SlideShare une entreprise Scribd logo
1  sur  5
Impact Investment
 Portfolio Analysis


55% RE and RE Backed (21% impact)
   45% Securities (16% impact)
   Target = 25% impact by 2012
       50%+ impact by 2020
  First Impact Investment - 2004
International
                                        Microfinance
•   Microfinance – Global Diversified Fund
     –   MicroVest Fund 1, LP - www.microvestfund.com
           •   Debt/Equity Fund (80/20) – Founding Investor
           •   10% annual IRR since 2004 – 10 year closed end fund
           •   Additional CD investment, pays 3-4%
     –   MicroVest II LP
           •   Equity Fund, 2009, target 10+%
     –   MicroVest Short Duration Fund
           •   Target 2%
     –   Investment Committee / Board Seat


•   Microfinance – Direct Investment in MFI
     –   Micredito – Nicaragua – www.meda.org
           •   Direct Loan to MEDA sponsored MFI
           •   6% annual pay since 2005
           •   Short term bridge loan, 9% (repaid)
           •   Board Observer


     –   AMSA – Argentina
           •   Preferred Stock
           •   Under/non performing
International
                                    Private Equity
•   Emerging Market Private Equity Fund of Funds
     – Sarona Frontier Market Fund, LP – www.saronafund.com
          •   Founding Investor
          •   Target Return 12-15%
          •   Diversified, Global, Target companies that focus on demand of the rising lower/middle class
          •   Sector and/or Geographic focus
          •   Agriculture, Water, Health Care, Renewable Energy, Low Income Housing
          •   Board Chair – Assist in Due Diligence Process


•   Emerging Market Private Equity Fund
     – Sarona Risk Capital Fund – www.meda.org
          •   Global, Opportunistic Fund
          •   Provides seed capital for start-up of Impact Investment initiatives
          •   Latin America, Eastern Europe
          •   8% return since 2007


•   Individual Investments
     – Via Mennonite Economic Development Associates, managed by Sarona Asset Management
          •   Paraguay – Starch Processing Company; loan (6%)
          •   Paraguay – Sugar Cane Ethanol Plant ; equity
Domestic (US)
                    Community Development
•   Community Real Estate Investment Fund
     –   WCI Partners, LP www.wcipartners.com
     –   www.olduptownhbg.com
     –   Total return since 2005 (-5%) – slight underperformance vs similar RE nationally in time period
     –   Partnerships with PHFA, Commonwealth of PA
     –   Built 18 new market rate townhomes ($210k) on vacant ‘brownfield like’ land
     –   Renovated 100+ townhomes ($110-$210k)
     –   Transformed 4 square block area (320 tax parcels) from known drug area to leading neighborhood
     –   Added $15M value to city tax rolls
     –   Established neighborhood association
     –   Substitute city services in area of strained city budgets (street cleaning, security, sidewalks, street trees, banners, lawn
         care)
     –   Recognized as “best” city neighborhood, Historic Preservation Awards
     –   Jobs created 3 permanent, 15 ongoing construction since 2005, additional 10+ part time (doesn’t include mine – no
         pay)
     –   Managing partner


•   Real Estate Backed Loans
     –   Loan Portfolio backed by mortgages on homes in “target” area
     –   Yields: various, blended 5.5%
     –   Essential support for early stages of project due to lack of appraisal values, first time home buyers, etc
     –   0 loss rate since 2005
Impact Investment
               Principals and Observations
•   Match Investment with Values
•   Provide/Demand Risk Adjusted Market Rate Returns
•   Achieve/Seek Discreet, Measurable Goals
•   Impact has met/outperformed traditional since 2004 (for this portfolio)

US Investments
• more difficult due to transaction costs, competition, other market capital
• Risk of free rider problem (reduced return by 10-15% - “cost” over $1M)

International Market – strong opportunities for return and impact
• Seek diversity, strong, local, engaged management
• Consider “Fund of Funds” or Sector Focused Funds
• Individual (one-off) investments very risky – unlikely to scale profitably
• Ensure local interests/managers aligned with global investors
• Consider opportunity for Board involvement, travel

Three Principals of Impact Investing: Success/Vision/Humility
1.    Success: come with real investment (not charity) $$
2.    Vision: come with the ability to see beyond your traditional financial advisor
3.    Humility: perhaps most importantly, unless your name is Gates – don’t expect to do it all yourself
      or break new ground, join with others already doing good things and help to make them better –
      be like Buffet, for example

