SlideShare une entreprise Scribd logo
1  sur  8
Télécharger pour lire hors ligne
The EU Copyright Reform
An Update
Dr Eleonora Rosati
26th Fordham IP Conference
New York City, April 5-6 2018
Contents
•  Where are we now?
•  Are we really speaking of ‘compromises’?
•  Towards a DSM? What kind of DSM?
Where are we now?
•  Bulgarian presidency of the Council
– Latest compromise proposal: March 23
– Next presidency: Austria
•  JURI Committee to vote on MEP Voss’s
Report
– Compromise proposals on Arts 11 and 13 so far
– Vote scheduled late April
Are we really speaking of compromises
at this stage?
Towards a DSM? What kind of DSM?
•  Beneficiaries
•  Goals of copyright reform
•  Meanwhile
– ‘Codification’ of CJEU case law
– Forthcoming CJEU cases
eleonora@e-lawnora.com
@eLAWnora
Thanks for your attention

Contenu connexe

Plus de Eleonora Rosati

Should online platforms do more to tackle unlawful content online? (Eleonora ...
Should online platforms do more to tackle unlawful content online? (Eleonora ...Should online platforms do more to tackle unlawful content online? (Eleonora ...
Should online platforms do more to tackle unlawful content online? (Eleonora ...Eleonora Rosati
 
Eleonora Rosati - The Filmspeler CJEU Judgment: Legal Implications for Maker...
Eleonora Rosati - The Filmspeler CJEU Judgment: Legal Implications for Maker...Eleonora Rosati - The Filmspeler CJEU Judgment: Legal Implications for Maker...
Eleonora Rosati - The Filmspeler CJEU Judgment: Legal Implications for Maker...Eleonora Rosati
 
Effects of Brexit on Copyright (Effetti sulla Disciplina del Diritto d'Autore...
Effects of Brexit on Copyright (Effetti sulla Disciplina del Diritto d'Autore...Effects of Brexit on Copyright (Effetti sulla Disciplina del Diritto d'Autore...
Effects of Brexit on Copyright (Effetti sulla Disciplina del Diritto d'Autore...Eleonora Rosati
 
Second-hand markets for digital copies: an EU copyright chimera?
Second-hand markets for digital copies: an EU copyright chimera?Second-hand markets for digital copies: an EU copyright chimera?
Second-hand markets for digital copies: an EU copyright chimera?Eleonora Rosati
 
Digital Single Market and Brexit (Eleonora Rosati)
Digital Single Market and Brexit (Eleonora Rosati)Digital Single Market and Brexit (Eleonora Rosati)
Digital Single Market and Brexit (Eleonora Rosati)Eleonora Rosati
 
Private copying and fair compensation under EU copyright law
Private copying and fair compensation under EU copyright lawPrivate copying and fair compensation under EU copyright law
Private copying and fair compensation under EU copyright lawEleonora Rosati
 
Neighbouring rights for publishers: are national and (possible) EU initiative...
Neighbouring rights for publishers: are national and (possible) EU initiative...Neighbouring rights for publishers: are national and (possible) EU initiative...
Neighbouring rights for publishers: are national and (possible) EU initiative...Eleonora Rosati
 
A decade of (random) copyright reform in Europe (Eleonora Rosati)
A decade of (random) copyright reform in Europe (Eleonora Rosati)A decade of (random) copyright reform in Europe (Eleonora Rosati)
A decade of (random) copyright reform in Europe (Eleonora Rosati)Eleonora Rosati
 
UK Copyright Policy and the Impact of EU-Level Reform: Is There such a Thing?...
UK Copyright Policy and the Impact of EU-Level Reform: Is There such a Thing?...UK Copyright Policy and the Impact of EU-Level Reform: Is There such a Thing?...
UK Copyright Policy and the Impact of EU-Level Reform: Is There such a Thing?...Eleonora Rosati
 
Overview of Recent CJEU Copyright Judgments - ICEL IT Law Conference 2015 (El...
Overview of Recent CJEU Copyright Judgments - ICEL IT Law Conference 2015 (El...Overview of Recent CJEU Copyright Judgments - ICEL IT Law Conference 2015 (El...
Overview of Recent CJEU Copyright Judgments - ICEL IT Law Conference 2015 (El...Eleonora Rosati
 
