SlideShare une entreprise Scribd logo
1  sur  15
Télécharger pour lire hors ligne
How can assessments be designed in a way that
authentically show the layered evidence inherent
in arts-based learning?


                        Kristina Lamour Sansone
                        Associate Professor, Design
                        The Art Institute of Boston at Lesley University
                        Lisa Donovan
                        Divison Director, Creative Arts in Learning
                        The School of Education at Lesley University
                        NAEA 2011, Seattle
Documentation must become a central part of our work in education. So often, significant
learning goals are met when students are exploring ideas [through arts based inquiry such
as drawing, making videos, creating models, dramatizing stories and in other forms of
investigation)] but not fully realized because there is often too much data in a variety of
forms to show the layers of learning happening “in the moment.” We must find ways to
make visible the power and nuance of this work in ways that can change what counts
as appropriate tools for assessment.
Example 1:
Mastway Elementary School
David McCormick’s 4th grade
Lee, New Hampshire
The learning goal from David’s perspective

The objective for the whole thing — it’s very dry. The objectives for the
whole unit are understanding the history of the Lamprey River. If you ever
see the Lamprey River, it’s about as wide as this classroom at its widest.
It’s probably about this deep. But historically it had an impact in this area.
It was traveled during colonial times. The work that’s led up to this is we’ve
talked about food chains and habitats and changing environment and
changing where the animal lives and all that.

So trying to get [students] to see — to understand not only the animal,
but also the river and the habitat… that’s…the overall goal. But also,
I’m trying to get them — we’re working a lot on their objectives in writing
and descriptive writing. And…once we get going, we’ll be doing a lot
of dialogue and how to write that.
In arts-integration there
is often a cumbersome
stack of contact sheets,
field notes interview
transcripts, classroom
discussion, and video
data.

ALL show aspects of
the learning going on.

How do we select the
most salient data,
prioritize it and then
design assessment
that consider various
perspectives?
teacher transformation

a teacher’s lifespan


                         content area
   teacher before arts integration                                           teacher after arts integration

               show examples of teaching processes, environment, risk-taking before and after




mirrored processes

                                   his own        witnessing in students
Example 2:
The Charles Sumner School
3rd grade classroom
Roslindale, Massachusetts
Example 3
Monument Mountain High School
Dance Integration
How can the design of documentation provide a feedback loop tool for the
student and for the teacher? For the multiple skateholders?

How can documentation serve to make visible all that has occurred in learning?
This includes the planned objectives but also other interesting connections
and discoveries.

How can graphic design process help to steer the reading we want of the
in-depth learning experience including where the learning goals are met?

Contenu connexe

En vedette

Nanotech Standards - Industry Participation - Strengthening Ties
Nanotech Standards - Industry Participation - Strengthening TiesNanotech Standards - Industry Participation - Strengthening Ties
Nanotech Standards - Industry Participation - Strengthening Tiesharidoss
 
corequestionsIntro
corequestionsIntrocorequestionsIntro
corequestionsIntroRadka
 
Sisli Terakki Vakfi Okullari
Sisli Terakki Vakfi Okullari Sisli Terakki Vakfi Okullari
Sisli Terakki Vakfi Okullari fulyaa
 
Carnaval
CarnavalCarnaval
Carnavalnelsun
 
Web 2.0
Web 2.0Web 2.0
Web 2.0IsaR
 
A vida de jesus
A vida de jesusA vida de jesus
A vida de jesusWorkman
 
文明礼仪班会Ppt
文明礼仪班会Ppt文明礼仪班会Ppt
文明礼仪班会Pptlms0023
 
Kendel Avaya-Fabric connect -Demo Lab Guide – SPB IP Shortcuts-3
Kendel  Avaya-Fabric connect -Demo Lab Guide – SPB IP Shortcuts-3Kendel  Avaya-Fabric connect -Demo Lab Guide – SPB IP Shortcuts-3
Kendel Avaya-Fabric connect -Demo Lab Guide – SPB IP Shortcuts-3ELI KENDEL אלי קנדל
 
