SlideShare une entreprise Scribd logo
1  sur  15
Integrating Digital Inclusion,
Dissolving Silos
ICA Digital Divide Preconference: Communication and "The Good Life”
May 22, 2014
Angela Siefer
Senior Research Associate,
Center for Digital Inclusion
asiefer@illinois.edu
@angelasiefer
Digital Inclusion Definition
"Digital inclusion is the ability of
individuals and groups to access and use
information and communication
technologies."
From “Building DigitalCommunities: A
Framework for Action”, 2011
City sponsored:
Seattle Minneapolis Austin Chicago Philadelphia
Public Statements
x x x x
Access & Use Surveys
x x x
University
of IL at
Chicago
x
Staff
x x x
Dedicated Digital
Inclusion Funding x x x x
Involvement in City-
wide Digital Inclusion
Network
x x x x
• 1995 - CitizensTelecommunications andTechnology
Advisory Board created.
• 1996 - Staff position created. Community
Technology Program now has 4 full-time staff.
• 1996 - Funding established.
• 2000 - Survey conducted approximately every 4
years.
City of Seattle
• 2004 - 4 local organizations partner on an AmeriCorps
grant to utilize community tech resources.
• 2006 -Technology Literacy Collaborative created.
• 2007 - Funding established.
• 2010 - Staff position created.
• 2012 - Survey conducted annually.
City of Minneapolis
• 2006 – Mayor’s Advisory Council on Closing the Digital
Divide was created.
• 2009 – Community technology planning process
conducted in 5 neighborhoods.
• 2010 – BTOP SBA award.
• 2013 – City of ChicagoTechnology Plan released.
City of Chicago
• 1995 - Austin FreeNet support begins.
• 2011 - Survey conducted.
• 2013 - Austin City Council approved $200,000 for
community technology and $50,000 to conduct a
residential survey.
City of Austin
• 2010 - NTIA awards two BTOP grants in Philadelphia.
• 2010 - Office of Innovation andTechnology is created.
• 2011 - City hires a Chief Innovation Officer.
• 2013 - Funding established for internal and external
Keyspots.
• 2013 - Survey conducted.Will be released 2014.
City of Philadelphia
Internal External
Academy of
Municipal
Innovation
Innovation Lab
Innovation
Fund
City of Philadelphia
Components of Innovation
CivicApps Open
Data
Digital
Inclusion
“Among the KEYSPOTS
partners, there is no
single organization that
‘owns’ digital inclusion.
Digital inclusion is
something that
everyone can, and
should, collectively own
in Philadelphia.”
Ashley Del Bianco, Program Manager,
Office of Innovation andTechnology, City of Philadelphia
City sponsored:
1. Stakeholder engagement that results in public statements of digital
inclusion goals and strategies
2. Information technology access & use surveys.
3. Staff dedicated to digital inclusion.
4. Dedicated digital inclusion funding.
5. Involvement in a city-wide digital inclusion network.
The city’s involvement does the following:
• Increases the likelihood that digital inclusion
issues will be integrated into other city
departments and community-based efforts.
• Reduces the possibility that the digital
inclusion efforts could become a political
casualty.
• Increases potential for a reliable source of
funding.
• Helps ensure that investments from all sectors
are coordinated and strategic.
Sustaining Digital Inclusion May 2014
Sustaining Digital Inclusion May 2014

Contenu connexe

Tendances

Femi Longe (Co-creation Hub Nigeria) on the Power of Technology
Femi Longe (Co-creation Hub Nigeria) on the Power of TechnologyFemi Longe (Co-creation Hub Nigeria) on the Power of Technology
Femi Longe (Co-creation Hub Nigeria) on the Power of Technology
Social Innovation Exchange
 

Tendances (15)

Preparing an NSF16 610 proposal
Preparing an NSF16 610 proposalPreparing an NSF16 610 proposal
Preparing an NSF16 610 proposal
 
Downscale for sustainability Downscale 2016 Anna Bon
Downscale for sustainability Downscale 2016 Anna BonDownscale for sustainability Downscale 2016 Anna Bon
Downscale for sustainability Downscale 2016 Anna Bon
 
Array of Things Engagement Report
Array of Things Engagement ReportArray of Things Engagement Report
Array of Things Engagement Report
 
