda vs Toyota Business StrategyHonda vs Toyota Business Strategy
Honda vs Toyota Business StrategyGurvinder Baggan
 
CONSTRUCTION OF OVERHEAD BRIDGE
CONSTRUCTION OF OVERHEAD BRIDGECONSTRUCTION OF OVERHEAD BRIDGE
CONSTRUCTION OF OVERHEAD BRIDGEAnkit Gautam
 
competitve analysis of pepsi and coca cola
competitve analysis of pepsi and coca colacompetitve analysis of pepsi and coca cola
competitve analysis of pepsi and coca colaAvinash Kumar
 
CNG station construction project report.
CNG station construction project report.CNG station construction project report.
CNG station construction project report.Hagi Sahib
 
Internship Report
Internship ReportInternship Report
Internship ReportBala Murali
 
G+20 Corporate House Construction & Project Management.
G+20 Corporate House Construction & Project Management.G+20 Corporate House Construction & Project Management.
G+20 Corporate House Construction & Project Management.Neelay Khese
 
kfc vs macdonald world
kfc vs macdonald world kfc vs macdonald world
kfc vs macdonald world Karishma Shah
 
Samsung vs Nokia-Comparative Marketing Analysis
Samsung vs Nokia-Comparative Marketing AnalysisSamsung vs Nokia-Comparative Marketing Analysis
Samsung vs Nokia-Comparative Marketing AnalysisPinnakk Paul
 
Project Management Plan - Cafe Au Lait.PDF
Project Management Plan - Cafe Au Lait.PDFProject Management Plan - Cafe Au Lait.PDF
Project Management Plan - Cafe Au Lait.PDFGeoff Penhorwood
 
wedding ppt
wedding pptwedding ppt
wedding pptAPPLE29
 
Project on construction of 3 block house report
Project on construction of 3 block house reportProject on construction of 3 block house report
Project on construction of 3 block house reportHagi Sahib
 
Brand Rivalries: Pepsi Vs Coca- Cola-Cbse class 12 Entrepreneurship Project
Brand Rivalries: Pepsi Vs Coca- Cola-Cbse class 12 Entrepreneurship ProjectBrand Rivalries: Pepsi Vs Coca- Cola-Cbse class 12 Entrepreneurship Project
Brand Rivalries: Pepsi Vs Coca- Cola-Cbse class 12 Entrepreneurship ProjectDan John
 
Cafe construction project report
Cafe construction project reportCafe construction project report
Cafe construction project reportHagi Sahib
 
road construction project
road construction projectroad construction project
road construction projectnishant singh
 
project on construction of house report.
project on construction of house report.project on construction of house report.
project on construction of house report.Hagi Sahib
 
Business plan for Coffee Shop
Business plan for Coffee ShopBusiness plan for Coffee Shop
Business plan for Coffee ShopCochin University
 

En vedette (20)

Cola Wars: Coca-Cola vs.Pepsico
Cola Wars: Coca-Cola vs.PepsicoCola Wars: Coca-Cola vs.Pepsico
Cola Wars: Coca-Cola vs.Pepsico
 
bridge construction
bridge constructionbridge construction
bridge construction
 
Honda vs Toyota Business Strategy
Honda vs Toyota Business StrategyHonda vs Toyota Business Strategy
Honda vs Toyota Business Strategy
 
CONSTRUCTION OF OVERHEAD BRIDGE
CONSTRUCTION OF OVERHEAD BRIDGECONSTRUCTION OF OVERHEAD BRIDGE
CONSTRUCTION OF OVERHEAD BRIDGE
 
competitve analysis of pepsi and coca cola
competitve analysis of pepsi and coca colacompetitve analysis of pepsi and coca cola
competitve analysis of pepsi and coca cola
 
CNG station construction project report.
CNG station construction project report.CNG station construction project report.
CNG station construction project report.
 
