SlideShare une entreprise Scribd logo
1  sur  38
Télécharger pour lire hors ligne
How to better exploit (not waste) a company’s scarcest resource

Management Attention
Dr. Alan Barnard
CEO, Goldratt Research Labs
23rd October, 2013
IMPROVEMENT CHALLENGES

What makes improving productivity so difficult…
Challenge 1: Achieving Growth AND Stability and Harmony
Stakeholder’s Conflict

Growth

Satisfy
Growth in
Demand
Disharmony

Be
Successful

Maintain
Stability /
Harmony

GOAL

PERFORMANCE

Pressure
to Change
Constraint
Stability
Harmony

Pressure to
Not Change

What Next?
Decay
Past

Now

Future

TACTICS

STRATEGIES

TIME

Challenge 2: Ensuring every Local Change = System Improvement




WHY?

How can Goldratt’s Theory of Constraints help overcome these challenges?
© Goldratt Research Labs, 2013

Slide 2
Presentation outline
1. What is Theory of Constraints (TOC)?
•

TOC’s Five Focusing Steps (5FS)

•

TOC’s Throughput Accounting (TA)

2. Using TOC to measure and improve
Management Productivity
3. Using TOC to measure and improve
Operational Productivity
4. Case Studies
5. Q&A
© Goldratt Research Labs, 2013

Slide 3
Part 1
What is
Theory of Constraints?
Knowing What to Change…and What NOT

© Goldratt Research Labs, 2013

Slide 4
What is Theory of Constraints?

Dr. Eli Goldratt (1947-2011) said that we can summarize
Theory of Constraints with a single word...

FOCUS
However, FOCUS do not only mean knowing what we should DO,
but as importantly, what we should NOT DO…
because…
Focusing on everything is synonymous with not focusing on anything.

1984

1986

1990

1994

1997

1999

2000

© Goldratt Research Labs, 2013

2009

2010

Slide 5

2010
WHAT IS THEORY OF CONSTRAINTS?

Knowing “WHAT TO CHANGE” - The 5 Focusing Steps of TOC…
“A chain is only as strong as its weakest link”
Step 0: Agree on the System GOAL
Step 1: IDENTIFY the System Constraint (WEAKEST LINK)
Step 2: Decide how to better EXPLOIT (not Waste) the System Constraint
Step 3: SUBORDINATE everything to the above decision (CHANGE only those RULES – policies &
measurements in conflict with decision on how to better exploit/not waste system constraint)
Step 4: ELEVATE the Constraint (get more of it)
Step 5: WARNING!!!! If in a previous step the constraint has moved, GO BACK to Step 1, - do not let
inertia become the constraint. (However, try not to reach Step 5 else you have to change rules)

Supply
Step 1
IDENTIFY the
Constraint

15/hr

12/hr

12/hr

10/hr

Step 3
Step 2
SUBORDINATE
Decide How to
EXPLOIT the constraint everything to this decision
GOAL 

EXPLOIT potential
for more Goal Units

PROTECT current
level of Constraint
Exploitation

↓ Overproduction / Multiitasking
↓ Rework
↓ Starvation/Blockage
↓ Setups/Downtime

Current level of
Constraint
Exploitation

+ VE

+ VE

Change

- VE

GOAL 

New Constraint
Exploitation Rules

Demand

Step 4
Elevate the Constraint

GOAL 
+ VE

Protective Capacity

New level of
Constraint
Exploitation

+ VE

Change

NOT

- VE

Elevate

NOT

- VE

13/hr

- VE

GOAL 

New Constraint
Elevation Rules

Step 5
If a constraint has been broken, Go back to Step 1

© Goldratt Research Labs, 2013

Slide 6
GOLDRATT’S DICE GAME

Why is the Throughput of systems well below their bottleneck capacity?

The Dice Game – Insights
A

B

C

D

Expected = 70 upm
Actual = 35 upm
(around 50%)

E

Min

1

U/day

Min

1

U/day

Min

1

U/day

Min

1

U/day

Min

1

U/day

Min

?

U/hr

Avg

3.5

U/day

Avg

3.5

U/day

Avg

3.5

U/day

Avg

3.5

U/day

Avg

3.5

U/day

Avg

?

U/hr

Max

6

U/day

Max

6

U/day

Max

6

U/day

Max

6

U/day

Max

6

U/day

Max

?

U/hr

Important Lessons Learned:
1. System Output is normally significantly below Output of the Bottleneck
2. “Balancing Capacities” (to be efficient) creates a chaotic system – i.e. its impossible to
reliably predict performance and very difficult to know where to focus…
3. We need to balance the FLOW …not Capacities…which requires Buffers + Protective
Capacity in non-bottleneck processes…but will this not cost too much / take too long?
© Goldratt Research Labs, 2013

Slide 7
WHAT IS THEORY OF CONSTRAINTS?

Why is the Throughput of systems well below their bottleneck capacity?

The Dice Game – Insights
A

B

C

D

Expected = 60 upm
Actual = 58 upm
(around 97%)

E

Min

1

U/day

Min

1

U/day

Min

1

U/day

Min

1

U/day

Min

1

U/day

Min

?

U/hr

Avg

3.5

U/day

Avg

3.5

U/day

Avg

3

U/day

Avg

3.5

U/day

Avg

3.5

U/day

Avg

?

U/hr

Max

6

U/day

Max

6

U/day

Max

5

U/day

Max

6

U/day

Max

6

U/day

Max

?

U/hr

Important Lessons Learned:
1. By slowing down the Bottleneck, we can create Protective Capacity in non-bottlenecks
to reduce starvation and blockage of the Bottleneck.
2. If the Starvation and Blockage buffers work 100% effectively, the system performance will
be equal to the bottleneck performance (and be very predictable).
3. Starvation and Blockage buffers should be dynamically adjusted based on actual supply
reliability and demand variation (Too much Red = Too small  Increase ; Too little Red = Too large Reduce) .
© Goldratt Research Labs, 2013

Slide 8
© Goldratt Research Labs, 2013

Slide 9
WHAT IS THEORY OF CONSTRAINTS?

Quantifying the impact of CHANGES – TOC Throughput Accounting
To determine the likely GLOBAL impact of any LOCAL Change,
Estimate the LOW, LIKELY and HIGH impact of each Change on ΔT, OE and I

Sales Revenue (SR)

Now
US$
% of SR
$ 10,000
100%

Variable Cost (VC)

$

5,000

50%

Throughput (T)
Operating Expenses (OE)

$
$

5,000
4,500

50%
45%

0.0%
0.0%

$ 5,000
$ 4,500

50%
45%

Net Profit (NP)

$

500

5%

0.0%

$

5%

Investment (I)

$

2,500

25%

0%

Return on Investment (NP/I)

% Change
in Qty

% Change
in Price

0.0%

0.0%

Future
US$
% of SR
$10,000
100%

0.0%

0.0%

$ 5,000

50%

20%

0%

500

$ 2,500
25%
6
20%

Throughput (T)
The rate at which the system generates money through Sales or
T = Sales Revenue (SR) – Variable Cost (VC)
Operating Expenses (OE)
The rate at which the system spends money to generate Throughput (or other goal units)
i.e. OE = All non-variable costs (also called Fixed Costs)
Investment (I)
All the money tied up in the system (the money invested to generate Throughput).
© Goldratt Research Labs, 2013

Slide 10
Part 2
Using TOC to improve
Management Productivity
What is the bottleneck to improving
Management Productivity?

© Goldratt Research Labs, 2013

Slide 11
WHAT IS THEORY OF CONSTRAINTS?

Applying the 5 Focusing Steps to Management Productivity…

What is the Constraint or Bottleneck to
improving MANAGEMENT Productivity…

…needed to achieve more GROWTH, STABILITY and HARMONY?

The Bottleneck is always at the TOP of the bottle…

© Goldratt Research Labs, 2013

Slide 12
Applying TOC’s 5 Focusing Steps to Improving
and Managing Organizations
Step 1: Identify the System Constraint …to

Achieving GROWTH, STABILITY AND HARMONY
(within Organizations)
Management Information
Demand

vs.

Supply

Surplus

Required
Information to
make better
faster decisions

Available
data and
Information

Management Attention
Demand

MANY
Things that
demand OR
could benefit
from our
Attention

vs.

Supply

Shortage

Available
Attention

Management Attention = System Constraint
© Goldratt Research Labs, 2013

Slide 13
Applying TOC’s 5 Focusing Steps to Improving
Management Productivity
Step 2: Decide how to EXPLOIT the System Constraint …
Identify the things that WASTE our Management Attention…

Better Exploiting Management Attention
 Supply
vs.
 Demand
HOW? … STOP …
REDUCE
FOCUS on FEW
Things that
could really
benefit from our
limited
Attention…and
DON’T MULTITASK

3. Repeating Mistakes – not
Learning from Experience

INCREASE

Error of Detection &
Correction

2. NOT DOING what we should

Error of Omission

1. DOING what we should not

Error of Commission

Productive use of
our
Attention

How much of your limited MANAGEMENT ATTENTION do you
think you WASTE due to mistakes 1, 2 and 3?
© Goldratt Research Labs, 2013

Slide 14
Quick Self-Assessment Check
Make a list of the things that cause you to WASTE your limited attention….

DOING WHAT YOU
SHOULD NOT

NOT DOING WHAT YOU
SHOULD

© Goldratt Research Labs, 2013

REPEATING AVOIDABLE
MISTAKES (REWORK)

Slide 15
Why do we say “PAY” attention…?
WARNING

or pay the price
There is a COST and a BENEFIT of PAYING Attention
1. COST – we GIVE UP the benefit of focusing our attention on something or
someone else…
2. BENEFIT – we GAIN the benefit of focusing our attention on this thing or
this person…
What is a common strategy to maximize BENEFIT and minimize COST…

We Multitask
…we try to give equal attention to the MANY things that demand or can
benefit from our attention…….but don’t realize the high PRICE we pay.…
© Goldratt Research Labs, 2013

Slide 16
Checking Sufficiency…
So, are there any other ways that we
waste our limited Attention?
For example…

For the cases where we are
DOING WHAT WE SHOULD,
is “Multi-tasking”
the best way
to allocate our limited attention?

© Goldratt Research Labs, 2013

Slide 17
Dr. Eli Goldratt’s real Legacy

Standing on the shoulders of Giants
“Finally, and most importantly, I wanted to show that we can all be
outstanding scientists. The secret of being a good scientist, I believe,
lies not in our brain power. We have enough. We simply need to look
at reality and think logically and precisely about what we see.”
Dr. Eliyahu M. Goldratt
1948 - 2011

Dr. Goldratt, the creator of Theory of Constraints, said the two key abilities to
“being an outstanding scientist” are simply:
(STEP1) Have the courage to face inconsistencies between what we (expect to)
see and the way things are… and then
(STEP 2) Have the wisdom to challenge basic assumption(s) to resolve these
inconsistencies.

Research Questions
•

What are the inconsistency regarding how we invest our limited attention to
get work done?

