SlideShare une entreprise Scribd logo
1  sur  2
Télécharger pour lire hors ligne
WHAT NOW FOR HONOLULU'S RAIL PROJECT?
By Ron Fisher and Jim Ryan, Honolulu Star Advertiser, September 12, 2021
<https://www.staradvertiser.com/2021/09/12/editorial/island-voices/what-now-for-honolulus-rail-project/>
The Honolulu rail project has reached a point where completion of the project as originally
planned no longer appears possible without another large infusion of local or state funding.
Honolulu now faces a momentous decision on where to locate the terminus of a shorter rail
project that may be in place for many years, possibly decades. The way that decision is reached
will determine the confidence of local officials, and the trust of the public, that the modified
project will be finished successfully.
We evaluated dozens of major transit projects during our careers in the Federal Transit
Administration's Office of Planning. Honolulu's rail project clearly met the evaluation criteria set
by Congress and, consequently, received a Full Funding Grant Agreement in 2012.
We personally supported that decision because the project would be a huge improvement in
transit service for the tens of thousands of existing transit riders and others who might choose to
use it. We continue to think that is true.
The estimated $5.1 billion project cost was a concern because of Honolulu's relatively small
population and tax base. But we believed the benefits of the project justified that expenditure and
the city's financial plan indicated it was affordable.
Escalating costs and schedule delays led the FTA to require a “recovery plan” for completion of
the 20-mile project. The Honolulu Authority for Rapid Transportation (HART) prepared, and
FTA accepted, a plan that in 2019 promised completion by 2026 at a total cost of $8.9 billion,
with the additional funding coming from new local tax revenues.
Now, barely two years later, HART anticipates completion in 2031 at a total cost of $12.4 billion
but with a $3.5 billion funding shortfall — a stunning revelation that threatens any remaining
public faith in a useful project outcome.
Another “recovery plan” is clearly inappropriate for the decision at hand. The question is
no longer, “How will we finish the 20-mile project?” but rather, “What shorter project
makes most sense for our foreseeable future?” [Emphasis Supplied]
The answer to this new question requires, first, a careful and objective analysis of where the
project actually stands in terms of expenditures to date, and then, a realistic assessment of the
costs and benefits of alternative locations for a new project terminus short of Ala Moana Center.
Candidate locations would likely include several of the currently planned stations.
The analysis would have to address the design of a terminal station that could accommodate
potentially heavy volumes of arriving rail passengers; changes to the bus system needed to move
rail passengers from the terminal; impacts on street traffic near the terminal; impacts on transit
travel times and transferring; the number of potential riders who would opt out of travel by rail;
and the trade-offs among the costs, impacts, and benefits of the options.
While HART would be an essential PARTICIPANT, THE EFFORT REQUIRES
EXPERTISE THAT IS DIFFERENT FROM HART'S CONSTRUCTION-ORIENTED
MISSION. THE WORK SHOULD BE DONE BY AN INDEPENDENT TEAM WITH
OBJECTIVITY, THE NECESSARY TECHNICAL EXPERTISE, AND A
COMMITMENT TO TRANSPARENCY. The team's [HART] only responsibility would be
to provide solid information that the people of Oahu and their elected officials can trust as
the basis for the hard decisions at hand, and not to advocate for a particular terminus
location.
The City Council or HAWAII LEGISLATURE would be the appropriate sponsor of the
analysis, ideally with TECHNICAL ASSISTANCE FROM FTA. Having worked on the
planning of this worthy project for many years, we want it to succeed. Decisions should not
be rushed, and the necessary analysis will take some time. It is critical to get started —
soon.
[Emphasis and Clarification Supplied]
__________________________________________________
The “iron rice bowl” is a Chinese idiom which referred to the now abolished system of
guaranteed lifetime employment
__________________________________________________
I hope people find hope in my life story and know to never give up. People are stronger than
I hope people find hope in my life story and know to never give up. People are stronger than
they think they are. I've never seen the world stop like this. People are tired and asking when
they think they are. I've never seen the world stop like this. People are tired and asking when
this is going to stop. They must believe that anything is possible in this life and that things will
this is going to stop. They must believe that anything is possible in this life and that things will
get better. I'm living proof of that.
get better. I'm living proof of that.
JIM MORRIS – “ THE ROOKIE”
JIM MORRIS – “ THE ROOKIE”
The Guardian, Johnathan Drennan, August 30, 2020
<https://www.theguardian.com/sport/behind-the-lines/2020/aug/03/jim-morris-anything-is-possible-life-major-league-baseball>

Contenu connexe

Similaire à Hawaii - HART Rail Project - FTA - Welcome Aboard - Taking Charge - Breaking the Iron Rice Bowl - Moving Ahead

The Honolulu Rail Project - Hawaii Senator Brian Schatz - Reality for Challen...
The Honolulu Rail Project - Hawaii Senator Brian Schatz - Reality for Challen...The Honolulu Rail Project - Hawaii Senator Brian Schatz - Reality for Challen...
The Honolulu Rail Project - Hawaii Senator Brian Schatz - Reality for Challen...Clifton M. Hasegawa & Associates, LLC
 
Honolulu Rail Project - Who's to Blame Game - Responsiblity and Accountabilit...
Honolulu Rail Project - Who's to Blame Game - Responsiblity and Accountabilit...Honolulu Rail Project - Who's to Blame Game - Responsiblity and Accountabilit...
Honolulu Rail Project - Who's to Blame Game - Responsiblity and Accountabilit...Clifton M. Hasegawa & Associates, LLC
 