EU Copyright: Just Like a New IP Lawyer? (Eleonora Rosati)
EU Copyright: Just Like a New IP Lawyer? (Eleonora Rosati)EU Copyright: Just Like a New IP Lawyer? (Eleonora Rosati)
EU Copyright: Just Like a New IP Lawyer? (Eleonora Rosati)Eleonora Rosati
 
EU-Style Fair Use - Eleonora Rosati
EU-Style Fair Use - Eleonora RosatiEU-Style Fair Use - Eleonora Rosati
EU-Style Fair Use - Eleonora RosatiEleonora Rosati
 
Sensory and Sensibility - Will Copyright Awake Your Senses?
Sensory and Sensibility - Will Copyright Awake Your Senses?Sensory and Sensibility - Will Copyright Awake Your Senses?
Sensory and Sensibility - Will Copyright Awake Your Senses?Eleonora Rosati
 
Alberto Bellan - The AGCOM Regulation in Italy
Alberto Bellan - The AGCOM Regulation in ItalyAlberto Bellan - The AGCOM Regulation in Italy
Alberto Bellan - The AGCOM Regulation in ItalyEleonora Rosati
 
Darren Meale - Blocking Injunctions: The Weapon of Choice in the UK?
Darren Meale - Blocking Injunctions: The Weapon of Choice in the UK?Darren Meale - Blocking Injunctions: The Weapon of Choice in the UK?
Darren Meale - Blocking Injunctions: The Weapon of Choice in the UK?Eleonora Rosati
 
Gareth Young - Creating A Global Internet Anti-Piracy Strategy
Gareth Young - Creating A Global Internet Anti-Piracy StrategyGareth Young - Creating A Global Internet Anti-Piracy Strategy
Gareth Young - Creating A Global Internet Anti-Piracy StrategyEleonora Rosati
 
Tom Ohta - Graduated response: what role do private agreements play?
Tom Ohta -  Graduated response: what role do private agreements play? Tom Ohta -  Graduated response: what role do private agreements play?
Tom Ohta - Graduated response: what role do private agreements play? Eleonora Rosati
 
Birgit Clark - ISP Liability through Interference in Germany
Birgit Clark - ISP Liability through Interference in GermanyBirgit Clark - ISP Liability through Interference in Germany
Birgit Clark - ISP Liability through Interference in GermanyEleonora Rosati
 
Alberto Bellan - The AGCOM Regulation in Italy: Nessun dorma
Alberto Bellan - The AGCOM Regulation in Italy: Nessun dormaAlberto Bellan - The AGCOM Regulation in Italy: Nessun dorma
Alberto Bellan - The AGCOM Regulation in Italy: Nessun dormaEleonora Rosati
 
Copyright Enforcement in the EU - Review Plans in the Shade of CJEU Blooming ...
Copyright Enforcement in the EU - Review Plans in the Shade of CJEU Blooming ...Copyright Enforcement in the EU - Review Plans in the Shade of CJEU Blooming ...
Copyright Enforcement in the EU - Review Plans in the Shade of CJEU Blooming ...Eleonora Rosati
 

Plus de Eleonora Rosati (20)

Should online platforms do more to tackle unlawful content online? (Eleonora ...
Should online platforms do more to tackle unlawful content online? (Eleonora ...Should online platforms do more to tackle unlawful content online? (Eleonora ...
Should online platforms do more to tackle unlawful content online? (Eleonora ...
 
Eleonora Rosati - The Filmspeler CJEU Judgment: Legal Implications for Maker...
Eleonora Rosati - The Filmspeler CJEU Judgment: Legal Implications for Maker...Eleonora Rosati - The Filmspeler CJEU Judgment: Legal Implications for Maker...
Eleonora Rosati - The Filmspeler CJEU Judgment: Legal Implications for Maker...
 
Effects of Brexit on Copyright (Effetti sulla Disciplina del Diritto d'Autore...
Effects of Brexit on Copyright (Effetti sulla Disciplina del Diritto d'Autore...Effects of Brexit on Copyright (Effetti sulla Disciplina del Diritto d'Autore...
Effects of Brexit on Copyright (Effetti sulla Disciplina del Diritto d'Autore...
 
Second-hand markets for digital copies: an EU copyright chimera?
Second-hand markets for digital copies: an EU copyright chimera?Second-hand markets for digital copies: an EU copyright chimera?
Second-hand markets for digital copies: an EU copyright chimera?
 
