1. Case 1:11-cv-20120-PAS Document 72 Entered on FLSD Docket 11/29/2011 Page 1 of 5
* *+ '
I THE UN I
N TED STATES DISTRI COURT FO R
CT
THE SOUTH ERN DISTRI O F FLORIDA
CT
CASE N O. 1I-
: ZOIZO- V- T;/ M ON TON
CI SEI ISI
FI ED b
L D. .
C
. v 'e j
hg$ 1 i Loj
. ? .'
!
j 0
TRAI BUJ
AN DUV EAN U,
Pl ntf,
ai if STEV EN M .L R1q RE
A rO
v
'
C L RK UJS. l T CT,
E DS ,
S.D.7 F A -MIp; .
bf L Av'
1
VS.
D I A S CHARI ES,l C.AN A GI
SM TI N , SPER TI
DEREK THOM AS and LASHANDA ADAM S
Def endant.
s
M O TION FO R SUM M ARY JI DG EM ENT
J
COM E NOW Pli ifTr inBu du a u, o Se he en fe M o n , n
antf aa j ve n P1 , r ia tr va t a d
rs cflymo st sCou tfrs
epetul ve hi r o ummayj gme i ti a to ona1 li i
r ud nln hs cin, 1cams n
t Com pl ntplr uantt Fed.R.Ci P.56,l s
he ai zs o v. n uppor oft sm oton,M ova r i
t hi i nt eles
upon t accompanyi M emor
he ng andum ofPoi sa Aut iy,t St em entof
nt nd hort he at
Un s tdMaeilFa t a t De lrtonofTrinBudu a
dipue tra cs nd he caai aa j ve nu.
EVIDENCE
Pl ntf r y upon t f l ng e dence:
ai if el he olowi vi
1. Thei ce aton oft M ovantatFDC M i if 75 days.
ncar r i he am or
2. Doc ent sgned by t Def nda sLashondaAdam sand Der Thomas,s ntt
um s i he e nt ek e o
t CCM /BOP,i w hi t ac
he n ch hey knowl d t m edi condii oft M ovant
edge he cal tons he .
(
EXHI T A)
BI
3. Adm i i ofDef nda st copi oft M ovan Drvi Recor fom t Cl k
sson e nt hat es he t i ng d r he er
OfThe Courtand f om DM V i Talahas ee,Fl i Copy ofvald St e ofFl i
r n l s orda, i at orda
Drver Li e,Copi of t vehi e i ur
i cens es he cl ns ance fom Alsat l ur
r l t e ns ance Company,
weea Dima h e i t M ov ntsr c r 5l,f rs metme (
r t s s ous , n he a ' e o d e o o i . EXHI T B)
BI
4. St em ent ofFDC M i iCot s orPrce and Fl M i iUni M anager
at s am m el i 7C am t
Har ion,maki i cl rt an i tgaton orcha gesagai tt M ova ne
rs ng t ea hat nvesi i r ns he nt ver
exit and t i cer i was il .
sed he ncar aton legal

