SlideShare une entreprise Scribd logo
1  sur  19
Ethics at the extremes:   Lessons From Population Health Surveys in  Darfur Ghaiath Hussein MBBS, MD Comm. Med. (Part I, Sudan) MHSc. Student, Joint Center for Bioethics (U of T)   Ethical Challenges to Research in Darfur National Council on Ethics in Human Research (NCER) conference, Ottawa February 16, 2008
Disclaimer and Competing Interests ,[object Object],[object Object],Ethical Challenges to Research in Darfur
In this presentation ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],Ethical Challenges to Research in Darfur
Darfur in a nutshell ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],Ethical Challenges to Research in Darfur
Examples of conducted studies ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],Ethical Challenges to Research in Darfur
Ethical Challenges to Research in Conflicts ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],Ethical Challenges to Research in Darfur
Ethical issues in focus   ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],Ethical Challenges to Research in Darfur
1. Informed Consent “ I’m …. (name of interviewer)  from …  (name of agency) . This study is not a census. We are studying…  (aim of the study),  and we need to ask you some questions about …, and to do… This will take about 30 minutes of your time.  All the information that you will provide will be strictly  confidential , and your answers will  never be identified . You will  not be given  any direct aid, or  compensation  for participating in this survey. May I start now?”   Modified from Sudan Household Health Survey ( www.shhs.i8.com )  Ethical Challenges to Research in Darfur
Ethical Issues About Consent Ethical Challenges to Research in Darfur (Hussein, G., 2007)
2. Selection Bias ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],Ethical Challenges to Research in Darfur Accessible   Limited access   No access
3. Conflict of Interests Ethical Challenges to Research in Darfur ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Political Tools?  Ethical Challenges to Research in Darfur Good and “ethical”?
4.  Benefits of Conducted Surveys ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],Ethical Challenges to Research in Darfur
5. Potential Risks to Participants ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],Ethical Challenges to Research in Darfur
Two hours late! No water today! ,[object Object],Ethical Challenges to Research in Darfur
Risks to survey teams ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],Ethical Challenges to Research in Darfur What to do? How to get them out? Do you mean alive or dead?
Few steps forward ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],Ethical Challenges to Research in Darfur
Acknowledgements  Thanks to my “Teachers” in the JCB: And to the heroes whom I worked with in Darfur  Ethical Challenges to Research in Darfur
[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],Ethical Challenges to Research in Darfur Ghaiath Hussein:  [email_address]   www.bioethicsnet.googlepages.com

Contenu connexe

Similaire à Ethical Issues in Research Conducted in Darfur

PEER empowers marginalized women (elmusharaf IFGH 2012)
PEER empowers marginalized women (elmusharaf IFGH 2012)PEER empowers marginalized women (elmusharaf IFGH 2012)
PEER empowers marginalized women (elmusharaf IFGH 2012)
Khalifa Elmusharaf
 
online class ·Ethical, Legal, and Cultural Considerations.docx
online class ·Ethical, Legal, and Cultural Considerations.docxonline class ·Ethical, Legal, and Cultural Considerations.docx
online class ·Ethical, Legal, and Cultural Considerations.docx
johnbbruce72945
 
Safeguarding Traditional Knowledge in Health and Wellbeing in Sri Lanka as In...
Safeguarding Traditional Knowledge in Health and Wellbeing in Sri Lanka as In...Safeguarding Traditional Knowledge in Health and Wellbeing in Sri Lanka as In...
Safeguarding Traditional Knowledge in Health and Wellbeing in Sri Lanka as In...
Nirekha De Silva
 
28 muster2014 Goudie
28 muster2014 Goudie28 muster2014 Goudie
28 muster2014 Goudie
Muster2014
 
i need an answer for each discussion.discussion 1Even though I.docx
i need an answer for each discussion.discussion 1Even though I.docxi need an answer for each discussion.discussion 1Even though I.docx
i need an answer for each discussion.discussion 1Even though I.docx
evontdcichon
 
