SlideShare une entreprise Scribd logo
1  sur  21
Télécharger pour lire hors ligne
Apollo and Dionysus at Play
       Dan Dixon
       Digital Cultures Research Centre | Pervasive Media Studio
       University of the West of England




Thursday, 25 February 2010
• Where Caillois went wrong


       • Nietzsche, Dionysus and Apollo


       • New phenomenological approach


       • Conclusions




Thursday, 25 February 2010
Roger Caillois

Thursday, 25 February 2010
ludus



                             ilinx   mimicry           alea   agon




                                           paidia



Thursday, 25 February 2010
For it is only as an aesthetic phenomena that
       existence and the world are externally justified.
                           - Nietzsche - The Birth of Tragedy




Thursday, 25 February 2010
Nietzsche




Thursday, 25 February 2010
Apollo and Dionysus


Thursday, 25 February 2010
Dionysian		 	 	 	 	 	   Apollonian

       • physical              • cognitive
       • ecstatic              • individuating
       • chaotic               • understandable
       • intoxicated           • illusions
       • music                 • visual arts
       • dance                 • narrative




Thursday, 25 February 2010
play   games




Thursday, 25 February 2010
digital
                        play   games     gamic




Thursday, 25 February 2010
digital
                        play   games       st s
                                          o e     gamic
                                         m m
                                     nd ga
                                    a r
                                    ot he




Thursday, 25 February 2010
Dionysian		 	 	 	 	 	   Apollonian

       • physical              • cognitive
       • ecstatic              • individuating
       • chaotic               • understandable
       • intoxicated           • illusions
       • music                 • visual arts
       • dance                 • narrative




Thursday, 25 February 2010
playing		 	 	 	 	 	 	   gaming

       • physical              • cognitive
       • ecstatic              • individuating
       • chaotic               • understandable
       • intoxicating          • simulation
       • interaction           • rules
       • rhythm                • narrative




Thursday, 25 February 2010
movement                                                 systems/rhizome
            rhythm                                                   understanding

                                                                       Lego
                             Twirling
                                              Pervasive
                                               gaming          RPGs
                                                                        PnP RPG
           sensation                    rhythm-action

                        play                     FPS
                                                          MMORPGs         gamic
                             Dancing




               Dionysian                                               Apollonian


Thursday, 25 February 2010
Mature manhood; that means to have found the
       seriousness one had as a child at play.
                        - Nietzsche - Beyond Good and Evil


       Play is less the opposite of seriousness than the vital
       ground of spirit as nature, a form of restraint and
       freedom at one and the same time.
                   - Gadamer - The Relevance of the Beautiful



Thursday, 25 February 2010
autotelic




                        play                 gamic




               Dionysian       earnest     Apollonian


Thursday, 25 February 2010
movement                                                     systems/rhizome
            rhythm                                                       understanding
                                                    autotelic

                                                                            Lego
                             Twirling
                                               Pervasive
                                                gaming             RPGs
                                                                             PnP RPG
           sensation                    rhythm-action

                        play                       FPS
                                                              MMORPGs           gamic
                                                                                    navigation
                             Dancing
                                                                         Gambling
                                        Ballroom
                                                                        Stockmarket
                                        Dancing      Sports



               Dionysian                             earnest                Apollonian
                Gadamer                                                     de Certeau
Thursday, 25 February 2010
Conclusions

       • Not everything is Flow

       • The Dionysian is intoxicating => addictive

       • New physical interfaces hold promise

       • Narrative is not the only route to ‘art’




Thursday, 25 February 2010
Summary

       • No essentialist ontology/taxonomy

       • Focus on the aesthetic experience

       • Gaming and Playing as separate but intertwined principles

       • Apollo and Dionysus are merely starting points

       • Experiences are not privileged




Thursday, 25 February 2010
So tremendous is the power of the Apolline
              epic that it enchants the most terrible events
              before us with delightful illusion.
                             - Nietzsche - The Birth of Tragedy




Thursday, 25 February 2010
To be beautiful, everything must first be
              intelligible.
                            - Nietzsche paraphrasing Socrates
                                         - The Birth of Tragedy




Thursday, 25 February 2010

Contenu connexe

Tendances

Analysis of culture - Raymond Williams
Analysis of culture - Raymond WilliamsAnalysis of culture - Raymond Williams
Analysis of culture - Raymond Williamskubrasivisoglu
 
Major Themes and analysis of Aristotle Poetics
Major Themes and analysis of Aristotle PoeticsMajor Themes and analysis of Aristotle Poetics
Major Themes and analysis of Aristotle Poeticssaba rai
 