Internship Report
Internship ReportInternship Report
Internship Report
 
G+20 Corporate House Construction & Project Management.
G+20 Corporate House Construction & Project Management.G+20 Corporate House Construction & Project Management.
G+20 Corporate House Construction & Project Management.
 
kfc vs macdonald world
kfc vs macdonald world kfc vs macdonald world
kfc vs macdonald world
 
Comparative Analysis Coca-Cola Vs Pepsi
Comparative Analysis Coca-Cola Vs PepsiComparative Analysis Coca-Cola Vs Pepsi
Comparative Analysis Coca-Cola Vs Pepsi
 
Samsung vs Nokia-Comparative Marketing Analysis
Samsung vs Nokia-Comparative Marketing AnalysisSamsung vs Nokia-Comparative Marketing Analysis
Samsung vs Nokia-Comparative Marketing Analysis
 
Project Management Plan - Cafe Au Lait.PDF
Project Management Plan - Cafe Au Lait.PDFProject Management Plan - Cafe Au Lait.PDF
Project Management Plan - Cafe Au Lait.PDF
 
wedding ppt
wedding pptwedding ppt
wedding ppt
 
Project on construction of 3 block house report
Project on construction of 3 block house reportProject on construction of 3 block house report
Project on construction of 3 block house report
 
Brand Rivalries: Pepsi Vs Coca- Cola-Cbse class 12 Entrepreneurship Project
Brand Rivalries: Pepsi Vs Coca- Cola-Cbse class 12 Entrepreneurship ProjectBrand Rivalries: Pepsi Vs Coca- Cola-Cbse class 12 Entrepreneurship Project
Brand Rivalries: Pepsi Vs Coca- Cola-Cbse class 12 Entrepreneurship Project
 
Cafe construction project report
Cafe construction project reportCafe construction project report
Cafe construction project report
 
road construction project
road construction projectroad construction project
road construction project
 
project on construction of house report.
project on construction of house report.project on construction of house report.
project on construction of house report.
 
Business plan for Coffee Shop
Business plan for Coffee ShopBusiness plan for Coffee Shop
Business plan for Coffee Shop
 
709302-PICM
709302-PICM709302-PICM
709302-PICM
 

Similaire à Nokia vs Motorola

Update on T-Mobile post Q3
Update on T-Mobile post Q3Update on T-Mobile post Q3
Update on T-Mobile post Q3thomas paulson
 
TMUS ICM November 2020 update 11.9.20
TMUS ICM November 2020 update 11.9.20TMUS ICM November 2020 update 11.9.20
TMUS ICM November 2020 update 11.9.20thomas paulson
 
Q3 2006 Earnings Release
Q3 2006 Earnings ReleaseQ3 2006 Earnings Release
Q3 2006 Earnings Releasefinance7
 
Q2 2006 Earnings Release
Q2 2006 Earnings ReleaseQ2 2006 Earnings Release
Q2 2006 Earnings Releasefinance7
 
Q1 2006 Earnings Release
Q1 2006 Earnings ReleaseQ1 2006 Earnings Release
Q1 2006 Earnings Releasefinance7
 
Q2 2005 Earnings Release
Q2 2005 Earnings ReleaseQ2 2005 Earnings Release
Q2 2005 Earnings Releasefinance7
 
Q4 2007 Earnings Press Release and Financial Tables
Q4 2007 Earnings Press Release and Financial TablesQ4 2007 Earnings Press Release and Financial Tables
Q4 2007 Earnings Press Release and Financial Tablesfinance7
 
Présentation des résultats financiers ST Ericsson (Q3 2010)
Présentation des résultats financiers ST Ericsson (Q3 2010)Présentation des résultats financiers ST Ericsson (Q3 2010)
Présentation des résultats financiers ST Ericsson (Q3 2010)Ericsson France
 
Q1 2008 Earnings Press Release and Financial Tables
Q1 2008 Earnings Press Release and Financial TablesQ1 2008 Earnings Press Release and Financial Tables
Q1 2008 Earnings Press Release and Financial Tablesfinance7
 
Q3 2005 Earnings Release
Q3 2005 Earnings ReleaseQ3 2005 Earnings Release
Q3 2005 Earnings Releasefinance7
 
Strategic management Nokia
Strategic management NokiaStrategic management Nokia
Strategic management NokiaMahesh Karane
 
Q1 2002 Earnings Release
Q1 2002 Earnings ReleaseQ1 2002 Earnings Release
Q1 2002 Earnings Releasefinance7
 
SPEEDA INSIGHTS_A Brief Glance at Japan's Mobile Communications Related Indus...
SPEEDA INSIGHTS_A Brief Glance at Japan's Mobile Communications Related Indus...SPEEDA INSIGHTS_A Brief Glance at Japan's Mobile Communications Related Indus...
SPEEDA INSIGHTS_A Brief Glance at Japan's Mobile Communications Related Indus...Kyna Tsai
 
MMV Webinar 4. Telco Perspectives. April 2018
MMV Webinar 4. Telco Perspectives. April 2018MMV Webinar 4. Telco Perspectives. April 2018
MMV Webinar 4. Telco Perspectives. April 2018Match-Maker Ventures
 