Digital Single Market and Brexit (Eleonora Rosati)
Digital Single Market and Brexit (Eleonora Rosati)Digital Single Market and Brexit (Eleonora Rosati)
Digital Single Market and Brexit (Eleonora Rosati)
 
Private copying and fair compensation under EU copyright law
Private copying and fair compensation under EU copyright lawPrivate copying and fair compensation under EU copyright law
Private copying and fair compensation under EU copyright law
 
Neighbouring rights for publishers: are national and (possible) EU initiative...
Neighbouring rights for publishers: are national and (possible) EU initiative...Neighbouring rights for publishers: are national and (possible) EU initiative...
Neighbouring rights for publishers: are national and (possible) EU initiative...
 
A decade of (random) copyright reform in Europe (Eleonora Rosati)
A decade of (random) copyright reform in Europe (Eleonora Rosati)A decade of (random) copyright reform in Europe (Eleonora Rosati)
A decade of (random) copyright reform in Europe (Eleonora Rosati)
 
UK Copyright Policy and the Impact of EU-Level Reform: Is There such a Thing?...
UK Copyright Policy and the Impact of EU-Level Reform: Is There such a Thing?...UK Copyright Policy and the Impact of EU-Level Reform: Is There such a Thing?...
UK Copyright Policy and the Impact of EU-Level Reform: Is There such a Thing?...
 
Overview of Recent CJEU Copyright Judgments - ICEL IT Law Conference 2015 (El...
Overview of Recent CJEU Copyright Judgments - ICEL IT Law Conference 2015 (El...Overview of Recent CJEU Copyright Judgments - ICEL IT Law Conference 2015 (El...
Overview of Recent CJEU Copyright Judgments - ICEL IT Law Conference 2015 (El...
 
EU Copyright: Just Like a New IP Lawyer? (Eleonora Rosati)
EU Copyright: Just Like a New IP Lawyer? (Eleonora Rosati)EU Copyright: Just Like a New IP Lawyer? (Eleonora Rosati)
EU Copyright: Just Like a New IP Lawyer? (Eleonora Rosati)
 
EU-Style Fair Use - Eleonora Rosati
EU-Style Fair Use - Eleonora RosatiEU-Style Fair Use - Eleonora Rosati
EU-Style Fair Use - Eleonora Rosati
 
Sensory and Sensibility - Will Copyright Awake Your Senses?
Sensory and Sensibility - Will Copyright Awake Your Senses?Sensory and Sensibility - Will Copyright Awake Your Senses?
Sensory and Sensibility - Will Copyright Awake Your Senses?
 
Alberto Bellan - The AGCOM Regulation in Italy
Alberto Bellan - The AGCOM Regulation in ItalyAlberto Bellan - The AGCOM Regulation in Italy
Alberto Bellan - The AGCOM Regulation in Italy
 
Darren Meale - Blocking Injunctions: The Weapon of Choice in the UK?
Darren Meale - Blocking Injunctions: The Weapon of Choice in the UK?Darren Meale - Blocking Injunctions: The Weapon of Choice in the UK?
Darren Meale - Blocking Injunctions: The Weapon of Choice in the UK?
 
Gareth Young - Creating A Global Internet Anti-Piracy Strategy
Gareth Young - Creating A Global Internet Anti-Piracy StrategyGareth Young - Creating A Global Internet Anti-Piracy Strategy
Gareth Young - Creating A Global Internet Anti-Piracy Strategy
 
Tom Ohta - Graduated response: what role do private agreements play?
Tom Ohta -  Graduated response: what role do private agreements play? Tom Ohta -  Graduated response: what role do private agreements play?
Tom Ohta - Graduated response: what role do private agreements play?
 
Birgit Clark - ISP Liability through Interference in Germany
Birgit Clark - ISP Liability through Interference in GermanyBirgit Clark - ISP Liability through Interference in Germany
Birgit Clark - ISP Liability through Interference in Germany
 
Alberto Bellan - The AGCOM Regulation in Italy: Nessun dorma
Alberto Bellan - The AGCOM Regulation in Italy: Nessun dormaAlberto Bellan - The AGCOM Regulation in Italy: Nessun dorma
Alberto Bellan - The AGCOM Regulation in Italy: Nessun dorma
 
Copyright Enforcement in the EU - Review Plans in the Shade of CJEU Blooming ...
Copyright Enforcement in the EU - Review Plans in the Shade of CJEU Blooming ...Copyright Enforcement in the EU - Review Plans in the Shade of CJEU Blooming ...
Copyright Enforcement in the EU - Review Plans in the Shade of CJEU Blooming ...
 