Achieve business agility with Cloud APIs, Cloud-aware Apps, and Cloud DevOps ...
Achieve business agility with Cloud APIs, Cloud-aware Apps, and Cloud DevOps ...Achieve business agility with Cloud APIs, Cloud-aware Apps, and Cloud DevOps ...
Achieve business agility with Cloud APIs, Cloud-aware Apps, and Cloud DevOps ...Chris Haddad
 
Open Education As A Practice + Notes
Open Education As A Practice + NotesOpen Education As A Practice + Notes
Open Education As A Practice + NotesChris Chesher
 
Conducting Media Interviews
Conducting Media InterviewsConducting Media Interviews
Conducting Media InterviewsJeffrey Swartz
 
Available listing inventory Essex County, MA
Available listing inventory  Essex County, MAAvailable listing inventory  Essex County, MA
Available listing inventory Essex County, MAEd Ridolfi
 
Drupal in Higher Education
Drupal in Higher EducationDrupal in Higher Education
Drupal in Higher Educationjohnbickar
 
Narrtive and repersentation
Narrtive and repersentationNarrtive and repersentation
Narrtive and repersentationChun Kit Yiu
 
Cav Crime - Um olhar Transdisciplinar
Cav Crime - Um olhar TransdisciplinarCav Crime - Um olhar Transdisciplinar
Cav Crime - Um olhar TransdisciplinarKellison Lima
 
Role of the Court in the third pillar: Does not it grow too fast?
Role of the Court in the third pillar: Does not it grow too fast?Role of the Court in the third pillar: Does not it grow too fast?
Role of the Court in the third pillar: Does not it grow too fast?Ivan Grigoriev
 

En vedette (18)

Nanotech Standards - Industry Participation - Strengthening Ties
Nanotech Standards - Industry Participation - Strengthening TiesNanotech Standards - Industry Participation - Strengthening Ties
Nanotech Standards - Industry Participation - Strengthening Ties
 
corequestionsIntro
corequestionsIntrocorequestionsIntro
corequestionsIntro
 
Sisli Terakki Vakfi Okullari
Sisli Terakki Vakfi Okullari Sisli Terakki Vakfi Okullari
Sisli Terakki Vakfi Okullari
 
Carnaval
CarnavalCarnaval
Carnaval
 
Web 2.0
Web 2.0Web 2.0
Web 2.0
 
A vida de jesus
A vida de jesusA vida de jesus
A vida de jesus
 
Courtney NAEA2011
Courtney NAEA2011Courtney NAEA2011
Courtney NAEA2011
 
文明礼仪班会Ppt
文明礼仪班会Ppt文明礼仪班会Ppt
文明礼仪班会Ppt
 
Youth Cultures
Youth CulturesYouth Cultures
Youth Cultures
 
Kendel Avaya-Fabric connect -Demo Lab Guide – SPB IP Shortcuts-3
Kendel  Avaya-Fabric connect -Demo Lab Guide – SPB IP Shortcuts-3Kendel  Avaya-Fabric connect -Demo Lab Guide – SPB IP Shortcuts-3
Kendel Avaya-Fabric connect -Demo Lab Guide – SPB IP Shortcuts-3
 
Achieve business agility with Cloud APIs, Cloud-aware Apps, and Cloud DevOps ...
Achieve business agility with Cloud APIs, Cloud-aware Apps, and Cloud DevOps ...Achieve business agility with Cloud APIs, Cloud-aware Apps, and Cloud DevOps ...
Achieve business agility with Cloud APIs, Cloud-aware Apps, and Cloud DevOps ...
 