Microsoft opening address presentation 2010
Microsoft opening address presentation 2010Microsoft opening address presentation 2010
Microsoft opening address presentation 2010
 
12 14-17 keyes connected city
12 14-17 keyes connected city12 14-17 keyes connected city
12 14-17 keyes connected city
 
The Organization Of Lusophone Wikipedia
The Organization Of Lusophone WikipediaThe Organization Of Lusophone Wikipedia
The Organization Of Lusophone Wikipedia
 
Route to PA Project Meeting Dublinked Presentation 03.12.2015
Route to PA Project Meeting Dublinked Presentation 03.12.2015Route to PA Project Meeting Dublinked Presentation 03.12.2015
Route to PA Project Meeting Dublinked Presentation 03.12.2015
 
20141105 presentatie taipei
20141105 presentatie taipei20141105 presentatie taipei
20141105 presentatie taipei
 
Femi Longe (Co-creation Hub Nigeria) on the Power of Technology
Femi Longe (Co-creation Hub Nigeria) on the Power of TechnologyFemi Longe (Co-creation Hub Nigeria) on the Power of Technology
Femi Longe (Co-creation Hub Nigeria) on the Power of Technology
 
Dublinked - Celebrating Over Three Years of Open Data for the Dublin Region
Dublinked - Celebrating Over Three Years of Open Data for the Dublin RegionDublinked - Celebrating Over Three Years of Open Data for the Dublin Region
Dublinked - Celebrating Over Three Years of Open Data for the Dublin Region
 
SI LIVE Closing Session - Peter Baeck on Digital Social Innovation
SI LIVE Closing Session - Peter Baeck on Digital Social InnovationSI LIVE Closing Session - Peter Baeck on Digital Social Innovation
SI LIVE Closing Session - Peter Baeck on Digital Social Innovation
 
Building the things network in norfolk and suffolk
Building the things network in norfolk and suffolkBuilding the things network in norfolk and suffolk
Building the things network in norfolk and suffolk
 
IIeP [at] Open days Brussels
IIeP [at] Open days BrusselsIIeP [at] Open days Brussels
IIeP [at] Open days Brussels
 
Group 3 Prototyped in Dublin
Group 3 Prototyped in DublinGroup 3 Prototyped in Dublin
Group 3 Prototyped in Dublin
 
Pres 127 werner b korte june 29 2016
Pres 127 werner b korte june 29 2016Pres 127 werner b korte june 29 2016
Pres 127 werner b korte june 29 2016
 

Similaire à Sustaining Digital Inclusion May 2014

Kansas City Digital Inclusion Summit 2014 Keynote
Kansas City Digital Inclusion Summit 2014 KeynoteKansas City Digital Inclusion Summit 2014 Keynote
Kansas City Digital Inclusion Summit 2014 Keynote
Angela Siefer
 
Accelerating Impact with Technology: Building Skills, Confidence, and Community
Accelerating Impact with Technology: Building Skills, Confidence, and CommunityAccelerating Impact with Technology: Building Skills, Confidence, and Community
Accelerating Impact with Technology: Building Skills, Confidence, and Community
Smart Chicago Collaborative
 
Evidencing digital inclusion in the uk alice mathers
Evidencing digital inclusion in the uk alice mathersEvidencing digital inclusion in the uk alice mathers
Evidencing digital inclusion in the uk alice mathers
Al Mathers
 

Similaire à Sustaining Digital Inclusion May 2014 (20)

Sustaining digital inclusion
Sustaining digital inclusionSustaining digital inclusion
Sustaining digital inclusion
 
Kansas City Digital Inclusion Summit 2014 Keynote
Kansas City Digital Inclusion Summit 2014 KeynoteKansas City Digital Inclusion Summit 2014 Keynote
Kansas City Digital Inclusion Summit 2014 Keynote
 
Accelerating Impact with Technology: Building Skills, Confidence, and Community
Accelerating Impact with Technology: Building Skills, Confidence, and CommunityAccelerating Impact with Technology: Building Skills, Confidence, and Community
Accelerating Impact with Technology: Building Skills, Confidence, and Community
 
3.2.16 McCormick Foundation Presentation
3.2.16 McCormick Foundation Presentation3.2.16 McCormick Foundation Presentation
3.2.16 McCormick Foundation Presentation
 
Inclusive Smart Cities - Net Inclusion 2017 Presentation
Inclusive Smart Cities - Net Inclusion 2017 PresentationInclusive Smart Cities - Net Inclusion 2017 Presentation
Inclusive Smart Cities - Net Inclusion 2017 Presentation
 
Learn How to Get Your Residents Online: Digital Inclusion Leadership Awards S...
Learn How to Get Your Residents Online: Digital Inclusion Leadership Awards S...Learn How to Get Your Residents Online: Digital Inclusion Leadership Awards S...
Learn How to Get Your Residents Online: Digital Inclusion Leadership Awards S...
 