Dernier

A SHORT HISTORY OF LIBERTY'S PROGREE THROUGH HE EIGHTEENTH CENTURY
A SHORT HISTORY OF LIBERTY'S PROGREE THROUGH HE EIGHTEENTH CENTURYA SHORT HISTORY OF LIBERTY'S PROGREE THROUGH HE EIGHTEENTH CENTURY
A SHORT HISTORY OF LIBERTY'S PROGREE THROUGH HE EIGHTEENTH CENTURYJulian Scutts
 
Understanding the Role of Labor Unions and Collective Bargaining
Understanding the Role of Labor Unions and Collective BargainingUnderstanding the Role of Labor Unions and Collective Bargaining
Understanding the Role of Labor Unions and Collective Bargainingbartzlawgroup1
 
Reason Behind the Success of Law Firms in India
Reason Behind the Success of Law Firms in IndiaReason Behind the Success of Law Firms in India
Reason Behind the Success of Law Firms in IndiaYash
 
Sangyun Lee, Duplicate Powers in the Criminal Referral Process and the Overla...
Sangyun Lee, Duplicate Powers in the Criminal Referral Process and the Overla...Sangyun Lee, Duplicate Powers in the Criminal Referral Process and the Overla...
Sangyun Lee, Duplicate Powers in the Criminal Referral Process and the Overla...Sangyun Lee
 
一比一原版(AUT毕业证书)新西兰奥克兰理工大学毕业证如何办理
一比一原版(AUT毕业证书)新西兰奥克兰理工大学毕业证如何办理一比一原版(AUT毕业证书)新西兰奥克兰理工大学毕业证如何办理
一比一原版(AUT毕业证书)新西兰奥克兰理工大学毕业证如何办理e9733fc35af6
 
一比一原版赫尔大学毕业证如何办理
一比一原版赫尔大学毕业证如何办理一比一原版赫尔大学毕业证如何办理
一比一原版赫尔大学毕业证如何办理Airst S
 
一比一原版(UCB毕业证书)英国伯明翰大学学院毕业证如何办理
一比一原版(UCB毕业证书)英国伯明翰大学学院毕业证如何办理一比一原版(UCB毕业证书)英国伯明翰大学学院毕业证如何办理
一比一原版(UCB毕业证书)英国伯明翰大学学院毕业证如何办理e9733fc35af6
 
Types of Agricultural markets LLB- SEM I
Types of Agricultural markets LLB- SEM ITypes of Agricultural markets LLB- SEM I
Types of Agricultural markets LLB- SEM Iyogita9398
 
ASMA JILANI EXPLAINED CASE PLD 1972 FOR CSS
ASMA JILANI EXPLAINED CASE PLD 1972 FOR CSSASMA JILANI EXPLAINED CASE PLD 1972 FOR CSS
ASMA JILANI EXPLAINED CASE PLD 1972 FOR CSSCssSpamx
 
The Main Procedures for a Divorce in Greece
The Main Procedures for a Divorce in GreeceThe Main Procedures for a Divorce in Greece
The Main Procedures for a Divorce in GreeceBridgeWest.eu
 
一比一原版(ECU毕业证书)埃迪斯科文大学毕业证如何办理
一比一原版(ECU毕业证书)埃迪斯科文大学毕业证如何办理一比一原版(ECU毕业证书)埃迪斯科文大学毕业证如何办理
一比一原版(ECU毕业证书)埃迪斯科文大学毕业证如何办理Airst S
 
Philippine FIRE CODE REVIEWER for Architecture Board Exam Takers
Philippine FIRE CODE REVIEWER for Architecture Board Exam TakersPhilippine FIRE CODE REVIEWER for Architecture Board Exam Takers
Philippine FIRE CODE REVIEWER for Architecture Board Exam TakersJillianAsdala
 
Article 12 of the Indian Constitution law
Article 12 of the Indian Constitution lawArticle 12 of the Indian Constitution law
Article 12 of the Indian Constitution lawyogita9398
 