•

What “basic assumption(s)” can and should be challenged to resolve this
inconsistency….and how to do this especially if challenging the assumption
might be counter-intuitive?
© Goldratt Research Labs, 2013

Slide 18
Management Productivity Challenge

Facing an inconsistency and challenging basic assumption(s)

Research Problem
Inconsistency: Despite major advances in technology and know-how most
change initiatives are still completed late, over-budget and/or under-scope.
Research Question
Can changing the RULE we use in do work/ project tasks have a significant
impact on the lead time, costs and quality (or not)?
Research Method
• You are giving three projects to complete for your organization.
• These three projects together make up a Program but each project is for
a different “Customer” and each of these customers want you to finish
their project as soon as possible, want you to give them highest priority
but is also asking for a “reliable estimate of completion”.
• Which RULE should you use to do these projects:
RULE 1: Work on all of them at the same time (Multi-task), or
RULE 2: Do them one by one…(No Multi-tasking)?
© Goldratt Research Labs, 2013

Slide 19
Round #1

Complete Tasks by Multi-tasking …
A
B
C
D
E
F
G
H
I
J
K
L
M
N
O
P
Q
R
S
T
59 sec

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
58 sec
88 – 178 sec
50-200% Longer

Δ
Ο
☐
Δ
Ο
☐
Δ
Ο
☐
Δ
Ο
☐
Δ
Ο
☐
Δ
Ο
☐
Δ
Ο
60 sec

89 – 179 sec
90 – 180 sec
50-200% longer
50 - 200% longer

© Goldratt Research Labs, 2013

Slide 20
Round #2

Complete Tasks without Multi-tasking
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
20 sec

A
B
C
D
E
F
G
H
I
J
K
L
M
N
O
P
Q
R
S
T
40 sec

10 - 20sec
Early / On time

Δ
Ο
☐
Δ
Ο
☐
Δ
Ο
☐
Δ
Ο
☐
Δ
Ο
☐
Δ
Ο
☐
Δ
Ο
60 sec

20 - 40sec
30 - 60 sec
Early / On time
Early / On time

© Goldratt Research Labs, 2013

Slide 21
UNDERSTANDING WHY MULTI-TASKING IS SO BAD…

Multi-tasking delays project flow …and distracts our attention
SCENARIO #1: No Capacity Constraints
Project X
Project Y
Project Z
0

10

20

BASIC ASSUMPTION CHALLENGED
“The earlier we start… the earlier we finish” / Its unfair to prioritize
VS.
“The later we start... the earlier we finish” / Its unfair not to prioritize

SCENARIO #2: PLAN - Multi-tasking
Project X
Project Y
Project Z

End
Earlier?

Start
Earlier

10

0

20

30

40

50

60

Finish
Later
70

80

SCENARIO #2: ACTUAL - Multi-tasking with Distraction Delays
Project X

LATE
FINISH!

Project Y
Project Z
0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

SCENARIO #3: PLAN - No Multitasking
Project X
Project Y
Project Z

Start
Later

0

10

Finish
Earlier

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

SCENARIO #3: ACTUAL - No Multitasking
Can safely reduce
Project buffer by 50%

Project X
Project Y
Project Z

EARLY FINISH

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

90
ANALYZING POOR PROJECT PERFORMANCE
Is it the Starting Conditions…or the Rules WE use…
Our Challenge
Difficulty to Improve & sustain
higher Project Performance

Other Consequences…

Delays and Mistakes in prediction,
detection & correction

People at all levels are
stressed and overworked

Increased Project
Work + Wait Time
Main Cause…

Real Cause…

 Complexity, Uncertainty
and Resource Constraints
Really?
Lets check this
assumption with
Multitasking Game

Multitasking
at all levels

“Local Optima”
Rules…

Too High WIP Too Detailed Schedules
+ Not Full Kit
+ Local Safety

Pipelining
Lower WIP +
TOC Solution Ensure Full Kit
CCPM Rule 1

Local Priorities +
Measurements

Execution
Planning
Schedules with Aggregated
Global Priorities +
Tasks + Buffers
Buffer Management
CCPM Rule 2
CCPM Rule 3
Simple …but not easy…

© Goldratt Research Labs, 2013

Slide 23
Part 3
Using TOC to improve
Operational Productivity
Is TOC the same as Debottlenecking?

© Goldratt Research Labs, 2013

Slide 24
STANDING ON THE SHOULDERS OF GIANTS

THE Four Concepts of Flow

1. Improving Flow (specifically reducing Flow Time) is
should be the #1 objective for Operations/Supply Chains
2. To reduce Flow Time, we need a Practical Mechanism to
Stop Overproduction and maintain right priority
–
–
–

Ford: Use Space and Sequence of Launch
Ohno: Use Kanbans and Colors to show emergency Kanbans
Goldratt: Use Time (Buffers) and Buffer Penetration to ensure same
priority everywhere and to focus management attention

3. Abolish all Local Efficiencies / Local Optima
4. Put in place a Focusing Mechanism to continuously
improve and re-balance Flow
(e.g. Do Pareto on what is causing delays in flow?)

Yes, but….
How do we know that FLOWS are not balanced…
© Goldratt Research Labs, 2013

Slide 25
RISK: DEMAND GROWTH / INSUFFICENT CAPACITY
Growth in backlog vs. Decay in Reliability of Supply...
Arrivals

Departures

Resource

Linear growth
until reaching
“Turning the
Corner” Point
at >80%
utilization

0%

Resource Utilization

80%

Reliability in meeting demand

Queue Length/Supply Lead time

Growth in Queues & Decay in Reliability vs. Growth in Resource Utilization

100%

How can we turn this insight into a GOOD MEASUREMENT SYSTEM…?
© Goldratt Research Labs, 2013

Slide 26
Balancing FLOWS … not balancing CAPACITY
Using Cumulative Flow Diagrams as Early Warnings of Scarcity

Cumulative Flow Diagrams
Higher
WIP
WIP
Supply
Lead Time
Time

Longer
Supply LT

Time

Higher
WIP
Longer
Supply LT
Time

LITTLE’s LAW
Work-in-Process = Flow Rate x Flow Time
WIPavg = FRavg x FTavg
If either arrivals (demand) increase or departures (supply) reduce, it causes Supply
Lead Time and WIP to grow.
• Growth will be exponential if demand grows faster than supply.
• Growth will be permanent without sufficient catch-up (protective) capacity…
© Goldratt Research Labs, 2013

Slide 27
CRITERIA FOR DESIGNING A GOOD
MEASUREMENT SYSTEM
GOOD MEASUREMENT SYSTEM
1. Accurately measures the STATUS (Ok or not?) and TREND (Improving or Not?)
 Know WHEN to act…and When NOT
 Mistakes
 Type 1 - Reporting we are OK when we are not…and
 Type 2 - Reporting we are not OK when we are.

2. Accurately predicts likely CAUSE(S) of the status (i.e. Demand or Supply problem?)
 Know WHERE to act …and Where NOT
 Mistakes
 Type 1 – Reporting something as a major cause when it is not…and
 Type 2 – Not Reporting something as a major cause when it was
3. Drives desired / discourages undesired behaviors (what is best for the system)
 Know HOW to act…and HOW not
 Mistakes
 Type 1 - Encouraging an undesirable behaviour (local optima)…and
 Type 2 – Not encouraging a desired behavior
How well does your company’s measurement system meet these criteria?
© Goldratt Research Labs, 2013

Slide 28
IMPORTANT GLOBAL MEASUREMENTS

Measuring Productivity, Flow and Timeliness
GOOD MEASUREMENTS

CUMULATIVE FLOW
Arrivals
(Demand)

Cumulative Flow

• Cumulative Flow for System and Subsystems
• Operational Productivity = $T/$OE or
(for Service Depts)
= QT/OE
• Capital Productivity = $T/$I
• Quality can be measured as:
% Coverage, % OnTime or % InSpec

WIP
Longer Flow Time
Throughput
(Supply)

Flow Time

• % Protective Capacity Available on CCRs
(Capacity Constraint Resource)

Time in Days

PRODUCTIVITY

QUALITY THROUGHPUT
75% of On-time / Coverage

Productivity

Operational Productivity = $T/$OE or QT/OE

25% Late /
Not served

20%
15%

Capital Productivity = $T/$I

15%

10%

10%

5%

Time in Days

0-5d

5-10d

10-15d

© Goldratt Research Labs, 2013

15-20d 20-25d

25-30d

30-35d

35-40d

> 40d

Slide 29
Part 4
Case Study
How can we apply the 4 Concepts of flow
and insights on the damaging
consequences of Multi-tasking to improve
Productivity of Managers at all levels?
© Goldratt Research Labs, 2013

Slide 30
Case Study:

Focusing on improving Flow & stopping multi-tasking
Every manager can improve the productivity of its department if
they can find ways to reduce flow delays and stop multi-tasking
The case studies shared will show the impact of improving flow
and stopping multi-tasking in different departments within two
different companies.
Company 1 – Applying it within Sales Department
This case study will reveal how the company applied the 4 Concepts to
significantly reduce the Average Sales Cycle Time and increase the success
rate of their sales

Company 2 – Applying it within IT Department
This case study will reveal how the company applied the 4 Concepts to
significantly improve due date performance and reduce the average Lead
time of IT Projects.
© Goldratt Research Labs, 2013

Slide 31
CASE STUDY 1 – LESS IS MORE

Applying four FLOW concepts to Sales Department
1. IMPROVING FLOW IS #1 - Faster Flow of “good” (higher Throughput margin and higher
probability of closing deal) sales opportunities through the sales channel should be the #1
objective because any flow delays cause longer sales cycles, lower hit rate & margins.
2. MECHANISM TO PREVENT OVERPRODUCTION & SYNCHRONIZE PRIORITIES - “Choke
the release” by ensuring whole Sales Teams focus on “well qualified sales opportunities”–
Less is More because too High WIP causes Multi-tasking that cause bottlenecks, longer
sales cycles and lower hit rate …so more pressure to go get even more(vicious cycle)
3. ABOLISH LOCAL OPTIMA – Abolish any incentives or measurements that drive behavior
that is in conflict with better flow (e.g. number of opportunities in pipeline)
4. FOCUSING MECHANISM – Identify and eliminate the most significant sources of low hit ratio
and or long sales cycles to focus continuous improvement efforts - check for build-up of
WIP in sales process steps and record and analyze reasons for delay.

 30%

 47%

 263%

Reference: Chapter 21 of Theory of Constraints Handbook, Less is more: Applying Flow concepts to Sales by Mauricio Herman and Rami Goldratt
© Goldratt Research Labs, 2013

Slide 32
CASE STUDY 2 – LESS IS MORE

Applying four FLOW concepts to IT Department
1. IMPROVING FLOW IS #1 - Faster Flow of “good” (higher ROI) projects through the Project
Office should be the #1 objective because any flow delays cause longer lead times,
lower quality and throughput of projects, higher cost & risk and lower ROI
2. MECHANISM TO PREVENT MULTITASKING & SYNCHRONIZE PRIORITIES - “Choke the
release” by pipelining projects (prioritize, freeze and stop) as starting projects too soon causes
multi-tasking that causes longer wait and work time (longer flow time).
3. ABOLISH LOCAL OPTIMA – Abolish any incentives or measurements that drive behavior
that is in conflict with better flow (e.g. no. of projects in pipeline, reporting % complete etc.)
4. FOCUSING MECHANISM – Identify and eliminate the most significant sources of delays on
projects and resource bottlenecks to focus continuous improvement efforts check for
build-up of WIP at TASK Manager Level (for resource constraints) and record and analyze
reasons for most penetrating delays.

© Goldratt Research Labs, 2013

Slide 33
CLOSING REMARKS

Achieving FLOW in Personal productivity…

STOP Multi-tasking – get into FLOW

© Goldratt Research Labs, 2013

Slide 34
Key Take-Aways
Management Attention
Available

Repeating mistakes

Doing right things
wrong

Wasted

Not doing the RIGHT
Time/Attention
things

Actual
Utilization

Doing the WRONG
things

Productive
Time
(Adding Value)

Not doing the
Wrong Things
(STOP/NOT START)

Doing the Right
Things

Doing the right
things right

(ACCELERATE/START)

(FOCUS/DONT MULTI-TASK)

Learn from
Experience
(FAST FEEDBACK)

REMEMBER….THE BOTTLENECK IS ALWAYS AT THE TOP OF THE BOTTLE
© Goldratt Research Labs, 2013

Slide 35
THANK YOU FOR YOUR
ATTENTION…
….I KNOW IT IS YOUR SCARCEST
RESOURCE

GOOD LUCK!

© Goldratt Research Labs, 2013

Slide 36
Q&A

© Goldratt Research Labs, 2013

Slide 37
ABOUT THE PRESENTERS
Dr. Alan Barnard (PhD)

Dr. Alan Barnard is one of the leading experts in the world in Theory
of Constraints (TOC) frequently worked with Dr. Eli Goldratt, creator
of Theory of Constraints on large and complex projects around the
world. He is the CEO of Goldratt Research Labs (USA), Chairman of
Realization Africa (RSA), African Phosphates (RSA) and The
Odyssey Institute (USA). Alan is also a board member of TOCICO
and the Dr. Eliyahu M. Goldratt Foundation.
In 2009, Alan was awarded a PhD in Management of Technology &
Innovation, from the Da Vinci Institute in 2009 with a thesis titled
“How to identify and unlock inherent potential within organizations
(private & public) and individuals?”. Alan is also the author of 2
chapters in the McGraw Hill published Theory of Constraints
Handbook.
Alan is a past-President of SAPICS (2000 to 2002) and past-President of TOCICO (2003 to
2005) and serve on the judging panels of the Logistics Achiever Awards and Technology
Top 100.
He has worked with global companies such as ABB, BHP, Cisco, SAP, Random House
Publishing, Tata in the Private sector and also with UN DP, UN WFP and InWent in the
public sector on applying for example Theory of Constraints to City Councils in
Developing Countries in the Public Sector to help them identify and unlock inherent
potential to achieve more with the same resources in less time.

