1. School Leadership Teams Workshop “It is about focusing on building a culture of quality data through professional development and web based dynamic inquiries for school improvement.” April 2010
2.
3. Today’s Agenda 8:30-9:15 Introductions, develop common knowledge about Data4SS 9:15-9:30 Understand the ESD’s role, vision and implementation plan 9:30-11:00 Creating a culture of quality data 11:00-12:00 How to use Data 4SS 12:00-12:45 Lunch! 12:45-2:45 Data mining time 2:45-3:00 Next steps
4. Building Background Knowledge “Which Came First: The Data or the Decision?” Read the article. Choose one sentence, one phrase, and one word that you believe captures the message of this article. Share your selections with your leadership team. Share your word with the whole group. Create a wordle (www.wordle.net)
5. Data 4 SS Overview Video http://www.mistreamnet.org/videtail.php?who=cisd071509
6. Picture This… Teachers are no longer working in isolation, instead there is a culture of collaboration in place. Decisions are based on the findings from quality data. Professional development is job-embedded on a steady basis. The community is aware of the power of having a collaborative culture of educators using quality data and they are well-informed of the impact this can have on all students.
7. Making it Happen AMA ESD’s Mission: Serve and Support Student Achievement Data Initiative Vision: With support from the AMA ESD, school leadership teams will guide their schools in creating a collaborative culture using quality data.
8. Two Data Mining Systems + PLC model = Vision! AMA ESD has two data mining systems available for schools: Data 4 Student Success (historical state-level data) Data4 SS vs. TestWiz Data Director (historical plus local data) School leaders and AMA ESD Data Coaches understand the concept of the PLC model Let’s put these two pieces together to create a collaborative culture that focuses on quality data!
9. Implementation Plan Five schools signed up to be the first cohort group to dive into the AMA ESD’s data initiative journey. The plan was developed for this first cohort to become the inspiration and guide for the rest of the schools. AMA ESD will lead the workshops, offer support, and sustain resources.
10. We need to think of “the leader as one whose function is to engage groups of people in a way that creates accountability and commitment.” Peter Block To do this, the leader should: Create a context based on gifts, generosity, accountability and commitment. Initiate and convene conversations that shift people’s experience, which occurs through the way people are brought together and the nature of the questions used to engage them. Listen and pay attention
12. Creating a Culture of Quality Data Learning Target: Understand a culture of quality data and the impact of change theory on staff
13. Culture of Quality Data On chart paper, please answer the following questions with your school team: What is a culture of quality data? What does it look like? What does it sound like? What is the evidence?
14. The School’s Culture… dictates, in no uncertain terms, “the way we do things around here.” Ultimately, a school’s culture has far more influence on life and learning in the schoolhouse than the state department of education, the superintendent, the school board or even the principal can ever have… Roland Barth (2001)
15. Continuum of Community Function 15 Toxic Laissez-faire Congenial Collaborative Accountable Toxic – All about the teacher, adults not nice to one another or to the students Laissez-faire – Teacher centered, autonomous, individual contractors Congenial – Counterfeit, confuse niceness w/collaborative, focus not on kids Collaborative – Have structures and skills in working together for improved student achievement Accountable – Able to acknowledge and deal with difficult data effectively; Move beyond familiar solutions and approaches; Let go of instructional practices that do not work; Call one another on unmet expectations or violated norms. Source: Skillful Leader II, Warnock presentation
16. Changing Cultures Bringing about cultural change in any organization is a complex and challenging task. Phil Schlechty (2005) refers to the challenge of reculturing as “disruptive change” because it “calls upon the system and those who work in it to do things they have never done”. It has been referred to as “2nd order change”- a dramatic departure from the expected and familiar.