Contenu connexe

Tendances

ESO Capital - NOAH15 Berlin
ESO Capital - NOAH15 BerlinESO Capital - NOAH15 Berlin
ESO Capital - NOAH15 BerlinNOAH Advisors
 
Hub Overview 2009
Hub Overview 2009Hub Overview 2009
Hub Overview 2009amie2007
 
Sidonie Gwet, CGC - Developing a green finance facility to catalyse private i...
Sidonie Gwet, CGC - Developing a green finance facility to catalyse private i...Sidonie Gwet, CGC - Developing a green finance facility to catalyse private i...
Sidonie Gwet, CGC - Developing a green finance facility to catalyse private i...OECD Environment
 
Angel Investor View on ASEAN Common Fund for Startup
Angel Investor View on ASEAN Common Fund for StartupAngel Investor View on ASEAN Common Fund for Startup
Angel Investor View on ASEAN Common Fund for StartupGoutama Bachtiar
 
Julie wake sib newcastle roadshow event presentation
Julie wake sib newcastle roadshow event presentationJulie wake sib newcastle roadshow event presentation
Julie wake sib newcastle roadshow event presentationalphacoop
 
Exploring New Opportunities and Diversification Strategies in Alternative Inv...
Exploring New Opportunities and Diversification Strategies in Alternative Inv...Exploring New Opportunities and Diversification Strategies in Alternative Inv...
Exploring New Opportunities and Diversification Strategies in Alternative Inv...Investments Network marcus evans
 
The Benefits of Hedge Fund Investing
The Benefits of Hedge Fund InvestingThe Benefits of Hedge Fund Investing
The Benefits of Hedge Fund InvestingHedgeFundFundamentals
 
Michigan Energy Forum - June 7, 2012 - Jeff Bocan
Michigan Energy Forum - June 7, 2012 -  Jeff Bocan Michigan Energy Forum - June 7, 2012 -  Jeff Bocan
Michigan Energy Forum - June 7, 2012 - Jeff Bocan AnnArborSPARK
 
2C – SOCIAL INVESTMENT
2C – SOCIAL INVESTMENT2C – SOCIAL INVESTMENT
2C – SOCIAL INVESTMENTCFG
 
Faber capital profile (july 16)
Faber capital profile (july 16)Faber capital profile (july 16)
Faber capital profile (july 16)Keshav Rathi.
 
Naat bat louisville, ky 07 sep 2011 - 11 09 05 ep
Naat bat louisville, ky   07 sep 2011 - 11 09 05 epNaat bat louisville, ky   07 sep 2011 - 11 09 05 ep
Naat bat louisville, ky 07 sep 2011 - 11 09 05 epEmmanuel Pouliquen
 
UIT: 101 Webinar
UIT: 101 WebinarUIT: 101 Webinar
UIT: 101 WebinarNICSA
 
Sustainable Land Use Funds – Althelia Ecosphere
Sustainable Land Use Funds – Althelia Ecosphere Sustainable Land Use Funds – Althelia Ecosphere
Sustainable Land Use Funds – Althelia Ecosphere CIFOR-ICRAF
 
Blended finance for beginners : a simplified framework
Blended finance for beginners : a simplified frameworkBlended finance for beginners : a simplified framework
Blended finance for beginners : a simplified frameworkIRC
 
Blendedfinancepresentation
BlendedfinancepresentationBlendedfinancepresentation
BlendedfinancepresentationVictor Snyders
 
Thuja presentation bio business summer school 2015
Thuja presentation bio business summer school 2015Thuja presentation bio business summer school 2015
Thuja presentation bio business summer school 2015Thuja Capital
 
Triodos bank mark ogden 26 6 13
Triodos bank mark ogden 26 6 13Triodos bank mark ogden 26 6 13
Triodos bank mark ogden 26 6 13HACThousing
 

Tendances (20)

ESO Capital - NOAH15 Berlin
ESO Capital - NOAH15 BerlinESO Capital - NOAH15 Berlin
ESO Capital - NOAH15 Berlin
 
Hub Overview 2009
Hub Overview 2009Hub Overview 2009
Hub Overview 2009
 
Sidonie Gwet, CGC - Developing a green finance facility to catalyse private i...
Sidonie Gwet, CGC - Developing a green finance facility to catalyse private i...Sidonie Gwet, CGC - Developing a green finance facility to catalyse private i...
Sidonie Gwet, CGC - Developing a green finance facility to catalyse private i...
 
