Thematic workshop Lazio

1. This project has received funding from the European Union’s Horizon 2020 research and innovation programme under grant agreement no
764717. The sole responsibility for the content of this presentation lies with its author and in no way reflects the views of the European Union.
Principali risultati del Progetto WinWind
Laura Gaetana Giuffrida
Elena De Luca
STAV-VALTEC

2.  Obiettivi del Progetto WinWind
 Strumenti per il coinvolgimento degli stakeholder
 Desk nazionale e Desk tematici
 Risultati e prossime azioni
Principali risultati del Progetto

3. Scheda del progetto Europeo WinWind
PQ EU R&I
“Winning social acceptance for wind energy in wind energy scarce regions”
 Germania
 NorvegiaPartner
Horizon 2020
 Italia
 Spagna
 Polonia
 Lettonia
Coordinatore Univ. Freie Berlino - Environmental Policy
Research Centre - Berlino
Durata 30 mesi (1/10/2017- 31/3/2020)
Responsabili per Italia  ENEA  Ecoazioni S.n.C.

4.  Caratterizzazione delle aree territoriali oggetto di indagine, con
focus sull’accettabilità sociale;
 Classificazione delle barriere/soluzioni e selezione di buone pratiche
trasferibili in altri contesti territoriali;
 Messa a punto di Linee guida, strumenti e raccomandazioni di
supporto al processo decisionale a tutti livelli di «governance».
Progetto europeo WinWind: obiettivi
Messa a punto di una metodologia di riferimento per favorire
uno sviluppo del mercato dell’eolico onshore sostenibile e
socialmente inclusivo con processi partecipativi di confronto.

5. Regioni target oggetto di indagine
Country Germany Italy Latvia Norway Poland Spain
Wind gross electricity penetration
(2014) 9.1% 5,4% 2,7% 1,7% 4,8% 19%
Wind power capacity (kW) per
1,000 inhabitants (2015) 554 147 35 106 134 496
Wind Energy Scarce Regions
WESR Thuringia, Saxony Abruzzo Latium
almost the whole
country Mid-Norway
Warmian-Masurian
Voivodeship Balearic Islands
Wind energy rich Regions
Schleswig-Holstein,
Brandenburg Apulia, Sardinia
Northern Vidzeme
Biosphere Reserve Fosen District City of Kisielice Canary Islands
Data for 2015; Sources: EurObserv’ER 2016, European Commission (2016a), figures for Norway
provided by NVE.
Le regioni target sono oggetto di analisi e confronto con altre esperienze dove la
tecnologia eolica ha avuto una forte diffusione

6. Eolico e regioni target: alcuni dati
Potenza eolica installata totale: 9766 MW
(5.579 impianti eolici)
Sardegna
Lazio Puglia
Abruzzi
2015:Target EU 2020 già raggiunto (17,5% dei CFL)
2030: SEN 2017 Target: 28% dei CFL e 55% dei CFL elettrici
2030: Nuova RED fissa un nuovo target del 32%
2018: :PNEC 30% dei CFL e 55,4% dei CFL elettrici.
2020: Competitività costi delle FER anno di svolta (IRENA, IEA)
Fonte: Terna, 2017
Lazio
0.5%
Abruzzi
2.4%
Sardegna
10%
Puglia
25%
Sicilia
19%Resto
d'Italia
43%

7. Struttura e fasi del Progetto
Management&Coordination
Comunication&Disimination
PolicyLessons;
GuidingPrinciplesandcriterias
WP 6
NationalDesks&Stakoldersdialogue
Germany Italy Latvia PolandNorway Spain
WP 2 Literature analysis Technical socio-
economic parameters
Taxonomy of barriers &
drivers
Best practice analysis
& synthesis
WP 5
Best practice
transfert
Validation of Best
practice
WP 4 Best practice portfolio
Best practice
Identification
Learning
laboratories
WP 3

8. This project has received funding from the European Union’s Horizon 2020 research and innovation programme under grant agreement no
764717. The sole responsibility for the content of this presentation lies with its author and in no way reflects the views of the European Union.
ITALIA: coinvolgimento degli STK
Matrice stakeholder
Questionario
on-line
Tecniche
Focus Group
Primo screening
(Long list: 80 STK)
Analisi/Selezione
(Short list: 40 STK)
Diverse modalità di coinvolgimento
(Desk National, Thematic workshop,
Field visit, dedicated stakeholder
consultation, policy Rountable ..)
Individuazione di
temi specifici
Elaborazione
di report da
condividere
WP 3

9. Desk Nazionale Italia
Roma, 23 Febbraio - ENEA Sede Legale
• The point of wiew of the institutional representative in the field of energy
• Presentation of WinWind, presentation of questionnaire results
• Focus group on critical factors and good practices link to social acceptance
How many and who attended it?
Research 19.7%
Market actors
10.6%
Associations and
other interest
groups 9.1%
Professionals
and
practitioners
4.5%
Public
Authorities 7.6%
Number of STK 34

10. Primo Meeting Tematico in Abruzzo
Pescara, 19 Giugno 2018
• The point of wiew of the regional representative in the field of energy
• Presentation of WinWind, presentation of questionnaire results
• Presentation of main protected areas issues and the territorial context
• Presentation of the Best Practice: Wind farm repowering in Abruzzo
• Focus group on landscape and visual impacts, tourism issues and wind
and environmental integration
%
How many and who attended it?
Number of STK: 25

11. Field visit in Sardegna
Sassari-Alghero-PortoTorres June 2018
• Area of interest with highest density of wind
farms
• Main issues of acceptability focus on the
landscape/visual impact
but …… being the wind farms mainly near of
industrial areas, those seem to be considered as
perceived impacts …..

