There are several methodological elements that could be combined to create a balanced rangeland carbon sequestration protocol, including direct soil sampling, spectroscopy methods, eddy covariance towers, remote sensing, and ecosystem models. A successful protocol may have a simple front-end using visual indicators and some direct sampling, combined with a sophisticated back-office using modeling, analysis, and new technologies to drive adoption rates. Both soil carbon and tree carbon should be considered given their interactions and impacts on ecosystem functions.