Contenu connexe Similaire à 視覚デザイン探索のためのクラウドソーシングを活用したパラメタ空間解析(WISS 2014) (20) 視覚デザイン探索のためのクラウドソーシングを活用したパラメタ空間解析(WISS 2014)1. 8*44
鋔鋙رؠ؎ٝ䱱稊ךך
ؙٓؐسا٦ءؚٝ崞欽׃ػًٓة瑞鍑匿
㼭㿊酔䊹խխ㖩劤㣐➜խխ✿⼧䆀⨳㣗
Not Good Good
Parameter Space Suggested Designs
Visualization
User’s Edit
Interactive
Optimization
Not Good Good
Parameter Space Suggested Designs
Visualization
User’s Edit
Interactive
Optimization
5. 灇瑔嚊銲
! ؼُ٦وٝ؝ٝؾُذ٦ءّٝח״ג
رؠ؎ٝ瑞鍑匿ׅ䩛岀ך䲿周
رؠ؎ٝךչ葺׃䝤׃պך瑞ⴓ䋒䱿㹀ׅ
! رؠ؎ٝ䱱稊ךך؎ٝةؿؑ٦أך䲿周
4NBSU4VHHFTUJPO
7JT0QU4MJEFS
㼭㿊酔䊹㖩劤㣐➜✿⼧䆀⨳㣗խխ鋔鋙رؠ؎ٝ䱱稊ךךؙٓؐسا٦ءؚٝ崞欽׃ػًٓة瑞鍑匿խխ8*44
6. 灇瑔嚊銲
! ؼُ٦وٝ؝ٝؾُذ٦ءّٝח״ג
رؠ؎ٝ瑞鍑匿ׅ䩛岀ך䲿周
رؠ؎ٝךչ葺׃䝤׃պך瑞ⴓ䋒䱿㹀ׅ
! رؠ؎ٝ䱱稊ךך؎ٝةؿؑ٦أך䲿周
4NBSU4VHHFTUJPO
7JT0QU4MJEFS
㼭㿊酔䊹㖩劤㣐➜✿⼧䆀⨳㣗խխ鋔鋙رؠ؎ٝ䱱稊ךךؙٓؐسا٦ءؚٝ崞欽׃ػًٓة瑞鍑匿խխ8*44
7. 灇瑔嚊銲
! ؼُ٦وٝ؝ٝؾُذ٦ءّٝח״ג
رؠ؎ٝ瑞鍑匿ׅ䩛岀ך䲿周
رؠ؎ٝךչ葺׃䝤׃պך瑞ⴓ䋒䱿㹀ׅ
! رؠ؎ٝ䱱稊ךך؎ٝةؿؑ٦أך䲿周
4NBSU4VHHFTUJPO
7JT0QU4MJEFS
㼭㿊酔䊹㖩劤㣐➜✿⼧䆀⨳㣗խխ鋔鋙رؠ؎ٝ䱱稊ךךؙٓؐسا٦ءؚٝ崞欽׃ػًٓة瑞鍑匿խխ8*44
9. ٙ٦ؙؿٗ٦
Design Task
design parameters
㼭㿊酔䊹㖩劤㣐➜✿⼧䆀⨳㣗խխ鋔鋙رؠ؎ٝ䱱稊ךךؙٓؐسا٦ءؚٝ崞欽׃ػًٓة瑞鍑匿խխ8*44
10. ٙ٦ؙؿٗ٦
Design Task Analysis
design parameters
parameter space
parameter 1
parameter 2
㼭㿊酔䊹㖩劤㣐➜✿⼧䆀⨳㣗խխ鋔鋙رؠ؎ٝ䱱稊ךךؙٓؐسا٦ءؚٝ崞欽׃ػًٓة瑞鍑匿խխ8*44
11. ٙ٦ؙؿٗ٦
Design Task Analysis
design parameters
parameter space
parameter 1
parameter 2
㼭㿊酔䊹㖩劤㣐➜✿⼧䆀⨳㣗խխ鋔鋙رؠ؎ٝ䱱稊ךךؙٓؐسا٦ءؚٝ崞欽׃ػًٓة瑞鍑匿խխ8*44
12. ٙ٦ؙؿٗ٦
Design Task Analysis
design parameters
parameter space
parameter 1
parameter 2
crowd workers
㼭㿊酔䊹㖩劤㣐➜✿⼧䆀⨳㣗խխ鋔鋙رؠ؎ٝ䱱稊ךךؙٓؐسا٦ءؚٝ崞欽׃ػًٓة瑞鍑匿խխ8*44
13. ٙ٦ؙؿٗ٦
Design Task Analysis
design parameters
parameter space
⹛歗
parameter 1
parameter 2
crowd workers
㼭㿊酔䊹㖩劤㣐➜✿⼧䆀⨳㣗խխ鋔鋙رؠ؎ٝ䱱稊ךךؙٓؐسا٦ءؚٝ崞欽׃ػًٓة瑞鍑匿խխ8*44
14. ٙ٦ؙؿٗ٦
Design Task Analysis
design parameters
