Contenu connexe
Similaire à PREVENTION OF PRETERM BIRTH (20)
Plus de Aboubakr Elnashar (20)
PREVENTION OF PRETERM BIRTH
- 20. Conclusions
▪Identificationofriskfactorsforpretermdeliverybefore
conceptionorearlyinpregnancymayprovideanopportunityfor
primaryprevention.Aninterpregnancyintervalofmorethansix
monthsmayreducetheriskofPTB.Womenwithperiodontal
diseaseareatincreasedriskof
▪pretermdelivery.Periodontaldiseaseshouldbetreatedasa
componentofgooddentalhygiene,butthereareinadequate
datatosuggestatreatmentforpreventionofPTB.
▪Thereisinsufficientevidencetosupporttheuseofbedrest;on
thecontrary,dailyphysicalactivityshouldbesupportedamong
womenatriskofsPTB.
•Utilizingstrategiestopreventmultiplegestations
resultingfromassistedreproductionshoulddecrease
thenumberofpretermbirthsrelatedtomultiplegestations.
▪However,mostpretermbirthsoccuramongwomenwithno
obviousriskfactorsandthenumberofeffectiveinterventionsis
limited
▪Secondarypreventivestrategiessuchasacervicalcerclage,
ABOUBAKRELNASHAR
TheNationalInstituteofClinicalExcellenceintheUnitedKingdom,35
FIGO,andtheSMFMintheUnitedStatesallrecommendtheuse
ofprogestogensforwomenathighriskofpretermbirth.Thelatter
advisesthatwomenbetween20and366gestationalweeksreceive
17‐hydroxyprogesteronecaproate(250mgintramuscularlyweekly)
startingat16–20weeksuntil36weeksordeliveryforwomenwitha
singletongestationandahistoryofpriorspontaneouspretermbirth.36
Thetwoformerorganizationsendorsetheuseofvaginalprogesterone
forwomenwithashortcervix.
Asdiscussedinthisreview,however,theevidenceonefficacy
forthoseatriskofpretermbirth,impactonpretermbirthrates,and
long‐termeffectsforthebabyofimplementingtheserecommendations
remainsinconclusive.Cliniciansandpregnantwomencanlook
forwardtosomeresolutionoftheconflictingviewsonefficacyonce
thePCORI‐fundedindividualpatientdatameta‐analysisispublished.
Recommendationsshouldbeupdatedoncethefulldetailsofthe
PCORIindividualpatientdatameta‐analysisisinthepublicdomain.
ABOUBAKRELNASHAR
- 21. Conclusion
1.Introduction:PTBisamajorpublichealthproblemwithhighneonatal
morbidityandMortality
2.Prediction:Cervicallength(CL)measuredbytransvaginalultrasoundat
20e24weeksisareliabletesttoidentifypregnancywithahigherriskfor
spontaneousPTB.
3.Primaryprevention:LDA,smokingcessation,reducemultiplepregnancy,
occupationalfatigue,znsupplementation,avoidshortinterpregnancy
intervals
4.Secondaryprevention
▪NaturalprogesteronehalvestheriskofPTBinsingletonpregnant
womenwithashortCL.
▪Cervicalcerclagemaybeindicatedhistoricallyorultrasound
Insingletonpregnancywithmid-gestationultrasoundshortCL,vaginal
progesteroneisassociatedwithastatisticallysignificantreductionintheriskof
(RDS),LBW),verylowbirthweight(VLBW),andlessadmissiontothe
neonatalintensivecareunit(NICU).
Intwin-pregnantwomenwithaCLlessthan25mm,vaginalprogesterone
mightbeassociatedwiththereductionofPTBandneonatalmorbidityincluding
reductionintheriskofRDS,neonatalandperinataldeath,VLBW,andalsoless
needformechanicalventilation.
However,RCTareneededtoconfirmthesefindings.