Digital inclusion cambridgeshire 2014 01 15
Digital inclusion cambridgeshire 2014 01 15Digital inclusion cambridgeshire 2014 01 15
Digital inclusion cambridgeshire 2014 01 15
 
San Francisco Tech Council - July 2016
San Francisco Tech Council - July 2016San Francisco Tech Council - July 2016
San Francisco Tech Council - July 2016
 
Smart Chicago presentation to the Knight Community Information Challenge webinar
Smart Chicago presentation to the Knight Community Information Challenge webinarSmart Chicago presentation to the Knight Community Information Challenge webinar
Smart Chicago presentation to the Knight Community Information Challenge webinar
 
Discoverseedscale af june2013
Discoverseedscale af june2013Discoverseedscale af june2013
Discoverseedscale af june2013
 
City of Chicago Tech Plan 18 Month Progress Update
City of Chicago Tech Plan 18 Month Progress UpdateCity of Chicago Tech Plan 18 Month Progress Update
City of Chicago Tech Plan 18 Month Progress Update
 
What is a digital city
What is a digital cityWhat is a digital city
What is a digital city
 
Evidencing digital inclusion in the uk alice mathers
Evidencing digital inclusion in the uk alice mathersEvidencing digital inclusion in the uk alice mathers
Evidencing digital inclusion in the uk alice mathers
 
Evidencing Digital Inclusion in the UK - Dr. Alice Mathers
Evidencing Digital Inclusion in the UK - Dr. Alice MathersEvidencing Digital Inclusion in the UK - Dr. Alice Mathers
Evidencing Digital Inclusion in the UK - Dr. Alice Mathers
 
Getting Smarter in Chicago: Presentation to Baltimore Data Days
Getting Smarter in Chicago: Presentation to Baltimore Data DaysGetting Smarter in Chicago: Presentation to Baltimore Data Days
Getting Smarter in Chicago: Presentation to Baltimore Data Days
 
DC10plus NAVCA
DC10plus NAVCADC10plus NAVCA
DC10plus NAVCA
 
The Rise of Social Government
The Rise of Social GovernmentThe Rise of Social Government
The Rise of Social Government
 
Community Informatics: Where are we now?
Community Informatics: Where are we now?Community Informatics: Where are we now?
Community Informatics: Where are we now?
 
2012_Philadelphia End of Year Report
2012_Philadelphia End of Year Report2012_Philadelphia End of Year Report
2012_Philadelphia End of Year Report
 
Knight civic-tech
Knight civic-techKnight civic-tech
Knight civic-tech
 

Plus de Angela Siefer

Digital Inclusion Stakeholder Engagement Workshop at the SHLB Conference 2013
Digital Inclusion Stakeholder Engagement Workshop at the SHLB Conference 2013Digital Inclusion Stakeholder Engagement Workshop at the SHLB Conference 2013
Digital Inclusion Stakeholder Engagement Workshop at the SHLB Conference 2013
Angela Siefer
 

Plus de Angela Siefer (17)

Top 25 Worst-Connected Cities Poor Households ACS 2014
Top 25 Worst-Connected Cities Poor Households ACS 2014Top 25 Worst-Connected Cities Poor Households ACS 2014
Top 25 Worst-Connected Cities Poor Households ACS 2014
 
Top 25 Worst Connected Cities ACS 2014
Top 25 Worst Connected Cities ACS 2014Top 25 Worst Connected Cities ACS 2014
Top 25 Worst Connected Cities ACS 2014
 
About Digital Dodge City 2013
About Digital Dodge City 2013About Digital Dodge City 2013
About Digital Dodge City 2013
 