Jacques Lacan & Elizabeth Bishop
Jacques Lacan & Elizabeth BishopJacques Lacan & Elizabeth Bishop
Jacques Lacan & Elizabeth Bishopalexreed1977
 
Modern, modernity, modernism
Modern, modernity, modernism Modern, modernity, modernism
Modern, modernity, modernism apc108
 
AMND12 Apollonian and Dionysian
AMND12 Apollonian and DionysianAMND12 Apollonian and Dionysian
AMND12 Apollonian and Dionysianavellanacova
 
Barthes’ five narrative codes
Barthes’ five narrative codesBarthes’ five narrative codes
Barthes’ five narrative codesNeill Ford
 
Simulacra and Simulations - Jean Baudrillard
Simulacra and Simulations - Jean BaudrillardSimulacra and Simulations - Jean Baudrillard
Simulacra and Simulations - Jean BaudrillardSamantha Trieu
 
An apology for poetry paragraph 1-30
An apology for poetry paragraph 1-30An apology for poetry paragraph 1-30
An apology for poetry paragraph 1-30Anamta Dua
 
Oedipus rex as a tragic hero
Oedipus rex as a tragic heroOedipus rex as a tragic hero
Oedipus rex as a tragic heroKhalid Karim
 
Literary Criticism-Longinus.pptx
Literary Criticism-Longinus.pptxLiterary Criticism-Longinus.pptx
Literary Criticism-Longinus.pptxNirmala Padmavat
 
Six parts of tragedy
Six parts of tragedySix parts of tragedy
Six parts of tragedyMonalijethwa
 
Notes: A Defense of Poetry by Percy Bysshe Shelly + From the Letters by John ...
Notes: A Defense of Poetry by Percy Bysshe Shelly + From the Letters by John ...Notes: A Defense of Poetry by Percy Bysshe Shelly + From the Letters by John ...
Notes: A Defense of Poetry by Percy Bysshe Shelly + From the Letters by John ...Sarah Abdussalam
 
Analysis of the Poem :' The Extasie' by John Donne
Analysis of the Poem :' The Extasie' by John DonneAnalysis of the Poem :' The Extasie' by John Donne
Analysis of the Poem :' The Extasie' by John DonneNirav Amreliya
 
Catharsis by Aristotle
Catharsis by Aristotle Catharsis by Aristotle
Catharsis by Aristotle VaibhavCollege
 
Aristotle's Poetics - Epic And Tragedy
Aristotle's Poetics - Epic And TragedyAristotle's Poetics - Epic And Tragedy
Aristotle's Poetics - Epic And TragedyWater Birds (Ali)
 
Aristotle Poetics concepts of Tragedy and Plot
Aristotle Poetics concepts of Tragedy and PlotAristotle Poetics concepts of Tragedy and Plot
Aristotle Poetics concepts of Tragedy and PlotAleeenaFarooq
 
Medieval Aesthetics
Medieval AestheticsMedieval Aesthetics
Medieval AestheticsGreg A.
 

Tendances (20)

Analysis of culture - Raymond Williams
Analysis of culture - Raymond WilliamsAnalysis of culture - Raymond Williams
Analysis of culture - Raymond Williams
 
Major Themes and analysis of Aristotle Poetics
Major Themes and analysis of Aristotle PoeticsMajor Themes and analysis of Aristotle Poetics
Major Themes and analysis of Aristotle Poetics
 
Yeats’ Themes
Yeats’ ThemesYeats’ Themes
Yeats’ Themes
 
Jacques Lacan & Elizabeth Bishop
Jacques Lacan & Elizabeth BishopJacques Lacan & Elizabeth Bishop
Jacques Lacan & Elizabeth Bishop
 
Modern, modernity, modernism
Modern, modernity, modernism Modern, modernity, modernism
Modern, modernity, modernism
 
AMND12 Apollonian and Dionysian
AMND12 Apollonian and DionysianAMND12 Apollonian and Dionysian
AMND12 Apollonian and Dionysian
 
Barthes’ five narrative codes
Barthes’ five narrative codesBarthes’ five narrative codes
Barthes’ five narrative codes
 
Ironies in oedipus_rex
Ironies in oedipus_rexIronies in oedipus_rex
Ironies in oedipus_rex
 
Simulacra and Simulations - Jean Baudrillard
Simulacra and Simulations - Jean BaudrillardSimulacra and Simulations - Jean Baudrillard
Simulacra and Simulations - Jean Baudrillard
 
An apology for poetry paragraph 1-30
An apology for poetry paragraph 1-30An apology for poetry paragraph 1-30
An apology for poetry paragraph 1-30
 
Oedipus rex as a tragic hero
Oedipus rex as a tragic heroOedipus rex as a tragic hero
Oedipus rex as a tragic hero
 
Literary Criticism-Longinus.pptx
Literary Criticism-Longinus.pptxLiterary Criticism-Longinus.pptx
Literary Criticism-Longinus.pptx
 
Six parts of tragedy
Six parts of tragedySix parts of tragedy
Six parts of tragedy
 
Notes: A Defense of Poetry by Percy Bysshe Shelly + From the Letters by John ...
Notes: A Defense of Poetry by Percy Bysshe Shelly + From the Letters by John ...Notes: A Defense of Poetry by Percy Bysshe Shelly + From the Letters by John ...
Notes: A Defense of Poetry by Percy Bysshe Shelly + From the Letters by John ...
 
