SlideShare une entreprise Scribd logo
1  sur  4
Role of L1 in the English classroom
                                Dannae Del Campo Méndez

 Language acquisition and how people learn a language are discussions directly

related to education. That is why some authors have guided their attention to the

first and second language learning, the language acquisition and the importance

of L1 in the learning process of L2. Authors as Cook refer to the child differences

in the learning process of L1 and L2 dividing them in eight main ideas in which we

can find factors such as: the children’s behavior, emotional life, needs and

interests, mental capacity, and others… with these factors in mind Cook (2011)

specifies that the environment in the classroom “is likely to be freer, more

spontaneous, with less direction by the teacher and less control of the language”

(para.37). To complement Kook’s words is Krashen, he focuses on the topic of

“first language interference” and how this may affect the learning of an L2. His

researches demonstrate three cases in which the role of the mother tongue

makes interference in the second language performance. Krashen (1981) pointed

out that the mother tongue “appears to be strongest in complex word order and

in word-for-word translations of phrases”, “first language influence is weaker in

bound morphology”, and also that “first language influence seems to be strongest

in acquisition poor environments”. Newmark’s work (1997) suggests that the cure

for this interference of L1 is simply the cure for ignorance, this means, learning.

To develop the topic of “first language acquisition” from different points of views

is Freeman. He explains insights from sociology, linguistics and psychology.

Moreover he describes two views or methods about language development in the

areas of reading and writing, one view is that language is learn and the other one

is that language is acquired.
As a personal opinion after reading these different texts I can say how important

is for future teachers to acquire this knowledge. The authors focused on different

features yet all of them demonstrated with facts, researches, studies, etc… how

important is the acquisition of a language and at the same time how this affects in

the process of learning a second language, as English is for us. In Cooks’s words

(2011) and refering directly to language teachers with a wise reasoning , is that

he insists that teachers might consider children’s needs in the classroom rather

than in their foreseeable future, in this way their motivation is more powerful and

it will be easier to catch their attention. Moreover Cook (2011) kept maintaining

my interest and at the same time changing my perspective of the development of

a class with certain important points which I totally ignore before reading this

text. One of these points is the fact that L2 can have more ability to learn syntax,

because it has the example of L1 structure, but at the same time we can learn

from krashen’s words (1981) that L1 can make interferences on L2, so it made

think how thin is the line between how helpful can L1 be and how it can guide

students to commit mistakes. On the other hand, we have Freeman (2004) who

explained different insights which, personally, I did not thought about before,

students always tend to think about the linguistic insight although the sociologic

vision it is also important. Freeman (2004) notes “the best support that adults can

give to children is to encourage them to initiate conversation and make it easy

and enjoyable” (para.32), in this way they can modify the things they say which

are incorrect with adults’ help. Moreover Freeman (2004) also explain how

affective factors can make adults hesitate at the moment of learn a new language,

we are going to work with teenagers who are forming their selves to become

adults, so it’s our responsibility to find the way of making them realize that there

is no point in hesitation but to demonstrate them and give them the confidence
to start talking and learning English. Finally, and as a conclusion, as a future

teacher is important and it’s my responsibility to commit myself with what I just

studied and put everything in practice in an appropriate way so that I can teach

efficiently.
References

- Cook, V. (2011). Second Language Learning and Language Teaching (3rd ed.)

- Krashen, S. (1981). Second Language Acquisition and Second Language Learning. University of

Southern California.

- Freeman, D. & Freeman, Y. (2004). Essential Linguistics What you need to know to teach
reading, ESL, Spelling, Phonics, Grammar. Heinemann.

Contenu connexe

Tendances

Reaction paper - "L1 and L2 language learning"
Reaction paper - "L1 and L2 language learning"Reaction paper - "L1 and L2 language learning"
Reaction paper - "L1 and L2 language learning"Gerardo Zavalla
 
Reaction paper: "The relationship between First and Second Language Learning ...
Reaction paper: "The relationship between First and Second Language Learning ...Reaction paper: "The relationship between First and Second Language Learning ...
Reaction paper: "The relationship between First and Second Language Learning ...marialagoslagos
 
The Reading Approach - Leo Bryan Lisboa
The Reading Approach - Leo Bryan LisboaThe Reading Approach - Leo Bryan Lisboa
The Reading Approach - Leo Bryan LisboaLeoLisboa13
 
