#TCI2019 Break - out sessions: Presentation Evaluation Workshop
•Télécharger en tant que PPTX, PDF•
1 j'aime•103 vues
New emerging themes for Cluster evaluation and learning by Madeline Smith and Emily Wise
Recommandé
Recommandé
Contenu connexe
Tendances
Tendances (20)
Similaire à #TCI2019 Break - out sessions: Presentation Evaluation Workshop
Similaire à #TCI2019 Break - out sessions: Presentation Evaluation Workshop (20)
Plus de TCI Network
Plus de TCI Network (20)
Dernier
Dernier (20)
#TCI2019 Break - out sessions: Presentation Evaluation Workshop
- 1. New emerging themes for Cluster evaluation and learning October 2019 Madeline Smith, Emily Wise 16/10/2019
- 2. Cluster Evaluation Working Group The Story so far… 16/10/2019
- 3. 3 COLLABORATING TO IMPROVE PRACTICE • A forum for learning collectively around common, complex & important cluster evaluation challenges – Meeting twice a year since 2013 – Brought together over 100 people – Mix of academics, policy-makers, practitioners www.tci-network.org/evaluation Evidencing the value of cluster policy is only part of the question The bigger issue is how we can use evaluation to learn and do things better
- 4. 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 Workshop Forres TCI Conference Kolding TCI Conference Monterrey TCI Conference Eindhoven Workshop Belfast Workshop Rzeszow Workshop Barcelona TCI Conference Daegu Workshop Oslo TCI Conference Bogota 2018 Workshop Cork TCI Conference Toronto A long-run journey of collective learning 2019 Workshop Malmö
- 5. SOME KEY OUTPUTS • Booklet on Designing Cluster Evaluation (2014) • Perfect cluster evaluation framework (2016) • Principles to guide cluster evaluation (2016) • Set of firm-level survey questions aimed at capturing the human element of clusters (2016) • Poster & short paper presented at OECD Blue Sky Forum (2016) • Conference presentations (2018 - THC, RSA) • Evaluation Cases • Journal articles…. • Collected together on website: www.tci-network.org/evaluation
- 6. Emerging themes for exploration and evaluation learning • How can we use data more creatively? • How can we build a compelling case story? • How can these inform policy and leadership?
- 7. Discussion and Group Sharing 1. Two groups – one focusing on data, one on case stories 2. Data – using Vinnväxt cluster data as an example • interrogate the data • How could that feed into evaluation evidence and policy development • What analysis needed and any gaps? 3. Case stories for learning – using Scotland Food and Drink as an example • Quiz the evaluator • Gather the pieces of the story • Assemble into a narrative
- 8. Group Discussion • How do data and case studies cross over? • Informing leadership and policy • How can cluster leaders use this evidence? • How can this influence policy? • How to best communicate success
- 9. WG progress and plans • Ongoing working group activities and outputs • Website, social media and newsletter updates • Conferences – Kazan 2020 • Evaluation WG meeting 2020 in Italy • Evaluation WG meeting 2021 in Wales
- 10. Thank you James Wilson Research Director Orkestra Deusto Business School jwilson@orkestra.deusto.es Madeline Smith Head of Strategy, Innovation School The Glasgow School of Art m.smith@gsa.ac.uk Emily Wise Affiliated Research Fellow Research Policy Group Lund University emily.wise@fsi.lu.se