Ethical Research
Ethical ResearchEthical Research
Ethical Research
wtidwell
 
Building Ethics into the Research with Vulnerable groups
Building Ethics into the Research with Vulnerable groups Building Ethics into the Research with Vulnerable groups
Building Ethics into the Research with Vulnerable groups
la71
 
Naidu and Darong 2015. When Illness is more than just a Sick Body
Naidu and Darong 2015. When Illness is more than just a Sick BodyNaidu and Darong 2015. When Illness is more than just a Sick Body
Naidu and Darong 2015. When Illness is more than just a Sick Body
Gabriel Darong
 

Similaire à Ethical Issues in Research Conducted in Darfur (20)

Improving Health Disparities in the African-American Community by Educating P...
Improving Health Disparities in the African-American Community by Educating P...Improving Health Disparities in the African-American Community by Educating P...
Improving Health Disparities in the African-American Community by Educating P...
 
Mulusew andualem ethics in health research
Mulusew andualem  ethics in health researchMulusew andualem  ethics in health research
Mulusew andualem ethics in health research
 
PEER empowers marginalized women (elmusharaf IFGH 2012)
PEER empowers marginalized women (elmusharaf IFGH 2012)PEER empowers marginalized women (elmusharaf IFGH 2012)
PEER empowers marginalized women (elmusharaf IFGH 2012)
 
Who Can Speak for the Emergently Ill 11.10.08
Who Can Speak for the Emergently Ill 11.10.08Who Can Speak for the Emergently Ill 11.10.08
Who Can Speak for the Emergently Ill 11.10.08
 
1.pdf
1.pdf1.pdf
1.pdf
 
Presentation KU
Presentation KUPresentation KU
Presentation KU
 
Democracy and Bioethics in the ‘Developing’ Countries: Who has the X-Factor?
Democracy and Bioethics in the ‘Developing’ Countries: Who has the X-Factor?Democracy and Bioethics in the ‘Developing’ Countries: Who has the X-Factor?
Democracy and Bioethics in the ‘Developing’ Countries: Who has the X-Factor?
 
online class ·Ethical, Legal, and Cultural Considerations.docx
online class ·Ethical, Legal, and Cultural Considerations.docxonline class ·Ethical, Legal, and Cultural Considerations.docx
online class ·Ethical, Legal, and Cultural Considerations.docx
 
Safeguarding Traditional Knowledge in Health and Wellbeing in Sri Lanka as In...
Safeguarding Traditional Knowledge in Health and Wellbeing in Sri Lanka as In...Safeguarding Traditional Knowledge in Health and Wellbeing in Sri Lanka as In...
Safeguarding Traditional Knowledge in Health and Wellbeing in Sri Lanka as In...
 
British Columbia Pt Safety & Quality Council, Feb. 2014
British Columbia Pt Safety & Quality Council, Feb. 2014British Columbia Pt Safety & Quality Council, Feb. 2014
British Columbia Pt Safety & Quality Council, Feb. 2014
 
28 muster2014 Goudie
28 muster2014 Goudie28 muster2014 Goudie
28 muster2014 Goudie
 
Introduction to ethical issues in public health, Public Health Institute (PHI...
Introduction to ethical issues in public health, Public Health Institute (PHI...Introduction to ethical issues in public health, Public Health Institute (PHI...
Introduction to ethical issues in public health, Public Health Institute (PHI...
 