ABOUBAKRELNASHAR
ABOUBAKRELNASHAR
- 22. Mateietal,2019
Intotal,112reviewswereincludedinthisstudy.Overalltherewere49Cochraneand63non-
Cochranereviews.Eightwereindividualparticipantdata(IPD)reviews.Sixtyreviewsassessed
theeffectofprimarypreventioninterventionsonriskofPTB.Positiveeffectswerereportedfor
lifestyleandbehaviouralchanges(includingdietandexercise);nutritionalsupplements
(includingcalciumandzincsupplementation);nutritionaleducation;screeningforlowergenital
tractinfections.Eighty-threesystematicreviewswereidentifiedrelatingtosecondaryPTB
preventioninterventions.Positiveeffectswerefoundforlowdoseaspirinamongwomenatrisk
ofpreeclampsia;clindamycinfortreatmentofbacterialvaginosis;treatmentofvaginal
candidiasis;progesteroneinwomenwithpriorspontaneousPTBandinthosewithshort
midtrimestercervicallength;L-arginineinwomenatriskforpreeclampsia;levothyroxineamong
womenwithtyroiddisease;calciumsupplementationinwomenatriskofhypertensive
disorders;smokingcessation;cervicallengthscreeninginwomenwithhistoryofPTBwith
placementofcerclageinthosewithshortcervix;cervicalpessaryinsingletongestationswith
shortcervix;andtreatmentofperiodontaldisease.Conclusion:Theoverviewservesasaguide
tocurrentevidencerelevanttoPTBprevention.Onlyafewinterventionshavebeen
demononstratedtobeeffective,includingcerclage,progesterone,lowdoseaspirin,and
lifestyleandbehaviouralchanges.Forseveraloftheinterventionsevaluated,therewas
insufficientevidencetoassesswhethertheywereeffectiveornot.
ABOUBAKRELNASHAR
Conclusion
▪prophylacticprogesteroneadministrationinwomenpresentingwithashortCL
reducestheincidenceofPTB.
▪Vaginalprogesteroneisassociatedwithastatisticallysignificantreductionintherisk
ofneonatalmorbidityandalowerfrequencyofearlyPTB,loweradmissiontothe
NICU,andshorterlengthofNICUstay[18e20].
▪nosignificantrelationshipbetweenclinicallyadministerednaturalprogesteroneand
congenitalmalformations[83,84].
▪ProphylacticadministrationofprogesteroneforthepreventionofPTBshouldbe
offeredtowomenwithapriorspontaneousPTBandtothosepregnantwomenwitha
shortcervixof25mmorlessatmid-gestationscan.
▪ForsingletonpregnantwomenwithapriorhistoryofspontaneousearlyPTBanda
shortCL(<25mm)incurrentpregnancy,bothcerclageandvaginalprogesteroneare
aneffectivetreatmentforpreventingPTBandimprovingneonataloutcomes.
However,thechoiceoftreatmentwilldependonadverseeventsand
patient/physician'spreferences.
▪routineuseofprogesteroneintwinpregnancieswithCLlessthanorequalto25mm.
Nevertheless,furtherRCTsareneededtoconfirmsuchevidenceandmaybe
determinedifthereareotherindicationsforprogesteronetherapyfortheprevention
ofPTBespeciallyinsymptomaticpatients.
ABOUBAKRELNASHAR
- 23. thanks
ABOUBAKRELNASHAR
Preventionofspontaneouspretermbirth
▪Thereissubstantialevidenceshowingthatvaginalprogesteronesignificantlydecreasesthe
riskofpretermbirth≤34weeksby34%amongwomenwithpriorhistoryofpretermdelivery
and/oramidtrimesterCL≤25mm.Furthermore,pooledestimatesobtainedbycombining
datafromfourtrialsindicatethatvaginalprogesteronewasassociatedwithastatistically
significantreductionintheriskofpretermbirthfrom<28to<36weeks’gestation,
respiratorydistresssyndrome,compositeneonatalmorbidityandmortality,birthweight
<1500g,andadmissiontoNICU.Vaginalprogesteroneissafeandhadnoeffectontherisk
ofbothfetaldeath[37]andontheriskofadverseneurodevelopmentaloutcomes.Therewere
nosignificantdifferencesinthecognitivecompositescoresorratesofneurodevelopmental
impairmentuptosixyearsofagebetweenchildrenexposedinuterotovaginalprogesterone
andthoseexposedtoplacebo[37-41].