Department of Transportation Fiscal Year 2012 Budget Highlights
Department of Transportation Fiscal Year 2012 Budget HighlightsDepartment of Transportation Fiscal Year 2012 Budget Highlights
Department of Transportation Fiscal Year 2012 Budget HighlightsPorts-To-Plains Blog
 
Managing California HSPR Programs-Caltrain, Bazeley
Managing California HSPR Programs-Caltrain, Bazeley Managing California HSPR Programs-Caltrain, Bazeley
Managing California HSPR Programs-Caltrain, Bazeley Roger Bazeley, USA
 
Caldwell for Mayor 2012: Build Rail Better
Caldwell for Mayor 2012: Build Rail BetterCaldwell for Mayor 2012: Build Rail Better
Caldwell for Mayor 2012: Build Rail BetterNeenz Faleafine
 
2-2016 - Tackling the Infrastructure Deficit
2-2016 - Tackling the Infrastructure Deficit2-2016 - Tackling the Infrastructure Deficit
2-2016 - Tackling the Infrastructure DeficitShane Skelton
 
Rapoport Testimony Pa 1 14 10
Rapoport Testimony   Pa 1 14 10Rapoport Testimony   Pa 1 14 10
Rapoport Testimony Pa 1 14 10frapop
 
Financing Public Transit in San Diego
Financing Public Transit in San DiegoFinancing Public Transit in San Diego
Financing Public Transit in San DiegoHana Creger
 
Build it Right
Build it RightBuild it Right
Build it RightLee Haber
 
PuttingPlacesFirst
PuttingPlacesFirstPuttingPlacesFirst
PuttingPlacesFirstCharles Tso
 
The Honolulu Rail - Kirk Caldwell - Courage Under Fire - Release the Kraken -...
The Honolulu Rail - Kirk Caldwell - Courage Under Fire - Release the Kraken -...The Honolulu Rail - Kirk Caldwell - Courage Under Fire - Release the Kraken -...
The Honolulu Rail - Kirk Caldwell - Courage Under Fire - Release the Kraken -...Clifton M. Hasegawa & Associates, LLC
 
Return on Investment Analysis City of Denver
Return on Investment Analysis City of DenverReturn on Investment Analysis City of Denver
Return on Investment Analysis City of DenverAndrew Orrego-Lindstad
 
ARTBA Comments on DOT Geographic Based Preferences Pilot Program
ARTBA Comments on DOT Geographic Based Preferences Pilot ProgramARTBA Comments on DOT Geographic Based Preferences Pilot Program
ARTBA Comments on DOT Geographic Based Preferences Pilot Programartba
 
Honolulu Mayor Kirk Caldwell - Field of Dreams Build It They Will Come - The...
Honolulu Mayor Kirk Caldwell - Field of Dreams  Build It They Will Come - The...Honolulu Mayor Kirk Caldwell - Field of Dreams  Build It They Will Come - The...
Honolulu Mayor Kirk Caldwell - Field of Dreams Build It They Will Come - The...Clifton M. Hasegawa & Associates, LLC
 
Public Private Partnerships - State of the Market and the Future of P3's
Public Private Partnerships - State of the Market and the Future of P3'sPublic Private Partnerships - State of the Market and the Future of P3's
Public Private Partnerships - State of the Market and the Future of P3'sJonathan Hunt
 

Similaire à Hawaii - HART Rail Project - FTA - Welcome Aboard - Taking Charge - Breaking the Iron Rice Bowl - Moving Ahead (20)

The Honolulu Rail Project - Hawaii Senator Brian Schatz - Reality for Challen...
The Honolulu Rail Project - Hawaii Senator Brian Schatz - Reality for Challen...The Honolulu Rail Project - Hawaii Senator Brian Schatz - Reality for Challen...
The Honolulu Rail Project - Hawaii Senator Brian Schatz - Reality for Challen...
 
Honolulu Rail Project - Who's to Blame Game - Responsiblity and Accountabilit...
Honolulu Rail Project - Who's to Blame Game - Responsiblity and Accountabilit...Honolulu Rail Project - Who's to Blame Game - Responsiblity and Accountabilit...
Honolulu Rail Project - Who's to Blame Game - Responsiblity and Accountabilit...
 
Department of Transportation Fiscal Year 2012 Budget Highlights
Department of Transportation Fiscal Year 2012 Budget HighlightsDepartment of Transportation Fiscal Year 2012 Budget Highlights
Department of Transportation Fiscal Year 2012 Budget Highlights
 
Managing California HSPR Programs-Caltrain, Bazeley
Managing California HSPR Programs-Caltrain, Bazeley Managing California HSPR Programs-Caltrain, Bazeley
Managing California HSPR Programs-Caltrain, Bazeley
 
FMOC Report
FMOC ReportFMOC Report
FMOC Report
 
Caldwell for Mayor 2012: Build Rail Better
Caldwell for Mayor 2012: Build Rail BetterCaldwell for Mayor 2012: Build Rail Better
Caldwell for Mayor 2012: Build Rail Better
 
Resolution 15-90
Resolution 15-90Resolution 15-90
Resolution 15-90
 
2-2016 - Tackling the Infrastructure Deficit
2-2016 - Tackling the Infrastructure Deficit2-2016 - Tackling the Infrastructure Deficit
2-2016 - Tackling the Infrastructure Deficit
 
