SlideShare une entreprise Scribd logo
1  sur  48
Télécharger pour lire hors ligne
Panel:
David S. Kupetz, Partner, SulmeyerKupetz
George P. Blanco, Partner, Avant Advisory Group
Steve J. Cupingood, CPA, Partner, SingerLewak
Mitchell Cohen, EVP; CIT Trade Finance
Moderator: Alexander B. Kasdan, Managing Director, DelMorgan & Co.
Event Organized by Anna Spektor, Founder and President, Expert Presence
ALTERNATIVES FOR A DISTRESSED COMPANY
IN APPARELAND RETAIL
May 9, 2013
1
David S. Kupetz, a member of SulmeyerKupetz, specializes in troubled transactions, crisis avoidance
consultation, workouts, restructurings, reorganizations, bankruptcies, receiverships, assignments for the
benefit of creditors and other non bankruptcy insolvency proceedings. He represents debtors (in
restructurings and workouts and in chapter 11 reorganization cases), secured creditors, unsecured
creditors' committees, assignees for the benefit of creditors, buyers/sellers of businesses/assets in
distressed circumstances and other entities in insolvency and bankruptcy situations.
A sampling of clients represented by Mr. Kupetz includes: Care Enterprises, Inc. (debtor in possession);
Ocean Pacific Sunwear, Ltd. (debtor in possession); County of Los Angeles (creditor); General Electric
Capital Corporation (secured lender); Litton Industries, Inc. (creditor); Boston West, LLC (Boston
Markets) (debtor in possession); ExxonMobil Corporation (creditor); Honda Trading Co. (creditor);
CKE Restaurants (creditor); San Diego Television, Inc. (debtor in possession); South Bay Pizza, Inc.
(debtor in possession); Transgo Corp. (unsecured creditors’ committees); Aura Systems, Inc. (out-of-
court unsecured creditors’ committee); Snow Valley, LLC (debtor in possession); Gardenburger, Inc.
(debtor in possession); eStyle, Inc. (debtor in possession); American Home (debtor in possession); No
Fear Retail Stores, Inc. (debtor in possession); and Ventura Port District (chapter 9 debtor).
His many articles on bankruptcy related subjects have been published in The Business Lawyer,
Commercial Law Journal, IDEA: The Journal of Law and Technology, Journal of Bankruptcy Law and
Practice, The Annual Survey of Bankruptcy Law, The Urban Lawyer, The Banking Law Journal, Los
Angeles Lawyer, California Lawyer, Commercial Law Bulletin, Los Angeles Daily Journal, The
Secured Lender, The Journal of Private Equity, The Journal of Corporate Renewal, Public Law Journal,
Federal Lawyer and many other publications. Mr. Kupetz served as the author of Collier Commercial
Bankruptcy Forms for many years and currently is the author of the Collier Handbook for Creditors'
Committees.
Mr. Kupetz is a frequent lecturer on reorganization and other insolvency topics.
Mr. Kupetz was admitted to the California bar in 1986. He obtained his legal education at the
University of California, Hastings College of the Law (J.D., 1986).
333 South Hope Street
35th Floor
Los Angeles CA 90071
(213) 617-5274
dkupetz@sulmeyerlaw.com
www.sulmeyerlaw.com
2
George P. Blanco, Managing Director and Partner, Avant Advisory Group, has
more than 25 years of senior executive and consulting experience in financial and
operational management high growth and financially distressed companies. His crisis
and turnaround management experience includes operational and financial
restructuring, cost reduction programs, reorganizations in bankruptcy, negotiations
with lenders and creditors, and capital sourcing.
In addition to chief restructuring officer (“CRO”) roles, he also has served as CFO of a
public company and CEO of a telecommunications provider.
George is a Certified Insolvency and Restructuring Advisor (“CIRA”), having served
more than 12 years in the Big 4 accounting and consulting firm environment. In his 30
years of consulting and senior-level experience, he has served as partner and managing
director in consulting, financial advisory and the corporate recovery practices of
PricewaterhouseCoopers and AlixPartners.
George is experienced in manufacturing plant consolidations, supply chain/logistics,
management business process re-engineering, operational restructuring, financial and
manufacturing systems implementation, post-acquisition integration and working
capital improvement for both middle-market and “Fortune 500” companies across
multiple industries.
George has taught classes in Total Quality Management and participated on numerous
panels involving operational restructuring and profitability improvement. In addition to
being a CIRA, he earned his MBA in finance from the UCLAAnderson Graduate
School of Management and his BA in economics and accounting from Claremont
McKenna College.
601 South Figueroa Street,
Suite 4050
Los Angeles CA 90017
(213) 479-7900
GBlanco@AvantAdvisory.com
www.AvantAdvisory.com
3
Steve J. Cupingood leads SingerLewak’s firm-wide Tax practice and he
is the Los Angeles Office Lead Partner.
Steve has over 24 years of experience in individual and business entity
taxation (including with shareholders and partners). He has significant
experience with nonprofits as well as with high net worth individuals. In
addition to possessing strong technical expertise, Steve has extensive
consulting experience in tax planning, research and compliance services. A
significant portion of Steve’s professional experience includes over six
years in the tax department of a large international accounting firm.
Steve received his Bachelors of Science degree in Business Administration
with an Accounting major from California State University, Northridge, in
1984. He is a Certified Public Accountant and a member of the American
Institute of Certified Public Accountants and the California Society of
CPAs.
10960 Wilshire Blvd.
Suite 700
Los Angeles CA 900241
(310) 477-3924
scupingood@singerlewak.com
www.singerlewak.com
4
Mitch Cohen is Executive Vice President - Managing Director and Western
Regional Manager of CIT Trade Finance, responsible for client service and
retention, business development and client credit quality. He has more than 30 years
experience in the financing industry. His responsibilities include client service and
retention, ensuring client credit quality and profitability, and new business
development throughout the Western United States, as well as CIT’s Hong Kong
office.
Mitch’s areas of expertise include factoring and credit protection solutions for
companies that want to increase sales, improve cash flow, reduce operating expenses
and eliminate customer credit losses, and financing solutions for consumer products
companies (apparel, footwear, housewares, furniture and home furnishings).
Mitch has more than 30 years of experience in the financing industry. Prior to joining
CIT, he served as Senior Vice President for Bank of Newport. Prior to this, he was
Senior Vice President with Mitsui Manufacturers Bank. In 2004, Cohen was honored
with the Spirit of Life Award by the Apparel Industries Group for the City of Hope and
was the recipient of the 1999 Humanitarian Award from the National Jewish Medical
and Research Center.
Mitch earned a bachelor’s degree in accounting from the State University of New York
and is a graduate of the University of Washington’s Pacific Coast Banking School. He
also completed the Wharton Executive Development Program.
300 S Grand Ave #12
Los Angeles CA 90071
(213) 613-2416
mitchell.cohen@cit.com
www.cit.com
5
Alexander B. Kasdan is a Managing Director at DelMorgan & Co. He has more
than twenty years of investment banking, real estate, corporate law and corporate
strategy experience. Alex has executed over 100 domestic and cross-border
transactions totaling more than $10 billion in overall volume in a variety of industries.
Prior to joining DelMorgan, Alex founded and ran Convergence Capital Partners, LLC,
a boutique investment banking advisory firm and was an investment banker at
Barrington Associates in Los Angeles, where he headed the restructuring group, Peter
J. Solomon Company, Credit Suisse First Boston and Merrill Lynch.
Alex practiced law with O’Melveny & Myers LLP (formerly O’Sullivan Graev &
Karabell LLP) and Paul, Hastings, Janofsky & Walker LLP (formerly Battle Fowler
LLP), where he specialized in mergers and acquisitions, private equity and corporate
finance transactions. In addition, Alex served as Corporate Counsel in charge of
business development at Schlumberger Ltd., a global oilfield and information services
company.
Alex graduated magna cum laude from Middlebury College with a B.A. degree in
Economics and Italian and was elected to Phi Beta Kappa during his junior year. In
addition, he holds a J.D. degree from Columbia University Law School and has studied
at the University of Florence in Italy. Alex is admitted to the Bar in the State of New
York.
Alex is a Senior Advisor to Governance and Transactions LLC, an advisory firm
established in 2003 by Mr. James L. Gunderson, former Secretary and General Counsel
of Schlumberger Limited, to assist boards, management and owners with corporate
governance, compliance, structuring and strategic transactions.
100 Wilshire Blvd.
Suite 750
Santa Monica, CA 90401
(310) 980-1718
www.delmorganco.com
www.cvgpartners.com
ak@cvgpartners.com
6
Anna Spektor, the Founder and President of Expert Presence,
specializes in digital and event marketing, public relations and
brand communications programs for professional services firms. As
a business development consultant, Anna helps clients develop and
implement comprehensive strategies designed to generate new and
solidify existing referral relationship, elevate profile, and build
brand awareness. Anna is also the founder of Expert Forum and
Expert Webcast, affiliate companies focused on providing the
professional community with quality educational content,
continuing professional education and targeted networking
opportunities.
1999 Avenue of the Stars
Suite 1100
Los Angeles, CA 90067
(310) 995-6579
www.expertpresence.com
anna@expertpresence.com
7
Alternatives for a Distressed Company in
Apparel and Retail
David S. Kupetz
8
Common Fatal Errors by Retailers
•  Failure to engage an experienced turnaround professionals to guide a
return to profitability
•  Failure to quickly arrest cash hemorrhaging
•  Failure to engage merchandisers to refocus the marketing strategy
•  Insufficient focus on core business strength
•  Closing too few stores and taking too long to close them
•  Failure to rationalize the administrative structure of the operations
•  Failure to integrate different concepts in the same management
information system
•  Disastrous acquisitions
9
Repositioning
•  Many retail failures are caused by rapid expansion, mismanagement
or too much leverage.
•  A significant number of failures occur as a result of being out of step
with the market and losing touch with the client base that made a
company successful in the first place.
•  The fashion industry is particularly susceptible.
10
Transaction Structures
•  Chapter 11
–  Section 363 Sale
–  Plan of Reorganization
•  Assignment for the Benefit of Creditors (ABC)
•  Friendly Foreclosure
•  Receiverships
•  Out-of-court workouts/debt restructurings
•  Acquisition of secured debt to be followed by foreclosure or one of
other distressed transaction structures
•  Chapter 7
11
Legal Developments/Issues
•  Secured Creditor Cannot be Stripped of Right to Credit Bid Under
Chapter 11 Plan Providing for Sale
–  RadLAX Gateway Hotel, LLC v. Amalgamated Bank, 132 S. Ct.
2065 (2012)
•  Uncertainty Regarding Trademark Licensee’s Right to Retain
License if Licensor Files Bankruptcy
–  Lubrizol (4th Cir. 1985)
–  Bankruptcy Code § 365(n) (1988)
–  Sunbeam (7th Cir. 2012)
•  Cap on Time (210 days) to Decide Whether to Assume or Reject
Leases under Which Debtor is Lessee
•  Administrative Priority for § 503(b)(9) Reclamation Claims
12
Selected Southern CA Case Studies
•  ABC – Acquisition of Assets of Fortune Fashion Industries by Jerry
Leigh of California
–  Apparel Manufacturer
–  Secured Lenders Undersecured and Consented to ABC Transaction
–  Seamless Transaction Executed Upon Commencement of ABC
•  Section 363 Sales by No Fear Retail Stores
–  Apparel Licensor & Retailer
–  Expedited Sale Process
–  Separate, Contemporaneous Sales Completed for IP Rights and Retail
Assets
•  Chapter 11 Plan by American Home
–  Furniture Retailer
–  Liquidated Arizona Stores Upon Commencement of Case to Pay Off
Secured Lender
–  Reorganized Around Core New Mexico locations and Restructured
Unsecured Debt Under Chapter 11 Plan
13
Alternatives for a Distressed Company in
Apparel and Retail
Alexander B. Kasdan, Managing Director
14
Capital Markets Overview
•  As of December 31, 2012 the S&P 500 Retailing
Index and the S&P 500 Consumer Durables &
Apparel Index increased by 25% and 19%,
respectively, over prior year levels while
outperforming the S&P 500 by 11% and 6%,
respectively
•  The equity markets displayed overall strength and
investor demand
•  Several initial and secondary public equity
offerings were completed in 2012