Resume CDAM
Resume CDAMResume CDAM
Resume CDAM
 
Angel Investor View on ASEAN Common Fund for Startup
Angel Investor View on ASEAN Common Fund for StartupAngel Investor View on ASEAN Common Fund for Startup
Angel Investor View on ASEAN Common Fund for Startup
 
Julie wake sib newcastle roadshow event presentation
Julie wake sib newcastle roadshow event presentationJulie wake sib newcastle roadshow event presentation
Julie wake sib newcastle roadshow event presentation
 
Exploring New Opportunities and Diversification Strategies in Alternative Inv...
Exploring New Opportunities and Diversification Strategies in Alternative Inv...Exploring New Opportunities and Diversification Strategies in Alternative Inv...
Exploring New Opportunities and Diversification Strategies in Alternative Inv...
 
The Benefits of Hedge Fund Investing
The Benefits of Hedge Fund InvestingThe Benefits of Hedge Fund Investing
The Benefits of Hedge Fund Investing
 
Seed_money.pdf
Seed_money.pdfSeed_money.pdf
Seed_money.pdf
 
G Fundraising
G FundraisingG Fundraising
G Fundraising
 
Michigan Energy Forum - June 7, 2012 - Jeff Bocan
Michigan Energy Forum - June 7, 2012 -  Jeff Bocan Michigan Energy Forum - June 7, 2012 -  Jeff Bocan
Michigan Energy Forum - June 7, 2012 - Jeff Bocan
 
2C – SOCIAL INVESTMENT
2C – SOCIAL INVESTMENT2C – SOCIAL INVESTMENT
2C – SOCIAL INVESTMENT
 
Faber capital profile (july 16)
Faber capital profile (july 16)Faber capital profile (july 16)
Faber capital profile (july 16)
 
Naat bat louisville, ky 07 sep 2011 - 11 09 05 ep
Naat bat louisville, ky   07 sep 2011 - 11 09 05 epNaat bat louisville, ky   07 sep 2011 - 11 09 05 ep
Naat bat louisville, ky 07 sep 2011 - 11 09 05 ep
 
UIT: 101 Webinar
UIT: 101 WebinarUIT: 101 Webinar
UIT: 101 Webinar
 
Sustainable Land Use Funds – Althelia Ecosphere
Sustainable Land Use Funds – Althelia Ecosphere Sustainable Land Use Funds – Althelia Ecosphere
Sustainable Land Use Funds – Althelia Ecosphere
 
Blended finance for beginners : a simplified framework
Blended finance for beginners : a simplified frameworkBlended finance for beginners : a simplified framework
Blended finance for beginners : a simplified framework
 
Blendedfinancepresentation
BlendedfinancepresentationBlendedfinancepresentation
Blendedfinancepresentation
 
Thuja presentation bio business summer school 2015
Thuja presentation bio business summer school 2015Thuja presentation bio business summer school 2015
Thuja presentation bio business summer school 2015
 
Triodos bank mark ogden 26 6 13
Triodos bank mark ogden 26 6 13Triodos bank mark ogden 26 6 13
Triodos bank mark ogden 26 6 13
 

En vedette

Making The Market: Social Venture Fund
Making The Market: Social Venture FundMaking The Market: Social Venture Fund
Making The Market: Social Venture FundTakeAction
 
Pythagorean theorem and distance formula
Pythagorean theorem and distance formulaPythagorean theorem and distance formula
Pythagorean theorem and distance formuladavio95
 
Building a Portfolio & Executing a Strategy
Building a Portfolio & Executing a StrategyBuilding a Portfolio & Executing a Strategy
Building a Portfolio & Executing a StrategyTakeAction
 
Easy Things You Can Do To Have An Impact
Easy Things You Can Do To Have An ImpactEasy Things You Can Do To Have An Impact
Easy Things You Can Do To Have An ImpactTakeAction
 

En vedette (7)

Futbol
FutbolFutbol
Futbol
 
Making The Market: Social Venture Fund
Making The Market: Social Venture FundMaking The Market: Social Venture Fund
Making The Market: Social Venture Fund
 
