SlideShare une entreprise Scribd logo
1  sur  47
Bioethical Issues in Patients’ Safety Practice & Research Ghaiath M.A. Hussein MBBS, MHSc. (Bioethics) Patients’ Safety Proposal Development Workshop July 29, 08
Objectives  ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],Ghaiath Ethics of Pt. Safety, July 08.
What is Bioethics? ,[object Object],Ghaiath Ethics of Pt. Safety, July 08.
When does an issue in practice/research be an ethical issue (i.e. S&S)?   (modified from Barbara Secker and Frank Wagner)   ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],Ghaiath Ethics of Pt. Safety, July 08.
Three Questions  & Three Categories ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],Ghaiath Ethics of Pt. Safety, July 08.
Three Questions &  Three Categories ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],Ghaiath Ethics of Pt. Safety, July 08.
Ethical Principles in Clinical Practice and Research   (Beauchamp & Childress) : ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],Ghaiath Ethics of Pt. Safety, July 08.
Part I Ghaiath Ethics of Pt. Safety, July 08.
A. Free Informed Consent: ,[object Object],[object Object],Ghaiath Ethics of Pt. Safety, July 08.
Definition : ,[object Object],[object Object],Ghaiath Ethics of Pt. Safety, July 08.
Components of FIC : ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],Ghaiath Ethics of Pt. Safety, July 08.
Exceptions to individually-given consent   (from Hebert P.  Doing Right) ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],Ghaiath Ethics of Pt. Safety, July 08.
FORMS OF CONSENT ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],Ghaiath Ethics of Pt. Safety, July 08.
Practical challenges to a "Fully Informed Consent" ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],Ghaiath Ethics of Pt. Safety, July 08.
B. Disclosure ,[object Object],Ghaiath Ethics of Pt. Safety, July 08.
Elements of disclosure ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],Ghaiath Ethics of Pt. Safety, July 08.
Elements of disclosure… cont. ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],Ghaiath Ethics of Pt. Safety, July 08.
Principles for providing information to the patient: ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],Ghaiath Ethics of Pt. Safety, July 08.
C. Capacity : ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],Ghaiath Ethics of Pt. Safety, July 08.
D. Voluntariness : ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],Ghaiath Ethics of Pt. Safety, July 08.
Part II Ghaiath Ethics of Pt. Safety, July 08.
[object Object],Ghaiath Ethics of Pt. Safety, July 08.
Objectives of Part II  ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],Ghaiath Ethics of Pt. Safety, July 08.
Historical Background ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],Ghaiath Ethics of Pt. Safety, July 08.
Which Research needs ethical review? ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],Ghaiath Ethics of Pt. Safety, July 08.
Guiding Principles of Research Ethics ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],Ghaiath Ethics of Pt. Safety, July 08.
Guiding principles ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],Ghaiath Ethics of Pt. Safety, July 08.
Guiding principles ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],Ghaiath Ethics of Pt. Safety, July 08.
Guiding principles ,[object Object],[object Object],Ghaiath Ethics of Pt. Safety, July 08.
Guiding principles ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],Ghaiath Ethics of Pt. Safety, July 08.
Participants should know about: ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],Ghaiath Ethics of Pt. Safety, July 08.
Applications of the Principles ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],Ghaiath Ethics of Pt. Safety, July 08.
A.  Clinical Equipoise and Dual Role ,[object Object],[object Object],Ghaiath Ethics of Pt. Safety, July 08.
Key issues for Researching Clinicians ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],Ghaiath Ethics of Pt. Safety, July 08.
B.  Consent for Research… what to disclose? ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],Ghaiath Ethics of Pt. Safety, July 08.
What to disclose?...cont. ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],Ghaiath Ethics of Pt. Safety, July 08.
What to disclose? ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],Ghaiath Ethics of Pt. Safety, July 08.
C.  Confidentiality   ,[object Object],Ghaiath Ethics of Pt. Safety, July 08.
Measures to respect confidentiality ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],Ghaiath Ethics of Pt. Safety, July 08.
D.  Conflict of Interests (COIs) ,[object Object],Ghaiath Ethics of Pt. Safety, July 08.
Types of COIs  (basically financial) ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],Ghaiath Ethics of Pt. Safety, July 08.
Problems of the COIs ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],Ghaiath Ethics of Pt. Safety, July 08.
How to minimize the ethical issues? ,[object Object],[object Object],Ghaiath Ethics of Pt. Safety, July 08.
Ethics Review Questions: ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],Ghaiath Ethics of Pt. Safety, July 08.
Before enrolling patients As part of the completed protocol, PI details safety monitoring plans and procedures including assessing, documenting, and reporting adverse events. PI sends to program officer or medical officer for approval. Program officer or medical officer review Does the PO or MO have concerns about patient safety? Yes, concerned PO or MO sends recommendations to the PI for collaborative revisions. No concerns  Approval PO or MO approves safety plan and adverse event reporting plan. Patients may be enrolled once the trial meets all approval requirements. Needs IRB approval of complete protocol as well as approval by other parties such as the DSMB, FDA, and division regulatory staff. After peer review NIAID commits funds. During a clinical trial PO monitors compliance with monitoring plan and adverse event reporting requirements. IRB, FDA, and NIAID address DSMB and SAE reports PO must email or fax PI within 10 days and send official letter within 30 days of receipt. NIAID can terminate award or take other action if PI does not comply with monitoring plan. Serious adverse events PI provides reports of serious adverse events following  NIAID Clinical Terms of Award Guidance . For multi-site trials, PI also sends DSMB summary reports to all IRBs and program officer.  Last reviewed June 27, 2007 (jlg) Relevant Extramural SOP:  Adverse Events Reporting Requirements Example of Clinical Trial Safety Monitoring and Reporting Requirements
Back to our case ,[object Object],Ghaiath Ethics of Pt. Safety, July 08.
Ghaiath Ethics of Pt. Safety, July 08.