Open Education As A Practice + Notes
Open Education As A Practice + NotesOpen Education As A Practice + Notes
Open Education As A Practice + Notes
 
Conducting Media Interviews
Conducting Media InterviewsConducting Media Interviews
Conducting Media Interviews
 
Available listing inventory Essex County, MA
Available listing inventory  Essex County, MAAvailable listing inventory  Essex County, MA
Available listing inventory Essex County, MA
 
Drupal in Higher Education
Drupal in Higher EducationDrupal in Higher Education
Drupal in Higher Education
 
Narrtive and repersentation
Narrtive and repersentationNarrtive and repersentation
Narrtive and repersentation
 
Cav Crime - Um olhar Transdisciplinar
Cav Crime - Um olhar TransdisciplinarCav Crime - Um olhar Transdisciplinar
Cav Crime - Um olhar Transdisciplinar
 
Role of the Court in the third pillar: Does not it grow too fast?
Role of the Court in the third pillar: Does not it grow too fast?Role of the Court in the third pillar: Does not it grow too fast?
Role of the Court in the third pillar: Does not it grow too fast?
 

Similaire à Kristine NAEA

Schultz.Sarah_Ideological Stance FINAL
Schultz.Sarah_Ideological Stance FINALSchultz.Sarah_Ideological Stance FINAL
Schultz.Sarah_Ideological Stance FINALSarah M. Schultz
 
Teaching Presence Facilitates Learning
Teaching Presence Facilitates LearningTeaching Presence Facilitates Learning
Teaching Presence Facilitates LearningPatrick Lowenthal
 
TYCA 2017 Situating Composition
TYCA 2017 Situating CompositionTYCA 2017 Situating Composition
TYCA 2017 Situating Compositionjjory7
 
Topic 4A: The Constructivist Classroom
Topic 4A: The Constructivist ClassroomTopic 4A: The Constructivist Classroom
Topic 4A: The Constructivist Classroombgalloway
 
20. The Transformative Potential of Creative Assignments in Higher Education.pdf
20. The Transformative Potential of Creative Assignments in Higher Education.pdf20. The Transformative Potential of Creative Assignments in Higher Education.pdf
20. The Transformative Potential of Creative Assignments in Higher Education.pdfCarrie Tran
 
Tomlinson Hottopic Spring09
Tomlinson Hottopic Spring09Tomlinson Hottopic Spring09
Tomlinson Hottopic Spring09srozendaal
 
Arp Report Erika Rimes 2007
Arp Report Erika Rimes 2007Arp Report Erika Rimes 2007
Arp Report Erika Rimes 2007Erika Rimes
 
Widdicombe - Getting creative with research: a case study approach to informa...
Widdicombe - Getting creative with research: a case study approach to informa...Widdicombe - Getting creative with research: a case study approach to informa...
Widdicombe - Getting creative with research: a case study approach to informa...IL Group (CILIP Information Literacy Group)
 
Grade 4 Portfolio
Grade 4 PortfolioGrade 4 Portfolio
Grade 4 PortfolioSolveig00
 
Across The Disciplines Exploring Relationships Between Aesthetic Education An...
Across The Disciplines Exploring Relationships Between Aesthetic Education An...Across The Disciplines Exploring Relationships Between Aesthetic Education An...
Across The Disciplines Exploring Relationships Between Aesthetic Education An...Sean Flores
 
How Teaching American History Supported Our Classrooms
How Teaching American History Supported Our ClassroomsHow Teaching American History Supported Our Classrooms
How Teaching American History Supported Our ClassroomsSusan Olds
 
Ace Intercultural Dimensions Of Task Based Learning For Authentic Communication
Ace Intercultural Dimensions Of Task Based Learning For Authentic CommunicationAce Intercultural Dimensions Of Task Based Learning For Authentic Communication
Ace Intercultural Dimensions Of Task Based Learning For Authentic CommunicationDavid Brooks
 
Graphic language (arts) @ the library!
Graphic language (arts) @ the library!Graphic language (arts) @ the library!
Graphic language (arts) @ the library!Susan Grigsby
 