15
Annual M&A Activity
•  Overall M&A activity in the Consumer & Retail
industry remains healthy with190 closed
transactions during 2012
•  The total value of completed M&A transactions in
the Consumer & Retail industry increased 41% to
$66.6 billion
•  Transactions with values less than $500 million
represented approximately 86% of total deal
volume and 32% of total deal value
16
Apparel Manufacturing Employment
•  Employment has declined
by more than 80% in the last
two decades
•  The decline has been
proportional throughout the
component industries
Source: U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics.
17
Productivity-Output Per Hour
•  Labor productivity in the U.S. manufacturing sector, textile mills and footwear manufacturing
more than or nearly doubled from1987 to 2010
•  Labor productivity in apparel manufacturing grew at about the same rate as overall
manufacturing productivity from 1987 to 2000 but generally declined from 2000 to 2010
Source: U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics.
18
Producer Prices in Apparel
•  Producer Price Index (PPI) for fabric mills, a major component in textile-related production,
increased significantly from October 2010 until September 2011
•  PPI increases for other industries such as footwear manufacturing and for accessories and other
apparel were more muted until December 2011
Source: U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics.
“Opportuni*es-in-Distressed-M&A:--
Finding&Hidden&Value,&&
Preven1ng&Surprises,&and&Winning!!”-
Discussion-Points-
  Why$consider$distressed$M&A$
  Current$market$condi6ons$for$buying$distressed$companies$
  The$economic$recovery$has$not$salvaged$underperforming$companies$
  More$defaults$on$the$horizon$as$companies$lack$liquidity$
  Their$capital$structures$remain$over@leveraged$and$expected$revenue$increases$
have$not$transpired$
  Are$there$“Zombie$companies”$that$can$be$returned$to$life?$$$
  Where$do$you$find$them$and$how$do$you$return$them$to$value?$
  Diligence$on$distressed$company$assets$is$different$than$the$more$typical$quality$of$
earnings$report$
  Beware&of&the&“mel1ng&ice&cub”&
2$
3$
Why-Consider-Distressed-M&A?-
  Healthy-companies-are$purchased$at$fair$market$value$with$compe66ve$bidding;$$
and$without-organic-growth-or$simple$roll@up$strategies,$incremental-value-is-hard-
to-obtain-
  Substan*al-Economic-Upside-
  Financially$distressed$–$i.e.,$good$company$with$bad$balance$sheet$
  Opera6onally$distressed$–$e.g.,$6ghtening$margins,$broken$economic$model,$
bad$management,$slow$reac6on$to$economic$market$condi6ons$
  Distressed$companies$have$fewer-buyers-due-to-perceived-risk-
  Distressed$acquisi6on$can-be-very-risky-for$the$less$experienced$
  Requires-special-skill-set-and$investment$criteria$/$risk$tolerance$
  Assets$can$be$purchased$at$deep-discounts-
4$
Bankruptcy-Sales-&-The-Current-Market-
  Bankruptcy-sales-increased-significantly-during-the-height-of-the-recent-U.S.-financial-crisis;-but$
subsequently,$ the$ pace$ has$ decreased,$ consistent$ with$ trends$ in$ loan$ default$ rates$ and$
bankruptcy$filings$
  Lenders-pulled-back-from-calling-defaults-and-threatening-remedies-in-light-of-the-decline-
in-middlePmarket-valua*on-mul*ples,-and-weak-collateral-values-
  Forces$that$con6nue$to$drive$bankruptcy$sales,$include:$$
  Increasing-amounts-of-private-capital-seeking-higher$returns$from$distressed$situa6ons$
  Increasing-cost-/-complexity-of-the-Chapter-11-process,$which$mo6vates$diverse$groups$of$
creditors$to$push$for$the$speed$and$certainty$achieved$in$a$distressed$sale$
-
57
70 67
75
100
125
173
153 157
136
168
103
125
147
107
91
61
0
20
40
60
80
100
120
140
160
180
200
1Q08 2Q08 3Q08 4Q08 1Q09 2Q09 3Q09 4Q09 1Q10 2Q10 3Q10 4Q10 1Q11 2Q11 3Q11 4Q11 1Q12
Number of Bankruptcy Sales
Source: Capital IQ.
Note: Includes all domestic targets and sellers that have filed for bankruptcy.
5$
Window-of-Opportunity$
  Impending-spike-of-loan-maturi*es-in-2012P2014-as$a$catalyst$for$increased$restructuring$ac6vity$
  AmendPtoPextend-ac*vity-and$new$bond$issuances$con6nue$to$push$out$the$maturity$schedule$
  The-amount-of-loans-coming-due-is-s*ll-high,-but-declining-@@$by$the$end$of$2014,$volume$fell$to$$90$
billion,$from$$145$billion$and$$260$billion$at$the$end$of$2011$and$2010,$respec6vely$
  Constrained-capital-availability-@@$significant$loan$volume$coming$due$just$as$the$CLO’s$reinvestment$
windows$close$(assuming$the$market$for$new$CLO’s$remains$virtually$dead)$
  Impact$of$low-interest-rates-
$0B
$50B
$100B
$150B
$200B
$250B
$300B
YE*2010 YE*2011 YE*2012 YE*2013
Source:(LCD(Es.mates(
CLO-Vehicles-S*ll-in-Reinvestment-Period-
Loan-Distribu*on-by-Year-of-Maturity-
Source:(Standard(&(Poor’s(LCD(
$0B
$50B
$100B
$150B
$200B
2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
12/31/2010 12/31/2011 6/1/2012
The&broader&market&has&a&direct&
impact&on&middle&and&lower&
middle&market&transac1ons&
6$
The-Future-Outlook-
The-Broader-Market-View-
  Standard$&$Poor's$es6mates$that$around$$8.6$trillion$of$US$corporate$borrowings$(including$both$
rated$and$unrated$debt,$but$excluding$securi6zed$loans)$will$mature$and$require$refinancing$over$
the$next$5$years$
  An$addi6onal$need$for$between$$2.5$to$$3$trillion$of$funding$for$corporate$growth,$
depending$on$the$level$of$GDP$growth$$
  The$uncertain$economic$climate$creates$doubt$as$to$whether$the$capital$markets$will$be$able$to$
meet$this$$11$to$$11.5$trillion$capital$need$for$both$refinancing$and$growth$
Impact-on-the-Middle-Market-
  The&resul1ng&capital&adequacy&constraints&and&uncertain1es&are&likely&to&create&financial&distress&
for&the&weak&and&overGlevered&
  Opportuni1es&for&the&distressed&investor&GG&the&need&for&valueGmaximizing&transac1ons&will&drive&
capital&structures&
  Alterna1ve&financing&as&an&op1on&for&geLng&invited&to&the&party?&&LoanGtoGOwn?&
  Interest&rates&con1nue&to&be&low&except&for&alterna1ve&financing&op1ons&
The&broader&market&has&a&direct&impact&on&middle&and&lower&middle&market&transac1ons&
7$
Where-to-Find-Deals-
“Alterna*ve-financing-as-a-source-of-deal-flow”-
$
Key-Sources:-
  Investment$Bankers$–$seeking$“value$investors”;$broken$refinancing$deals$
  Quasi$Investment$Bankers$–$finders$and$brokers$$@@$“Beware-of-incredible-projec*ons”$
  Turnaround$Consultants$–$“rifle$shot$opportuni6es”$
  Corporate$disposi6ons$–$usually$low$profile$with$a$high$opportunity$for$return$
Other-Sources:-
  Commercial$lenders;$but$probably$through$a$“refinancing$opportunity”$that$turns$into$
a$sale$transac6on$
  Finance$companies$that$provide$higher$leverage$with$higher$interest$rates;$more$
inclined$to$liquidate$for$force$a$“quick$sale”$
Opportunis*c-Sources:-
  Akorneys$
  CPA$/$audit$firms$
Alterna*ves-To-Purchase-Distressed-Company-Assets-
Alterna*ves- Opportuni*es-&-Risks-
1.--OutPofPCourt-Workout-
  Out$of$court$workout$is$more$cost$effec6ve$than$alterna6ves$
  Success$is$dependent$upon$all$par6cipants$agreeing$to$nego6ate$coopera6vely$
throughout$the$process$
2.--Chapter-11-Reorganiza*on-
  Secured$creditors$and$antagonis6c$unsecured$creditors$
  May$dissipate$going$concern$/$value$of$estate$
  Ability$to$deal$with$executory$contracts$
  Purchase$assets$free$and$clear$@@$Bankruptcy$Code$Sec6on$363$–$Sale$Process$
3.--Ar*cle-9-PP-“Friendly-
Foreclosure”--
  Secured$creditor$has$right$under$UCC$to$foreclose$and$sell$its$collateral$
  Company$wants$to$sell$assets$quickly$to$a$friendly$buyer$who$will$con6nue$
business$as$a$going$concern$
  Subject$to$“commercial$reasonableness,”$e.g.,$fair$value,$which$can$be$shown$
on$its$face,$if$secured$lender$discounts$its$debt$
4.--Assignment-for-Benefit-of-
Creditors-(ABC)--
  Debtor$may$choose$assignee,$and$lender$may$have$input$into$debtor’s$choice$
  Unhappy$creditors$may$s6ll$file$an$involuntary$bankruptcy$
  Consent$of$landlords$and/or$other$par6es$may$be$necessary$to$sell$or$assign$
debtor’s$rights$under$contracts$(as$opposed$to$bankruptcy$court)$
5.--OutPofPCourt-Liquida*on-–-Self-
Liquida*on--
  Reorganiza6on$is$not$possible$
  No$discharge$of$liabili6es$
  May$lose$value$of$opera6ng$company$
6.--Chapter-7-Liquida*on--
  Company$is$too$weak$or$prospect$of$success$unlikely$(plan$or$reorganiza6on$not$
feasible)$
  Management$no$longer$involved,$as$Trustee$is$appointed$
8$
What-to-Consider-
  Many$/distressed$acquisi6ons$have$phenomenal-economic-opportunity$
  Substan*al-risk-for$those$not$experienced$or$that$do$not$understand$the$unique$complex$
legal,$opera6ng/business,$and$cash$flow$issues$in$this$space-
  Don’t$venture$into$distressed$without$good-advisors-$
$
  Poor-/-inadequate-due-diligence$onen6mes$results$from$the$accelerated-*me-frames$
imposed$by$the$“mel*ng-ice-cube”-environment$of$these$companies$
  Risks$areas,$con6ngencies$and$“cash$burn”$are$onen$uniden6fied$or$misunderstood$by$those$
investors$/$buyers$acquiring$those$companies$
$
  Go-beyond-the-numbers-as$the$accoun6ng$is$onen$broken$$$
  “Quality$of$earnings”$and$adjusted$EBITDAs$may$not$apply$in$a$turnaround$
$
  Do$not$underes6mate$that$distressed$situa6ons$require$significantly$greater$6me,$
effort,$and-a-different-kind-of-management-skill-set$
9$
Key-“TakePAway”-Considera*ons-
  Due$diligence$with$an$opera6onal$focus$
  Is-there-a-core-business-that-can-be-stripped-down-to-profitability?$$Buyers$
frequently$hope$they’ll$be$able$to$grow$their$way$back$out$
  Is-there-sufficient-capital-to-get-to-a-closing;$before$you$lose$key$employees,$
contracts$and$customers?$
  “Does-this-business-have-a-right-to-exist?”$$Is$there$sufficient$intellectual$
property$and$branding$to$support$future$opera6ons?$$
  What$are$the$working-capital-requirements-for$aner$the$acquisi6on,$and$what$is$
the$6meline$to$complete$the$turnaround?$
  Is$there$a$defensible-tac*cal-plan-and$a$viable$long@term$strategy?$
  Think$about$successor-liability-and$how$to$mi6gate$
  ”Peel$away$the$layers$of$the$onion”$before$you$commit,$and$know$when$to$cut$your$
losses$
  Beware&of&the&“mel1ng&ice&cub”$
  Ensure$the$Company$has$or$you$bring$in$strong-and-ethical-management-that$is$
experienced$and$comfortable-turning-around-a-company-
  $That$is$more$cri6cal$than$ever$in$distressed$acquisi6ons$and$turnarounds$
  The$100$day$plan$
$ 10$
Other-Informa*on-
More-on-Market-Condi*ons-
11$
M&A-Ac*vity-and-Mul*ples-
12$
  Middle@market$M&A$volume$is$picking$up$as$shown$
below$
  The$gap$between$seller-expecta*ons-(~8x-EBITDA)-
and$leverage-availability-(~4x-EBITDA),-remains$a$
challenge$for$financial$sponsors$with$high$return$
targets$
  An6cipate$an$increase$in$distressed$M&A$ac6vity$as$
this$gap$closes,$and$lenders$begin$to$view$this$as$a$
feasible$alterna6ve$for$recovery$
Middle-Market-M&A-Volume-(1)-
Middle-Market-LBO-Purchase-Price-Mul*ples-
Source:(LCD(Comps(
Source:&Thomson&One&Banker&Notes:&Includes&all&U.S.&announced&deals&with&transac1on&values&between&$20&mm&and&$1bn.&&
&
7.6x 7.5x
7.1x 6.9x
5.9x
6.7x 7.0x 7.2x
8.5x 8.1x
9.3x
8.3x
6.6x
8.4x 8.2x
0.0x
2.0x
4.0x
6.0x
8.0x
10.0x
1997 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011
Senior3D ebt/EBITDA Sub3D ebt/EBITD A Equity/EBITDA O thers
$419
$235 $225
$240
$282
$327
$378
$411
$269
$170
$281
$297
2,559
1,611
1,573
1,682
1,783
2,025
2,263
2,250
1,680
1,107
1,561 1,606
0
500
1,000
1,500
2,000
2,500
3,000
$0B
$50B
$100B
$150B
$200B
$250B
$300B
$350B
$400B
$450B
2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011
Deal2Value Number2of2Deals
4.8x
4.7x
4.1x 4.0x
3.4x
3.9x 3.8x
4.2x
4.7x 4.7x
5.6x
4.5x
3.3x
4.2x 4.3x
0.0x
2.0x
4.0x
6.0x
1997 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011
FLD /EBITD A SLD /EBITDA O ther<Sr<D ebt/EBITD A Sub<D ebt/EBITD A
Source:(LCD(Comps(
Debt-Mul*ples-of-Middle-Market-LBO-Loans-
(First-Lien-/-Second-Lien-Debt)-
13$
U.S.-Private-Equity-Capital-Overhang-
  A$significant$driver$of$distressed$asset$sales$comes$from$the$availability$of$private$equity$capital$
  The$quan6ty$of$“dry$powder”$in$the$hands$of$private$equity$groups$seeking$distressed$and$other$
opportuni6es$is$currently$close$to$$450$billion$of$total$private$equity$capital$(i.e.$uncalled$
commitments)$
  Accordingly,$it$maybe$an$opportunis6c$6me$for$secured$creditors$to$consider$the$sale$alterna6ve$to$
mone6ze$their$exposure$in$certain$situa6ons$$PP-Selling&the&Zombie&Companies&
$ U.S. Private Equity Overhang
($ in billions)
Source: PitchBook Data – 2012 Capital Overhang and Fund Cash Flow Report.
$463
$530
$576 $561
$477
$456
$67)
$46)
($16)
($83)
($21)
($150)
$0'
$150'
$300'
$450'
$600'
$750'
2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011
Cumulative)O verhang Annual)O verhang
1
TAX
CONSIDERATIONS
FOR
RETAIL
AND
APPAREL
Steve J. Cupingood
Tax Partner
(310) 477 – 3924, Ext. 1353
scupingood@singerlewak.com
2
Cancellation of Indebtedness Income
General'rule'–'a'discharge'of'debt'for'less'than'the'amount'due'must'be'recognized'as'taxable'income.''
Codified'in'IRC'Sec.'61(a)(12)'–'gross'income'includes'income'from'the'discharge'of'indebtedness.'''
'
Income'recognized'is'generally'the'difference'between'the'face'amount'of'the'instrument'and'the'amount'