© Goldratt Research Labs, 2013

Contenu connexe

Tendances

How to Achieve Superior Performance Improvement by Integrating Constraints Ma...
How to Achieve Superior Performance Improvement by Integrating Constraints Ma...How to Achieve Superior Performance Improvement by Integrating Constraints Ma...
How to Achieve Superior Performance Improvement by Integrating Constraints Ma...commonsenseLT
 
Gemba walk: the start of your lean journey
Gemba walk: the start of your lean journeyGemba walk: the start of your lean journey
Gemba walk: the start of your lean journeyboscollkid
 
Lean Healthcare - Streamlining Patient Journeys
Lean Healthcare - Streamlining Patient Journeys Lean Healthcare - Streamlining Patient Journeys
Lean Healthcare - Streamlining Patient Journeys Lean Enterprise Academy
 
Pmi 124796324233 Phpapp01
Pmi 124796324233 Phpapp01Pmi 124796324233 Phpapp01
Pmi 124796324233 Phpapp01jasonhian
 
Terraforming organisations
Terraforming organisationsTerraforming organisations
Terraforming organisationsClaudio Perrone
 
Evolve or Die: A3 Thinking and Popcorn Flow in Action (#LKCE14)
Evolve or Die: A3 Thinking and Popcorn Flow in Action (#LKCE14)Evolve or Die: A3 Thinking and Popcorn Flow in Action (#LKCE14)
Evolve or Die: A3 Thinking and Popcorn Flow in Action (#LKCE14)Claudio Perrone
 
Lean Startup for Smart Entrepreneurs
Lean Startup for Smart EntrepreneursLean Startup for Smart Entrepreneurs
Lean Startup for Smart EntrepreneursClaudio Perrone
 
B. den Haak. How to make OKRs Lean Again
B. den Haak. How to make OKRs Lean AgainB. den Haak. How to make OKRs Lean Again
B. den Haak. How to make OKRs Lean AgainAgile Lietuva
 
10 Things Competencies
10 Things Competencies10 Things Competencies
10 Things Competenciesjothisekaran
 
2009 03 05 Asm Keynote Working For Distribution
2009 03 05 Asm Keynote Working For Distribution2009 03 05 Asm Keynote Working For Distribution
2009 03 05 Asm Keynote Working For DistributionRobert Early (Rob) Johnson
 
Agile: Beyond Software
Agile: Beyond SoftwareAgile: Beyond Software
Agile: Beyond SoftwareEdwin Dando
 
A3 THINKING FOR SOLVING COMPLEX PROBLEMS AND EVOLUTIONARY CHANGE (ALEXEI ZHEG...
A3 THINKING FOR SOLVING COMPLEX PROBLEMS AND EVOLUTIONARY CHANGE (ALEXEI ZHEG...A3 THINKING FOR SOLVING COMPLEX PROBLEMS AND EVOLUTIONARY CHANGE (ALEXEI ZHEG...
A3 THINKING FOR SOLVING COMPLEX PROBLEMS AND EVOLUTIONARY CHANGE (ALEXEI ZHEG...Lean Kanban Central Europe
 
What Next? Sustaining Innovation
What Next? Sustaining InnovationWhat Next? Sustaining Innovation
What Next? Sustaining InnovationPaul McIvor
 
EVOLVE & DISRUPT (Agileee 2015)
EVOLVE & DISRUPT (Agileee 2015) EVOLVE & DISRUPT (Agileee 2015)
EVOLVE & DISRUPT (Agileee 2015) Arthur Lokaychuk
 
Experiment Driven Product Innovation
Experiment Driven Product InnovationExperiment Driven Product Innovation
Experiment Driven Product InnovationadaptiveX
 
JR Dickens - FPS 2004
JR Dickens - FPS 2004JR Dickens - FPS 2004
JR Dickens - FPS 2004jrd9234
 

Tendances (20)

How to Achieve Superior Performance Improvement by Integrating Constraints Ma...
How to Achieve Superior Performance Improvement by Integrating Constraints Ma...How to Achieve Superior Performance Improvement by Integrating Constraints Ma...
How to Achieve Superior Performance Improvement by Integrating Constraints Ma...
 
Purple Curve Magazine
Purple Curve MagazinePurple Curve Magazine
Purple Curve Magazine
 
Gemba walk: the start of your lean journey
Gemba walk: the start of your lean journeyGemba walk: the start of your lean journey
Gemba walk: the start of your lean journey
 
Lean Healthcare - Streamlining Patient Journeys
Lean Healthcare - Streamlining Patient Journeys Lean Healthcare - Streamlining Patient Journeys
Lean Healthcare - Streamlining Patient Journeys
 
Pmi 124796324233 Phpapp01
Pmi 124796324233 Phpapp01Pmi 124796324233 Phpapp01
Pmi 124796324233 Phpapp01
 
Startup way overview lsc montreal - nov. 14 2017
Startup way overview   lsc montreal - nov. 14 2017Startup way overview   lsc montreal - nov. 14 2017
Startup way overview lsc montreal - nov. 14 2017
 
Terraforming organisations
Terraforming organisationsTerraforming organisations
Terraforming organisations
 
Evolve or Die: A3 Thinking and Popcorn Flow in Action (#LKCE14)
Evolve or Die: A3 Thinking and Popcorn Flow in Action (#LKCE14)Evolve or Die: A3 Thinking and Popcorn Flow in Action (#LKCE14)
Evolve or Die: A3 Thinking and Popcorn Flow in Action (#LKCE14)
 
Lean Startup for Smart Entrepreneurs
Lean Startup for Smart EntrepreneursLean Startup for Smart Entrepreneurs
Lean Startup for Smart Entrepreneurs
 
B. den Haak. How to make OKRs Lean Again
B. den Haak. How to make OKRs Lean AgainB. den Haak. How to make OKRs Lean Again
B. den Haak. How to make OKRs Lean Again
 
10 Things Competencies
10 Things Competencies10 Things Competencies
10 Things Competencies
 
2009 03 05 Asm Keynote Working For Distribution
2009 03 05 Asm Keynote Working For Distribution2009 03 05 Asm Keynote Working For Distribution
2009 03 05 Asm Keynote Working For Distribution
 
Agile: Beyond Software
Agile: Beyond SoftwareAgile: Beyond Software
Agile: Beyond Software
 
Ooda pres
Ooda presOoda pres
Ooda pres
 
A3 THINKING FOR SOLVING COMPLEX PROBLEMS AND EVOLUTIONARY CHANGE (ALEXEI ZHEG...
A3 THINKING FOR SOLVING COMPLEX PROBLEMS AND EVOLUTIONARY CHANGE (ALEXEI ZHEG...A3 THINKING FOR SOLVING COMPLEX PROBLEMS AND EVOLUTIONARY CHANGE (ALEXEI ZHEG...
A3 THINKING FOR SOLVING COMPLEX PROBLEMS AND EVOLUTIONARY CHANGE (ALEXEI ZHEG...
 
Gemba Walks Helping Management to See
Gemba Walks Helping Management to SeeGemba Walks Helping Management to See
Gemba Walks Helping Management to See
 
What Next? Sustaining Innovation
What Next? Sustaining InnovationWhat Next? Sustaining Innovation
What Next? Sustaining Innovation
 
EVOLVE & DISRUPT (Agileee 2015)
EVOLVE & DISRUPT (Agileee 2015) EVOLVE & DISRUPT (Agileee 2015)
EVOLVE & DISRUPT (Agileee 2015)
 
Experiment Driven Product Innovation
Experiment Driven Product InnovationExperiment Driven Product Innovation
Experiment Driven Product Innovation
 
JR Dickens - FPS 2004
JR Dickens - FPS 2004JR Dickens - FPS 2004
JR Dickens - FPS 2004
 

En vedette

Building the cash machine (sales team and sale process management) (red)
Building the cash machine (sales team and sale process management) (red)Building the cash machine (sales team and sale process management) (red)
Building the cash machine (sales team and sale process management) (red)Versli Lietuva (Enterprise Lithuania)
 
TOC Daily Operations Room Meeting
TOC Daily Operations Room MeetingTOC Daily Operations Room Meeting
TOC Daily Operations Room MeetingArrie van Niekerk
 
Ar didėja Lietuvos įmonių konkurencingumas: kaip atrodėme anksčiau ir kur pat...
Ar didėja Lietuvos įmonių konkurencingumas: kaip atrodėme anksčiau ir kur pat...Ar didėja Lietuvos įmonių konkurencingumas: kaip atrodėme anksčiau ir kur pat...
Ar didėja Lietuvos įmonių konkurencingumas: kaip atrodėme anksčiau ir kur pat...Versli Lietuva (Enterprise Lithuania)
 
The Process of Innovation
The Process of InnovationThe Process of Innovation
The Process of InnovationJoel Wenger
 
Introductionto toc
Introductionto tocIntroductionto toc
Introductionto tocHasham22
 
Goal - Eliyahu Moshe Goldratt
Goal - Eliyahu Moshe GoldrattGoal - Eliyahu Moshe Goldratt
Goal - Eliyahu Moshe GoldrattManmohan Anand
 
The GOAL - Book Review
The GOAL - Book ReviewThe GOAL - Book Review
The GOAL - Book Reviewsada102010
 
Increasing Sales Productivity with Social Selling
Increasing Sales Productivity with Social SellingIncreasing Sales Productivity with Social Selling
Increasing Sales Productivity with Social SellingKurt Shaver
 
The Goal by Eliyahu M. Goldratt - A Book Review
The Goal by Eliyahu M. Goldratt - A Book ReviewThe Goal by Eliyahu M. Goldratt - A Book Review
The Goal by Eliyahu M. Goldratt - A Book ReviewRahul Wane
 
Growth Hacking Marketing: técnicas y estrategias
Growth Hacking Marketing: técnicas y estrategiasGrowth Hacking Marketing: técnicas y estrategias
Growth Hacking Marketing: técnicas y estrategiasÁlvaro Vázquez Chimeno
 
The age of exponential organisations
The age of exponential organisationsThe age of exponential organisations
The age of exponential organisationsYan-Erik Decorde
 
Implementing ToC it doesnt have to be hard!
Implementing ToC   it doesnt have to be hard!Implementing ToC   it doesnt have to be hard!
Implementing ToC it doesnt have to be hard!Pinnacle Strategies
 
Quotes that represent deep mental models
Quotes that represent deep mental modelsQuotes that represent deep mental models
Quotes that represent deep mental modelsArrie van Niekerk
 
Theory Of Constraints
Theory Of ConstraintsTheory Of Constraints
Theory Of Constraintsshawncarner
 
Tocico 2007 finance of toc distribution v1.1
Tocico 2007   finance of toc distribution v1.1Tocico 2007   finance of toc distribution v1.1
Tocico 2007 finance of toc distribution v1.1HumbertoRB
 
06.09.2015 Professor Tony Bendell TOCICO Conference Keynote Slides
06.09.2015 Professor Tony Bendell TOCICO Conference Keynote Slides06.09.2015 Professor Tony Bendell TOCICO Conference Keynote Slides
06.09.2015 Professor Tony Bendell TOCICO Conference Keynote Slidesaliciaandrews
 

En vedette (20)

Building mafia offers for smbs
Building mafia offers for smbs Building mafia offers for smbs
Building mafia offers for smbs
 
Building the cash machine (sales team and sale process management) (red)
Building the cash machine (sales team and sale process management) (red)Building the cash machine (sales team and sale process management) (red)
Building the cash machine (sales team and sale process management) (red)
 
¿Qué es Growth Hacking? - Infografía
¿Qué es Growth Hacking? - Infografía¿Qué es Growth Hacking? - Infografía
¿Qué es Growth Hacking? - Infografía
 
How to prepare mafia offers under lithuanian circumstances (red)
How to prepare mafia offers under lithuanian circumstances (red)How to prepare mafia offers under lithuanian circumstances (red)
How to prepare mafia offers under lithuanian circumstances (red)
 
TOC Daily Operations Room Meeting
TOC Daily Operations Room MeetingTOC Daily Operations Room Meeting
TOC Daily Operations Room Meeting
 
Goldratt
GoldrattGoldratt
Goldratt
 
Ar didėja Lietuvos įmonių konkurencingumas: kaip atrodėme anksčiau ir kur pat...
Ar didėja Lietuvos įmonių konkurencingumas: kaip atrodėme anksčiau ir kur pat...Ar didėja Lietuvos įmonių konkurencingumas: kaip atrodėme anksčiau ir kur pat...
Ar didėja Lietuvos įmonių konkurencingumas: kaip atrodėme anksčiau ir kur pat...
 