Aristotle's poetics
Aristotle's poetics Aristotle's poetics
Aristotle's poetics
 
Analysis of the Poem :' The Extasie' by John Donne
Analysis of the Poem :' The Extasie' by John DonneAnalysis of the Poem :' The Extasie' by John Donne
Analysis of the Poem :' The Extasie' by John Donne
 
Catharsis by Aristotle
Catharsis by Aristotle Catharsis by Aristotle
Catharsis by Aristotle
 
Aristotle's Poetics - Epic And Tragedy
Aristotle's Poetics - Epic And TragedyAristotle's Poetics - Epic And Tragedy
Aristotle's Poetics - Epic And Tragedy
 
Aristotle Poetics concepts of Tragedy and Plot
Aristotle Poetics concepts of Tragedy and PlotAristotle Poetics concepts of Tragedy and Plot
Aristotle Poetics concepts of Tragedy and Plot
 
Medieval Aesthetics
Medieval AestheticsMedieval Aesthetics
Medieval Aesthetics
 

Plus de Dan Dixon

Digital Insights from Pervasive & Urban Gaming
Digital Insights from Pervasive & Urban GamingDigital Insights from Pervasive & Urban Gaming
Digital Insights from Pervasive & Urban GamingDan Dixon
 
UX Bristol Gameful Design
UX Bristol Gameful DesignUX Bristol Gameful Design
UX Bristol Gameful DesignDan Dixon
 
Time management tips
Time management tipsTime management tips
Time management tipsDan Dixon
 
Big Games and Hipsters: Cool Capital in Pervasive Gaming Festivals
Big Games and Hipsters: Cool Capital in Pervasive Gaming FestivalsBig Games and Hipsters: Cool Capital in Pervasive Gaming Festivals
Big Games and Hipsters: Cool Capital in Pervasive Gaming FestivalsDan Dixon
 
Educating Creative Technologists
Educating Creative TechnologistsEducating Creative Technologists
Educating Creative TechnologistsDan Dixon
 
Pervasive game ethnography
Pervasive game ethnographyPervasive game ethnography
Pervasive game ethnographyDan Dixon
 
Bodies, rhythms and digital games
Bodies, rhythms and digital gamesBodies, rhythms and digital games
Bodies, rhythms and digital gamesDan Dixon
 
A Ludic Aesthetic in Everyday life
A Ludic Aesthetic in Everyday lifeA Ludic Aesthetic in Everyday life
A Ludic Aesthetic in Everyday lifeDan Dixon
 
Nietzsche Contra Caillois Presentation
Nietzsche Contra Caillois PresentationNietzsche Contra Caillois Presentation
Nietzsche Contra Caillois PresentationDan Dixon
 
What is a Game?
What is a Game?What is a Game?
What is a Game?Dan Dixon
 
Elements Of Web Design
Elements Of Web DesignElements Of Web Design
Elements Of Web DesignDan Dixon
 
Dramatic Elements
Dramatic ElementsDramatic Elements
Dramatic ElementsDan Dixon
 
Games Matrix
Games MatrixGames Matrix
Games MatrixDan Dixon
 
Death; a minor annoyance or an invitation to play?
Death; a minor annoyance or an invitation to play?Death; a minor annoyance or an invitation to play?
Death; a minor annoyance or an invitation to play?Dan Dixon
 

Plus de Dan Dixon (14)

Digital Insights from Pervasive & Urban Gaming
Digital Insights from Pervasive & Urban GamingDigital Insights from Pervasive & Urban Gaming
Digital Insights from Pervasive & Urban Gaming
 
UX Bristol Gameful Design
UX Bristol Gameful DesignUX Bristol Gameful Design
UX Bristol Gameful Design
 
Time management tips
Time management tipsTime management tips
Time management tips
 
Big Games and Hipsters: Cool Capital in Pervasive Gaming Festivals
Big Games and Hipsters: Cool Capital in Pervasive Gaming FestivalsBig Games and Hipsters: Cool Capital in Pervasive Gaming Festivals
Big Games and Hipsters: Cool Capital in Pervasive Gaming Festivals
 