paid'on'discharge.'
'
The'debt'discharge'income'is'generally'taxed'at'ordinary'income'tax'rates.''
'
IRC'sec.'108(a)(1)'lists'four'situaIons'in'which'realized'debt'discharge'income'may'not'be'recognized'for'
federal'income'tax'purposes.'Subject'to'numerous'other'rules'and'requirements,'nonMrecogniIon'may'occur'
if:'
'
'(A)'the'discharge'occurs'in'a'Itle'11'case;'
'(B)'the'discharge'occurs'when'the'taxpayer'is'insolvent;''
'(C)'the'discharged'debt'is'qualified'farm'indebtedness;'or'
'(D)'the'discharged'debt'is'qualified'real'property'business'indebtedness'
'
The'IRC'defines'insolvency'to'mean'the'excess'of'liabiliIes'over'the'fair'market'value'of'assets'immediately'
before'the'debt'discharge.'
'
3
Tax Attribute Reduction
When'debt'discharge'income'is'excluded'from'gross'income'under'the'insolvency'
excepIon,'there'are'potenIal'prices.'
'
In'some'cases,'I.R.C.'Sec.'108(b)'requires'an'offseVng'reducIon'of'tax'aWributes,'in'the'
following'order:'
'
1.  NOLs'for'the'current'taxable'year'and'any'NOL'carryovers.'
2.  General'business'credits'under'I.R.C.'Sec.'38.'
3.  Minimum'tax'credits'available'under'I.R.C.''Sec.'53(b).'
4.  Capital'loss'carryovers.'
5.  Basis'in'property,'with'ordering'rules'in'I.R.C.'Sec.'1017.'
6.  Passive'acIvity'loss'and'credit'carryovers'under'I.R.C.'Sec.'469(b).'
7.  Foreign'tax'credit'carryovers.'
'
'
'
4
What is the Research & Development
Tax Credit?
•  The'research'credit'( R&D'Credit )'is'a'tax'incenIve'for'performing'qualified'
research'in'the'U.S.''
•  The'net'credit'is'equal'to'approximately'6.5%'of'qualified'research'expenditures.'
•  About'35'states'have'enacted'some'type'of'R&D'credit.''
'
Profile'of'R&D'Candidate'
•  Develops'and'manufactures'new'products'
•  Improves'exisIng'products'
•  Develops'or'improves'manufacturing'process'
•  Has'filed'for'patents'–'Intellectual'property'
•  Plant'improvements'–'new'machinery/process'
•  Developed'soiware'for'internal'use'
5
What is Qualified Research ?
•  Research'that'saIsfies'a' fourMpart'test 'is' Qualified'Research '(must'meet'ALL'4'parts).'
•  Qualified'Research 'is'research'that'is:'
1.  Technological'in'Nature'
2.  Undertaken'to'Eliminate'Uncertainty'
3.  Undertaken'for'a'PermiWed'Purpose;'and'
4.  Consists'of'a'Process'of'ExperimentaIon'
'
What'Expenses'Qualify'for'the'R&D'Credit:'
•  Wages'–'employees 'WM2,'box'1'amount'
•  Research,'direct'supervision,'direct'support'
•  Supplies'–'nonMdepreciable'tangible'personal'property'used'or'consumed'in'the'research'process'
•  Contract'Research'–'research'performed'by'nonMemployees'
•  65%'Rule'–'65%'of'contract'research'is'eligible'
6
Research and Development Tax Incentives
for the Apparel and Textiles Industry
In'the'apparel'and'texIles'industry,'R&D'acIviIes'are'evidenced'in'the'design'and'development'of'new'garments,'
shoes,'accessories,'texIles/fabrics,'chemical'and'topical'treatments,'and'embroidery'techniques.'Apparel'
companies'at'any'stage'in'the'development'chain'can'have'qualifying'acIviIes,'from'the'texIle'mills,'to'the'
design'houses,'to'the'manufacturing'plants.''
If'your'company'operates'in'the'apparel,'shoe,'or'texIle'industries,'there'is'a'strong'chance'that'you'would'
benefit'from'an'R&D'tax'credit'study.''
'
Examples'of'apparel'and'texIle'innovaIons'eligible'for'R&D'tax'incenIves'include'the'following:'
'
• Designing'new'garments'and'apparel''
• Designing'new'shoe'designs''
• Designing'innovaIve'shoe'fit'and'comfort'techniques''
• GeneraIng'prototypes'and'fit'samples'of'new'products'for'tesIng'and'validaIon''
• Developing'new'woven,'knit,'or'nonMwoven'texIles''
• Developing'new'or'improved'chemical'or'topical'treatments''
• Developing'new'or'improved'manufacturing'processes''
• Design'and'development'of'scaled'up'manufacturing'processes''
'
'
7
Section 363 Sales of Debtor Corporation
Stock vs. Assets
SecIon' 363' allows' for' the' courtMapproved' sale' of' either' the' assets' of' a' debtor'
corporaIon'or'the'stock'of'a'debtor'corporaIon.' 'The'structuring'of'the'SecIon'363'
sale' affects' the' immediate' income' tax' consequences' of' the' transacIon' to' both' the'
buyer'corporaIon'and'the'seller'corporaIon.'
'
For'example,'the'buyer'may'wish'to'keep'the'debtor'corporaIon'intact'and,'thereby,'
preserve'the'debtor'income'tax'aWributes'such'as'its'net'operaIng'losses'(NOLs).' 'In'
that'case,'the'buyer'will'prefer'to'purchase'the'debtor'corporaIon'stock.'
'
However,'if'the'buyer'cannot'use'the'debtor'income'tax'aWributes,'then'the'buyer'may'
prefer'to'purchase'the'debtor'corporaIon'assets.' 'That'way,'the'buyer'can'obtain'a'
stepMup'in'the'depreciable'tax'basis'of'the'acquired'debtor'assets.''This'tax'basis'stepM
up' can' result' in' future' depreciaIon' or' amorIzaIon' income' tax' deducIons' for' the'
buyer.'
'
8
Section 363 Sales of Debtor Corporation
Stock vs. Assets
On'the'other'hand,'the'debtor'corporaIon'will'generally'want'to'minimize'the'taxable'
income'recognized'on'the'sale'of'either'its'stock'or'its'assets.' 'The'seller s'ability'to'
minimize'the'reported'income'on'the'sale'will'depend'on:'
1.  The'debtor s'tax'basis'in'the'corporaIon'stock'or'the'corporaIon'assets,'
2.  The'availability'of'offseVng'losses,'and'
3.  The' realizaIon' of' any' cancellaIon' of' debt' (COD)' income' related' to' the'
bankruptcy'or'reorganizaIon.'
The'debtor'corporaIon'may'be'able'to'indefinitely'defer'the'recogniIon'of'the'gain'on'
the'transacIon'by'structuring'the'SecIon'363'sale'as'a'taxMfree'reorganizaIon'under'
Internal'Revenue'Code'SecIon'368.'
'
'
9
Section 363 Sales of Debtor Corporation
Stock vs. Assets
Typically,'either'the'debtor'corporaIon'assets'or'stock'are'sold'in'a'taxable'SecIon'363'
sale,'the'debtor'will'recognize'either'a'gain'or'loss.''The'amount'of'the'taxable'gain'or'
loss'will'be'equal'to'the'difference'between:'
1.  The'amount'realized'from'the'sale'and'
2.  The'seller s'adjusted'tax'basis'of'the'transferred'property.'
'
The' amount' realized' from' the' SecIon' 363' sale' includes' all' of' the' consideraIon'
received'by'the'seller.''This'consideraIon'includes'the'following:'
1.  Cash'
2.  The'fair'market'value'of'any'property'received'from'the'buyer'
3.  Any'liabiliIes'assumed'by'the'buyer'
4.  The'issue'price'of'any'debt'instrument'issued'by'the'buyer'
'
'
10
Additional Items to Consider with
Acquisitions in Bankruptcy
AcquisiIons'from'a'bankruptcy'estate'can'be'subject'to'a'number'of'taxes,'such'as'real'estate'transfer'taxes'and'
sales'taxes,'that'could'apply'to'transfers'of'assets.' 'The'U.S.'Bankruptcy'Code'contains'an'excepIon'for'some'
transfer'taxes,'though'it'does'not'apply'in'all'circumstances.'
'
Further,' acquisiIons' could' trigger' changeMofMcontrol' provisions' in' property' tax' statutes,' which' may' lead' to' a'
revaluaIon'of'real'estate'and'an'increase'in'property'tax'rates.'
'
Internal'Revenue'Code'SecIon'382'limits'the'use'of'the'acquired'debtor'corporaIon'NOLs'and'capital'losses'(and'
certain'builtMin'losses).' 'SecIon'382'applies'to'a'transacIon'where'a'greater'than'50'percent'change'in'stock'
ownership'of'the'loss'corporaIon'occurred'during'a'three'–year'period'(called'an'“ownership'change”).'
'
If'there'is'an'ownership'change,'SecIon'382'places'an'annual'limit'on'the'amount'of'taxable'income'aier'the'
ownership'change'that'may'be'offset'by'the'loss'corporaIon'NOL'carryovers'arising'before'the'ownership'change.'
'
'
11
Section 199 – Domestic Production
Activities Deduction
Taxpayer s'who'manufacture'or'produce'goods,'develop'or'improve'qualifying'producIon'property'may''
qualify'for'the'DomesIc'ProducIon'AcIviIes'DeducIon'(DPAD)'on'their'federal'income'tax'return.'This'tax''
deducIon'is'9%'of'the'smaller'of:'
'
•  the'qualified'producIon'acIviIes'income'(QPAI),'or''
•  taxable'income'figured'without'the'DPAD''
'''
Qualified'ProducIon'AcIviIes'
''
Qualified'producIon'acIviIes'eligible'for'claiming'the'deducIon'under'IRC'SecIon'199:'
•  Manufacturing'based'in'the'United'States,'
•  Selling,'leasing,'or'licensing'items'that'have'been'manufactured'in'the'United'States,'
•  Selling,'leasing,'or'licensing'moIon'pictures'that'have'been'produced'in'the'United'States,'
•  ConstrucIon' services' in' the' United' States,' including' building' and' renovaIon' of' residenIal' and'
commercial'properIes,'
•  Engineering'and'architectural'services'relaIng'to'a'USMbased'construcIon'project,'
•  Soiware'development'in'the'United'States,'including'the'development'of'video'games.''
'
'
12
IC-DISC – Interest Charge Domestic
International Sales Corporation
What'is'an'ICMDISC?'
'
The'ICMDISC'( Interest'Charged'DomesIc'InternaIonal'Sales'CorporaIon )'was'designed'as'a'tax'incenIve'for'small'to'midsized''
U.S.'ExporIng'companies.'The'boWom'line'is'that'the'tax'laws'provide'an'opportunity'for'a'company'to'use'an'ICMDISC'to'have''
the'tax'on'50%'of'its'export'income'reduced'by'more'than'50%.''Profits'are'taxed'at'the'dividend'rate'(currently'5%'or'20%'
depending'on'AGI)'as'opposed'to'ordinary'income'tax'rates'(top'rate'currently'35%).'
'
How'does'it'work?'
'
The'exporter'pays'a'commission'to'the'ICMDISC.''The'commissions'are'deducIble'to'the'exporter,'and'the''
deemed'or'actual'dividend'payment'of'the'commission'income'in'the'ICMDISC'is'taxed'to'the'exporter s'shareholders/partners''
at'the'23.8%'rate'(as'opposed'to'being'taxed'as'ordinary'income'–'ex.'35%'rate).'''
'
At'the'end'of'the'day,'the'exporter'receives'a'deducIon'of'35%'on'the'commission'payments'made'to'the'ICMDISC'and'on'the''
other'hand'only'pays'a'23.8%'tax'rate'on'the'income'repatriated'from'the'ICMDISC.''The'boWom'line'is'a'permanent'tax'savings''
for'U.S.'exporters'and'their'shareholders'of'10%'or'higher'of'net'export'income.'''
'
13
IC-DISC – Interest Charge Domestic
International Sales Corporation
What'is'an'ICMDISC?'
'
The'ICMDISC'( Interest'Charged'DomesIc'InternaIonal'Sales'CorporaIon )'was'designed'as'a'tax'incenIve'for'small'to'midsized''
U.S.'ExporIng'companies.'The'boWom'line'is'that'the'tax'laws'provide'an'opportunity'for'a'company'to'use'an'ICMDISC'to'have''
the'tax'on'50%'of'its'export'income'reduced'by'more'than'50%.''Profits'are'taxed'at'the'dividend'rate'(currently'15%)'as''
opposed'to'ordinary'income'tax'rates'(top'rate'currently'35%).'
'
How'does'it'work?'
'
In'a'nutshell'you'are'creaIng'a'separate'enIty'(or'someImes'several'enIIes'to'maximize'the'tax'benefits)'–'the' CorporaIon ''
part'of'ICMDISC.''The'exporter'pays'commissions'to'the'ICMDISC.''The'commissions'are'deducIble'to'the'exporter,'and'the''
deemed'or'actual'dividend'payment'of'the'commission'income'in'the'ICMDISC'is'taxed'to'the'exporter s'shareholders/partners''
at'the'23.8%'rate'(as'opposed'to'being'taxed'as'ordinary'income'–'ex.'35%'rate).'''
'
At'the'end'of'the'day,'the'exporter'receives'a'deducIon'of'35%'on'the'commission'payments'made'to'the'ICMDISC'and'on'the''
other'hand'only'pays'a'23.8%'tax'rate'on'the'income'repatriated'from'the'ICMDISC.''The'boWom'line'is'a'permanent'tax'savings''
for'U.S.'exporters'and'their'shareholders'of'10%'or'higher'of'net'export'income.'''
'
14
IC-DISC – Interest Charge Domestic
International Sales Corporation
EXAMPLE:'
'
'
Company(Without(an(IC/DISC'
Foreign'Trading'Gross'Receipts' $10,000,000'
Cost'of'Goods'Sold' $6,000,000'
Selling,'General'and'AdministraIve' $3,000,000'
Export'Net'Income' $1,000,000'
Tax'Rate' 35%'
Tax'Paid' $350,000'
Company(With(an(IC/DISC'
Foreign'Trading'Gross'Receipts' $10,000,000' '' ''
Costs'of'Goods'Sold' $6,000,000' '' ''
Selling,'General'and'AdministraIve' $3,000,000' 'CMCorp' ICMDISC'
Export'Net'Income' $1,000,000' $1,000,000' ''
ICMDISC'Commission'DeducIon' '' ($500,000)' $500,000'
Tax'Base'Aier'ICMDISC'Commission' '' $500,000' $500,000'
Tax'Rate' '' 35%' 23.8%'
Tax'Paid' '' $175,000' $119,000'
IC/DISC(Net(Tax(Savings($350,000(/(($175,000(+($119,000)(=($56,000'
15
Geographic Targeted Economics
Development Areas (G-TEDAs)
California'has'four'types'of'GMTEDAs.'Each'of'these'areas'have'related'tax'incenIve'benefits.'The'
main'purpose'of'the'GMTEDAs'is'to'sImulate'and'encourage'business'investment'by'allowing'the'
private' market' forces' to' revive' the' local' economy' and' job' creaIon' for' qualified' disadvantaged'
individuals'in'state'designated'economically'distressed'areas.''
'
Enterprise'Zone'Benefits'
 Hiring'Credits'
 Sales'or'Use'Tax'Credits'
 Business'Expense'DeducIon'
 Net'Interest'DeducIon'
  100%'Net'OperaIng'Loss'Carryover'(NOL)''
  CarryMforward'for'15'years'
 Local'Agency'IncenIves'may'also'be'available'(e.g.,'City'of'Los'Angeles'DWP'rate'discounts,'and'
reduced'parking'ordinances).'
'
16
Employee Hiring Credits
'
The'EZ'Hiring'Credit'is'a'dollar&for&dollar'state'income'tax'credit:'
'
  Up'to'$37,440'per'qualified'employee'over'a'fiveMyear'Period'
  $12,480'in'the'first'year'
  The'credit'is'based'on'the'lesser'of'the'qualified'employee s'hourly'wage'paid'or'
150%'of'the'minimum'wage'
  Voucher'confirming'eligibility'is'required'from'the'local'EZ'vouchering'agency'
and'maintained'for'a'period'of'four'years'
  Taxpayers'can'only'offset'tax'paid'with'EZ'credits'
'