Who is Spencer McDaniel? And Does He Actually Exist?
Who is Spencer McDaniel? And Does He Actually Exist?Who is Spencer McDaniel? And Does He Actually Exist?
Who is Spencer McDaniel? And Does He Actually Exist?Abdul-Hakim Shabazz
 
一比一原版(UNSW毕业证书)新南威尔士大学毕业证如何办理
一比一原版(UNSW毕业证书)新南威尔士大学毕业证如何办理一比一原版(UNSW毕业证书)新南威尔士大学毕业证如何办理
一比一原版(UNSW毕业证书)新南威尔士大学毕业证如何办理ss
 
Code_Ethics of_Mechanical_Engineering.ppt
Code_Ethics of_Mechanical_Engineering.pptCode_Ethics of_Mechanical_Engineering.ppt
Code_Ethics of_Mechanical_Engineering.pptJosephCanama
 
一比一原版伦敦南岸大学毕业证如何办理
一比一原版伦敦南岸大学毕业证如何办理一比一原版伦敦南岸大学毕业证如何办理
一比一原版伦敦南岸大学毕业证如何办理Airst S
 
CASE STYDY Lalman Shukla v Gauri Dutt BY MUKUL TYAGI.pptx
CASE STYDY Lalman Shukla v Gauri Dutt BY MUKUL TYAGI.pptxCASE STYDY Lalman Shukla v Gauri Dutt BY MUKUL TYAGI.pptx
CASE STYDY Lalman Shukla v Gauri Dutt BY MUKUL TYAGI.pptxMUKUL TYAGI
 
一比一原版悉尼科技大学毕业证如何办理
一比一原版悉尼科技大学毕业证如何办理一比一原版悉尼科技大学毕业证如何办理
一比一原版悉尼科技大学毕业证如何办理e9733fc35af6
 

Dernier (20)

A SHORT HISTORY OF LIBERTY'S PROGREE THROUGH HE EIGHTEENTH CENTURY
A SHORT HISTORY OF LIBERTY'S PROGREE THROUGH HE EIGHTEENTH CENTURYA SHORT HISTORY OF LIBERTY'S PROGREE THROUGH HE EIGHTEENTH CENTURY
A SHORT HISTORY OF LIBERTY'S PROGREE THROUGH HE EIGHTEENTH CENTURY
 
It’s Not Easy Being Green: Ethical Pitfalls for Bankruptcy Novices
It’s Not Easy Being Green: Ethical Pitfalls for Bankruptcy NovicesIt’s Not Easy Being Green: Ethical Pitfalls for Bankruptcy Novices
It’s Not Easy Being Green: Ethical Pitfalls for Bankruptcy Novices
 
Understanding the Role of Labor Unions and Collective Bargaining
Understanding the Role of Labor Unions and Collective BargainingUnderstanding the Role of Labor Unions and Collective Bargaining
Understanding the Role of Labor Unions and Collective Bargaining
 
Reason Behind the Success of Law Firms in India
Reason Behind the Success of Law Firms in IndiaReason Behind the Success of Law Firms in India
Reason Behind the Success of Law Firms in India
 
Sangyun Lee, Duplicate Powers in the Criminal Referral Process and the Overla...
Sangyun Lee, Duplicate Powers in the Criminal Referral Process and the Overla...Sangyun Lee, Duplicate Powers in the Criminal Referral Process and the Overla...
Sangyun Lee, Duplicate Powers in the Criminal Referral Process and the Overla...
 
一比一原版(AUT毕业证书)新西兰奥克兰理工大学毕业证如何办理
一比一原版(AUT毕业证书)新西兰奥克兰理工大学毕业证如何办理一比一原版(AUT毕业证书)新西兰奥克兰理工大学毕业证如何办理
一比一原版(AUT毕业证书)新西兰奥克兰理工大学毕业证如何办理
 
一比一原版赫尔大学毕业证如何办理
一比一原版赫尔大学毕业证如何办理一比一原版赫尔大学毕业证如何办理
一比一原版赫尔大学毕业证如何办理
 
一比一原版(UCB毕业证书)英国伯明翰大学学院毕业证如何办理
一比一原版(UCB毕业证书)英国伯明翰大学学院毕业证如何办理一比一原版(UCB毕业证书)英国伯明翰大学学院毕业证如何办理
一比一原版(UCB毕业证书)英国伯明翰大学学院毕业证如何办理
 