17. CHANGE is difficult… Those who undertake a 2nd Order Change - such as transforming their schools into Professional Learning Communities must realize that change is difficult but not impossible. Anxiety, discomfort and conflict will accompany 2nd Order Change initiatives. 17
18. 1st and 2nd Order Change First Order Change: Extension of past Within existing paradigms Consistent w/ current norms, values Incremental Linear Implemented w/ current knowledge, skills Implemented by experts Second Order Change: Break w/ past Outside existing paradigms Conflicts w/ current norms, values Complex Non-linear Requires new knowledge, skills Implemented by stakeholders
19. 8 Common Mistakes Allowing too much complacency Establish a sense of urgency Failing to create powerful guiding coalition Create guiding coalition ID critical number of champions re: change process Underestimating the power of vision Vision = direction, alignment, inspiration Without direction, individuals “do their own thing” Lack of direction leads to “permission” or “debate”
20. 8 Common Mistakes 4. Under communicating the vision by a power of 10 2nd Order Change requires credible and frequent communication Important to communicate vision often Unite leadership focused on vision Action aligned to vision 5. Permitting structural, cultural obstacles to block change process Confront obstacles: PD, structures, staff, policy 20
21. 8 Common Mistakes 6. Failing to create short-term wins Build on incremental gains; avoid “long march” ID goals, performance criteria, celebrate 7. Declaring victory too soon Know difference between “win” and “victory” Successful change must be anchored in culture Celebration provides impetus to tackle bigger problems 8. Neglecting to anchor changes firmly in culture “Change” is part of the way we do things Behaviors must be rooted in social norms, shared values 21
23. Complex Change… Requires leadership greater than one person can provide. Distributed leadership maximizes the collective strengths of individuals in a coherent, adaptive, and sustainable organization. It requires individuals to assume responsibility, take action, learn and grow for the benefit of the whole. 23
24. How do we impact culture? Begin by focusing on changing BEHAVIORS. Attitudes follow behavior. That means people accept new beliefs as a result of changing their behavior. (Fullan) Behaviors and emotions change before beliefs so we need to act in a new way before we get insights and feelings related to new beliefs. (Elmore)
25. What will it look like? From … A focus on teaching Emphasis on what was taught Coverage of content Infrequent summative assessments Remediation Isolation To … A focus on learning A fixation on what students learned Demonstration of proficiency Frequent common formative assessments Intervention Collaboration
26. Roles and Responsibilities in Creating a Culture of Quality Data Learning Target: Understand the roles that need to be involved in building a culture of quality data
27. Roles and Responsibilities Group Activity In your teams, please choose one person to record your answers on the worksheet. Be ready to share with the group.
28. Assessing the Culture ofQuality Data Learning Target: Assess your current culture of quality data to help develop a plan of action
29. Assessing Your Culture of Quality Data After completing the chart together in your school teams, please take some time to answer the questions that follow. Share a few thoughts with the whole group. We will re-visit this chart as we journey through this initiative.
30. The Impact of Quality Data In small groups, answer these questions: What is the impact of missing kids? What is the impact of mislabeling kids? What is the impact of having only historical data? What other systems depend on student data?
31. Getting to Know Data4SS Computer Lab Tips: Sit with your school team Assign one person to be in charge of the computer operations (one computer per team to get started) When it’s “Tutorial Time” please avoid using your computer until it is over, then we can explore
Notes de l'éditeur
This section is used to set the stage for what a culture of quality data looks like
Take a minute and talk with your table teams:If a culture of data is in place, what behaviors would you observe?What evidence would the locals have that would indicate this is in place?Chart responsesData culture Reading and interpreting data correctly Goals written based on data Using data to make decisions Teacher know what the goals are – not just the SI team Funding allocated based on data More that one person has access to the data Data collected systematicallyData evidenceData walls Actions are related to the goal Well written goals measured by an assessment During conversations and meetings data is used Locally generated data (formative) PD relates to goals and goals are based on data Progress toward the goal is monitored, data is collected specific to the goal and analyzed Data analyzed and shared with staff on timely basis and regularly Data used to plan for making decisions ‘I believe’ and ‘I feel’ aren’t used – use narrative statements and work from those to focus on data not feelingThis information can be used to help determine were to begin the series of modules.
Read this statement as a group and reflect as a group
Facilitation:Jot on continuum where your local schools areNote that it requires significant PD to move up the continuum
1st Order Change is doing more of, less of, better (but the same)2nd Order Change is doing things differently – which requires a support group that allows people to ask for help
What comments would you hear if you are making mistake #11. Urgency yes, but FEAR does not work. Urgency alone is not sufficient. Studies show that 9 of 10 patients would be unable to make and sustain changes necessary to save their lives (Deutshman) John Kotter (1996) Harvard Business School
Celebrating giving HOPE for a better future motivates people to keep going.Be carefulHolding one another accountable for how we do business
Have discussion at tables about projects in the past that perhaps stumbled – can the missing required elements be identified and the result observed from those prior projects?
Therefore, actual changes in culture occur late in the process. Patience. Persistence.How do you do this? Monitor, Expect, Clarity, Conversation
Facilitation – break here to get Google Doc set up, folks accessing it (one per table). Need timer
Handout: Assessing the Culture of Quality Data Worksheet