This was my submission posted as part of the e-Learning and Digital Cultures MOOC run by the University of Edinburgh during 2013. It was peer assessed as part of the course.
1. Name: Andrew Moore
andryn@iafrica.com
I work closely with
academics in African
Higher Education
institutions and support
them to develop online
versions of their courses.
Technology is important
but I’ve always
championed sound
pedagogy.
Johannesburg, S
outh Africa
2. Take that Apple
fan boys!
Chandler’sTechnologicalDeterminism
Dahlberg
Dahlberg would categorise my Tech
perspective as falling into the ‘Uses
Determinism’ camp.
The implication is that I’ve always played
down the technological as well as the
social influences by emphasising the
user’s control and agency.
Awareness of this has opened up a
whole new way of looking at the
relationship between the three
components and identification of
potential barriers to success.
Personal Discovery
Utopias & Dystopias: Past
3. Utopias & Dystopias: Future
Loved Shirky’s provocative posturing and
side with Thrun that MOOCs are still
experimental and will need to be fine
tuned over time.
Critical of Bady’s belief that the old state
college system can be resurrected in a
country that is facing economic hardship
and enormous government debt. Also
for me his alternative is insular and does
not benefit global education.
But it’s Campbell’s reading of Bateson
and his call for trans-contextual learning
that has got me fired up.
Personal Discovery
Campbell
4. Being Human: Reasserting
Professionally I’m a Humanist. I want the
best for those students I come across in
the disadvantaged institutions I work.
But then Fuller identifies a movement
that believes ‘Humanity Not Good for
All’ that identifies the duplicity in some
of the motives and even questions
viability of universal access.
As an individual I’m NOT a Humanist at
heart and find the approach reactionary
and conservative.
I’m torn in two and not sure how to
resolve this schism. At least its out in the
open now waiting for me to investigate
further.
Personal Discovery
MEAT
Fukuyama
Post Humanism
gon’na kill us
off but that’s
OK ‘cos History
is dead!
5. Being Human: Redefining
Roll on the Trans-humanists Cant wait to
be ‘enhanced’. Think I’ll lose the glasses
first! The video, True Skin, was stunning.
Of significance though was my reading
of the TEL report. It highlights that while
Developed countries are way ahead of
many of the Developing nations in terms
of access to technology they still have
not really exploited it properly in the
area of Education. Many of the themes
that structure the report are the type of
things I’m trying to encourage with
those I work. Admittedly our attempts
are modest but it looks like we are on
the right track.
Personal Discovery
Bostrom
ELC
Notes de l'éditeur
My digital artefact is a conventional presentation wherein I’ll identify course resources that have had some influence on me and will, I hope, impact positively on my work. I support African academics make the transition from a lecture based model of teaching to an online mode. I’m interested in how this course has changed my perceptions of, and perhaps approaches to, e-learning.
I was a history teacher who taught historiography so appreciated the approach of unpacking literary perspectives as a first step! It makes sense to do this here as views on technology are so often polarised. Chandler’s focus on Technological Determinism was useful but I was aware of this perspective. I’ve heard too many over zealous tech vendors in the past. However, it was with Lincoln Dahlberg’s ‘Tracings’ paper that a personal chord was struck. I did not realise it previously but according to him my tech perspective fell into what he calls ‘Uses Determinism’… to quote,“the technological artefact tends to be seen as a neutral tool able to satisfy the purposes of agents employing it.” The implication of course is that I’ve always played down the technological as well as the social influences. This awareness has opened up a whole new way of looking at the relationship between use(rs), social and technological components in the institutions where I work.
I got a kick out of Johannesburg, my home town, being featured in the Productivity Future Vision (2011) video and also the fact that the young girl bakes a melktert! But the real gems in week two were the Shirky / Bady debate about MOOCs and Campbell’s Ecology of Yearning lecture. Shirky’s perspective I had read previously so it was good to hear an eloquent counter argument. However, I feel Bady’s alternative is not a viable option. The old state college system he puts so much faith in cannot be resurrected in a country that is facing economic hardship and enormous government debt. Also his views are insular, thinking only of education in the USA and not of benefits for global education, something I’m passionate about working in under resourced intuitions across this continent. But it’s Campbell’s reading of Bateson and his call for trans-contextual learning that has got me fired up.
Professionally I am a Humanist, I guess. I want the best for those students I come across in the disadvantaged institutions I work. But of concern was Fuller’s assertion that there is a movement within the perspective that advocates ‘Humanity is Not Good for All.” that identifies the duplicity in some of the motives and even questions the viability of universal access. This I’ve seen in my work and sometimes wondered about. More broadly, however, I have I often considered the humanist perspectives rather … ‘lame’…. Made obvious to me by the discussion, ‘Are we closer to ‘God’ or ‘Apes’?’ Neither! What a bizarre continuum to have to choose from. Maybe its because I’ve a History background and am aware that what we consider human, or at least Modern Man, is something quite new in terms of our development. Values and social mores change with the each era. I don’t think we will lose the fundamental characteristics that separate us from animals but I believe we have evolved and changed in the past and will in the future. I’m torn in two then between my personal beliefs and those appropriate to my work and am not sure how to resolve this schism. At least its out in the open now, rather than inferred, waiting for me to investigate further.The best part of this whole section though was the video They’re Made out of Meat. Excellently filmed where even I felt nauseated by the teenagers ‘swopping spit’!
Bostrom’s article blew me away. I marked up my copy with numerous references to characters from Science Fiction novels and films: Dr Manhattan fits right in here! Cant wait to be ‘enhanced’. Think I’ll lose the glasses first! The video, True Skin, was stunning. Want to know if he does get his Memories back wholesale! Of significance though was my reading of the TEL report. It highlights that while the Developed world is way ahead of many of the Developing nations in terms of access to technology they still have not really exploited it properly in the area of Education. Many of the themes that structure the report are the type of things I’m trying to encourage with those I work. Admittedly our attempts are modest but it looks like we are on the right track.So there you have it! Those components of the course that have got me reflecting on my own practices!