Q3 2007 Earnings Press Release and Financial Tables
Q3 2007 Earnings Press Release and Financial TablesQ3 2007 Earnings Press Release and Financial Tables
Q3 2007 Earnings Press Release and Financial Tablesfinance7
 
Telecom Italia 3Q 2012 Results – Operations – Marco Patuano
Telecom Italia 3Q 2012 Results – Operations – Marco PatuanoTelecom Italia 3Q 2012 Results – Operations – Marco Patuano
Telecom Italia 3Q 2012 Results – Operations – Marco PatuanoGruppo TIM
 
Q3 2003 Earnings Release
Q3 2003 Earnings ReleaseQ3 2003 Earnings Release
Q3 2003 Earnings Releasefinance7
 
International Finance
International Finance International Finance
International Finance Sheeza Asim
 

Similaire à Nokia vs Motorola (20)

Update on T-Mobile post Q3
Update on T-Mobile post Q3Update on T-Mobile post Q3
Update on T-Mobile post Q3
 
TMUS ICM November 2020 update 11.9.20
TMUS ICM November 2020 update 11.9.20TMUS ICM November 2020 update 11.9.20
TMUS ICM November 2020 update 11.9.20
 
Q3 2006 Earnings Release
Q3 2006 Earnings ReleaseQ3 2006 Earnings Release
Q3 2006 Earnings Release
 
Q2 2006 Earnings Release
Q2 2006 Earnings ReleaseQ2 2006 Earnings Release
Q2 2006 Earnings Release
 
Deloitte tmt predictions_2012
Deloitte tmt predictions_2012Deloitte tmt predictions_2012
Deloitte tmt predictions_2012
 
Q1 2006 Earnings Release
Q1 2006 Earnings ReleaseQ1 2006 Earnings Release
Q1 2006 Earnings Release
 
Q2 2005 Earnings Release
Q2 2005 Earnings ReleaseQ2 2005 Earnings Release
Q2 2005 Earnings Release
 
Q4 2007 Earnings Press Release and Financial Tables
Q4 2007 Earnings Press Release and Financial TablesQ4 2007 Earnings Press Release and Financial Tables
Q4 2007 Earnings Press Release and Financial Tables
 
Présentation des résultats financiers ST Ericsson (Q3 2010)
Présentation des résultats financiers ST Ericsson (Q3 2010)Présentation des résultats financiers ST Ericsson (Q3 2010)
Présentation des résultats financiers ST Ericsson (Q3 2010)
 
Q1 2008 Earnings Press Release and Financial Tables
Q1 2008 Earnings Press Release and Financial TablesQ1 2008 Earnings Press Release and Financial Tables
Q1 2008 Earnings Press Release and Financial Tables
 
Q3 2005 Earnings Release
Q3 2005 Earnings ReleaseQ3 2005 Earnings Release
Q3 2005 Earnings Release
 
Strategic management Nokia
Strategic management NokiaStrategic management Nokia
Strategic management Nokia
 
Q1 2002 Earnings Release
Q1 2002 Earnings ReleaseQ1 2002 Earnings Release
Q1 2002 Earnings Release
 
SPEEDA INSIGHTS_A Brief Glance at Japan's Mobile Communications Related Indus...
SPEEDA INSIGHTS_A Brief Glance at Japan's Mobile Communications Related Indus...SPEEDA INSIGHTS_A Brief Glance at Japan's Mobile Communications Related Indus...
SPEEDA INSIGHTS_A Brief Glance at Japan's Mobile Communications Related Indus...
 
MMV Webinar 4. Telco Perspectives. April 2018
MMV Webinar 4. Telco Perspectives. April 2018MMV Webinar 4. Telco Perspectives. April 2018
MMV Webinar 4. Telco Perspectives. April 2018
 
Q3 2007 Earnings Press Release and Financial Tables
Q3 2007 Earnings Press Release and Financial TablesQ3 2007 Earnings Press Release and Financial Tables
Q3 2007 Earnings Press Release and Financial Tables
 
Telecom Italia 3Q 2012 Results – Operations – Marco Patuano
Telecom Italia 3Q 2012 Results – Operations – Marco PatuanoTelecom Italia 3Q 2012 Results – Operations – Marco Patuano
Telecom Italia 3Q 2012 Results – Operations – Marco Patuano
 
