SlideShare une entreprise Scribd logo
1  sur  21
Télécharger pour lire hors ligne
Orphan Works
presented by Ali Accarino
Orphan Work:
 A copyrighted work (book,
 music, film, photo, record,
etc.) whose copyright owner
 cannot be found or is not
        easily found
History
1976 Copyright Act

Eliminated any formal registration requirements
for a copyright
Included an extension of the duration of the
copyright protection
Led to a proliferation in orphan works



        1976
Sonny Bono Copyright Term Extension Act

    Extended copyrights for an additional 20 years,
    so that it lasts for the life span of the creator and
    an additional 70 years after their death
    Allowed libraries and archives to use a work
    without permission if the work is not otherwise
    being used for commercial exploitation and not
    available at a reasonable price


                                 1998
Public Domain Enhancement Act
 Introduced in House of Representatives in 2003
 Reintroduced in 2005
 Did not pass
 Would have released some orphan works into the
 public domain if the copyright owners did not
 renew their copyright 50 years after the work
 was first released and then every 10 years after


                             2003 2005
Copyright Office Orphan Works Study
   Issued a Notice of Inquiry and asked the public
   to submit comments about orphan works
   Conducted 3 roundtable discussions
   Issued report in January of 2006
   Concluded that orphan works are an issue that
   needs to be dealt with legislatively


                                      2005
Legislation
Orphan Works Act of 2006 was introduced in
the House
Provided a limitation on remedies for when the
copyright holder cannot be found
Bill was withdrawn in September 2006



                                   2006
Legislation
In 2008 the Orphan Works Act was introduced
in the House and the Shawn Bentley Orphan
Act was introduced in the Senate
Both called for similar things
Neither were passed before the end of the
session, nor were they reintroduced in the next
session


                                         2008
Book Search Settlement
Current settlement allows Google to sell orphan
works
If passed, everyone would be able to access
previously untouchable orphan works, but
Google would have a monopoly and complete
control over all orphan works



                                            2009
Critical
Analysis
Book Search Settlement




- James Grimmelman, “ACS Issue Brief on Google Book Settlement”
Book Search Settlement




- Lateef Mtima & Stephen Jamar, “Re: The Authors Guild et al. v. Google, Inc. Case No.
1:05 cv 8136 (S.D.N.Y)”
Legislation




- Jerry Brito & Bridget Dooling, “An Orphan Works Affirmative Defense to
Copyright Infringement Acts”
Legislation




        - Mark Dery, “works--progress?”
Legislation




     - Lawrence Lessig, “Little Orphan Artworks”
Berne Convention
 for the Protection of Literary and Artistic Works



Signed in 1886 by the most prominent countries
of the time
Stipulates that copyright ownership must be
automatic (meaning it should not involve
registration)
U.K. Orphan Works Model
The Treasury Department published a report in
2005 about Intellectual Property
Recommended that the UK Intellectual
Property Office should clearly define what
qualifies as a “reasonable search”
Should also established voluntary register of
copyright
Canadian Copyright Act
The Canadian Copyright Board examines a
user’s search process and issues a non-exclusive
copyright license and collects a licensing fee that
is sent to the relevant creator’s collecting society
If the artist or author is not traced or identified
within 5 years, the fee can be used by the
collecting society for the benefit of its general
membership
So... what should
happen to all of the
orphan works in the
  United States?
Orphan Works

Contenu connexe

Tendances

Copyright and plagiarism
Copyright and plagiarismCopyright and plagiarism
Copyright and plagiarismJerry Stovall
 
Open Data MeetUp, Cork, January 2014
Open Data MeetUp, Cork, January 2014Open Data MeetUp, Cork, January 2014
Open Data MeetUp, Cork, January 2014Darius Whelan
 
What is Creative Commons?
What is Creative Commons?What is Creative Commons?
What is Creative Commons?Kamel Belhamel
 
Comparative Analysis of National Approaches on Voluntary Copyright Relinquish...
Comparative Analysis of National Approaches on Voluntary Copyright Relinquish...Comparative Analysis of National Approaches on Voluntary Copyright Relinquish...
Comparative Analysis of National Approaches on Voluntary Copyright Relinquish...Andres Guadamuz
 
The landscape of the law
The landscape of the lawThe landscape of the law
The landscape of the lawerobinson1ny
 
Capstone wednesday copyright_fair_use_k
Capstone wednesday copyright_fair_use_kCapstone wednesday copyright_fair_use_k
Capstone wednesday copyright_fair_use_kPer Hoel
 
Introduction To Copyright Law
Introduction To Copyright LawIntroduction To Copyright Law
Introduction To Copyright LawJerry Stovall
 
Copywrite and creative commons lida
Copywrite and creative commons lidaCopywrite and creative commons lida
Copywrite and creative commons lidaTheodoraMuabala
 
Short History of Creative Commons
Short History of Creative Commons Short History of Creative Commons
Short History of Creative Commons Maria Garruccio
 
Cultural Production In A Digital Age
Cultural Production In A Digital AgeCultural Production In A Digital Age
Cultural Production In A Digital AgeKathy Gill
 

Tendances (17)

Copyright
CopyrightCopyright
Copyright
 
Remix culture
Remix cultureRemix culture
Remix culture
 
Copyright and plagiarism
Copyright and plagiarismCopyright and plagiarism
Copyright and plagiarism
 
Open Data MeetUp, Cork, January 2014
Open Data MeetUp, Cork, January 2014Open Data MeetUp, Cork, January 2014
Open Data MeetUp, Cork, January 2014
 
What is Creative Commons?
What is Creative Commons?What is Creative Commons?
What is Creative Commons?
 