The Process of Innovation
The Process of InnovationThe Process of Innovation
The Process of Innovation
 
Introductionto toc
Introductionto tocIntroductionto toc
Introductionto toc
 
Goal - Eliyahu Moshe Goldratt
Goal - Eliyahu Moshe GoldrattGoal - Eliyahu Moshe Goldratt
Goal - Eliyahu Moshe Goldratt
 
The GOAL - Book Review
The GOAL - Book ReviewThe GOAL - Book Review
The GOAL - Book Review
 
Increasing Sales Productivity with Social Selling
Increasing Sales Productivity with Social SellingIncreasing Sales Productivity with Social Selling
Increasing Sales Productivity with Social Selling
 
The Goal by Eliyahu M. Goldratt - A Book Review
The Goal by Eliyahu M. Goldratt - A Book ReviewThe Goal by Eliyahu M. Goldratt - A Book Review
The Goal by Eliyahu M. Goldratt - A Book Review
 
Growth Hacking Marketing: técnicas y estrategias
Growth Hacking Marketing: técnicas y estrategiasGrowth Hacking Marketing: técnicas y estrategias
Growth Hacking Marketing: técnicas y estrategias
 
The age of exponential organisations
The age of exponential organisationsThe age of exponential organisations
The age of exponential organisations
 
Implementing ToC it doesnt have to be hard!
Implementing ToC   it doesnt have to be hard!Implementing ToC   it doesnt have to be hard!
Implementing ToC it doesnt have to be hard!
 
Quotes that represent deep mental models
Quotes that represent deep mental modelsQuotes that represent deep mental models
Quotes that represent deep mental models
 
Theory Of Constraints
Theory Of ConstraintsTheory Of Constraints
Theory Of Constraints
 
Tocico 2007 finance of toc distribution v1.1
Tocico 2007   finance of toc distribution v1.1Tocico 2007   finance of toc distribution v1.1
Tocico 2007 finance of toc distribution v1.1
 
06.09.2015 Professor Tony Bendell TOCICO Conference Keynote Slides
06.09.2015 Professor Tony Bendell TOCICO Conference Keynote Slides06.09.2015 Professor Tony Bendell TOCICO Conference Keynote Slides
06.09.2015 Professor Tony Bendell TOCICO Conference Keynote Slides
 

Similaire à How to better exploit (not waste) a company’s scarcest resource Management Attention

Theory Of Constraints 2
Theory Of Constraints  2Theory Of Constraints  2
Theory Of Constraints 2MOHD ARISH
 
Radically increase your process and project throughput with the theory of con...
Radically increase your process and project throughput with the theory of con...Radically increase your process and project throughput with the theory of con...
Radically increase your process and project throughput with the theory of con...Jonathan Sapir
 
Theory of constraints
Theory of constraintsTheory of constraints
Theory of constraintsMOHD ARISH
 
Theory of constraints._eliyahu_m._goldra
Theory of constraints._eliyahu_m._goldraTheory of constraints._eliyahu_m._goldra
Theory of constraints._eliyahu_m._goldraJuan Colin
 
[Whitepaper] The “Theory of Constraints:” What’s Limiting Your Organization?
[Whitepaper] The “Theory of Constraints:” What’s Limiting Your Organization?[Whitepaper] The “Theory of Constraints:” What’s Limiting Your Organization?
[Whitepaper] The “Theory of Constraints:” What’s Limiting Your Organization?Flevy.com Best Practices
 
.Change Management1We are often resist.docx
.Change Management1We are often resist.docx.Change Management1We are often resist.docx
.Change Management1We are often resist.docxhoney725342
 
Total Quality Management Lec.6.pptx
Total Quality Management Lec.6.pptxTotal Quality Management Lec.6.pptx
Total Quality Management Lec.6.pptxAynur27
 
Theory of constraints
Theory of constraintsTheory of constraints
Theory of constraintsmzpkn
 
Flow for agile testing - lssc11 proceedings
Flow for agile testing - lssc11 proceedingsFlow for agile testing - lssc11 proceedings
Flow for agile testing - lssc11 proceedingsYuval Yeret
 
Leadership and System Change Using Lab Based Techniques
Leadership and System Change Using Lab Based TechniquesLeadership and System Change Using Lab Based Techniques
Leadership and System Change Using Lab Based TechniquesPaul Taylor
 
Reviewing a Developer Experience
Reviewing a Developer ExperienceReviewing a Developer Experience
Reviewing a Developer ExperienceArty Starr
 
Session 3_TOC.pptx in theory if constraints
Session 3_TOC.pptx in theory if constraintsSession 3_TOC.pptx in theory if constraints
Session 3_TOC.pptx in theory if constraintsritukaushikmba25
 
Theory of constraints
Theory of constraintsTheory of constraints
Theory of constraintsSourabh Joshi
 
Unconstrained Benefits Assignment
Unconstrained Benefits AssignmentUnconstrained Benefits Assignment
Unconstrained Benefits AssignmentJames Dunford
 
A p r i l 2 0 0 5 I S T R AT E G I C F I N A N C E 5 1A.docx
A p r i l  2 0 0 5 I S T R AT E G I C  F I N A N C E 5 1A.docxA p r i l  2 0 0 5 I S T R AT E G I C  F I N A N C E 5 1A.docx
A p r i l 2 0 0 5 I S T R AT E G I C F I N A N C E 5 1A.docxransayo
 

Similaire à How to better exploit (not waste) a company’s scarcest resource Management Attention (20)

Theory of constraints
Theory of constraintsTheory of constraints
Theory of constraints
 
Theory Of Constraints 2
Theory Of Constraints  2Theory Of Constraints  2
Theory Of Constraints 2
 
Radically increase your process and project throughput with the theory of con...
Radically increase your process and project throughput with the theory of con...Radically increase your process and project throughput with the theory of con...
Radically increase your process and project throughput with the theory of con...
 
Theory of constraints
Theory of constraintsTheory of constraints
Theory of constraints
 
Theory of constraints._eliyahu_m._goldra
Theory of constraints._eliyahu_m._goldraTheory of constraints._eliyahu_m._goldra
Theory of constraints._eliyahu_m._goldra
 
[Whitepaper] The “Theory of Constraints:” What’s Limiting Your Organization?
[Whitepaper] The “Theory of Constraints:” What’s Limiting Your Organization?[Whitepaper] The “Theory of Constraints:” What’s Limiting Your Organization?
[Whitepaper] The “Theory of Constraints:” What’s Limiting Your Organization?
 
.Change Management1We are often resist.docx
.Change Management1We are often resist.docx.Change Management1We are often resist.docx
.Change Management1We are often resist.docx
 
Total Quality Management Lec.6.pptx
Total Quality Management Lec.6.pptxTotal Quality Management Lec.6.pptx
Total Quality Management Lec.6.pptx
 
Toc service industry
Toc service industryToc service industry
Toc service industry
 
Theory of Constraint
Theory of ConstraintTheory of Constraint
Theory of Constraint
 
Theory of constraints
Theory of constraintsTheory of constraints
Theory of constraints
 
Flow for agile testing - lssc11 proceedings
Flow for agile testing - lssc11 proceedingsFlow for agile testing - lssc11 proceedings
Flow for agile testing - lssc11 proceedings
 
Leadership and System Change Using Lab Based Techniques
Leadership and System Change Using Lab Based TechniquesLeadership and System Change Using Lab Based Techniques
Leadership and System Change Using Lab Based Techniques
 
Reviewing a Developer Experience
Reviewing a Developer ExperienceReviewing a Developer Experience
Reviewing a Developer Experience
 
Session 3_TOC.pptx in theory if constraints
Session 3_TOC.pptx in theory if constraintsSession 3_TOC.pptx in theory if constraints
Session 3_TOC.pptx in theory if constraints
 
Theory of constraints
Theory of constraintsTheory of constraints
Theory of constraints
 
Unconstrained Benefits Assignment
Unconstrained Benefits AssignmentUnconstrained Benefits Assignment
Unconstrained Benefits Assignment
 
Theory of Constraints
Theory of ConstraintsTheory of Constraints
Theory of Constraints
 
A p r i l 2 0 0 5 I S T R AT E G I C F I N A N C E 5 1A.docx
A p r i l  2 0 0 5 I S T R AT E G I C  F I N A N C E 5 1A.docxA p r i l  2 0 0 5 I S T R AT E G I C  F I N A N C E 5 1A.docx
A p r i l 2 0 0 5 I S T R AT E G I C F I N A N C E 5 1A.docx
 
Toc Sample
Toc SampleToc Sample
Toc Sample
 

Plus de Versli Lietuva (Enterprise Lithuania)

UPS įgaliotosios atstovės Lietuvoje UAB „Skubios siuntos“ vadovai, „10 prakti...
UPS įgaliotosios atstovės Lietuvoje UAB „Skubios siuntos“ vadovai, „10 prakti...UPS įgaliotosios atstovės Lietuvoje UAB „Skubios siuntos“ vadovai, „10 prakti...
UPS įgaliotosios atstovės Lietuvoje UAB „Skubios siuntos“ vadovai, „10 prakti...Versli Lietuva (Enterprise Lithuania)
 
Audrius Matiukas, personalo konsultacijų bendrovės „PRIMUM ESSE“ konsultantas...
Audrius Matiukas, personalo konsultacijų bendrovės „PRIMUM ESSE“ konsultantas...Audrius Matiukas, personalo konsultacijų bendrovės „PRIMUM ESSE“ konsultantas...
Audrius Matiukas, personalo konsultacijų bendrovės „PRIMUM ESSE“ konsultantas...Versli Lietuva (Enterprise Lithuania)
 
Edmundas Piesarskas, „PRIMUM ESSE“ konsultantas, „Kultūriniai aspektai ekspor...
Edmundas Piesarskas, „PRIMUM ESSE“ konsultantas, „Kultūriniai aspektai ekspor...Edmundas Piesarskas, „PRIMUM ESSE“ konsultantas, „Kultūriniai aspektai ekspor...
Edmundas Piesarskas, „PRIMUM ESSE“ konsultantas, „Kultūriniai aspektai ekspor...Versli Lietuva (Enterprise Lithuania)
 
Justas Gavėnas, EKT verslo plėtros vadovas, sertifikuotas vadybos konsultanta...
Justas Gavėnas, EKT verslo plėtros vadovas, sertifikuotas vadybos konsultanta...Justas Gavėnas, EKT verslo plėtros vadovas, sertifikuotas vadybos konsultanta...
Justas Gavėnas, EKT verslo plėtros vadovas, sertifikuotas vadybos konsultanta...Versli Lietuva (Enterprise Lithuania)
 
Audrius Matiukas, personalo konsultacijų bendrovės PRIMUM ESSE konsultantas, ...
Audrius Matiukas, personalo konsultacijų bendrovės PRIMUM ESSE konsultantas, ...Audrius Matiukas, personalo konsultacijų bendrovės PRIMUM ESSE konsultantas, ...
Audrius Matiukas, personalo konsultacijų bendrovės PRIMUM ESSE konsultantas, ...Versli Lietuva (Enterprise Lithuania)
 
Rūta Gudmonaitė, personalo konsultacijų bendrovės PRIMUM ESSE konsultantė, „K...
Rūta Gudmonaitė, personalo konsultacijų bendrovės PRIMUM ESSE konsultantė, „K...Rūta Gudmonaitė, personalo konsultacijų bendrovės PRIMUM ESSE konsultantė, „K...
Rūta Gudmonaitė, personalo konsultacijų bendrovės PRIMUM ESSE konsultantė, „K...Versli Lietuva (Enterprise Lithuania)
 
