Presentation delivered to CorkCon 2016, an IBM Internal Conference on Ideas and Creativity. This presentation summarises my research on politics and big data, on technology and the state, and on the automation of government. Is it technics out of control? Or are we on the threshold of a great new age?
2. This started with a question:
How does big data change the state?
Which became
How does technology change politics?
3. ‘Newsreaders still feel it is worth a special
and rather worrying mention if, for instance,
a crime was planned by people ‘over the
Internet.’ They don’t bother to mention
when criminals use the telephone or the M4,
or discuss their dastardly plans ‘over a cup of
tea,’ though each of these was new and
controversial in their day.’
Douglas Adams
4. Communication is a form of life.
Ludwig Josef Johann Wittgenstein
26 April 1889 – 29 April 1951 1953
Ergo…Technology is a form of life.
5.
6. Cyborgs are enhanced humans
Birds have nests, spiders have webs, and we have our technology.
(What does it mean to be human? To be whole?)
7. Machines are like humans, but in some respects better
Does it matter that those with whom we interact are actually human?
8. Technology has changed people.
Personal Communications and Interactions have Changed.
The way we speak to each other, communicate with one another, buy and
exchange stuff, express ourselves – all that has changed now.
9. Marshall McLuhan,
July 21, 1911 – December 31, 1980
The
medium
is
the
message
1964
"we live mythically and integrally ... but continue to think in the old, fragmented space and time patterns of the pre-electric age."
10. Loyalty to family, community, nation, geography -
dissipates
Emotional, Personal Connections and Communities are Distributed, Decentralised,
Global.
11. Politics Changes.
Politics is about power, and communications, and relationships, and social
infrastructure. If communications changes, politics must change. Right?
12. Politics, and the State, is Broken.
These people are not us. The State is not us. The State is illegitimate.
13. So, here’s a thought.
Why don’t the machines run the government?
We’d trust them more than we do people, right?
17. There may be an answer in Big Data Machines
Monitor everything,
understand
everyone’s
behaviour,
everywhere.
People, and the internet of
things
Using that
data, create,
adapt, and
infer laws that
it is likely
people will
accept.
People, and the internet of
things
Monitor everything,
understand everyone’s
behaviour, everywhere.
Measure / Judge them.
Enforce the law.
18. So let’s ask the question about speed cameras.
Traffic monitoring.
Mass surveillance.
Why don’t we do it everywhere? All the time?
What are we afraid of?
19. The Politics of Automation: Big Data Machines and the Prosecution of State Bureaucracy
An assessment of automated law enforcement in Ireland, and the barriers to extended automation
Anthony Behan
October 2016
MSc by Research
Department of Government
National University of Ireland, Cork