parameter space
parameter 1
parameter 2
crowd workers
㼭㿊酔䊹㖩劤㣐➜✿⼧䆀⨳㣗խխ鋔鋙رؠ؎ٝ䱱稊ךךؙٓؐسا٦ءؚٝ崞欽׃ػًٓة瑞鍑匿խխ8*44
15. ٙ٦ؙؿٗ٦
Design Task Analysis
design parameters
not good good
parameter space
parameter 1
parameter 2
crowd workers
㼭㿊酔䊹㖩劤㣐➜✿⼧䆀⨳㣗խխ鋔鋙رؠ؎ٝ䱱稊ךךؙٓؐسا٦ءؚٝ崞欽׃ػًٓة瑞鍑匿խխ8*44
16. ٙ٦ؙؿٗ٦
Design Task Analysis
f : n
design parameters
not good good
parameter space
parameter 1
parameter 2
crowd workers
㼭㿊酔䊹㖩劤㣐➜✿⼧䆀⨳㣗խխ鋔鋙رؠ؎ٝ䱱稊ךךؙٓؐسا٦ءؚٝ崞欽׃ػًٓة瑞鍑匿խխ8*44
17. ٙ٦ؙؿٗ٦
Design Task Analysis
f : n
crowd workers
User Interface
VisOpt Slider
design parameters
not good good
parameter space
parameter 1
parameter 2
㼭㿊酔䊹㖩劤㣐➜✿⼧䆀⨳㣗խխ鋔鋙رؠ؎ٝ䱱稊ךךؙٓؐسا٦ءؚٝ崞欽׃ػًٓة瑞鍑匿խխ8*44
21. ꧊さ濼欽ְرؠ؎ٝ
5BMUPO
7PZBOU9V
ךِ٦ؠךرؠ؎ٝהח
倜׃ְٌرٕرؠ؎ׅٝ
㢳ֻך⸇罏הꞿְ麊欽劍ָ䗳銲
֮رؠ؎ٝחאְג
ؿ؍٦سغحؙ꧊
ػًٓة瑞ך鍑匿٥䱱稊דכזְ
㼭㿊酔䊹㖩劤㣐➜✿⼧䆀⨳㣗խխ鋔鋙رؠ؎ٝ䱱稊ךךؙٓؐسا٦ءؚٝ崞欽׃ػًٓة瑞鍑匿խխ8*44
22. ꧊さ濼欽ְرؠ؎ٝ
5BMUPO
7PZBOU9V
ךِ٦ؠךرؠ؎ٝהח
倜׃ְٌرٕرؠ؎ׅٝ
㢳ֻך⸇罏הꞿְ麊欽劍ָ䗳銲
֮رؠ؎ٝחאְג
ؿ؍٦سغحؙ꧊
ػًٓة瑞ך鍑匿٥䱱稊דכזְ
㼭㿊酔䊹㖩劤㣐➜✿⼧䆀⨳㣗խխ鋔鋙رؠ؎ٝ䱱稊ךךؙٓؐسا٦ءؚٝ崞欽׃ػًٓة瑞鍑匿խխ8*44
23. ꧊さ濼欽ְرؠ؎ٝ
5BMUPO
7PZBOU9V
ךِ٦ؠךرؠ؎ٝהח
倜׃ְٌرٕرؠ؎ׅٝ
㢳ֻך⸇罏הꞿְ麊欽劍ָ䗳銲
֮رؠ؎ٝחאְג
ؿ؍٦سغحؙ꧊
ػًٓة瑞ך鍑匿٥䱱稊דכזְ
㼭㿊酔䊹㖩劤㣐➜✿⼧䆀⨳㣗խխ鋔鋙رؠ؎ٝ䱱稊ךךؙٓؐسا٦ءؚٝ崞欽׃ػًٓة瑞鍑匿խխ8*44
34. رؠ؎ٝ瑞ך鍑匿
4BNQMJOH
1BSBNFUFS4FUT
(BUIFSJOH1BJSXJTF
$PNQBSJTPOT
TUJNBUJOH(PPEOFTT
7BMVFTPG1PJOUT
TUJNBUJOH(PPEOFTT
7BMVFTPG1PJOUT
'JUUJOHB(PPEOFTT
'VODUJPO
ػًٓةإحزך
؟ٝفؚٔٝ
挿חֶֽ
嫰鯰ر٦ةך ꧊
ぐ挿חֶֽ
(PPEOFTTך䱿㹀
鸬竲ꟼ侧פך
ؿ؍حذ؍ؚٝ
鑫稢
Yuki Koyama, Daisuke Sakamoto, and Takeo Igarashi. 2014. Crowd-powered parameter analysis for visual design exploration. In
Proceedings of the 27th annual ACM symposium on User interface software and technology (UIST '14). ACM, New York, NY, USA, 65-74.