Contenu connexe

Tendances

Strategies for closely held companies
Strategies for closely held companiesStrategies for closely held companies
Strategies for closely held companies
Expert Webcast
 
03.27.2014 Raising Capital webcast
03.27.2014 Raising Capital webcast03.27.2014 Raising Capital webcast
03.27.2014 Raising Capital webcast
Expert Webcast
 
Expert Webcast Maximizing Value of Privately Held Company
Expert Webcast Maximizing Value of Privately Held CompanyExpert Webcast Maximizing Value of Privately Held Company
Expert Webcast Maximizing Value of Privately Held Company
Expert Webcast
 

Tendances (17)

Transcript: Alternatives for a Distressed Company in Apparel and Retail
Transcript: Alternatives for a Distressed Company in Apparel and RetailTranscript: Alternatives for a Distressed Company in Apparel and Retail
Transcript: Alternatives for a Distressed Company in Apparel and Retail
 
Covendium secure your legacy
Covendium   secure your legacyCovendium   secure your legacy
Covendium secure your legacy
 
Strategies for closely held companies
Strategies for closely held companiesStrategies for closely held companies
Strategies for closely held companies
 
06.12.2014 Emerging Markets Cross-Border Transactions
06.12.2014 Emerging Markets Cross-Border Transactions06.12.2014 Emerging Markets Cross-Border Transactions
06.12.2014 Emerging Markets Cross-Border Transactions
 
03.27.2014 Raising Capital webcast
03.27.2014 Raising Capital webcast03.27.2014 Raising Capital webcast
03.27.2014 Raising Capital webcast
 
06.12.2014 Emerging Markets Cross-Border Transactions
06.12.2014 Emerging Markets Cross-Border Transactions06.12.2014 Emerging Markets Cross-Border Transactions
06.12.2014 Emerging Markets Cross-Border Transactions
 
Expert Webcast Maximizing Value of Privately Held Company
Expert Webcast Maximizing Value of Privately Held CompanyExpert Webcast Maximizing Value of Privately Held Company
Expert Webcast Maximizing Value of Privately Held Company
 
Expert Webcast Roundtable: Liquidity and Transition Strategies for Business O...
Expert Webcast Roundtable: Liquidity and Transition Strategies for Business O...Expert Webcast Roundtable: Liquidity and Transition Strategies for Business O...
Expert Webcast Roundtable: Liquidity and Transition Strategies for Business O...
 
02.15.2018 Trends, Transactions and Opportunities in Oil & Gas
02.15.2018 Trends, Transactions and Opportunities in Oil & Gas02.15.2018 Trends, Transactions and Opportunities in Oil & Gas
02.15.2018 Trends, Transactions and Opportunities in Oil & Gas
 
Ownership Transfers of Closely Held Businesses
Ownership Transfers of Closely Held BusinessesOwnership Transfers of Closely Held Businesses
Ownership Transfers of Closely Held Businesses
 
10.20.2016 Maximizing Value for Distressed Venture Companies
10.20.2016 Maximizing Value for Distressed Venture Companies10.20.2016 Maximizing Value for Distressed Venture Companies
10.20.2016 Maximizing Value for Distressed Venture Companies
 
03.01.2018 The Blockchain Revolution
03.01.2018 The Blockchain Revolution03.01.2018 The Blockchain Revolution
03.01.2018 The Blockchain Revolution
 
01.11.2018 Distressed Asset Acquisitions
01.11.2018 Distressed Asset Acquisitions01.11.2018 Distressed Asset Acquisitions
01.11.2018 Distressed Asset Acquisitions
 
Valuation Trends and Investment Opportunities in the Cannabis Industry
 Valuation Trends and Investment Opportunities in the Cannabis Industry Valuation Trends and Investment Opportunities in the Cannabis Industry
Valuation Trends and Investment Opportunities in the Cannabis Industry
 
01.10.2019 Healthcare Restructuring Outlook 2019
01.10.2019 Healthcare Restructuring Outlook 201901.10.2019 Healthcare Restructuring Outlook 2019
01.10.2019 Healthcare Restructuring Outlook 2019
 
Managing Different Shareholder Constituencies in a Private Company Sale Process
Managing Different Shareholder Constituencies in a Private Company Sale ProcessManaging Different Shareholder Constituencies in a Private Company Sale Process
Managing Different Shareholder Constituencies in a Private Company Sale Process
 
July 13, 2017: Strategic Solutions to Cross-Border Business Disputes
July 13, 2017: Strategic Solutions to Cross-Border Business DisputesJuly 13, 2017: Strategic Solutions to Cross-Border Business Disputes
July 13, 2017: Strategic Solutions to Cross-Border Business Disputes
 

En vedette

Trendducation expert webcast 1
Trendducation expert webcast 1Trendducation expert webcast 1
Trendducation expert webcast 1
Expert Webcast
 
05 22 2014 key financial and estate planning issues before during and after d...
05 22 2014 key financial and estate planning issues before during and after d...05 22 2014 key financial and estate planning issues before during and after d...
05 22 2014 key financial and estate planning issues before during and after d...
Expert Webcast
 
20110924 china mes team building-stag1.rev3
20110924 china mes team building-stag1.rev320110924 china mes team building-stag1.rev3
20110924 china mes team building-stag1.rev3
lingliwu
 
SS Class PPT
SS Class PPTSS Class PPT
SS Class PPT
Kroyer96
 
Plug in #3 export presentation
Plug in #3 export presentationPlug in #3 export presentation
Plug in #3 export presentation
Kroyer96
 
The scientific method
The scientific methodThe scientific method
The scientific method
Amy0143
 
La resta portant-ne
La resta portant-ne La resta portant-ne
La resta portant-ne
inicialalmeda
 
Teens, drugs and alcohol
Teens, drugs and alcoholTeens, drugs and alcohol
Teens, drugs and alcohol
Jellys Almario
 

En vedette (15)

Trendducation expert webcast 1
Trendducation expert webcast 1Trendducation expert webcast 1
Trendducation expert webcast 1
 
05 22 2014 key financial and estate planning issues before during and after d...
05 22 2014 key financial and estate planning issues before during and after d...05 22 2014 key financial and estate planning issues before during and after d...
05 22 2014 key financial and estate planning issues before during and after d...
 
20110924 china mes team building-stag1.rev3
20110924 china mes team building-stag1.rev320110924 china mes team building-stag1.rev3
20110924 china mes team building-stag1.rev3
 
SS Class PPT
SS Class PPTSS Class PPT
SS Class PPT
 
Plug in #3 export presentation
Plug in #3 export presentationPlug in #3 export presentation
Plug in #3 export presentation
 
Achieving the next level of corporate growth - navigating “no man’s land”
Achieving the next level of corporate growth - navigating “no man’s land”Achieving the next level of corporate growth - navigating “no man’s land”
Achieving the next level of corporate growth - navigating “no man’s land”
 
The scientific method
The scientific methodThe scientific method
The scientific method
 
Pak sandi anakon anakes
Pak sandi anakon anakesPak sandi anakon anakes
Pak sandi anakon anakes
 
Cuadro descriptivo fuentes de las obligaciones
Cuadro descriptivo fuentes de las obligacionesCuadro descriptivo fuentes de las obligaciones
Cuadro descriptivo fuentes de las obligaciones
 
Trends and Transactions in Private Post-Secondary Education
Trends and Transactions in Private Post-Secondary EducationTrends and Transactions in Private Post-Secondary Education
Trends and Transactions in Private Post-Secondary Education
 
La resta portant ne
La resta portant neLa resta portant ne
La resta portant ne
 
La resta portant-ne
La resta portant-ne La resta portant-ne
La resta portant-ne
 
Ley contra delitos informáticos y Ley sobre armas y explosivos
Ley contra delitos informáticos y Ley sobre armas y explosivosLey contra delitos informáticos y Ley sobre armas y explosivos
Ley contra delitos informáticos y Ley sobre armas y explosivos
 
Listening skill
Listening skillListening skill
Listening skill
 
Teens, drugs and alcohol
Teens, drugs and alcoholTeens, drugs and alcohol
Teens, drugs and alcohol
 

Similaire à 5 9 presentation final 1

Achieving the Next Level of Corporate Growth: Navigating “No Man’s Land”
Achieving the Next Level of Corporate Growth: Navigating “No Man’s Land”Achieving the Next Level of Corporate Growth: Navigating “No Man’s Land”
Achieving the Next Level of Corporate Growth: Navigating “No Man’s Land”
Expert Webcast
 
Reducing Payable to Position a Company for Growth or Sale
Reducing Payable to Position a Company for Growth or Sale Reducing Payable to Position a Company for Growth or Sale
Reducing Payable to Position a Company for Growth or Sale
Expert Webcast
 
11.7.13 reducing payables expert webcast
11.7.13 reducing payables expert webcast 11.7.13 reducing payables expert webcast
11.7.13 reducing payables expert webcast
Expert Webcast
 
Business Succession Planning and Exit Strategies for the Closely Held and Fam...
Business Succession Planning and Exit Strategies for the Closely Held and Fam...Business Succession Planning and Exit Strategies for the Closely Held and Fam...
Business Succession Planning and Exit Strategies for the Closely Held and Fam...
Expert Webcast
 
Business Succession Planning and Exit Strategies for the Closely Held and Fam...
Business Succession Planning and Exit Strategies for the Closely Held and Fam...Business Succession Planning and Exit Strategies for the Closely Held and Fam...
Business Succession Planning and Exit Strategies for the Closely Held and Fam...
Expert Webcast
 
Cross-Border Investment & M&A: Risk Management and Mitigation
Cross-Border Investment & M&A: Risk Management and MitigationCross-Border Investment & M&A: Risk Management and Mitigation
Cross-Border Investment & M&A: Risk Management and Mitigation
Expert Webcast
 
CrossBorder Investment & M&A: Risk Management and Mitigation
CrossBorder Investment & M&A: Risk Management and MitigationCrossBorder Investment & M&A: Risk Management and Mitigation
CrossBorder Investment & M&A: Risk Management and Mitigation
Expert Webcast
 

Similaire à 5 9 presentation final 1 (17)

10.19.2017 The State of Cross-Border Private Equity and the Role of Alternati...
10.19.2017 The State of Cross-Border Private Equity and the Role of Alternati...10.19.2017 The State of Cross-Border Private Equity and the Role of Alternati...
10.19.2017 The State of Cross-Border Private Equity and the Role of Alternati...
 
09.28.2017 Alternative Investment Strategies - Life Insurance Settlements
09.28.2017 Alternative Investment Strategies  - Life Insurance Settlements09.28.2017 Alternative Investment Strategies  - Life Insurance Settlements
09.28.2017 Alternative Investment Strategies - Life Insurance Settlements
 
Expert Webcast: Maximizing Value of Privately Held Company
Expert Webcast: Maximizing Value of Privately Held CompanyExpert Webcast: Maximizing Value of Privately Held Company
Expert Webcast: Maximizing Value of Privately Held Company
 
Achieving the Next Level of Corporate Growth: Navigating “No Man’s Land”
Achieving the Next Level of Corporate Growth: Navigating “No Man’s Land”Achieving the Next Level of Corporate Growth: Navigating “No Man’s Land”
Achieving the Next Level of Corporate Growth: Navigating “No Man’s Land”
 
Expert Webcast: Healthcare Restructuring Outlook 2019
Expert Webcast: Healthcare Restructuring Outlook 2019Expert Webcast: Healthcare Restructuring Outlook 2019
Expert Webcast: Healthcare Restructuring Outlook 2019
 
01.18.2018 Tax Reform and its Effect on Corporate America
01.18.2018 Tax Reform and its Effect on Corporate America01.18.2018 Tax Reform and its Effect on Corporate America
01.18.2018 Tax Reform and its Effect on Corporate America
 
Reducing Payable to Position a Company for Growth or Sale
Reducing Payable to Position a Company for Growth or Sale Reducing Payable to Position a Company for Growth or Sale
Reducing Payable to Position a Company for Growth or Sale
 
Reducing Payables to Position a Company for Growth or Sale
Reducing Payables to Position a Company for Growth or SaleReducing Payables to Position a Company for Growth or Sale
Reducing Payables to Position a Company for Growth or Sale
 
11.7.13 reducing payables expert webcast
11.7.13 reducing payables expert webcast 11.7.13 reducing payables expert webcast
11.7.13 reducing payables expert webcast
 
Business Succession Planning and Exit Strategies for the Closely Held and Fam...
Business Succession Planning and Exit Strategies for the Closely Held and Fam...Business Succession Planning and Exit Strategies for the Closely Held and Fam...
Business Succession Planning and Exit Strategies for the Closely Held and Fam...
 
Business Succession Planning and Exit Strategies for the Closely Held and Fam...
Business Succession Planning and Exit Strategies for the Closely Held and Fam...Business Succession Planning and Exit Strategies for the Closely Held and Fam...
Business Succession Planning and Exit Strategies for the Closely Held and Fam...
 
M&A Risk Allocation: Representations and Warranties Insurance
M&A Risk Allocation: Representations and Warranties InsuranceM&A Risk Allocation: Representations and Warranties Insurance
M&A Risk Allocation: Representations and Warranties Insurance
 
M&A Risk Allocation: Representations and Warranties Insurance.
M&A Risk Allocation: Representations and Warranties Insurance.   M&A Risk Allocation: Representations and Warranties Insurance.
M&A Risk Allocation: Representations and Warranties Insurance.
 
Trends and Transactions in Hemp
Trends and Transactions in HempTrends and Transactions in Hemp
Trends and Transactions in Hemp
 
Cross-Border Investment & M&A: Risk Management and Mitigation
Cross-Border Investment & M&A: Risk Management and MitigationCross-Border Investment & M&A: Risk Management and Mitigation
Cross-Border Investment & M&A: Risk Management and Mitigation
 
CrossBorder Investment & M&A: Risk Management and Mitigation
CrossBorder Investment & M&A: Risk Management and MitigationCrossBorder Investment & M&A: Risk Management and Mitigation
CrossBorder Investment & M&A: Risk Management and Mitigation
 
Avoid legal and business mistakes when your company, client or customer is in...
Avoid legal and business mistakes when your company, client or customer is in...Avoid legal and business mistakes when your company, client or customer is in...
Avoid legal and business mistakes when your company, client or customer is in...
 