Q3 2003 Earnings Release
Q3 2003 Earnings ReleaseQ3 2003 Earnings Release
Q3 2003 Earnings Release
 
International Finance
International Finance International Finance
International Finance
 
IF project
IF projectIF project
IF project
 

Nokia vs Motorola

  • 1. Nokia vs. Motorola Suhail Attar Pushpinderjit Singh Dr. Raja Nag May 08, 2014
  • 2. Abstract. In this project, we are calculating the Capital Gains Yield, the Dividends Yield, and the Total Yield for Nokia and Motorola to illustrate how these two companies are preforming financially. Those calculations are made from the Stock Prices and the Dividends, which were allocated form the Bloomberg Terminal. Introduction. Before we talk about our findings and our research, let us get to know about what these companies are how they are performing in the market. Nokia.  Headquarters in Finland.  The company was founded in 1871 by Fredrik Idestam and Leo Mechelin.  Nokia first entered the telecommunications equipment market in 1960 when an electronics department was established at Finnish Cable Works to concentrate on the production of radio-transmission equipment.  One of the world's cutting-edge technology companies and until 2012 the world's largest maker of cellphones—failed to adjust quickly enough to changes in how people used their phones.  Nokia is traded is NOK in New York Stock Exchange. (NYSE)  Currently owned by Microsoft. Motorola.  Founded on September 25, 1928.  Headquarters- Schaumburg, Illinois, United States.  Motorola's wireless telephone handset division was a pioneer in cellular telephones. Also known as the Personal Communication Sector (PCS) prior to 2004, it pioneered the "flip phone" with the MicroTAC.  Motorola's handset division recorded a loss of $1.2 billion in the fourth quarter of 2007, while the company as a whole earned $100 million during that quarter.
  • 3.  Its global market share has been on the decline; from 18.4% of the market in 2007 the company had a share of just 6.0% by Q1 2009.  Motorola is traded is MSI in New York Stock Exchange. (NYSE)  Currently owned by Google. INDUSTRY OVERVIEW While the telecommunications industry is more than a century old, the industry today finds itself in the middle of a communications revolution as broadband and wireless technologies radically transforming the industry. According to the recent study done by the government agency, In the United States:  The number of American wireless customers now exceeds 290 million, a penetration rate of approximately 95 percent. According to a recent government study, 27 percent of U.S. homes rely on cell phones only for voice services.  With the wireless voice market at near saturation, the new major growth area for service providers is data as more and more customers upgrade to smartphones with data service plans. In addition, a new market is emerging for machine-to-machine wireless data communications.  In recent quarters, smartphones have made up for at least 40 percent of all new handset sales. Approximately 31 percent of all wireless customers now have smartphones, and that number is projected to grow to 67 percent by 2015.  According to the Federal Communications Commission (FCC), high-speed wire line Internet connections have flattened. Growth in the first half of 2010 was 1 percent, totaling 82 million connections. Meanwhile, mobile broadband connections in the same period grew by more than 27 percent to more than 71 million connections.
  • 4.  Two-thirds of all Americans now have wire line-based broadband service at home, according to the Pew Internet Project's August 2010 survey. That figure is an increase from 2009 when 63 percent of Americans had a home wire line broadband connection. The Financial Information. (P) Stock Price, “The cost of purchasing a security on an exchange.” (InvestorWords) (D) Dividends, “A dividend is a distribution of a portion of a company's earnings, decided by the board of directors, to a class of its shareholders. Dividends can be issued as cash payments, as shares of stock, or other property.” (Investopedia) (CGY) Capital Gains Yield, “The price appreciation component of a security's (such as a common stock) total return. For stock holdings, the capital gains yield will be the change in price divided by the original (purchase) price.” (Investopedia) (DY) Dividends Yield, “A financial ratio that indicates how much a company pays out in dividends each year relative to its share price.” (Investopedia) (TY) Total Yield, CGY + DY. Motorola 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 P0 P1 P2 P3 P4 P5 $18.14 $31.78 $37.15 $46.29 $55.68 $67.50 D0 D1 D2 D3 D4 D5 $1.40 $0.35 $0 $0.22 $0.96 $1.14 DY1% DY2% DY3% DY4% DY5% 1.93 0.00 0.59 2.07 2.05 CGY1% CGY2% CGY3% CGY4% CGY5% 75.19 16.90 24.60 20.29 21.23 TY1% TY2% TY3% TY4% TY5% 77.12 16.90 25.20 22.36 23.28 Nokia 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 P0 P1 P2 P3 P4 P5 $15.67 $12.79 $10.27 $4.89 $3.87 $8.03 D0 D1 D2 D3 D4 D5 $0.59 $0.56 $0.53 $0.28 $0 $0 DY1% DY2% DY3% DY4% DY5% 3.57 4.14 2.73 0.00 0.00 CGY1% CGY2% CGY3% CGY4% CGY5% -18.38 -19.70 -52.39 -20.86 107.49