▪Cervicalcerclagedoesnotappeartobeeffectiveforwomenwithashortcervixwhohave
not
hadapriorpretermbirth[42].Inameta-analysisoffourrandomizedtrialsinwhichsingleton
pregnancieswerescreenedwithcervicalultrasoundexaminationandrandomlyassignedto
cerclageornocerclageifthecervixwasshort,cerclageplacementinwomenwithnoprior
15pretermbirthdidnotresultinsignificantreductioninbirth<35weeks(21%vs31%without
cerclage:relativerisk0.84,95%CI0.60-1.17)[42].
Inwomenwithashortcervix(≤25mm)atmidtrimester,singletongestationandpriorpreterm
birthearlierthan34weeks,cerclageandvaginalprogesteroneareequallyeffectiveinan
indirectcomparisonmeta-analysisforpreventingpretermbirthandimprovingperinatal
outcomes[43].However,thechoiceoftreatmentshoulddependontheriskofadverseevents
andcost-effectivenessofinterventions,andpatient/physician’spreferences.ABOUBAKRELNASHAR
- 24. Controversieswithinobservationalstudiesmaybe
attributedtodifferentoperativeskillsandclinicalsurveillance.
Itcanhardlybedeniedthattheefficacyofboththe
vaginalandabdominalcerclageishighlydependentonthe
surgeon`sskills,andunfortunately,thishasnotsufficiently
beenconsideredorauditedinpublishedstudies.Therefore,
itsimplementationcannotbeconsideredininexperienced
handsastheclinicalrisks,althoughrarecanbedevastating,
astheseincludehemorrhage,sepsis,perinatal,neonatal,or
evenmaternaldeath.
ABOUBAKRELNASHAR
4.Cervicalcerclage
Inanindividualpatientmeta-analysis,Jorgensenetal.suggested
thattheuseofcerclageeffectivelyreducestheriskofpregnancy
lossorneonataldeathpriortodischargefromthe
hospital[84].Twomaintechniqueshavebeendescribed,the
McDonaldandtheShirodkarprocedure.Althoughthelatter
permitstheintroductionofthestichinanuppercervical
level,evidencedoesnotsupportitssuperioritycomparedto
theMcDonaldtechnique[85].Theintroductionofasecond
cervicalstichhasbeeninvestigatedbyameta-analysisthat
includedsixobservationalstudiesandsuggestedthatthis
approachmightreducesPTBrates<28and<34weeksABOUBAKRELNASHAR
- 25. SOGC,2020
▪Progesteronetherapyreducestheriskofspontaneouspretermbirthin
womenatanincreasedriskbasedonhistoryofpreviousspontaneous
pretermbirthorinwomenwithashortcervicallength(moderate).
▪Thereisinsufficientevidencetosupporttheuseofprogesteronefor
preventionofspontaneouspretermbirthinwomenwithapregnancyinthe
absenceofcervicalshortening(moderate).
▪Thereisinsufficientevidencetosupporttheuseofprogesteronefor
preventionofspontaneouspretermbirthinwomenwithanormalcervical
lengthandapriorconizationprocedureonthecervixorabnormaluterine
anatomy(low).
▪Useofvaginalprogesteroneforpreventionofspontaneouspretermbirthhas
notbeenassociatedwithanincreaseincongenitalmalformationsorwitha
worseningofpostnatalneurodevelopmentaloutcomes(moderate).
ABOUBAKRELNASHAR
FSOG,2017
▪17OHPC
▪notrecommendedfortheprimarypreventionofpretermdeliveryina
populationofwomenwithsingletonpregnanciesandnohistoryof
pretermdelivery(GradeC).