Psychological Approaches to Language and Learning Stern 1983
Psychological Approaches to Language and Learning Stern 1983Psychological Approaches to Language and Learning Stern 1983
Psychological Approaches to Language and Learning Stern 1983Rizky Amelia
 
Reaction Paper II
Reaction Paper IIReaction Paper II
Reaction Paper IICamila__
 
How language is learned
How language is learnedHow language is learned
How language is learnedJulie Ciancio
 
Mother tongue interference
Mother tongue interferenceMother tongue interference
Mother tongue interferenceBLESSINGDARAMOLA
 
Peer response in the writing process tesol greece, 2013
Peer response in the writing process   tesol greece, 2013Peer response in the writing process   tesol greece, 2013
Peer response in the writing process tesol greece, 2013Davidbradshaw
 
Socio arwa
Socio arwaSocio arwa
Socio arwaArwa4423
 
Power point language learning
Power point language learningPower point language learning
Power point language learningffffunes
 
Social Contexts of SLA, Sok Soth, RUPP, IFL
Social Contexts of SLA, Sok Soth, RUPP, IFLSocial Contexts of SLA, Sok Soth, RUPP, IFL
Social Contexts of SLA, Sok Soth, RUPP, IFLSoth Sok
 
Microsocial factors
Microsocial factorsMicrosocial factors
Microsocial factorsJess Sarabia
 

Tendances (20)

Reaction paper - "L1 and L2 language learning"
Reaction paper - "L1 and L2 language learning"Reaction paper - "L1 and L2 language learning"
Reaction paper - "L1 and L2 language learning"
 
Reaction paper: "The relationship between First and Second Language Learning ...
Reaction paper: "The relationship between First and Second Language Learning ...Reaction paper: "The relationship between First and Second Language Learning ...
Reaction paper: "The relationship between First and Second Language Learning ...
 
The Reading Approach - Leo Bryan Lisboa
The Reading Approach - Leo Bryan LisboaThe Reading Approach - Leo Bryan Lisboa
The Reading Approach - Leo Bryan Lisboa
 
Psychological Approaches to Language and Learning Stern 1983
Psychological Approaches to Language and Learning Stern 1983Psychological Approaches to Language and Learning Stern 1983
Psychological Approaches to Language and Learning Stern 1983
 
Reaction Paper II
Reaction Paper IIReaction Paper II
Reaction Paper II
 
Reaction paper
Reaction paperReaction paper
Reaction paper
 
Reaction paper
Reaction paperReaction paper
Reaction paper
 
Reaction paper
Reaction paperReaction paper
Reaction paper
 
L2 learning and teaching
L2 learning and teachingL2 learning and teaching
L2 learning and teaching
 
How language is learned
How language is learnedHow language is learned
How language is learned
 
Mother tongue interference
Mother tongue interferenceMother tongue interference
Mother tongue interference
 
Peer response in the writing process tesol greece, 2013
Peer response in the writing process   tesol greece, 2013Peer response in the writing process   tesol greece, 2013
Peer response in the writing process tesol greece, 2013
 
Socio arwa
Socio arwaSocio arwa
Socio arwa
 
Reaction paper
Reaction paperReaction paper
Reaction paper
 
Livemocha Vs[1][1][1]
Livemocha Vs[1][1][1]Livemocha Vs[1][1][1]
Livemocha Vs[1][1][1]
 
Reaction paper
Reaction paperReaction paper
Reaction paper
 
Power point language learning
Power point language learningPower point language learning
Power point language learning
 
Social Contexts of SLA, Sok Soth, RUPP, IFL
Social Contexts of SLA, Sok Soth, RUPP, IFLSocial Contexts of SLA, Sok Soth, RUPP, IFL
Social Contexts of SLA, Sok Soth, RUPP, IFL
 
Reaction Paper
Reaction PaperReaction Paper
Reaction Paper
 
Microsocial factors
Microsocial factorsMicrosocial factors
Microsocial factors
 

En vedette

GenderNeutralPronounMadLibs
GenderNeutralPronounMadLibsGenderNeutralPronounMadLibs
GenderNeutralPronounMadLibsJules Purnell
 
Paula andrea hoyos álvarez
Paula andrea hoyos álvarezPaula andrea hoyos álvarez
Paula andrea hoyos álvarezpaulaandreakathe
 
Scene measurement
Scene measurementScene measurement
Scene measurementmbsorensen2
 
