This document discusses how major brands handle demands from the Federal Trade Commission regarding affiliate marketing compliance. It provides an overview of FTC definitions, guidelines, and examples of compliance risks. Major points include that affiliates are seen as an extension of a brand's marketing, endorsements by affiliates need to include a disclosure if compensated, and brands need to proactively teach, create compliance processes, and enforce rules to avoid penalties from the FTC. The document offers examples of proactive actions taken by large brands to ensure affiliate marketing compliance.
2. COPYRIGHT BRANDVERITY, 2016
Outline
• FTC Definitions & Guidelines
• Types of Compliance Risks
– Examples
– BrandVerity Study
• Costs of Non-Compliance
• Real World Examples
• Proactively Taking Control
3. COPYRIGHT BRANDVERITY, 2016
Learn to think like the FTC
• Affiliates/Partners are seen as part of a brand’s
marketing channel
• If an affiliate/partner makes claims or discusses an
attribute and receives compensation, need to follow
guidelines
4. COPYRIGHT BRANDVERITY, 2016
FTC Guidelines
An advertisement or promotional message shouldn’t
suggest or imply to consumers that it is anything other
than an ad
https://girlwithcurves.com/post/132058612904/feather-blazer-high-waist-jeans
5. COPYRIGHT BRANDVERITY, 2016
Disclosures
Disclosures must be clearly and conspicuously stated
for any sponsored content
"Native Advertising: A Guide For Businesses | Federal Trade Commission". Ftc.gov. N.p., 2016. Web. 20 Dec. 2016.
"The FTC’S Endorsement Guides: What People Are Asking | Federal Trade Commission". Ftc.gov. N.p., 2016. Web. 19 Dec. 2016.
".Com Disclosures: How To Make Effective Disclosures In Digital Advertising". Ftc.gov. N.p., 2016. Web. 20 Dec. 2016.
8. COPYRIGHT BRANDVERITY, 2016
BrandVerity Study
• Failure is the Norm
– 80% did not include a disclosure
• Better Together
– 79% of posts created through
advertiser and affiliate collaboration
included some form of disclosure
• All Disclosures Not Created
Equal
– Only 21% of disclosures were
adequate
Download Today:
bit.ly/FTCstudy
9. COPYRIGHT BRANDVERITY, 2016
Costs of Non-Compliance
• Public Reprimands
– For Brands: Loss of customers
– For Publishers: Loss of business
• FTC Reprimands
– Court Ordered Monitoring
– Fines
11. COPYRIGHT BRANDVERITY, 2016
Example: Large Agency – Online Retail
• Actions Taken: Extreme Proactivity
– Require all affiliate pages to have a proper disclosure on their pages
stating there are paid links
– Not allowing any affiliates into program without disclosure present
• Benefit
– Starting their program out with a requirement, rather than having to go
back later and educate/enforce
12. COPYRIGHT BRANDVERITY, 2016
Example: Credit Card Issuer
• Actions Taken: Unique Disclosure
– Each time an affiliate has their card, they have a unique brand specific
advertiser disclosure
• Benefit
– Easy to show that they are being proactive
– Helpful in monitoring since you can look for specific text
13. COPYRIGHT BRANDVERITY, 2016
Example: Large Bank
• Actions Taken: Control Traffic Flow
– All referral links leaving publisher site only come from 1 page
– All links for a specific card in any article on a page must only link back
to one page on the site that will link back to the bank
• Benefit
– Able to ensure that every customer sees the disclosure, TOS, etc. if
all traffic goes through one page
16. COPYRIGHT BRANDVERITY, 2016
Tips For A Compliant Program
1. Teach
– Yourself
– Colleagues
– Partners
Teach
Create a
Process
Enforce
17. COPYRIGHT BRANDVERITY, 2016
Tips For A Compliant Program
2. Create a process
– Review each affiliate site
– Capture screenshots
– Record remediation actions
– Compile report
Create a
process
EnforceTeach
18. COPYRIGHT BRANDVERITY, 2016
Tips For A Compliant Program
3. Enforce
– When an issue is found, contact the affiliate and take action
– Keep a record of the issues to show you have a process for taking action
Enforce
Teach
Create a
process
19. COPYRIGHT BRANDVERITY, 2016
Summary
• Affiliates/Partners are seen as part of your marketing
program
• Any endorsements by affiliates/partners need to have a
disclosure if being compensated
• Learn the FTC guidelines for your industry
• Teach others what those guidelines are
• Develop a compliance process
• Enforce the your rules
pause in between bullets
Examples of "Success" "Actions" brands are taking to be compliant
Associated costs of risks
Ambiguity
Learn to think like the FTC
Referencing something on the slide
Included affiliate links embedded in blog posts
Classic truth in advertising principle – anything that provides value from the brand to publisher makes it a promoted message – Cash payments, Free products
Store credit, Discounts, Free services, Special access, Favors of any kind
(not link, etc.)
Clear – significant minority of reasonable consumers – not everyone knows what affiliate marketing/links mean, must be able to understand them, simple straightforward
Conspicuous – no scrolling, should not be able to click a link prior to seeing disclosure, proximity, stand out against background, can use one disclosure for a few links – must be clear
http://www.lexology.com/library/detail.aspx?g=f24b6ea0-907f-47ac-9ccb-9f70c353c167
You probably think you are fine – are you? What do others look like?
----- Meeting Notes (1/4/17 10:59) -----
Think like the FTC - reviewed bloggers
100 blogs when commercial relationships existed – applied framework of evaluation
79% - Direct vs indirect affiliates, non-collaboration was a leak where bloggers were able to drive traffic without being explicit partners, one-step too far, no influence, FTC position
Court ordered – opening your books to FTC
As a publisher – removed from program – may no longer have access
Including one of top 2 leading sports brands
Top 3 Credit Card Issuer
Leading national bank with over 2 trillion dollars in total assets
Standardizing UX
Affiliates – understanding they don’t have the legal resources, might not be aware, rewards good publishers instead of taxing, empowers them to be compliant for other brands as well
----- Meeting Notes (1/4/17 13:35) -----
All this information is free and publicly available
Taxing because they have to send it in every month – great example to show you what process the FTC is looking for
One off problems will not trigger the FTC, consistent non-compliance will
Removed “Court order of Legacy Learning Systems” since it wasn’t part of the “process” steps
Highlight – keeping record is difficult without technology – screenshots, email recording, evidence that the communication triggered a change
Over last few months conducting study – published that this morning