Contenu connexe

Tendances

Healthcare confidentiality training.2013bev
Healthcare confidentiality training.2013bevHealthcare confidentiality training.2013bev
Healthcare confidentiality training.2013bev
blk70130
 
1. introduction to bioethics
1.  introduction to bioethics1.  introduction to bioethics
1. introduction to bioethics
Mevelle Asuncion
 
Technology and Ethics in Health Care FINAL
Technology and Ethics in Health Care FINALTechnology and Ethics in Health Care FINAL
Technology and Ethics in Health Care FINAL
Amanda Romano-Kwan
 
Introduction to medical ethics
Introduction to medical ethics	Introduction to medical ethics
Introduction to medical ethics
Khalid
 

Tendances (20)

Healthcare confidentiality training.2013bev
Healthcare confidentiality training.2013bevHealthcare confidentiality training.2013bev
Healthcare confidentiality training.2013bev
 
Lecture 13 privacy, confidentiality and medical records
Lecture 13 privacy, confidentiality and medical recordsLecture 13 privacy, confidentiality and medical records
Lecture 13 privacy, confidentiality and medical records
 
Bioethics intoduction
Bioethics intoductionBioethics intoduction
Bioethics intoduction
 
1. introduction to bioethics
1.  introduction to bioethics1.  introduction to bioethics
1. introduction to bioethics
 
Confidentiality
ConfidentialityConfidentiality
Confidentiality
 
Medical ethics
Medical ethicsMedical ethics
Medical ethics
 
Bio ethics - Beneficence & Non-maleficence
Bio ethics - Beneficence & Non-maleficenceBio ethics - Beneficence & Non-maleficence
Bio ethics - Beneficence & Non-maleficence
 
Lecture 13 privacy, confidentiality and medical records
Lecture 13 privacy, confidentiality and medical recordsLecture 13 privacy, confidentiality and medical records
Lecture 13 privacy, confidentiality and medical records
 
Med ethics by dr najeeb
Med ethics by dr najeebMed ethics by dr najeeb
Med ethics by dr najeeb
 
introduction to medical ethics and bioethics
 introduction to medical ethics and bioethics introduction to medical ethics and bioethics
introduction to medical ethics and bioethics
 
Lecture 15 privacy of patients in clinical care
Lecture 15 privacy of patients in clinical careLecture 15 privacy of patients in clinical care
Lecture 15 privacy of patients in clinical care
 
Technology and Ethics in Health Care FINAL
Technology and Ethics in Health Care FINALTechnology and Ethics in Health Care FINAL
Technology and Ethics in Health Care FINAL
 
Introduction to medical ethics
Introduction to medical ethics	Introduction to medical ethics
Introduction to medical ethics
 
Bioethics
BioethicsBioethics
Bioethics
 
MEDICAL ETHICS 2.pptx
MEDICAL ETHICS 2.pptxMEDICAL ETHICS 2.pptx
MEDICAL ETHICS 2.pptx
 
Ethics for medical student
Ethics for medical studentEthics for medical student
Ethics for medical student
 
