3. Broad review of basins
• Development context
– Overall situation
• Water availability / use
• Water productivity
• Intervention and impact analysis
– Intervention: what ‘they can do’
– Impact: what ‘you’ can do
• Knowledge management
– Not much to show at this stage
5. • The poorest tend to rely on agriculture
Agriculture vs GNI
50,000
Gross National Income ($/capita)
40,000
30,000
20,000 Size of bubble
proportional to rural
10,000 population
0
-10 0 10 20 30 40 50
-10,000
Agricultural contribution to GDP (% )
World Bank, 2007
6. Agriculture agriculture to GDP
% Contribution of contribution to growth (%) Essential to understand relative function of agriculture
volta
Mekong
Sao Karkheh
Francisco
World Bank, 2007
% Rural poor
8. Multiple water use reflects hydrology
Suppy limit
Capacity limit
1.0
Ganges
ET / ETot
p
Sao Francisco
0.5 Mekong
Volta
Nile
Limpopo
Yellow River
Karkeh Indus
0.0 Andean
0.00 0.50 1.00 1.50 2.00
Rain / ETpot
9. Ganges
1,167 bcm
Water use supports varied livelihoods
M eko ng
1,19 5 b cm
Sa o Fr a nc i s c o
622 bcm
Nile
2,042 bcm
Suppy limit
Capacity limit
1.0
Net runoff
Indus
865 bcm
Ganges
ET / ETot
p
Sao Francisco
Grassland ET
Fish
0.5 Mekong
Rainfed crops Lim popo
229 bcm Volta
Crops
Nile
Irrigation ET Limpopo
Yellow River
Livestock
Karkeh Indus
Yellow
384 bcm
Irrigation
0.0 Andean
0.00 0.50 1.00 1.50 2.00
K ar kheh
2 1, 4 0 2 mcm
Rain / ETpot
11. Rainfed ag. by far the
biggest user 0.35
Rainfall
Evaporation or Rainfall (m)
0.30 ETo
0.25
0.20
0.15
0.10
0.05
0.00
Jan Feb M Apr M Jun Jul Aug Sep O N Dec
ar ay ct ov
45000
Calculated
40000
Observed
35000
30000
Flow,
25000
20000
15000
10000
0.35
Rainfall
5000
Evaporation or Rainfall (m)
0.30 ETo
0.25
0 0.20
1951 1956 1961 1966 1971 1976 1981 1986 1991 1996 0.15
0.10
0.05
0.00
Jan Feb M Apr M Jun Jul Aug Sep O N Dec
ar ay ct ov
Nile 0.35
Rainfall
Evaporation or Rainfall (m)
0.30 ETo
0.25
0.20
0.15
0.10
0.05
0.00
From Kirby et al., W-Use Jan Feb M Apr M Jun Jul Aug Sep O N Dec
ar ay ct ov
20. Basic concept: Need Water productivity to
respond faster than demand
Demand
response line
WP
crisis
time
21. In some places, water productivity is responding to demand
0.800
3
VN, Mekong Delta
Rice Water productivity, kg/m
0.600
Vietnam
VN Central
Highlands
0.400
Laos
0.200 Cambodia
NE Thailand
0.000
1990 1995 2000 2005
Year
Mac Kirby, 2007
27. Water availability seems less influential than
gain per volume used (water productivity)
Per capita income vs.
GNI vs Water
water availability
50,000
40,000
GNI ($/cap PPP)
30,000
20,000
10,000
0
-500 0 500 1000 1500 2000 2500
-10,000
Size of bubble proportional to agriculture contribution to GDP
3
Water availability (m /cap)
World Bank, 2007
28. São Francisco: Drought is one poverty factor…of many
Drought
Poor
education
Access to
credit
Marcello Torres
et al., 2008
29. Karkheh, Iran: Farmers not the poorest
politics controls
0.40
0.35
0.30
0.25
0.20
0.15
0.10
0.05
0.00
KB
ed
r
er
k
er
r
ry
n
ke
ke
er
so
nt
ag
rm
oy
or
Cl
r
ou
wo
er
an
Fa
pl
w
ep
C
m
M
d
n
e
lle
ad
io
Un
ct
ki
Tr
du
ns
o
U
Pr
Poverty lines from household Karkheh BFP team
income and expenditure data
30. .. Mekong
What people do can affect (shared) assets
Dam development
Changing land use,
shifting cultivation,
sustainability,
sedimentation
Seasonal water
shortage, poor soils,
low rice productivity
Fish &
environmental
impacts of upstream Salinisation, water
quality, highly
developed
Complex but understandable
Eric Kemp-Benedict, 2008
Syngenta Science Day 2009
32. Global -to local
GLOBAL
water and food systems considered separately
both impact on livelihoods
Basin scale
Systems interact through
(Unspecified) transfers
Local Scale
Local systems considered individually
Local impact not referenced to broader systems
33. Opportunities or pressures vary from basin to basin
Remember development
trajectory
Niger
Markets
Climate change
Population growth
Need for ecosystem
services
34. Impact pathway and
Knowledge management
• All impact pathways done
– All honest efforts
• Pathway depends on basin scale,
organization, existing network makers,
etc..
• Getting better engagement with CPWF
– Some more work needed with Topics