3. ‘Reviewing the Provision of Education
for young people in Detention:
Rights, Research and Reflections
on Policy and Practice’
4. Rationale
to identify the rights for children and young people in custody to
education in Northern Ireland;
to analyse and review the legal and policy provisions for the educational
needs of children and young people in custody;
to highlight research evidence and data in relation to the voice and
educational experiences of young people in custody and identify gaps in
existing provision;
to explore new strategies of providing education in custody and make
recommendations for policy development and implementation.
5. Current arrangements fall short of international
standards
Although progress has been made arrangements fall short of
international standards.
Provision of education remains problematic.
Provision of well-co-ordinated education, training and support is
fundamental to address offending and prepare young people for re-
integration to the community.
Young people not taught in line with the NI Curriculum.
In some circumstances young people not receiving adequate training to
prepare them for release.
Overuse of custodial remand and undue delay in youth justice system.
6. Need for Improved co-ordination and information
Poor transmission of key information and lack of continuity between
custodial-based education and provision in the wider community.
Whilst there has been some progress in this area, evidence indicates
that it is still not fully realised in practice.
There have been consistent calls for joint collaboration between
relevant government departments, agencies and community
organisations.
Consideration should be given to statutory guidance with
comprehensive provisions for children and young people in a youth
custody setting.
Welsh Assembly Government (2011) Learning for children and young
people in a youth custody setting in Wales: Statutory guidance for local
authorities in Wales.
7. Collaborative Partnerships are critical to improve
re-integration
A collaborative approach between youth custody settings and external
agencies can support young people during and after their time in
detention.
Education or work-based placement on release can be a significant
deterrent for reoffending.
The lack of access to and support in securing such placements post
custody can have a detrimental effect on successful re-integration.
There is a need to develop external relationships, for example, with
further education and work-based learning suppliers to make it easier
for young people leaving custody to reintegrate into mainstream
education and training.
Also requires strong support structures to be put in place including
those for family support.
8. Data Collection can be improved
Quality information and research that produce policy relevant
knowledge are crucial to inform policy.
Good progress has been made in recent years.
Difficulties remain with existing data on education in custody. Lack of
information or portfolio about educational gains made in custody.
There is a need for comprehensive data systems, particularly
longitudinal and disaggregated data on young people in custody; data
on re-offending and pathways and outcomes post release.
Need for longitudinal data which goes ‘Back to the Future’.
9. Dedicated Training and pedagogical approaches can
improve outcomes for Children and Young People
Children in custody are rights holders and not merely recipients of penal
care.
Role of professionals can influence the experiences of young people
and equip them with learning and skills to reintegrate into society.
There are deficits in child rights training for staff in places of detention
for young people in Northern Ireland.
Deficits remain in training on the complex and rehabilitative needs of
young people in custody.
Alternative approaches to education can help re-engage young people
who are disaffected and improve teaching quality.
Innovative pedagogy and technology can be used to improve learning.