Educating Creative Technologists
Educating Creative TechnologistsEducating Creative Technologists
Educating Creative Technologists
 
Pervasive game ethnography
Pervasive game ethnographyPervasive game ethnography
Pervasive game ethnography
 
Bodies, rhythms and digital games
Bodies, rhythms and digital gamesBodies, rhythms and digital games
Bodies, rhythms and digital games
 
A Ludic Aesthetic in Everyday life
A Ludic Aesthetic in Everyday lifeA Ludic Aesthetic in Everyday life
A Ludic Aesthetic in Everyday life
 
Nietzsche Contra Caillois Presentation
Nietzsche Contra Caillois PresentationNietzsche Contra Caillois Presentation
Nietzsche Contra Caillois Presentation
 
What is a Game?
What is a Game?What is a Game?
What is a Game?
 
Elements Of Web Design
Elements Of Web DesignElements Of Web Design
Elements Of Web Design
 
Dramatic Elements
Dramatic ElementsDramatic Elements
Dramatic Elements
 
Games Matrix
Games MatrixGames Matrix
Games Matrix
 
Death; a minor annoyance or an invitation to play?
Death; a minor annoyance or an invitation to play?Death; a minor annoyance or an invitation to play?
Death; a minor annoyance or an invitation to play?
 

Apollo and Dionysus at Play

  • 1. Apollo and Dionysus at Play Dan Dixon Digital Cultures Research Centre | Pervasive Media Studio University of the West of England Thursday, 25 February 2010
  • 2. • Where Caillois went wrong • Nietzsche, Dionysus and Apollo • New phenomenological approach • Conclusions Thursday, 25 February 2010
  • 4. ludus ilinx mimicry alea agon paidia Thursday, 25 February 2010
  • 5. For it is only as an aesthetic phenomena that existence and the world are externally justified. - Nietzsche - The Birth of Tragedy Thursday, 25 February 2010
  • 7. Apollo and Dionysus Thursday, 25 February 2010
  • 8. Dionysian Apollonian • physical • cognitive • ecstatic • individuating • chaotic • understandable • intoxicated • illusions • music • visual arts • dance • narrative Thursday, 25 February 2010
  • 9. play games Thursday, 25 February 2010
  • 10. digital play games gamic Thursday, 25 February 2010
  • 11. digital play games st s o e gamic m m nd ga a r ot he Thursday, 25 February 2010
  • 12. Dionysian Apollonian • physical • cognitive • ecstatic • individuating • chaotic • understandable • intoxicated • illusions • music • visual arts • dance • narrative Thursday, 25 February 2010
  • 13. playing gaming • physical • cognitive • ecstatic • individuating • chaotic • understandable • intoxicating • simulation • interaction • rules • rhythm • narrative Thursday, 25 February 2010
  • 14. movement systems/rhizome rhythm understanding Lego Twirling Pervasive gaming RPGs PnP RPG sensation rhythm-action play FPS MMORPGs gamic Dancing Dionysian Apollonian Thursday, 25 February 2010
  • 15. Mature manhood; that means to have found the seriousness one had as a child at play. - Nietzsche - Beyond Good and Evil Play is less the opposite of seriousness than the vital ground of spirit as nature, a form of restraint and freedom at one and the same time. - Gadamer - The Relevance of the Beautiful Thursday, 25 February 2010
  • 16. autotelic play gamic Dionysian earnest Apollonian Thursday, 25 February 2010
  • 17. movement systems/rhizome rhythm understanding autotelic Lego Twirling Pervasive gaming RPGs PnP RPG sensation rhythm-action play FPS MMORPGs gamic navigation Dancing Gambling Ballroom Stockmarket Dancing Sports Dionysian earnest Apollonian Gadamer de Certeau Thursday, 25 February 2010
  • 18. Conclusions • Not everything is Flow • The Dionysian is intoxicating => addictive • New physical interfaces hold promise • Narrative is not the only route to ‘art’ Thursday, 25 February 2010
  • 19. Summary • No essentialist ontology/taxonomy • Focus on the aesthetic experience • Gaming and Playing as separate but intertwined principles • Apollo and Dionysus are merely starting points • Experiences are not privileged Thursday, 25 February 2010
  • 20. So tremendous is the power of the Apolline epic that it enchants the most terrible events before us with delightful illusion. - Nietzsche - The Birth of Tragedy Thursday, 25 February 2010
  • 21. To be beautiful, everything must first be intelligible. - Nietzsche paraphrasing Socrates - The Birth of Tragedy Thursday, 25 February 2010