Nature Versus Nurture Essay.pdf
Nature Versus Nurture Essay.pdfNature Versus Nurture Essay.pdf
Nature Versus Nurture Essay.pdf
 
i need an answer for each discussion.discussion 1Even though I.docx
i need an answer for each discussion.discussion 1Even though I.docxi need an answer for each discussion.discussion 1Even though I.docx
i need an answer for each discussion.discussion 1Even though I.docx
 
Ethical Issues in a Rural Context
Ethical Issues in a Rural ContextEthical Issues in a Rural Context
Ethical Issues in a Rural Context
 
Ethical Research
Ethical ResearchEthical Research
Ethical Research
 
Building Ethics into the Research with Vulnerable groups
Building Ethics into the Research with Vulnerable groups Building Ethics into the Research with Vulnerable groups
Building Ethics into the Research with Vulnerable groups
 
Naidu and Darong 2015. When Illness is more than just a Sick Body
Naidu and Darong 2015. When Illness is more than just a Sick BodyNaidu and Darong 2015. When Illness is more than just a Sick Body
Naidu and Darong 2015. When Illness is more than just a Sick Body
 
Community engagement 101 CBPR Overview.pptx
Community engagement 101 CBPR Overview.pptxCommunity engagement 101 CBPR Overview.pptx
Community engagement 101 CBPR Overview.pptx
 
Ethical and Methodological Issues: Research on Conflict and Post-Conflict Sex...
Ethical and Methodological Issues: Research on Conflict and Post-Conflict Sex...Ethical and Methodological Issues: Research on Conflict and Post-Conflict Sex...
Ethical and Methodological Issues: Research on Conflict and Post-Conflict Sex...
 

Plus de Dr Ghaiath Hussein

Plus de Dr Ghaiath Hussein (20)

نظرية التطور عند المسلمين (بروفيسور محمد علي البار
نظرية التطور عند المسلمين (بروفيسور محمد علي البارنظرية التطور عند المسلمين (بروفيسور محمد علي البار
نظرية التطور عند المسلمين (بروفيسور محمد علي البار
 
10 Tips to make your search in Google Scholar more effective.pdf
10 Tips to make your search in Google Scholar more effective.pdf10 Tips to make your search in Google Scholar more effective.pdf
10 Tips to make your search in Google Scholar more effective.pdf
 
Ethical considerations in research during armed conflicts.pptx
Ethical considerations in research during armed conflicts.pptxEthical considerations in research during armed conflicts.pptx
Ethical considerations in research during armed conflicts.pptx
 
Medically Assisted Dying in (MAiD) Ireland - Mapping the Ethical Terrain (May...
Medically Assisted Dying in (MAiD) Ireland - Mapping the Ethical Terrain (May...Medically Assisted Dying in (MAiD) Ireland - Mapping the Ethical Terrain (May...
Medically Assisted Dying in (MAiD) Ireland - Mapping the Ethical Terrain (May...
 
Medically assisted dying in (MAiD) Ireland - mapping the ethical terrain
Medically assisted dying in (MAiD) Ireland - mapping the ethical terrainMedically assisted dying in (MAiD) Ireland - mapping the ethical terrain
Medically assisted dying in (MAiD) Ireland - mapping the ethical terrain
 
الجوانب الأخلاقية في العلاج الجيني
الجوانب الأخلاقية في العلاج الجينيالجوانب الأخلاقية في العلاج الجيني
الجوانب الأخلاقية في العلاج الجيني
 
الضرر في العمل الطبي-البروفيسور جمال جار الله
الضرر في العمل الطبي-البروفيسور جمال جار اللهالضرر في العمل الطبي-البروفيسور جمال جار الله
الضرر في العمل الطبي-البروفيسور جمال جار الله
 
العلاج الجيني والاخلاق
العلاج الجيني والاخلاقالعلاج الجيني والاخلاق
العلاج الجيني والاخلاق
 
القتل الرحيم و النظرة الإسلامية له
القتل الرحيم و النظرة الإسلامية لهالقتل الرحيم و النظرة الإسلامية له
القتل الرحيم و النظرة الإسلامية له
 
القواعد الفقهية لتخصص التخدير (2)
القواعد الفقهية لتخصص التخدير (2)القواعد الفقهية لتخصص التخدير (2)
القواعد الفقهية لتخصص التخدير (2)
 