Rapoport Testimony Pa 1 14 10
Rapoport Testimony   Pa 1 14 10Rapoport Testimony   Pa 1 14 10
Rapoport Testimony Pa 1 14 10
 
Financing Public Transit in San Diego
Financing Public Transit in San DiegoFinancing Public Transit in San Diego
Financing Public Transit in San Diego
 
Build it Right
Build it RightBuild it Right
Build it Right
 
Tod rules
Tod rulesTod rules
Tod rules
 
PuttingPlacesFirst
PuttingPlacesFirstPuttingPlacesFirst
PuttingPlacesFirst
 
HART letter
HART letterHART letter
HART letter
 
The Honolulu Rail - Kirk Caldwell - Courage Under Fire - Release the Kraken -...
The Honolulu Rail - Kirk Caldwell - Courage Under Fire - Release the Kraken -...The Honolulu Rail - Kirk Caldwell - Courage Under Fire - Release the Kraken -...
The Honolulu Rail - Kirk Caldwell - Courage Under Fire - Release the Kraken -...
 
Return on Investment Analysis City of Denver
Return on Investment Analysis City of DenverReturn on Investment Analysis City of Denver
Return on Investment Analysis City of Denver
 
ARTBA Comments on DOT Geographic Based Preferences Pilot Program
ARTBA Comments on DOT Geographic Based Preferences Pilot ProgramARTBA Comments on DOT Geographic Based Preferences Pilot Program
ARTBA Comments on DOT Geographic Based Preferences Pilot Program
 
Honolulu Mayor Kirk Caldwell - Field of Dreams Build It They Will Come - The...
Honolulu Mayor Kirk Caldwell - Field of Dreams  Build It They Will Come - The...Honolulu Mayor Kirk Caldwell - Field of Dreams  Build It They Will Come - The...
Honolulu Mayor Kirk Caldwell - Field of Dreams Build It They Will Come - The...
 
Ori honolulu
Ori honoluluOri honolulu
Ori honolulu
 
Public Private Partnerships - State of the Market and the Future of P3's
Public Private Partnerships - State of the Market and the Future of P3'sPublic Private Partnerships - State of the Market and the Future of P3's
Public Private Partnerships - State of the Market and the Future of P3's
 

Plus de Clifton M. Hasegawa & Associates, LLC

Hawaii Agricultural Development Agency (ADC) - Raising the Phoenix - Reconstr...
Hawaii Agricultural Development Agency (ADC) - Raising the Phoenix - Reconstr...Hawaii Agricultural Development Agency (ADC) - Raising the Phoenix - Reconstr...
Hawaii Agricultural Development Agency (ADC) - Raising the Phoenix - Reconstr...Clifton M. Hasegawa & Associates, LLC
 
Hawaii Agricultural Development Agency (ADC) - Hawaii Legislature Special Inv...
Hawaii Agricultural Development Agency (ADC) - Hawaii Legislature Special Inv...Hawaii Agricultural Development Agency (ADC) - Hawaii Legislature Special Inv...
Hawaii Agricultural Development Agency (ADC) - Hawaii Legislature Special Inv...Clifton M. Hasegawa & Associates, LLC
 
Hawaii Agricultural Development Corporation (ADC) - Hawaii Legislature Specia...
Hawaii Agricultural Development Corporation (ADC) - Hawaii Legislature Specia...Hawaii Agricultural Development Corporation (ADC) - Hawaii Legislature Specia...
Hawaii Agricultural Development Corporation (ADC) - Hawaii Legislature Specia...Clifton M. Hasegawa & Associates, LLC
 
Hawaii Agricultural Development Corporation (ADC) - Legislative Investigation...
Hawaii Agricultural Development Corporation (ADC) - Legislative Investigation...Hawaii Agricultural Development Corporation (ADC) - Legislative Investigation...
Hawaii Agricultural Development Corporation (ADC) - Legislative Investigation...Clifton M. Hasegawa & Associates, LLC
 
Hawaii Agriculture - Dammed If You Do, Dammed If You Don't - The Fork in the ...
Hawaii Agriculture - Dammed If You Do, Dammed If You Don't - The Fork in the ...Hawaii Agriculture - Dammed If You Do, Dammed If You Don't - The Fork in the ...
Hawaii Agriculture - Dammed If You Do, Dammed If You Don't - The Fork in the ...Clifton M. Hasegawa & Associates, LLC
 
Hawaii Agriculture - David Murdock - Man on a Mission Making the Pivot - The ...
Hawaii Agriculture - David Murdock - Man on a Mission Making the Pivot - The ...Hawaii Agriculture - David Murdock - Man on a Mission Making the Pivot - The ...
Hawaii Agriculture - David Murdock - Man on a Mission Making the Pivot - The ...Clifton M. Hasegawa & Associates, LLC
 
Hawaii - Working Together - Charting Hawaii's Course for a Resilient Future -...
Hawaii - Working Together - Charting Hawaii's Course for a Resilient Future -...Hawaii - Working Together - Charting Hawaii's Course for a Resilient Future -...
Hawaii - Working Together - Charting Hawaii's Course for a Resilient Future -...Clifton M. Hasegawa & Associates, LLC
 