Futbol sala
Futbol salaFutbol sala
Futbol sala
 
Series y tablas_futbol
Series y tablas_futbolSeries y tablas_futbol
Series y tablas_futbol
 
Pythagorean theorem and distance formula
Pythagorean theorem and distance formulaPythagorean theorem and distance formula
Pythagorean theorem and distance formula
 
Building a Portfolio & Executing a Strategy
Building a Portfolio & Executing a StrategyBuilding a Portfolio & Executing a Strategy
Building a Portfolio & Executing a Strategy
 
Easy Things You Can Do To Have An Impact
Easy Things You Can Do To Have An ImpactEasy Things You Can Do To Have An Impact
Easy Things You Can Do To Have An Impact
 

Similaire à Hartzler

International Microfinance
International MicrofinanceInternational Microfinance
International MicrofinanceTakeAction
 
Rockefeller Foundaton Impact Investment Overview | Brinda Gaugly (@Refresh 20...
Rockefeller Foundaton Impact Investment Overview | Brinda Gaugly (@Refresh 20...Rockefeller Foundaton Impact Investment Overview | Brinda Gaugly (@Refresh 20...
Rockefeller Foundaton Impact Investment Overview | Brinda Gaugly (@Refresh 20...ideaport
 
Smallholder and SME Investment Finance (SIF) Fund
Smallholder and SME Investment Finance (SIF) FundSmallholder and SME Investment Finance (SIF) Fund
Smallholder and SME Investment Finance (SIF) FundExternalEvents
 
Microfinance Investment: Due Diligence for Financial and Social Return
Microfinance Investment: Due Diligence for Financial and Social ReturnMicrofinance Investment: Due Diligence for Financial and Social Return
Microfinance Investment: Due Diligence for Financial and Social ReturnTakeAction
 
Presentation Small and Medium Agribusinesses Development Fund
Presentation Small and Medium Agribusinesses Development FundPresentation Small and Medium Agribusinesses Development Fund
Presentation Small and Medium Agribusinesses Development FundFrancois Stepman
 
Introduction To Venture Capital 9229 (5)
Introduction To Venture Capital 9229 (5)Introduction To Venture Capital 9229 (5)
Introduction To Venture Capital 9229 (5)Arnab Mukherjee
 
Renewable Energy Project Financing
Renewable Energy Project Financing Renewable Energy Project Financing
Renewable Energy Project Financing ACX
 
SVMN October 2007 Meeting - Calvert Foundation & eBay Microplace (Shari Beren...
SVMN October 2007 Meeting - Calvert Foundation & eBay Microplace (Shari Beren...SVMN October 2007 Meeting - Calvert Foundation & eBay Microplace (Shari Beren...
SVMN October 2007 Meeting - Calvert Foundation & eBay Microplace (Shari Beren...Dave McClure
 
Climate Finance and Voluntary Carbon Markets
Climate Finance and Voluntary Carbon MarketsClimate Finance and Voluntary Carbon Markets
Climate Finance and Voluntary Carbon MarketsACX
 
Impact Investing and Conservation Enterprise
Impact Investing and Conservation EnterpriseImpact Investing and Conservation Enterprise
Impact Investing and Conservation EnterpriseThe Long Run
 
EQUITYMULTIPLE Investor Intro
EQUITYMULTIPLE Investor IntroEQUITYMULTIPLE Investor Intro
EQUITYMULTIPLE Investor IntroSoren Godbersen
 
SDGs and the Future of Development Finance: Go Big, or Go Home
SDGs and the Future of Development Finance: Go Big, or Go HomeSDGs and the Future of Development Finance: Go Big, or Go Home
SDGs and the Future of Development Finance: Go Big, or Go HomeQueena Li
 
Dimension Mill Annual Presentation
Dimension Mill Annual PresentationDimension Mill Annual Presentation
Dimension Mill Annual PresentationDimension Mill
 
Accelerating Impact Impact Investing & Innovative Financing for Development
Accelerating Impact Impact Investing & Innovative Financing for DevelopmentAccelerating Impact Impact Investing & Innovative Financing for Development
Accelerating Impact Impact Investing & Innovative Financing for DevelopmentKarim Harji
 

Similaire à Hartzler (20)

International Microfinance
International MicrofinanceInternational Microfinance
International Microfinance
 
Rockefeller Foundaton Impact Investment Overview | Brinda Gaugly (@Refresh 20...
Rockefeller Foundaton Impact Investment Overview | Brinda Gaugly (@Refresh 20...Rockefeller Foundaton Impact Investment Overview | Brinda Gaugly (@Refresh 20...
Rockefeller Foundaton Impact Investment Overview | Brinda Gaugly (@Refresh 20...
 