Digital Inclusion Stakeholder Engagement Workshop at the SHLB Conference 2013
Digital Inclusion Stakeholder Engagement Workshop at the SHLB Conference 2013Digital Inclusion Stakeholder Engagement Workshop at the SHLB Conference 2013
Digital Inclusion Stakeholder Engagement Workshop at the SHLB Conference 2013
 
Smartphone Workshop for Small Business
Smartphone Workshop for Small BusinessSmartphone Workshop for Small Business
Smartphone Workshop for Small Business
 
Advanced resume writing
Advanced resume writingAdvanced resume writing
Advanced resume writing
 
Advanced resume writing
Advanced resume writingAdvanced resume writing
Advanced resume writing
 
ShinyDoor Business First Social Media Summer Camp August 2011
ShinyDoor Business First Social Media Summer Camp August 2011ShinyDoor Business First Social Media Summer Camp August 2011
ShinyDoor Business First Social Media Summer Camp August 2011
 
Social networking curriculum slides linked in
Social networking curriculum slides   linked inSocial networking curriculum slides   linked in
Social networking curriculum slides linked in
 
Morpc summit 10 5-10 presentation
Morpc summit 10 5-10 presentationMorpc summit 10 5-10 presentation
Morpc summit 10 5-10 presentation
 
Criteria for Evaluating Webpages
Criteria for Evaluating WebpagesCriteria for Evaluating Webpages
Criteria for Evaluating Webpages
 
Desktop & Windows handout
Desktop & Windows handoutDesktop & Windows handout
Desktop & Windows handout
 
Module intro
Module introModule intro
Module intro
 
Participant Guide for INROADS Social Networking Training
Participant Guide for INROADS Social Networking TrainingParticipant Guide for INROADS Social Networking Training
Participant Guide for INROADS Social Networking Training
 
Inroads social networking curriculum slides
Inroads social networking curriculum slidesInroads social networking curriculum slides
Inroads social networking curriculum slides
 
Facilitator guide
Facilitator guideFacilitator guide
Facilitator guide
 
Licking County Chamber Newsletter 09 May
Licking County Chamber Newsletter 09 MayLicking County Chamber Newsletter 09 May
Licking County Chamber Newsletter 09 May
 

Dernier

Dernier (20)

Scaling up coastal adaptation in Maldives through the NAP process
Scaling up coastal adaptation in Maldives through the NAP processScaling up coastal adaptation in Maldives through the NAP process
Scaling up coastal adaptation in Maldives through the NAP process
 
2024 UNESCO/Guillermo Cano World Press Freedom Prize
2024 UNESCO/Guillermo Cano World Press Freedom Prize2024 UNESCO/Guillermo Cano World Press Freedom Prize
2024 UNESCO/Guillermo Cano World Press Freedom Prize
 
Financing strategies for adaptation. Presentation for CANCC
Financing strategies for adaptation. Presentation for CANCCFinancing strategies for adaptation. Presentation for CANCC
Financing strategies for adaptation. Presentation for CANCC
 
3 May, Journalism in the face of the Environmental Crisis.
3 May, Journalism in the face of the Environmental Crisis.3 May, Journalism in the face of the Environmental Crisis.
3 May, Journalism in the face of the Environmental Crisis.
 
Finance strategies for adaptation. Presentation for CANCC
Finance strategies for adaptation. Presentation for CANCCFinance strategies for adaptation. Presentation for CANCC
Finance strategies for adaptation. Presentation for CANCC
 
74th Amendment of India PPT by Piyush(IC).pptx
74th Amendment of India PPT by Piyush(IC).pptx74th Amendment of India PPT by Piyush(IC).pptx
74th Amendment of India PPT by Piyush(IC).pptx
 
Peace-Conflict-and-National-Adaptation-Plan-NAP-Processes-.pdf
Peace-Conflict-and-National-Adaptation-Plan-NAP-Processes-.pdfPeace-Conflict-and-National-Adaptation-Plan-NAP-Processes-.pdf
Peace-Conflict-and-National-Adaptation-Plan-NAP-Processes-.pdf
 
31st World Press Freedom Day Conference.
31st World Press Freedom Day Conference.31st World Press Freedom Day Conference.
31st World Press Freedom Day Conference.
 