Hawaii - Hu Honua Biomass Plant -- Henk Rogers - Blue Planet, Man On A Mission
Hawaii  - Hu Honua Biomass Plant -- Henk Rogers - Blue Planet, Man On A MissionHawaii  - Hu Honua Biomass Plant -- Henk Rogers - Blue Planet, Man On A Mission
Hawaii - Hu Honua Biomass Plant -- Henk Rogers - Blue Planet, Man On A MissionClifton M. Hasegawa & Associates, LLC
 
Hawaii Public Utilities Commission - Young Brothers Ltd. - Delivering The Bes...
Hawaii Public Utilities Commission - Young Brothers Ltd. - Delivering The Bes...Hawaii Public Utilities Commission - Young Brothers Ltd. - Delivering The Bes...
Hawaii Public Utilities Commission - Young Brothers Ltd. - Delivering The Bes...Clifton M. Hasegawa & Associates, LLC
 
Hawaii - Equal Justice Under The Law - Office Of The Public Defender - Advoca...
Hawaii - Equal Justice Under The Law - Office Of The Public Defender - Advoca...Hawaii - Equal Justice Under The Law - Office Of The Public Defender - Advoca...
Hawaii - Equal Justice Under The Law - Office Of The Public Defender - Advoca...Clifton M. Hasegawa & Associates, LLC
 
Hawaii - Red Hill Fuel Storage - GO NAVY - The Time is Now-The Future is Here...
Hawaii - Red Hill Fuel Storage - GO NAVY - The Time is Now-The Future is Here...Hawaii - Red Hill Fuel Storage - GO NAVY - The Time is Now-The Future is Here...
Hawaii - Red Hill Fuel Storage - GO NAVY - The Time is Now-The Future is Here...Clifton M. Hasegawa & Associates, LLC
 
Hawaii - Corona Tsunami - The Wake Up Call - Hawaii Pono`i - We Are Warriors ...
Hawaii - Corona Tsunami - The Wake Up Call - Hawaii Pono`i - We Are Warriors ...Hawaii - Corona Tsunami - The Wake Up Call - Hawaii Pono`i - We Are Warriors ...
Hawaii - Corona Tsunami - The Wake Up Call - Hawaii Pono`i - We Are Warriors ...Clifton M. Hasegawa & Associates, LLC
 
HART - The Purge - The Prize - The Pivot - The Team - Great Opportunities and...
HART - The Purge - The Prize - The Pivot - The Team - Great Opportunities and...HART - The Purge - The Prize - The Pivot - The Team - Great Opportunities and...
HART - The Purge - The Prize - The Pivot - The Team - Great Opportunities and...Clifton M. Hasegawa & Associates, LLC
 
Hawaii - John A. Burns School of Medicine - Graffiti - ID Root of the Problem...
Hawaii - John A. Burns School of Medicine - Graffiti - ID Root of the Problem...Hawaii - John A. Burns School of Medicine - Graffiti - ID Root of the Problem...
Hawaii - John A. Burns School of Medicine - Graffiti - ID Root of the Problem...Clifton M. Hasegawa & Associates, LLC
 
Hawaii - Vaccine Research - Advancing Humanity - Invest in Our Future
Hawaii - Vaccine Research - Advancing Humanity - Invest in Our FutureHawaii - Vaccine Research - Advancing Humanity - Invest in Our Future
Hawaii - Vaccine Research - Advancing Humanity - Invest in Our FutureClifton M. Hasegawa & Associates, LLC
 
Hawaii - Merck and Pfizer - Providing for Humanity - Research and Clinical Tr...
Hawaii - Merck and Pfizer - Providing for Humanity - Research and Clinical Tr...Hawaii - Merck and Pfizer - Providing for Humanity - Research and Clinical Tr...
Hawaii - Merck and Pfizer - Providing for Humanity - Research and Clinical Tr...Clifton M. Hasegawa & Associates, LLC
 
Maui County, Hawaii - Fire and Public Safety - Outthinking Wildfire - A Tribu...
Maui County, Hawaii - Fire and Public Safety - Outthinking Wildfire - A Tribu...Maui County, Hawaii - Fire and Public Safety - Outthinking Wildfire - A Tribu...
Maui County, Hawaii - Fire and Public Safety - Outthinking Wildfire - A Tribu...Clifton M. Hasegawa & Associates, LLC
 
Maui - Communities at Risk - Wildfire Protection Plans - Ride the Fire-Breath...
Maui - Communities at Risk - Wildfire Protection Plans - Ride the Fire-Breath...Maui - Communities at Risk - Wildfire Protection Plans - Ride the Fire-Breath...
Maui - Communities at Risk - Wildfire Protection Plans - Ride the Fire-Breath...Clifton M. Hasegawa & Associates, LLC
 

Plus de Clifton M. Hasegawa & Associates, LLC (20)

Hawaii Agricultural Development Agency (ADC) - Raising the Phoenix - Reconstr...
Hawaii Agricultural Development Agency (ADC) - Raising the Phoenix - Reconstr...Hawaii Agricultural Development Agency (ADC) - Raising the Phoenix - Reconstr...
Hawaii Agricultural Development Agency (ADC) - Raising the Phoenix - Reconstr...
 
Hawaii Agricultural Development Agency (ADC) - Hawaii Legislature Special Inv...
Hawaii Agricultural Development Agency (ADC) - Hawaii Legislature Special Inv...Hawaii Agricultural Development Agency (ADC) - Hawaii Legislature Special Inv...
Hawaii Agricultural Development Agency (ADC) - Hawaii Legislature Special Inv...
 