English Multilitericies And Social Change Use Me!
English Multilitericies And Social Change Use Me!English Multilitericies And Social Change Use Me!
English Multilitericies And Social Change Use Me!tashmccarthy
 
Crossing Borders_final
Crossing Borders_finalCrossing Borders_final
Crossing Borders_finalDanny Tan
 
Annotation In School English A Social Semiotic Historical Account
Annotation In School English  A Social Semiotic Historical AccountAnnotation In School English  A Social Semiotic Historical Account
Annotation In School English A Social Semiotic Historical AccountDawn Cook
 
Week 3 Integration in the Middle Years Classroom
Week 3   Integration in the Middle Years ClassroomWeek 3   Integration in the Middle Years Classroom
Week 3 Integration in the Middle Years Classroombgalloway
 
Teaching in Higher Education
Teaching in Higher EducationTeaching in Higher Education
Teaching in Higher EducationKosta Giakoumis
 

Similaire à Kristine NAEA (20)

Schultz.Sarah_Ideological Stance FINAL
Schultz.Sarah_Ideological Stance FINALSchultz.Sarah_Ideological Stance FINAL
Schultz.Sarah_Ideological Stance FINAL
 
Teaching Presence Facilitates Learning
Teaching Presence Facilitates LearningTeaching Presence Facilitates Learning
Teaching Presence Facilitates Learning
 
TYCA 2017 Situating Composition
TYCA 2017 Situating CompositionTYCA 2017 Situating Composition
TYCA 2017 Situating Composition
 
Topic 4A: The Constructivist Classroom
Topic 4A: The Constructivist ClassroomTopic 4A: The Constructivist Classroom
Topic 4A: The Constructivist Classroom
 
20. The Transformative Potential of Creative Assignments in Higher Education.pdf
20. The Transformative Potential of Creative Assignments in Higher Education.pdf20. The Transformative Potential of Creative Assignments in Higher Education.pdf
20. The Transformative Potential of Creative Assignments in Higher Education.pdf
 
Tomlinson Hottopic Spring09
Tomlinson Hottopic Spring09Tomlinson Hottopic Spring09
Tomlinson Hottopic Spring09
 
Arp Report Erika Rimes 2007
Arp Report Erika Rimes 2007Arp Report Erika Rimes 2007
Arp Report Erika Rimes 2007
 
Widdicombe - Getting creative with research: a case study approach to informa...
Widdicombe - Getting creative with research: a case study approach to informa...Widdicombe - Getting creative with research: a case study approach to informa...
Widdicombe - Getting creative with research: a case study approach to informa...
 
Grade 4 Portfolio
Grade 4 PortfolioGrade 4 Portfolio
Grade 4 Portfolio
 
Across The Disciplines Exploring Relationships Between Aesthetic Education An...
Across The Disciplines Exploring Relationships Between Aesthetic Education An...Across The Disciplines Exploring Relationships Between Aesthetic Education An...
Across The Disciplines Exploring Relationships Between Aesthetic Education An...
 
How Teaching American History Supported Our Classrooms
How Teaching American History Supported Our ClassroomsHow Teaching American History Supported Our Classrooms
How Teaching American History Supported Our Classrooms
 
Ace Intercultural Dimensions Of Task Based Learning For Authentic Communication
Ace Intercultural Dimensions Of Task Based Learning For Authentic CommunicationAce Intercultural Dimensions Of Task Based Learning For Authentic Communication
Ace Intercultural Dimensions Of Task Based Learning For Authentic Communication
 
Graphic language (arts) @ the library!
Graphic language (arts) @ the library!Graphic language (arts) @ the library!
Graphic language (arts) @ the library!
 
EFL Educators Workshop
EFL Educators WorkshopEFL Educators Workshop
EFL Educators Workshop
 
English Multilitericies And Social Change Use Me!
English Multilitericies And Social Change Use Me!English Multilitericies And Social Change Use Me!
English Multilitericies And Social Change Use Me!
 