㼭㿊酔䊹㖩劤㣐➜✿⼧䆀⨳㣗խխ鋔鋙رؠ؎ٝ䱱稊ךךؙٓؐسا٦ءؚٝ崞欽׃ػًٓة瑞鍑匿խխ8*44
35. رؠ؎ٝ瑞ך鍑匿
4BNQMJOH
1BSBNFUFS4FUT
(BUIFSJOH1BJSXJTF
$PNQBSJTPOT
TUJNBUJOH(PPEOFTT
7BMVFTPG1PJOUT
TUJNBUJOH(PPEOFTT
7BMVFTPG1PJOUT
'JUUJOHB(PPEOFTT
'VODUJPO
ػًٓةإحزך
؟ٝفؚٔٝ
挿חֶֽ
嫰鯰ر٦ةך ꧊
ぐ挿חֶֽ
(PPEOFTTך䱿㹀
鸬竲ꟼ侧פך
ؿ؍حذ؍ؚٝ
鑫稢
Yuki Koyama, Daisuke Sakamoto, and Takeo Igarashi. 2014. Crowd-powered parameter analysis for visual design exploration. In
Proceedings of the 27th annual ACM symposium on User interface software and technology (UIST '14). ACM, New York, NY, USA, 65-74.
㼭㿊酔䊹㖩劤㣐➜✿⼧䆀⨳㣗խխ鋔鋙رؠ؎ٝ䱱稊ךךؙٓؐسا٦ءؚٝ崞欽׃ػًٓة瑞鍑匿խխ8*44
36. رؠ؎ٝ瑞ך鍑匿
4BNQMJOH
1BSBNFUFS4FUT
(BUIFSJOH1BJSXJTF
$PNQBSJTPOT
TUJNBUJOH(PPEOFTT
7BMVFTPG1PJOUT
TUJNBUJOH(PPEOFTT
7BMVFTPG1PJOUT
'JUUJOHB(PPEOFTT
'VODUJPO
ػًٓةإحزך
؟ٝفؚٔٝ
挿חֶֽ
嫰鯰ر٦ةך ꧊
ぐ挿חֶֽ
(PPEOFTTך䱿㹀
鸬竲ꟼ侧פך
ؿ؍حذ؍ؚٝ
鑫稢
Yuki Koyama, Daisuke Sakamoto, and Takeo Igarashi. 2014. Crowd-powered parameter analysis for visual design exploration. In
Proceedings of the 27th annual ACM symposium on User interface software and technology (UIST '14). ACM, New York, NY, USA, 65-74.
㼭㿊酔䊹㖩劤㣐➜✿⼧䆀⨳㣗խխ鋔鋙رؠ؎ٝ䱱稊ךךؙٓؐسا٦ءؚٝ崞欽׃ػًٓة瑞鍑匿խխ8*44
37. رؠ؎ٝ瑞ך鍑匿
4BNQMJOH
1BSBNFUFS4FUT
纇遚鎘皾
(BUIFSJOH1BJSXJTF
$PNQBSJTPOT
crowd workers
TUJNBUJOH(PPEOFTT
7BMVFTPG1PJOUT
TUJNBUJOH(PPEOFTT
7BMVFTPG1PJOUT
'JUUJOHB(PPEOFTT
'VODUJPO
ػًٓةإحزך
؟ٝفؚٔٝ
挿חֶֽ
嫰鯰ر٦ةך ꧊
ぐ挿חֶֽ
(PPEOFTTך䱿㹀
鸬竲ꟼ侧פך
ؿ؍حذ؍ؚٝ
鑫稢
Yuki Koyama, Daisuke Sakamoto, and Takeo Igarashi. 2014. Crowd-powered parameter analysis for visual design exploration. In
Proceedings of the 27th annual ACM symposium on User interface software and technology (UIST '14). ACM, New York, NY, USA, 65-74.