Hawaii Agricultural Development Corporation (ADC) - Hawaii Legislature Specia...
Hawaii Agricultural Development Corporation (ADC) - Hawaii Legislature Specia...Hawaii Agricultural Development Corporation (ADC) - Hawaii Legislature Specia...
Hawaii Agricultural Development Corporation (ADC) - Hawaii Legislature Specia...
 
Hawaii Agricultural Development Corporation (ADC) - Legislative Investigation...
Hawaii Agricultural Development Corporation (ADC) - Legislative Investigation...Hawaii Agricultural Development Corporation (ADC) - Legislative Investigation...
Hawaii Agricultural Development Corporation (ADC) - Legislative Investigation...
 
Hawaii Agriculture - Dammed If You Do, Dammed If You Don't - The Fork in the ...
Hawaii Agriculture - Dammed If You Do, Dammed If You Don't - The Fork in the ...Hawaii Agriculture - Dammed If You Do, Dammed If You Don't - The Fork in the ...
Hawaii Agriculture - Dammed If You Do, Dammed If You Don't - The Fork in the ...
 
Hawaii Agriculture - David Murdock - Man on a Mission Making the Pivot - The ...
Hawaii Agriculture - David Murdock - Man on a Mission Making the Pivot - The ...Hawaii Agriculture - David Murdock - Man on a Mission Making the Pivot - The ...
Hawaii Agriculture - David Murdock - Man on a Mission Making the Pivot - The ...
 
Hawaii - Working Together - Charting Hawaii's Course for a Resilient Future -...
Hawaii - Working Together - Charting Hawaii's Course for a Resilient Future -...Hawaii - Working Together - Charting Hawaii's Course for a Resilient Future -...
Hawaii - Working Together - Charting Hawaii's Course for a Resilient Future -...
 
Hawaii - Hu Honua Biomass Plant -- Henk Rogers - Blue Planet, Man On A Mission
Hawaii  - Hu Honua Biomass Plant -- Henk Rogers - Blue Planet, Man On A MissionHawaii  - Hu Honua Biomass Plant -- Henk Rogers - Blue Planet, Man On A Mission
Hawaii - Hu Honua Biomass Plant -- Henk Rogers - Blue Planet, Man On A Mission
 
Hawaii Public Utilities Commission - Young Brothers Ltd. - Delivering The Bes...
Hawaii Public Utilities Commission - Young Brothers Ltd. - Delivering The Bes...Hawaii Public Utilities Commission - Young Brothers Ltd. - Delivering The Bes...
Hawaii Public Utilities Commission - Young Brothers Ltd. - Delivering The Bes...
 
Hawaii - Mayor Mitch Roth - Freedom, Equality, and Justice for All
Hawaii - Mayor Mitch Roth - Freedom, Equality, and Justice for AllHawaii - Mayor Mitch Roth - Freedom, Equality, and Justice for All
Hawaii - Mayor Mitch Roth - Freedom, Equality, and Justice for All
 
Hawaii - Equal Justice Under The Law - Office Of The Public Defender - Advoca...
Hawaii - Equal Justice Under The Law - Office Of The Public Defender - Advoca...Hawaii - Equal Justice Under The Law - Office Of The Public Defender - Advoca...
Hawaii - Equal Justice Under The Law - Office Of The Public Defender - Advoca...
 
Hawaii - Red Hill Fuel Storage - GO NAVY - The Time is Now-The Future is Here...
Hawaii - Red Hill Fuel Storage - GO NAVY - The Time is Now-The Future is Here...Hawaii - Red Hill Fuel Storage - GO NAVY - The Time is Now-The Future is Here...
Hawaii - Red Hill Fuel Storage - GO NAVY - The Time is Now-The Future is Here...
 
Hawaii - Corona Tsunami - The Wake Up Call - Hawaii Pono`i - We Are Warriors ...
Hawaii - Corona Tsunami - The Wake Up Call - Hawaii Pono`i - We Are Warriors ...Hawaii - Corona Tsunami - The Wake Up Call - Hawaii Pono`i - We Are Warriors ...
Hawaii - Corona Tsunami - The Wake Up Call - Hawaii Pono`i - We Are Warriors ...
 
HART - The Purge - The Prize - The Pivot - The Team - Great Opportunities and...
HART - The Purge - The Prize - The Pivot - The Team - Great Opportunities and...HART - The Purge - The Prize - The Pivot - The Team - Great Opportunities and...
HART - The Purge - The Prize - The Pivot - The Team - Great Opportunities and...
 
Hawaii - Unite 5 - Protect Our Workers - Labor Day 2021
Hawaii - Unite 5 - Protect Our Workers - Labor Day 2021Hawaii - Unite 5 - Protect Our Workers - Labor Day 2021
Hawaii - Unite 5 - Protect Our Workers - Labor Day 2021
 
Hawaii - John A. Burns School of Medicine - Graffiti - ID Root of the Problem...
Hawaii - John A. Burns School of Medicine - Graffiti - ID Root of the Problem...Hawaii - John A. Burns School of Medicine - Graffiti - ID Root of the Problem...
Hawaii - John A. Burns School of Medicine - Graffiti - ID Root of the Problem...
 