Antisemitism Awareness Act: pénaliser la critique de l'Etat d'Israël
Antisemitism Awareness Act: pénaliser la critique de l'Etat d'IsraëlAntisemitism Awareness Act: pénaliser la critique de l'Etat d'Israël
Antisemitism Awareness Act: pénaliser la critique de l'Etat d'Israël
 
tOld settlement register shouldnotaffect BTR
tOld settlement register shouldnotaffect BTRtOld settlement register shouldnotaffect BTR
tOld settlement register shouldnotaffect BTR
 
2024 UN Civil Society Conference in Support of the Summit of the Future.
2024 UN Civil Society Conference in Support of the Summit of the Future.2024 UN Civil Society Conference in Support of the Summit of the Future.
2024 UN Civil Society Conference in Support of the Summit of the Future.
 
Make a difference in a girl's life by donating to her education!
Make a difference in a girl's life by donating to her education!Make a difference in a girl's life by donating to her education!
Make a difference in a girl's life by donating to her education!
 
Cheap Call Girls In Hyderabad Phone No 📞 9352988975 📞 Elite Escort Service Av...
Cheap Call Girls In Hyderabad Phone No 📞 9352988975 📞 Elite Escort Service Av...Cheap Call Girls In Hyderabad Phone No 📞 9352988975 📞 Elite Escort Service Av...
Cheap Call Girls In Hyderabad Phone No 📞 9352988975 📞 Elite Escort Service Av...
 
Honasa Consumer Limited Impact Report 2024.pdf
Honasa Consumer Limited Impact Report 2024.pdfHonasa Consumer Limited Impact Report 2024.pdf
Honasa Consumer Limited Impact Report 2024.pdf
 
Coastal Protection Measures in Hulhumale'
Coastal Protection Measures in Hulhumale'Coastal Protection Measures in Hulhumale'
Coastal Protection Measures in Hulhumale'
 
The NAP process & South-South peer learning
The NAP process & South-South peer learningThe NAP process & South-South peer learning
The NAP process & South-South peer learning
 
Sustainability by Design: Assessment Tool for Just Energy Transition Plans
Sustainability by Design: Assessment Tool for Just Energy Transition PlansSustainability by Design: Assessment Tool for Just Energy Transition Plans
Sustainability by Design: Assessment Tool for Just Energy Transition Plans
 
unang digmaang pandaigdig tagalog version
unang digmaang pandaigdig tagalog versionunang digmaang pandaigdig tagalog version
unang digmaang pandaigdig tagalog version
 
sponsor for poor old age person food.pdf
sponsor for poor old age person food.pdfsponsor for poor old age person food.pdf
sponsor for poor old age person food.pdf
 
1935 CONSTITUTION REPORT IN RIPH FINALLS
1935 CONSTITUTION REPORT IN RIPH FINALLS1935 CONSTITUTION REPORT IN RIPH FINALLS
1935 CONSTITUTION REPORT IN RIPH FINALLS
 