Smallholder and SME Investment Finance (SIF) Fund
Smallholder and SME Investment Finance (SIF) FundSmallholder and SME Investment Finance (SIF) Fund
Smallholder and SME Investment Finance (SIF) Fund
 
Microfinance Investment: Due Diligence for Financial and Social Return
Microfinance Investment: Due Diligence for Financial and Social ReturnMicrofinance Investment: Due Diligence for Financial and Social Return
Microfinance Investment: Due Diligence for Financial and Social Return
 
Presentation Small and Medium Agribusinesses Development Fund
Presentation Small and Medium Agribusinesses Development FundPresentation Small and Medium Agribusinesses Development Fund
Presentation Small and Medium Agribusinesses Development Fund
 
Introduction To Venture Capital 9229 (5)
Introduction To Venture Capital 9229 (5)Introduction To Venture Capital 9229 (5)
Introduction To Venture Capital 9229 (5)
 
Mig gig first draft
Mig gig first draftMig gig first draft
Mig gig first draft
 
Renewable Energy Project Financing
Renewable Energy Project Financing Renewable Energy Project Financing
Renewable Energy Project Financing
 
SVMN October 2007 Meeting - Calvert Foundation & eBay Microplace (Shari Beren...
SVMN October 2007 Meeting - Calvert Foundation & eBay Microplace (Shari Beren...SVMN October 2007 Meeting - Calvert Foundation & eBay Microplace (Shari Beren...
SVMN October 2007 Meeting - Calvert Foundation & eBay Microplace (Shari Beren...
 
Final ppt ifc1st fase
Final ppt ifc1st faseFinal ppt ifc1st fase
Final ppt ifc1st fase
 
Climate Finance and Voluntary Carbon Markets
Climate Finance and Voluntary Carbon MarketsClimate Finance and Voluntary Carbon Markets
Climate Finance and Voluntary Carbon Markets
 
Impact Investing and Conservation Enterprise
Impact Investing and Conservation EnterpriseImpact Investing and Conservation Enterprise
Impact Investing and Conservation Enterprise
 
EQUITYMULTIPLE Investor Intro
EQUITYMULTIPLE Investor IntroEQUITYMULTIPLE Investor Intro
EQUITYMULTIPLE Investor Intro
 
Workshop 3 - Adam Kiel and Leigh Whelpton
Workshop 3 - Adam Kiel and Leigh WhelptonWorkshop 3 - Adam Kiel and Leigh Whelpton
Workshop 3 - Adam Kiel and Leigh Whelpton
 
SDGs and the Future of Development Finance: Go Big, or Go Home
SDGs and the Future of Development Finance: Go Big, or Go HomeSDGs and the Future of Development Finance: Go Big, or Go Home
SDGs and the Future of Development Finance: Go Big, or Go Home
 
Dimension Mill Annual Presentation
Dimension Mill Annual PresentationDimension Mill Annual Presentation
Dimension Mill Annual Presentation
 
Accelerating Impact Impact Investing & Innovative Financing for Development
Accelerating Impact Impact Investing & Innovative Financing for DevelopmentAccelerating Impact Impact Investing & Innovative Financing for Development
Accelerating Impact Impact Investing & Innovative Financing for Development
 
Okan Presentation
Okan PresentationOkan Presentation
Okan Presentation
 
Alhuda CIBE -Case Study for Microfinance Sector by Salman Syed Ali
Alhuda CIBE -Case Study for Microfinance Sector by Salman Syed AliAlhuda CIBE -Case Study for Microfinance Sector by Salman Syed Ali
Alhuda CIBE -Case Study for Microfinance Sector by Salman Syed Ali
 
Unleash the 95% copy
Unleash the 95% copyUnleash the 95% copy
Unleash the 95% copy
 

