SlideShare une entreprise Scribd logo
1  sur  14
SECURITIZATION OF INTANGIBLE ASSETS | STRUCTURED FINANCE REPORT 1
STRUCTURED FINANCE
SECURITIZATION OF
INTANGIBLE ASSETS
FINAL REPORT SUBMISSION
This submission was made to Prof. Prantik Ray
Submitted by:
Aishwary Kumar Gupta
B15066
SECURITIZATION OF INTANGIBLE ASSETS | STRUCTURED FINANCE REPORT 2
Contents
INTRODUCTION....................................................................................................................................3
TYPES OF INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY ASSETS......................................................................................4
VALUING AN INTANGIBLE ASSET ........................................................................................................5
IDENTIFICATION OF SECURITIZABLE INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY........................................................10
PROCESS OF IP SECURITIZATION .......................................................................................................10
ADVANTAGES OF INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY SECURITIZATION .........................................................10
DISADVANTAGES OF INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY SECURITIZATION ....................................................11
CASE: DRUG ROYALTY III L.P. 1 (SERIES 2016-1)............................................................................12
PROBLEMS CONCERNING IPR SECURITIZATION.................................................................................12
CONCLUSION.....................................................................................................................................13
REFERENCES .....................................................................................................................................14
SECURITIZATION OF INTANGIBLE ASSETS | STRUCTURED FINANCE REPORT 3
INTRODUCTION
The location of Wrigley field is mostly residential. It is surrounded by residential apartments on both
the sides. For years, the lucky residents of those apartment buildings happily set up chairs on their
roofs and enjoyed the view of the game, free of cost, at leisure. But later, say a decade ago, some
building owners saw an opportunity in it. They decided to make money out of it, and wanted to
capitalize on their views. That idea gave birth to an intangible asset: Viewing Rights. The economic
value of the buildings in that area went up as intangible viewing rights became more important than
the regular rental income from the apartments. Many of the owners provided viewing rights coupled
with refreshments, and this gave them a steady flow of income for some time.
It’s interesting to note as to how a Cubs’ game moved from a proto-asset to giving birth to an
identifiable intangible asset, which in this case is also easily quantifiable. It wasn’t quite late when
the Tribune Company (owners of the Cubs’ franchise) realized that they were losing out in the
scenario, and that it needed to secure its ownership with respect to viewing the game. It did so, both
through legal channels, and through physically blocking the view from the rooftop of the buildings,
by installing screens and other devices. As a result, the business of the building owners suffered a
blow, the owners faced decreased security for the viewing rights. The two stakeholders soon reached
a consensus, wherein the rooftop business owners agreed to pay a royalty to the team and also agreed
that the Tribune had property rights there. On the other hand, the rooftop owners were assured that
the revenues associated with Cubs’ watching would continue with relative stability, and any physical
blockage of the view shall be removed. In this way, both the parties securitized their positions and
gained in the long run.
It is interesting to note as to how this example shows how something as simple as watching a game
from rooftop, can become a major business and eventually be seen as an intangible asset which is
being fought for and then securitized. Have laid the foundation, let’s now define intangible assets, its
different types and the history behind it.
INTANGIBLE ASSETS
IAS 38 defines Intangible Assets as assets which are without physical substance and identifiable.
Simply put, an intangible asset is an asset that is not physical in nature. Intangible assets can be
classified into three parts:
 Intellectual Property: Any product that is an application of human intellect, is novel,
unobvious, and to which some value can be attached, even if not assessed easily. It can be of
multiple forms: inventions, business methods, chemical formulae, designs used in commerce,
literary and artistic works, etc.
 Intellectual Capital: This can be defined as a business advantage that arises as a result of
employees of the Company (human capital), or the business model of the Company coupled
with trade secrets, or something as intangible as Company’s network or relationship with
other companies. Trade secrets, a part of Intellectual Capital, are sensitive business
information that provides a company a competitive edge over others.
 Goodwill: Goodwill is the excess value paid post acquisitions, over and above the book value
of the assets acquired.
Of the three kinds mentioned above, only Intellectual Property can be securitized and the reasons
for securitizing it are:
SECURITIZATION OF INTANGIBLE ASSETS | STRUCTURED FINANCE REPORT 4
 Reducing chances of wrongful imitation by the competitors, and thereby losing the
competitive edge
 Creating more opportunities for commercializing new products
 Greater safety against violation of IP rights
HISTORY OF INTANGIBLE ASSETS
The first ever incident of securitizing intangible asset owes its credit to the musician David Bowie,
way back in the year 1997. He popularized the concept of securitization by creating a $55 million
issuance of asset-backed bonds. The collateral was future royalties from some 25 albums Bowie
recorded before 1990. The investors were intrigued by Bowie’s creation that they named the bonds
after him and since then “Bowie bonds” have come to mean any bond backed by intangible assets.
These comprise offerings in film and television, literary works, and games. Although these bonds
have fared poorly for their guarantor, the concept has found merit with a lot of investors.
TYPES OF INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY ASSETS
Securitization of IP assets has seen the most development in the recent years. Although the purview
of intangible assets is very wide, most of these assets are under the books as copyrights, trademarks
or patents.
COPYRIGHT
The aim of the copyright law is to incentivize the creation of creative work. It grants the author of the
economic and moral rights of his creations. These exclusive rights are subject to a time limit and
generally expire seventy years after the death of the author. The author or his/her legal authority can
transfer copyright or can grant exclusive and non-exclusive licences.
Securitization in the field of copyright is still nascent and not a widespread practise. However, its
advantages are immense. It would provide with authors the opportunity to recoup their expenses.
Largely, this practise has yet only been adopted by the entertainment & media industry where
projects have been proven to be successful. Bowie Bonds of 1997 are a popular example of
securitization of copyright licences.
More recently in 2014, Miramax Film securitized its Film library containing more than 700 titles
(such as Pulp Fiction, Chicago, Good Will Hunting, etc.) for $250 million 3.34% notes due 2026 as
well as a $25 million revolving credit facility, which was undrawn at closing. The notes were rated
BBB+ by Standard & Poor’s and BBB (High) by DBRS.
TRADEMARK
A trademark is defined as the symbol which identifies the source of the product. Owners invest in
their products and by providing a consistent quality and experience in their product and service
offering and further also invest in trademarks to exhibit their commitment. Trademarks also benefit
customers by saving them search costs by relying on familiar products and services. This helps in
creating a captive market for their products by creating goodwill and reputation.
Traditionally, trademark protection is enforced only when it is used in commerce. However, in the
past century, some trademarks have come to represent lifestyle choices and hence these trademarks
have become extremely valuable to their owners. In the US, firms such as the restaurant and fast
food chains Arby’s, Dunkin Donuts, Domino’s Pizza, Sonic, Quizno’s, Applebee’s and IHOP, the
Hilton chain of hotels, fashion houses Candie’s and BCBG Max Azaria, the athletic footwear retailer
SECURITIZATION OF INTANGIBLE ASSETS | STRUCTURED FINANCE REPORT 5
Athlete’s Foot, and the retail chain Sears have used their trademarks to raise interim funds for their
business.
Bill Blass, a famous fashion designer who had a big portfolio of products under his trademark
securitized the future revenue streams coming in from his trademark in 1999. The securities against
his trademark received a rating of Baa3 by Moody’s, which was significantly higher than that of Bill
Blass’s fashion house. This was because simply the act of securitization divided the securitized
assets from other operating risks of the firm.
PATENT
Patents are meant to reward innovators by providing them a legal monopoly for a limited time to
incentivize innovation. This gives the innovators the legal right to prevent others from copying their
ideas. The time period in general by the US law is 20 years from the filing date of the patent.
The first known example of using patents to raise financing was of Thomas Alva Edison. He would
go on to utilize his patent on incandescent bulb as collateral towards repayment of the loan he took in
order to start the company which today is General Electric.
In 2012, DRI Capital securitized cash flows on 18 royalty streams from 14 patent-protected drugs,
amounted to a total of $195 million. The issue was rated Baa3 by Moody’s and BBB by Standard &
Poor’s. The issue was over-collateralized by as much as 34 % of the issue size.
VALUING AN INTANGIBLE ASSET
The first step in securitization of an intangible asset is the process of determining the value of the
asset itself. Since, these assets are intangible, the methods required for valuation are different and
sometimes unconventional.
Traditional Methods
 Income-Approach method
 Market-based Method
 Replacement-Cost Method
Non-Traditional Methods
 Binomial, Options, etc
TRADITIONAL METHODS
Income-Approach method
The director of a B-School has been approached by the administration with the idea of doing away
with the tea/coffee vending machine for professors. Professors gather around the vending machine
couple of times a day and would often talk about sports, local news, etc. The administration argues
that the machine acts as a distraction and actually pulls away the professors from doing their real
work, i.e. research.
The director decides to value the prospect of having a break room before he reaches a conclusion. He
asks the finance officer to value the prospect of having a vending machine.
The officer first decides to value the cash flows from the sale of the items from the vending machine.
Suppose the weighted average profit earned from the sale of one item from the machine is Rs. 5/unit.
SECURITIZATION OF INTANGIBLE ASSETS | STRUCTURED FINANCE REPORT 6
The school does not pay anything for the restocking and is kept fully stocked by the local distributor.
Since, the average faculty size of 80 is almost the same year-on-year, a simplification would be to
assume that each faculty on an average buys 2 items from the machine every work day. With 240
work days in a year on average, the yearly cash flow to the school will be = 5 * 80 (faculty size) * 2
(items/day) * 240 (work days) = Rs. 192000/year. The distributor gives the payment to the school on
a yearly basis. Since the prices of F&B products does not change drastically with time and taking a
horizon of 4 years for the sake of simplification, the present value of cash inflows from the vending
machine can be computed as follows –
PVcash inflow = 192000/(1+r) + 192000/[(1+r)^2] + 192000/[(1+r)^3] + 192000/[(1+r)^4]
Here, from the Capital Asset Pricing Model, we know that
ri = rf + β* ( rm – rf )
Here, it is safe to assume β=1 since the F&B business closely replicates the market dynamics. At
rf=6% and risk premium of 3%, we obtain –
ri = 6% + 1 * 3% = 9%
PVcash inflow = 192000/(1+0.09) + 192000/[(1+0.09)^2] + 192000/[(1+0.09)^3] + 192000/[(1+0.09)^4]
= Rs. 622026
Calculating Lost Wages –
Let’s assume that each professor spends 15 mins a day on the vending machine in taking his item and
talking with his/her peers.
Therefore, lost time = 80 * 0.25 (hours) = 20 hours/day
Assuming a 8 hour work day and 240 work days and each professor earning a salary of Rs. 19.2
lakh/annum, the hourly wage of a professor will be = 1920000/(8*240) = Rs. 1000/hr
Therefore, lost wages per day = 1000 * 20 = Rs. 20000/day
Lost Wages Annually = 20000 * 240 = Rs. 4800000/annum
Using DCF method to compute the cost over four years,
PVcost = 4800000/(1+0.09) + 4800000/[(1+0.09)^2] + 4800000/[(1+0.09)^3] + 4800000/[(1+0.09)^4]
= Rs. 15550655
On the face of it, it seems that eliminating the vending machine will lead to 15550655 – 622026 =
Rs. 14928629 of savings in lost wages and productivity.
When he showed his workings to the Director, he pointed out that not all vending machine
discussions are purely non-work related. Some discussions also relate to academic and scholarly
excellence which help in building the brand equity of the school. The discussions also facilitate
cross-functional collaboration on research papers.
This research excellence and opportunity helps in letting the school charge a 25% premium over the
average b-school fees of 16 lakhs of the same grade. This translates to a premium of 4 lakh/student.
For 360 students annually, this translates to Rs. 144000000/annum.
However, the entire contribution towards premium cannot be attributed to academic excellence.
SECURITIZATION OF INTANGIBLE ASSETS | STRUCTURED FINANCE REPORT 7
Factors allowing for the school to charge premium (Rs. 144000000) = Academic Excellence + Better
Placements + Unknowns
Roughly allotting one-third of the premium to academic excellence, the figure we obtain is Rs.
48000000. Let us assume for simplification that the vending machine contributes only 40% towards
helping academic excellence, the figure is Rs. 19200000.
Therefore, if the director decides to eliminate the vending machine, the net benefit of Rs. 14928629
will be overwhelmed by savings of Rs. 19200000.
At a net value of Rs. 4271371, eliminating the vending machine does not seem like the best idea.
Even though, the methodology takes into account many assumptions for the sake of simplicity, the
general idea behind the calculations is logical. The assumptions will cease to be subjective as there
are more and more sub-divisions.
Market-Based Approach
The market based approach for valuation of assets using comparable assets works best when the
asset under question is homogeneous. Therefore, the market based approach works best for
commodities, whose attributes are easily delineated and easy to compare in a market that is actively
traded. The market based approach is linked to other valuation principles such as; the valuation of
the reference asset must take into account the discounted value of the future cash flows from the
asset. Therefore, the implicit assumption is that the comparable assets are priced correctly. In case
the reference asset is overvalues or undervalued, so will the subject asset.
This make the market-based valuation of an intangible asset more difficult because of its
heterogeneity. However, the approach allows us gain some idea of the boundary values of the subject
asset. Let us look at an example to see how the value of an intangible asset varies widely based on
the context –
Suppose you wish to value a patent for a pharmaceutical company’s insulin medication designed for