▪Wecannotrecommendtheroutineadministrationof17OHPCtowomen
withahistoryofpretermdeliverytoreducetheirriskonthebasisofthis
singlerandomizedtrial,especiallyinviewofitslimitedexternalvalidity
▪notshownanybenefitsinwomenwithasingletonpregnancy,ahistory
ofpretermdelivery,andacervicallengthlessthan25mmduringthe
secondtrimester.Accordinglytheuseof17OHPCinthissituationisnot
recommended(GradeB).Inthesamepopulation,vaginalprogesterone
mightreducetheriskofpretermdelivery
▪Progestationalagents
▪whetheradministeredvaginallyorbyinjectionas17OHPC,arenot
associatedwithareducedriskofpretermdelivery,afterpretermlabor,for
asymptomatictwinpregnancieswithnormalorunknowncervicallength
measurements.Theyarethereforenotrecommendedinthesetwotwin-
pregnancysituations(respectivelyGradeAandGradeB).
▪Amongwomenwithtwinpregnanciesandacervixlessthan25mm,the
preventiveadministrationof17OHPChasshownnobenefitsforprolonging
pregnancyorreducingperinatalrisk.Itisthusnotrecommendedinthis
ABOUBAKRELNASHAR
- 26. FSOG,2017
▪Theonlypopulationforwhichprogestationaltreatmentisrecommendedis
asymptomaticpregnantwomenwithsingletonpregnanciesandnohistoryof
pretermdeliverywhohaveacervicallengthlessthan20mmbetween16
and24weeks.
▪17OHPC
▪notrecommendedfortheprimarypreventionofpretermdeliveryina
populationofwomenwithsingletonpregnanciesandnohistoryof
pretermdelivery(GradeC).
▪Wecannotrecommendtheroutineadministrationof17OHPCtowomen
withahistoryofpretermdeliverytoreducetheirriskonthebasisofthis
singlerandomizedtrial,especiallyinviewofitslimitedexternalvalidity
▪notshownanybenefitsinwomenwithasingletonpregnancy,ahistory
ofpretermdelivery,andacervicallengthlessthan25mmduringthe
secondtrimester.Accordinglytheuseof17OHPCinthissituationisnot
recommended(GradeB).Inthesamepopulation,vaginalprogesterone
mightreducetheriskofpretermdelivery
▪Progestationalagents
▪whetheradministeredvaginallyorbyinjectionas17OHPC,arenot
associatedwithareducedriskofpretermdelivery,afterpretermlabor,for
asymptomatictwinpregnancieswithnormalorunknowncervicallength
measurements.Theyarethereforenotrecommendedinthesetwotwin-
pregnancysituations(respectivelyGradeAandGradeB).
ABOUBAKRELNASHAR
3.Progestationalagents(FSOG,2017)
▪17OHPCisnotrecommendedfortheprimarypreventionofpretermdelivery
inapopulationofwomenwithsingletonpregnanciesandnohistoryof
pretermdelivery(GradeC).
▪naturalmicronizedprogesteroneadministeredvaginallydailyforupto36
weeksisrecommendedforasymptomaticwomenwithasingleton
pregnancy,nohistoryofpretermdelivery,andacervicallengthlessthan20
mmat16to24weeks(GradeB).
▪Onetrialhasassociated17OHPCwithareductionintheriskofdelivery
before34weeksandwithareductioninneonatalmorbidity(LE3)in
singletonpregnanciesamongwomenwithahistoryofatleastonedelivery
before34weeks.
▪Wecannotrecommendtheroutineadministrationof17OHPCtowomenwith
ahistoryofpretermdeliverytoreducetheirriskonthebasisofthissingle
randomizedtrial,especiallyinviewofitslimitedexternalvalidity
▪Vaginalprogesteroneforasymptomaticwomenwithahistoryofpreterm
deliverydoesnotappeartobeassociatedwithareducedriskofdelivery
before34weeks
▪Thevaginaladministrationofprogesteronetoreducetheriskofpreterm
deliveryinwomenwithahistoryofpretermdeliveryisnotrecommended
▪Treatmentwith17OHPChasnotshownanybenefitsinwomenwitha
singletonpregnancy,ahistoryofpretermdelivery,andacervicallengthless
ABOUBAKRELNASHAR
- 27. 2.Supplementalprogestogens
SingletonpregnanciesThepreventiveeffectofprogestogens
wasalreadydiscussedbyPapiernik-Berkhauerin
1970andthenbyKeirsein1990[62,63].Progestogens
havebeenusedtoreducePTBintheformofthesynthetic
17α-hydroxyprogesteronecaproateadministeredweeklyas
250mgortheformofnaturalprogesteroneapplieddailyas
vaginalsuppositoriesorgel.Bothsubstanceshavedifferent
half-timelivesanddifferenteffectsandshouldbeseparately
analyzed.