Plus de TakeAction

ICEF Public Schools
ICEF Public SchoolsICEF Public Schools
ICEF Public SchoolsTakeAction
 
Fixed Income Structuring Panel
Fixed Income Structuring PanelFixed Income Structuring Panel
Fixed Income Structuring PanelTakeAction
 
A Fiduciary's Approach to Impact Investing
A Fiduciary's Approach to Impact InvestingA Fiduciary's Approach to Impact Investing
A Fiduciary's Approach to Impact InvestingTakeAction
 
Due Diligence: Food Systems
Due Diligence: Food SystemsDue Diligence: Food Systems
Due Diligence: Food SystemsTakeAction
 
Getting to Yes: Strategy, Tactics & Governance
Getting to Yes: Strategy, Tactics & GovernanceGetting to Yes: Strategy, Tactics & Governance
Getting to Yes: Strategy, Tactics & GovernanceTakeAction
 
Getting to Yes: Strategy, Tactics & Governance
Getting to Yes: Strategy, Tactics & GovernanceGetting to Yes: Strategy, Tactics & Governance
Getting to Yes: Strategy, Tactics & GovernanceTakeAction
 
The Intersection of Innovation & Investments
The Intersection of Innovation & InvestmentsThe Intersection of Innovation & Investments
The Intersection of Innovation & InvestmentsTakeAction
 
International Microfinance
International MicrofinanceInternational Microfinance
International MicrofinanceTakeAction
 
Impact Investing History
Impact Investing HistoryImpact Investing History
Impact Investing HistoryTakeAction
 
Articulating Mission & Values
Articulating Mission & ValuesArticulating Mission & Values
Articulating Mission & ValuesTakeAction
 
blue moon fund
blue moon fundblue moon fund
blue moon fundTakeAction
 
Ways of Utilizing Financial Resources - The “Spectrum”
Ways of Utilizing Financial Resources - The “Spectrum”Ways of Utilizing Financial Resources - The “Spectrum”
Ways of Utilizing Financial Resources - The “Spectrum”TakeAction
 
Gray Ghost Ventures
Gray Ghost VenturesGray Ghost Ventures
Gray Ghost VenturesTakeAction
 
Meals with Integrity
Meals with IntegrityMeals with Integrity
Meals with IntegrityTakeAction
 
APG and Sustainability
APG and SustainabilityAPG and Sustainability
APG and SustainabilityTakeAction
 

Plus de TakeAction (17)

ICEF Public Schools
ICEF Public SchoolsICEF Public Schools
ICEF Public Schools
 
Fixed Income Structuring Panel
Fixed Income Structuring PanelFixed Income Structuring Panel
Fixed Income Structuring Panel
 
A Fiduciary's Approach to Impact Investing
A Fiduciary's Approach to Impact InvestingA Fiduciary's Approach to Impact Investing
A Fiduciary's Approach to Impact Investing
 
Due Diligence: Food Systems
Due Diligence: Food SystemsDue Diligence: Food Systems
Due Diligence: Food Systems
 
Getting to Yes: Strategy, Tactics & Governance
Getting to Yes: Strategy, Tactics & GovernanceGetting to Yes: Strategy, Tactics & Governance
Getting to Yes: Strategy, Tactics & Governance
 
Getting to Yes: Strategy, Tactics & Governance
Getting to Yes: Strategy, Tactics & GovernanceGetting to Yes: Strategy, Tactics & Governance
Getting to Yes: Strategy, Tactics & Governance
 
The Intersection of Innovation & Investments
The Intersection of Innovation & InvestmentsThe Intersection of Innovation & Investments
The Intersection of Innovation & Investments
 
Healthcare
HealthcareHealthcare
Healthcare
 
International Microfinance
International MicrofinanceInternational Microfinance
International Microfinance
 
Impact Investing History
Impact Investing HistoryImpact Investing History
Impact Investing History
 
Articulating Mission & Values
Articulating Mission & ValuesArticulating Mission & Values
Articulating Mission & Values
 
blue moon fund
blue moon fundblue moon fund
blue moon fund
 
Ways of Utilizing Financial Resources - The “Spectrum”
Ways of Utilizing Financial Resources - The “Spectrum”Ways of Utilizing Financial Resources - The “Spectrum”
Ways of Utilizing Financial Resources - The “Spectrum”
 
Gray Ghost Ventures
Gray Ghost VenturesGray Ghost Ventures
Gray Ghost Ventures
 
Take Action!
Take Action!Take Action!
Take Action!
 