patients with very high BMI index. For a good comparable analysis, we will take into account asset
prices at different depths and scope of similarity.
 All pharma patents
 Just insulin related patents
 Just patents pertaining to high BMI index patients
 Just insulin for high BMI index patients
At first thought, we will be tempted to use the most recent transaction for the category with the
narrowest market definition i.e. insulin for high BMI index patients. However, one must enquire
deeply about the reasons for the value they paid for their transactions.
Some factors to consider might be –
 Fit with existing portfolio
 History
 Scope of the patent
 Remaining useful life of the patent
 Likelihood of infringement of the patent
It is possible that for the most recent transaction which we plan to use as reference asset, for the
buyer, this patent might be a missing piece in its portfolio of medication and therefore might have
paid a premium for it. The same might not be the case for us for our subject asset.
SECURITIZATION OF INTANGIBLE ASSETS | STRUCTURED FINANCE REPORT 8
This is a small example to show how when even one factor which is different for valuation, the
market based approach becomes difficult to use. Therefore, the context of the transaction matters and
neutralizing its effect is not entirely possible.
Below, we will discuss a small real-world example of how such adjustments might be done.
Value of a trademark of a U.S. Cosmetic company which licences its trademark to several companies
in the Latin American market for use in their respective territories. The company will also provide
marketing support to these companies on a need basis. For a reference transaction, we consider the
most recent available transaction available with the terms: exclusive licence to the trademark with no
upfront fee and a running royalty rate of 7 % of net sales to a Western European company for a
period of 5 years. The adjustments made for the trademark are as follows:
 Location: Trademark valuation can differ widely between geographies. However, here it was
concluded that the value of trademarks in the cosmetic industry in the given geographies were
comparable and hence, no adjustment was required.
 Advertising Support: To help launch the brands in the new territories, the licensor has agreed
to provide market development support of up to $1 million in the first year. The royalty rate
was adjusted upward by 0.2 % to compensate the licensor for this added expense.
 IP Strength: Trademark protection and ability to manage the use of marks is determined to be
lower in Latin America than in Europe. Subjectively, royalty was decreased by 0.5% to
account for this.
 Length: Length of the licence is an important factor in determining the value. However, in
this instance the expectation is that the agreement would likely be renewed at the end of the
three year period, so no adjustment was performed.
Replacement Cost Method-
It is a forward looking method on how to create an asset with similar functionality to the asset in
question. A common usage of the method is the cost to design around a patent or a set of patents.
Many experts believe that the replacement cost method has little credence in IP valuation because; (i)
the legal protection of IP makes replacement difficult and (ii) with the legal protection, the
replacement cost for many IP assets is effectively zero. Nonetheless, the method is an efficient
measure for us to establish a ‘floor’ and ‘ceiling’ price.
In the following example, we try to determine the value of an Auto dealer network. Here, we do not
speak about valuing the dealership directly but the intangible asset of the network of relationships
between the distributor and the independent franchise dealerships. Here, the replacement cost is the
only viable method to value the network in the absence of any direct cash flows arising from the
intangible dealer relationship asset.
SECURITIZATION OF INTANGIBLE ASSETS | STRUCTURED FINANCE REPORT 9
The above shows the value of the dealer network arrived using Establishment & Support Costs. The
establishment costs include the efforts put into identification of site and the costs to establish the
dealer. This represents the cost to create a completely new dealer network. However, these costs
must be reduced due to changing consumer trends and demographics, obsolescence of the existing
network, etc. These costs are further supplemented by support costs in training, accounting support,
etc.
NON-TRADITIONAL METHODS
Over the past decade or so, we have seen the growth of new and non-traditional methods of
valuation. They include real options, binomial methods and Monte Carlo simulations. They are all
based on decision tree models where the conditional events required for the IP to generate revenue is
modelled explicitly. Therefore, these techniques are broadly composed of the following 2 steps:
 Calculate the probability of each favourable event that will make the IP valuable.
 Compute the payoff if the favourable event occurs.
Binomial Method
Using this method, we shall try to value a non-commercialized patent for purposes of negotiated sale.
The case is concerning Bt Corn in the US. The European corn borer caterpillar (ECB) is a pest that
destroys millions of dollars of corn each year. To stop this menace, a new variety of corn called Bt
corn was developed which is resistant from the bacteria. However, the Environmental Protection
Agency (EPA) is concerned that widespread use of Bt corn might make the ECB resistant to
conventional insecticides and affecting modified crop as well. The EPA has therefore mandated a
“refuge” policy in which 20-40% acreage of the farm is to be planted with the conventional corn
which would enable ECB to not generate resistance from the insecticide.
However, compliance to this policy is voluntary and up to the individual farmer. To help ensure
compliance with the refuge policy, a business method patent was obtained to bundle an insurance
policy with Bt Bacteria in the transgenic seed. The patent has 6 remaining years left.
Here, the binomial method is most relevant to use since, the payoff is dependent on the event that the
ECB does not mutate and spread. The valuation model is explained from the following decision tree:
SECURITIZATION OF INTANGIBLE ASSETS | STRUCTURED FINANCE REPORT 10
CHOOSING THE RIGHT VALUATION METHOD-
IP valuation is not yet advanced as is business valuation with much research done on the subject.
Therefore, there does not exist a hierarchy of methods to be used and all methods are equally
applicable. Thus, most experts urge people to employ multiple valuation methods for a given asset to
determine the robustness of the valuation. However, this is always pragmatically not possible due to
lack of financial/economic data or due to lack of precedent. Therefore, one must be on the lookout
for new and improved methods when it comes to the matter of valuing an intangible asset.
IDENTIFICATION OF SECURITIZABLE INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY
It must be noted that not all intellectual property is considered fit by the investors to be securitized.
For IP assets to be effectively securitized, they must have the following characteristics –
 Can be separately identified from other intangible assets
 Can be legally protected
 Are able to generate cash flows (income)
 Provide access to exclusive Research & Development
 Can be valued
Therefore, a quantifiable and legible flow of consistent cash stream arising from commerce activities
arising out of IP backed business is a requirement for the IP to be securitizable.
PROCESS OF IP SECURITIZATION
The IP Securitization process is not that different from that of a regular asset-backed securitization
process.
A typical IP Securitization process happens as follows –
 The royalty stream arising from the IP is transferred to a Special Purpose Vehicle (SPV). This
step is important to ensure that the IP assets will not be affected by the originator’s
bankruptcy. This transaction is tailored to be a ‘true sale’.
 The SPV next issues securities to the capital market. The offer may be bundled with credit
enhancement features to obtain a better credit rating. Most of these transactions happen by
private placement. A portion of the issuance capital may be set aside in a debt service reserve
fund.
 Rating of the issue is assigned to the security by the rating agencies. They typically go
through 3-5 years of financial history of the company’s portfolio and uses it to project the
performance of the company.
 It may also be prudent for the issuing firm to acquire additional IP which may act as ‘choke
points’ if left outside the vehicle.
ADVANTAGES OF INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY SECURITIZATION
In this section, we try to analyse the benefits of securitization from the different perspectives –
originators, investors and the public for expansion and diversification of the fields of creativity and
innovation.
SECURITIZATION OF INTANGIBLE ASSETS | STRUCTURED FINANCE REPORT 11
 Access to Non-Bank Credit – The securitization procedure acts as a substitute to bank credit.
Banks are subject to many regulations from the government and is limited by the amount of
its own capital. The access to wider range of credit not only promotes credit to innovative
people seeking financing but lowers the cost of financing overall.
 Lowering of Financing Costs – We have seen from previous examples that securitization of
IP rights allows originators to raise credit cheaply, since the credit risk involved in the IP
backed assets is lower as they are separated from the operating risk of the entire business.
 Off-Balance Sheet Financing - According to accounting principles, a secured loan should
appear as a liability on the balance sheet of the borrowing company. In contrast, obtaining
credit through securitization is considered off balance-sheet financing since, from an
accounting perspective, the securitization replaces one type of asset, future royalty streams,
with a different type of asset, liquid money. Off-balance-sheet financing is attractive for the
originator since it does not increase its debt-to-equity ratio and as a result has no negative
impact on the originator’s creditworthiness.
 Maintain Ownership rights in the Originator - An originator who securitizes royalty income
streams from IP rights is not separated from her rights; rather, the royalty income streams
revert to her possession when the asset-backed securities are fully repaid.
 Supporting Investments in Research, Development and Creativity – The ability to monetize
IP assets through securitization provides the originator with capital as and when he needs it.
The liquid capital can be invested in creating further IP assets which can further be
securitized and so on.
DISADVANTAGES OF INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY
SECURITIZATION
 If the primary asset of the company is the securitized IP asset, a default on the loan could lead
to liquidation of the IP and eventual turmoil for the company.
 Since the valuation of IP backed securities is difficult than for tangible assets, potential
creditors are not willing to invest readily as they do not know how the asset prices react to
market conditions.
 Intangible assets are far less liquid than tangible assets. This may restrict the width of
investors willing to invest in such assets.
 The IP securitization market is still in its nascent phase. This might make it a more expensive
financing alternative than traditional financing.
SECURITIZATION OF INTANGIBLE ASSETS | STRUCTURED FINANCE REPORT 12
CASE: DRUG ROYALTY III L.P. 1 (SERIES 2016-1)
Drug Royalty III LP 1 is the SPV set up to issue $145 million Senior Secured Class A Notes which is
backed by 8 royalty streams on seven patent-protected drugs and technologies. DRI Capital Inc. will
serve as the servicer of the issue. The offer profile snapshot is attached as follows –
A preliminary rating of BBB was given to the issue by the rating agency Standard & Poor’s. The
report mentions the overcollateralization of 42 % implicit in the issue.
The report further goes on to detail the rationale behind the rating, the industry & transaction
overview, details about the servicer, the underwriter, credit analysis, scenario analysis, payment
priority details and covenants relating to specific events such as default, etc.
The entire report can be accessed on:
https://www.spratings.com/documents/20184/769219/Drug+Royalty+III+L.P.+1+(Series+2016-
1).pdf/15da8dee-b8bc-4d1a-9115-50e0fed539b2
PROBLEMS CONCERNING IPR SECURITIZATION
Some problems relating to IPR securitization can be divided into the following categories-
1) Valuation & Cash Flows - Difficulty in predicting future cash flows due to IP specific risk
factors. Valuation of an IP still remains a developing area and there are various disputes over
methodology and veracity of the method used.
2) Characteristics of the assets to be securitized – Assets targeted for securitization are for the
royalties from the IPRs. To specify the assets to be securitized, it is necessary to correctly
identify the relationship between the subject IPR and third parties.
3) Transfer of Assets to be Securitized – Transfer of assets which need to be securitized may
include (i) transferability, (ii) true sales, (iii) effectiveness against third parties, (iv) risk of
cancellation of a license contract, and (v) evaluation of the IP concerned.
4) Credit Enhancement – The possibility of evaluating risk of failure of an IPR is difficult. This
creates a lot of issues that even a credit enhancement measure such as insurance would not
pay due to the high insurance premium rate.
SECURITIZATION OF INTANGIBLE ASSETS | STRUCTURED FINANCE REPORT 13
5) Balance of Disclosure – The owner faces the problem of balance of disclosure to investors
along with confidential technical information during issue of securities.
6) Handling after the implementation of the securitization – There are issues which need to be
taken care of after implementation of the securitization such as treatment of improvement
patents, how to handle annual patent fees, etc.
CONCLUSION
From the above discussion, we can conclude that the securitization of IPRs involves great
complexity. Even developed markets such as USA & Europe are not fully prepared for IP
securitization. Currently, the costs to build a securitization scheme for IPRs is enormous and the
volume of securities needs to be extremely large for it to become feasible for everyone.
In the current age, IP rights are more significant than ever. Securitization of tangible assets has
proven to be a credible financing source for many companies. Securitization allows for the
capitalization of IP rights that yield a foreseeable royalty stream in order to raise interim funds for
business activities. The growth of the securitization market has been steady and has not yet realized
its full potential.
Companies’ financing needs and growing Investors’ risk appetite will soon discover the rewards that
can be offered from the currently untapped potential of securitization of IP-backed assets.
SECURITIZATION OF INTANGIBLE ASSETS | STRUCTURED FINANCE REPORT 14
REFERENCES
 Ariel Glasner, Making Something Out of “Nothing” The Trend Towards Securitizing
Intellectual Property and the Legal Obstacles That Remain, 3 J. LEGAL TECH. RISK
MGMT.27,37, 39–40 (2008); Kaufmann, supra note 37, at 241.
 Kirsch, Alexander C. (2007). Intellectual property securitization. Germany: VDM Verlag Dr.
Muller.
 Bruce W. Burton, Financing Alternatives for Companies: Using Intellectual Property as
Collateral
 http://www.reuters.com/article/drug-royalties-abs-idUSL2E8E58LS20120305, Accessed on 3
Feb 2017
 http://www.wipo.int/edocs/mdocs/sme/en/wipo_wasme_ipr_ge_03/wipo_wasme_ipr_ge_03_
17.pdf, Accessed on 5 Feb 2017
 https://www.iip.or.jp/e/e_summary/pdf/detail2003/e15_20.pdf, Accessed on 7 Feb 2017
 http://nopr.niscair.res.in/bitstream/123456789/3563/1/JIPR%2011(2)%2098-102.pdf,
Accessed on 9 Feb 2017
 https://www.spratings.com/documents/20184/769219/Drug+Royalty+III+L.P.+1+(Series+20
16-1).pdf/15da8dee-b8bc-4d1a-9115-50e0fed539b2, Accessed on 28 Jan 2017
 http://www.miramax.com/press/miramax-completes-securitization-250-million/, Accessed on
13 Jan 2017