Comparative Analysis of National Approaches on Voluntary Copyright Relinquish...
Comparative Analysis of National Approaches on Voluntary Copyright Relinquish...Comparative Analysis of National Approaches on Voluntary Copyright Relinquish...
Comparative Analysis of National Approaches on Voluntary Copyright Relinquish...
 
The landscape of the law
The landscape of the lawThe landscape of the law
The landscape of the law
 
Capstone wednesday copyright_fair_use_k
Capstone wednesday copyright_fair_use_kCapstone wednesday copyright_fair_use_k
Capstone wednesday copyright_fair_use_k
 
Introduction To Copyright Law
Introduction To Copyright LawIntroduction To Copyright Law
Introduction To Copyright Law
 
Intellectual property law
Intellectual property lawIntellectual property law
Intellectual property law
 
Copyright
CopyrightCopyright
Copyright
 
CC and DPLA webinar
CC and DPLA webinarCC and DPLA webinar
CC and DPLA webinar
 
Copyright Law
Copyright LawCopyright Law
Copyright Law
 
SLA 2017 - Fair Use in the Digital Age - Kenneally
SLA 2017 - Fair Use in the Digital Age - KenneallySLA 2017 - Fair Use in the Digital Age - Kenneally
SLA 2017 - Fair Use in the Digital Age - Kenneally
 
Copywrite and creative commons lida
Copywrite and creative commons lidaCopywrite and creative commons lida
Copywrite and creative commons lida
 
Short History of Creative Commons
Short History of Creative Commons Short History of Creative Commons
Short History of Creative Commons
 
Cultural Production In A Digital Age
Cultural Production In A Digital AgeCultural Production In A Digital Age
Cultural Production In A Digital Age
 

Similaire à Orphan Works

Vaughan - Communication Law Powerpoint
Vaughan - Communication Law PowerpointVaughan - Communication Law Powerpoint
Vaughan - Communication Law PowerpointMarti Vaughan
 
A Dozen and One Things to Know About Copyright
A Dozen and One Things to Know About CopyrightA Dozen and One Things to Know About Copyright
A Dozen and One Things to Know About CopyrightRogan Hamby
 
Orphan Works at Home and Abroad
Orphan Works at Home and AbroadOrphan Works at Home and Abroad
Orphan Works at Home and AbroadGena Chattin
 
The Long Arm of the Law, presentation by Bill Hannay, Schiff Hardin LLP
The Long Arm of the Law, presentation by Bill Hannay, Schiff Hardin LLPThe Long Arm of the Law, presentation by Bill Hannay, Schiff Hardin LLP
The Long Arm of the Law, presentation by Bill Hannay, Schiff Hardin LLPCharleston Conference
 
Copyright Essentials
Copyright EssentialsCopyright Essentials
Copyright EssentialsTom Keays
 
Copyright ashort study by KJK
Copyright ashort study by KJKCopyright ashort study by KJK
Copyright ashort study by KJKMarmfluffy
 
Investigative Report - Copyright
Investigative Report - CopyrightInvestigative Report - Copyright
Investigative Report - Copyrightejg29
 
Music Law Final Paper - Copyright
Music Law Final Paper - CopyrightMusic Law Final Paper - Copyright
Music Law Final Paper - CopyrightMatthew Williamson
 
What is copyright jcholliday=eb
What is copyright jcholliday=ebWhat is copyright jcholliday=eb
What is copyright jcholliday=ebbibliowoman
 
Libraries, Copyright and the World
Libraries, Copyright and the WorldLibraries, Copyright and the World
Libraries, Copyright and the WorldALATechSource
 
The value of copyright in the creative industries
The value of copyright in the creative industriesThe value of copyright in the creative industries
The value of copyright in the creative industriesRobert Puffett
 

Similaire à Orphan Works (20)

Vaughan - Communication Law Powerpoint
Vaughan - Communication Law PowerpointVaughan - Communication Law Powerpoint
Vaughan - Communication Law Powerpoint
 
Copyright law
Copyright lawCopyright law
Copyright law
 
DobsonHW6CH8graded
DobsonHW6CH8gradedDobsonHW6CH8graded
DobsonHW6CH8graded
 
A Dozen and One Things to Know About Copyright
A Dozen and One Things to Know About CopyrightA Dozen and One Things to Know About Copyright
A Dozen and One Things to Know About Copyright
 
Orphan works
Orphan worksOrphan works
Orphan works
 
Research Paper
Research PaperResearch Paper
Research Paper
 
Orphan Works at Home and Abroad
Orphan Works at Home and AbroadOrphan Works at Home and Abroad
Orphan Works at Home and Abroad
 