Plus de Expert Webcast

Plus de Expert Webcast (18)

Expert Webcast 10.10.2019: Cannabis Private Equity
Expert Webcast 10.10.2019: Cannabis Private EquityExpert Webcast 10.10.2019: Cannabis Private Equity
Expert Webcast 10.10.2019: Cannabis Private Equity
 
Expert Webcast: Lower Middle Market Finance for Owner Operators
Expert Webcast: Lower Middle Market Finance for Owner OperatorsExpert Webcast: Lower Middle Market Finance for Owner Operators
Expert Webcast: Lower Middle Market Finance for Owner Operators
 
Qualified Opportunity Zones featuring Orla O'Connor, Lou Vlahis, Sky Moore, C...
Qualified Opportunity Zones featuring Orla O'Connor, Lou Vlahis, Sky Moore, C...Qualified Opportunity Zones featuring Orla O'Connor, Lou Vlahis, Sky Moore, C...
Qualified Opportunity Zones featuring Orla O'Connor, Lou Vlahis, Sky Moore, C...
 
08.09.2018 Tax Considerations in M&A for for Buyers and Sellers
08.09.2018 Tax Considerations in M&A for for Buyers and Sellers08.09.2018 Tax Considerations in M&A for for Buyers and Sellers
08.09.2018 Tax Considerations in M&A for for Buyers and Sellers
 
07.19.2018 Understanding the Sell Side M&A Process for a Private Company
07.19.2018 Understanding the Sell Side M&A Process for a Private Company07.19.2018 Understanding the Sell Side M&A Process for a Private Company
07.19.2018 Understanding the Sell Side M&A Process for a Private Company
 
06.20.2018 Third Party Funding of Internatinonal Arbitration
06.20.2018 Third Party Funding of Internatinonal Arbitration06.20.2018 Third Party Funding of Internatinonal Arbitration
06.20.2018 Third Party Funding of Internatinonal Arbitration
 
05.31.2018 Resolving Shareholder and Investor Disputes
05.31.2018 Resolving Shareholder and Investor Disputes05.31.2018 Resolving Shareholder and Investor Disputes
05.31.2018 Resolving Shareholder and Investor Disputes
 
05.15.2018 Mitigating Cyber Breach Liability for Companies and Board Members
05.15.2018 Mitigating Cyber Breach Liability for Companies and Board Members05.15.2018 Mitigating Cyber Breach Liability for Companies and Board Members
05.15.2018 Mitigating Cyber Breach Liability for Companies and Board Members
 
01.09.2018 Execution Excellence: Post-Merger Integration
01.09.2018 Execution Excellence: Post-Merger Integration01.09.2018 Execution Excellence: Post-Merger Integration
01.09.2018 Execution Excellence: Post-Merger Integration
 
12.19.2017 Multi-Jurisdictional Bankruptcies - Chapter 15
12.19.2017 Multi-Jurisdictional Bankruptcies - Chapter 1512.19.2017 Multi-Jurisdictional Bankruptcies - Chapter 15
12.19.2017 Multi-Jurisdictional Bankruptcies - Chapter 15
 
Understanding Claim History in M&A Insurance
Understanding Claim History in M&A InsuranceUnderstanding Claim History in M&A Insurance
Understanding Claim History in M&A Insurance
 
11.16.2017 Strategies for US Companies' Expansion Abroad
11.16.2017 Strategies for US Companies' Expansion Abroad11.16.2017 Strategies for US Companies' Expansion Abroad
11.16.2017 Strategies for US Companies' Expansion Abroad
 
10.26.2017 Raising Capital for Emerging Growth Companies
10.26.2017 Raising Capital for Emerging Growth Companies10.26.2017 Raising Capital for Emerging Growth Companies
10.26.2017 Raising Capital for Emerging Growth Companies
 
Mitigating Cyber Issues in M&A
Mitigating Cyber Issues in M&AMitigating Cyber Issues in M&A
Mitigating Cyber Issues in M&A
 
Expert Webcast Roundtable: Middle Market M&A and Private Equity Update 2017
Expert Webcast Roundtable: Middle Market M&A and Private Equity Update 2017Expert Webcast Roundtable: Middle Market M&A and Private Equity Update 2017
Expert Webcast Roundtable: Middle Market M&A and Private Equity Update 2017
 
Expert Webcast: Mastering Transactional Due Diligence
Expert Webcast: Mastering Transactional Due DiligenceExpert Webcast: Mastering Transactional Due Diligence
Expert Webcast: Mastering Transactional Due Diligence
 
5.25.2017 Getting Your Company Ready for Sale
5.25.2017 Getting Your Company Ready for Sale5.25.2017 Getting Your Company Ready for Sale
5.25.2017 Getting Your Company Ready for Sale
 
Duties of Officers and Directors of a Distressed Company
Duties of Officers and Directors of a Distressed CompanyDuties of Officers and Directors of a Distressed Company
Duties of Officers and Directors of a Distressed Company
 

Dernier

Call Girls In Noida 959961⊹3876 Independent Escort Service Noida
Call Girls In Noida 959961⊹3876 Independent Escort Service NoidaCall Girls In Noida 959961⊹3876 Independent Escort Service Noida
Call Girls In Noida 959961⊹3876 Independent Escort Service Noida
dlhescort
 
Call Girls in Delhi, Escort Service Available 24x7 in Delhi 959961-/-3876
Call Girls in Delhi, Escort Service Available 24x7 in Delhi 959961-/-3876Call Girls in Delhi, Escort Service Available 24x7 in Delhi 959961-/-3876
Call Girls in Delhi, Escort Service Available 24x7 in Delhi 959961-/-3876
dlhescort
 
Nelamangala Call Girls: 🍓 7737669865 🍓 High Profile Model Escorts | Bangalore...
Nelamangala Call Girls: 🍓 7737669865 🍓 High Profile Model Escorts | Bangalore...Nelamangala Call Girls: 🍓 7737669865 🍓 High Profile Model Escorts | Bangalore...
Nelamangala Call Girls: 🍓 7737669865 🍓 High Profile Model Escorts | Bangalore...
amitlee9823
 
Call Girls In DLf Gurgaon ➥99902@11544 ( Best price)100% Genuine Escort In 24...
Call Girls In DLf Gurgaon ➥99902@11544 ( Best price)100% Genuine Escort In 24...Call Girls In DLf Gurgaon ➥99902@11544 ( Best price)100% Genuine Escort In 24...
Call Girls In DLf Gurgaon ➥99902@11544 ( Best price)100% Genuine Escort In 24...
lizamodels9
 
Russian Call Girls In Gurgaon ❤️8448577510 ⊹Best Escorts Service In 24/7 Delh...
Russian Call Girls In Gurgaon ❤️8448577510 ⊹Best Escorts Service In 24/7 Delh...Russian Call Girls In Gurgaon ❤️8448577510 ⊹Best Escorts Service In 24/7 Delh...
Russian Call Girls In Gurgaon ❤️8448577510 ⊹Best Escorts Service In 24/7 Delh...
lizamodels9
 
Call Now ☎️🔝 9332606886🔝 Call Girls ❤ Service In Bhilwara Female Escorts Serv...
Call Now ☎️🔝 9332606886🔝 Call Girls ❤ Service In Bhilwara Female Escorts Serv...Call Now ☎️🔝 9332606886🔝 Call Girls ❤ Service In Bhilwara Female Escorts Serv...
Call Now ☎️🔝 9332606886🔝 Call Girls ❤ Service In Bhilwara Female Escorts Serv...
Anamikakaur10
 
unwanted pregnancy Kit [+918133066128] Abortion Pills IN Dubai UAE Abudhabi
unwanted pregnancy Kit [+918133066128] Abortion Pills IN Dubai UAE Abudhabiunwanted pregnancy Kit [+918133066128] Abortion Pills IN Dubai UAE Abudhabi
unwanted pregnancy Kit [+918133066128] Abortion Pills IN Dubai UAE Abudhabi
Abortion pills in Kuwait Cytotec pills in Kuwait
 
Call Girls Electronic City Just Call 👗 7737669865 👗 Top Class Call Girl Servi...
Call Girls Electronic City Just Call 👗 7737669865 👗 Top Class Call Girl Servi...Call Girls Electronic City Just Call 👗 7737669865 👗 Top Class Call Girl Servi...
Call Girls Electronic City Just Call 👗 7737669865 👗 Top Class Call Girl Servi...
amitlee9823
 
Chandigarh Escorts Service 📞8868886958📞 Just📲 Call Nihal Chandigarh Call Girl...
Chandigarh Escorts Service 📞8868886958📞 Just📲 Call Nihal Chandigarh Call Girl...Chandigarh Escorts Service 📞8868886958📞 Just📲 Call Nihal Chandigarh Call Girl...
Chandigarh Escorts Service 📞8868886958📞 Just📲 Call Nihal Chandigarh Call Girl...
Sheetaleventcompany
 

Dernier (20)

The Path to Product Excellence: Avoiding Common Pitfalls and Enhancing Commun...
The Path to Product Excellence: Avoiding Common Pitfalls and Enhancing Commun...The Path to Product Excellence: Avoiding Common Pitfalls and Enhancing Commun...
The Path to Product Excellence: Avoiding Common Pitfalls and Enhancing Commun...
 
Value Proposition canvas- Customer needs and pains
Value Proposition canvas- Customer needs and painsValue Proposition canvas- Customer needs and pains
Value Proposition canvas- Customer needs and pains
 
Call Girls In Noida 959961⊹3876 Independent Escort Service Noida
Call Girls In Noida 959961⊹3876 Independent Escort Service NoidaCall Girls In Noida 959961⊹3876 Independent Escort Service Noida
Call Girls In Noida 959961⊹3876 Independent Escort Service Noida
 
Dr. Admir Softic_ presentation_Green Club_ENG.pdf
Dr. Admir Softic_ presentation_Green Club_ENG.pdfDr. Admir Softic_ presentation_Green Club_ENG.pdf
Dr. Admir Softic_ presentation_Green Club_ENG.pdf
 
Call Girls Service In Old Town Dubai ((0551707352)) Old Town Dubai Call Girl ...
Call Girls Service In Old Town Dubai ((0551707352)) Old Town Dubai Call Girl ...Call Girls Service In Old Town Dubai ((0551707352)) Old Town Dubai Call Girl ...
Call Girls Service In Old Town Dubai ((0551707352)) Old Town Dubai Call Girl ...
 
RSA Conference Exhibitor List 2024 - Exhibitors Data
RSA Conference Exhibitor List 2024 - Exhibitors DataRSA Conference Exhibitor List 2024 - Exhibitors Data
RSA Conference Exhibitor List 2024 - Exhibitors Data
 
Mysore Call Girls 8617370543 WhatsApp Number 24x7 Best Services
Mysore Call Girls 8617370543 WhatsApp Number 24x7 Best ServicesMysore Call Girls 8617370543 WhatsApp Number 24x7 Best Services
Mysore Call Girls 8617370543 WhatsApp Number 24x7 Best Services
 
Call Girls in Delhi, Escort Service Available 24x7 in Delhi 959961-/-3876
Call Girls in Delhi, Escort Service Available 24x7 in Delhi 959961-/-3876Call Girls in Delhi, Escort Service Available 24x7 in Delhi 959961-/-3876
Call Girls in Delhi, Escort Service Available 24x7 in Delhi 959961-/-3876
 
B.COM Unit – 4 ( CORPORATE SOCIAL RESPONSIBILITY ( CSR ).pptx
B.COM Unit – 4 ( CORPORATE SOCIAL RESPONSIBILITY ( CSR ).pptxB.COM Unit – 4 ( CORPORATE SOCIAL RESPONSIBILITY ( CSR ).pptx
B.COM Unit – 4 ( CORPORATE SOCIAL RESPONSIBILITY ( CSR ).pptx
 
Nelamangala Call Girls: 🍓 7737669865 🍓 High Profile Model Escorts | Bangalore...
Nelamangala Call Girls: 🍓 7737669865 🍓 High Profile Model Escorts | Bangalore...Nelamangala Call Girls: 🍓 7737669865 🍓 High Profile Model Escorts | Bangalore...
Nelamangala Call Girls: 🍓 7737669865 🍓 High Profile Model Escorts | Bangalore...
 
Call Girls In DLf Gurgaon ➥99902@11544 ( Best price)100% Genuine Escort In 24...
Call Girls In DLf Gurgaon ➥99902@11544 ( Best price)100% Genuine Escort In 24...Call Girls In DLf Gurgaon ➥99902@11544 ( Best price)100% Genuine Escort In 24...
Call Girls In DLf Gurgaon ➥99902@11544 ( Best price)100% Genuine Escort In 24...
 
👉Chandigarh Call Girls 👉9878799926👉Just Call👉Chandigarh Call Girl In Chandiga...
👉Chandigarh Call Girls 👉9878799926👉Just Call👉Chandigarh Call Girl In Chandiga...👉Chandigarh Call Girls 👉9878799926👉Just Call👉Chandigarh Call Girl In Chandiga...
👉Chandigarh Call Girls 👉9878799926👉Just Call👉Chandigarh Call Girl In Chandiga...
 
Russian Call Girls In Gurgaon ❤️8448577510 ⊹Best Escorts Service In 24/7 Delh...
Russian Call Girls In Gurgaon ❤️8448577510 ⊹Best Escorts Service In 24/7 Delh...Russian Call Girls In Gurgaon ❤️8448577510 ⊹Best Escorts Service In 24/7 Delh...
Russian Call Girls In Gurgaon ❤️8448577510 ⊹Best Escorts Service In 24/7 Delh...
 
Call Now ☎️🔝 9332606886🔝 Call Girls ❤ Service In Bhilwara Female Escorts Serv...
Call Now ☎️🔝 9332606886🔝 Call Girls ❤ Service In Bhilwara Female Escorts Serv...Call Now ☎️🔝 9332606886🔝 Call Girls ❤ Service In Bhilwara Female Escorts Serv...
Call Now ☎️🔝 9332606886🔝 Call Girls ❤ Service In Bhilwara Female Escorts Serv...
 
Phases of Negotiation .pptx
 Phases of Negotiation .pptx Phases of Negotiation .pptx
Phases of Negotiation .pptx
 
unwanted pregnancy Kit [+918133066128] Abortion Pills IN Dubai UAE Abudhabi
unwanted pregnancy Kit [+918133066128] Abortion Pills IN Dubai UAE Abudhabiunwanted pregnancy Kit [+918133066128] Abortion Pills IN Dubai UAE Abudhabi
unwanted pregnancy Kit [+918133066128] Abortion Pills IN Dubai UAE Abudhabi
 
Call Girls Electronic City Just Call 👗 7737669865 👗 Top Class Call Girl Servi...
Call Girls Electronic City Just Call 👗 7737669865 👗 Top Class Call Girl Servi...Call Girls Electronic City Just Call 👗 7737669865 👗 Top Class Call Girl Servi...
Call Girls Electronic City Just Call 👗 7737669865 👗 Top Class Call Girl Servi...
 
Enhancing and Restoring Safety & Quality Cultures - Dave Litwiller - May 2024...
Enhancing and Restoring Safety & Quality Cultures - Dave Litwiller - May 2024...Enhancing and Restoring Safety & Quality Cultures - Dave Litwiller - May 2024...
Enhancing and Restoring Safety & Quality Cultures - Dave Litwiller - May 2024...
 