Contenu connexe

Tendances

Biomimetic architecture
Biomimetic architectureBiomimetic architecture
Biomimetic architectureMaheen Xawer
 
Cladding - Intro and types
Cladding - Intro and typesCladding - Intro and types
Cladding - Intro and typesMohith Rai
 
This entry analyses the Corfu Channel Case, the first case before the Interna...
This entry analyses the Corfu Channel Case, the first case before the Interna...This entry analyses the Corfu Channel Case, the first case before the Interna...
This entry analyses the Corfu Channel Case, the first case before the Interna...Utkarsh Kumar
 
School of thoughts in psychology
School of thoughts in psychologySchool of thoughts in psychology
School of thoughts in psychologyTasneem Saifee
 
John Locke.Ppt Final
John Locke.Ppt FinalJohn Locke.Ppt Final
John Locke.Ppt FinalBenning22
 
Contracts in Private International Law
Contracts in Private International LawContracts in Private International Law
Contracts in Private International Lawcarolineelias239
 
folded plate structure
folded plate structure folded plate structure
folded plate structure SumayyaSayeeda
 
Intellgence
IntellgenceIntellgence
Intellgencer g
 
Climate Change and the Built Environment
Climate Change and the Built EnvironmentClimate Change and the Built Environment
Climate Change and the Built EnvironmentEdge Hill University
 
METALS IN CONSTRUCTION.pptx
METALS IN CONSTRUCTION.pptxMETALS IN CONSTRUCTION.pptx
METALS IN CONSTRUCTION.pptxAnkita Bajpai
 
ALUMINIUM AS A BUILDING MATERIAL dissertation
ALUMINIUM AS A BUILDING MATERIAL dissertationALUMINIUM AS A BUILDING MATERIAL dissertation
ALUMINIUM AS A BUILDING MATERIAL dissertationArchDuty
 
Jeddah haj terminal
Jeddah haj terminalJeddah haj terminal
Jeddah haj terminalbansaldhruv
 
Cool Roofing and Building enveloping
Cool Roofing and Building envelopingCool Roofing and Building enveloping
Cool Roofing and Building envelopingArnav Mathur
 
Energy efficiency ENERGY EFFICIENT ARCHITECTURE
Energy efficiency ENERGY EFFICIENT ARCHITECTUREEnergy efficiency ENERGY EFFICIENT ARCHITECTURE
Energy efficiency ENERGY EFFICIENT ARCHITECTUREShabana Kotta
 
conflict of Laws or Private International Law
conflict of Laws or Private International Lawconflict of Laws or Private International Law
conflict of Laws or Private International Lawcarolineelias239
 

Tendances (20)

Biomimetic architecture
Biomimetic architectureBiomimetic architecture
Biomimetic architecture
 
Cladding - Intro and types
Cladding - Intro and typesCladding - Intro and types
Cladding - Intro and types
 
This entry analyses the Corfu Channel Case, the first case before the Interna...
This entry analyses the Corfu Channel Case, the first case before the Interna...This entry analyses the Corfu Channel Case, the first case before the Interna...
This entry analyses the Corfu Channel Case, the first case before the Interna...
 
Muslim marriages
Muslim marriagesMuslim marriages
Muslim marriages
 
School of thoughts in psychology
School of thoughts in psychologySchool of thoughts in psychology
School of thoughts in psychology
 
Domicile of Origin
Domicile of OriginDomicile of Origin
Domicile of Origin
 
John Locke.Ppt Final
John Locke.Ppt FinalJohn Locke.Ppt Final
John Locke.Ppt Final
 
Contracts in Private International Law
Contracts in Private International LawContracts in Private International Law
Contracts in Private International Law
 
folded plate structure
folded plate structure folded plate structure
folded plate structure
 
Intellgence
IntellgenceIntellgence
Intellgence
 
Climate Change and the Built Environment
Climate Change and the Built EnvironmentClimate Change and the Built Environment
Climate Change and the Built Environment
 
METALS IN CONSTRUCTION.pptx
METALS IN CONSTRUCTION.pptxMETALS IN CONSTRUCTION.pptx
METALS IN CONSTRUCTION.pptx
 
ALUMINIUM AS A BUILDING MATERIAL dissertation
ALUMINIUM AS A BUILDING MATERIAL dissertationALUMINIUM AS A BUILDING MATERIAL dissertation
ALUMINIUM AS A BUILDING MATERIAL dissertation
 
Jeddah haj terminal
Jeddah haj terminalJeddah haj terminal
Jeddah haj terminal
 
Ulwe case study l
Ulwe case study lUlwe case study l
Ulwe case study l
 
Cool Roofing and Building enveloping
Cool Roofing and Building envelopingCool Roofing and Building enveloping
Cool Roofing and Building enveloping
 
MEMORY
MEMORYMEMORY
MEMORY
 
Energy efficiency ENERGY EFFICIENT ARCHITECTURE
Energy efficiency ENERGY EFFICIENT ARCHITECTUREEnergy efficiency ENERGY EFFICIENT ARCHITECTURE
Energy efficiency ENERGY EFFICIENT ARCHITECTURE
 
Private international law
Private international  lawPrivate international  law
Private international law
 
conflict of Laws or Private International Law
conflict of Laws or Private International Lawconflict of Laws or Private International Law
conflict of Laws or Private International Law
 

En vedette

Factors that allow a Packaged Foods Brand to charge a premium
Factors that allow a Packaged Foods Brand to charge a premiumFactors that allow a Packaged Foods Brand to charge a premium
Factors that allow a Packaged Foods Brand to charge a premiumAishwary Kumar Gupta
 
RC Presentation 2 - 2016
RC Presentation 2 - 2016RC Presentation 2 - 2016
RC Presentation 2 - 2016Gail Silverman
 
M8 acc lesson 8 0 geometry basics
M8 acc lesson 8 0 geometry basicsM8 acc lesson 8 0 geometry basics
M8 acc lesson 8 0 geometry basicslothomas
 
Digipak & poster planning (1)
Digipak & poster planning (1)Digipak & poster planning (1)
Digipak & poster planning (1)Reba05
 