㼭㿊酔䊹㖩劤㣐➜✿⼧䆀⨳㣗խխ鋔鋙رؠ؎ٝ䱱稊ךךؙٓؐسا٦ءؚٝ崞欽׃ػًٓة瑞鍑匿խխ8*44
38. رؠ؎ٝ瑞ך鍑匿
4BNQMJOH
1BSBNFUFS4FUT
(BUIFSJOH1BJSXJTF
$PNQBSJTPOT
剑㼭✳⛦岀
TUJNBUJOH(PPEOFTT
7BMVFTPG1PJOUT
TUJNBUJOH(PPEOFTT
7BMVFTPG1PJOUT
'JUUJOHB(PPEOFTT
'VODUJPO
ػًٓةإحزך
؟ٝفؚٔٝ
挿חֶֽ
嫰鯰ر٦ةך ꧊
ぐ挿חֶֽ
(PPEOFTTך䱿㹀
鸬竲ꟼ侧פך
ؿ؍حذ؍ؚٝ
鑫稢
Yuki Koyama, Daisuke Sakamoto, and Takeo Igarashi. 2014. Crowd-powered parameter analysis for visual design exploration. In
Proceedings of the 27th annual ACM symposium on User interface software and technology (UIST '14). ACM, New York, NY, USA, 65-74.
㼭㿊酔䊹㖩劤㣐➜✿⼧䆀⨳㣗խխ鋔鋙رؠ؎ٝ䱱稊ךךؙٓؐسا٦ءؚٝ崞欽׃ػًٓة瑞鍑匿խխ8*44
39. رؠ؎ٝ瑞ך鍑匿
4BNQMJOH
1BSBNFUFS4FUT
(BUIFSJOH1BJSXJTF
$PNQBSJTPOT
TUJNBUJOH(PPEOFTT
7BMVFTPG1PJOUT
TUJNBUJOH(PPEOFTT
7BMVFTPG1PJOUT
3#'酡
'JUUJOHB(PPEOFTT
'VODUJPO
ػًٓةإحزך
؟ٝفؚٔٝ
挿חֶֽ
嫰鯰ر٦ةך ꧊
ぐ挿חֶֽ
(PPEOFTTך䱿㹀
鸬竲ꟼ侧פך
ؿ؍حذ؍ؚٝ
鑫稢
Yuki Koyama, Daisuke Sakamoto, and Takeo Igarashi. 2014. Crowd-powered parameter analysis for visual design exploration. In
Proceedings of the 27th annual ACM symposium on User interface software and technology (UIST '14). ACM, New York, NY, USA, 65-74.
㼭㿊酔䊹㖩劤㣐➜✿⼧䆀⨳㣗խխ鋔鋙رؠ؎ٝ䱱稊ךךؙٓؐسا٦ءؚٝ崞欽׃ػًٓة瑞鍑匿խխ8*44
44. 剑黝⻉ 0QU
xi
xj
xi
xj
㼭㿊酔䊹㖩劤㣐➜✿⼧䆀⨳㣗խխ鋔鋙رؠ؎ٝ䱱稊ךךؙٓؐسا٦ءؚٝ崞欽׃ػًٓة瑞鍑匿խխ8*44
46. 剑黝⻉ 0QU
xi
xj
xi
xj
植㖈ך⦼
㼭㿊酔䊹㖩劤㣐➜✿⼧䆀⨳㣗խխ鋔鋙رؠ؎ٝ䱱稊ךךؙٓؐسا٦ءؚٝ崞欽׃ػًٓة瑞鍑匿խխ8*44
48. 剑黝⻉ 0QU
xi
xj
xi
xj
㼭㿊酔䊹㖩劤㣐➜✿⼧䆀⨳㣗խխ鋔鋙رؠ؎ٝ䱱稊ךךؙٓؐسا٦ءؚٝ崞欽׃ػًٓة瑞鍑匿խխ8*44
50. 剑黝⻉ 0QU
xi
xj
xi
xj
㼭㿊酔䊹㖩劤㣐➜✿⼧䆀⨳㣗խխ鋔鋙رؠ؎ٝ䱱稊ךךؙٓؐسا٦ءؚٝ崞欽׃ػًٓة瑞鍑匿խխ8*44