Copyright lecture
Copyright lectureCopyright lecture
Copyright lecture
 
The Long Arm of the Law, presentation by Bill Hannay, Schiff Hardin LLP
The Long Arm of the Law, presentation by Bill Hannay, Schiff Hardin LLPThe Long Arm of the Law, presentation by Bill Hannay, Schiff Hardin LLP
The Long Arm of the Law, presentation by Bill Hannay, Schiff Hardin LLP
 
Copyright Basics
Copyright BasicsCopyright Basics
Copyright Basics
 
6.copyright.2020
6.copyright.20206.copyright.2020
6.copyright.2020
 
Copyright Essentials
Copyright EssentialsCopyright Essentials
Copyright Essentials
 
ILL & Copyright: Putting it all Together
ILL & Copyright: Putting it all TogetherILL & Copyright: Putting it all Together
ILL & Copyright: Putting it all Together
 
Copyright ashort study by KJK
Copyright ashort study by KJKCopyright ashort study by KJK
Copyright ashort study by KJK
 
Librarians as Archivists and Defenders of IP Rights
Librarians as Archivists and Defenders of IP RightsLibrarians as Archivists and Defenders of IP Rights
Librarians as Archivists and Defenders of IP Rights
 
Investigative Report - Copyright
Investigative Report - CopyrightInvestigative Report - Copyright
Investigative Report - Copyright
 
Music Law Final Paper - Copyright
Music Law Final Paper - CopyrightMusic Law Final Paper - Copyright
Music Law Final Paper - Copyright
 
What is copyright jcholliday=eb
What is copyright jcholliday=ebWhat is copyright jcholliday=eb
What is copyright jcholliday=eb
 
Libraries, Copyright and the World
Libraries, Copyright and the WorldLibraries, Copyright and the World
Libraries, Copyright and the World
 
The value of copyright in the creative industries
The value of copyright in the creative industriesThe value of copyright in the creative industries
The value of copyright in the creative industries
 

Orphan Works

  • 2. Orphan Work: A copyrighted work (book, music, film, photo, record, etc.) whose copyright owner cannot be found or is not easily found
  • 4. 1976 Copyright Act Eliminated any formal registration requirements for a copyright Included an extension of the duration of the copyright protection Led to a proliferation in orphan works 1976
  • 5. Sonny Bono Copyright Term Extension Act Extended copyrights for an additional 20 years, so that it lasts for the life span of the creator and an additional 70 years after their death Allowed libraries and archives to use a work without permission if the work is not otherwise being used for commercial exploitation and not available at a reasonable price 1998
  • 6. Public Domain Enhancement Act Introduced in House of Representatives in 2003 Reintroduced in 2005 Did not pass Would have released some orphan works into the public domain if the copyright owners did not renew their copyright 50 years after the work was first released and then every 10 years after 2003 2005
  • 7. Copyright Office Orphan Works Study Issued a Notice of Inquiry and asked the public to submit comments about orphan works Conducted 3 roundtable discussions Issued report in January of 2006 Concluded that orphan works are an issue that needs to be dealt with legislatively 2005
  • 8. Legislation Orphan Works Act of 2006 was introduced in the House Provided a limitation on remedies for when the copyright holder cannot be found Bill was withdrawn in September 2006 2006
  • 9. Legislation In 2008 the Orphan Works Act was introduced in the House and the Shawn Bentley Orphan Act was introduced in the Senate Both called for similar things Neither were passed before the end of the session, nor were they reintroduced in the next session 2008
  • 10. Book Search Settlement Current settlement allows Google to sell orphan works If passed, everyone would be able to access previously untouchable orphan works, but Google would have a monopoly and complete control over all orphan works 2009
  • 12. Book Search Settlement - James Grimmelman, “ACS Issue Brief on Google Book Settlement”
  • 13. Book Search Settlement - Lateef Mtima & Stephen Jamar, “Re: The Authors Guild et al. v. Google, Inc. Case No. 1:05 cv 8136 (S.D.N.Y)”
  • 14. Legislation - Jerry Brito & Bridget Dooling, “An Orphan Works Affirmative Defense to Copyright Infringement Acts”
  • 15. Legislation - Mark Dery, “works--progress?”
  • 16. Legislation - Lawrence Lessig, “Little Orphan Artworks”
  • 17. Berne Convention for the Protection of Literary and Artistic Works Signed in 1886 by the most prominent countries of the time Stipulates that copyright ownership must be automatic (meaning it should not involve registration)
  • 18. U.K. Orphan Works Model The Treasury Department published a report in 2005 about Intellectual Property Recommended that the UK Intellectual Property Office should clearly define what qualifies as a “reasonable search” Should also established voluntary register of copyright
  • 19. Canadian Copyright Act The Canadian Copyright Board examines a user’s search process and issues a non-exclusive copyright license and collects a licensing fee that is sent to the relevant creator’s collecting society If the artist or author is not traced or identified within 5 years, the fee can be used by the collecting society for the benefit of its general membership
  • 20. So... what should happen to all of the orphan works in the United States?