What's new in the OSGi 4.2 Enterprise Release
What's new in the OSGi 4.2 Enterprise ReleaseWhat's new in the OSGi 4.2 Enterprise Release
What's new in the OSGi 4.2 Enterprise ReleaseDavid Bosschaert
 
The Dark Art: Is Music Recommendation Science a Science
The Dark Art: Is Music Recommendation Science a ScienceThe Dark Art: Is Music Recommendation Science a Science
The Dark Art: Is Music Recommendation Science a Sciencempapish
 
Las células umis y mari
Las células umis y mariLas células umis y mari
Las células umis y marigrabugnot
 
Unsung Heroes: Shweta Chari's Toybank
Unsung Heroes: Shweta Chari's ToybankUnsung Heroes: Shweta Chari's Toybank
Unsung Heroes: Shweta Chari's ToybankAishwary Kumar Gupta
 
A2 Media Studies - Digipak analysis
A2 Media Studies - Digipak analysisA2 Media Studies - Digipak analysis
A2 Media Studies - Digipak analysisGliff
 
Aula 4 agitação e mistura
Aula 4   agitação e misturaAula 4   agitação e mistura
Aula 4 agitação e misturaDavi Fogaça
 
A2 Media Studies - Ancillary tasks(planning)
A2 Media Studies - Ancillary tasks(planning)A2 Media Studies - Ancillary tasks(planning)
A2 Media Studies - Ancillary tasks(planning)Gliff
 

En vedette (17)

Factors that allow a Packaged Foods Brand to charge a premium
Factors that allow a Packaged Foods Brand to charge a premiumFactors that allow a Packaged Foods Brand to charge a premium
Factors that allow a Packaged Foods Brand to charge a premium
 
RC Presentation 2 - 2016
RC Presentation 2 - 2016RC Presentation 2 - 2016
RC Presentation 2 - 2016
 
M8 acc lesson 8 0 geometry basics
M8 acc lesson 8 0 geometry basicsM8 acc lesson 8 0 geometry basics
M8 acc lesson 8 0 geometry basics
 
CarbonAds.click
CarbonAds.clickCarbonAds.click
CarbonAds.click
 
Digipak & poster planning (1)
Digipak & poster planning (1)Digipak & poster planning (1)
Digipak & poster planning (1)
 
What's new in the OSGi 4.2 Enterprise Release
What's new in the OSGi 4.2 Enterprise ReleaseWhat's new in the OSGi 4.2 Enterprise Release
What's new in the OSGi 4.2 Enterprise Release
 
The Dark Art: Is Music Recommendation Science a Science
The Dark Art: Is Music Recommendation Science a ScienceThe Dark Art: Is Music Recommendation Science a Science
The Dark Art: Is Music Recommendation Science a Science
 
Las células umis y mari
Las células umis y mariLas células umis y mari
Las células umis y mari
 
MEDICINA VETERINARIA
MEDICINA VETERINARIAMEDICINA VETERINARIA
MEDICINA VETERINARIA
 
Unsung Heroes: Shweta Chari's Toybank
Unsung Heroes: Shweta Chari's ToybankUnsung Heroes: Shweta Chari's Toybank
Unsung Heroes: Shweta Chari's Toybank
 
A2 Media Studies - Digipak analysis
A2 Media Studies - Digipak analysisA2 Media Studies - Digipak analysis
A2 Media Studies - Digipak analysis
 
Aula 4 agitação e mistura
Aula 4   agitação e misturaAula 4   agitação e mistura
Aula 4 agitação e mistura
 
A2 Media Studies - Ancillary tasks(planning)
A2 Media Studies - Ancillary tasks(planning)A2 Media Studies - Ancillary tasks(planning)
A2 Media Studies - Ancillary tasks(planning)
 
Starbucks
StarbucksStarbucks
Starbucks
 
101 lecture 2
101 lecture 2101 lecture 2
101 lecture 2
 
310 lecture 2
310 lecture 2310 lecture 2
310 lecture 2
 
Dibujos Prehistoria
Dibujos PrehistoriaDibujos Prehistoria
Dibujos Prehistoria
 

Similaire à Securitization of Intangible Assets

The Intersection of IP & Bankruptcy (Series: Chapter 11 Potpourri)
The Intersection of IP & Bankruptcy (Series: Chapter 11 Potpourri)The Intersection of IP & Bankruptcy (Series: Chapter 11 Potpourri)
The Intersection of IP & Bankruptcy (Series: Chapter 11 Potpourri)Financial Poise
 
FindLaw | Madoff Trustee Report
FindLaw | Madoff Trustee ReportFindLaw | Madoff Trustee Report
FindLaw | Madoff Trustee ReportLegalDocs
 
12-‹#›1Describe the characteristics, valuation, and amo.docx
12-‹#›1Describe the characteristics, valuation, and amo.docx12-‹#›1Describe the characteristics, valuation, and amo.docx
12-‹#›1Describe the characteristics, valuation, and amo.docxdrennanmicah
 
Legal Issues for Innovators & Inventors (Series: Intellectual Property 201)
Legal Issues for Innovators & Inventors (Series: Intellectual Property 201)Legal Issues for Innovators & Inventors (Series: Intellectual Property 201)
Legal Issues for Innovators & Inventors (Series: Intellectual Property 201)Financial Poise
 
A Strategic Approach to Identifying and Managing Valuable Intellectual Proper...
A Strategic Approach to Identifying and Managing Valuable Intellectual Proper...A Strategic Approach to Identifying and Managing Valuable Intellectual Proper...
A Strategic Approach to Identifying and Managing Valuable Intellectual Proper...Kelley Keller, Esq.
 
Investment banking and secondary markets ppt 999 @ bec doms
Investment banking and secondary markets ppt 999 @ bec domsInvestment banking and secondary markets ppt 999 @ bec doms
Investment banking and secondary markets ppt 999 @ bec domsBabasab Patil
 
INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY 201 2022 - Legal Issues for Innovators & Inventors
INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY 201 2022 - Legal Issues for Innovators & InventorsINTELLECTUAL PROPERTY 201 2022 - Legal Issues for Innovators & Inventors
INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY 201 2022 - Legal Issues for Innovators & InventorsFinancial Poise
 
Legal Issues for Innovators & Inventors (Series: Intellectual Property 201)
Legal Issues for Innovators & Inventors (Series: Intellectual Property 201) Legal Issues for Innovators & Inventors (Series: Intellectual Property 201)
Legal Issues for Innovators & Inventors (Series: Intellectual Property 201) Financial Poise
 
Amir Khoury Why Value Ip Oct 2007 Sent
Amir Khoury      Why Value Ip     Oct 2007    SentAmir Khoury      Why Value Ip     Oct 2007    Sent
Amir Khoury Why Value Ip Oct 2007 SentQRCE
 
Constraints in the media
Constraints in the mediaConstraints in the media
Constraints in the mediaJo Lowes
 
IP - What Every Lawyer & Every Client Must Understand (SERIES: INTELLECTUAL P...
IP - What Every Lawyer & Every Client Must Understand (SERIES: INTELLECTUAL P...IP - What Every Lawyer & Every Client Must Understand (SERIES: INTELLECTUAL P...
IP - What Every Lawyer & Every Client Must Understand (SERIES: INTELLECTUAL P...Financial Poise
 
Choosing, Building, & Protecting Your Brand (Series: Intellectual Property 20...
Choosing, Building, & Protecting Your Brand (Series: Intellectual Property 20...Choosing, Building, & Protecting Your Brand (Series: Intellectual Property 20...
Choosing, Building, & Protecting Your Brand (Series: Intellectual Property 20...Financial Poise
 
Introduction to Key Concepts (Series: Intellectual Property Boot Camp)
Introduction to Key Concepts (Series: Intellectual Property Boot Camp)Introduction to Key Concepts (Series: Intellectual Property Boot Camp)
Introduction to Key Concepts (Series: Intellectual Property Boot Camp)Financial Poise
 
Choosing, Building, & Protecting Your Brand (Series: Intellectual Property 201)
Choosing, Building, & Protecting Your Brand (Series: Intellectual Property 201)Choosing, Building, & Protecting Your Brand (Series: Intellectual Property 201)
Choosing, Building, & Protecting Your Brand (Series: Intellectual Property 201)Financial Poise
 
Intellectual Property in an Hour (Series: One Hour Law School)
Intellectual Property in an Hour (Series: One Hour Law School)Intellectual Property in an Hour (Series: One Hour Law School)
Intellectual Property in an Hour (Series: One Hour Law School)Financial Poise
 
Kendall College Presesntation
Kendall College PresesntationKendall College Presesntation
Kendall College Presesntationmaize12
 
Buying & Selling IP (Series: Intellectual Property 201 - 2020)
Buying & Selling IP (Series: Intellectual Property 201 - 2020)  Buying & Selling IP (Series: Intellectual Property 201 - 2020)
Buying & Selling IP (Series: Intellectual Property 201 - 2020) Financial Poise
 
international-capital-markets-glossary-report-2023.pdf
international-capital-markets-glossary-report-2023.pdfinternational-capital-markets-glossary-report-2023.pdf
international-capital-markets-glossary-report-2023.pdfCarla Caruso, PhD
 

Similaire à Securitization of Intangible Assets (20)

The Intersection of IP & Bankruptcy (Series: Chapter 11 Potpourri)
The Intersection of IP & Bankruptcy (Series: Chapter 11 Potpourri)The Intersection of IP & Bankruptcy (Series: Chapter 11 Potpourri)
The Intersection of IP & Bankruptcy (Series: Chapter 11 Potpourri)
 
FindLaw | Madoff Trustee Report
FindLaw | Madoff Trustee ReportFindLaw | Madoff Trustee Report
FindLaw | Madoff Trustee Report
 
12-‹#›1Describe the characteristics, valuation, and amo.docx
12-‹#›1Describe the characteristics, valuation, and amo.docx12-‹#›1Describe the characteristics, valuation, and amo.docx
12-‹#›1Describe the characteristics, valuation, and amo.docx
 
Legal Issues for Innovators & Inventors (Series: Intellectual Property 201)
Legal Issues for Innovators & Inventors (Series: Intellectual Property 201)Legal Issues for Innovators & Inventors (Series: Intellectual Property 201)
Legal Issues for Innovators & Inventors (Series: Intellectual Property 201)
 
A Strategic Approach to Identifying and Managing Valuable Intellectual Proper...
A Strategic Approach to Identifying and Managing Valuable Intellectual Proper...A Strategic Approach to Identifying and Managing Valuable Intellectual Proper...
A Strategic Approach to Identifying and Managing Valuable Intellectual Proper...
 