Kristina Biraitė, komercijos atašė Izraelyje, „Maisto produktų eksportas į Iz...
Kristina Biraitė, komercijos atašė Izraelyje, „Maisto produktų eksportas į Iz...Kristina Biraitė, komercijos atašė Izraelyje, „Maisto produktų eksportas į Iz...
Kristina Biraitė, komercijos atašė Izraelyje, „Maisto produktų eksportas į Iz...Versli Lietuva (Enterprise Lithuania)
 
Pascal van Delst, „Phood Consultancy” generalinis direktorius, „Pasaulinės ma...
Pascal van Delst, „Phood Consultancy” generalinis direktorius, „Pasaulinės ma...Pascal van Delst, „Phood Consultancy” generalinis direktorius, „Pasaulinės ma...
Pascal van Delst, „Phood Consultancy” generalinis direktorius, „Pasaulinės ma...Versli Lietuva (Enterprise Lithuania)
 
Pascal van Delst, „Phood Consultancy” generalinis direktorius, „Pasaulinės ma...
Pascal van Delst, „Phood Consultancy” generalinis direktorius, „Pasaulinės ma...Pascal van Delst, „Phood Consultancy” generalinis direktorius, „Pasaulinės ma...
Pascal van Delst, „Phood Consultancy” generalinis direktorius, „Pasaulinės ma...Versli Lietuva (Enterprise Lithuania)
 
Sigitas Šlepavičius, Branduolinės saugos departamento direktorius, Valstybinė...
Sigitas Šlepavičius, Branduolinės saugos departamento direktorius, Valstybinė...Sigitas Šlepavičius, Branduolinės saugos departamento direktorius, Valstybinė...
Sigitas Šlepavičius, Branduolinės saugos departamento direktorius, Valstybinė...Versli Lietuva (Enterprise Lithuania)
 
Sigitas Baltuška, UAB „Visagino atominė elektrinė“ išorinių reikalų direktori...
Sigitas Baltuška, UAB „Visagino atominė elektrinė“ išorinių reikalų direktori...Sigitas Baltuška, UAB „Visagino atominė elektrinė“ išorinių reikalų direktori...
Sigitas Baltuška, UAB „Visagino atominė elektrinė“ išorinių reikalų direktori...Versli Lietuva (Enterprise Lithuania)
 
Purje Juha, Inspecta Tarkastus (Suomija), „Visagino VAE projektas. Techniniai...
Purje Juha, Inspecta Tarkastus (Suomija), „Visagino VAE projektas. Techniniai...Purje Juha, Inspecta Tarkastus (Suomija), „Visagino VAE projektas. Techniniai...
Purje Juha, Inspecta Tarkastus (Suomija), „Visagino VAE projektas. Techniniai...Versli Lietuva (Enterprise Lithuania)
 
Mikael Kuokkkanen, Inspecta Nuclear (Švedija), „Visagino VAE projektas. Techn...
Mikael Kuokkkanen, Inspecta Nuclear (Švedija), „Visagino VAE projektas. Techn...Mikael Kuokkkanen, Inspecta Nuclear (Švedija), „Visagino VAE projektas. Techn...
Mikael Kuokkkanen, Inspecta Nuclear (Švedija), „Visagino VAE projektas. Techn...Versli Lietuva (Enterprise Lithuania)
 
Jukka Hellgren, Culmentor Oy vadovas (Suomija), „Suomijos įmonių dalyvavimas ...
Jukka Hellgren, Culmentor Oy vadovas (Suomija), „Suomijos įmonių dalyvavimas ...Jukka Hellgren, Culmentor Oy vadovas (Suomija), „Suomijos įmonių dalyvavimas ...
Jukka Hellgren, Culmentor Oy vadovas (Suomija), „Suomijos įmonių dalyvavimas ...Versli Lietuva (Enterprise Lithuania)
 
Asta Augutytė, advokatų kontoros „Raidla Lejins & Norcous“ asocijuota teisini...
Asta Augutytė, advokatų kontoros „Raidla Lejins & Norcous“ asocijuota teisini...Asta Augutytė, advokatų kontoros „Raidla Lejins & Norcous“ asocijuota teisini...
Asta Augutytė, advokatų kontoros „Raidla Lejins & Norcous“ asocijuota teisini...Versli Lietuva (Enterprise Lithuania)
 
Purje Juha, Inspecta Tarkastus (Suomija), „Visagino VAE projektas. Techniniai...
Purje Juha, Inspecta Tarkastus (Suomija), „Visagino VAE projektas. Techniniai...Purje Juha, Inspecta Tarkastus (Suomija), „Visagino VAE projektas. Techniniai...
Purje Juha, Inspecta Tarkastus (Suomija), „Visagino VAE projektas. Techniniai...Versli Lietuva (Enterprise Lithuania)
 
Anderson Matti, FinNuclear asociacijos pirmininko pavaduotojas (Suomija), „Pr...
Anderson Matti, FinNuclear asociacijos pirmininko pavaduotojas (Suomija), „Pr...Anderson Matti, FinNuclear asociacijos pirmininko pavaduotojas (Suomija), „Pr...
Anderson Matti, FinNuclear asociacijos pirmininko pavaduotojas (Suomija), „Pr...Versli Lietuva (Enterprise Lithuania)
 
Andersson Matti, Dekra Industrial Oy vadovas (Suomija), „Patirtis Olkiluoto 3...
Andersson Matti, Dekra Industrial Oy vadovas (Suomija), „Patirtis Olkiluoto 3...Andersson Matti, Dekra Industrial Oy vadovas (Suomija), „Patirtis Olkiluoto 3...
Andersson Matti, Dekra Industrial Oy vadovas (Suomija), „Patirtis Olkiluoto 3...Versli Lietuva (Enterprise Lithuania)
 

Plus de Versli Lietuva (Enterprise Lithuania) (20)

NVS šalių tendencijos prekybos segmente
NVS šalių tendencijos prekybos segmenteNVS šalių tendencijos prekybos segmente
NVS šalių tendencijos prekybos segmente
 
UPS įgaliotosios atstovės Lietuvoje UAB „Skubios siuntos“ vadovai, „10 prakti...
UPS įgaliotosios atstovės Lietuvoje UAB „Skubios siuntos“ vadovai, „10 prakti...UPS įgaliotosios atstovės Lietuvoje UAB „Skubios siuntos“ vadovai, „10 prakti...
UPS įgaliotosios atstovės Lietuvoje UAB „Skubios siuntos“ vadovai, „10 prakti...
 
Leidinys "Aš pradedu verslą"
Leidinys "Aš pradedu verslą"Leidinys "Aš pradedu verslą"
Leidinys "Aš pradedu verslą"
 
Audrius Matiukas, personalo konsultacijų bendrovės „PRIMUM ESSE“ konsultantas...
Audrius Matiukas, personalo konsultacijų bendrovės „PRIMUM ESSE“ konsultantas...Audrius Matiukas, personalo konsultacijų bendrovės „PRIMUM ESSE“ konsultantas...
Audrius Matiukas, personalo konsultacijų bendrovės „PRIMUM ESSE“ konsultantas...
 
Edmundas Piesarskas, „PRIMUM ESSE“ konsultantas, „Kultūriniai aspektai ekspor...
Edmundas Piesarskas, „PRIMUM ESSE“ konsultantas, „Kultūriniai aspektai ekspor...Edmundas Piesarskas, „PRIMUM ESSE“ konsultantas, „Kultūriniai aspektai ekspor...
Edmundas Piesarskas, „PRIMUM ESSE“ konsultantas, „Kultūriniai aspektai ekspor...
 
Justas Gavėnas, EKT verslo plėtros vadovas, sertifikuotas vadybos konsultanta...
Justas Gavėnas, EKT verslo plėtros vadovas, sertifikuotas vadybos konsultanta...Justas Gavėnas, EKT verslo plėtros vadovas, sertifikuotas vadybos konsultanta...
Justas Gavėnas, EKT verslo plėtros vadovas, sertifikuotas vadybos konsultanta...
 
Audrius Matiukas, personalo konsultacijų bendrovės PRIMUM ESSE konsultantas, ...
Audrius Matiukas, personalo konsultacijų bendrovės PRIMUM ESSE konsultantas, ...Audrius Matiukas, personalo konsultacijų bendrovės PRIMUM ESSE konsultantas, ...
Audrius Matiukas, personalo konsultacijų bendrovės PRIMUM ESSE konsultantas, ...
 
Rūta Gudmonaitė, personalo konsultacijų bendrovės PRIMUM ESSE konsultantė, „K...
Rūta Gudmonaitė, personalo konsultacijų bendrovės PRIMUM ESSE konsultantė, „K...Rūta Gudmonaitė, personalo konsultacijų bendrovės PRIMUM ESSE konsultantė, „K...
Rūta Gudmonaitė, personalo konsultacijų bendrovės PRIMUM ESSE konsultantė, „K...
 
Kristina Biraitė, komercijos atašė Izraelyje, „Maisto produktų eksportas į Iz...
Kristina Biraitė, komercijos atašė Izraelyje, „Maisto produktų eksportas į Iz...Kristina Biraitė, komercijos atašė Izraelyje, „Maisto produktų eksportas į Iz...
Kristina Biraitė, komercijos atašė Izraelyje, „Maisto produktų eksportas į Iz...
 
Pascal van Delst, „Phood Consultancy” generalinis direktorius, „Pasaulinės ma...
Pascal van Delst, „Phood Consultancy” generalinis direktorius, „Pasaulinės ma...Pascal van Delst, „Phood Consultancy” generalinis direktorius, „Pasaulinės ma...
Pascal van Delst, „Phood Consultancy” generalinis direktorius, „Pasaulinės ma...
 
Pascal van Delst, „Phood Consultancy” generalinis direktorius, „Pasaulinės ma...
Pascal van Delst, „Phood Consultancy” generalinis direktorius, „Pasaulinės ma...Pascal van Delst, „Phood Consultancy” generalinis direktorius, „Pasaulinės ma...
Pascal van Delst, „Phood Consultancy” generalinis direktorius, „Pasaulinės ma...
 
Sigitas Šlepavičius, Branduolinės saugos departamento direktorius, Valstybinė...
Sigitas Šlepavičius, Branduolinės saugos departamento direktorius, Valstybinė...Sigitas Šlepavičius, Branduolinės saugos departamento direktorius, Valstybinė...
Sigitas Šlepavičius, Branduolinės saugos departamento direktorius, Valstybinė...
 
Sigitas Baltuška, UAB „Visagino atominė elektrinė“ išorinių reikalų direktori...
Sigitas Baltuška, UAB „Visagino atominė elektrinė“ išorinių reikalų direktori...Sigitas Baltuška, UAB „Visagino atominė elektrinė“ išorinių reikalų direktori...
Sigitas Baltuška, UAB „Visagino atominė elektrinė“ išorinių reikalų direktori...
 
Purje Juha, Inspecta Tarkastus (Suomija), „Visagino VAE projektas. Techniniai...
Purje Juha, Inspecta Tarkastus (Suomija), „Visagino VAE projektas. Techniniai...Purje Juha, Inspecta Tarkastus (Suomija), „Visagino VAE projektas. Techniniai...
Purje Juha, Inspecta Tarkastus (Suomija), „Visagino VAE projektas. Techniniai...
 
Mikael Kuokkkanen, Inspecta Nuclear (Švedija), „Visagino VAE projektas. Techn...
Mikael Kuokkkanen, Inspecta Nuclear (Švedija), „Visagino VAE projektas. Techn...Mikael Kuokkkanen, Inspecta Nuclear (Švedija), „Visagino VAE projektas. Techn...
Mikael Kuokkkanen, Inspecta Nuclear (Švedija), „Visagino VAE projektas. Techn...
 
Jukka Hellgren, Culmentor Oy vadovas (Suomija), „Suomijos įmonių dalyvavimas ...
Jukka Hellgren, Culmentor Oy vadovas (Suomija), „Suomijos įmonių dalyvavimas ...Jukka Hellgren, Culmentor Oy vadovas (Suomija), „Suomijos įmonių dalyvavimas ...
Jukka Hellgren, Culmentor Oy vadovas (Suomija), „Suomijos įmonių dalyvavimas ...
 