12. Eventi e attività condotte dai partner WinWind
Germany
Italy Latvia Norway Poland Spain
Kick-off meeting
11 January 2018
Berlin
Kick-off meeting
23 February 2018
Rome
Kick-off meeting
30 November 2017
Riga
Kick-off meeting
23 January 2018
Oslo
Kick-off meeting
22 February 2018
Warsaw
Stakeholder questionnaires
1 February – 30 March 2018 Online
/ Email
1st Thematic workshop
Instruments for acceptance
raising
20 June 2018
Leipzig
Stakeholder consultation
February 2018 - Ongoing
Online
1st Thematic workshop
Onshore Wind Energy
21 June 2018
Riga
1st Desk meeting
Barriers and drivers of WE in
Norway
14 August 2018
Arendal
Follow up meetings
6 March, 15 March, 12 April
2018
Warsaw
Kick-off meeting in the target
region
24 April 2018
Palma de Mallorca
2nd Thematic workshop
Wind energy in forests
18 October 2018
Erfurt
Targeted stakeholder
interviews
15-16 June 2018
Sardinia
2nd Thematic workshop
Policy planning documents
6 November 2018
Riga
1st Thematic workshop
Minority rights and WE
11 October 2018
Afjord
Questionnaire for
stakeholders
March-June 2018
Online/via-emails
Speech at Greening the Islands
Conference
Showcasing WinWind
22 May 2018
Menorca
3rd Thematic workshop and
policy roundtable
Financial participation & planning
10 December 2018
Potsdam
1st Thematic workshop
Landscape & wind energy
19 June 2018
Pescara
Meeting with WFOŚiGW
Good practice measures
21 May 2018
Olsztyn
Stakeholder meeting
WE in Menorca
11 June 2018
Menorca
Online stakeholder survey
Social acceptance barriers and
drivers
March – July 2019
Online
2nd Thematic workshop
Benefits & incentives for local
communities
December 2018
Rome
1st Thematic workshop
Barriers & Motivations
November 2018
lsztyn
1st Thematic workshop
Wind energy and protected areas
8 November 2018
Menorca

13. Progetto WinWind: risultati raggiunti
• Coinvolgimento di oltre 500 stakeholder
• Individuazione delle criticità e soluzioni pertinenti
alle diverse realtà territoriali (context specific)
• Individuazione e descrizione di 40 Best Practice (es.
Istituzione di servizi ad hoc, WF Repowering)
• Individuazione di criteri per la selezione delle Best
practice (10 casi studi)

14. Progetto WinWind:
un approccio integrato
• Identificazioni di barriere e soluzioni nelle tre
dimensioni: Ambientale – Economica- Sociale
Approccio integrato
Coinvolgimento delle comunità in
ogni fase del processo di
implementazione degli impianti
Soluzioni flessibili specifiche che
valorizzano l’economia locale
Meccanismi di
condivisione dei
benefici
Informazione
ai cittadini sui
regolamenti e
linee guide
Cooperazione
tra DSO e
Comunità
energetiche
Promozione di
Comunità
energetiche
Una VIA
integrata e
aperta ai soggetti
interessati

15. 10 Buone Pratiche selezionate
Novel participatory
models and mechanisms
in planning and
permitting procedures
Measures addressing
direct and indirect
financial participation of
communities and citizens
Measures addressing
distributional justice and
promotion of regional
co-benefits
Measures to reduce
environmental impacts
of wind energy
Measures enhancing
communication and
building of institutional
structures including
voluntary agreements
and industry self-
commitment
Multi measures
approach
Germany
Community wind park
and civic non-profit
association in the
municipality of
Neuenkirchen
(Schleswig-Holstein)
Service Unit Wind Energy
and Quality label for
project developers in
Thuringia
Italy *Rivoli Veronese bond
Tax cuts and landscape
commitment in Tula
Municipality, Sardinia
Wind farm repowering in
Abruzzo
Latvia
Pro-active planning for
Wind energy areas in the
Northern Vidzeme
Biosphere Reserve
(NVBR)
Norway
A process for continuous
developer and
community dialogue in
Afjord
A local innovation house
in Birkenes
Poland
Preparation of wind
turbine investment in
Kisielice region
Spain
Som Energia - Energy
Cooperative
Mancomunidad del
Sureste de Gran Canaria:
Developing Wind and
Water

16. Barriere da superare
• Impatto ambientale
• Fattori socio-culturali
• Fattori legati alla pianificazione
• Fiducia nei decisori e nel processo di pianificazione
• Creazione di valore aggiunto per le comunità
Repowering di parchi eolici in Abruzzo

17. Punti di forza
Repowering di parchi eolici in Abruzzo
• Ampio consenso per la riduzione dell’impatto visivo
• Processo partecipativo nella pianificazione
• Possibilità di modificare il layout
• Ricadute economiche positive con valorizzazione
del territorio

18. This project has received funding from the European Union’s Horizon 2020 research and innovation programme under grant agreement no
764717. The sole responsibility for the content of this presentation lies with its author and in no way reflects the views of the European Union.
winwind-project.eu
info-winwind@PolSoz.FU-Berlin.de
@winwind_eu
WinWind Project
tania.giuffrida@enea.it
elena.deluca@enea.it