Hawaii - Vaccine Research - Advancing Humanity - Invest in Our Future
Hawaii - Vaccine Research - Advancing Humanity - Invest in Our FutureHawaii - Vaccine Research - Advancing Humanity - Invest in Our Future
Hawaii - Vaccine Research - Advancing Humanity - Invest in Our Future
 
Hawaii - Merck and Pfizer - Providing for Humanity - Research and Clinical Tr...
Hawaii - Merck and Pfizer - Providing for Humanity - Research and Clinical Tr...Hawaii - Merck and Pfizer - Providing for Humanity - Research and Clinical Tr...
Hawaii - Merck and Pfizer - Providing for Humanity - Research and Clinical Tr...
 
Maui County, Hawaii - Fire and Public Safety - Outthinking Wildfire - A Tribu...
Maui County, Hawaii - Fire and Public Safety - Outthinking Wildfire - A Tribu...Maui County, Hawaii - Fire and Public Safety - Outthinking Wildfire - A Tribu...
Maui County, Hawaii - Fire and Public Safety - Outthinking Wildfire - A Tribu...
 
Maui - Communities at Risk - Wildfire Protection Plans - Ride the Fire-Breath...
Maui - Communities at Risk - Wildfire Protection Plans - Ride the Fire-Breath...Maui - Communities at Risk - Wildfire Protection Plans - Ride the Fire-Breath...
Maui - Communities at Risk - Wildfire Protection Plans - Ride the Fire-Breath...
 

Dernier

Call now : 9892124323 Nalasopara Beautiful Call Girls Vasai virar Best Call G...
Call now : 9892124323 Nalasopara Beautiful Call Girls Vasai virar Best Call G...Call now : 9892124323 Nalasopara Beautiful Call Girls Vasai virar Best Call G...
Call now : 9892124323 Nalasopara Beautiful Call Girls Vasai virar Best Call G...Pooja Nehwal
 
operational plan ppt.pptx nursing management
operational plan ppt.pptx nursing managementoperational plan ppt.pptx nursing management
operational plan ppt.pptx nursing managementTulsiDhidhi1
 
CEO of Google, Sunder Pichai's biography
CEO of Google, Sunder Pichai's biographyCEO of Google, Sunder Pichai's biography
CEO of Google, Sunder Pichai's biographyHafizMuhammadAbdulla5
 
CALL ON ➥8923113531 🔝Call Girls Charbagh Lucknow best sexual service
CALL ON ➥8923113531 🔝Call Girls Charbagh Lucknow best sexual serviceCALL ON ➥8923113531 🔝Call Girls Charbagh Lucknow best sexual service
CALL ON ➥8923113531 🔝Call Girls Charbagh Lucknow best sexual serviceanilsa9823
 
GENUINE Babe,Call Girls IN Baderpur Delhi | +91-8377087607
GENUINE Babe,Call Girls IN Baderpur  Delhi | +91-8377087607GENUINE Babe,Call Girls IN Baderpur  Delhi | +91-8377087607
GENUINE Babe,Call Girls IN Baderpur Delhi | +91-8377087607dollysharma2066
 
{ 9892124323 }} Call Girls & Escorts in Hotel JW Marriott juhu, Mumbai
{ 9892124323 }} Call Girls & Escorts in Hotel JW Marriott juhu, Mumbai{ 9892124323 }} Call Girls & Escorts in Hotel JW Marriott juhu, Mumbai
{ 9892124323 }} Call Girls & Escorts in Hotel JW Marriott juhu, MumbaiPooja Nehwal
 
VIP Kolkata Call Girl Rajarhat 👉 8250192130 Available With Room
VIP Kolkata Call Girl Rajarhat 👉 8250192130  Available With RoomVIP Kolkata Call Girl Rajarhat 👉 8250192130  Available With Room
VIP Kolkata Call Girl Rajarhat 👉 8250192130 Available With Roomdivyansh0kumar0
 
VIP 7001035870 Find & Meet Hyderabad Call Girls Kondapur high-profile Call Girl
VIP 7001035870 Find & Meet Hyderabad Call Girls Kondapur high-profile Call GirlVIP 7001035870 Find & Meet Hyderabad Call Girls Kondapur high-profile Call Girl
VIP 7001035870 Find & Meet Hyderabad Call Girls Kondapur high-profile Call Girladitipandeya
 
Pooja Mehta 9167673311, Trusted Call Girls In NAVI MUMBAI Cash On Payment , V...
Pooja Mehta 9167673311, Trusted Call Girls In NAVI MUMBAI Cash On Payment , V...Pooja Mehta 9167673311, Trusted Call Girls In NAVI MUMBAI Cash On Payment , V...
Pooja Mehta 9167673311, Trusted Call Girls In NAVI MUMBAI Cash On Payment , V...Pooja Nehwal
 
Day 0- Bootcamp Roadmap for PLC Bootcamp
Day 0- Bootcamp Roadmap for PLC BootcampDay 0- Bootcamp Roadmap for PLC Bootcamp
Day 0- Bootcamp Roadmap for PLC BootcampPLCLeadershipDevelop
 

Dernier (20)

Call now : 9892124323 Nalasopara Beautiful Call Girls Vasai virar Best Call G...
Call now : 9892124323 Nalasopara Beautiful Call Girls Vasai virar Best Call G...Call now : 9892124323 Nalasopara Beautiful Call Girls Vasai virar Best Call G...
Call now : 9892124323 Nalasopara Beautiful Call Girls Vasai virar Best Call G...
 