Tworandomizedplacebo-controlledtrialsfrom2003
foundthatprogesterone,administeredaseitherweekly
intramuscularinjectionsof250mgof17α-hydroxyprogesterone
caproateordailyprogesteronevaginalsuppositories,
reducedtherateofrecurrentpretermdeliverybyabouta
third[64,65].Otherwise,thebenefitof17-OHPCiscontroversially
discussed[66].ThestillongoingPROLONGtrial
isintendedtoinvestigatetheuseof17-OHPCinhigh-risk
pregnancieswiththepreviousPTB.
ABOUBAKRELNASHAR
Challengesinlow-andmiddle-incomecountries
▪WhilemosteffortsonpreventionofsPTBcomefromhigh-
incomecountries,manyLMIChavetodealwithmore
challengingconditions.
▪Poorlydevelopedpublicinstitutions,limitedfundinganda
relativelylownumberofskilledstaffcompoundedbycontextual
factorssuchascorruptionandpatronagemayleadtoadverse
andunpredictableneonataloutcomes.
Unfortunately,manyLMIChavefailedtopromotemodernisation
inhealthcareadministration[125].Consequently,
theremaybeakindofpublic/privatecollaboration,
supportedinpartbyexternalaidagencies.These
conditionsmaybemetinwell-equippedhospitals,butare
oftenabsentinlowerlevelfacilities,suchassecond-level
hospitalsandprimaryhealthcarecenters,wheremostof
thedeliveriesoccurinthesecountries[126].
Ithasbeenrecognizedthatthelackofawarenessand
educationofstakeholdersoutsidethehealthcaresector,asABOUBAKRELNASHAR
- 28. Singletonpregnancies
SeveralstudieshaveshowedthattheriskofPTBisinverselyrelatedtothe
lengthofthecervix[9e14],andearlypretermdeliveryincreaseswiththe
decreaseinCL,fromabout0.2%at60mmto1.1%at25mm,4.0%at15mm,
and78%at5mm[10].
Combineddatafromthethreelargeststudiesinvolvingatotalof7861women
showedthatthedetectionrateofbirthbefore35weekswas34%forafalse-
positiverateofabout5%[9,10,13].Celiketal.[13]conductedapopulation-
basedprospectivemulticenterstudyin58,807womenwithsingleton
pregnanciesattendingforroutinehospitalantenatalcare.Thecervicallength
(CxL)measuredbyTVUat20e24þ6/7dayswasnormallydistributedwitha
meanof36mm.Thelengthwas25mmorlessinabout10%ofwomen,20
mmorlessin5%,and15mmorlessinabout1%.Usingthesecutoffvalues,the
respectivedetectionratesofspontaneousearlyPTBbefore32weekswere
35%,48%,and55%.Furthermore,theCLof15mmaccountsfor25.8%ofthe
spontaneousearlydeliveriesbefore34weeksandbetween16and25mm
accountsfor20.4%oftheearlydeliveriesbefore34weeks.
Twinpregnancies
Intwinpregnancies,therateofearlyPTBisabout10%,comparedwith1e2%
insingletons[38].Inthelargeststudy,CLwasmeasuredat20e24weeksin
1163twinpregnanciesattendingforroutineantenatalcare[15,39].Therateof
deliverywasinverselyrelatedtotheCL,being66%for10mm,24%for
20mm,12%for25mm,andlessthan1%for40mm.ThemedianCxLwas35
ABOUBAKRELNASHAR
Universalscreeningforshortcervicallength
Recommendationfortheuseofvaginalprogesteroneforpregnancieswithno
historyofspontaneousPTDbutashortcervixbeforeorat24weeksraisesthe
issueofuniversalCLmeasurementat18e24weeks(21).Theansweris
complexandraisesthreeissues:first,giventhelowprevalenceofthe
shortcervixmeasuringbetween10and20mmbefore24weeksinthegeneral
population,between1.7%(27)and2.3%(29),itisnecessarytoscreen
between400and588pregnanciestoavoidonePTB.