  • 5. It seems that Motorola have a better performance form the information regarding its increasing stock prices which more than tripled during the years 2008 through 2013 which is possibly due to the purchase of Google to the company’s mobile division. This resulted in a steady flow in the overall Capital Gain Yield Ratio expect for the year 2009 due to the high increase from $18.14 in 2008 to 31.78 in the year 2009. In the last three years the company had an average CGY in the low twenties, which is a good indicator of the good security of the company’s investment. Whereas, Nokia the very well-known Finnish telecommunication company had a decreasing stock price over the years 2008 through the year 2012, but in the year 2013 the company had a considerable increase the doubled its stock price, which could be very much due to the purchase of Microsoft to the Mobile division of the company that benefited the company’s performance lately. In regard to the Capital Gain Yield the company was not doing nearly good as Motorola where it was resulting in negative percentages due to the decreasing stock prices but again as mentioned the impact of Microsoft purchase have shown a significantly better result in the CGY of the year 2013, that is resulting in a safe and secure investment. In regards to the dividends, Motorola gives very low dividends compared to their stock, but it is increasing from the last three years. The Dividends Yield reflects the dividends policy of the company which are low but steady in the last two years, where it would be a very unlikely to an investor interested in a high cash flow of his or her investment, but likely for some who want a steady alternative. In the other side, Nokia’s dividends are proportionally high with their stock prices, but it seems that they have 1.93 0.00 0.59 2.07 2.05 CGY1% CGY2% CGY3% CGY4% CGY5% 75.19 16.90 24.60 20.29 21.23 TY1% TY2% TY3% TY4% TY5% 77.12 16.90 25.20 22.36 23.28 Nokia 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 P0 P1 P2 P3 P4 P5 $15.67 $12.79 $10.27 $4.89 $3.87 $8.03 D0 D1 D2 D3 D4 D5 $0.59 $0.56 $0.53 $0.28 $0 $0 DY1% DY2% DY3% DY4% DY5% 3.57 4.14 2.73 0.00 0.00 CGY1% CGY2% CGY3% CGY4% CGY5% -18.38 -19.70 -52.39 -20.86 107.49 TY1% TY2% TY3% TY4% TY5% -14.81 -15.56 -49.66 -20.86 107.49
  • 6. stopped giving it in the last two years, which resulted in a decreasing dividends amount to zero in the last two years, which could be due to the new Management by Microsoft. Their new dividends policy is reflected in their Dividends Yield ratio which shows that it went up, down, and zero in the last two years. Unlike Motorola, this performance will be very unlikely for those interested in a cash flow because it seems that there is none.
  • 7. Citations  "Our story." Nokia. N.p., n.d. Web. 8 May 2014. <http://company.nokia.com/en/about-us/our-company/our-story>.  "Company Profile." Investor Relations. N.p., n.d. Web. 8 May 2014. <http://www.verizon.com/investor/industryoverview.htm>.  "Manufacturing." - Motorola Solutions USA. N.p., n.d. Web. 8 May 2014. <http://www.motorolasolutions.com/US- EN/Business+Solutions/Industry+Solutions/Manufacturing>.  "Nokia hangs on to second place in mobile-phone market - CNET." CNET. N.p., n.d. Web. 8 May 2014. <http://www.cnet.com/news/nokia-hangs-on-to-second- place-in-mobile-phone-market/>.  The Bloomberg Terminal.  "Stock Price." What Is Stock Price? Definition and Meaning. Web. 14 Oct. 2015.  "Dividend Definition | Investopedia." Investopedia. 25 Nov. 2003. Web. 14 Oct. 2015.  "Capital Gains Yield Definition | Investopedia." Investopedia. 9 Nov. 2006. Web. 14 Oct. 2015.  "Capital Gains Yield Definition | Investopedia." Investopedia. 9 Nov. 2006. Web. 14 Oct. 2015.  "Capital Gains Yield Definition | Investopedia." Investopedia. 9 Nov. 2006. Web. 14 Oct. 2015.