Crossing Borders_final
Crossing Borders_finalCrossing Borders_final
Crossing Borders_final
 
Annotation In School English A Social Semiotic Historical Account
Annotation In School English  A Social Semiotic Historical AccountAnnotation In School English  A Social Semiotic Historical Account
Annotation In School English A Social Semiotic Historical Account
 
Week 3 Integration in the Middle Years Classroom
Week 3   Integration in the Middle Years ClassroomWeek 3   Integration in the Middle Years Classroom
Week 3 Integration in the Middle Years Classroom
 
Design for Learning: Enriching School Landscapes
Design for Learning: Enriching School LandscapesDesign for Learning: Enriching School Landscapes
Design for Learning: Enriching School Landscapes
 
Teaching in Higher Education
Teaching in Higher EducationTeaching in Higher Education
Teaching in Higher Education
 

Plus de aileenwilson

Presentation judyfeb2012
Presentation judyfeb2012Presentation judyfeb2012
Presentation judyfeb2012aileenwilson
 
NAEA Research2011-Aileen
NAEA Research2011-AileenNAEA Research2011-Aileen
NAEA Research2011-Aileenaileenwilson
 
Cont Art and Education NAEA2011
Cont Art and Education NAEA2011Cont Art and Education NAEA2011
Cont Art and Education NAEA2011aileenwilson
 
Research Presentation Heather
Research Presentation HeatherResearch Presentation Heather
Research Presentation Heatheraileenwilson
 
NAEA Presentation 2010
NAEA Presentation 2010NAEA Presentation 2010
NAEA Presentation 2010aileenwilson
 
Teachingportfolio 2009
Teachingportfolio 2009Teachingportfolio 2009
Teachingportfolio 2009aileenwilson
 
Aileen Wilson- thesis
Aileen Wilson- thesisAileen Wilson- thesis
Aileen Wilson- thesisaileenwilson
 
Gender & Violence Presentation
Gender & Violence PresentationGender & Violence Presentation
Gender & Violence Presentationaileenwilson
 
Visualizing Research Design, NAEA Presentation 2009
Visualizing Research Design, NAEA Presentation 2009Visualizing Research Design, NAEA Presentation 2009
Visualizing Research Design, NAEA Presentation 2009aileenwilson
 
Drawing (violent) acts: Adolescent's search for meaningful expression, NAEA P...
Drawing (violent) acts: Adolescent's search for meaningful expression, NAEA P...Drawing (violent) acts: Adolescent's search for meaningful expression, NAEA P...
Drawing (violent) acts: Adolescent's search for meaningful expression, NAEA P...aileenwilson
 
Youth Cultures Presentation
Youth Cultures PresentationYouth Cultures Presentation
Youth Cultures Presentationaileenwilson
 
Examples Of Student Work from Fall 07
Examples Of Student Work from Fall 07Examples Of Student Work from Fall 07
Examples Of Student Work from Fall 07aileenwilson
 
Saturday Art School
Saturday Art SchoolSaturday Art School
Saturday Art Schoolaileenwilson
 

Plus de aileenwilson (16)

Presentation judyfeb2012
Presentation judyfeb2012Presentation judyfeb2012
Presentation judyfeb2012
 
NAEA Research2011-Aileen
NAEA Research2011-AileenNAEA Research2011-Aileen
NAEA Research2011-Aileen
 
Cont Art and Education NAEA2011
Cont Art and Education NAEA2011Cont Art and Education NAEA2011
Cont Art and Education NAEA2011
 
Research Presentation Heather
Research Presentation HeatherResearch Presentation Heather
Research Presentation Heather
 
NAEA Presentation 2010
NAEA Presentation 2010NAEA Presentation 2010
NAEA Presentation 2010
 
Teachingportfolio 2009
Teachingportfolio 2009Teachingportfolio 2009
Teachingportfolio 2009
 