Sustaining Digital Inclusion May 2014

  • 1. Integrating Digital Inclusion, Dissolving Silos ICA Digital Divide Preconference: Communication and "The Good Life” May 22, 2014
  • 2. Angela Siefer Senior Research Associate, Center for Digital Inclusion asiefer@illinois.edu @angelasiefer
  • 3. Digital Inclusion Definition "Digital inclusion is the ability of individuals and groups to access and use information and communication technologies." From “Building DigitalCommunities: A Framework for Action”, 2011
  • 4. City sponsored: Seattle Minneapolis Austin Chicago Philadelphia Public Statements x x x x Access & Use Surveys x x x University of IL at Chicago x Staff x x x Dedicated Digital Inclusion Funding x x x x Involvement in City- wide Digital Inclusion Network x x x x
  • 5. • 1995 - CitizensTelecommunications andTechnology Advisory Board created. • 1996 - Staff position created. Community Technology Program now has 4 full-time staff. • 1996 - Funding established. • 2000 - Survey conducted approximately every 4 years. City of Seattle
  • 6. • 2004 - 4 local organizations partner on an AmeriCorps grant to utilize community tech resources. • 2006 -Technology Literacy Collaborative created. • 2007 - Funding established. • 2010 - Staff position created. • 2012 - Survey conducted annually. City of Minneapolis
  • 7. • 2006 – Mayor’s Advisory Council on Closing the Digital Divide was created. • 2009 – Community technology planning process conducted in 5 neighborhoods. • 2010 – BTOP SBA award. • 2013 – City of ChicagoTechnology Plan released. City of Chicago
  • 8. • 1995 - Austin FreeNet support begins. • 2011 - Survey conducted. • 2013 - Austin City Council approved $200,000 for community technology and $50,000 to conduct a residential survey. City of Austin
  • 9. • 2010 - NTIA awards two BTOP grants in Philadelphia. • 2010 - Office of Innovation andTechnology is created. • 2011 - City hires a Chief Innovation Officer. • 2013 - Funding established for internal and external Keyspots. • 2013 - Survey conducted.Will be released 2014. City of Philadelphia
  • 10. Internal External Academy of Municipal Innovation Innovation Lab Innovation Fund City of Philadelphia Components of Innovation CivicApps Open Data Digital Inclusion
  • 11. “Among the KEYSPOTS partners, there is no single organization that ‘owns’ digital inclusion. Digital inclusion is something that everyone can, and should, collectively own in Philadelphia.” Ashley Del Bianco, Program Manager, Office of Innovation andTechnology, City of Philadelphia
  • 12. City sponsored: 1. Stakeholder engagement that results in public statements of digital inclusion goals and strategies 2. Information technology access & use surveys. 3. Staff dedicated to digital inclusion. 4. Dedicated digital inclusion funding. 5. Involvement in a city-wide digital inclusion network.
  • 13. The city’s involvement does the following: • Increases the likelihood that digital inclusion issues will be integrated into other city departments and community-based efforts. • Reduces the possibility that the digital inclusion efforts could become a political casualty. • Increases potential for a reliable source of funding. • Helps ensure that investments from all sectors are coordinated and strategic.

Notes de l'éditeur

  1. This presentation is based upon my work in Trailblazing Digital Inclusion Communities.
  2. Other than Chicago, each of the Cities is conducting access and use surveys on at least a tentative schedule. All Cities with a dedicated staff (or portion of a person dedicated to digital inclusion) are located in a technology department. I’m going to run through the highlights of each of these 5 cities. It’ll be fast so I’ll stick with the most relevant activities in each city.
  3. Granddaddy of them all. Their slide should be 3 slides but we don’t have enough time. The staff have integrated digital inclusion issues into other city departments, advocated for digital inclusion locally and nationally and helped establish local and state networks of community technology programs. The funding is a result of a cable franchise agreement.
  4. The first two bullets are important because they show the community working together. Everything that follows would not have happened without the local organizations together convincing the City that digital inclusion should be part of the Wireless Minneapolis discussion. Nor would it all have happened without a strong champion. The funding source is 5% of profits from Wireless Minneapolis, which recently has not resulted in amounts large enough to distribute.
  5. Chicago has a rich history of community-based technology services and community organizing dating back to the 1990’s. Chicago was the only city to organize itself into a chapter of the national Community Technology Center Network (now dissolved). The community technology planning process conducted with neighborhoods occurred BEFORE they received the BTOP funding. The City of Chicago Technology Plan, now released, includes support and expansion of Chicago’s five Smart Communities plus creation of a benchmark and toolkit for broadband access and use. Chicago does not have staff, funding or a regularly scheduled survey. BUT they are the largest city with a Technology Plan that even mentions strategies for digital inclusion.
  6. Austin is example of a city in the initial stages, exemplified by the survey and the funding. The Austin Internet and Global Citizens Project was conducted in 2011. The survey focused on access to the Internet both at home and at public locations, the barriers to access, and reasons for using the Internet.
  7. Philadelphia is an example of a city with lasting impact from BTOP. The City of Philadelphia is funding Keyspots (PCCs) that are operated by City departments. The City has also made available funding for Keyspots in CBOs. 10 CBOs are receiving approximately $12,000 each. 60 of the original 80 Keyspots are in operation. Went from being a partnership to being a network. They are meeting quarterly. Drexel is maintaining the website.
  8. The items in the Internal circle are how the City is encouraging City departments and staff to be innovative. The items in the External circle show how the City is using innovation to engage and support residents to be more innovative themselves.
  9. Oh, wait. That’s not what I wanted to say. Oh, but I do love cookies.
  10. We need more information. We have only scratched the surface. We need to know why some cities see the value of a digitally inclusive community and take action toward it. The more we understand about those places, the more we can provide guidance to individuals and organizations who want to strengthen their communities.