Investment banking and secondary markets ppt 999 @ bec doms
Investment banking and secondary markets ppt 999 @ bec domsInvestment banking and secondary markets ppt 999 @ bec doms
Investment banking and secondary markets ppt 999 @ bec doms
 
INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY 201 2022 - Legal Issues for Innovators & Inventors
INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY 201 2022 - Legal Issues for Innovators & InventorsINTELLECTUAL PROPERTY 201 2022 - Legal Issues for Innovators & Inventors
INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY 201 2022 - Legal Issues for Innovators & Inventors
 
Legal Issues for Innovators & Inventors (Series: Intellectual Property 201)
Legal Issues for Innovators & Inventors (Series: Intellectual Property 201) Legal Issues for Innovators & Inventors (Series: Intellectual Property 201)
Legal Issues for Innovators & Inventors (Series: Intellectual Property 201)
 
Amir Khoury Why Value Ip Oct 2007 Sent
Amir Khoury      Why Value Ip     Oct 2007    SentAmir Khoury      Why Value Ip     Oct 2007    Sent
Amir Khoury Why Value Ip Oct 2007 Sent
 
Constraints in the media
Constraints in the mediaConstraints in the media
Constraints in the media
 
Investment Banking Lecture
Investment Banking LectureInvestment Banking Lecture
Investment Banking Lecture
 
IP - What Every Lawyer & Every Client Must Understand (SERIES: INTELLECTUAL P...
IP - What Every Lawyer & Every Client Must Understand (SERIES: INTELLECTUAL P...IP - What Every Lawyer & Every Client Must Understand (SERIES: INTELLECTUAL P...
IP - What Every Lawyer & Every Client Must Understand (SERIES: INTELLECTUAL P...
 
Choosing, Building, & Protecting Your Brand (Series: Intellectual Property 20...
Choosing, Building, & Protecting Your Brand (Series: Intellectual Property 20...Choosing, Building, & Protecting Your Brand (Series: Intellectual Property 20...
Choosing, Building, & Protecting Your Brand (Series: Intellectual Property 20...
 
Introduction to Key Concepts (Series: Intellectual Property Boot Camp)
Introduction to Key Concepts (Series: Intellectual Property Boot Camp)Introduction to Key Concepts (Series: Intellectual Property Boot Camp)
Introduction to Key Concepts (Series: Intellectual Property Boot Camp)
 
Choosing, Building, & Protecting Your Brand (Series: Intellectual Property 201)
Choosing, Building, & Protecting Your Brand (Series: Intellectual Property 201)Choosing, Building, & Protecting Your Brand (Series: Intellectual Property 201)
Choosing, Building, & Protecting Your Brand (Series: Intellectual Property 201)
 
Intellectual Property in an Hour (Series: One Hour Law School)
Intellectual Property in an Hour (Series: One Hour Law School)Intellectual Property in an Hour (Series: One Hour Law School)
Intellectual Property in an Hour (Series: One Hour Law School)
 
Kendall College Presesntation
Kendall College PresesntationKendall College Presesntation
Kendall College Presesntation
 
Buying & Selling IP (Series: Intellectual Property 201 - 2020)
Buying & Selling IP (Series: Intellectual Property 201 - 2020)  Buying & Selling IP (Series: Intellectual Property 201 - 2020)
Buying & Selling IP (Series: Intellectual Property 201 - 2020)
 
The Story of UCC Insurance, An Insider's View
The Story of UCC Insurance, An Insider's ViewThe Story of UCC Insurance, An Insider's View
The Story of UCC Insurance, An Insider's View
 
international-capital-markets-glossary-report-2023.pdf
international-capital-markets-glossary-report-2023.pdfinternational-capital-markets-glossary-report-2023.pdf
international-capital-markets-glossary-report-2023.pdf
 

Plus de Aishwary Kumar Gupta

Effect of FMC-SEBI Merger in India
Effect of FMC-SEBI Merger in IndiaEffect of FMC-SEBI Merger in India
Effect of FMC-SEBI Merger in IndiaAishwary Kumar Gupta
 
Drivers & Motivators of Handicraft Consumption
Drivers & Motivators of Handicraft ConsumptionDrivers & Motivators of Handicraft Consumption
Drivers & Motivators of Handicraft ConsumptionAishwary Kumar Gupta
 
Working Capital Report of Dabur India
Working Capital Report of Dabur IndiaWorking Capital Report of Dabur India
Working Capital Report of Dabur IndiaAishwary Kumar Gupta
 
Investment Analysis Report of Dabur India
Investment Analysis Report of Dabur IndiaInvestment Analysis Report of Dabur India
Investment Analysis Report of Dabur IndiaAishwary Kumar Gupta
 
Stock Pitch Presentation of Apollo Hospitals
Stock Pitch Presentation of Apollo HospitalsStock Pitch Presentation of Apollo Hospitals
Stock Pitch Presentation of Apollo HospitalsAishwary Kumar Gupta
 
Forecasting Road Accident Fatalities in India
Forecasting Road Accident Fatalities in IndiaForecasting Road Accident Fatalities in India
Forecasting Road Accident Fatalities in IndiaAishwary Kumar Gupta
 
Manchester United : Leadership Crisis after 2013
Manchester United : Leadership Crisis after 2013Manchester United : Leadership Crisis after 2013
Manchester United : Leadership Crisis after 2013Aishwary Kumar Gupta
 
How to Increase participation in XLRI's annual management festival ENSEMBLE
How to Increase participation in XLRI's annual management festival ENSEMBLEHow to Increase participation in XLRI's annual management festival ENSEMBLE
How to Increase participation in XLRI's annual management festival ENSEMBLEAishwary Kumar Gupta
 
Group Technology (Cell Manufacturing)
Group Technology (Cell Manufacturing)Group Technology (Cell Manufacturing)
Group Technology (Cell Manufacturing)Aishwary Kumar Gupta
 
Innovations in Distribution in India
Innovations in Distribution in IndiaInnovations in Distribution in India
Innovations in Distribution in IndiaAishwary Kumar Gupta
 
Sustainable Development of the Textile Industry
Sustainable Development of the Textile IndustrySustainable Development of the Textile Industry
Sustainable Development of the Textile IndustryAishwary Kumar Gupta
 

Plus de Aishwary Kumar Gupta (17)

Effect of FMC-SEBI Merger in India
Effect of FMC-SEBI Merger in IndiaEffect of FMC-SEBI Merger in India
Effect of FMC-SEBI Merger in India
 
Chateau Ste Michelle
Chateau Ste MichelleChateau Ste Michelle
Chateau Ste Michelle
 
Sustainable Transportation
Sustainable TransportationSustainable Transportation
Sustainable Transportation
 
Carbon Footprint Analysis
Carbon Footprint AnalysisCarbon Footprint Analysis
Carbon Footprint Analysis
 
Drivers & Motivators of Handicraft Consumption
Drivers & Motivators of Handicraft ConsumptionDrivers & Motivators of Handicraft Consumption
Drivers & Motivators of Handicraft Consumption
 
Working Capital Report of Dabur India
Working Capital Report of Dabur IndiaWorking Capital Report of Dabur India
Working Capital Report of Dabur India
 
FMCG Sector Report
FMCG Sector ReportFMCG Sector Report
FMCG Sector Report
 
Investment Analysis Report of Dabur India
Investment Analysis Report of Dabur IndiaInvestment Analysis Report of Dabur India
Investment Analysis Report of Dabur India
 
Stock Pitch Presentation of Apollo Hospitals
Stock Pitch Presentation of Apollo HospitalsStock Pitch Presentation of Apollo Hospitals
Stock Pitch Presentation of Apollo Hospitals
 
Forecasting Road Accident Fatalities in India
Forecasting Road Accident Fatalities in IndiaForecasting Road Accident Fatalities in India
Forecasting Road Accident Fatalities in India
 
Operations Research Project
Operations Research ProjectOperations Research Project
Operations Research Project
 
Manchester United : Leadership Crisis after 2013
Manchester United : Leadership Crisis after 2013Manchester United : Leadership Crisis after 2013
Manchester United : Leadership Crisis after 2013
 
MoA Analysis of Infosys
MoA Analysis of InfosysMoA Analysis of Infosys
MoA Analysis of Infosys
 
How to Increase participation in XLRI's annual management festival ENSEMBLE
How to Increase participation in XLRI's annual management festival ENSEMBLEHow to Increase participation in XLRI's annual management festival ENSEMBLE
How to Increase participation in XLRI's annual management festival ENSEMBLE
 
Group Technology (Cell Manufacturing)
Group Technology (Cell Manufacturing)Group Technology (Cell Manufacturing)
Group Technology (Cell Manufacturing)
 
Innovations in Distribution in India
Innovations in Distribution in IndiaInnovations in Distribution in India
Innovations in Distribution in India
 
Sustainable Development of the Textile Industry
Sustainable Development of the Textile IndustrySustainable Development of the Textile Industry
Sustainable Development of the Textile Industry
 

Dernier

Pharma Works Profile of Karan Communications
Pharma Works Profile of Karan CommunicationsPharma Works Profile of Karan Communications
Pharma Works Profile of Karan Communicationskarancommunications
 
Value Proposition canvas- Customer needs and pains
Value Proposition canvas- Customer needs and painsValue Proposition canvas- Customer needs and pains
Value Proposition canvas- Customer needs and painsP&CO
 
Monte Carlo simulation : Simulation using MCSM
Monte Carlo simulation : Simulation using MCSMMonte Carlo simulation : Simulation using MCSM
Monte Carlo simulation : Simulation using MCSMRavindra Nath Shukla
 
M.C Lodges -- Guest House in Jhang.
M.C Lodges --  Guest House in Jhang.M.C Lodges --  Guest House in Jhang.
M.C Lodges -- Guest House in Jhang.Aaiza Hassan
 
Call Girls Navi Mumbai Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Avail...
Call Girls Navi Mumbai Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Avail...Call Girls Navi Mumbai Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Avail...
Call Girls Navi Mumbai Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Avail...Dipal Arora
 
Unlocking the Secrets of Affiliate Marketing.pdf
Unlocking the Secrets of Affiliate Marketing.pdfUnlocking the Secrets of Affiliate Marketing.pdf
Unlocking the Secrets of Affiliate Marketing.pdfOnline Income Engine
 
KYC-Verified Accounts: Helping Companies Handle Challenging Regulatory Enviro...
KYC-Verified Accounts: Helping Companies Handle Challenging Regulatory Enviro...KYC-Verified Accounts: Helping Companies Handle Challenging Regulatory Enviro...
KYC-Verified Accounts: Helping Companies Handle Challenging Regulatory Enviro...Any kyc Account
 
Insurers' journeys to build a mastery in the IoT usage
Insurers' journeys to build a mastery in the IoT usageInsurers' journeys to build a mastery in the IoT usage
Insurers' journeys to build a mastery in the IoT usageMatteo Carbone
 
VIP Call Girl Jamshedpur Aashi 8250192130 Independent Escort Service Jamshedpur
VIP Call Girl Jamshedpur Aashi 8250192130 Independent Escort Service JamshedpurVIP Call Girl Jamshedpur Aashi 8250192130 Independent Escort Service Jamshedpur
VIP Call Girl Jamshedpur Aashi 8250192130 Independent Escort Service JamshedpurSuhani Kapoor
 
Boost the utilization of your HCL environment by reevaluating use cases and f...
Boost the utilization of your HCL environment by reevaluating use cases and f...Boost the utilization of your HCL environment by reevaluating use cases and f...
Boost the utilization of your HCL environment by reevaluating use cases and f...Roland Driesen
 