MODULE 8 - PRIVACY AND CONFIDENTIALITY
MODULE 8 - PRIVACY AND CONFIDENTIALITYMODULE 8 - PRIVACY AND CONFIDENTIALITY
MODULE 8 - PRIVACY AND CONFIDENTIALITY
 
Patient right
Patient rightPatient right
Patient right
 
Bioethical issues in nursing
Bioethical issues in nursingBioethical issues in nursing
Bioethical issues in nursing
 
Introduction to medical ethics
Introduction to medical ethicsIntroduction to medical ethics
Introduction to medical ethics
 

Similaire à Ethical Issues in Patients’ Safety Practice &research

historical_background_research_ethics
historical_background_research_ethicshistorical_background_research_ethics
historical_background_research_ethics
Dr Ghaiath Hussein
 
historical_background_research_ethics
historical_background_research_ethicshistorical_background_research_ethics
historical_background_research_ethics
Dr Ghaiath Hussein
 
It is time to make a move new
It is time to make a move newIt is time to make a move new
It is time to make a move new
Acri India
 
DECLARATION OF HELSINKI
DECLARATION OF HELSINKI DECLARATION OF HELSINKI
DECLARATION OF HELSINKI
ClinosolIndia
 
Ethical considerations
Ethical considerationsEthical considerations
Ethical considerations
Usama Jamshaid
 

Similaire à Ethical Issues in Patients’ Safety Practice &research (20)

informed consent
informed consentinformed consent
informed consent
 
historical_background_research_ethics
historical_background_research_ethicshistorical_background_research_ethics
historical_background_research_ethics
 
historical_background_research_ethics
historical_background_research_ethicshistorical_background_research_ethics
historical_background_research_ethics
 
Helsinki declaration
Helsinki declarationHelsinki declaration
Helsinki declaration
 
Module 5-Ethics in Different Domain.pptx
Module 5-Ethics in Different Domain.pptxModule 5-Ethics in Different Domain.pptx
Module 5-Ethics in Different Domain.pptx
 
It is time to make a move new
It is time to make a move newIt is time to make a move new
It is time to make a move new
 
Ethics in clinical research
Ethics in clinical researchEthics in clinical research
Ethics in clinical research
 
DECLARATION OF HELSINKI
DECLARATION OF HELSINKI DECLARATION OF HELSINKI
DECLARATION OF HELSINKI
 
Ethical Issues in Obtaining Informed Consent.pptx
Ethical Issues in Obtaining Informed Consent.pptxEthical Issues in Obtaining Informed Consent.pptx
Ethical Issues in Obtaining Informed Consent.pptx
 
Lecture 19 research ethics (2)
Lecture 19 research ethics (2)Lecture 19 research ethics (2)
Lecture 19 research ethics (2)
 
Ethical aspects of anesthesia care and euthanasia
Ethical aspects of anesthesia care and euthanasiaEthical aspects of anesthesia care and euthanasia
Ethical aspects of anesthesia care and euthanasia
 
Medical ethics & evidence based medicine?
Medical ethics & evidence based medicine?Medical ethics & evidence based medicine?
Medical ethics & evidence based medicine?
 
Ethics of Medical Researches
Ethics of Medical ResearchesEthics of Medical Researches
Ethics of Medical Researches
 
Ethical considerations
Ethical considerationsEthical considerations
Ethical considerations
 
HL MAIRA H.od2kkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkk
HL MAIRA H.od2kkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkHL MAIRA H.od2kkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkk
HL MAIRA H.od2kkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkk
 
core ethics.pptx
core ethics.pptxcore ethics.pptx
core ethics.pptx
 
Medical ethics
Medical ethicsMedical ethics
Medical ethics
 
Medical ethics
Medical ethicsMedical ethics
Medical ethics
 
Ethico-moral responsibilities powerpoint
Ethico-moral responsibilities powerpointEthico-moral responsibilities powerpoint
Ethico-moral responsibilities powerpoint
 
Paula Kim
Paula KimPaula Kim
Paula Kim
 

Plus de Dr Ghaiath Hussein

Plus de Dr Ghaiath Hussein (20)

نظرية التطور عند المسلمين (بروفيسور محمد علي البار
نظرية التطور عند المسلمين (بروفيسور محمد علي البارنظرية التطور عند المسلمين (بروفيسور محمد علي البار
نظرية التطور عند المسلمين (بروفيسور محمد علي البار
 
10 Tips to make your search in Google Scholar more effective.pdf
10 Tips to make your search in Google Scholar more effective.pdf10 Tips to make your search in Google Scholar more effective.pdf
10 Tips to make your search in Google Scholar more effective.pdf
 
