Paper evaluation in research methodology subject to acquired the answer of preliminary questions by evaluation one example paper.

2. International Islamic University Malaysia
Research Methodology
Prof.Aisha
Assignment 1 : Paper Evaluation
Title :A Study of HMIPV6 Handover
Management for Packet Transmission Analysis
Presenter Syed Absar Kazmi
Engrabsarkazmi@gmail.com
MSEE G1220119

3.  2) Does the article have a stated research question?
 Solution:- Yes , In the introduction (para.3) from line # 1 onward. long delay
time handover in standard Hierarchical Mobile IPv6 is the main problem to be solved
by proposed method.
4) Is the article logically organized and easy to follow?
 Solution:-Yes, the total hierarchy is in step by step defined and making it simpler to
 Understand for reader however the overview for all sections has not mentioned .
 5) Does the article contain a section that describes and integrates previous studies
on the topic?
 Solution:- Yes in introduction section(2 para 4 line ) the publisher clearly describes
and integrates previous studies on to the topic.

Paper Evaluation …….

4. Paper Evaluation …….
 6) Are the procedure enough to be replicated?
 Solution:-Yes it seems that it is very close to be replicated due to Fig. 3.
Handover Latency Comparison at time alpha
8) Do you agree with the interpretation of the results?
 Solution:-Yes, as the results are interpreted in the form of facts and figures plotted in
graph as performance analysis for all protocol and TC-HMIPv6 is efficient
management handover more than Standard MIPv6 and HMIPv6.
 9) What are the weaknesses of the article?
 Solution:-The two dominant shortcomings that I have observed in the session are that,
1- Lack of references and most of papers which are consider for his reseach are more
old than 5 years
2- Graph has not been described to analyze the performance and In the conclusion
phase the publisher need to do some comparison in numerical approximation that
how his method of solution of the problem is better than the others
Strength # Off course it’s a great approach of TC-HMIPv6 protocol to reduce the handover delay
time .