Progress Report - Oracle Database Analyst Summit
Progress  Report - Oracle Database Analyst SummitProgress  Report - Oracle Database Analyst Summit
Progress Report - Oracle Database Analyst SummitHolger Mueller
 
7.pdf This presentation captures many uses and the significance of the number...
7.pdf This presentation captures many uses and the significance of the number...7.pdf This presentation captures many uses and the significance of the number...
7.pdf This presentation captures many uses and the significance of the number...Paul Menig
 
GD Birla and his contribution in management
GD Birla and his contribution in managementGD Birla and his contribution in management
GD Birla and his contribution in managementchhavia330
 
Call Girls In Panjim North Goa 9971646499 Genuine Service
Call Girls In Panjim North Goa 9971646499 Genuine ServiceCall Girls In Panjim North Goa 9971646499 Genuine Service
Call Girls In Panjim North Goa 9971646499 Genuine Serviceritikaroy0888
 
VIP Kolkata Call Girl Howrah 👉 8250192130 Available With Room
VIP Kolkata Call Girl Howrah 👉 8250192130  Available With RoomVIP Kolkata Call Girl Howrah 👉 8250192130  Available With Room
VIP Kolkata Call Girl Howrah 👉 8250192130 Available With Roomdivyansh0kumar0
 
Mysore Call Girls 8617370543 WhatsApp Number 24x7 Best Services
Mysore Call Girls 8617370543 WhatsApp Number 24x7 Best ServicesMysore Call Girls 8617370543 WhatsApp Number 24x7 Best Services
Mysore Call Girls 8617370543 WhatsApp Number 24x7 Best ServicesDipal Arora
 
Call Girls Pune Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Pune Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service AvailableCall Girls Pune Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Pune Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service AvailableDipal Arora
 

Dernier (20)

Forklift Operations: Safety through Cartoons
Forklift Operations: Safety through CartoonsForklift Operations: Safety through Cartoons
Forklift Operations: Safety through Cartoons
 
Pharma Works Profile of Karan Communications
Pharma Works Profile of Karan CommunicationsPharma Works Profile of Karan Communications
Pharma Works Profile of Karan Communications
 
Value Proposition canvas- Customer needs and pains
Value Proposition canvas- Customer needs and painsValue Proposition canvas- Customer needs and pains
Value Proposition canvas- Customer needs and pains
 
Monte Carlo simulation : Simulation using MCSM
Monte Carlo simulation : Simulation using MCSMMonte Carlo simulation : Simulation using MCSM
Monte Carlo simulation : Simulation using MCSM
 
Nepali Escort Girl Kakori \ 9548273370 Indian Call Girls Service Lucknow ₹,9517
Nepali Escort Girl Kakori \ 9548273370 Indian Call Girls Service Lucknow ₹,9517Nepali Escort Girl Kakori \ 9548273370 Indian Call Girls Service Lucknow ₹,9517
Nepali Escort Girl Kakori \ 9548273370 Indian Call Girls Service Lucknow ₹,9517
 
M.C Lodges -- Guest House in Jhang.
M.C Lodges --  Guest House in Jhang.M.C Lodges --  Guest House in Jhang.
M.C Lodges -- Guest House in Jhang.
 
Call Girls Navi Mumbai Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Avail...
Call Girls Navi Mumbai Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Avail...Call Girls Navi Mumbai Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Avail...
Call Girls Navi Mumbai Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Avail...
 
Unlocking the Secrets of Affiliate Marketing.pdf
Unlocking the Secrets of Affiliate Marketing.pdfUnlocking the Secrets of Affiliate Marketing.pdf
Unlocking the Secrets of Affiliate Marketing.pdf
 
KYC-Verified Accounts: Helping Companies Handle Challenging Regulatory Enviro...
KYC-Verified Accounts: Helping Companies Handle Challenging Regulatory Enviro...KYC-Verified Accounts: Helping Companies Handle Challenging Regulatory Enviro...
KYC-Verified Accounts: Helping Companies Handle Challenging Regulatory Enviro...
 
Insurers' journeys to build a mastery in the IoT usage
Insurers' journeys to build a mastery in the IoT usageInsurers' journeys to build a mastery in the IoT usage
Insurers' journeys to build a mastery in the IoT usage
 
VIP Call Girl Jamshedpur Aashi 8250192130 Independent Escort Service Jamshedpur
VIP Call Girl Jamshedpur Aashi 8250192130 Independent Escort Service JamshedpurVIP Call Girl Jamshedpur Aashi 8250192130 Independent Escort Service Jamshedpur
VIP Call Girl Jamshedpur Aashi 8250192130 Independent Escort Service Jamshedpur
 
Boost the utilization of your HCL environment by reevaluating use cases and f...
Boost the utilization of your HCL environment by reevaluating use cases and f...Boost the utilization of your HCL environment by reevaluating use cases and f...
Boost the utilization of your HCL environment by reevaluating use cases and f...
 
Progress Report - Oracle Database Analyst Summit
Progress  Report - Oracle Database Analyst SummitProgress  Report - Oracle Database Analyst Summit
Progress Report - Oracle Database Analyst Summit
 
7.pdf This presentation captures many uses and the significance of the number...
7.pdf This presentation captures many uses and the significance of the number...7.pdf This presentation captures many uses and the significance of the number...
7.pdf This presentation captures many uses and the significance of the number...
 
GD Birla and his contribution in management
GD Birla and his contribution in managementGD Birla and his contribution in management
GD Birla and his contribution in management
 
Call Girls In Panjim North Goa 9971646499 Genuine Service
Call Girls In Panjim North Goa 9971646499 Genuine ServiceCall Girls In Panjim North Goa 9971646499 Genuine Service
Call Girls In Panjim North Goa 9971646499 Genuine Service
 
VIP Kolkata Call Girl Howrah 👉 8250192130 Available With Room
VIP Kolkata Call Girl Howrah 👉 8250192130  Available With RoomVIP Kolkata Call Girl Howrah 👉 8250192130  Available With Room
VIP Kolkata Call Girl Howrah 👉 8250192130 Available With Room
 
Mysore Call Girls 8617370543 WhatsApp Number 24x7 Best Services
Mysore Call Girls 8617370543 WhatsApp Number 24x7 Best ServicesMysore Call Girls 8617370543 WhatsApp Number 24x7 Best Services
Mysore Call Girls 8617370543 WhatsApp Number 24x7 Best Services
 
VVVIP Call Girls In Greater Kailash ➡️ Delhi ➡️ 9999965857 🚀 No Advance 24HRS...
VVVIP Call Girls In Greater Kailash ➡️ Delhi ➡️ 9999965857 🚀 No Advance 24HRS...VVVIP Call Girls In Greater Kailash ➡️ Delhi ➡️ 9999965857 🚀 No Advance 24HRS...
VVVIP Call Girls In Greater Kailash ➡️ Delhi ➡️ 9999965857 🚀 No Advance 24HRS...
 
Call Girls Pune Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Pune Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service AvailableCall Girls Pune Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Pune Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
 

