2. Traditional M&E focuses on the monitoring
and evaluation of inputs, activities, and
outputs (i.e., on project or program
implementation).
Results-based M&E, in contrast, combines the
traditional approach of monitoring
implementation with the assessment of Results.
(from MDF traning material)
3. What does this mean? What are results? And
why are we focusing on RBM?
What would be the challnges?
4. A way to tell success from failure
Seeing success means ability to reward it
Identifying succes gives opportunity to learn
Identifying failures gives opportunity for
correction
Results can lead to broad support.
(Adapted from 10 steps to RMB)
6. A monitoring system, is needed – in this
specific indicators for which types of changes
we want to see are essential.
How do we get the right indicators?
7. A results-based M&E system:
Provides answers to the ’what then’ question
Provides crucial information about
organizational performance.
Can help policy makers, decision makers, and
other stakeholders answer the fundamental
questions of whether promises were kept and
goals achieved
(Source MDF training material)
8. A results-based M&E system:
promote credibility and confidence in the
work.
Is a management and motivational tool
Provides managers with crucial information on
whether the theory of change guiding the
intervention is appropriate, correct, and
adequate to the changes being sought through
this intervention.
(Source MDF training material)
9. Formulate goal and outcomes
Select outcome indicators to monitor
Gather baseline information
Set specific targets and a timetable for
achievment
Regularely collect data to assess wether the
targets are being met
Analyse and report the results
(Adapted from 10 steps to RBM)
12. Define what we want to know
Be clear on ’What I need this information for’.
Clarify if ’I have access to this information’.
Be clear on ’How will I gather it’?
Remember there is a difference between data
and information.
Clarify, who needs what type of information
and for what purpose.
14. The monitoring system should provide answers to
the questions the ’managers’ ask to make informed
decision.
There should be clarity on the processes
”bottlenecks of time” and responsibilities on all
levels
Which of your identified questions are the most
relevant ones? – only these should be in the system
(MDF training material)
15. Open ended
Related to chain of events
Formulated in full sentenses
WHO needs to know?
WHAT do they need to know?
HOW to get that info to them?
17. Objective Baseline Current Situation
Expect
ed
Result
and
impact
Indica
tor
Indic
ator
Score
(numb
er and
narrat
ive)
Assessment
Based on IBIS
and partners’
quarterly
reports,
questionnaires
and focus
groups as
relevant
Attribution
To what extent
and how can
changes in the
indicator be
attributed to
IBIS’ activities
and support?
Score
(1-5)
Trend
in
Score:
(up/unc
hanged
/down
as
compare
d with
previou
s
assessm
ent)
Score
Justifi
cation
(Monitoring system from IBIS SL)
18.
19.
20. Ten steps to a Results Based Monitoring and
Ecaluation System. Kusek and Rist.
MDF training materials.
Notes de l'éditeur
The logical thinking in the results chain doesn’t take the full environment into considerations – it demands heavy assumptions. (refer back to PC slides)Ex – better educated teacehers hightens education which then inturn results in the community increasing their income... Also – we are measuring something we have no control over...
Output: the product – the deliverable from the projectOutcome: the change in behaviour by targetImpact: the long term effects on the broader society.
Refer back to the horse – we want a happy horse, but how can we know if it is happy, that is beyond us. What will show us that the horse is happy? Preset indicators – derived from what determined that the horse was unhappy. Link from problem to impact is CRUSIAL.
With a basis in the results chain:1) Expectations and contribution to joint monitoring– (Who needs to know?)2) Areas to Monitor – - What they need to know3) Key performance indicators - How to get info to managers?4) Organising RbM5) Usage of Monitoring!
Record suggestions on flip chart – compare with next slide...
The system is not fully encompassing: The manager needs to chose what info goes in which system:Regluar monitoring system -done by othersOrOn demand evaluation systemOrPersonal info system...
Discuss how we register, report, dissiminate, learn and improve... This needs to be part of our monitoring system...
Who collects the information?Who processes it?Who reports?How is it coordintated?
A good way of looking at specific indicators and measure inprovement – but it doesn’t go beyound that...