Introducción a los virus informáticos y tipos de virus - Grupo 4
Introducción a los virus informáticos y tipos de virus - Grupo 4Introducción a los virus informáticos y tipos de virus - Grupo 4
Introducción a los virus informáticos y tipos de virus - Grupo 4odalisloor
 
Plan de clase (graficos en excel)
Plan de clase (graficos en excel)Plan de clase (graficos en excel)
Plan de clase (graficos en excel)Luna Sanabria
 

En vedette (12)

Us5678342
Us5678342Us5678342
Us5678342
 
GenderNeutralPronounMadLibs
GenderNeutralPronounMadLibsGenderNeutralPronounMadLibs
GenderNeutralPronounMadLibs
 
Twitter
TwitterTwitter
Twitter
 
PPM RA lead troubleshooting
PPM RA lead troubleshootingPPM RA lead troubleshooting
PPM RA lead troubleshooting
 
MOE Módulo5 Excel 2010 Examen_final
MOE Módulo5 Excel 2010 Examen_finalMOE Módulo5 Excel 2010 Examen_final
MOE Módulo5 Excel 2010 Examen_final
 
Paula andrea hoyos álvarez
Paula andrea hoyos álvarezPaula andrea hoyos álvarez
Paula andrea hoyos álvarez
 
Scene measurement
Scene measurementScene measurement
Scene measurement
 
Noormuhammed
NoormuhammedNoormuhammed
Noormuhammed
 
Slide DEF
Slide DEFSlide DEF
Slide DEF
 
Introducción a los virus informáticos y tipos de virus - Grupo 4
Introducción a los virus informáticos y tipos de virus - Grupo 4Introducción a los virus informáticos y tipos de virus - Grupo 4
Introducción a los virus informáticos y tipos de virus - Grupo 4
 
Plan de clase (graficos en excel)
Plan de clase (graficos en excel)Plan de clase (graficos en excel)
Plan de clase (graficos en excel)
 
Adtran WLan
Adtran WLanAdtran WLan
Adtran WLan
 

Similaire à Rp didactics

Reaction paper - L1 and L2
Reaction paper - L1 and L2Reaction paper - L1 and L2
Reaction paper - L1 and L2Gerardo Zavalla
 
Second language acquisition and english language teaching
Second language acquisition and english language teachingSecond language acquisition and english language teaching
Second language acquisition and english language teachingOsnovna šola Pivka
 
Reaction Paper
Reaction PaperReaction Paper
Reaction Papertowersgary
 
Role of L1 in the English Classroom
Role of L1 in the English ClassroomRole of L1 in the English Classroom
Role of L1 in the English Classroomcamimf
 
The role of L1 on second language acquisition
The role of L1 on second language acquisitionThe role of L1 on second language acquisition
The role of L1 on second language acquisitionRonglin Yao
 
Cognitive interactionist approaches to l2 instruction
Cognitive interactionist approaches to l2 instruction Cognitive interactionist approaches to l2 instruction
Cognitive interactionist approaches to l2 instruction Seyed Mojtaba Jafari Naseri
 
SLA ,Learning Theories , Second language Aquisition
SLA ,Learning Theories , Second language AquisitionSLA ,Learning Theories , Second language Aquisition
SLA ,Learning Theories , Second language Aquisitionmoji azimi
 
First Language acquisition
First Language acquisition First Language acquisition
First Language acquisition LeahSapelino
 
9300AWEEK 1 What is language Our relationship with language. T.docx
9300AWEEK 1 What is language Our relationship with language. T.docx9300AWEEK 1 What is language Our relationship with language. T.docx
9300AWEEK 1 What is language Our relationship with language. T.docxblondellchancy
 

Similaire à Rp didactics (20)

Reaction paper final
Reaction paper finalReaction paper final
Reaction paper final
 
Rpk
RpkRpk
Rpk
 
Reaction paper - L1 and L2
Reaction paper - L1 and L2Reaction paper - L1 and L2
Reaction paper - L1 and L2
 
Second language acquisition and english language teaching
Second language acquisition and english language teachingSecond language acquisition and english language teaching
Second language acquisition and english language teaching
 
Reaction paper
Reaction paperReaction paper
Reaction paper
 
Reaction Paper
Reaction PaperReaction Paper
Reaction Paper
 
Second Language Acquisition - David Nuan
Second Language Acquisition - David NuanSecond Language Acquisition - David Nuan
Second Language Acquisition - David Nuan
 