operational plan ppt.pptx nursing management
operational plan ppt.pptx nursing managementoperational plan ppt.pptx nursing management
operational plan ppt.pptx nursing management
 
Call Girls Service Tilak Nagar @9999965857 Delhi 🫦 No Advance VVIP 🍎 SERVICE
Call Girls Service Tilak Nagar @9999965857 Delhi 🫦 No Advance  VVIP 🍎 SERVICECall Girls Service Tilak Nagar @9999965857 Delhi 🫦 No Advance  VVIP 🍎 SERVICE
Call Girls Service Tilak Nagar @9999965857 Delhi 🫦 No Advance VVIP 🍎 SERVICE
 
CEO of Google, Sunder Pichai's biography
CEO of Google, Sunder Pichai's biographyCEO of Google, Sunder Pichai's biography
CEO of Google, Sunder Pichai's biography
 
CALL ON ➥8923113531 🔝Call Girls Charbagh Lucknow best sexual service
CALL ON ➥8923113531 🔝Call Girls Charbagh Lucknow best sexual serviceCALL ON ➥8923113531 🔝Call Girls Charbagh Lucknow best sexual service
CALL ON ➥8923113531 🔝Call Girls Charbagh Lucknow best sexual service
 
LoveLocalGov - Chris Twigg, Inner Circle
LoveLocalGov - Chris Twigg, Inner CircleLoveLocalGov - Chris Twigg, Inner Circle
LoveLocalGov - Chris Twigg, Inner Circle
 
Unlocking the Future - Dr Max Blumberg, Founder of Blumberg Partnership
Unlocking the Future - Dr Max Blumberg, Founder of Blumberg PartnershipUnlocking the Future - Dr Max Blumberg, Founder of Blumberg Partnership
Unlocking the Future - Dr Max Blumberg, Founder of Blumberg Partnership
 
GENUINE Babe,Call Girls IN Baderpur Delhi | +91-8377087607
GENUINE Babe,Call Girls IN Baderpur  Delhi | +91-8377087607GENUINE Babe,Call Girls IN Baderpur  Delhi | +91-8377087607
GENUINE Babe,Call Girls IN Baderpur Delhi | +91-8377087607
 
{ 9892124323 }} Call Girls & Escorts in Hotel JW Marriott juhu, Mumbai
{ 9892124323 }} Call Girls & Escorts in Hotel JW Marriott juhu, Mumbai{ 9892124323 }} Call Girls & Escorts in Hotel JW Marriott juhu, Mumbai
{ 9892124323 }} Call Girls & Escorts in Hotel JW Marriott juhu, Mumbai
 
VIP Kolkata Call Girl Rajarhat 👉 8250192130 Available With Room
VIP Kolkata Call Girl Rajarhat 👉 8250192130  Available With RoomVIP Kolkata Call Girl Rajarhat 👉 8250192130  Available With Room
VIP Kolkata Call Girl Rajarhat 👉 8250192130 Available With Room
 
Rohini Sector 16 Call Girls Delhi 9999965857 @Sabina Saikh No Advance
Rohini Sector 16 Call Girls Delhi 9999965857 @Sabina Saikh No AdvanceRohini Sector 16 Call Girls Delhi 9999965857 @Sabina Saikh No Advance
Rohini Sector 16 Call Girls Delhi 9999965857 @Sabina Saikh No Advance
 
Imagine - Creating Healthy Workplaces - Anthony Montgomery.pdf
Imagine - Creating Healthy Workplaces - Anthony Montgomery.pdfImagine - Creating Healthy Workplaces - Anthony Montgomery.pdf
Imagine - Creating Healthy Workplaces - Anthony Montgomery.pdf
 
Imagine - HR; are handling the 'bad banter' - Stella Chandler.pdf
Imagine - HR; are handling the 'bad banter' - Stella Chandler.pdfImagine - HR; are handling the 'bad banter' - Stella Chandler.pdf
Imagine - HR; are handling the 'bad banter' - Stella Chandler.pdf
 
Discover -CQ Master Class - Rikita Wadhwa.pdf
Discover -CQ Master Class - Rikita Wadhwa.pdfDiscover -CQ Master Class - Rikita Wadhwa.pdf
Discover -CQ Master Class - Rikita Wadhwa.pdf
 
Leadership in Crisis - Helio Vogas, Risk & Leadership Keynote Speaker
Leadership in Crisis - Helio Vogas, Risk & Leadership Keynote SpeakerLeadership in Crisis - Helio Vogas, Risk & Leadership Keynote Speaker
Leadership in Crisis - Helio Vogas, Risk & Leadership Keynote Speaker
 
VIP 7001035870 Find & Meet Hyderabad Call Girls Kondapur high-profile Call Girl
VIP 7001035870 Find & Meet Hyderabad Call Girls Kondapur high-profile Call GirlVIP 7001035870 Find & Meet Hyderabad Call Girls Kondapur high-profile Call Girl
VIP 7001035870 Find & Meet Hyderabad Call Girls Kondapur high-profile Call Girl
 
Disrupt or be Disrupted - Kirk Vallis.pdf
Disrupt or be Disrupted - Kirk Vallis.pdfDisrupt or be Disrupted - Kirk Vallis.pdf
Disrupt or be Disrupted - Kirk Vallis.pdf
 
Pooja Mehta 9167673311, Trusted Call Girls In NAVI MUMBAI Cash On Payment , V...
Pooja Mehta 9167673311, Trusted Call Girls In NAVI MUMBAI Cash On Payment , V...Pooja Mehta 9167673311, Trusted Call Girls In NAVI MUMBAI Cash On Payment , V...
Pooja Mehta 9167673311, Trusted Call Girls In NAVI MUMBAI Cash On Payment , V...
 