Ethical considerations in research during armed conflicts.pptx
Ethical considerations in research during armed conflicts.pptxEthical considerations in research during armed conflicts.pptx
Ethical considerations in research during armed conflicts.pptx
 
Medically Assisted Dying in (MAiD) Ireland - Mapping the Ethical Terrain (May...
Medically Assisted Dying in (MAiD) Ireland - Mapping the Ethical Terrain (May...Medically Assisted Dying in (MAiD) Ireland - Mapping the Ethical Terrain (May...
Medically Assisted Dying in (MAiD) Ireland - Mapping the Ethical Terrain (May...
 
Research or not research (JCB 17.11.21).pptx
Research or not research (JCB 17.11.21).pptxResearch or not research (JCB 17.11.21).pptx
Research or not research (JCB 17.11.21).pptx
 
Medically assisted dying in (MAiD) Ireland - mapping the ethical terrain
Medically assisted dying in (MAiD) Ireland - mapping the ethical terrainMedically assisted dying in (MAiD) Ireland - mapping the ethical terrain
Medically assisted dying in (MAiD) Ireland - mapping the ethical terrain
 
الجوانب الأخلاقية في العلاج الجيني
الجوانب الأخلاقية في العلاج الجينيالجوانب الأخلاقية في العلاج الجيني
الجوانب الأخلاقية في العلاج الجيني
 
الضرر في العمل الطبي-البروفيسور جمال جار الله
الضرر في العمل الطبي-البروفيسور جمال جار اللهالضرر في العمل الطبي-البروفيسور جمال جار الله
الضرر في العمل الطبي-البروفيسور جمال جار الله
 
العلاج الجيني والاخلاق
العلاج الجيني والاخلاقالعلاج الجيني والاخلاق
العلاج الجيني والاخلاق
 
القتل الرحيم و النظرة الإسلامية له
القتل الرحيم و النظرة الإسلامية لهالقتل الرحيم و النظرة الإسلامية له
القتل الرحيم و النظرة الإسلامية له
 
القواعد الفقهية لتخصص التخدير (2)
القواعد الفقهية لتخصص التخدير (2)القواعد الفقهية لتخصص التخدير (2)
القواعد الفقهية لتخصص التخدير (2)
 
المقارنة بين الفلسفات الغربية والمقاربة الإسلام
المقارنة بين الفلسفات الغربية والمقاربة الإسلامالمقارنة بين الفلسفات الغربية والمقاربة الإسلام
المقارنة بين الفلسفات الغربية والمقاربة الإسلام
 
تحديد الوفاة بالقرائن الدماغية الدكتور محمد زهير
تحديد الوفاة بالقرائن الدماغية الدكتور محمد زهيرتحديد الوفاة بالقرائن الدماغية الدكتور محمد زهير
تحديد الوفاة بالقرائن الدماغية الدكتور محمد زهير
 
الاحتضار والموت والمنظور الشرعي له التعامل مع المحتضر والميت طلب عدم الإنعاش...
الاحتضار والموت والمنظور الشرعي له  التعامل مع المحتضر والميت طلب عدم الإنعاش...الاحتضار والموت والمنظور الشرعي له  التعامل مع المحتضر والميت طلب عدم الإنعاش...
الاحتضار والموت والمنظور الشرعي له التعامل مع المحتضر والميت طلب عدم الإنعاش...
 
إسهامات الفقهاء والأطباء في تطبيق القواعد الفقهية
إسهامات الفقهاء    والأطباء في تطبيق القواعد الفقهيةإسهامات الفقهاء    والأطباء في تطبيق القواعد الفقهية
إسهامات الفقهاء والأطباء في تطبيق القواعد الفقهية
 
جراحات التجميل ـ محاضرة كلية الطب
جراحات التجميل ـ محاضرة كلية الطبجراحات التجميل ـ محاضرة كلية الطب
جراحات التجميل ـ محاضرة كلية الطب
 
حقوق المريض ـ الحوار الوطني
حقوق المريض ـ الحوار الوطنيحقوق المريض ـ الحوار الوطني
حقوق المريض ـ الحوار الوطني
 
حقوق المريض في الاسلام
حقوق المريض في الاسلامحقوق المريض في الاسلام
حقوق المريض في الاسلام
 
دراسة حالة وتقديمها
دراسة حالة وتقديمهادراسة حالة وتقديمها
دراسة حالة وتقديمها
 
سوء الممارسة الطبية 1
سوء الممارسة الطبية 1سوء الممارسة الطبية 1
سوء الممارسة الطبية 1
 