52. 剑黝⻉ 0QU
xi
xj
xi
xj
㼭㿊酔䊹㖩劤㣐➜✿⼧䆀⨳㣗խխ鋔鋙رؠ؎ٝ䱱稊ךךؙٓؐسا٦ءؚٝ崞欽׃ػًٓة瑞鍑匿խխ8*44
54. 剑黝⻉ 0QU
xi
xj
xi
xj
ِ٦ؠך箟꧊
㼭㿊酔䊹㖩劤㣐➜✿⼧䆀⨳㣗խխ鋔鋙رؠ؎ٝ䱱稊ךךؙٓؐسا٦ءؚٝ崞欽׃ػًٓة瑞鍑匿խխ8*44
56. 剑黝⻉ 0QU
xi
xj
xi
xj
荈⹛锃眍
ِ٦ؠך箟꧊
㼭㿊酔䊹㖩劤㣐➜✿⼧䆀⨳㣗խխ鋔鋙رؠ؎ٝ䱱稊ךךؙٓؐسا٦ءؚٝ崞欽׃ػًٓة瑞鍑匿խխ8*44
69. 黝欽⢽
邌䞔ٌرؚٔٝ
OPUOBUVSBM OBUVSBM
00..1155 00..3311 00..4499 00..6611 0.88
鋔鋙涸ח㧅䔲ז䱿㹀穠卓ָ䖤
㼭㿊酔䊹㖩劤㣐➜✿⼧䆀⨳㣗խխ鋔鋙رؠ؎ٝ䱱稊ךךؙٓؐسا٦ءؚٝ崞欽׃ػًٓة瑞鍑匿խխ8*44
70. 黝欽⢽
邌䞔ٌرؚٔٝ
OPUOBUVSBM OBUVSBM
00..1155 00..3311 00..4499 00..6611 0.88
鋔鋙涸ח㧅䔲ז䱿㹀穠卓ָ䖤
㼭㿊酔䊹㖩劤㣐➜✿⼧䆀⨳㣗խխ鋔鋙رؠ؎ٝ䱱稊ךךؙٓؐسا٦ءؚٝ崞欽׃ػًٓة瑞鍑匿խխ8*44
71. 黝欽⢽窟鎘ر٦ة
$PMPS
$PSSFDUJPO
$BNFSB
-JHIU
4IBEFS 'BDJBM
YQSFTTJPO
ػًٓة侧
鐰⣣鯥 HPPE HPPE SFBMJTUJD OBUVSBM
嫰鯰ر٦ة侧
さ鎘ꆃ겘 64% 64% 64% 64%
さ鎘儗 NJO NJO NJO NJO
㼭㿊酔䊹㖩劤㣐➜✿⼧䆀⨳㣗խխ鋔鋙رؠ؎ٝ䱱稊ךךؙٓؐسا٦ءؚٝ崞欽׃ػًٓة瑞鍑匿խխ8*44
73. 鐰⣣鍑匿䩛岀
勲 XSU嫰鯰侧
❛䊴嗚鏾
鑫稢
Yuki Koyama, Daisuke Sakamoto, and Takeo Igarashi. 2014. Crowd-powered parameter analysis for visual design exploration. In
Proceedings of the 27th annual ACM symposium on User interface software and technology (UIST '14). ACM, New York, NY, USA, 65-74.
㼭㿊酔䊹㖩劤㣐➜✿⼧䆀⨳㣗խխ鋔鋙رؠ؎ٝ䱱稊ךךؙٓؐسا٦ءؚٝ崞欽׃ػًٓة瑞鍑匿խխ8*44
74. 鐰⣣ِ٦ؠ؎ٝةؿؑ٦أ
ِ٦ؠأةر؍
➂ך㷕欰חِ٦ؠ؎ٝةؿؑ٦أ⢪גֲ
4ZTUFN6TBCJMJUZ4DBMF#BOHPS
ˑHPPE˒ WFSBHF
4%
鑫稢
Yuki Koyama, Daisuke Sakamoto, and Takeo Igarashi. 2014. Crowd-powered parameter analysis for visual design exploration. In
Proceedings of the 27th annual ACM symposium on User interface software and technology (UIST '14). ACM, New York, NY, USA, 65-74.