However,thenumberofcaseswithashortCLneededtotreatisonly7e13.4to
preventonePTB;second,disseminationofsuchscreeningrequiresthe
developmentofqualitystandardsforthemeasurement
ofCLbyTVU;andthird,thereisariskofinsidiousslidingwitharbitrary
extensionoftheeligibilityandmanagementcriteria,suchasrepeated
ultrasoundsperformedoutside18e24weeks,treatmentadministeredoutside
theboundsofCLstudied(bordereffect),useofotherinterventionsnot
justifiedincaseofshortCL,andthereforepotentiallyundesirable
consequenceswithintramuscularinjectionsof17P[40].
Infact,theCLmeasuredbyTVUisaneffectivescreeningtestforthe
preventionofPTB,andthecriteriaforaneffectivescreeningtestareallmetby
CL.AlthoughroutineCLscreeningisnotclearlyrecommendedbysome
internationalsocieties,suchscreeningisseenasreasonableforallofthem
[41e44].Furthermore,bothAmericancollegeofobstetriciansandgynecologistsABOUBAKRELNASHAR
- 30. thattheriskofadelivery<33weekswasreducedby45%
[67].Significantdifferenceswerealsoreportedconcerning
theratesofsPTB28weeks,respiratorydistresssyndrome,
andneonatalmorbidityandmortality.Thisstudywasdifferently
analyzedbystatisticiansoftheFDAwhofoundno
evidencewhencorrectingthesedataformaternalparameters
andnodifferenceinoutcomeaftertwoyears.Thismight
havebeenareasonwhytheFDAdidnotagreethatvaginal
progesteronewasapprovedintheUS[68].Thereafter,the
OPPTIMUMtrialinvestigatedthelong-termeffectofvaginal
progesteroneversusplaceboforthepreventionofPTB
untiltheageof2yearsandfoundneithersignificantbenefits
norharmsrelatedtothepost-neonataloutcome,neithera
significantprolongationofpregnancy[69].Therefore,the
authorJaneNormanconcludedthatadrugforwhichno
differencescouldbedeterminedaftertwoyearsshouldatleast
requirethatpatientsarewell-informed.Criticsofthisstudy
wererelatedtotheinclusioncriteriaandallowcompliance
ofonly60%.Meanwhile,Romeroetal.haveconductedthree
ABOUBAKRELNASHAR
Indirectanddirectcomparisonsofcervicalpessary,
cerclage,andprogesterone
Currentresearchstillfocussesontheoptimaltreatmentof
pregnancieswithashortcervixdetectedbytransvaginal
ultrasound.In2013,Alfirevicetal.publishedthefirstretrospective
studycomparingcerclage,vaginalprogesterone,
andcervicalpessaryinpatientsatriskforPTBandashort
CLandfoundthattheywereallefficaciousinpreventing
PTBwithsomemorebenefitsofthecervicalpessary[92].
Conde-Agudeloetal.publishedanindirectcomparison
meta-analysisofvaginalprogesteroneversuscervicalcerclage
andfoundnoclinicallyrelevantdifferences[93]and
a“networkmeta-analysis”whichincluded36trials,suggested
thatprogesteroneseemstobebetterthancerclage
andpessary[94].However,thereareseveralproblemsin
theseindirectcomparisons.AnopenlabelmulticenterRCT
iscurrentlyrecruitingpatientstodirectlycomparecervical
cerclage,cervicalpessary,andvaginalprogesteronein
womenwithashortcervix[95].
Somedirectcomparisonsoftwostrategieshave,meanwhile,
beenpublishedasRCTscomparingvaginalprogesterone
andcervicalpessaryinsingletonsandintwins[96,
97].TheRCTinsingletonpregnanciescouldnotfinda
significantdifferencebetweencervicalpessaryandvaginal
ABOUBAKRELNASHAR