Asta Augutytė, advokatų kontoros „Raidla Lejins & Norcous“ asocijuota teisini...
Asta Augutytė, advokatų kontoros „Raidla Lejins & Norcous“ asocijuota teisini...Asta Augutytė, advokatų kontoros „Raidla Lejins & Norcous“ asocijuota teisini...
Asta Augutytė, advokatų kontoros „Raidla Lejins & Norcous“ asocijuota teisini...
 
Purje Juha, Inspecta Tarkastus (Suomija), „Visagino VAE projektas. Techniniai...
Purje Juha, Inspecta Tarkastus (Suomija), „Visagino VAE projektas. Techniniai...Purje Juha, Inspecta Tarkastus (Suomija), „Visagino VAE projektas. Techniniai...
Purje Juha, Inspecta Tarkastus (Suomija), „Visagino VAE projektas. Techniniai...
 
Anderson Matti, FinNuclear asociacijos pirmininko pavaduotojas (Suomija), „Pr...
Anderson Matti, FinNuclear asociacijos pirmininko pavaduotojas (Suomija), „Pr...Anderson Matti, FinNuclear asociacijos pirmininko pavaduotojas (Suomija), „Pr...
Anderson Matti, FinNuclear asociacijos pirmininko pavaduotojas (Suomija), „Pr...
 
Andersson Matti, Dekra Industrial Oy vadovas (Suomija), „Patirtis Olkiluoto 3...
Andersson Matti, Dekra Industrial Oy vadovas (Suomija), „Patirtis Olkiluoto 3...Andersson Matti, Dekra Industrial Oy vadovas (Suomija), „Patirtis Olkiluoto 3...
Andersson Matti, Dekra Industrial Oy vadovas (Suomija), „Patirtis Olkiluoto 3...
 

Dernier

BEST ✨ Call Girls In Indirapuram Ghaziabad ✔️ 9871031762 ✔️ Escorts Service...
BEST ✨ Call Girls In  Indirapuram Ghaziabad  ✔️ 9871031762 ✔️ Escorts Service...BEST ✨ Call Girls In  Indirapuram Ghaziabad  ✔️ 9871031762 ✔️ Escorts Service...
BEST ✨ Call Girls In Indirapuram Ghaziabad ✔️ 9871031762 ✔️ Escorts Service...noida100girls
 
0183760ssssssssssssssssssssssssssss00101011 (27).pdf
0183760ssssssssssssssssssssssssssss00101011 (27).pdf0183760ssssssssssssssssssssssssssss00101011 (27).pdf
0183760ssssssssssssssssssssssssssss00101011 (27).pdfRenandantas16
 
The CMO Survey - Highlights and Insights Report - Spring 2024
The CMO Survey - Highlights and Insights Report - Spring 2024The CMO Survey - Highlights and Insights Report - Spring 2024
The CMO Survey - Highlights and Insights Report - Spring 2024christinemoorman
 
It will be International Nurses' Day on 12 May
It will be International Nurses' Day on 12 MayIt will be International Nurses' Day on 12 May
It will be International Nurses' Day on 12 MayNZSG
 
VIP Call Girls In Saharaganj ( Lucknow ) 🔝 8923113531 🔝 Cash Payment (COD) 👒
VIP Call Girls In Saharaganj ( Lucknow  ) 🔝 8923113531 🔝  Cash Payment (COD) 👒VIP Call Girls In Saharaganj ( Lucknow  ) 🔝 8923113531 🔝  Cash Payment (COD) 👒
VIP Call Girls In Saharaganj ( Lucknow ) 🔝 8923113531 🔝 Cash Payment (COD) 👒anilsa9823
 
Best VIP Call Girls Noida Sector 40 Call Me: 8448380779
Best VIP Call Girls Noida Sector 40 Call Me: 8448380779Best VIP Call Girls Noida Sector 40 Call Me: 8448380779
Best VIP Call Girls Noida Sector 40 Call Me: 8448380779Delhi Call girls
 
Creating Low-Code Loan Applications using the Trisotech Mortgage Feature Set
Creating Low-Code Loan Applications using the Trisotech Mortgage Feature SetCreating Low-Code Loan Applications using the Trisotech Mortgage Feature Set
Creating Low-Code Loan Applications using the Trisotech Mortgage Feature SetDenis Gagné
 
Call Girls Navi Mumbai Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Avail...
Call Girls Navi Mumbai Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Avail...Call Girls Navi Mumbai Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Avail...
Call Girls Navi Mumbai Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Avail...Dipal Arora
 
RE Capital's Visionary Leadership under Newman Leech
RE Capital's Visionary Leadership under Newman LeechRE Capital's Visionary Leadership under Newman Leech
RE Capital's Visionary Leadership under Newman LeechNewman George Leech
 
Regression analysis: Simple Linear Regression Multiple Linear Regression
Regression analysis:  Simple Linear Regression Multiple Linear RegressionRegression analysis:  Simple Linear Regression Multiple Linear Regression
Regression analysis: Simple Linear Regression Multiple Linear RegressionRavindra Nath Shukla
 
DEPED Work From Home WORKWEEK-PLAN.docx
DEPED Work From Home  WORKWEEK-PLAN.docxDEPED Work From Home  WORKWEEK-PLAN.docx
DEPED Work From Home WORKWEEK-PLAN.docxRodelinaLaud
 
Vip Dewas Call Girls #9907093804 Contact Number Escorts Service Dewas
Vip Dewas Call Girls #9907093804 Contact Number Escorts Service DewasVip Dewas Call Girls #9907093804 Contact Number Escorts Service Dewas
Vip Dewas Call Girls #9907093804 Contact Number Escorts Service Dewasmakika9823
 
Call Girls Pune Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Pune Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service AvailableCall Girls Pune Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Pune Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service AvailableDipal Arora
 
Ensure the security of your HCL environment by applying the Zero Trust princi...
Ensure the security of your HCL environment by applying the Zero Trust princi...Ensure the security of your HCL environment by applying the Zero Trust princi...
Ensure the security of your HCL environment by applying the Zero Trust princi...Roland Driesen
 
Yaroslav Rozhankivskyy: Три складові і три передумови максимальної продуктивн...
Yaroslav Rozhankivskyy: Три складові і три передумови максимальної продуктивн...Yaroslav Rozhankivskyy: Три складові і три передумови максимальної продуктивн...
Yaroslav Rozhankivskyy: Три складові і три передумови максимальної продуктивн...Lviv Startup Club
 
Keppel Ltd. 1Q 2024 Business Update Presentation Slides
Keppel Ltd. 1Q 2024 Business Update  Presentation SlidesKeppel Ltd. 1Q 2024 Business Update  Presentation Slides
Keppel Ltd. 1Q 2024 Business Update Presentation SlidesKeppelCorporation
 
Grateful 7 speech thanking everyone that has helped.pdf
Grateful 7 speech thanking everyone that has helped.pdfGrateful 7 speech thanking everyone that has helped.pdf
Grateful 7 speech thanking everyone that has helped.pdfPaul Menig
 
The Coffee Bean & Tea Leaf(CBTL), Business strategy case study
The Coffee Bean & Tea Leaf(CBTL), Business strategy case studyThe Coffee Bean & Tea Leaf(CBTL), Business strategy case study
The Coffee Bean & Tea Leaf(CBTL), Business strategy case studyEthan lee
 

Dernier (20)

BEST ✨ Call Girls In Indirapuram Ghaziabad ✔️ 9871031762 ✔️ Escorts Service...
BEST ✨ Call Girls In  Indirapuram Ghaziabad  ✔️ 9871031762 ✔️ Escorts Service...BEST ✨ Call Girls In  Indirapuram Ghaziabad  ✔️ 9871031762 ✔️ Escorts Service...
BEST ✨ Call Girls In Indirapuram Ghaziabad ✔️ 9871031762 ✔️ Escorts Service...
 
Best Practices for Implementing an External Recruiting Partnership
Best Practices for Implementing an External Recruiting PartnershipBest Practices for Implementing an External Recruiting Partnership
Best Practices for Implementing an External Recruiting Partnership
 
0183760ssssssssssssssssssssssssssss00101011 (27).pdf
0183760ssssssssssssssssssssssssssss00101011 (27).pdf0183760ssssssssssssssssssssssssssss00101011 (27).pdf
0183760ssssssssssssssssssssssssssss00101011 (27).pdf
 
The CMO Survey - Highlights and Insights Report - Spring 2024
The CMO Survey - Highlights and Insights Report - Spring 2024The CMO Survey - Highlights and Insights Report - Spring 2024
The CMO Survey - Highlights and Insights Report - Spring 2024
 
It will be International Nurses' Day on 12 May
It will be International Nurses' Day on 12 MayIt will be International Nurses' Day on 12 May
It will be International Nurses' Day on 12 May
 
VIP Call Girls In Saharaganj ( Lucknow ) 🔝 8923113531 🔝 Cash Payment (COD) 👒
VIP Call Girls In Saharaganj ( Lucknow  ) 🔝 8923113531 🔝  Cash Payment (COD) 👒VIP Call Girls In Saharaganj ( Lucknow  ) 🔝 8923113531 🔝  Cash Payment (COD) 👒
VIP Call Girls In Saharaganj ( Lucknow ) 🔝 8923113531 🔝 Cash Payment (COD) 👒
 
Best VIP Call Girls Noida Sector 40 Call Me: 8448380779
Best VIP Call Girls Noida Sector 40 Call Me: 8448380779Best VIP Call Girls Noida Sector 40 Call Me: 8448380779
Best VIP Call Girls Noida Sector 40 Call Me: 8448380779
 
Creating Low-Code Loan Applications using the Trisotech Mortgage Feature Set
Creating Low-Code Loan Applications using the Trisotech Mortgage Feature SetCreating Low-Code Loan Applications using the Trisotech Mortgage Feature Set
Creating Low-Code Loan Applications using the Trisotech Mortgage Feature Set
 
Call Girls Navi Mumbai Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Avail...
Call Girls Navi Mumbai Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Avail...Call Girls Navi Mumbai Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Avail...
Call Girls Navi Mumbai Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Avail...
 
RE Capital's Visionary Leadership under Newman Leech
RE Capital's Visionary Leadership under Newman LeechRE Capital's Visionary Leadership under Newman Leech
RE Capital's Visionary Leadership under Newman Leech
 
Regression analysis: Simple Linear Regression Multiple Linear Regression
Regression analysis:  Simple Linear Regression Multiple Linear RegressionRegression analysis:  Simple Linear Regression Multiple Linear Regression
Regression analysis: Simple Linear Regression Multiple Linear Regression
 
DEPED Work From Home WORKWEEK-PLAN.docx
DEPED Work From Home  WORKWEEK-PLAN.docxDEPED Work From Home  WORKWEEK-PLAN.docx
DEPED Work From Home WORKWEEK-PLAN.docx
 
Vip Dewas Call Girls #9907093804 Contact Number Escorts Service Dewas
Vip Dewas Call Girls #9907093804 Contact Number Escorts Service DewasVip Dewas Call Girls #9907093804 Contact Number Escorts Service Dewas
Vip Dewas Call Girls #9907093804 Contact Number Escorts Service Dewas
 
Call Girls Pune Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Pune Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service AvailableCall Girls Pune Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Pune Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
 
Ensure the security of your HCL environment by applying the Zero Trust princi...
Ensure the security of your HCL environment by applying the Zero Trust princi...Ensure the security of your HCL environment by applying the Zero Trust princi...
Ensure the security of your HCL environment by applying the Zero Trust princi...
 
Yaroslav Rozhankivskyy: Три складові і три передумови максимальної продуктивн...
Yaroslav Rozhankivskyy: Три складові і три передумови максимальної продуктивн...Yaroslav Rozhankivskyy: Три складові і три передумови максимальної продуктивн...
Yaroslav Rozhankivskyy: Три складові і три передумови максимальної продуктивн...
 