Day 0- Bootcamp Roadmap for PLC Bootcamp
Day 0- Bootcamp Roadmap for PLC BootcampDay 0- Bootcamp Roadmap for PLC Bootcamp
Day 0- Bootcamp Roadmap for PLC Bootcamp
 
Peak Performance & Resilience - Dr Dorian Dugmore
Peak Performance & Resilience - Dr Dorian DugmorePeak Performance & Resilience - Dr Dorian Dugmore
Peak Performance & Resilience - Dr Dorian Dugmore
 

Hawaii - HART Rail Project - FTA - Welcome Aboard - Taking Charge - Breaking the Iron Rice Bowl - Moving Ahead

  • 1. WHAT NOW FOR HONOLULU'S RAIL PROJECT? By Ron Fisher and Jim Ryan, Honolulu Star Advertiser, September 12, 2021 <https://www.staradvertiser.com/2021/09/12/editorial/island-voices/what-now-for-honolulus-rail-project/> The Honolulu rail project has reached a point where completion of the project as originally planned no longer appears possible without another large infusion of local or state funding. Honolulu now faces a momentous decision on where to locate the terminus of a shorter rail project that may be in place for many years, possibly decades. The way that decision is reached will determine the confidence of local officials, and the trust of the public, that the modified project will be finished successfully. We evaluated dozens of major transit projects during our careers in the Federal Transit Administration's Office of Planning. Honolulu's rail project clearly met the evaluation criteria set by Congress and, consequently, received a Full Funding Grant Agreement in 2012. We personally supported that decision because the project would be a huge improvement in transit service for the tens of thousands of existing transit riders and others who might choose to use it. We continue to think that is true. The estimated $5.1 billion project cost was a concern because of Honolulu's relatively small population and tax base. But we believed the benefits of the project justified that expenditure and the city's financial plan indicated it was affordable. Escalating costs and schedule delays led the FTA to require a “recovery plan” for completion of the 20-mile project. The Honolulu Authority for Rapid Transportation (HART) prepared, and FTA accepted, a plan that in 2019 promised completion by 2026 at a total cost of $8.9 billion, with the additional funding coming from new local tax revenues. Now, barely two years later, HART anticipates completion in 2031 at a total cost of $12.4 billion but with a $3.5 billion funding shortfall — a stunning revelation that threatens any remaining public faith in a useful project outcome. Another “recovery plan” is clearly inappropriate for the decision at hand. The question is no longer, “How will we finish the 20-mile project?” but rather, “What shorter project makes most sense for our foreseeable future?” [Emphasis Supplied] The answer to this new question requires, first, a careful and objective analysis of where the project actually stands in terms of expenditures to date, and then, a realistic assessment of the costs and benefits of alternative locations for a new project terminus short of Ala Moana Center.
  • 2. Candidate locations would likely include several of the currently planned stations. The analysis would have to address the design of a terminal station that could accommodate potentially heavy volumes of arriving rail passengers; changes to the bus system needed to move rail passengers from the terminal; impacts on street traffic near the terminal; impacts on transit travel times and transferring; the number of potential riders who would opt out of travel by rail; and the trade-offs among the costs, impacts, and benefits of the options. While HART would be an essential PARTICIPANT, THE EFFORT REQUIRES EXPERTISE THAT IS DIFFERENT FROM HART'S CONSTRUCTION-ORIENTED MISSION. THE WORK SHOULD BE DONE BY AN INDEPENDENT TEAM WITH OBJECTIVITY, THE NECESSARY TECHNICAL EXPERTISE, AND A COMMITMENT TO TRANSPARENCY. The team's [HART] only responsibility would be to provide solid information that the people of Oahu and their elected officials can trust as the basis for the hard decisions at hand, and not to advocate for a particular terminus location. The City Council or HAWAII LEGISLATURE would be the appropriate sponsor of the analysis, ideally with TECHNICAL ASSISTANCE FROM FTA. Having worked on the planning of this worthy project for many years, we want it to succeed. Decisions should not be rushed, and the necessary analysis will take some time. It is critical to get started — soon. [Emphasis and Clarification Supplied] __________________________________________________ The “iron rice bowl” is a Chinese idiom which referred to the now abolished system of guaranteed lifetime employment __________________________________________________ I hope people find hope in my life story and know to never give up. People are stronger than I hope people find hope in my life story and know to never give up. People are stronger than they think they are. I've never seen the world stop like this. People are tired and asking when they think they are. I've never seen the world stop like this. People are tired and asking when this is going to stop. They must believe that anything is possible in this life and that things will this is going to stop. They must believe that anything is possible in this life and that things will get better. I'm living proof of that. get better. I'm living proof of that. JIM MORRIS – “ THE ROOKIE” JIM MORRIS – “ THE ROOKIE” The Guardian, Johnathan Drennan, August 30, 2020 <https://www.theguardian.com/sport/behind-the-lines/2020/aug/03/jim-morris-anything-is-possible-life-major-league-baseball>