المقارنة بين الفلسفات الغربية والمقاربة الإسلام
المقارنة بين الفلسفات الغربية والمقاربة الإسلامالمقارنة بين الفلسفات الغربية والمقاربة الإسلام
المقارنة بين الفلسفات الغربية والمقاربة الإسلام
 
تحديد الوفاة بالقرائن الدماغية الدكتور محمد زهير
تحديد الوفاة بالقرائن الدماغية الدكتور محمد زهيرتحديد الوفاة بالقرائن الدماغية الدكتور محمد زهير
تحديد الوفاة بالقرائن الدماغية الدكتور محمد زهير
 
الاحتضار والموت والمنظور الشرعي له التعامل مع المحتضر والميت طلب عدم الإنعاش...
الاحتضار والموت والمنظور الشرعي له  التعامل مع المحتضر والميت طلب عدم الإنعاش...الاحتضار والموت والمنظور الشرعي له  التعامل مع المحتضر والميت طلب عدم الإنعاش...
الاحتضار والموت والمنظور الشرعي له التعامل مع المحتضر والميت طلب عدم الإنعاش...
 
إسهامات الفقهاء والأطباء في تطبيق القواعد الفقهية
إسهامات الفقهاء    والأطباء في تطبيق القواعد الفقهيةإسهامات الفقهاء    والأطباء في تطبيق القواعد الفقهية
إسهامات الفقهاء والأطباء في تطبيق القواعد الفقهية
 
جراحات التجميل ـ محاضرة كلية الطب
جراحات التجميل ـ محاضرة كلية الطبجراحات التجميل ـ محاضرة كلية الطب
جراحات التجميل ـ محاضرة كلية الطب
 
حقوق المريض ـ الحوار الوطني
حقوق المريض ـ الحوار الوطنيحقوق المريض ـ الحوار الوطني
حقوق المريض ـ الحوار الوطني
 
حقوق المريض في الاسلام
حقوق المريض في الاسلامحقوق المريض في الاسلام
حقوق المريض في الاسلام
 
دراسة حالة وتقديمها
دراسة حالة وتقديمهادراسة حالة وتقديمها
دراسة حالة وتقديمها
 
سوء الممارسة الطبية 1
سوء الممارسة الطبية 1سوء الممارسة الطبية 1
سوء الممارسة الطبية 1
 
عرض الأستاذ الدكتور فيصل شاهين
عرض الأستاذ الدكتور فيصل شاهينعرض الأستاذ الدكتور فيصل شاهين
عرض الأستاذ الدكتور فيصل شاهين
 

Ethical Issues in Research Conducted in Darfur

  • 1. Ethics at the extremes: Lessons From Population Health Surveys in Darfur Ghaiath Hussein MBBS, MD Comm. Med. (Part I, Sudan) MHSc. Student, Joint Center for Bioethics (U of T) Ethical Challenges to Research in Darfur National Council on Ethics in Human Research (NCER) conference, Ottawa February 16, 2008
  • 2.
  • 3.
  • 4.
  • 5.
  • 6.
  • 7.
  • 8. 1. Informed Consent “ I’m …. (name of interviewer) from … (name of agency) . This study is not a census. We are studying… (aim of the study), and we need to ask you some questions about …, and to do… This will take about 30 minutes of your time. All the information that you will provide will be strictly confidential , and your answers will never be identified . You will not be given any direct aid, or compensation for participating in this survey. May I start now?” Modified from Sudan Household Health Survey ( www.shhs.i8.com ) Ethical Challenges to Research in Darfur
  • 9. Ethical Issues About Consent Ethical Challenges to Research in Darfur (Hussein, G., 2007)
  • 10.
  • 11.
  • 12. Political Tools? Ethical Challenges to Research in Darfur Good and “ethical”?
  • 13.
  • 14.
  • 15.
  • 16.
  • 17.
  • 18. Acknowledgements Thanks to my “Teachers” in the JCB: And to the heroes whom I worked with in Darfur Ethical Challenges to Research in Darfur
  • 19.