Securitization of Intangible Assets

  • 1. SECURITIZATION OF INTANGIBLE ASSETS | STRUCTURED FINANCE REPORT 1 STRUCTURED FINANCE SECURITIZATION OF INTANGIBLE ASSETS FINAL REPORT SUBMISSION This submission was made to Prof. Prantik Ray Submitted by: Aishwary Kumar Gupta B15066
  • 2. SECURITIZATION OF INTANGIBLE ASSETS | STRUCTURED FINANCE REPORT 2 Contents INTRODUCTION....................................................................................................................................3 TYPES OF INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY ASSETS......................................................................................4 VALUING AN INTANGIBLE ASSET ........................................................................................................5 IDENTIFICATION OF SECURITIZABLE INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY........................................................10 PROCESS OF IP SECURITIZATION .......................................................................................................10 ADVANTAGES OF INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY SECURITIZATION .........................................................10 DISADVANTAGES OF INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY SECURITIZATION ....................................................11 CASE: DRUG ROYALTY III L.P. 1 (SERIES 2016-1)............................................................................12 PROBLEMS CONCERNING IPR SECURITIZATION.................................................................................12 CONCLUSION.....................................................................................................................................13 REFERENCES .....................................................................................................................................14
  • 3. SECURITIZATION OF INTANGIBLE ASSETS | STRUCTURED FINANCE REPORT 3 INTRODUCTION The location of Wrigley field is mostly residential. It is surrounded by residential apartments on both the sides. For years, the lucky residents of those apartment buildings happily set up chairs on their roofs and enjoyed the view of the game, free of cost, at leisure. But later, say a decade ago, some building owners saw an opportunity in it. They decided to make money out of it, and wanted to capitalize on their views. That idea gave birth to an intangible asset: Viewing Rights. The economic value of the buildings in that area went up as intangible viewing rights became more important than the regular rental income from the apartments. Many of the owners provided viewing rights coupled with refreshments, and this gave them a steady flow of income for some time. It’s interesting to note as to how a Cubs’ game moved from a proto-asset to giving birth to an identifiable intangible asset, which in this case is also easily quantifiable. It wasn’t quite late when the Tribune Company (owners of the Cubs’ franchise) realized that they were losing out in the scenario, and that it needed to secure its ownership with respect to viewing the game. It did so, both through legal channels, and through physically blocking the view from the rooftop of the buildings, by installing screens and other devices. As a result, the business of the building owners suffered a blow, the owners faced decreased security for the viewing rights. The two stakeholders soon reached a consensus, wherein the rooftop business owners agreed to pay a royalty to the team and also agreed that the Tribune had property rights there. On the other hand, the rooftop owners were assured that the revenues associated with Cubs’ watching would continue with relative stability, and any physical blockage of the view shall be removed. In this way, both the parties securitized their positions and gained in the long run. It is interesting to note as to how this example shows how something as simple as watching a game from rooftop, can become a major business and eventually be seen as an intangible asset which is being fought for and then securitized. Have laid the foundation, let’s now define intangible assets, its different types and the history behind it. INTANGIBLE ASSETS IAS 38 defines Intangible Assets as assets which are without physical substance and identifiable. Simply put, an intangible asset is an asset that is not physical in nature. Intangible assets can be classified into three parts:  Intellectual Property: Any product that is an application of human intellect, is novel, unobvious, and to which some value can be attached, even if not assessed easily. It can be of multiple forms: inventions, business methods, chemical formulae, designs used in commerce, literary and artistic works, etc.  Intellectual Capital: This can be defined as a business advantage that arises as a result of employees of the Company (human capital), or the business model of the Company coupled with trade secrets, or something as intangible as Company’s network or relationship with other companies. Trade secrets, a part of Intellectual Capital, are sensitive business information that provides a company a competitive edge over others.  Goodwill: Goodwill is the excess value paid post acquisitions, over and above the book value of the assets acquired. Of the three kinds mentioned above, only Intellectual Property can be securitized and the reasons for securitizing it are:
  • 4. SECURITIZATION OF INTANGIBLE ASSETS | STRUCTURED FINANCE REPORT 4  Reducing chances of wrongful imitation by the competitors, and thereby losing the competitive edge  Creating more opportunities for commercializing new products  Greater safety against violation of IP rights HISTORY OF INTANGIBLE ASSETS The first ever incident of securitizing intangible asset owes its credit to the musician David Bowie, way back in the year 1997. He popularized the concept of securitization by creating a $55 million issuance of asset-backed bonds. The collateral was future royalties from some 25 albums Bowie recorded before 1990. The investors were intrigued by Bowie’s creation that they named the bonds after him and since then “Bowie bonds” have come to mean any bond backed by intangible assets. These comprise offerings in film and television, literary works, and games. Although these bonds have fared poorly for their guarantor, the concept has found merit with a lot of investors. TYPES OF INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY ASSETS Securitization of IP assets has seen the most development in the recent years. Although the purview of intangible assets is very wide, most of these assets are under the books as copyrights, trademarks or patents. COPYRIGHT The aim of the copyright law is to incentivize the creation of creative work. It grants the author of the economic and moral rights of his creations. These exclusive rights are subject to a time limit and generally expire seventy years after the death of the author. The author or his/her legal authority can transfer copyright or can grant exclusive and non-exclusive licences. Securitization in the field of copyright is still nascent and not a widespread practise. However, its advantages are immense. It would provide with authors the opportunity to recoup their expenses. Largely, this practise has yet only been adopted by the entertainment & media industry where projects have been proven to be successful. Bowie Bonds of 1997 are a popular example of securitization of copyright licences. More recently in 2014, Miramax Film securitized its Film library containing more than 700 titles (such as Pulp Fiction, Chicago, Good Will Hunting, etc.) for $250 million 3.34% notes due 2026 as well as a $25 million revolving credit facility, which was undrawn at closing. The notes were rated BBB+ by Standard & Poor’s and BBB (High) by DBRS. TRADEMARK A trademark is defined as the symbol which identifies the source of the product. Owners invest in their products and by providing a consistent quality and experience in their product and service offering and further also invest in trademarks to exhibit their commitment. Trademarks also benefit customers by saving them search costs by relying on familiar products and services. This helps in creating a captive market for their products by creating goodwill and reputation. Traditionally, trademark protection is enforced only when it is used in commerce. However, in the past century, some trademarks have come to represent lifestyle choices and hence these trademarks have become extremely valuable to their owners. In the US, firms such as the restaurant and fast food chains Arby’s, Dunkin Donuts, Domino’s Pizza, Sonic, Quizno’s, Applebee’s and IHOP, the Hilton chain of hotels, fashion houses Candie’s and BCBG Max Azaria, the athletic footwear retailer
  • 5. SECURITIZATION OF INTANGIBLE ASSETS | STRUCTURED FINANCE REPORT 5 Athlete’s Foot, and the retail chain Sears have used their trademarks to raise interim funds for their business. Bill Blass, a famous fashion designer who had a big portfolio of products under his trademark securitized the future revenue streams coming in from his trademark in 1999. The securities against his trademark received a rating of Baa3 by Moody’s, which was significantly higher than that of Bill Blass’s fashion house. This was because simply the act of securitization divided the securitized assets from other operating risks of the firm. PATENT Patents are meant to reward innovators by providing them a legal monopoly for a limited time to incentivize innovation. This gives the innovators the legal right to prevent others from copying their ideas. The time period in general by the US law is 20 years from the filing date of the patent. The first known example of using patents to raise financing was of Thomas Alva Edison. He would go on to utilize his patent on incandescent bulb as collateral towards repayment of the loan he took in order to start the company which today is General Electric. In 2012, DRI Capital securitized cash flows on 18 royalty streams from 14 patent-protected drugs, amounted to a total of $195 million. The issue was rated Baa3 by Moody’s and BBB by Standard & Poor’s. The issue was over-collateralized by as much as 34 % of the issue size. VALUING AN INTANGIBLE ASSET The first step in securitization of an intangible asset is the process of determining the value of the asset itself. Since, these assets are intangible, the methods required for valuation are different and sometimes unconventional. Traditional Methods  Income-Approach method  Market-based Method  Replacement-Cost Method Non-Traditional Methods  Binomial, Options, etc TRADITIONAL METHODS Income-Approach method The director of a B-School has been approached by the administration with the idea of doing away with the tea/coffee vending machine for professors. Professors gather around the vending machine couple of times a day and would often talk about sports, local news, etc. The administration argues that the machine acts as a distraction and actually pulls away the professors from doing their real work, i.e. research. The director decides to value the prospect of having a break room before he reaches a conclusion. He asks the finance officer to value the prospect of having a vending machine. The officer first decides to value the cash flows from the sale of the items from the vending machine. Suppose the weighted average profit earned from the sale of one item from the machine is Rs. 5/unit.
  • 6. SECURITIZATION OF INTANGIBLE ASSETS | STRUCTURED FINANCE REPORT 6 The school does not pay anything for the restocking and is kept fully stocked by the local distributor. Since, the average faculty size of 80 is almost the same year-on-year, a simplification would be to assume that each faculty on an average buys 2 items from the machine every work day. With 240 work days in a year on average, the yearly cash flow to the school will be = 5 * 80 (faculty size) * 2 (items/day) * 240 (work days) = Rs. 192000/year. The distributor gives the payment to the school on a yearly basis. Since the prices of F&B products does not change drastically with time and taking a horizon of 4 years for the sake of simplification, the present value of cash inflows from the vending machine can be computed as follows – PVcash inflow = 192000/(1+r) + 192000/[(1+r)^2] + 192000/[(1+r)^3] + 192000/[(1+r)^4] Here, from the Capital Asset Pricing Model, we know that ri = rf + β* ( rm – rf ) Here, it is safe to assume β=1 since the F&B business closely replicates the market dynamics. At rf=6% and risk premium of 3%, we obtain – ri = 6% + 1 * 3% = 9% PVcash inflow = 192000/(1+0.09) + 192000/[(1+0.09)^2] + 192000/[(1+0.09)^3] + 192000/[(1+0.09)^4] = Rs. 622026 Calculating Lost Wages – Let’s assume that each professor spends 15 mins a day on the vending machine in taking his item and talking with his/her peers. Therefore, lost time = 80 * 0.25 (hours) = 20 hours/day Assuming a 8 hour work day and 240 work days and each professor earning a salary of Rs. 19.2 lakh/annum, the hourly wage of a professor will be = 1920000/(8*240) = Rs. 1000/hr Therefore, lost wages per day = 1000 * 20 = Rs. 20000/day Lost Wages Annually = 20000 * 240 = Rs. 4800000/annum Using DCF method to compute the cost over four years, PVcost = 4800000/(1+0.09) + 4800000/[(1+0.09)^2] + 4800000/[(1+0.09)^3] + 4800000/[(1+0.09)^4] = Rs. 15550655 On the face of it, it seems that eliminating the vending machine will lead to 15550655 – 622026 = Rs. 14928629 of savings in lost wages and productivity. When he showed his workings to the Director, he pointed out that not all vending machine discussions are purely non-work related. Some discussions also relate to academic and scholarly excellence which help in building the brand equity of the school. The discussions also facilitate cross-functional collaboration on research papers. This research excellence and opportunity helps in letting the school charge a 25% premium over the average b-school fees of 16 lakhs of the same grade. This translates to a premium of 4 lakh/student. For 360 students annually, this translates to Rs. 144000000/annum. However, the entire contribution towards premium cannot be attributed to academic excellence.
  • 7. SECURITIZATION OF INTANGIBLE ASSETS | STRUCTURED FINANCE REPORT 7 Factors allowing for the school to charge premium (Rs. 144000000) = Academic Excellence + Better Placements + Unknowns Roughly allotting one-third of the premium to academic excellence, the figure we obtain is Rs. 48000000. Let us assume for simplification that the vending machine contributes only 40% towards helping academic excellence, the figure is Rs. 19200000. Therefore, if the director decides to eliminate the vending machine, the net benefit of Rs. 14928629 will be overwhelmed by savings of Rs. 19200000. At a net value of Rs. 4271371, eliminating the vending machine does not seem like the best idea. Even though, the methodology takes into account many assumptions for the sake of simplicity, the general idea behind the calculations is logical. The assumptions will cease to be subjective as there are more and more sub-divisions. Market-Based Approach The market based approach for valuation of assets using comparable assets works best when the asset under question is homogeneous. Therefore, the market based approach works best for commodities, whose attributes are easily delineated and easy to compare in a market that is actively traded. The market based approach is linked to other valuation principles such as; the valuation of the reference asset must take into account the discounted value of the future cash flows from the asset. Therefore, the implicit assumption is that the comparable assets are priced correctly. In case the reference asset is overvalues or undervalued, so will the subject asset. This make the market-based valuation of an intangible asset more difficult because of its heterogeneity. However, the approach allows us gain some idea of the boundary values of the subject asset. Let us look at an example to see how the value of an intangible asset varies widely based on the context – Suppose you wish to value a patent for a pharmaceutical company’s insulin medication designed for patients with very high BMI index. For a good comparable analysis, we will take into account asset prices at different depths and scope of similarity.  All pharma patents  Just insulin related patents  Just patents pertaining to high BMI index patients  Just insulin for high BMI index patients At first thought, we will be tempted to use the most recent transaction for the category with the narrowest market definition i.e. insulin for high BMI index patients. However, one must enquire deeply about the reasons for the value they paid for their transactions. Some factors to consider might be –  Fit with existing portfolio  History  Scope of the patent  Remaining useful life of the patent  Likelihood of infringement of the patent It is possible that for the most recent transaction which we plan to use as reference asset, for the buyer, this patent might be a missing piece in its portfolio of medication and therefore might have paid a premium for it. The same might not be the case for us for our subject asset.