Role of L1 in the English Classroom
Role of L1 in the English ClassroomRole of L1 in the English Classroom
Role of L1 in the English Classroom
 
The role of L1 on second language acquisition
The role of L1 on second language acquisitionThe role of L1 on second language acquisition
The role of L1 on second language acquisition
 
From Theory to Practice for Teachers of English Learners.docx
From Theory to Practice for Teachers of English Learners.docxFrom Theory to Practice for Teachers of English Learners.docx
From Theory to Practice for Teachers of English Learners.docx
 
cross.linguitics.on website
cross.linguitics.on websitecross.linguitics.on website
cross.linguitics.on website
 
Cognitive interactionist approaches to l2 instruction
Cognitive interactionist approaches to l2 instruction Cognitive interactionist approaches to l2 instruction
Cognitive interactionist approaches to l2 instruction
 
Theories of language learning.ppt
Theories of language learning.pptTheories of language learning.ppt
Theories of language learning.ppt
 
SLA ,Learning Theories , Second language Aquisition
SLA ,Learning Theories , Second language AquisitionSLA ,Learning Theories , Second language Aquisition
SLA ,Learning Theories , Second language Aquisition
 
First Language acquisition
First Language acquisition First Language acquisition
First Language acquisition
 
Lesson-1-ENG106.ppt.pptx
Lesson-1-ENG106.ppt.pptxLesson-1-ENG106.ppt.pptx
Lesson-1-ENG106.ppt.pptx
 
Place of Motivation in English Language Teaching
 Place of Motivation in English Language Teaching Place of Motivation in English Language Teaching
Place of Motivation in English Language Teaching
 
Reaction paper
Reaction paperReaction paper
Reaction paper
 
9300AWEEK 1 What is language Our relationship with language. T.docx
9300AWEEK 1 What is language Our relationship with language. T.docx9300AWEEK 1 What is language Our relationship with language. T.docx
9300AWEEK 1 What is language Our relationship with language. T.docx
 
Tema 2
Tema 2 Tema 2
Tema 2
 

Plus de dannaet

Final reflection
Final reflectionFinal reflection
Final reflectiondannaet
 
Reflection on my role and expectations of the professional practicum experience
Reflection on my role and expectations of the professional practicum experienceReflection on my role and expectations of the professional practicum experience
Reflection on my role and expectations of the professional practicum experiencedannaet
 
Estandar 4 dannae del campo
Estandar 4 dannae del campoEstandar 4 dannae del campo
Estandar 4 dannae del campodannaet
 
Dannae unit plan and individual lessons
Dannae unit plan and individual lessonsDannae unit plan and individual lessons
Dannae unit plan and individual lessonsdannaet
 
Standards 2 and 3
Standards  2 and 3Standards  2 and 3
Standards 2 and 3dannaet
 
Standard I
Standard IStandard I
Standard Idannaet
 
Estándar 6
Estándar 6Estándar 6
Estándar 6dannaet
 
Estándar 5
Estándar 5Estándar 5
Estándar 5dannaet
 
Estandar 4
Estandar 4Estandar 4
Estandar 4dannaet
 
Speaking task reflection
Speaking task reflectionSpeaking task reflection
Speaking task reflectiondannaet
 
Rubrics reflection
Rubrics reflectionRubrics reflection
Rubrics reflectiondannaet
 
Theoretical framework reflection
Theoretical framework reflectionTheoretical framework reflection
Theoretical framework reflectiondannaet
 

Plus de dannaet (20)

Tres.2
Tres.2Tres.2
Tres.2
 
Tres.1
Tres.1Tres.1
Tres.1
 
Uno.2
Uno.2Uno.2
Uno.2
 
Uno.1
Uno.1Uno.1
Uno.1
 
Final reflection
Final reflectionFinal reflection
Final reflection
 
Reflection on my role and expectations of the professional practicum experience
Reflection on my role and expectations of the professional practicum experienceReflection on my role and expectations of the professional practicum experience
Reflection on my role and expectations of the professional practicum experience
 
Estandar 4 dannae del campo
Estandar 4 dannae del campoEstandar 4 dannae del campo
Estandar 4 dannae del campo
 
Dannae unit plan and individual lessons
Dannae unit plan and individual lessonsDannae unit plan and individual lessons
Dannae unit plan and individual lessons
 