Organizational Transformation Lead with Culture
Organizational Transformation Lead with CultureOrganizational Transformation Lead with Culture
Organizational Transformation Lead with Culture
 
Chandigarh Escorts Service 📞8868886958📞 Just📲 Call Nihal Chandigarh Call Girl...
Chandigarh Escorts Service 📞8868886958📞 Just📲 Call Nihal Chandigarh Call Girl...Chandigarh Escorts Service 📞8868886958📞 Just📲 Call Nihal Chandigarh Call Girl...
Chandigarh Escorts Service 📞8868886958📞 Just📲 Call Nihal Chandigarh Call Girl...
 

5 9 presentation final 1

  • 1. Panel: David S. Kupetz, Partner, SulmeyerKupetz George P. Blanco, Partner, Avant Advisory Group Steve J. Cupingood, CPA, Partner, SingerLewak Mitchell Cohen, EVP; CIT Trade Finance Moderator: Alexander B. Kasdan, Managing Director, DelMorgan & Co. Event Organized by Anna Spektor, Founder and President, Expert Presence ALTERNATIVES FOR A DISTRESSED COMPANY IN APPARELAND RETAIL May 9, 2013
  • 2. 1 David S. Kupetz, a member of SulmeyerKupetz, specializes in troubled transactions, crisis avoidance consultation, workouts, restructurings, reorganizations, bankruptcies, receiverships, assignments for the benefit of creditors and other non bankruptcy insolvency proceedings. He represents debtors (in restructurings and workouts and in chapter 11 reorganization cases), secured creditors, unsecured creditors' committees, assignees for the benefit of creditors, buyers/sellers of businesses/assets in distressed circumstances and other entities in insolvency and bankruptcy situations. A sampling of clients represented by Mr. Kupetz includes: Care Enterprises, Inc. (debtor in possession); Ocean Pacific Sunwear, Ltd. (debtor in possession); County of Los Angeles (creditor); General Electric Capital Corporation (secured lender); Litton Industries, Inc. (creditor); Boston West, LLC (Boston Markets) (debtor in possession); ExxonMobil Corporation (creditor); Honda Trading Co. (creditor); CKE Restaurants (creditor); San Diego Television, Inc. (debtor in possession); South Bay Pizza, Inc. (debtor in possession); Transgo Corp. (unsecured creditors’ committees); Aura Systems, Inc. (out-of- court unsecured creditors’ committee); Snow Valley, LLC (debtor in possession); Gardenburger, Inc. (debtor in possession); eStyle, Inc. (debtor in possession); American Home (debtor in possession); No Fear Retail Stores, Inc. (debtor in possession); and Ventura Port District (chapter 9 debtor). His many articles on bankruptcy related subjects have been published in The Business Lawyer, Commercial Law Journal, IDEA: The Journal of Law and Technology, Journal of Bankruptcy Law and Practice, The Annual Survey of Bankruptcy Law, The Urban Lawyer, The Banking Law Journal, Los Angeles Lawyer, California Lawyer, Commercial Law Bulletin, Los Angeles Daily Journal, The Secured Lender, The Journal of Private Equity, The Journal of Corporate Renewal, Public Law Journal, Federal Lawyer and many other publications. Mr. Kupetz served as the author of Collier Commercial Bankruptcy Forms for many years and currently is the author of the Collier Handbook for Creditors' Committees. Mr. Kupetz is a frequent lecturer on reorganization and other insolvency topics. Mr. Kupetz was admitted to the California bar in 1986. He obtained his legal education at the University of California, Hastings College of the Law (J.D., 1986). 333 South Hope Street 35th Floor Los Angeles CA 90071 (213) 617-5274 dkupetz@sulmeyerlaw.com www.sulmeyerlaw.com
  • 3. 2 George P. Blanco, Managing Director and Partner, Avant Advisory Group, has more than 25 years of senior executive and consulting experience in financial and operational management high growth and financially distressed companies. His crisis and turnaround management experience includes operational and financial restructuring, cost reduction programs, reorganizations in bankruptcy, negotiations with lenders and creditors, and capital sourcing. In addition to chief restructuring officer (“CRO”) roles, he also has served as CFO of a public company and CEO of a telecommunications provider. George is a Certified Insolvency and Restructuring Advisor (“CIRA”), having served more than 12 years in the Big 4 accounting and consulting firm environment. In his 30 years of consulting and senior-level experience, he has served as partner and managing director in consulting, financial advisory and the corporate recovery practices of PricewaterhouseCoopers and AlixPartners. George is experienced in manufacturing plant consolidations, supply chain/logistics, management business process re-engineering, operational restructuring, financial and manufacturing systems implementation, post-acquisition integration and working capital improvement for both middle-market and “Fortune 500” companies across multiple industries. George has taught classes in Total Quality Management and participated on numerous panels involving operational restructuring and profitability improvement. In addition to being a CIRA, he earned his MBA in finance from the UCLAAnderson Graduate School of Management and his BA in economics and accounting from Claremont McKenna College. 601 South Figueroa Street, Suite 4050 Los Angeles CA 90017 (213) 479-7900 GBlanco@AvantAdvisory.com www.AvantAdvisory.com
  • 4. 3 Steve J. Cupingood leads SingerLewak’s firm-wide Tax practice and he is the Los Angeles Office Lead Partner. Steve has over 24 years of experience in individual and business entity taxation (including with shareholders and partners). He has significant experience with nonprofits as well as with high net worth individuals. In addition to possessing strong technical expertise, Steve has extensive consulting experience in tax planning, research and compliance services. A significant portion of Steve’s professional experience includes over six years in the tax department of a large international accounting firm. Steve received his Bachelors of Science degree in Business Administration with an Accounting major from California State University, Northridge, in 1984. He is a Certified Public Accountant and a member of the American Institute of Certified Public Accountants and the California Society of CPAs. 10960 Wilshire Blvd. Suite 700 Los Angeles CA 900241 (310) 477-3924 scupingood@singerlewak.com www.singerlewak.com
  • 5. 4 Mitch Cohen is Executive Vice President - Managing Director and Western Regional Manager of CIT Trade Finance, responsible for client service and retention, business development and client credit quality. He has more than 30 years experience in the financing industry. His responsibilities include client service and retention, ensuring client credit quality and profitability, and new business development throughout the Western United States, as well as CIT’s Hong Kong office. Mitch’s areas of expertise include factoring and credit protection solutions for companies that want to increase sales, improve cash flow, reduce operating expenses and eliminate customer credit losses, and financing solutions for consumer products companies (apparel, footwear, housewares, furniture and home furnishings). Mitch has more than 30 years of experience in the financing industry. Prior to joining CIT, he served as Senior Vice President for Bank of Newport. Prior to this, he was Senior Vice President with Mitsui Manufacturers Bank. In 2004, Cohen was honored with the Spirit of Life Award by the Apparel Industries Group for the City of Hope and was the recipient of the 1999 Humanitarian Award from the National Jewish Medical and Research Center. Mitch earned a bachelor’s degree in accounting from the State University of New York and is a graduate of the University of Washington’s Pacific Coast Banking School. He also completed the Wharton Executive Development Program. 300 S Grand Ave #12 Los Angeles CA 90071 (213) 613-2416 mitchell.cohen@cit.com www.cit.com
  • 6. 5 Alexander B. Kasdan is a Managing Director at DelMorgan & Co. He has more than twenty years of investment banking, real estate, corporate law and corporate strategy experience. Alex has executed over 100 domestic and cross-border transactions totaling more than $10 billion in overall volume in a variety of industries. Prior to joining DelMorgan, Alex founded and ran Convergence Capital Partners, LLC, a boutique investment banking advisory firm and was an investment banker at Barrington Associates in Los Angeles, where he headed the restructuring group, Peter J. Solomon Company, Credit Suisse First Boston and Merrill Lynch. Alex practiced law with O’Melveny & Myers LLP (formerly O’Sullivan Graev & Karabell LLP) and Paul, Hastings, Janofsky & Walker LLP (formerly Battle Fowler LLP), where he specialized in mergers and acquisitions, private equity and corporate finance transactions. In addition, Alex served as Corporate Counsel in charge of business development at Schlumberger Ltd., a global oilfield and information services company. Alex graduated magna cum laude from Middlebury College with a B.A. degree in Economics and Italian and was elected to Phi Beta Kappa during his junior year. In addition, he holds a J.D. degree from Columbia University Law School and has studied at the University of Florence in Italy. Alex is admitted to the Bar in the State of New York. Alex is a Senior Advisor to Governance and Transactions LLC, an advisory firm established in 2003 by Mr. James L. Gunderson, former Secretary and General Counsel of Schlumberger Limited, to assist boards, management and owners with corporate governance, compliance, structuring and strategic transactions. 100 Wilshire Blvd. Suite 750 Santa Monica, CA 90401 (310) 980-1718 www.delmorganco.com www.cvgpartners.com ak@cvgpartners.com
  • 7. 6 Anna Spektor, the Founder and President of Expert Presence, specializes in digital and event marketing, public relations and brand communications programs for professional services firms. As a business development consultant, Anna helps clients develop and implement comprehensive strategies designed to generate new and solidify existing referral relationship, elevate profile, and build brand awareness. Anna is also the founder of Expert Forum and Expert Webcast, affiliate companies focused on providing the professional community with quality educational content, continuing professional education and targeted networking opportunities. 1999 Avenue of the Stars Suite 1100 Los Angeles, CA 90067 (310) 995-6579 www.expertpresence.com anna@expertpresence.com
  • 8. 7 Alternatives for a Distressed Company in Apparel and Retail David S. Kupetz
  • 9. 8 Common Fatal Errors by Retailers •  Failure to engage an experienced turnaround professionals to guide a return to profitability •  Failure to quickly arrest cash hemorrhaging •  Failure to engage merchandisers to refocus the marketing strategy •  Insufficient focus on core business strength •  Closing too few stores and taking too long to close them •  Failure to rationalize the administrative structure of the operations •  Failure to integrate different concepts in the same management information system •  Disastrous acquisitions
  • 10. 9 Repositioning •  Many retail failures are caused by rapid expansion, mismanagement or too much leverage. •  A significant number of failures occur as a result of being out of step with the market and losing touch with the client base that made a company successful in the first place. •  The fashion industry is particularly susceptible.
  • 11. 10 Transaction Structures •  Chapter 11 –  Section 363 Sale –  Plan of Reorganization •  Assignment for the Benefit of Creditors (ABC) •  Friendly Foreclosure •  Receiverships •  Out-of-court workouts/debt restructurings •  Acquisition of secured debt to be followed by foreclosure or one of other distressed transaction structures •  Chapter 7
  • 12. 11 Legal Developments/Issues •  Secured Creditor Cannot be Stripped of Right to Credit Bid Under Chapter 11 Plan Providing for Sale –  RadLAX Gateway Hotel, LLC v. Amalgamated Bank, 132 S. Ct. 2065 (2012) •  Uncertainty Regarding Trademark Licensee’s Right to Retain License if Licensor Files Bankruptcy –  Lubrizol (4th Cir. 1985) –  Bankruptcy Code § 365(n) (1988) –  Sunbeam (7th Cir. 2012) •  Cap on Time (210 days) to Decide Whether to Assume or Reject Leases under Which Debtor is Lessee •  Administrative Priority for § 503(b)(9) Reclamation Claims
  • 13. 12 Selected Southern CA Case Studies •  ABC – Acquisition of Assets of Fortune Fashion Industries by Jerry Leigh of California –  Apparel Manufacturer –  Secured Lenders Undersecured and Consented to ABC Transaction –  Seamless Transaction Executed Upon Commencement of ABC •  Section 363 Sales by No Fear Retail Stores –  Apparel Licensor & Retailer –  Expedited Sale Process –  Separate, Contemporaneous Sales Completed for IP Rights and Retail Assets •  Chapter 11 Plan by American Home –  Furniture Retailer –  Liquidated Arizona Stores Upon Commencement of Case to Pay Off Secured Lender –  Reorganized Around Core New Mexico locations and Restructured Unsecured Debt Under Chapter 11 Plan
  • 14. 13 Alternatives for a Distressed Company in Apparel and Retail Alexander B. Kasdan, Managing Director