Keppel Ltd. 1Q 2024 Business Update Presentation Slides
Keppel Ltd. 1Q 2024 Business Update  Presentation SlidesKeppel Ltd. 1Q 2024 Business Update  Presentation Slides
Keppel Ltd. 1Q 2024 Business Update Presentation Slides
 
Grateful 7 speech thanking everyone that has helped.pdf
Grateful 7 speech thanking everyone that has helped.pdfGrateful 7 speech thanking everyone that has helped.pdf
Grateful 7 speech thanking everyone that has helped.pdf
 
Forklift Operations: Safety through Cartoons
Forklift Operations: Safety through CartoonsForklift Operations: Safety through Cartoons
Forklift Operations: Safety through Cartoons
 
The Coffee Bean & Tea Leaf(CBTL), Business strategy case study
The Coffee Bean & Tea Leaf(CBTL), Business strategy case studyThe Coffee Bean & Tea Leaf(CBTL), Business strategy case study
The Coffee Bean & Tea Leaf(CBTL), Business strategy case study
 

How to better exploit (not waste) a company’s scarcest resource Management Attention

  • 1. How to better exploit (not waste) a company’s scarcest resource Management Attention Dr. Alan Barnard CEO, Goldratt Research Labs 23rd October, 2013
  • 2. IMPROVEMENT CHALLENGES What makes improving productivity so difficult… Challenge 1: Achieving Growth AND Stability and Harmony Stakeholder’s Conflict Growth Satisfy Growth in Demand Disharmony Be Successful Maintain Stability / Harmony GOAL PERFORMANCE Pressure to Change Constraint Stability Harmony Pressure to Not Change What Next? Decay Past Now Future TACTICS STRATEGIES TIME Challenge 2: Ensuring every Local Change = System Improvement   WHY? How can Goldratt’s Theory of Constraints help overcome these challenges? © Goldratt Research Labs, 2013 Slide 2
  • 3. Presentation outline 1. What is Theory of Constraints (TOC)? • TOC’s Five Focusing Steps (5FS) • TOC’s Throughput Accounting (TA) 2. Using TOC to measure and improve Management Productivity 3. Using TOC to measure and improve Operational Productivity 4. Case Studies 5. Q&A © Goldratt Research Labs, 2013 Slide 3
  • 4. Part 1 What is Theory of Constraints? Knowing What to Change…and What NOT © Goldratt Research Labs, 2013 Slide 4
  • 5. What is Theory of Constraints? Dr. Eli Goldratt (1947-2011) said that we can summarize Theory of Constraints with a single word... FOCUS However, FOCUS do not only mean knowing what we should DO, but as importantly, what we should NOT DO… because… Focusing on everything is synonymous with not focusing on anything. 1984 1986 1990 1994 1997 1999 2000 © Goldratt Research Labs, 2013 2009 2010 Slide 5 2010
  • 6. WHAT IS THEORY OF CONSTRAINTS? Knowing “WHAT TO CHANGE” - The 5 Focusing Steps of TOC… “A chain is only as strong as its weakest link” Step 0: Agree on the System GOAL Step 1: IDENTIFY the System Constraint (WEAKEST LINK) Step 2: Decide how to better EXPLOIT (not Waste) the System Constraint Step 3: SUBORDINATE everything to the above decision (CHANGE only those RULES – policies & measurements in conflict with decision on how to better exploit/not waste system constraint) Step 4: ELEVATE the Constraint (get more of it) Step 5: WARNING!!!! If in a previous step the constraint has moved, GO BACK to Step 1, - do not let inertia become the constraint. (However, try not to reach Step 5 else you have to change rules) Supply Step 1 IDENTIFY the Constraint 15/hr 12/hr 12/hr 10/hr Step 3 Step 2 SUBORDINATE Decide How to EXPLOIT the constraint everything to this decision GOAL  EXPLOIT potential for more Goal Units PROTECT current level of Constraint Exploitation ↓ Overproduction / Multiitasking ↓ Rework ↓ Starvation/Blockage ↓ Setups/Downtime Current level of Constraint Exploitation + VE + VE Change - VE GOAL  New Constraint Exploitation Rules Demand Step 4 Elevate the Constraint GOAL  + VE Protective Capacity New level of Constraint Exploitation + VE Change NOT - VE Elevate NOT - VE 13/hr - VE GOAL  New Constraint Elevation Rules Step 5 If a constraint has been broken, Go back to Step 1 © Goldratt Research Labs, 2013 Slide 6
  • 7. GOLDRATT’S DICE GAME Why is the Throughput of systems well below their bottleneck capacity? The Dice Game – Insights A B C D Expected = 70 upm Actual = 35 upm (around 50%) E Min 1 U/day Min 1 U/day Min 1 U/day Min 1 U/day Min 1 U/day Min ? U/hr Avg 3.5 U/day Avg 3.5 U/day Avg 3.5 U/day Avg 3.5 U/day Avg 3.5 U/day Avg ? U/hr Max 6 U/day Max 6 U/day Max 6 U/day Max 6 U/day Max 6 U/day Max ? U/hr Important Lessons Learned: 1. System Output is normally significantly below Output of the Bottleneck 2. “Balancing Capacities” (to be efficient) creates a chaotic system – i.e. its impossible to reliably predict performance and very difficult to know where to focus… 3. We need to balance the FLOW …not Capacities…which requires Buffers + Protective Capacity in non-bottleneck processes…but will this not cost too much / take too long? © Goldratt Research Labs, 2013 Slide 7
  • 8. WHAT IS THEORY OF CONSTRAINTS? Why is the Throughput of systems well below their bottleneck capacity? The Dice Game – Insights A B C D Expected = 60 upm Actual = 58 upm (around 97%) E Min 1 U/day Min 1 U/day Min 1 U/day Min 1 U/day Min 1 U/day Min ? U/hr Avg 3.5 U/day Avg 3.5 U/day Avg 3 U/day Avg 3.5 U/day Avg 3.5 U/day Avg ? U/hr Max 6 U/day Max 6 U/day Max 5 U/day Max 6 U/day Max 6 U/day Max ? U/hr Important Lessons Learned: 1. By slowing down the Bottleneck, we can create Protective Capacity in non-bottlenecks to reduce starvation and blockage of the Bottleneck. 2. If the Starvation and Blockage buffers work 100% effectively, the system performance will be equal to the bottleneck performance (and be very predictable). 3. Starvation and Blockage buffers should be dynamically adjusted based on actual supply reliability and demand variation (Too much Red = Too small  Increase ; Too little Red = Too large Reduce) . © Goldratt Research Labs, 2013 Slide 8
  • 9. © Goldratt Research Labs, 2013 Slide 9
  • 10. WHAT IS THEORY OF CONSTRAINTS? Quantifying the impact of CHANGES – TOC Throughput Accounting To determine the likely GLOBAL impact of any LOCAL Change, Estimate the LOW, LIKELY and HIGH impact of each Change on ΔT, OE and I Sales Revenue (SR) Now US$ % of SR $ 10,000 100% Variable Cost (VC) $ 5,000 50% Throughput (T) Operating Expenses (OE) $ $ 5,000 4,500 50% 45% 0.0% 0.0% $ 5,000 $ 4,500 50% 45% Net Profit (NP) $ 500 5% 0.0% $ 5% Investment (I) $ 2,500 25% 0% Return on Investment (NP/I) % Change in Qty % Change in Price 0.0% 0.0% Future US$ % of SR $10,000 100% 0.0% 0.0% $ 5,000 50% 20% 0% 500 $ 2,500 25% 6 20% Throughput (T) The rate at which the system generates money through Sales or T = Sales Revenue (SR) – Variable Cost (VC) Operating Expenses (OE) The rate at which the system spends money to generate Throughput (or other goal units) i.e. OE = All non-variable costs (also called Fixed Costs) Investment (I) All the money tied up in the system (the money invested to generate Throughput). © Goldratt Research Labs, 2013 Slide 10
  • 11. Part 2 Using TOC to improve Management Productivity What is the bottleneck to improving Management Productivity? © Goldratt Research Labs, 2013 Slide 11
  • 12. WHAT IS THEORY OF CONSTRAINTS? Applying the 5 Focusing Steps to Management Productivity… What is the Constraint or Bottleneck to improving MANAGEMENT Productivity… …needed to achieve more GROWTH, STABILITY and HARMONY? The Bottleneck is always at the TOP of the bottle… © Goldratt Research Labs, 2013 Slide 12
  • 13. Applying TOC’s 5 Focusing Steps to Improving and Managing Organizations Step 1: Identify the System Constraint …to Achieving GROWTH, STABILITY AND HARMONY (within Organizations) Management Information Demand vs. Supply Surplus Required Information to make better faster decisions Available data and Information Management Attention Demand MANY Things that demand OR could benefit from our Attention vs. Supply Shortage Available Attention Management Attention = System Constraint © Goldratt Research Labs, 2013 Slide 13
  • 14. Applying TOC’s 5 Focusing Steps to Improving Management Productivity Step 2: Decide how to EXPLOIT the System Constraint … Identify the things that WASTE our Management Attention… Better Exploiting Management Attention  Supply vs.  Demand HOW? … STOP … REDUCE FOCUS on FEW Things that could really benefit from our limited Attention…and DON’T MULTITASK 3. Repeating Mistakes – not Learning from Experience INCREASE Error of Detection & Correction 2. NOT DOING what we should Error of Omission 1. DOING what we should not Error of Commission Productive use of our Attention How much of your limited MANAGEMENT ATTENTION do you think you WASTE due to mistakes 1, 2 and 3? © Goldratt Research Labs, 2013 Slide 14
  • 15. Quick Self-Assessment Check Make a list of the things that cause you to WASTE your limited attention…. DOING WHAT YOU SHOULD NOT NOT DOING WHAT YOU SHOULD © Goldratt Research Labs, 2013 REPEATING AVOIDABLE MISTAKES (REWORK) Slide 15
  • 16. Why do we say “PAY” attention…? WARNING or pay the price There is a COST and a BENEFIT of PAYING Attention 1. COST – we GIVE UP the benefit of focusing our attention on something or someone else… 2. BENEFIT – we GAIN the benefit of focusing our attention on this thing or this person… What is a common strategy to maximize BENEFIT and minimize COST… We Multitask …we try to give equal attention to the MANY things that demand or can benefit from our attention…….but don’t realize the high PRICE we pay.… © Goldratt Research Labs, 2013 Slide 16
  • 17. Checking Sufficiency… So, are there any other ways that we waste our limited Attention? For example… For the cases where we are DOING WHAT WE SHOULD, is “Multi-tasking” the best way to allocate our limited attention? © Goldratt Research Labs, 2013 Slide 17
  • 18. Dr. Eli Goldratt’s real Legacy Standing on the shoulders of Giants “Finally, and most importantly, I wanted to show that we can all be outstanding scientists. The secret of being a good scientist, I believe, lies not in our brain power. We have enough. We simply need to look at reality and think logically and precisely about what we see.” Dr. Eliyahu M. Goldratt 1948 - 2011 Dr. Goldratt, the creator of Theory of Constraints, said the two key abilities to “being an outstanding scientist” are simply: (STEP1) Have the courage to face inconsistencies between what we (expect to) see and the way things are… and then (STEP 2) Have the wisdom to challenge basic assumption(s) to resolve these inconsistencies. Research Questions • What are the inconsistency regarding how we invest our limited attention to get work done? • What “basic assumption(s)” can and should be challenged to resolve this inconsistency….and how to do this especially if challenging the assumption might be counter-intuitive? © Goldratt Research Labs, 2013 Slide 18
  • 19. Management Productivity Challenge Facing an inconsistency and challenging basic assumption(s) Research Problem Inconsistency: Despite major advances in technology and know-how most change initiatives are still completed late, over-budget and/or under-scope. Research Question Can changing the RULE we use in do work/ project tasks have a significant impact on the lead time, costs and quality (or not)? Research Method • You are giving three projects to complete for your organization. • These three projects together make up a Program but each project is for a different “Customer” and each of these customers want you to finish their project as soon as possible, want you to give them highest priority but is also asking for a “reliable estimate of completion”. • Which RULE should you use to do these projects: RULE 1: Work on all of them at the same time (Multi-task), or RULE 2: Do them one by one…(No Multi-tasking)? © Goldratt Research Labs, 2013 Slide 19