Standards 2 and 3
Standards  2 and 3Standards  2 and 3
Standards 2 and 3
 
Standard I
Standard IStandard I
Standard I
 
Estándar 6
Estándar 6Estándar 6
Estándar 6
 
Estándar 5
Estándar 5Estándar 5
Estándar 5
 
Estandar 4
Estandar 4Estandar 4
Estandar 4
 
MDD3
MDD3MDD3
MDD3
 
MDD2
MDD2MDD2
MDD2
 
MDD1
MDD1MDD1
MDD1
 
Ict
IctIct
Ict
 
Speaking task reflection
Speaking task reflectionSpeaking task reflection
Speaking task reflection
 
Rubrics reflection
Rubrics reflectionRubrics reflection
Rubrics reflection
 
Theoretical framework reflection
Theoretical framework reflectionTheoretical framework reflection
Theoretical framework reflection
 

Rp didactics

  • 1. Role of L1 in the English classroom Dannae Del Campo Méndez Language acquisition and how people learn a language are discussions directly related to education. That is why some authors have guided their attention to the first and second language learning, the language acquisition and the importance of L1 in the learning process of L2. Authors as Cook refer to the child differences in the learning process of L1 and L2 dividing them in eight main ideas in which we can find factors such as: the children’s behavior, emotional life, needs and interests, mental capacity, and others… with these factors in mind Cook (2011) specifies that the environment in the classroom “is likely to be freer, more spontaneous, with less direction by the teacher and less control of the language” (para.37). To complement Kook’s words is Krashen, he focuses on the topic of “first language interference” and how this may affect the learning of an L2. His researches demonstrate three cases in which the role of the mother tongue makes interference in the second language performance. Krashen (1981) pointed out that the mother tongue “appears to be strongest in complex word order and in word-for-word translations of phrases”, “first language influence is weaker in bound morphology”, and also that “first language influence seems to be strongest in acquisition poor environments”. Newmark’s work (1997) suggests that the cure for this interference of L1 is simply the cure for ignorance, this means, learning. To develop the topic of “first language acquisition” from different points of views is Freeman. He explains insights from sociology, linguistics and psychology. Moreover he describes two views or methods about language development in the areas of reading and writing, one view is that language is learn and the other one is that language is acquired.
  • 2. As a personal opinion after reading these different texts I can say how important is for future teachers to acquire this knowledge. The authors focused on different features yet all of them demonstrated with facts, researches, studies, etc… how important is the acquisition of a language and at the same time how this affects in the process of learning a second language, as English is for us. In Cooks’s words (2011) and refering directly to language teachers with a wise reasoning , is that he insists that teachers might consider children’s needs in the classroom rather than in their foreseeable future, in this way their motivation is more powerful and it will be easier to catch their attention. Moreover Cook (2011) kept maintaining my interest and at the same time changing my perspective of the development of a class with certain important points which I totally ignore before reading this text. One of these points is the fact that L2 can have more ability to learn syntax, because it has the example of L1 structure, but at the same time we can learn from krashen’s words (1981) that L1 can make interferences on L2, so it made think how thin is the line between how helpful can L1 be and how it can guide students to commit mistakes. On the other hand, we have Freeman (2004) who explained different insights which, personally, I did not thought about before, students always tend to think about the linguistic insight although the sociologic vision it is also important. Freeman (2004) notes “the best support that adults can give to children is to encourage them to initiate conversation and make it easy and enjoyable” (para.32), in this way they can modify the things they say which are incorrect with adults’ help. Moreover Freeman (2004) also explain how affective factors can make adults hesitate at the moment of learn a new language, we are going to work with teenagers who are forming their selves to become adults, so it’s our responsibility to find the way of making them realize that there is no point in hesitation but to demonstrate them and give them the confidence
  • 3. to start talking and learning English. Finally, and as a conclusion, as a future teacher is important and it’s my responsibility to commit myself with what I just studied and put everything in practice in an appropriate way so that I can teach efficiently.
  • 4. References - Cook, V. (2011). Second Language Learning and Language Teaching (3rd ed.) - Krashen, S. (1981). Second Language Acquisition and Second Language Learning. University of Southern California. - Freeman, D. & Freeman, Y. (2004). Essential Linguistics What you need to know to teach reading, ESL, Spelling, Phonics, Grammar. Heinemann.