  • 15. 14 Capital Markets Overview •  As of December 31, 2012 the S&P 500 Retailing Index and the S&P 500 Consumer Durables & Apparel Index increased by 25% and 19%, respectively, over prior year levels while outperforming the S&P 500 by 11% and 6%, respectively •  The equity markets displayed overall strength and investor demand •  Several initial and secondary public equity offerings were completed in 2012
  • 16. 15 Annual M&A Activity •  Overall M&A activity in the Consumer & Retail industry remains healthy with190 closed transactions during 2012 •  The total value of completed M&A transactions in the Consumer & Retail industry increased 41% to $66.6 billion •  Transactions with values less than $500 million represented approximately 86% of total deal volume and 32% of total deal value
  • 17. 16 Apparel Manufacturing Employment •  Employment has declined by more than 80% in the last two decades •  The decline has been proportional throughout the component industries Source: U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics.
  • 18. 17 Productivity-Output Per Hour •  Labor productivity in the U.S. manufacturing sector, textile mills and footwear manufacturing more than or nearly doubled from1987 to 2010 •  Labor productivity in apparel manufacturing grew at about the same rate as overall manufacturing productivity from 1987 to 2000 but generally declined from 2000 to 2010 Source: U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics.
  • 19. 18 Producer Prices in Apparel •  Producer Price Index (PPI) for fabric mills, a major component in textile-related production, increased significantly from October 2010 until September 2011 •  PPI increases for other industries such as footwear manufacturing and for accessories and other apparel were more muted until December 2011 Source: U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics.
  • 21. Discussion-Points-   Why$consider$distressed$M&A$   Current$market$condi6ons$for$buying$distressed$companies$   The$economic$recovery$has$not$salvaged$underperforming$companies$   More$defaults$on$the$horizon$as$companies$lack$liquidity$   Their$capital$structures$remain$over@leveraged$and$expected$revenue$increases$ have$not$transpired$   Are$there$“Zombie$companies”$that$can$be$returned$to$life?$$$   Where$do$you$find$them$and$how$do$you$return$them$to$value?$   Diligence$on$distressed$company$assets$is$different$than$the$more$typical$quality$of$ earnings$report$   Beware&of&the&“mel1ng&ice&cub”& 2$
  • 22. 3$ Why-Consider-Distressed-M&A?-   Healthy-companies-are$purchased$at$fair$market$value$with$compe66ve$bidding;$$ and$without-organic-growth-or$simple$roll@up$strategies,$incremental-value-is-hard- to-obtain-   Substan*al-Economic-Upside-   Financially$distressed$–$i.e.,$good$company$with$bad$balance$sheet$   Opera6onally$distressed$–$e.g.,$6ghtening$margins,$broken$economic$model,$ bad$management,$slow$reac6on$to$economic$market$condi6ons$   Distressed$companies$have$fewer-buyers-due-to-perceived-risk-   Distressed$acquisi6on$can-be-very-risky-for$the$less$experienced$   Requires-special-skill-set-and$investment$criteria$/$risk$tolerance$   Assets$can$be$purchased$at$deep-discounts-
  • 23. 4$ Bankruptcy-Sales-&-The-Current-Market-   Bankruptcy-sales-increased-significantly-during-the-height-of-the-recent-U.S.-financial-crisis;-but$ subsequently,$ the$ pace$ has$ decreased,$ consistent$ with$ trends$ in$ loan$ default$ rates$ and$ bankruptcy$filings$   Lenders-pulled-back-from-calling-defaults-and-threatening-remedies-in-light-of-the-decline- in-middlePmarket-valua*on-mul*ples,-and-weak-collateral-values-   Forces$that$con6nue$to$drive$bankruptcy$sales,$include:$$   Increasing-amounts-of-private-capital-seeking-higher$returns$from$distressed$situa6ons$   Increasing-cost-/-complexity-of-the-Chapter-11-process,$which$mo6vates$diverse$groups$of$ creditors$to$push$for$the$speed$and$certainty$achieved$in$a$distressed$sale$ - 57 70 67 75 100 125 173 153 157 136 168 103 125 147 107 91 61 0 20 40 60 80 100 120 140 160 180 200 1Q08 2Q08 3Q08 4Q08 1Q09 2Q09 3Q09 4Q09 1Q10 2Q10 3Q10 4Q10 1Q11 2Q11 3Q11 4Q11 1Q12 Number of Bankruptcy Sales Source: Capital IQ. Note: Includes all domestic targets and sellers that have filed for bankruptcy.
  • 24. 5$ Window-of-Opportunity$   Impending-spike-of-loan-maturi*es-in-2012P2014-as$a$catalyst$for$increased$restructuring$ac6vity$   AmendPtoPextend-ac*vity-and$new$bond$issuances$con6nue$to$push$out$the$maturity$schedule$   The-amount-of-loans-coming-due-is-s*ll-high,-but-declining-@@$by$the$end$of$2014,$volume$fell$to$$90$ billion,$from$$145$billion$and$$260$billion$at$the$end$of$2011$and$2010,$respec6vely$   Constrained-capital-availability-@@$significant$loan$volume$coming$due$just$as$the$CLO’s$reinvestment$ windows$close$(assuming$the$market$for$new$CLO’s$remains$virtually$dead)$   Impact$of$low-interest-rates- $0B $50B $100B $150B $200B $250B $300B YE*2010 YE*2011 YE*2012 YE*2013 Source:(LCD(Es.mates( CLO-Vehicles-S*ll-in-Reinvestment-Period- Loan-Distribu*on-by-Year-of-Maturity- Source:(Standard(&(Poor’s(LCD( $0B $50B $100B $150B $200B 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 12/31/2010 12/31/2011 6/1/2012 The&broader&market&has&a&direct& impact&on&middle&and&lower& middle&market&transac1ons&
  • 25. 6$ The-Future-Outlook- The-Broader-Market-View-   Standard$&$Poor's$es6mates$that$around$$8.6$trillion$of$US$corporate$borrowings$(including$both$ rated$and$unrated$debt,$but$excluding$securi6zed$loans)$will$mature$and$require$refinancing$over$ the$next$5$years$   An$addi6onal$need$for$between$$2.5$to$$3$trillion$of$funding$for$corporate$growth,$ depending$on$the$level$of$GDP$growth$$   The$uncertain$economic$climate$creates$doubt$as$to$whether$the$capital$markets$will$be$able$to$ meet$this$$11$to$$11.5$trillion$capital$need$for$both$refinancing$and$growth$ Impact-on-the-Middle-Market-   The&resul1ng&capital&adequacy&constraints&and&uncertain1es&are&likely&to&create&financial&distress& for&the&weak&and&overGlevered&   Opportuni1es&for&the&distressed&investor&GG&the&need&for&valueGmaximizing&transac1ons&will&drive& capital&structures&   Alterna1ve&financing&as&an&op1on&for&geLng&invited&to&the&party?&&LoanGtoGOwn?&   Interest&rates&con1nue&to&be&low&except&for&alterna1ve&financing&op1ons& The&broader&market&has&a&direct&impact&on&middle&and&lower&middle&market&transac1ons&
  • 26. 7$ Where-to-Find-Deals- “Alterna*ve-financing-as-a-source-of-deal-flow”- $ Key-Sources:-   Investment$Bankers$–$seeking$“value$investors”;$broken$refinancing$deals$   Quasi$Investment$Bankers$–$finders$and$brokers$$@@$“Beware-of-incredible-projec*ons”$   Turnaround$Consultants$–$“rifle$shot$opportuni6es”$   Corporate$disposi6ons$–$usually$low$profile$with$a$high$opportunity$for$return$ Other-Sources:-   Commercial$lenders;$but$probably$through$a$“refinancing$opportunity”$that$turns$into$ a$sale$transac6on$   Finance$companies$that$provide$higher$leverage$with$higher$interest$rates;$more$ inclined$to$liquidate$for$force$a$“quick$sale”$ Opportunis*c-Sources:-   Akorneys$   CPA$/$audit$firms$
  • 27. Alterna*ves-To-Purchase-Distressed-Company-Assets- Alterna*ves- Opportuni*es-&-Risks- 1.--OutPofPCourt-Workout-   Out$of$court$workout$is$more$cost$effec6ve$than$alterna6ves$   Success$is$dependent$upon$all$par6cipants$agreeing$to$nego6ate$coopera6vely$ throughout$the$process$ 2.--Chapter-11-Reorganiza*on-   Secured$creditors$and$antagonis6c$unsecured$creditors$   May$dissipate$going$concern$/$value$of$estate$   Ability$to$deal$with$executory$contracts$   Purchase$assets$free$and$clear$@@$Bankruptcy$Code$Sec6on$363$–$Sale$Process$ 3.--Ar*cle-9-PP-“Friendly- Foreclosure”--   Secured$creditor$has$right$under$UCC$to$foreclose$and$sell$its$collateral$   Company$wants$to$sell$assets$quickly$to$a$friendly$buyer$who$will$con6nue$ business$as$a$going$concern$   Subject$to$“commercial$reasonableness,”$e.g.,$fair$value,$which$can$be$shown$ on$its$face,$if$secured$lender$discounts$its$debt$ 4.--Assignment-for-Benefit-of- Creditors-(ABC)--   Debtor$may$choose$assignee,$and$lender$may$have$input$into$debtor’s$choice$   Unhappy$creditors$may$s6ll$file$an$involuntary$bankruptcy$   Consent$of$landlords$and/or$other$par6es$may$be$necessary$to$sell$or$assign$ debtor’s$rights$under$contracts$(as$opposed$to$bankruptcy$court)$ 5.--OutPofPCourt-Liquida*on-–-Self- Liquida*on--   Reorganiza6on$is$not$possible$   No$discharge$of$liabili6es$   May$lose$value$of$opera6ng$company$ 6.--Chapter-7-Liquida*on--   Company$is$too$weak$or$prospect$of$success$unlikely$(plan$or$reorganiza6on$not$ feasible)$   Management$no$longer$involved,$as$Trustee$is$appointed$ 8$
  • 28. What-to-Consider-   Many$/distressed$acquisi6ons$have$phenomenal-economic-opportunity$   Substan*al-risk-for$those$not$experienced$or$that$do$not$understand$the$unique$complex$ legal,$opera6ng/business,$and$cash$flow$issues$in$this$space-   Don’t$venture$into$distressed$without$good-advisors-$ $   Poor-/-inadequate-due-diligence$onen6mes$results$from$the$accelerated-*me-frames$ imposed$by$the$“mel*ng-ice-cube”-environment$of$these$companies$   Risks$areas,$con6ngencies$and$“cash$burn”$are$onen$uniden6fied$or$misunderstood$by$those$ investors$/$buyers$acquiring$those$companies$ $   Go-beyond-the-numbers-as$the$accoun6ng$is$onen$broken$$$   “Quality$of$earnings”$and$adjusted$EBITDAs$may$not$apply$in$a$turnaround$ $   Do$not$underes6mate$that$distressed$situa6ons$require$significantly$greater$6me,$ effort,$and-a-different-kind-of-management-skill-set$ 9$
  • 29. Key-“TakePAway”-Considera*ons-   Due$diligence$with$an$opera6onal$focus$   Is-there-a-core-business-that-can-be-stripped-down-to-profitability?$$Buyers$ frequently$hope$they’ll$be$able$to$grow$their$way$back$out$   Is-there-sufficient-capital-to-get-to-a-closing;$before$you$lose$key$employees,$ contracts$and$customers?$   “Does-this-business-have-a-right-to-exist?”$$Is$there$sufficient$intellectual$ property$and$branding$to$support$future$opera6ons?$$   What$are$the$working-capital-requirements-for$aner$the$acquisi6on,$and$what$is$ the$6meline$to$complete$the$turnaround?$   Is$there$a$defensible-tac*cal-plan-and$a$viable$long@term$strategy?$   Think$about$successor-liability-and$how$to$mi6gate$   ”Peel$away$the$layers$of$the$onion”$before$you$commit,$and$know$when$to$cut$your$ losses$   Beware&of&the&“mel1ng&ice&cub”$   Ensure$the$Company$has$or$you$bring$in$strong-and-ethical-management-that$is$ experienced$and$comfortable-turning-around-a-company-   $That$is$more$cri6cal$than$ever$in$distressed$acquisi6ons$and$turnarounds$   The$100$day$plan$ $ 10$
  • 31. M&A-Ac*vity-and-Mul*ples- 12$   Middle@market$M&A$volume$is$picking$up$as$shown$ below$   The$gap$between$seller-expecta*ons-(~8x-EBITDA)- and$leverage-availability-(~4x-EBITDA),-remains$a$ challenge$for$financial$sponsors$with$high$return$ targets$   An6cipate$an$increase$in$distressed$M&A$ac6vity$as$ this$gap$closes,$and$lenders$begin$to$view$this$as$a$ feasible$alterna6ve$for$recovery$ Middle-Market-M&A-Volume-(1)- Middle-Market-LBO-Purchase-Price-Mul*ples- Source:(LCD(Comps( Source:&Thomson&One&Banker&Notes:&Includes&all&U.S.&announced&deals&with&transac1on&values&between&$20&mm&and&$1bn.&& & 7.6x 7.5x 7.1x 6.9x 5.9x 6.7x 7.0x 7.2x 8.5x 8.1x 9.3x 8.3x 6.6x 8.4x 8.2x 0.0x 2.0x 4.0x 6.0x 8.0x 10.0x 1997 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 Senior3D ebt/EBITDA Sub3D ebt/EBITD A Equity/EBITDA O thers $419 $235 $225 $240 $282 $327 $378 $411 $269 $170 $281 $297 2,559 1,611 1,573 1,682 1,783 2,025 2,263 2,250 1,680 1,107 1,561 1,606 0 500 1,000 1,500 2,000 2,500 3,000 $0B $50B $100B $150B $200B $250B $300B $350B $400B $450B 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 Deal2Value Number2of2Deals 4.8x 4.7x 4.1x 4.0x 3.4x 3.9x 3.8x 4.2x 4.7x 4.7x 5.6x 4.5x 3.3x 4.2x 4.3x 0.0x 2.0x 4.0x 6.0x 1997 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 FLD /EBITD A SLD /EBITDA O ther<Sr<D ebt/EBITD A Sub<D ebt/EBITD A Source:(LCD(Comps( Debt-Mul*ples-of-Middle-Market-LBO-Loans- (First-Lien-/-Second-Lien-Debt)-
  • 32. 13$ U.S.-Private-Equity-Capital-Overhang-   A$significant$driver$of$distressed$asset$sales$comes$from$the$availability$of$private$equity$capital$   The$quan6ty$of$“dry$powder”$in$the$hands$of$private$equity$groups$seeking$distressed$and$other$ opportuni6es$is$currently$close$to$$450$billion$of$total$private$equity$capital$(i.e.$uncalled$ commitments)$   Accordingly,$it$maybe$an$opportunis6c$6me$for$secured$creditors$to$consider$the$sale$alterna6ve$to$ mone6ze$their$exposure$in$certain$situa6ons$$PP-Selling&the&Zombie&Companies& $ U.S. Private Equity Overhang ($ in billions) Source: PitchBook Data – 2012 Capital Overhang and Fund Cash Flow Report. $463 $530 $576 $561 $477 $456 $67) $46) ($16) ($83) ($21) ($150) $0' $150' $300' $450' $600' $750' 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 Cumulative)O verhang Annual)O verhang
  • 33. 1 TAX CONSIDERATIONS FOR RETAIL AND APPAREL Steve J. Cupingood Tax Partner (310) 477 – 3924, Ext. 1353 scupingood@singerlewak.com