Ethical Issues in Patients’ Safety Practice &research

  • 1. Bioethical Issues in Patients’ Safety Practice & Research Ghaiath M.A. Hussein MBBS, MHSc. (Bioethics) Patients’ Safety Proposal Development Workshop July 29, 08
  • 2.
  • 3.
  • 4.
  • 5.
  • 6.
  • 7.
  • 8. Part I Ghaiath Ethics of Pt. Safety, July 08.
  • 9.
  • 10.
  • 11.
  • 12.
  • 13.
  • 14.
  • 15.
  • 16.
  • 17.
  • 18.
  • 19.
  • 20.
  • 21. Part II Ghaiath Ethics of Pt. Safety, July 08.
  • 22.
  • 23.
  • 24.
  • 25.
  • 26.
  • 27.
  • 28.
  • 29.
  • 30.
  • 31.
  • 32.
  • 33.
  • 34.
  • 35.
  • 36.
  • 37.
  • 38.
  • 39.
  • 40.
  • 41.
  • 42.
  • 43.
  • 44.
  • 45. Before enrolling patients As part of the completed protocol, PI details safety monitoring plans and procedures including assessing, documenting, and reporting adverse events. PI sends to program officer or medical officer for approval. Program officer or medical officer review Does the PO or MO have concerns about patient safety? Yes, concerned PO or MO sends recommendations to the PI for collaborative revisions. No concerns  Approval PO or MO approves safety plan and adverse event reporting plan. Patients may be enrolled once the trial meets all approval requirements. Needs IRB approval of complete protocol as well as approval by other parties such as the DSMB, FDA, and division regulatory staff. After peer review NIAID commits funds. During a clinical trial PO monitors compliance with monitoring plan and adverse event reporting requirements. IRB, FDA, and NIAID address DSMB and SAE reports PO must email or fax PI within 10 days and send official letter within 30 days of receipt. NIAID can terminate award or take other action if PI does not comply with monitoring plan. Serious adverse events PI provides reports of serious adverse events following NIAID Clinical Terms of Award Guidance . For multi-site trials, PI also sends DSMB summary reports to all IRBs and program officer. Last reviewed June 27, 2007 (jlg) Relevant Extramural SOP: Adverse Events Reporting Requirements Example of Clinical Trial Safety Monitoring and Reporting Requirements
  • 46.
  • 47. Ghaiath Ethics of Pt. Safety, July 08.

Notes de l'éditeur

  1. When there is conflict of moral values , beliefs, and objectives e.g. between the health care providers and the patients. For instance, the classical example of blood transfusion to a severely bleeding Jehovah Witness who refuses to take blood, even this refusal can lead to severe life threat and eventually death. When there is conflict of commitments and responsibilities : for example at one hand there is the commitment of the health care provider to preserve his/her patients' lives, however there is the responsibility to "rationally" use the resources available to him/her on the other hand. The classical example of which is "one ICU bed, and two patients: whom to choose?" When there is the concern that our patients rights/values are not respected . When the issue in focus is related to justice in allocating the available resources . A classical example is which of the cancer drugs should be funded publicly. Should we choose a drug which efficiently improves the quality of life of few patients? Or a drug that makes little improvement for a larger number of patients. Finally, when we, as care providers feel that we are not sure what we should do .
  2. this is usually the hardest exercise, and commonly known in the bioethics literature as "moral reasoning". There are 10s of ethical approaches, theories, principles etc. to make a sound ethical/moral reasoning.
  3. Community care ethics is now being developed as a subset of this category;
  4. Prospective IC: This approach suffers from all the weaknesses associated with advance directives, and is rarely applicable to the conditions relevant to emergency research, such as sudden cardiac arrest or motor vehicle trauma.
  5. The easiest answer to overcome the ethics bore is to say, “ok. You’re talking about research ethics. This is not research”
  6. This protocol should be submitted for consideration, comment, guidance, and where appropriate, approval to a specially appointed ethical review committee, which must be independent of the investigator, the sponsor or any other kind of undue influence. This independent committee should be in conformity with the laws and regulations of the country in which the research experiment is performed.
  7. Incompetent: who is legally incompetent, physically or mentally incapable of giving consent or is a legally incompetent minor
  8. it is necessary during the study planning process to identify post-trial access by study participants to prophylactic, diagnostic and therapeutic procedures identified as beneficial in the study or access to other appropriate care.