2. Case 1:11-cv-20120-PAS Document 72 Entered on FLSD Docket 11/29/2011 Page 2 of 5
>
5. St t
a ementofCCM Diect CarosRodrguez, a ng i cl t an i tgaton
r or l i m ki t ear hat nvesi i
by Feder Bur ofPrsonsorUS M ar hal neve exit si no l c ges
al eau i s s r sed nce egal har
agai tt M ovanteverexit
ns he sed.
6. St e ent ofUSPO St
at m s even Aas e d t USPO wasnotadvi oft
t nz hat sed he
i cer i wihi 48 hour asr quies and t f t t f
ncar aton t n s e r , he act hat hey ound outaboutt
he
M ova i rc aton i Januar 201l when t haver ve fom t M ovanta
nt nca er i n y , hey ecei d r he
copy oft M oton f t Retzn ofPr rt
he i or he tr ope y.
7. l erogat y r pons oft Def
nt r or es e he endant ,adm itng t abs
s ti he enceofs urveil
lance
camer da a,fom t har drveoft comput ,ani porantpi ofevi
as t r he d i he er m t ece dence f
or
teil a s a c a d s iur c du tdby teDe e n s (
h leg l e r h n ez e on ce h fnda t. EXHI T C)
BI
8. Ans e sofDef ndat and pr
w r e s oducton ofDoc e sshowi cl t t
i um nt ng ear hat he
M ova wasde ed a
nt ni ccesst r i ouss vieson Sa
o elgi er c ndays whie he wasar dent
, l esi
ofDima ho e a ltrwh l onHomeConfne nt (
s s us , nd ae ie i me . EXHI T D)
BI
9.Ref aloft Def
us he endant t pr
s o oducea1 docum e sand ans al wrte
l nt wer l itn
i er ogat i whie i si t tt havecompled w ih a1 r esofD icover
nt r ores, l nsitng ha hey i t 1 ul s y.
1 M ovantsover400 pagesofm e calr dsfom Fede alBur O fprs
0. ' di ecor r r eau ion
M e calSt f Recor fom M emoralHos t ,Br a d Hos t land varous
di af , ds r i pial ow r pia i
physci s
i ans hown t medi condii oft M oNa .
he cal tons he nt
11 Admi son ofDef
. si endantDer Thom assatng t the knew t M ovantwas
ek t i hat t he
sc bu heddnot w ho sc h wa . (
ik, t i kno w ik e s' EXHI T E)
' BI
1 Doc ent sgned by Lashonda Adamsand Der Thom as Sentt t CCM /
2. um s i ek , o he
BOP requesi t tt M ovantbepl
tng ha he aced i Hom e Confnementdue t hi s al
n i o s ever
c o cme c l ndtons (
hr ni dia co ii . EXHI T F)
BI
l Dico r rla e d u ntsowi Dee cssbe tngt Mo n t wok,
3. s vey ee sd oc me h ng fnda t u jci he va to r
t t a vacuum and cl t foor.
o ake ean he l
14. Copi oft ee i dentr t wrten on t ef m s,f t s e i dent
es hr nci epors, it her or or he am nci
t ttokha oc ure i t s med ya i tes mepa . EXHI T G)
ha o s c rd n he a a nd n h a lce ( BI
l5.Copy ofone çl om e M ade l dentRepor ,bea ng t nam e ofFeder Bur au
tl nci f' ri he al e
OfPrs , dea sgne b De e Th .(
ions ma nd i d y rk omas EXHI T H)
BI
16.Copy oft Condii ofHome Contnem ent s
he tons i s howi t ti doesnotmenton
ng ha t i
a yt n a ac lulrt e one (
n hig bout el a elph . EXHI T 1
BI )
17.True i iy oft Def ndant obt ned on l1 012011.No ot r
dentt he e s ai / / her equesed
t
i o main rgadi t De e da swa e rr la e (
nf r to e r ng he f n nt s ve ee s d. EXHI T J
BI )

3. Case 1:11-cv-20120-PAS Document 72 Entered on FLSD Docket 11/29/2011 Page 3 of 5
1 Dic r d u n sowi t Dee da t s jci t Mova t wok
8. sovey oc me t h ng he fn ns ube tng he nto r
whe t ykne t thi me c l ondii .(
n he w ha s dia c tons EXHI T K)
BI
Dat N ovember22,2011
ed: Res f l s nit
pectuly ubr ted,
.AX /
- 1 1
h r N y /lz
z e hk
a
TRAI BUJ
AN DUV N U,Pr Se
o

4. Case 1:11-cv-20120-PAS Document 72 Entered on FLSD Docket 11/29/2011 Page 4 of 5

5. *
Case 1:11-cv-20120-PAS Document 72 Entered on FLSD Docket 11/29/2011 Page 5 of 5
u*
(
. ss
*k
. t
o '
C*
t *
n t7
c:
o
Qu -
k
*2
tt
2o
)
O
q 4
j . ..
' .
(
. 1
-
. tA# ;'
œv .
.! b
. .
- +
. .
#. v
'
k.; yp'.
.. #.
, p'
. sb
é3
,,
..
#
. .-
y.
%'
.T
y
'
.
q r'
k ,'
#.
:
2
k V
t =
#
/ o
*.
# -%
>
z
.
e
h 4
-
Nk Nu .e
.
% A o
-
, 4
< o
. '..
!
.
b: . -k, .
>
' -
- m
-
-
m
V -AN
Ah - . h<
K -
' - m -
s. X
O
* >
.
m &
M* . -
w .j -
.Jp-
.j
t.
) -
. &
a
. y'
-
- &
. ..
Z. @
.. q - &
.
e O
.
. .
! -
'
amN- -
R> .- - - - .
w -
* -
#
N
-
K
)
f
1
1
f
>
> m
Q =
> =
œ N X
> $=
ï =m
o e
x m
m $'.
w
9
' - x
; c
-
=* Z
> m m