㼭㿊酔䊹㖩劤㣐➜✿⼧䆀⨳㣗խխ鋔鋙رؠ؎ٝ䱱稊ךךؙٓؐسا٦ءؚٝ崞欽׃ػًٓة瑞鍑匿խխ8*44
77. תה
! ؼُ٦وٝ؝ٝؾُذ٦ءّٝח״ג
⟣䠐ךرؠ؎ٝ瑞鍑匿ׅ䩛岀
! رؠ؎ٝ䱱稊ךך؎ٝةؿؑ٦أ
4NBSU4VHHFTUJPO
7JT0QU4MJEFS
! אך殯זرؠ؎ٝ걄㚖ח黝欽
㼭㿊酔䊹㖩劤㣐➜✿⼧䆀⨳㣗խխ鋔鋙رؠ؎ٝ䱱稊ךךؙٓؐسا٦ءؚٝ崞欽׃ػًٓة瑞鍑匿խխ8*44
78. תה
! ؼُ٦وٝ؝ٝؾُذ٦ءّٝח״ג
⟣䠐ךرؠ؎ٝ瑞鍑匿ׅ䩛岀
! رؠ؎ٝ䱱稊ךך؎ٝةؿؑ٦أ
4NBSU4VHHFTUJPO
7JT0QU4MJEFS
! אך殯זرؠ؎ٝ걄㚖ח黝欽
㼭㿊酔䊹㖩劤㣐➜✿⼧䆀⨳㣗խխ鋔鋙رؠ؎ٝ䱱稊ךךؙٓؐسا٦ءؚٝ崞欽׃ػًٓة瑞鍑匿խխ8*44
79. תה
! ؼُ٦وٝ؝ٝؾُذ٦ءّٝח״ג
⟣䠐ךرؠ؎ٝ瑞鍑匿ׅ䩛岀
! رؠ؎ٝ䱱稊ךך؎ٝةؿؑ٦أ
4NBSU4VHHFTUJPO
7JT0QU4MJEFS
! אך殯זرؠ؎ٝ걄㚖ח黝欽
㼭㿊酔䊹㖩劤㣐➜✿⼧䆀⨳㣗խխ鋔鋙رؠ؎ٝ䱱稊ךךؙٓؐسا٦ءؚٝ崞欽׃ػًٓة瑞鍑匿խխ8*44
80. תה
! ؼُ٦وٝ؝ٝؾُذ٦ءّٝח״ג
⟣䠐ךرؠ؎ٝ瑞鍑匿ׅ䩛岀
! رؠ؎ٝ䱱稊ךך؎ٝةؿؑ٦أ
4NBSU4VHHFTUJPO
7JT0QU4MJEFS
! אך殯זرؠ؎ٝ걄㚖ח黝欽
㼭㿊酔䊹㖩劤㣐➜✿⼧䆀⨳㣗խխ鋔鋙رؠ؎ٝ䱱稊ךךؙٓؐسا٦ءؚٝ崞欽׃ػًٓة瑞鍑匿խխ8*44
83. $SPXETPVSDJOH)VNBO$PNQVUBUJPO
)VNBO@
$SPXE1PXFSFE
)VNBO$PNQVUBUJPO
$PNQVUBUJPO@ $SPXETPVSDJOH
$SPXETPVSDJOHBTLDSPXEXPSLFSTUPEPTPNFUBTLT
)VNBO$PNQVUBUJPOBTTVNFIVNBOBTBQSPDFTTPS
TFF2VJOOGPSEFUBJMT
㼭㿊酔䊹㖩劤㣐➜✿⼧䆀⨳㣗խխ鋔鋙رؠ؎ٝ䱱稊ךךؙٓؐسا٦ءؚٝ崞欽׃ػًٓة瑞鍑匿խխ8*44
86. .JDSP5BTLGPS$SPXETPVSDJOH
Which of the two images of OPVOis more BEKFDUJWF? !
For example, DMBVTF.!
Please choose the most appropriate one from the 5 options below.!
YBNQMFPGVTFSˏTTQFDJDBUJPO
OPVO vegetables
BEKFDUJWF good
DMBVTF
suppose that you had to choose one of these two
images to appear in a magazine or product
advertisement!
㼭㿊酔䊹㖩劤㣐➜✿⼧䆀⨳㣗խխ鋔鋙رؠ؎ٝ䱱稊ךךؙٓؐسا٦ءؚٝ崞欽׃ػًٓة瑞鍑匿խխ8*44