In 2012 presenteerde Rasmus B. Andersen, Head of Research van het Deense Dansk Reclame Film een aantal specifieke econometrische cases op de Brightfish Research Day. Danks Reclame Film analyseerde de ROI van reclamecampagnes van Haribo, Coca Cola Zero en Carlsberg.
4. Media Mix of Haribo 2008-10
Haribo Claims Movie Universe
tv
38%
cinema
39%
outdoor
16%
EB
(Newspaper
– Movie
Print kino.dk section)
2%
magazine: 1%
kino
4%
Newspaper – Movie section
5. Return On Investment
Spending share for Haribo
Average ROI: 4,1
4,7
Biograf
Cinema
39%
3,1
TV
38%
2,8
Outdoor
16%
ROI
Andel af Haribos mediainvestering
Share of Haribo’s
media investment
6. Allocating Budget from Cinema
to TV Caused a 4% Decrease in Sales!
800K MOVED FROM CINEMA TO TV CREATE A LOWER ROI ON THE SAME BUDGET
Media mix
2
1
Jan
TV
Online
Magazine
Magasiner
Print
Outdoor
Cinema
Biograf
Feb
# #
Mar
Apr
May
Jun
# # # #
#
# # # # # # #
# # # # # #
#
#
#
#
#
# #
# # # # # # #
# #
# #
#
# # #
#
# # #
Jul
Aug
#
#
Sep
# #
# #
#
#
Oct
Nov
Dec
# # #
# # # # # # # # # # # # # #
#
#
#
#
# #
# #
# # # # # # #
# #
# #
# #
# #
# #
2
1
Eff. coverage
Dobbeltdækning
Double coverage
Dobbeltdækning
Jan
Jan
Feb
Mar
Mar
TV
Apr
Apr
Apr
Online
Online
May
May
Jun
Magazine
Magasin
Magasin
Jul
Print
Print
Aug
Aug
Sep
Cinema
Biograf
Biograf
Outdoor
Outdoor
Oct
Nov
Nov
Dec
Key figures
2
1
Estimeret add. sales: DKK 37 mio.
Estimated mer-salg: DKK 38,5 mio.
TV: 33%
44%
kino.dk: 5%
kino: 3%
EB (film):
Movie: 1%1%
ROI fra investeringen: 5,3
ROI from the investment: 5,1
Outdoor: 24%
Biograf: 23%
Cinema: 34%
Allocation from cinema to TV
create a lower ROI for HARIBO!
9. Background
and Method
The market:
•
Coca-Cola is in a market with
enormous price competition
•
Media budgets have been declining
due to competition
The focus:
•
Return on Investment
•
Decomposition of the sales
•
Identifying the long-term effects of
television and cinema advertising
•
Models for optimizing the
marketing of Coca-Cola
11. Cinema is the Best
Despite Price Competition
ROI
2,0
1,2
1,1
0,4
Cinema
TV
Launch
print
Post print
The levels are satisfactory because
of a sales structure where approx.
65% of sales is on special offer
13. The campaign is
continuous in cinema
Wasp
Penguin
Squirrel
The commercial has
been abridged
Source: BrandScience jan. 2011. The cinema campaign has largely remained at the same time with the big TV campaign.
14. Cinema is the strongest medium
to boost sales!
Indexing of ROI-Numbers
Cinema
133
TV
103
Internet
83
Radio
83
15. Comment
From the Media Agency
" Through this sales modeling, we have measured in
recent years
the strong ability of cinema advertising to generate
increased sales for Carlsberg Sport.
In this sales modeling we also found that
cinema advertising contributed the most positive
to the revenue for Carlsberg Sport during this period."
Rikke Grønlund
Media Director, PHD
Denmark A/S
16. Comment
From the Advertiser
”It has been important for us to uncover the effect on sales of
each specific medium in the media plan. We have seen this
very clearly in the actual sales modeling case.
It is very interesting to see, how the impact has been the last
year and cinema has separated itself positively from the
other media with a higher ROI.