  • 8. SECURITIZATION OF INTANGIBLE ASSETS | STRUCTURED FINANCE REPORT 8 This is a small example to show how when even one factor which is different for valuation, the market based approach becomes difficult to use. Therefore, the context of the transaction matters and neutralizing its effect is not entirely possible. Below, we will discuss a small real-world example of how such adjustments might be done. Value of a trademark of a U.S. Cosmetic company which licences its trademark to several companies in the Latin American market for use in their respective territories. The company will also provide marketing support to these companies on a need basis. For a reference transaction, we consider the most recent available transaction available with the terms: exclusive licence to the trademark with no upfront fee and a running royalty rate of 7 % of net sales to a Western European company for a period of 5 years. The adjustments made for the trademark are as follows:  Location: Trademark valuation can differ widely between geographies. However, here it was concluded that the value of trademarks in the cosmetic industry in the given geographies were comparable and hence, no adjustment was required.  Advertising Support: To help launch the brands in the new territories, the licensor has agreed to provide market development support of up to $1 million in the first year. The royalty rate was adjusted upward by 0.2 % to compensate the licensor for this added expense.  IP Strength: Trademark protection and ability to manage the use of marks is determined to be lower in Latin America than in Europe. Subjectively, royalty was decreased by 0.5% to account for this.  Length: Length of the licence is an important factor in determining the value. However, in this instance the expectation is that the agreement would likely be renewed at the end of the three year period, so no adjustment was performed. Replacement Cost Method- It is a forward looking method on how to create an asset with similar functionality to the asset in question. A common usage of the method is the cost to design around a patent or a set of patents. Many experts believe that the replacement cost method has little credence in IP valuation because; (i) the legal protection of IP makes replacement difficult and (ii) with the legal protection, the replacement cost for many IP assets is effectively zero. Nonetheless, the method is an efficient measure for us to establish a ‘floor’ and ‘ceiling’ price. In the following example, we try to determine the value of an Auto dealer network. Here, we do not speak about valuing the dealership directly but the intangible asset of the network of relationships between the distributor and the independent franchise dealerships. Here, the replacement cost is the only viable method to value the network in the absence of any direct cash flows arising from the intangible dealer relationship asset.
  • 9. SECURITIZATION OF INTANGIBLE ASSETS | STRUCTURED FINANCE REPORT 9 The above shows the value of the dealer network arrived using Establishment & Support Costs. The establishment costs include the efforts put into identification of site and the costs to establish the dealer. This represents the cost to create a completely new dealer network. However, these costs must be reduced due to changing consumer trends and demographics, obsolescence of the existing network, etc. These costs are further supplemented by support costs in training, accounting support, etc. NON-TRADITIONAL METHODS Over the past decade or so, we have seen the growth of new and non-traditional methods of valuation. They include real options, binomial methods and Monte Carlo simulations. They are all based on decision tree models where the conditional events required for the IP to generate revenue is modelled explicitly. Therefore, these techniques are broadly composed of the following 2 steps:  Calculate the probability of each favourable event that will make the IP valuable.  Compute the payoff if the favourable event occurs. Binomial Method Using this method, we shall try to value a non-commercialized patent for purposes of negotiated sale. The case is concerning Bt Corn in the US. The European corn borer caterpillar (ECB) is a pest that destroys millions of dollars of corn each year. To stop this menace, a new variety of corn called Bt corn was developed which is resistant from the bacteria. However, the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) is concerned that widespread use of Bt corn might make the ECB resistant to conventional insecticides and affecting modified crop as well. The EPA has therefore mandated a “refuge” policy in which 20-40% acreage of the farm is to be planted with the conventional corn which would enable ECB to not generate resistance from the insecticide. However, compliance to this policy is voluntary and up to the individual farmer. To help ensure compliance with the refuge policy, a business method patent was obtained to bundle an insurance policy with Bt Bacteria in the transgenic seed. The patent has 6 remaining years left. Here, the binomial method is most relevant to use since, the payoff is dependent on the event that the ECB does not mutate and spread. The valuation model is explained from the following decision tree:
  • 10. SECURITIZATION OF INTANGIBLE ASSETS | STRUCTURED FINANCE REPORT 10 CHOOSING THE RIGHT VALUATION METHOD- IP valuation is not yet advanced as is business valuation with much research done on the subject. Therefore, there does not exist a hierarchy of methods to be used and all methods are equally applicable. Thus, most experts urge people to employ multiple valuation methods for a given asset to determine the robustness of the valuation. However, this is always pragmatically not possible due to lack of financial/economic data or due to lack of precedent. Therefore, one must be on the lookout for new and improved methods when it comes to the matter of valuing an intangible asset. IDENTIFICATION OF SECURITIZABLE INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY It must be noted that not all intellectual property is considered fit by the investors to be securitized. For IP assets to be effectively securitized, they must have the following characteristics –  Can be separately identified from other intangible assets  Can be legally protected  Are able to generate cash flows (income)  Provide access to exclusive Research & Development  Can be valued Therefore, a quantifiable and legible flow of consistent cash stream arising from commerce activities arising out of IP backed business is a requirement for the IP to be securitizable. PROCESS OF IP SECURITIZATION The IP Securitization process is not that different from that of a regular asset-backed securitization process. A typical IP Securitization process happens as follows –  The royalty stream arising from the IP is transferred to a Special Purpose Vehicle (SPV). This step is important to ensure that the IP assets will not be affected by the originator’s bankruptcy. This transaction is tailored to be a ‘true sale’.  The SPV next issues securities to the capital market. The offer may be bundled with credit enhancement features to obtain a better credit rating. Most of these transactions happen by private placement. A portion of the issuance capital may be set aside in a debt service reserve fund.  Rating of the issue is assigned to the security by the rating agencies. They typically go through 3-5 years of financial history of the company’s portfolio and uses it to project the performance of the company.  It may also be prudent for the issuing firm to acquire additional IP which may act as ‘choke points’ if left outside the vehicle. ADVANTAGES OF INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY SECURITIZATION In this section, we try to analyse the benefits of securitization from the different perspectives – originators, investors and the public for expansion and diversification of the fields of creativity and innovation.
  • 11. SECURITIZATION OF INTANGIBLE ASSETS | STRUCTURED FINANCE REPORT 11  Access to Non-Bank Credit – The securitization procedure acts as a substitute to bank credit. Banks are subject to many regulations from the government and is limited by the amount of its own capital. The access to wider range of credit not only promotes credit to innovative people seeking financing but lowers the cost of financing overall.  Lowering of Financing Costs – We have seen from previous examples that securitization of IP rights allows originators to raise credit cheaply, since the credit risk involved in the IP backed assets is lower as they are separated from the operating risk of the entire business.  Off-Balance Sheet Financing - According to accounting principles, a secured loan should appear as a liability on the balance sheet of the borrowing company. In contrast, obtaining credit through securitization is considered off balance-sheet financing since, from an accounting perspective, the securitization replaces one type of asset, future royalty streams, with a different type of asset, liquid money. Off-balance-sheet financing is attractive for the originator since it does not increase its debt-to-equity ratio and as a result has no negative impact on the originator’s creditworthiness.  Maintain Ownership rights in the Originator - An originator who securitizes royalty income streams from IP rights is not separated from her rights; rather, the royalty income streams revert to her possession when the asset-backed securities are fully repaid.  Supporting Investments in Research, Development and Creativity – The ability to monetize IP assets through securitization provides the originator with capital as and when he needs it. The liquid capital can be invested in creating further IP assets which can further be securitized and so on. DISADVANTAGES OF INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY SECURITIZATION  If the primary asset of the company is the securitized IP asset, a default on the loan could lead to liquidation of the IP and eventual turmoil for the company.  Since the valuation of IP backed securities is difficult than for tangible assets, potential creditors are not willing to invest readily as they do not know how the asset prices react to market conditions.  Intangible assets are far less liquid than tangible assets. This may restrict the width of investors willing to invest in such assets.  The IP securitization market is still in its nascent phase. This might make it a more expensive financing alternative than traditional financing.
  • 12. SECURITIZATION OF INTANGIBLE ASSETS | STRUCTURED FINANCE REPORT 12 CASE: DRUG ROYALTY III L.P. 1 (SERIES 2016-1) Drug Royalty III LP 1 is the SPV set up to issue $145 million Senior Secured Class A Notes which is backed by 8 royalty streams on seven patent-protected drugs and technologies. DRI Capital Inc. will serve as the servicer of the issue. The offer profile snapshot is attached as follows – A preliminary rating of BBB was given to the issue by the rating agency Standard & Poor’s. The report mentions the overcollateralization of 42 % implicit in the issue. The report further goes on to detail the rationale behind the rating, the industry & transaction overview, details about the servicer, the underwriter, credit analysis, scenario analysis, payment priority details and covenants relating to specific events such as default, etc. The entire report can be accessed on: https://www.spratings.com/documents/20184/769219/Drug+Royalty+III+L.P.+1+(Series+2016- 1).pdf/15da8dee-b8bc-4d1a-9115-50e0fed539b2 PROBLEMS CONCERNING IPR SECURITIZATION Some problems relating to IPR securitization can be divided into the following categories- 1) Valuation & Cash Flows - Difficulty in predicting future cash flows due to IP specific risk factors. Valuation of an IP still remains a developing area and there are various disputes over methodology and veracity of the method used. 2) Characteristics of the assets to be securitized – Assets targeted for securitization are for the royalties from the IPRs. To specify the assets to be securitized, it is necessary to correctly identify the relationship between the subject IPR and third parties. 3) Transfer of Assets to be Securitized – Transfer of assets which need to be securitized may include (i) transferability, (ii) true sales, (iii) effectiveness against third parties, (iv) risk of cancellation of a license contract, and (v) evaluation of the IP concerned. 4) Credit Enhancement – The possibility of evaluating risk of failure of an IPR is difficult. This creates a lot of issues that even a credit enhancement measure such as insurance would not pay due to the high insurance premium rate.
  • 13. SECURITIZATION OF INTANGIBLE ASSETS | STRUCTURED FINANCE REPORT 13 5) Balance of Disclosure – The owner faces the problem of balance of disclosure to investors along with confidential technical information during issue of securities. 6) Handling after the implementation of the securitization – There are issues which need to be taken care of after implementation of the securitization such as treatment of improvement patents, how to handle annual patent fees, etc. CONCLUSION From the above discussion, we can conclude that the securitization of IPRs involves great complexity. Even developed markets such as USA & Europe are not fully prepared for IP securitization. Currently, the costs to build a securitization scheme for IPRs is enormous and the volume of securities needs to be extremely large for it to become feasible for everyone. In the current age, IP rights are more significant than ever. Securitization of tangible assets has proven to be a credible financing source for many companies. Securitization allows for the capitalization of IP rights that yield a foreseeable royalty stream in order to raise interim funds for business activities. The growth of the securitization market has been steady and has not yet realized its full potential. Companies’ financing needs and growing Investors’ risk appetite will soon discover the rewards that can be offered from the currently untapped potential of securitization of IP-backed assets.
  • 14. SECURITIZATION OF INTANGIBLE ASSETS | STRUCTURED FINANCE REPORT 14 REFERENCES  Ariel Glasner, Making Something Out of “Nothing” The Trend Towards Securitizing Intellectual Property and the Legal Obstacles That Remain, 3 J. LEGAL TECH. RISK MGMT.27,37, 39–40 (2008); Kaufmann, supra note 37, at 241.  Kirsch, Alexander C. (2007). Intellectual property securitization. Germany: VDM Verlag Dr. Muller.  Bruce W. Burton, Financing Alternatives for Companies: Using Intellectual Property as Collateral  http://www.reuters.com/article/drug-royalties-abs-idUSL2E8E58LS20120305, Accessed on 3 Feb 2017  http://www.wipo.int/edocs/mdocs/sme/en/wipo_wasme_ipr_ge_03/wipo_wasme_ipr_ge_03_ 17.pdf, Accessed on 5 Feb 2017  https://www.iip.or.jp/e/e_summary/pdf/detail2003/e15_20.pdf, Accessed on 7 Feb 2017  http://nopr.niscair.res.in/bitstream/123456789/3563/1/JIPR%2011(2)%2098-102.pdf, Accessed on 9 Feb 2017  https://www.spratings.com/documents/20184/769219/Drug+Royalty+III+L.P.+1+(Series+20 16-1).pdf/15da8dee-b8bc-4d1a-9115-50e0fed539b2, Accessed on 28 Jan 2017  http://www.miramax.com/press/miramax-completes-securitization-250-million/, Accessed on 13 Jan 2017