  • 20. Round #1 Complete Tasks by Multi-tasking … A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T 59 sec 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 58 sec 88 – 178 sec 50-200% Longer Δ Ο ☐ Δ Ο ☐ Δ Ο ☐ Δ Ο ☐ Δ Ο ☐ Δ Ο ☐ Δ Ο 60 sec 89 – 179 sec 90 – 180 sec 50-200% longer 50 - 200% longer © Goldratt Research Labs, 2013 Slide 20
  • 21. Round #2 Complete Tasks without Multi-tasking 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 20 sec A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T 40 sec 10 - 20sec Early / On time Δ Ο ☐ Δ Ο ☐ Δ Ο ☐ Δ Ο ☐ Δ Ο ☐ Δ Ο ☐ Δ Ο 60 sec 20 - 40sec 30 - 60 sec Early / On time Early / On time © Goldratt Research Labs, 2013 Slide 21
  • 22. UNDERSTANDING WHY MULTI-TASKING IS SO BAD… Multi-tasking delays project flow …and distracts our attention SCENARIO #1: No Capacity Constraints Project X Project Y Project Z 0 10 20 BASIC ASSUMPTION CHALLENGED “The earlier we start… the earlier we finish” / Its unfair to prioritize VS. “The later we start... the earlier we finish” / Its unfair not to prioritize SCENARIO #2: PLAN - Multi-tasking Project X Project Y Project Z End Earlier? Start Earlier 10 0 20 30 40 50 60 Finish Later 70 80 SCENARIO #2: ACTUAL - Multi-tasking with Distraction Delays Project X LATE FINISH! Project Y Project Z 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 SCENARIO #3: PLAN - No Multitasking Project X Project Y Project Z Start Later 0 10 Finish Earlier 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 SCENARIO #3: ACTUAL - No Multitasking Can safely reduce Project buffer by 50% Project X Project Y Project Z EARLY FINISH 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90
  • 23. ANALYZING POOR PROJECT PERFORMANCE Is it the Starting Conditions…or the Rules WE use… Our Challenge Difficulty to Improve & sustain higher Project Performance Other Consequences… Delays and Mistakes in prediction, detection & correction People at all levels are stressed and overworked Increased Project Work + Wait Time Main Cause… Real Cause…  Complexity, Uncertainty and Resource Constraints Really? Lets check this assumption with Multitasking Game Multitasking at all levels “Local Optima” Rules… Too High WIP Too Detailed Schedules + Not Full Kit + Local Safety Pipelining Lower WIP + TOC Solution Ensure Full Kit CCPM Rule 1 Local Priorities + Measurements Execution Planning Schedules with Aggregated Global Priorities + Tasks + Buffers Buffer Management CCPM Rule 2 CCPM Rule 3 Simple …but not easy… © Goldratt Research Labs, 2013 Slide 23
  • 24. Part 3 Using TOC to improve Operational Productivity Is TOC the same as Debottlenecking? © Goldratt Research Labs, 2013 Slide 24
  • 25. STANDING ON THE SHOULDERS OF GIANTS THE Four Concepts of Flow 1. Improving Flow (specifically reducing Flow Time) is should be the #1 objective for Operations/Supply Chains 2. To reduce Flow Time, we need a Practical Mechanism to Stop Overproduction and maintain right priority – – – Ford: Use Space and Sequence of Launch Ohno: Use Kanbans and Colors to show emergency Kanbans Goldratt: Use Time (Buffers) and Buffer Penetration to ensure same priority everywhere and to focus management attention 3. Abolish all Local Efficiencies / Local Optima 4. Put in place a Focusing Mechanism to continuously improve and re-balance Flow (e.g. Do Pareto on what is causing delays in flow?) Yes, but…. How do we know that FLOWS are not balanced… © Goldratt Research Labs, 2013 Slide 25
  • 26. RISK: DEMAND GROWTH / INSUFFICENT CAPACITY Growth in backlog vs. Decay in Reliability of Supply... Arrivals Departures Resource Linear growth until reaching “Turning the Corner” Point at >80% utilization 0% Resource Utilization 80% Reliability in meeting demand Queue Length/Supply Lead time Growth in Queues & Decay in Reliability vs. Growth in Resource Utilization 100% How can we turn this insight into a GOOD MEASUREMENT SYSTEM…? © Goldratt Research Labs, 2013 Slide 26
  • 27. Balancing FLOWS … not balancing CAPACITY Using Cumulative Flow Diagrams as Early Warnings of Scarcity Cumulative Flow Diagrams Higher WIP WIP Supply Lead Time Time Longer Supply LT Time Higher WIP Longer Supply LT Time LITTLE’s LAW Work-in-Process = Flow Rate x Flow Time WIPavg = FRavg x FTavg If either arrivals (demand) increase or departures (supply) reduce, it causes Supply Lead Time and WIP to grow. • Growth will be exponential if demand grows faster than supply. • Growth will be permanent without sufficient catch-up (protective) capacity… © Goldratt Research Labs, 2013 Slide 27
  • 28. CRITERIA FOR DESIGNING A GOOD MEASUREMENT SYSTEM GOOD MEASUREMENT SYSTEM 1. Accurately measures the STATUS (Ok or not?) and TREND (Improving or Not?)  Know WHEN to act…and When NOT  Mistakes  Type 1 - Reporting we are OK when we are not…and  Type 2 - Reporting we are not OK when we are. 2. Accurately predicts likely CAUSE(S) of the status (i.e. Demand or Supply problem?)  Know WHERE to act …and Where NOT  Mistakes  Type 1 – Reporting something as a major cause when it is not…and  Type 2 – Not Reporting something as a major cause when it was 3. Drives desired / discourages undesired behaviors (what is best for the system)  Know HOW to act…and HOW not  Mistakes  Type 1 - Encouraging an undesirable behaviour (local optima)…and  Type 2 – Not encouraging a desired behavior How well does your company’s measurement system meet these criteria? © Goldratt Research Labs, 2013 Slide 28
  • 29. IMPORTANT GLOBAL MEASUREMENTS Measuring Productivity, Flow and Timeliness GOOD MEASUREMENTS CUMULATIVE FLOW Arrivals (Demand) Cumulative Flow • Cumulative Flow for System and Subsystems • Operational Productivity = $T/$OE or (for Service Depts) = QT/OE • Capital Productivity = $T/$I • Quality can be measured as: % Coverage, % OnTime or % InSpec WIP Longer Flow Time Throughput (Supply) Flow Time • % Protective Capacity Available on CCRs (Capacity Constraint Resource) Time in Days PRODUCTIVITY QUALITY THROUGHPUT 75% of On-time / Coverage Productivity Operational Productivity = $T/$OE or QT/OE 25% Late / Not served 20% 15% Capital Productivity = $T/$I 15% 10% 10% 5% Time in Days 0-5d 5-10d 10-15d © Goldratt Research Labs, 2013 15-20d 20-25d 25-30d 30-35d 35-40d > 40d Slide 29
  • 30. Part 4 Case Study How can we apply the 4 Concepts of flow and insights on the damaging consequences of Multi-tasking to improve Productivity of Managers at all levels? © Goldratt Research Labs, 2013 Slide 30
  • 31. Case Study: Focusing on improving Flow & stopping multi-tasking Every manager can improve the productivity of its department if they can find ways to reduce flow delays and stop multi-tasking The case studies shared will show the impact of improving flow and stopping multi-tasking in different departments within two different companies. Company 1 – Applying it within Sales Department This case study will reveal how the company applied the 4 Concepts to significantly reduce the Average Sales Cycle Time and increase the success rate of their sales Company 2 – Applying it within IT Department This case study will reveal how the company applied the 4 Concepts to significantly improve due date performance and reduce the average Lead time of IT Projects. © Goldratt Research Labs, 2013 Slide 31
  • 32. CASE STUDY 1 – LESS IS MORE Applying four FLOW concepts to Sales Department 1. IMPROVING FLOW IS #1 - Faster Flow of “good” (higher Throughput margin and higher probability of closing deal) sales opportunities through the sales channel should be the #1 objective because any flow delays cause longer sales cycles, lower hit rate & margins. 2. MECHANISM TO PREVENT OVERPRODUCTION & SYNCHRONIZE PRIORITIES - “Choke the release” by ensuring whole Sales Teams focus on “well qualified sales opportunities”– Less is More because too High WIP causes Multi-tasking that cause bottlenecks, longer sales cycles and lower hit rate …so more pressure to go get even more(vicious cycle) 3. ABOLISH LOCAL OPTIMA – Abolish any incentives or measurements that drive behavior that is in conflict with better flow (e.g. number of opportunities in pipeline) 4. FOCUSING MECHANISM – Identify and eliminate the most significant sources of low hit ratio and or long sales cycles to focus continuous improvement efforts - check for build-up of WIP in sales process steps and record and analyze reasons for delay.  30%  47%  263% Reference: Chapter 21 of Theory of Constraints Handbook, Less is more: Applying Flow concepts to Sales by Mauricio Herman and Rami Goldratt © Goldratt Research Labs, 2013 Slide 32
  • 33. CASE STUDY 2 – LESS IS MORE Applying four FLOW concepts to IT Department 1. IMPROVING FLOW IS #1 - Faster Flow of “good” (higher ROI) projects through the Project Office should be the #1 objective because any flow delays cause longer lead times, lower quality and throughput of projects, higher cost & risk and lower ROI 2. MECHANISM TO PREVENT MULTITASKING & SYNCHRONIZE PRIORITIES - “Choke the release” by pipelining projects (prioritize, freeze and stop) as starting projects too soon causes multi-tasking that causes longer wait and work time (longer flow time). 3. ABOLISH LOCAL OPTIMA – Abolish any incentives or measurements that drive behavior that is in conflict with better flow (e.g. no. of projects in pipeline, reporting % complete etc.) 4. FOCUSING MECHANISM – Identify and eliminate the most significant sources of delays on projects and resource bottlenecks to focus continuous improvement efforts check for build-up of WIP at TASK Manager Level (for resource constraints) and record and analyze reasons for most penetrating delays. © Goldratt Research Labs, 2013 Slide 33
  • 34. CLOSING REMARKS Achieving FLOW in Personal productivity… STOP Multi-tasking – get into FLOW © Goldratt Research Labs, 2013 Slide 34
  • 35. Key Take-Aways Management Attention Available Repeating mistakes Doing right things wrong Wasted Not doing the RIGHT Time/Attention things Actual Utilization Doing the WRONG things Productive Time (Adding Value) Not doing the Wrong Things (STOP/NOT START) Doing the Right Things Doing the right things right (ACCELERATE/START) (FOCUS/DONT MULTI-TASK) Learn from Experience (FAST FEEDBACK) REMEMBER….THE BOTTLENECK IS ALWAYS AT THE TOP OF THE BOTTLE © Goldratt Research Labs, 2013 Slide 35
  • 36. THANK YOU FOR YOUR ATTENTION… ….I KNOW IT IS YOUR SCARCEST RESOURCE  GOOD LUCK! © Goldratt Research Labs, 2013 Slide 36
  • 37. Q&A © Goldratt Research Labs, 2013 Slide 37
  • 38. ABOUT THE PRESENTERS Dr. Alan Barnard (PhD) Dr. Alan Barnard is one of the leading experts in the world in Theory of Constraints (TOC) frequently worked with Dr. Eli Goldratt, creator of Theory of Constraints on large and complex projects around the world. He is the CEO of Goldratt Research Labs (USA), Chairman of Realization Africa (RSA), African Phosphates (RSA) and The Odyssey Institute (USA). Alan is also a board member of TOCICO and the Dr. Eliyahu M. Goldratt Foundation. In 2009, Alan was awarded a PhD in Management of Technology & Innovation, from the Da Vinci Institute in 2009 with a thesis titled “How to identify and unlock inherent potential within organizations (private & public) and individuals?”. Alan is also the author of 2 chapters in the McGraw Hill published Theory of Constraints Handbook. Alan is a past-President of SAPICS (2000 to 2002) and past-President of TOCICO (2003 to 2005) and serve on the judging panels of the Logistics Achiever Awards and Technology Top 100. He has worked with global companies such as ABB, BHP, Cisco, SAP, Random House Publishing, Tata in the Private sector and also with UN DP, UN WFP and InWent in the public sector on applying for example Theory of Constraints to City Councils in Developing Countries in the Public Sector to help them identify and unlock inherent potential to achieve more with the same resources in less time. © Goldratt Research Labs, 2013