Cinema is a unique medium which not only contributes to
the quality of exposure but can also increase sales on short
and long term. ”
Rasmus Bendtsen
Brand Manager, Carlsberg
Danmark A/S
17. Conclusion
•
•
•
•
Carlsberg Sport has particular chosen cinema because of the good audience
segment match, the high quality of exposure and the ability to execute a
continuous campaign strategy
But Cinema has also been able to create sales
Cinema delivers an excellent result as the medium that achieves the highest ROI:
as much as 33% better than average
Cinema is therefore the most cost effective media investment for Carlsberg Sport
Notes de l'éditeur
Baseret på SuperGros dataSom alm. salgsmodellering
TV 16,6 m, Bio 16,9 m ogOutdoor 6,7 m
Gennemsnitlig ROI 4,1Bio højest med 4,7Online og printThe media has contributed with 2.3 billion DKK in increased turnover in the storesFor each dollar invested in advertising the return is 4 dollars and 10 cents ROI is easily measured based on retail profits. The correct margin just needs to be taken into account ikke med pga. meget lavt budget
Kvalificerede eksponeringer kan beregnes, når man ved, hvilke eksponeringer der fører til salg.Conversion rate er et simplet udtryk for, hvor stor en andel af det totale antal eksponeringer der er kvalificerede – altså medfører salg
Ohal og MEC har brugt salgsmodelleringen til at definere forskellige scenarier.Fx hvad sker der hvis man fjerner budget fra bio til tv => lavere salgMeget brugbart værktøj for Haribo, hvor det kreative indhold tilsyneladende ikke har det store at sige
Udarbejdet af Markting Clinic med fokus Coca-Cola Zero siden lanceringen i 2008
Modellen har en forklaringsgrad på 95% af salget. Og som det ses har modellen en stærk base på 83%Denne figur tager således IKKE højde for mediebudgettets størrelseFx er investeringen i TV væsentlig højere end i Biografmediet – investering 80/20, men effekt 67/33
Biograf har været en del af mediamixet for Coca-Cola Zero siden lanceringen i 2007Biograf har været det stærkeste bidrag til Zeros salg siden lanceringenBiograf har vist et positivt ROI omkring 2, hvilket er marginalt bedre end TV. Dette er positivt i et meget prisfokuseret og discountpræget sodavandsmarkedI tillæg er der kvalitative fordele ved biograf, som retfærdiggør biograf som grundlag for en kreativ platform for Coca-ColaBiograf har været et stærkt supplement til TV pga. kombinationen af TV’s korte salgseffekt og biografens mere langsigtede salgsopbygningAlle medier har ROI tæt på 1 pga. en salgsstruktur, hvor ca. 65% af salget er relateret til tilbudDerfor må niveauerne betragtes som tilfredsstillendeDet totale ROI er baseret på fire års mediainvestering med forskellige budgetterROI er beregnet på baggrund af bruttoinvesteringer relateret til salgsløft
Cinema is 33% over the average ROIThis is significantly above the other media on the mediaplanTV is over average (100)Internet og Radio is 17 % under average
Carlsberg Sport har bl.a. valgt biograf pga. det gode målgruppematch, den høje eksponeringskvalitet samt muligheden for at eksekvere en kontinuerlig kampagnestrategiMen biografen har også været i stand til at skabe salgBiografen leverer et flot resultat som det medie der opnår højst ROI – hele 33% bedre end gennemsnitBiograf er dermed den mest kosteffektive mediainvestering for Carlsberg Sport
Thank you for allowing me to speak to you here today.I am very happy to be here among good colleagues.I am the only representative from Denmark: Dansk Reklame Film – which means Danish Advertising FilmWe see ourselves as a small giant in a large Nordic corporation (Egmont). In our department we are only 20 employees. Hereof 4 working with research.We have been doing quite good with growth since we digitalized in 2008. Our revenue is USD 11 mill.