  • 34. 2 Cancellation of Indebtedness Income General'rule'–'a'discharge'of'debt'for'less'than'the'amount'due'must'be'recognized'as'taxable'income.'' Codified'in'IRC'Sec.'61(a)(12)'–'gross'income'includes'income'from'the'discharge'of'indebtedness.''' ' Income'recognized'is'generally'the'difference'between'the'face'amount'of'the'instrument'and'the'amount' paid'on'discharge.' ' The'debt'discharge'income'is'generally'taxed'at'ordinary'income'tax'rates.'' ' IRC'sec.'108(a)(1)'lists'four'situaIons'in'which'realized'debt'discharge'income'may'not'be'recognized'for' federal'income'tax'purposes.'Subject'to'numerous'other'rules'and'requirements,'nonMrecogniIon'may'occur' if:' ' '(A)'the'discharge'occurs'in'a'Itle'11'case;' '(B)'the'discharge'occurs'when'the'taxpayer'is'insolvent;'' '(C)'the'discharged'debt'is'qualified'farm'indebtedness;'or' '(D)'the'discharged'debt'is'qualified'real'property'business'indebtedness' ' The'IRC'defines'insolvency'to'mean'the'excess'of'liabiliIes'over'the'fair'market'value'of'assets'immediately' before'the'debt'discharge.' '
  • 35. 3 Tax Attribute Reduction When'debt'discharge'income'is'excluded'from'gross'income'under'the'insolvency' excepIon,'there'are'potenIal'prices.' ' In'some'cases,'I.R.C.'Sec.'108(b)'requires'an'offseVng'reducIon'of'tax'aWributes,'in'the' following'order:' ' 1.  NOLs'for'the'current'taxable'year'and'any'NOL'carryovers.' 2.  General'business'credits'under'I.R.C.'Sec.'38.' 3.  Minimum'tax'credits'available'under'I.R.C.''Sec.'53(b).' 4.  Capital'loss'carryovers.' 5.  Basis'in'property,'with'ordering'rules'in'I.R.C.'Sec.'1017.' 6.  Passive'acIvity'loss'and'credit'carryovers'under'I.R.C.'Sec.'469(b).' 7.  Foreign'tax'credit'carryovers.' ' ' '
  • 36. 4 What is the Research & Development Tax Credit? •  The'research'credit'( R&D'Credit )'is'a'tax'incenIve'for'performing'qualified' research'in'the'U.S.'' •  The'net'credit'is'equal'to'approximately'6.5%'of'qualified'research'expenditures.' •  About'35'states'have'enacted'some'type'of'R&D'credit.'' ' Profile'of'R&D'Candidate' •  Develops'and'manufactures'new'products' •  Improves'exisIng'products' •  Develops'or'improves'manufacturing'process' •  Has'filed'for'patents'–'Intellectual'property' •  Plant'improvements'–'new'machinery/process' •  Developed'soiware'for'internal'use'
  • 37. 5 What is Qualified Research ? •  Research'that'saIsfies'a' fourMpart'test 'is' Qualified'Research '(must'meet'ALL'4'parts).' •  Qualified'Research 'is'research'that'is:' 1.  Technological'in'Nature' 2.  Undertaken'to'Eliminate'Uncertainty' 3.  Undertaken'for'a'PermiWed'Purpose;'and' 4.  Consists'of'a'Process'of'ExperimentaIon' ' What'Expenses'Qualify'for'the'R&D'Credit:' •  Wages'–'employees 'WM2,'box'1'amount' •  Research,'direct'supervision,'direct'support' •  Supplies'–'nonMdepreciable'tangible'personal'property'used'or'consumed'in'the'research'process' •  Contract'Research'–'research'performed'by'nonMemployees' •  65%'Rule'–'65%'of'contract'research'is'eligible'
  • 38. 6 Research and Development Tax Incentives for the Apparel and Textiles Industry In'the'apparel'and'texIles'industry,'R&D'acIviIes'are'evidenced'in'the'design'and'development'of'new'garments,' shoes,'accessories,'texIles/fabrics,'chemical'and'topical'treatments,'and'embroidery'techniques.'Apparel' companies'at'any'stage'in'the'development'chain'can'have'qualifying'acIviIes,'from'the'texIle'mills,'to'the' design'houses,'to'the'manufacturing'plants.'' If'your'company'operates'in'the'apparel,'shoe,'or'texIle'industries,'there'is'a'strong'chance'that'you'would' benefit'from'an'R&D'tax'credit'study.'' ' Examples'of'apparel'and'texIle'innovaIons'eligible'for'R&D'tax'incenIves'include'the'following:' ' • Designing'new'garments'and'apparel'' • Designing'new'shoe'designs'' • Designing'innovaIve'shoe'fit'and'comfort'techniques'' • GeneraIng'prototypes'and'fit'samples'of'new'products'for'tesIng'and'validaIon'' • Developing'new'woven,'knit,'or'nonMwoven'texIles'' • Developing'new'or'improved'chemical'or'topical'treatments'' • Developing'new'or'improved'manufacturing'processes'' • Design'and'development'of'scaled'up'manufacturing'processes'' ' '
  • 39. 7 Section 363 Sales of Debtor Corporation Stock vs. Assets SecIon' 363' allows' for' the' courtMapproved' sale' of' either' the' assets' of' a' debtor' corporaIon'or'the'stock'of'a'debtor'corporaIon.' 'The'structuring'of'the'SecIon'363' sale' affects' the' immediate' income' tax' consequences' of' the' transacIon' to' both' the' buyer'corporaIon'and'the'seller'corporaIon.' ' For'example,'the'buyer'may'wish'to'keep'the'debtor'corporaIon'intact'and,'thereby,' preserve'the'debtor'income'tax'aWributes'such'as'its'net'operaIng'losses'(NOLs).' 'In' that'case,'the'buyer'will'prefer'to'purchase'the'debtor'corporaIon'stock.' ' However,'if'the'buyer'cannot'use'the'debtor'income'tax'aWributes,'then'the'buyer'may' prefer'to'purchase'the'debtor'corporaIon'assets.' 'That'way,'the'buyer'can'obtain'a' stepMup'in'the'depreciable'tax'basis'of'the'acquired'debtor'assets.''This'tax'basis'stepM up' can' result' in' future' depreciaIon' or' amorIzaIon' income' tax' deducIons' for' the' buyer.' '
  • 40. 8 Section 363 Sales of Debtor Corporation Stock vs. Assets On'the'other'hand,'the'debtor'corporaIon'will'generally'want'to'minimize'the'taxable' income'recognized'on'the'sale'of'either'its'stock'or'its'assets.' 'The'seller s'ability'to' minimize'the'reported'income'on'the'sale'will'depend'on:' 1.  The'debtor s'tax'basis'in'the'corporaIon'stock'or'the'corporaIon'assets,' 2.  The'availability'of'offseVng'losses,'and' 3.  The' realizaIon' of' any' cancellaIon' of' debt' (COD)' income' related' to' the' bankruptcy'or'reorganizaIon.' The'debtor'corporaIon'may'be'able'to'indefinitely'defer'the'recogniIon'of'the'gain'on' the'transacIon'by'structuring'the'SecIon'363'sale'as'a'taxMfree'reorganizaIon'under' Internal'Revenue'Code'SecIon'368.' ' '
  • 41. 9 Section 363 Sales of Debtor Corporation Stock vs. Assets Typically,'either'the'debtor'corporaIon'assets'or'stock'are'sold'in'a'taxable'SecIon'363' sale,'the'debtor'will'recognize'either'a'gain'or'loss.''The'amount'of'the'taxable'gain'or' loss'will'be'equal'to'the'difference'between:' 1.  The'amount'realized'from'the'sale'and' 2.  The'seller s'adjusted'tax'basis'of'the'transferred'property.' ' The' amount' realized' from' the' SecIon' 363' sale' includes' all' of' the' consideraIon' received'by'the'seller.''This'consideraIon'includes'the'following:' 1.  Cash' 2.  The'fair'market'value'of'any'property'received'from'the'buyer' 3.  Any'liabiliIes'assumed'by'the'buyer' 4.  The'issue'price'of'any'debt'instrument'issued'by'the'buyer' ' '
  • 42. 10 Additional Items to Consider with Acquisitions in Bankruptcy AcquisiIons'from'a'bankruptcy'estate'can'be'subject'to'a'number'of'taxes,'such'as'real'estate'transfer'taxes'and' sales'taxes,'that'could'apply'to'transfers'of'assets.' 'The'U.S.'Bankruptcy'Code'contains'an'excepIon'for'some' transfer'taxes,'though'it'does'not'apply'in'all'circumstances.' ' Further,' acquisiIons' could' trigger' changeMofMcontrol' provisions' in' property' tax' statutes,' which' may' lead' to' a' revaluaIon'of'real'estate'and'an'increase'in'property'tax'rates.' ' Internal'Revenue'Code'SecIon'382'limits'the'use'of'the'acquired'debtor'corporaIon'NOLs'and'capital'losses'(and' certain'builtMin'losses).' 'SecIon'382'applies'to'a'transacIon'where'a'greater'than'50'percent'change'in'stock' ownership'of'the'loss'corporaIon'occurred'during'a'three'–year'period'(called'an'“ownership'change”).' ' If'there'is'an'ownership'change,'SecIon'382'places'an'annual'limit'on'the'amount'of'taxable'income'aier'the' ownership'change'that'may'be'offset'by'the'loss'corporaIon'NOL'carryovers'arising'before'the'ownership'change.' ' '
  • 43. 11 Section 199 – Domestic Production Activities Deduction Taxpayer s'who'manufacture'or'produce'goods,'develop'or'improve'qualifying'producIon'property'may'' qualify'for'the'DomesIc'ProducIon'AcIviIes'DeducIon'(DPAD)'on'their'federal'income'tax'return.'This'tax'' deducIon'is'9%'of'the'smaller'of:' ' •  the'qualified'producIon'acIviIes'income'(QPAI),'or'' •  taxable'income'figured'without'the'DPAD'' ''' Qualified'ProducIon'AcIviIes' '' Qualified'producIon'acIviIes'eligible'for'claiming'the'deducIon'under'IRC'SecIon'199:' •  Manufacturing'based'in'the'United'States,' •  Selling,'leasing,'or'licensing'items'that'have'been'manufactured'in'the'United'States,' •  Selling,'leasing,'or'licensing'moIon'pictures'that'have'been'produced'in'the'United'States,' •  ConstrucIon' services' in' the' United' States,' including' building' and' renovaIon' of' residenIal' and' commercial'properIes,' •  Engineering'and'architectural'services'relaIng'to'a'USMbased'construcIon'project,' •  Soiware'development'in'the'United'States,'including'the'development'of'video'games.'' ' '
  • 44. 12 IC-DISC – Interest Charge Domestic International Sales Corporation What'is'an'ICMDISC?' ' The'ICMDISC'( Interest'Charged'DomesIc'InternaIonal'Sales'CorporaIon )'was'designed'as'a'tax'incenIve'for'small'to'midsized'' U.S.'ExporIng'companies.'The'boWom'line'is'that'the'tax'laws'provide'an'opportunity'for'a'company'to'use'an'ICMDISC'to'have'' the'tax'on'50%'of'its'export'income'reduced'by'more'than'50%.''Profits'are'taxed'at'the'dividend'rate'(currently'5%'or'20%' depending'on'AGI)'as'opposed'to'ordinary'income'tax'rates'(top'rate'currently'35%).' ' How'does'it'work?' ' The'exporter'pays'a'commission'to'the'ICMDISC.''The'commissions'are'deducIble'to'the'exporter,'and'the'' deemed'or'actual'dividend'payment'of'the'commission'income'in'the'ICMDISC'is'taxed'to'the'exporter s'shareholders/partners'' at'the'23.8%'rate'(as'opposed'to'being'taxed'as'ordinary'income'–'ex.'35%'rate).''' ' At'the'end'of'the'day,'the'exporter'receives'a'deducIon'of'35%'on'the'commission'payments'made'to'the'ICMDISC'and'on'the'' other'hand'only'pays'a'23.8%'tax'rate'on'the'income'repatriated'from'the'ICMDISC.''The'boWom'line'is'a'permanent'tax'savings'' for'U.S.'exporters'and'their'shareholders'of'10%'or'higher'of'net'export'income.''' '
  • 45. 13 IC-DISC – Interest Charge Domestic International Sales Corporation What'is'an'ICMDISC?' ' The'ICMDISC'( Interest'Charged'DomesIc'InternaIonal'Sales'CorporaIon )'was'designed'as'a'tax'incenIve'for'small'to'midsized'' U.S.'ExporIng'companies.'The'boWom'line'is'that'the'tax'laws'provide'an'opportunity'for'a'company'to'use'an'ICMDISC'to'have'' the'tax'on'50%'of'its'export'income'reduced'by'more'than'50%.''Profits'are'taxed'at'the'dividend'rate'(currently'15%)'as'' opposed'to'ordinary'income'tax'rates'(top'rate'currently'35%).' ' How'does'it'work?' ' In'a'nutshell'you'are'creaIng'a'separate'enIty'(or'someImes'several'enIIes'to'maximize'the'tax'benefits)'–'the' CorporaIon '' part'of'ICMDISC.''The'exporter'pays'commissions'to'the'ICMDISC.''The'commissions'are'deducIble'to'the'exporter,'and'the'' deemed'or'actual'dividend'payment'of'the'commission'income'in'the'ICMDISC'is'taxed'to'the'exporter s'shareholders/partners'' at'the'23.8%'rate'(as'opposed'to'being'taxed'as'ordinary'income'–'ex.'35%'rate).''' ' At'the'end'of'the'day,'the'exporter'receives'a'deducIon'of'35%'on'the'commission'payments'made'to'the'ICMDISC'and'on'the'' other'hand'only'pays'a'23.8%'tax'rate'on'the'income'repatriated'from'the'ICMDISC.''The'boWom'line'is'a'permanent'tax'savings'' for'U.S.'exporters'and'their'shareholders'of'10%'or'higher'of'net'export'income.''' '
  • 46. 14 IC-DISC – Interest Charge Domestic International Sales Corporation EXAMPLE:' ' ' Company(Without(an(IC/DISC' Foreign'Trading'Gross'Receipts' $10,000,000' Cost'of'Goods'Sold' $6,000,000' Selling,'General'and'AdministraIve' $3,000,000' Export'Net'Income' $1,000,000' Tax'Rate' 35%' Tax'Paid' $350,000' Company(With(an(IC/DISC' Foreign'Trading'Gross'Receipts' $10,000,000' '' '' Costs'of'Goods'Sold' $6,000,000' '' '' Selling,'General'and'AdministraIve' $3,000,000' 'CMCorp' ICMDISC' Export'Net'Income' $1,000,000' $1,000,000' '' ICMDISC'Commission'DeducIon' '' ($500,000)' $500,000' Tax'Base'Aier'ICMDISC'Commission' '' $500,000' $500,000' Tax'Rate' '' 35%' 23.8%' Tax'Paid' '' $175,000' $119,000' IC/DISC(Net(Tax(Savings($350,000(/(($175,000(+($119,000)(=($56,000'
  • 47. 15 Geographic Targeted Economics Development Areas (G-TEDAs) California'has'four'types'of'GMTEDAs.'Each'of'these'areas'have'related'tax'incenIve'benefits.'The' main'purpose'of'the'GMTEDAs'is'to'sImulate'and'encourage'business'investment'by'allowing'the' private' market' forces' to' revive' the' local' economy' and' job' creaIon' for' qualified' disadvantaged' individuals'in'state'designated'economically'distressed'areas.'' ' Enterprise'Zone'Benefits'  Hiring'Credits'  Sales'or'Use'Tax'Credits'  Business'Expense'DeducIon'  Net'Interest'DeducIon'   100%'Net'OperaIng'Loss'Carryover'(NOL)''   CarryMforward'for'15'years'  Local'Agency'IncenIves'may'also'be'available'(e.g.,'City'of'Los'Angeles'DWP'rate'discounts,'and' reduced'parking'ordinances).' '
  • 48. 16 Employee Hiring Credits ' The'EZ'Hiring'Credit'is'a'dollar&for&dollar'state'income'tax'credit:' '   Up'to'$37,440'per'qualified'employee'over'a'fiveMyear'Period'   $12,480'in'the'first'year'   The'credit'is'based'on'the'lesser'of'the'qualified'employee s'hourly'wage'paid'or' 150%'of'the'minimum'wage'   Voucher'confirming'eligibility'is'required'from'the'local'EZ'vouchering'agency' and'maintained'for'a'period'of'four'years'   Taxpayers'can'only'offset'tax'paid'with'EZ'credits' '