Openstudioimages
OpenstudioimagesOpenstudioimages
Openstudioimages
 
Aileen Wilson- thesis
Aileen Wilson- thesisAileen Wilson- thesis
Aileen Wilson- thesis
 
Gender & Violence Presentation
Gender & Violence PresentationGender & Violence Presentation
Gender & Violence Presentation
 
Visualizing Research Design, NAEA Presentation 2009
Visualizing Research Design, NAEA Presentation 2009Visualizing Research Design, NAEA Presentation 2009
Visualizing Research Design, NAEA Presentation 2009
 
Drawing (violent) acts: Adolescent's search for meaningful expression, NAEA P...
Drawing (violent) acts: Adolescent's search for meaningful expression, NAEA P...Drawing (violent) acts: Adolescent's search for meaningful expression, NAEA P...
Drawing (violent) acts: Adolescent's search for meaningful expression, NAEA P...
 
Youth Cultures Presentation
Youth Cultures PresentationYouth Cultures Presentation
Youth Cultures Presentation
 
Examples Of Student Work from Fall 07
Examples Of Student Work from Fall 07Examples Of Student Work from Fall 07
Examples Of Student Work from Fall 07
 
NAEA 3 14 07
NAEA 3 14 07NAEA 3 14 07
NAEA 3 14 07
 
Saturday Art School
Saturday Art SchoolSaturday Art School
Saturday Art School
 
ADE 630 final
ADE 630 finalADE 630 final
ADE 630 final
 

Kristine NAEA

  • 1. How can assessments be designed in a way that authentically show the layered evidence inherent in arts-based learning? Kristina Lamour Sansone Associate Professor, Design The Art Institute of Boston at Lesley University Lisa Donovan Divison Director, Creative Arts in Learning The School of Education at Lesley University NAEA 2011, Seattle
  • 2. Documentation must become a central part of our work in education. So often, significant learning goals are met when students are exploring ideas [through arts based inquiry such as drawing, making videos, creating models, dramatizing stories and in other forms of investigation)] but not fully realized because there is often too much data in a variety of forms to show the layers of learning happening “in the moment.” We must find ways to make visible the power and nuance of this work in ways that can change what counts as appropriate tools for assessment.
  • 3. Example 1: Mastway Elementary School David McCormick’s 4th grade Lee, New Hampshire
  • 4. The learning goal from David’s perspective The objective for the whole thing — it’s very dry. The objectives for the whole unit are understanding the history of the Lamprey River. If you ever see the Lamprey River, it’s about as wide as this classroom at its widest. It’s probably about this deep. But historically it had an impact in this area. It was traveled during colonial times. The work that’s led up to this is we’ve talked about food chains and habitats and changing environment and changing where the animal lives and all that. So trying to get [students] to see — to understand not only the animal, but also the river and the habitat… that’s…the overall goal. But also, I’m trying to get them — we’re working a lot on their objectives in writing and descriptive writing. And…once we get going, we’ll be doing a lot of dialogue and how to write that.
  • 5. In arts-integration there is often a cumbersome stack of contact sheets, field notes interview transcripts, classroom discussion, and video data. ALL show aspects of the learning going on. How do we select the most salient data, prioritize it and then design assessment that consider various perspectives?
  • 6.
  • 7.
  • 8.
  • 9. teacher transformation a teacher’s lifespan content area teacher before arts integration teacher after arts integration show examples of teaching processes, environment, risk-taking before and after mirrored processes his own witnessing in students
  • 10. Example 2: The Charles Sumner School 3rd grade classroom Roslindale, Massachusetts
  • 11.
  • 12.
  • 13. Example 3 Monument Mountain High School Dance Integration
  • 14.
  • 15. How can the design of documentation provide a feedback loop tool for the student and for the teacher? For the multiple skateholders? How can documentation serve to make visible all that has occurred in learning? This includes the planned objectives but also other interesting connections and discoveries. How can graphic design process help to steer the reading we want of the in-depth learning experience including where the learning goals are met?