Types of Agricultural markets LLB- SEM I
Types of Agricultural markets LLB- SEM ITypes of Agricultural markets LLB- SEM I
Types of Agricultural markets LLB- SEM I
 
ASMA JILANI EXPLAINED CASE PLD 1972 FOR CSS
ASMA JILANI EXPLAINED CASE PLD 1972 FOR CSSASMA JILANI EXPLAINED CASE PLD 1972 FOR CSS
ASMA JILANI EXPLAINED CASE PLD 1972 FOR CSS
 
The Main Procedures for a Divorce in Greece
The Main Procedures for a Divorce in GreeceThe Main Procedures for a Divorce in Greece
The Main Procedures for a Divorce in Greece
 
一比一原版(ECU毕业证书)埃迪斯科文大学毕业证如何办理
一比一原版(ECU毕业证书)埃迪斯科文大学毕业证如何办理一比一原版(ECU毕业证书)埃迪斯科文大学毕业证如何办理
一比一原版(ECU毕业证书)埃迪斯科文大学毕业证如何办理
 
Philippine FIRE CODE REVIEWER for Architecture Board Exam Takers
Philippine FIRE CODE REVIEWER for Architecture Board Exam TakersPhilippine FIRE CODE REVIEWER for Architecture Board Exam Takers
Philippine FIRE CODE REVIEWER for Architecture Board Exam Takers
 
Article 12 of the Indian Constitution law
Article 12 of the Indian Constitution lawArticle 12 of the Indian Constitution law
Article 12 of the Indian Constitution law
 
Who is Spencer McDaniel? And Does He Actually Exist?
Who is Spencer McDaniel? And Does He Actually Exist?Who is Spencer McDaniel? And Does He Actually Exist?
Who is Spencer McDaniel? And Does He Actually Exist?
 
一比一原版(UNSW毕业证书)新南威尔士大学毕业证如何办理
一比一原版(UNSW毕业证书)新南威尔士大学毕业证如何办理一比一原版(UNSW毕业证书)新南威尔士大学毕业证如何办理
一比一原版(UNSW毕业证书)新南威尔士大学毕业证如何办理
 
Code_Ethics of_Mechanical_Engineering.ppt
Code_Ethics of_Mechanical_Engineering.pptCode_Ethics of_Mechanical_Engineering.ppt
Code_Ethics of_Mechanical_Engineering.ppt
 
一比一原版伦敦南岸大学毕业证如何办理
一比一原版伦敦南岸大学毕业证如何办理一比一原版伦敦南岸大学毕业证如何办理
一比一原版伦敦南岸大学毕业证如何办理
 
CASE STYDY Lalman Shukla v Gauri Dutt BY MUKUL TYAGI.pptx
CASE STYDY Lalman Shukla v Gauri Dutt BY MUKUL TYAGI.pptxCASE STYDY Lalman Shukla v Gauri Dutt BY MUKUL TYAGI.pptx
CASE STYDY Lalman Shukla v Gauri Dutt BY MUKUL TYAGI.pptx
 
一比一原版悉尼科技大学毕业证如何办理
一比一原版悉尼科技大学毕业证如何办理一比一原版悉尼科技大学毕业证如何办理
一比一原版悉尼科技大学毕业证如何办理
 

The EU Copyright Reform - An Update (Eleonora Rosati)

  • 1. The EU Copyright Reform An Update Dr Eleonora Rosati 26th Fordham IP Conference New York City, April 5-6 2018
  • 2. Contents •  Where are we now? •  Are we really speaking of ‘compromises’? •  Towards a DSM? What kind of DSM?
  • 3. Where are we now? •  Bulgarian presidency of the Council – Latest compromise proposal: March 23 – Next presidency: Austria •  JURI Committee to vote on MEP Voss’s Report – Compromise proposals on Arts 11 and 13 so far – Vote scheduled late April
  • 4. Are we really speaking of compromises at this stage?
  • 5.
  • 6.
  • 7. Towards a DSM? What kind of DSM? •  Beneficiaries •  Goals of copyright reform •  Meanwhile – ‘Codification’ of CJEU case law – Forthcoming CJEU cases