Meals with Integrity
Meals with IntegrityMeals with Integrity
Meals with Integrity
 
APG and Sustainability
APG and SustainabilityAPG and Sustainability
APG and Sustainability
 

Hartzler

  • 1. Impact Investment Portfolio Analysis 55% RE and RE Backed (21% impact) 45% Securities (16% impact) Target = 25% impact by 2012 50%+ impact by 2020 First Impact Investment - 2004
  • 2. International Microfinance • Microfinance – Global Diversified Fund – MicroVest Fund 1, LP - www.microvestfund.com • Debt/Equity Fund (80/20) – Founding Investor • 10% annual IRR since 2004 – 10 year closed end fund • Additional CD investment, pays 3-4% – MicroVest II LP • Equity Fund, 2009, target 10+% – MicroVest Short Duration Fund • Target 2% – Investment Committee / Board Seat • Microfinance – Direct Investment in MFI – Micredito – Nicaragua – www.meda.org • Direct Loan to MEDA sponsored MFI • 6% annual pay since 2005 • Short term bridge loan, 9% (repaid) • Board Observer – AMSA – Argentina • Preferred Stock • Under/non performing
  • 3. International Private Equity • Emerging Market Private Equity Fund of Funds – Sarona Frontier Market Fund, LP – www.saronafund.com • Founding Investor • Target Return 12-15% • Diversified, Global, Target companies that focus on demand of the rising lower/middle class • Sector and/or Geographic focus • Agriculture, Water, Health Care, Renewable Energy, Low Income Housing • Board Chair – Assist in Due Diligence Process • Emerging Market Private Equity Fund – Sarona Risk Capital Fund – www.meda.org • Global, Opportunistic Fund • Provides seed capital for start-up of Impact Investment initiatives • Latin America, Eastern Europe • 8% return since 2007 • Individual Investments – Via Mennonite Economic Development Associates, managed by Sarona Asset Management • Paraguay – Starch Processing Company; loan (6%) • Paraguay – Sugar Cane Ethanol Plant ; equity
  • 4. Domestic (US) Community Development • Community Real Estate Investment Fund – WCI Partners, LP www.wcipartners.com – www.olduptownhbg.com – Total return since 2005 (-5%) – slight underperformance vs similar RE nationally in time period – Partnerships with PHFA, Commonwealth of PA – Built 18 new market rate townhomes ($210k) on vacant ‘brownfield like’ land – Renovated 100+ townhomes ($110-$210k) – Transformed 4 square block area (320 tax parcels) from known drug area to leading neighborhood – Added $15M value to city tax rolls – Established neighborhood association – Substitute city services in area of strained city budgets (street cleaning, security, sidewalks, street trees, banners, lawn care) – Recognized as “best” city neighborhood, Historic Preservation Awards – Jobs created 3 permanent, 15 ongoing construction since 2005, additional 10+ part time (doesn’t include mine – no pay) – Managing partner • Real Estate Backed Loans – Loan Portfolio backed by mortgages on homes in “target” area – Yields: various, blended 5.5% – Essential support for early stages of project due to lack of appraisal values, first time home buyers, etc – 0 loss rate since 2005
  • 5. Impact Investment Principals and Observations • Match Investment with Values • Provide/Demand Risk Adjusted Market Rate Returns • Achieve/Seek Discreet, Measurable Goals • Impact has met/outperformed traditional since 2004 (for this portfolio) US Investments • more difficult due to transaction costs, competition, other market capital • Risk of free rider problem (reduced return by 10-15% - “cost” over $1M) International Market – strong opportunities for return and impact • Seek diversity, strong, local, engaged management • Consider “Fund of Funds” or Sector Focused Funds • Individual (one-off) investments very risky – unlikely to scale profitably • Ensure local interests/managers aligned with global investors • Consider opportunity for Board involvement, travel Three Principals of Impact Investing: Success/Vision/Humility 1. Success: come with real investment (not charity) $$ 2. Vision: come with the ability to see beyond your traditional financial advisor 3. Humility: perhaps most importantly, unless your name is Gates – don’t expect to do it all yourself or break new ground, join with others already doing good things and help to make them better – be like Buffet, for example